+ 2015 Insurance Industry Mega Conference IICC Growth Options for Insurance Business in Nigeria By Bismarck Rewane CEO, Financial Derivatives Company Ltd July 27, 2015 + Audience Analysis Commissioner and regulatory officials of the insurance industry Insurance firms and professionals Inaugurated in 2013, IICC is the umbrella institute for: The National Insurance Commission (NAICOM) The Chartered Insurance Institute of Nigeria (CIIN) The Nigeria Insurers Association (NIA) The Nigerian Council of Registered Insurance Brokers (NCRIB) The Institute of Loss Adjusters of Nigeria (ILAN) Distinguished Elders and Leaders of the Insurance Industry + Audience Analysis Established Policy alignment Regulator Self as an advocacy vehicle for: practitioner collaboration regulation and best practice Upgrading principles local practices with universal + Background The insurance industry in Nigeria has underperformed the economy in its growth Its profitability and size has been suboptimal Relative to the financial services industry and global peers The industry has been subject of new capital requirements and capacity rules + Objectives of Presentation Discuss the alignment of the new regulations and the business philosophy of an open economy To understand the new economic challenges and opportunities of Nigeria under a new leadership To discuss the wider implications of the commodity price shock on the economy, insurance values and risks + Outline Historical Nigerian Oil Link between Britain and Nigeria Economy: Basic Facts in 2015 Price Shock and its Impact Policy Options, Choices and Actions Implications Case on the Insurance Industry Study for Developing Economies: Singapore Growth Options & Opportunities Summary and Outlook + Historical Link Between Britain and Nigeria + The Industry and Britain First insurance company in Nigeria was an offshoot of Royal Exchange Assurance London Subsequent insurance firms had strong British ties and operating models Prior to the Indigenization decree of 1976, Britain had majority stake in the industry The United Kingdom insurance industry received premiums of £50.2bn in 2013 Total premium income in Africa during the same period was £46.3bn + UK Insurance Sector Integral part of the financial services industry 1229 insurance companies Employs approximately 320,000 people Funds under management: Over £1.8trn Total Premiums written (2013): $351.26bn 7.35% of world total world premiums Insurance Penetration: 12.18% Insurance and pension funds account for 1.6% of GDP The contribution of brokers adds another 1% 30% of premium income comes from overseas + UK Insurance Sector UK insurance cluster composed of: Underwriting Broking Actuarial Marketing Operating General across a range of sectors: insurance Life Wholesale Reinsurance Supported by strong regulatory environment + UK Insurance Sector The cluster and the Lloyd’s market in London all operate internationally Have a highly developed skill base Provides expertise unmatched by other financial centres Fosters a creative environment where innovative solutions can be developed Specialize in global markets + Nigeria +How far away is Nigeria from the Model? Insurance accounted for 13% of the financial sector’s GDP in 2014 Other In financial institutions:87% UK, insurance accounts for 20% Other financial institutions: 80% Nigeria 2014 GDP per sector (N’bn) Q1’15 % of Total fin. sector GDP GDP per sector (N’bn) % of Total fin. sector GDP Financial 1,724 Institutions 87% 501 89% Insurance 13% 63 11% 259 +How far away is Nigeria from the Model? Growth rate of 5.11% in Q1’15 from Q1’14 Contribution to GDP: 0.39% Consists of 58 insurance and reinsurance companies 27 are listed on the Nigerian stock exchange Statutory regulators are National Insurance Commission (NAICOM) and Chartered Insurance Institute of Nigeria (CIIN) Number of Licensed Companies in Nigeria Life 15 Non Life 29 Composite 12 Re-Insurance 2 +How far away is Nigeria from the Model? Risk areas covered varies across insurance companies E.g. 54% of risk covered by Custodian and Allied Plc. is in oil and gas Class Of Business % of Total Risk Areas Covered Accident 13.2% Engineering 2.8% Fire 15.2% Marine 4.8% Motor 9.1% Oil & Gas 53.6% Bond 0.4% Aviation 0.9% + How far away is Nigeria from the Model? According to NAICOM, total net premium estimated at N188.75bn Gross premium at N258.40bn Life and Non Life Insurance Premiums, 2013 ($’m) Direct Premiums Written Non Life premiums * 1,406 Life premiums 457 Total Premiums 1,863 % of total world premiums 0.04% * Includes accident and health insurance. Source: Swiss Re, sigma, No. 3/2014; Insurance Information Institute +How far away is Nigeria from the Model? But issues are gradually being resolved Industry There is consolidating have been M&As Crusader insurance Vs Custodian & Allied AXA Insurance acquired Mansard FBN Life acquired OASIS insurance Increasing Import level of foreign ownership of international best practices Prospect of improved growth + Nigerian Economy: Basic Facts in 2015 + Economy SSA’s 26th largest economy with GDP of $568.5bn largest economy in the world 0.7% of Global GDP 35% of African GDP 76% of ECOWAS GDP Has consistently outperformed the SSA average growth in the last 10 years until 2015 + Slowing GDP Growth Rate Has a 5 year average growth rate of 6.72% Q1’15 GDP slowed to 3.96% from 5.94% in Q4’14 2015 growth of 4.3% lags SSA’s average of 4.5% Real GDP Growth Rate (%) 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Q4'12 Q1'13 Q2'13 Q3'13 Q4'13 Q1'14 Q2'14 Q3'14 Q4'14 Q1'15 Q2'15 Q3'15 Q4'15 + Structure GDP is more dependent on services than production in a 55:45 ratio Largest sectors are growing sub-optimally Below Nigeria’s economic growth of 6.22% (2014) But insurance sector surpassed it (8.27%) Largest Sectors 2014 Contribution to GDP (%) 2014 GDP growth Rate (%) Agriculture 22.9 4.27 Trade 17.64 5.88 Telecoms 8.34 4.75 Oil & Gas 10.8 -1.32 Insurance 0.39 8.27 Trade consists of formal & informal trade Informal trade accounts for about 90% Formal trade is approximately 10% + Misery Index- Underemployment + Unemployment +Inflation Misery index has increased to 33.6% in Q1’15 45 40 35 30 Underemployment 25 Unemployment 20 Inflation Misery Index 15 10 5 0 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Q1 Source: NBS + Gross Capital Formation Stagnating 35 investing enough in 30 fixed capital 25 Nigeria’s gross Capital Formation lags its peers at 20 15 % of GDP Singapore: 20% 15 Brazil: 18% Turkey: 20% 10 Capital/recurrent ratio in 5 2015: 83/17 Buhari is targeting 30/70 in 0 year and 40/60 in 2016 GCF as % of GDP Not Nigeria 2005 2006 2007 Brazil 2008 20009 2010 Singapore 2011 2012 2013 Turkey + Income is Growing but Consumption is Lagging Growth in aggregate consumption of 4.4% is relatively at par with GDP growth of 4.3% Income is stranded at the top of the pyramid Gini coefficient is 48.8 Top 20% owned 25% of income in 2008 Top 20% now control 35% in 2013 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 -5 -10 Aggregate Consumption (%) GDP Growth (%) + Relationship between Consumption, Savings and GDP Insignificant positive relationship between national savings and interest rates 80 70 60 50 Interest rates 40 National Savings %GDP 30 Consumption %GDP 20 10 0 2010 2011 National 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 savings is 19% of GDP Insurance constitutes 1.7% of national savings + Average Consumer Basket- EIU Consumer expenditure is dominated by FB&T Accounting for 65% of household expenditure Expenditure on transport and communications is expected to increase Anticipations of a fuel subsidy removal Growth in mobile phone market In reality, largest spending is on: Education Health Feeding Alternative power + Consumer Expenditure (% of Total) 70.00% 66.37% 60.00% 50.00% 40.00% 30.00% 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% 18.14% 3.19% 3.79% 1.26% 4.50% 1.11% 1.32% 0.31% Source: EIU + Where is the Nigerian Economy Now? + The Known Knowns Economic Variables •Nominal GDP of $568bn (2014) •GDP growth rate of 3.96% (Q1’15); 4.3% (FY’15) •Inflation of 9.2% (June) •Unemployment rate of 33.6% •Exchange rate spread of N45 •Oil price is down 50% from 2014’s peak of $116pb Fiscal Policy •2015 budget of N4.49trn •Budget revenue of N3.45trn •Fiscal deficit in excess of 2% •Oil price is 9.4% above benchmark oil price of $53pb Political •Buhari is President •Economic patriot •Kept the markets guessing •In no hurry to announce cabinet •NSA and service chiefs •PDP has become a regional party as a proxy for former Biafra •APC is a mix of interest groups that need to be aligned Monetary Policy •CRR harmonized •MPR unchanged at 13% p.a. + The Unknown Unknowns Political Cabinet members, heads of agencies, ambassadors, Ministers Full extent of anti-corruption drive Fiscal policy Fiscal policy direction Supplementary budget Whether fuel subsidies will be removed or maintained Increase in VAT or implementation of new taxes Structure of tariffs and duties Monetary policy Approximate or true value of the naira Inflation in the next 2-3months + Oil Price Shock and its Impact + Oil Prices Rebound in Q2’15 but Falling Again Oil prices rebounded more than expected in Q2’15 Gained 15% in Q2 to an average of $62pb Down 53% from June 2014 peak of $116pb Reflecting higher demand and Expectations oil production growth in US will slow But concerns about Iran’s deal and oversupply in the market is pushing it back towards $50pb Oil Price ($’b) 70 60 63.59 54.52 52.99 50 40 30 20 10 0 Jan'15 Jun'15 Jul'15 + Pre-Oil Shock (2010-2013) 60 Export prices were increasing faster than the change in import prices Resulting in a positive terms of trade Consumption outpaced GDP growth after a dip caused by the partial removal of fuel subsidies Terms of Trade 120 50 100 40 80 35 Growth in GDP vs Consumption 30 25 20 30 60 20 40 10 20 15 10 5 0 0 0 2010 2011 Export Prices (% change) Terms of Trade (RHS) 2012 2013 Import Prices (%Change) -5 2010 2011 2012 2013 -10 GDP (% change) Private Consumption (% change) + Post Oil Shock US $ Oil Price Vs. Aggregate Consumption Sources: OPEC, EIU According to EIU, Nigeria’s aggregate consumption was $408.4bn compared to GDP of $568.5bn in 2014 Projected to decline to $363.3bn in 2015 against nominal GDP of $491bn + Movements in export and import prices Export and import prices dipped due to the plummet in oil prices Exports falling faster than imports, negatively affecting our terms of trade Crude oil being a major export Refined crude being a major import 60 120 50 100 40 30 80 20 10 60 0 -10 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 40 20 -40 -50 Import Price (% change) Terms of Trade (2005 = 100) -20 -30 Export Price (% change) 0 + Exchange Rate and External Reserves Exchange rate differential now at N45.57 from N24 in May Interbank: N198.43/$ Parallel: N244/$ External Before a marginal recovery in July to $30.7bn YTD decline is 10.94% ($3.77bn) Import reserves fell 15.92% ($5.49bn) in H1’15 cover of 4.88 months Well below EM average of 11months + Policy options, choices & actions + Policies Implemented (January – June) Fiscal A Policy N10 cut in PMS price to N87 Trade Policy Common Monetary Net External Tariff implemented Policy Open Position reviewed upwards to 0.5% RDAS scrapped, IFEM adopted CRR debits now weekly CRR harmonized to 31% MPR unchanged at 13% p.a. + CBN’s Administrative Policies (January – June) RDAS and interbank funds restricted to LC’s, Bills for collection and other invisible transactions Limit placed on card usage abroad Reduced from $150,000 to $50,000 Dollarization of the economy is completely prohibited and Naira to remain the only legal tender 41 items excluded from IFEM and BDCs Staples: rice, poultry and tinned fish in sauce Euro bond/ forex bonds/ share purchases + MPC Meeting in July MPC maintained status quo Despite inflation and exchange rate concerns MPR:13% CRR: 31% Impact: The naira fear factor will increase Parallel Naira N250 market premium will increase will depreciate in the parallel market towards + Outlook: MPC Decision (September) CBN may allow currency to float to N205-210 Cut MPR from 13% p.a. to 12% p.a. Reduce the CRR Rationale: The currency will find its true value Encourage lending & stimulate economic growth Remove the fear factor Stimulate economic activity with accommodative monetary policy International investors will increase their positions in Nigeria The divergence in rates will reduce + Outlook: MPC Decision (September) Impact: Short Risk term increased inflationary pressure investment flow reversal Relative stability of the exchange rate Slowdown in the depletion rate of the external reserves level Lead to 2% decline in interest rates Govt borrowing costs will fall by N18.8bn in 2015 + Fiscal Policy + FAAC vs. Oil Prices Government funds highly dependent on oil revenues Direct relationship between FAAC and oil prices FAAC funds vs Oil Prices 120 800 700 100 600 80 500 60 400 300 40 200 20 100 0 0 Oil prices $/pb FAAC Funds (RHS) N'bn + State Allocation trends downwards Projected state allocation for 2015 is almost half of 2013 Other sources of revenue needed to fund government expenditure 70 Gross Statutory Allocation (N'bn) 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2013 2015 (projected) + State Debt: Bailout Funds Approved A comprehensive relief package approved to address outstanding state debt obligations In excess of N800bn N413.7bn ($2.1bn) to be shared amongst the three tiers of government 2.15% A of money supply CBN special intervention fund of N250-300bn has been created to provide soft loans to the states Will increase consumers purchasing power and productivity + Supplementary Budget Buhari’s administration expected to draft a supplementary budget It will reflect further austerity measures Likely be funded through domestic borrowing Blocked leakages can increase revenues by 15- 20% Subsidy Removal (25% of budget) will help increase income + Subsidy Removal: Price Elasticity Demand of PMS Subsidy payments were 0.85% (N971bn/ $4.9bn) of GDP in 2014 Subsidy N'bn 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Impact of a Subsidy Removal + National Income Identity Y=C+I+G+(X-M) Y= $568bn C=$408bn I=$95bn G=$46bn X-M=$17bn Y= $568bn C=$403.1bn I=$95bn G=$50.9bn X-M=$17bn •Removal of fuel subsidy is expected to move $4.9bn from C to G to be used for rehabilitation of oil refineries and payments of salary arrears + Subsidy Removal Remove subsidy and reduce import bill by 15- 20% of bogus demand To complement 26% plus 5% devaluation Will equal 48% decline in oil revenue Bringing Putting equilibrium to forex market the naira in the real equilibrium exchange rate path + Exchange Rate Policy PPP: Is the Naira Undervalued + Jun-15 =N= US $ PPP ('=N=/US$) =N= Jun-14 PPP ('=N=/US$) US $ Bottle of Coke (50cl) 100 2.00 50.00100 2.00 50.00 Heineken 350 2.11 165.88350 1.50 233.33 Hamburger 1,200 4.80 250.00850 3.14 270.70 Uncle Ben's rice (S. Pkt) 1,500 3.48 431.031,500 3.50 428.57 Toyota Corolla 6,900,000 Bottled Water (1ltr) 100 0.41 241.21100 1.49 67.11 Big Loaf Bread 300 3.50 85.71300 2.50 120.00 Irish Spring Soap (1 cake) 250 3.59 69.64250 2.00 125.00 1 Packet of Benson & Hedges 200 8.00 25.00170 8.00 21.25 Chicken Drumsticks ( 1 kilo) 800 4.40 181.82800 7.45 107.38 Eggs (One dozen) Average PPP 600 4.19 143.20400 186.75 2.75 145.45 166.70 16800 410.714,300,000 16,230 Naira Price at IFEM 198.15 PPP (%) Decision: Naira is Undervalued -5.76% Spot Rate (Parallel) 244 Outcome: Compared to official spot rate of N197/$1, the Naira is undervalued by 5.76% 264.94 160.50 3.87% 163 + PPP Analysis vs. Burgernomics Using a basket of items to determine the currency value PPP index shows that naira is slightly undervalued by 5.76% An indication that IFEM rate may be trading at its fair value But using a one item basket – the Big Mac Index Price KFC of MacDonald's Burger in the US: $4.53 as a proxy at N1200 in Nigeria Using the current exchange rate gives $6.06 This suggests the naira is overvalued by 25% The true value of the naira based on the burgernomics today is N248.7/$ (parallel rate??) + Using the Big Mac Index One item basket: the big Mac hamburger ($4.79) According to this index, only 2 countries have overvalued currencies PPP holds only in the long run Over shorter periods, currencies are often pushed far away from their fairvalue yardsticks by international capital flows Driven by broader trends in the global economy Exchange rates are currently being buffeted by: Euro crisis Growing likelihood of a rise U.S. interest Slowdown in China Sharp drop in the oil price + Currency Adjustment S&P says Nigeria cannot avoid another devaluation of about 15% RenCap sees naira depreciating by 18% over the next 6-12 months due to: Pent up forex demand If oil prices remain low Little scope for further policy tightening We think further devaluation may not be necessary if fuel subsidy is removed If at all, adjustment will be marginal + Implications on the Nigerian Insurance Industry + Implications on the Insurance Industry Inflation Risk Higher inflation increases the cost of future claims on current policies Erodes asset values Increased inflation makes higher interest rates more likely Implies value of total assets under management could drop In the 2008 financial crisis, insurance companies were some of the biggest losers + Implications on the Insurance Industry Interest Rate Risk Sensitivity For varies by line of business and market life insurers: it affects savings products where investment returns are major source of profit Higher For interest rate encourages savings non-life insurers: if interest rates reduce, they could react by raising premiums to maintain profitability + Implications on the Insurance Industry Exchange Rate Risk A devaluation increases the risk that the assured will face higher replacement cost It increases the risk of non-payment of future premiums as disposable income falls Premium on foreign re-insurance higher + Case Study for Developing Economies: Singapore + State of the Singaporean Economy Singapore has one of the most open and competitive market in the world It is ranked the best country to do business in the world It takes 3 days to start a business in Singapore compared to world’s average of 34 days Highly skilled workforce and favourable tax regime created a conducive business environment Its economy is largely dependent on exports Consumer electronics Information technology products Medical and optical devices + State of the Singaporean Economy GDP estimated at $307.9bn in 2014 Growth rate of 2.9% Economy contracted during the global financial crisis in 2009 but continued to grow in 2010 due to renewed exports Per capita GDP higher than most developed countries $81,300 Has (2014) a low unemployment rate of 2% (2014) The only Asian country to have AAA credit ratings from all 3 major credit rating agencies + How did they get here? The Singapore model was born out of necessity Singapore had a relatively small domestic market For the economy to thrive, it decided to open its economy to external markets Its government enacted economic policies to safeguard the country from vulnerability in depending on external markets This economic system where both market and the state have equally strong roles in the government is the Singapore model + Singapore Insurance Sector One of the most developed insurance markets in Asia Regional hub for Asia Pacific region 161 registered insurers and reinsurers Assets Under Management: $130bn (48% of GDP) Total Premiums written (2013): $27bn 0.57% of world total world premiums Regional Global centre for reinsurance reinsurers making up large proportion of the offshore non-life business written + Singapore Insurance Sector High insurance penetration rate – 7.3% High per capita expenditure on insurance Health insurance has been growing rapidly Increasing Dominated High demography of ageing population by life insurance income levels and high savings rate Life insurance penetration (67.8% of households) Life premium density 5.5% of GDP + Singapore Insurance Sector Non-life insurance penetration has risen over the years From High Low 2.55% in 2005 to 3% in 2013 per capita expenditure on insurance interest rates and investment returns impacting profitability Focus is now on core functions like underwriting and claims + Singapore’s Insurance Challenges Regulations addressing insurer solvency, capital and risk management have been changed New rules could swamp the industry with costs and compliance Longstanding strategic positions maybe altered Costs, prices and returns could soon become unsustainable if changes are mismanaged + Global Insurance Challenges in 2015 According to Ernst & Young, key challenges for the insurance industry in 2015: Rising Soft competition pricing conditions Tight profit margins Low interest rates will make savings product difficult to manage Cyber Lack crime and data insecurity of experienced talent due to higher mobility and increased competition Growth Options and + Opportunities for the Nigerian Insurance Industry + Growth Options and Opportunities According to Ernst and Young, the focus of insurers in 2015 is “technology” Investing in digital platforms that strengthen their relationships with customers across product classifications and geographies Capitalize on data analytics, cloud computing and modelling techniques To sharpen market segmentation strategies, reduce claims fraud and strengthen underwriting and risk management + Growth Options and Opportunities Smart use of Technology Promoting mobile app services: to take pictures of a scene; file claims Custodian Allied already using it Sale of life insurance using mobile phone network to 126million active lines Mobile phone ownership is 84.9% in urban areas and 55.6% in rural areas Using social media to increase the variety of distribution channels + Growth Options and Opportunities Cost control initiatives Outsourcing Extend borders of insurability Attractive Value product packaging creation and differentiation strategies Further merger & acquisitions Increased Cost a business process? value generation efficiency in the long term + Growth Options and Opportunities Diversify investments Consider long-term investment in infrastructure and project finance Close collaboration between government and the industry To draft reforms that will promote the work of the industry Better and less burdensome regulation + Growth Options and Opportunities Favourable Young demographics and growing population of approx. 170m people Growth rate of 2.6% (4m) Implies potential increase in customer base Attracting new talent To maintain dynamism and capacity to innovate To meet changing customer demands + Summary and Outlook + Summary Nominal GDP estimated to reach $525bn in 2016 From $488bn in 2015 Sectors that will drive growth: Agric, Telecom, Financial services, Petroleum and manufacturing Oil prices in H2’15 are likely to soften towards $45-50pb Challenges remain that will constrain growth Policy options are limited + Policy Outlook Aggressive Removal tax collection of subsidy to increase fiscal revenue Currency adjustment and possible removal of forex controls Accommodative Electricity CET interest rate policy tariff adjustment implementation + Critical Events to Watch out for MPC meeting in July and September Announcement Likely shake up in regulatory appointments Passage World of Cabinet names of a supplementary budget Bank meeting in Peru + Economic Outlook (Oil at $65pb) GDP growth rate forecast of 5.5% in 2016 From 4.3% in 2015 Increased focus to diversify away from oil, with huge investments in sectors such as agriculture, manufacturing and power Fuel subsidy will be removed and the passed PIB annulled Aggregate consumption will rise Slowdown in the depletion rate of fiscal revenue and external reserves + Economic Outlook (Oil at $65pb) Inflation will trend around the 11% level, reflecting a weaker naira Accommodative interest rate policy Efforts to create a more attractive business environment likely to produce modest results Huge investment in infrastructure and a Marshall plan to reflate the economy This will positively impact on purchasing power + Economic Outlook (Oil at $50pb) Contraction Depletion Sharp in GDP growth rate to 3.5% of fiscal and external buffers reduction in monthly FAAC to an average of N300bn Fiscal deficit will widen to above 3% of GDP Sharp fall in external reserves below $25bn Increased pressure on the naira As the CBN’s ability to defend the currency declines + Economic Outlook (Oil at $50pb) Currency adjustment and possible removal of forex controls The As removal of fuel subsidies will be inevitable there will be no subsidies at low oil prices Inflation will reach 13% because of imported inflation Increase in the electricity tariff + Economic Outlook (Oil at $50pb) Austerity • measures will be implemented Possible increase in taxation Will speed up diversification and investment in Agriculture Cut in government expenditure Reduced spending on infrastructure + Risks in Order of Magnitude Escalation of insurgency and Boko Haram attacks Fuel subsidy removal Exchange rate adjustment Trade restrictions Sharp fall in the price of oil + Insurance Outlook According to EY, Diminishing economic growth likely to affect demand for life and non–life products Stronger capital requirements will act as a catalyst for consolidation of smaller insurers Changing regulatory environment will encourage investment in real estate Cross border sales to commence January 2016 Collective investment scheme to expand further Improvement in data controls prompted by newer and stricter regulations + Growth Expectation for Insurance Industry But growth in the insurance sector may remain positive Likely to be driven by Automotive Oil policy & gas Housing sector Opportunity for growth in the insurance sector in the next four years is estimated at $105.24bn If it grows at par with South Africa (12% of GDP) + Thank You