Professionalism Chapter 2 38 Chapter Purpose Discuss the purposes and functions of professionalism in social work Discuss the significance of professionalism for effective social work practice Complete a preliminary assessment of proficiency in the social work skills and identify those skills that require additional practice Discuss the relevance of professional knowledge and self-efficacy, critical thinking and lifelong learning, self-understanding, selfcontrol, cultural competence and acceptance of others, and social support for ethical and effective social work practice Prepare a family genogram Prepare an eco-map Prepare a critical events time line Complete a personality assessment and discuss its implications Complete an initial assessment of readiness for the social work profession Social Work …As a Professional Career in Ontario 40 Social Work Labor Statistics -Ontario Employment in 2004 22,100 Male Female Part-Time Full-Time Self-Employed Employees Usual Place of work Work at Home No fixed work address 19% 80% 86% 13% 3% 96% 92% 2% 4% Main Industries of Employment -Ontario Social Assistance 41% Hospitals 10% Nursing and Residential Care Facilities 10% Ambulatory Health Care Services 9% All Other Industries 27% http://www.ontariojobfutures.ca/profile4152.html What is professionalism? Mirriam-Webster exhibiting a courteous, conscientious, and generally businesslike manner in the workplace Social Work Dictionary the degree to which an individual possess and uses the knowledge, skills, and qualifications of the profession and adheres to its values and ethics when serving the client Why care about professionalism? Network Grievances often center around professionalism Employee Swore to a Code of Ethics; builds confidence Employer Prevents social worker burnout and promotes mutual respect Client Client is satisfied What is professional integrity? 1. Morally good/right conduct according to accepted professional guidelines/codes of ethics 2. ‘Standing for something’ Practitioners are committed to sets of professional ideals/principles, which may go beyond extant professional norms. 3. A capacity/moral competence This can be described as a process of ‘continuous reflexive sense-making’, which may even involve reevaluating and giving up previously held ideals and principles. 1. a. Professional conduct (codes of ethics) Integrity comprises honesty, truthfulness, and sincerity, and is an essential value in the practice of social work. (BASW 2002) Social workers are continually aware of the profession's mission, values, ethical principles, and ethical standards and practice in a manner consistent with them. Social workers act honestly and responsibly and promote ethical practices on the part of the organizations with which they are affiliated. (NASW 1996) 1.b. Professional conduct (hearings ) GSCC conduct committee suspended social worker from register for advertising herself as an escort. This event ‘Brought the profession into disrepute and damaged public confidence in social care services’. ‘Social workers have a duty to act appropriately and professionally both inside and outside work’ ‘… essential that service users can trust them’ (GSCC June 2006) Key elements of integrity in professional life A commitment to a set of values. An awareness that the values are inter-related and form a coherent whole. A capacity to make sense of professional values and their relationship to our own personally-held values. The ability to give a coherent account of beliefs and actions. Strength of purpose and ability to act on the values. Student Activity The following scenario deals with professional integrity as it relates to protection of client identity Did the student intern act in the right way? What might you have done? 49 Student-Intern: Professionalism Student E writes, “My new neighbor started talking to me about his ex-wife who just happens to be a client of mine at the community health centre I am interning at. I didn’t really know what to say and so I just listened to him and didn’t let on that I knew her. I also didn’t tell him my name, nor that I was a social work student interning at the health centre. I am wondering if my actions were professional and justified. I would like to think that I have my profession backing me up and that I am protecting my client” Professional Knowledge and SelfEfficacy Social workers continually strive to increase their professional knowledge and skills and to apply them in practice. Social workers should aspire to contribute to the knowledge base of the profession. 51 Professional Knowledge Many different kinds of knowledge in social work Psycho-social knowledge: Explanatory knowledge, model, or theory for understanding affective, cognitive, and behavioural observations of clients and groups. Interactive knowledge: Explanatory knowledge, model, or theory for understanding transactions. Contextual knowledge: Explanatory knowledge, model, or theory for understanding structural and environmental factors. Organizational knowledge: Explanatory knowledge, model, or theory for understanding organizational behaviour and how to influence change. Class Activity Read the following case scenario What kind of psycho-social knowledge would allow you to better understand the client and her situation? 53 Psycho-social Knowledge A social worker is employed in a shelter for battered women. The client, a woman, aged thirty-four years, has three children, ages six, eight, and ten years, and is physically abused repeatedly by her husband. Although the police have been involved, no charges have been laid. The woman has sought refuge in the shelter times in the past, but has always made a decision to return to her husband. She has never held a paying job and has a grade 10 education. Psycho-social Knowledge Psycho-social knowledge may involve recognizing the impact of the client’s cultural expectations about traditional female behaviour in a marriage on her selfidentity, self-esteem, and her fears about permanently leaving the relationship. Knowledge of family dynamics is also relevant, such as the emotional impact on the children and the reactivation of the woman’s experience of violence in her family of origin. Formal support networks might include financial maintenance, subsidized housing, vocational training and education, and provisions for day care. Social Work Students: Required Curriculum 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Values and ethics Diversity Populations-at-risk and social and economic Justice Human behavior and the social environment Social welfare policy and services Social work practice Research Field practicum Class Activity Assess selected aspects of critical thinking and learning as they apply to you Rate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements 1=Strongly Agree 2=Agree 3=Disagree 4=Strongly Disagree 57 Evidence-Based Social Work Questionnaire 1. I rarely make judgments based solely upon intuition or emotion 2. I almost always think before I speak or act 3. I almost never express opinions as if they were facts 4. I always identify the assumptions underlying an argument 5. I carefully consider the source of information in determining validity 6. I rarely reach conclusions without considering the evidence 7. I regularly think in terms of probabilities 8. I rarely think in terms of absolutes 9. I always question the validity of arguments and conclusions 10. I rarely assume that something is valid or true 11. I regularly identify my own biases and preferences 12. I regularly think about issues of reliability 13. I routinely identify my own logical fallacies 14. I rarely say that something is true unless I have supporting evidence 15. I regularly use a thinking process routine to reach decisions Evidence-Based Social Work Questionnaire 16. I regularly read professional journals in my field 17. I genuinely enjoy learning 18. I always do more than the minimum requirements in courses, seminars or workshops 19. I regularly pursue opportunities to advance my knowledge and expertise 20. I never become defensive when someone offers feedback that could improve skill 21. I like to study 22. I know my personal learning style 23. I am actively involved in learning experiences 24. I take personal responsibility for my own learning 25. I view examinations as a way to learn 26. I know how to conduct a professional literature review 27. I sometimes contact national and international experts in my learning efforts 28. I have a list of learning goals 29. I have specific plans to advance my learning 30. I enjoy teaching others Professional Knowledge: Content Areas 1. Human development and behavior in the environment (14%) 2. Issues of diversity (7%) 3. Assessment in social work practice (20%) 4. Direct and indirect practice (21%) 5. Communication (10%) 6. Professional relationships (5%) 7. Professional values and ethics (13%) 8. Supervision in social work (2%) 9. Practice evaluation and the utilization of research (2%) 10.Service delivery (5%) 11.Social work administration (1%) Critical Thinking… “The propensity and skill to use reflective skepticism when engaged in some specific activity” (McPeck, 1990) Involves the careful examination and evaluation of beliefs and actions” (Gibbs & Gambrill, 1996) UP TO HERE FOR THURS. SEPT 20TH/07 Good Critical Thinkers… 1. Distinguishing between verifiable facts and value statements 2. Distinguishing relevant from irrelevant observations or reasons 3. Determining the factual accuracy of a statement 4. Determining the credibility of a source 5. Identifying ambiguous statements 6. Identifying unstated assumptions 7. Detecting bias 8. Identifying logical fallacies 9. Recognizing logical inconsistencies in a line of reasoning 10. Determining the overall strength of an argument or conclusion Stages of Critical Thinking Development Unreflective Master Challenged Critical Thinking Development Stages Advanced Beginning Practicing (Paul & Elder, 2002; Elder & Paul, 1996) Perry’s Model of Critical Thinking Development Perry studied Harvard and Radcliffe students in the 1950s and 1960s. He studied the nature of late adolescent and adult development and the role of higher education in fostering intellectual and ethical development in students. Suggested that as students move from adolescence into adulthood, they advance from a simplistic, categorical view of knowledge to a more complex, contextual view of the world and themselves. Dualism The world is viewed in absolute, right-andwrong terms. Individuals believe that right answers exist to all questions and that authorities have these answers. It is the instructor’s job to provide these answers and the students’ job to learn them. Examples of Dualistic Thought Dualistic Thoughts of College Students: I’m lost in this class; the professor lacks a clue. Every lecture course, no matter how bad, has taught me more than any seminar, no matter how good. In a lecture, you get taught by an expert, which means the information is credible. When I came here, I didn’t think any question could have more than one answer. These quotes illustrate that: Students expect the instructor to provide the answer to every question. In their minds, good teachers know the answers; bad ones don’t. Multiplicity In some areas, knowledge is certain. In most areas, nobody knows anything for sure. In those areas where the authorities have yet to find the answers, uncertainty is viewed as temporary. In the meantime, everyone’s opinions are just as valid as everyone else’s. Examples of Multiplistic Thought What it looks like: You know, it seems to me that there are two different kinds of things we study—things where there are answers and things where there aren’t any! I like that there are many ways to solve or code a program. Since the material tends to be subjective, it helps to see the reasoning of another person sometimes. If there are no right answers, I think my ideas are as good as anyone’s and I do not see why I got a “C” on my midterm. What this illustrates: Students begin to realize that the instructor will not provide all the answers to their questions. As they seek to discover the solution on their own, they struggle with the realization that there is generally more than one solution to a complex problem. Since there are many ways to look at an issue, they conclude that their view is as good as anybody else’s. Relativism Students come to view knowledge as contextual and relative in nature. Right and wrong answers exist within a specific context and are judged by how well one is able to construct a well-reasoned point of view. Examples of Relativistic Thought What it looks like: I love our class discussions because they help me figure out what I think about things. I always thought I knew what I thought about social work, but after hearing others and thinking more, I realize that there are so many ways of looking at the same thing! What this illustrates: Students realize that there is more than one solution to a dilemma and that the solutions must be examined based on evidence and sound thought processes. Students also become aware of the strengths and weaknesses in their lines of reasoning. They expect instructors to help them see alternatives more clearly. When exploring multiple theories or answers to a problem, they begin thinking, “What principles underlie each of them? Which is the most efficient?” Commitment Students are able to test out and evaluate various alternatives and commit to the most well-reasoned theory, solution, or interpretation. The commitment leads to the development of a personalized set of values, lifestyle, and identity. Examples of Commitment Thought What it looks like: • As the president of the student social work committee I have chosen to embrace and promote the value of diversity. I have the opportunity and responsibility to maintain a climate that affirms diversity of persons and diversity of views. • For purposes of my thesis I have chosen to pursue the topic of violence in inter-cultural relationships and the use of dialogue as a means to promote peace. I believe that the creation of a peaceful environment in which to function is vital to survival. What this illustrates: Students are capable of integrating personal experience with the complex set of skills and knowledge they have mastered. Students commit to a choice or viewpoint and become aware of the consequences of that commitment. They also realize that commitment is an ongoing, unfolding, evolving activity. Argument An attempt to establish the truth or validity of an idea through a series of statements and involves two parts Logical Fallacies Arguments that are usually psychologically persuasive but logically weak (Pine, 1996) Types: Ad Hominem Anecdotal Evidence Appeal to Pity Begging the Question Biased Sample Burden of Proof False Dilemma Personal Experience Popular Belief Red Herring Same Cause Slippery Slope Straw Person Wishful Thinking Why study logical fallacies? It is important to develop logical fallacy detection skills in your own writing, as well as others’. Think of this as “intellectual kung-fu: the art of intellectual self defense.” (Logical Fallacies Handlist) Ad Hominem Attempts to discredit an argument or position by drawing attention to characteristics of the person who is making the argument or who holds the position. Example: "People who are psychotic act in a bizarre manner. This person acts in a bizarre manner. Therefore: This person is psychotic." Alternate example: "If this client is competent to stand trial, she will certainly know the answers to at least 80% of the questions on this standardized test. She knows the answers to 87% of the test questions. Therefore she is competent to stand trial." Begging the Question This fallacy, one of the fallacies of circularity, takes the form of arguments or other statements that simply assume or re-state their own truth rather than providing relevant evidence and logical arguments. Examples: "Has your social work department stopped teaching that ineffective approach to therapy yet?" (The question assumes--and a "yes" or "no" response to the question affirms--that the approach is ineffective.) "It must be acknowledged that [whatever psychological test battery I use] is the only legitimate test battery." Red Herring Drawing attention away from the issue at hand by focusing on an irrelevant issue as a substitute for making a case. Example: You can’t trust Jim to do a good job as student body president; he doesn’t dress with an up-to-date sense of style. Example: I don’t support the President’s foreign policy; look at the disastrous way he has taken care of our domestic economy. Straw Person The straw person, or straw man, or straw woman fallacy takes the form mischaracterizing someone else's position in a way that makes it weaker, false, or ridiculous. Example: "Those who believe in behavior modification obviously want to try to control everyone by subjecting them to rewards and punishments." Slippery Slope To greatly exaggerate the supposedly inevitable future consequences of an action by suggesting one small step will initiate a process that will necessarily lead the way to a much bigger result. Example: If you restrict my right to say whatever I want anywhere I want however I want this is the beginning of totalitarianism in America. Example: If we let one homosexual couple live on our street before you know it our neighborhood will start to become like Greenwich Village in New York or the Castro District in San Francisco. Self-Understanding and Self-Control At a minimum, social workers must understand how their personal beliefs, attitudes, and ideologies might influence or interfere with their professional social work activities 82 Rescuing Pattern May be evident when a social worker tends to view clients as victims in need of rescue or salvation i.e. …there was a tendency for the caseworker to 'rescue' victims from abusive situations rather than assist them to disclose their concerns in their own way and to make their own choices. Stay away from "going overboard" in your role. You must not go beyond what is professionally appropriate while trying to help clients. Rescuing may give a temporary relief from your own feelings of helplessness and anger, but it does not lead to positive outcomes for the clients. Clients will best be served by facilitating the development of empowerment. This may mean that you allow clients to flounder at times. The Family: Context for Development of Self Genogram Contain basic data found in family trees such as the name, gender, date of birth, and date of death of each individual. A graphic representation of one’s family tree or pedigree, providing a picture of the parties involved and a chronology of significant events or themes Additional data may include education, occupation, major life events, chronic illnesses, social behaviors, nature of family relationships, emotional relationships, and social relationships. Some genograms also include information on disorders running in the family such as alcoholism, depression, diseases, alliances, and living situations. Genograms can vary significantly because there is no limitation as to what type of data can be included. Family relationships may be used to describe the emotional bond between people involved in a union, but the emotional relationship component is used to describe the emotional bond between any two individuals in the genogram (family tree). Interpretation Daniel was born in 1974 and Hélène died in 1981. Raphaël was born in 1978 and died in 2003 at the age of 25. André has been married twice. His first marriage to Hélène ended in 1981 due to her untimely death. His first marriage date is not specified in this genogram. In 1983, he married his second wife, Lisa. André is currently separated from Lisa, and living alone. Lisa was married to someone before marrying André. She gave birth to triplets with one male stillbirth. Lisa and her first husband became foster parents to a child. The couple eventually got divorced. Mike is André and Lisa's son. Mike has many half-siblings: Daniel, Anne, Benoit, Estelle, Jean-Claude and Lisa's two surviving children. On the other end, Max and Nicole had identical twins in 1973. Later, Nicole had a miscarriage and a stillbirth. The couple adopted Daniel. Interpretation: Emotional Relationships André was physically abused by his father. This violent behavior was passed on, and André later emotionally abused his own son Daniel. Daniel had a fused relationship with his mother. He now has a close relationship (friendship) with Jean and his younger brother JeanClaude. Hélène was very close (intimacy) to her mother in-law. Lisa and her first husband are estranged (cutoff). Lisa neglected her son Mike, and now Mike is violent towards his girlfriend. Anne is focused (obsessed) on her younger brother Benoit. Jean-Claude is indifferent (apathetic) to his half-brother Mike. This genogram clearly illustrates that this family has many issues to deal with! Ecological Assessment Eco-map The graphic nature highlights social strengths and social deficiencies and helps identify areas of conflict and compatibility Paper-and-pencil assessment tool used to assess specific troubles and plan intervention for clients. Drawing of the client or client family in its social environment. Helps both the social worker and the client achieve a holistic or ecological view of the client’s family life and the nature of the family’s relationships with groups, associations, organizations, and other families and individuals. Social Environment Commonly Used Symbols in an Ecomap Female Male Person, sex & age unknown Commonly Used Symbols in an Ecomap A stressful, conflictladen relationship ++++++++ A tenuous, uncertain relationship --------- A positive relationship or resource _________ The direction of the giving & receiving exchange or a relationship or resource Timelines Types of timelines A. a. Critical Events Timeline Outlines significant or meaningful experiences in a person’s life B. b. Issue (or Problem) Timeline Trace the origin and development of a particular issue or problem C. c. Relationship Timeline A graphic temporal representation of key moments in a personal family, or professional relationship D. d. Successes Timeline Records dates of accomplishments, achievements, and other successful experiences Lynn Chase: Critical Events Timeline 35 years ago Lynn Shaugnessy is born Age 5-12 Unhappy childhood Father often away Lynne is a good student Age 12 Boy calls Lynn “fat”; very upsetting Age 13 Maternal uncle makes sexual approach Age 15 Feels intense shame during confession to priest Age 18 First dates; first sexual experiences as high school senior Age 19 Drinks heavily; parties often; has multiple sex partners Meets Richard Age 20 Marries Richard; stops heavy drinking Age 22 Robert is born Age 26 Cyst is discovered and removed; Lynn unable to have more children Age 34 In July, Lynn goes to work at Fox manufacturing and begins to experience headaches, weight loss, irritability, starts smoking Age 35 In January, Lynn makes her first visit to the agency Personality “Characteristic pattern of thinking, feeling and acting.” Theoretical Approaches a. Type – focus on distinct and categorized types b. Trait –focus on specific dimensions of individual personality c. Psychodynamic/psychoanalytic –focus on unconscious motivations d. Behavioral –focus on individuals overt behavior e. Social learning/social cognitive -focus on influence of environment f. Humanistic - focus on inner capacity for growth Class Activity I see myself as someone who… 1. Strongly disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither disagree nor agree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 99 1. ...Is talkative 2. ...Tends to find fault with others 3. ...Does a thorough job 4. ...Is depressed, blue 5. ...Is original, comes up with new ideas 6. ...Is reserved 7. ...Is helpful and unselfish with others 8. ...Can be somewhat careless 9. ...Is relaxed, handles stress well 10. ...Is curious about many different things 11. ...Is full of energy 12. ...Starts quarrels with others 13. ...Is a reliable worker 14. ...Can be tense 15. ...Is ingenious, a deep thinker 16. ...Generates a lot of enthusiasm 17. ...Has a forgiving nature 18. ...Tends to be disorganized 19. ...Worries a lot 20. ...Has an active imagination 21. ...Tends to be quiet 22. ...Is generally trusting 23. ...Tends to be lazy 24. ...Is emotionally stable, not easily upset 25. ...Is inventive 26. ...Has an assertive personality 27. ...Can be cold and aloof 28. ...Perseveres until the task is finished 29. ...Can be moody 30. ...Values artistic, aesthetic experiences 31. ...Is sometimes shy, inhibited 32. ...Is considerate and kind to almost everyone 33. ...Does things efficiently 34. ...Remains calm in tense situations 35. ...Prefers work that is routine 36. ...Is outgoing, sociable 37. ...Is sometimes rude to others 39. ...Gets nervous easily 40. ...Likes to reflect, play with ideas 41. ...Has few artistic interests 42. ...Likes to cooperate with others 43. ...Is easily distracted 44. ...Is sophisticated in art, music, or literature 45. ...Has high self-esteem 46. ...Is very religious 47. ...Is politically liberal 48. ...Is often on bad terms with others The “Big 5” Modern personality research argues for 5 basic personality traits (OCEAN) Openness: whether a person is open to new experiences Conscientiousness: whether a person is disciplined and responsible Extroversion: whether a person is sociable, outgoing and affectionate Agreeableness: whether a person is cooperative, trusting, and helpful Neuroticism: whether a person is unstable and prone to insecurity Overview of the Big “5” Cultural Competence Cultural Competence and Acceptance of Others Culture “A learned worldview or paradigm shared by a population or group and transmitted socially that influences values, beliefs, customs, and behaviors, and is reflected in the language, dress, food, materials, and social institutions of a group” (Burchum, 2002) Cultural Competence The process by which individuals and systems respond respectfully and effectively to people of all cultures, languages, classes, races, ethnic backgrounds, religions, and other diversity factors in a manner that recognizes, affirms, and values the worth of individuals, families, and communities and protects and preserves the dignity of each (NASW, 2001) “Cultural Jeopardy” How to play: A definition will be presented and you must determine the appropriate word from the list. Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism A belief that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race. Race Discrimination Culture Racism Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism The ability to be open to learning about and accepting of different cultural groups. Race Discrimination Culture Cultural Sensitivity Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism A generalization of characteristics that is applied to all members of a cultural group. Race Discrimination Culture Stereotype Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism Race “The prejudgment and negative treatment of people based on identifiable characteristics such as race, gender, religion, or ethnicity” (Barker, 1995) Internalized Oppression Discrimination Culture Discrimination Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism Race The recognition and acknowledgement that society is pluralistic. In addition to the dominant cultural, there exists many other cultures based around ethnicity, sexual orientation, geography, religion, gender, and class. Internalized Oppression Discrimination Heterosexism Culture Multiculturalism Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism Race Internalized Oppression “An opinion about an individual, group, or phenomenon that is developed without proof or systematic evidence” (Barker, 1995) Discrimination Heterosexism Culture Prejudice Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism The belief in the inherent superiority of one sex (gender) over the other and thereby the right to dominance. Race Internalized Oppression Discrimination Heterosexism Culture Sexism Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism Race A body of learned beliefs, traditions, principles, and guides for behavior that are shared among members of a particular group. Discrimination Culture Culture Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism “Tendency to consider one’s own group, usually national or ethnic, superior to other groups using one’s own group or groups as the frame of reference against which other groups are judged” (Wolman, 1973) Race Discrimination Culture Ethnocentrism Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Racism As a biological concept, it defines groups of people based on a set of genetically transmitted characteristics. Race Discrimination Culture race Prejudice Ethnocentrism Stereotype Sexism Multiculturalism Cultural Sensitivity Ethnicity Sharing a strong sense of identity with a particular religious, racial, or national group. Racism Race Discrimination Culture Ethnicity Social Support Recognizing the importance of the social world for your clients’ well being, as well as for your own UP TO HERE FOR THURS. SEPT 27TH, 2007