Countdown to Hatching! Summary Students explore the role of temperature in salmon egg development by recording daily water temp and calculating Accumulated Temperature Units (ATUs) to predict hatch date. Objectives Students will: Make predictions of hatch date based on evidence. Track an environmental factor (water temperature) throughout egg development. Understand that temperature affects salmon survival throughout their life cycle. Making Connections Duration 35 min for first day calculations and hatch date predictions 5 min daily to record tank water temp NGSS LS1B: Growth and development of organisms Materials Floating thermometer Daily and Accumulated Temperature Log Many students know that salmon face extraordinary challenges in their lives, beginning at the egg stage. Salmon eggs in rivers and streams are subject to predators, smothering by silt, and fluctuations in water quality. Because of these challenges, only 10% of salmon eggs survive to hatch. Temperature is one of the most critical factors for salmon survival throughout its life cycle. Students may not realize how important water temperature is to the survival of salmon, from the egg stage all the way to adult salmon returning to spawn. This activity introduces the effects of temperature on salmon in the first stage of their life cycle as developing eggs, and can serve as a reference point for future discussions about temperature requirements of adult salmon in streams, the role of shade from trees in maintaining water temperatures cold enough for salmon to survive, and community stream restoration and tree planting efforts. Background Temperature controls the developmental rate of many organisms. Many living things require a certain amount of heat to develop from one point in their life cycles to another. Because fish are cold-blooded, the temperature of the water they live in controls when their eyes develop, when they begin to move inside the egg, and when they will hatch. Of all the factors that control salmonid egg development (i.e. temperature, dissolved oxygen, water quality, and light), temperature is probably the most critical. By recording the temperature of the water each day at a hatchery, fish culturists can estimate when the eggs will hatch, as well as other important milestones in fish development. Procedure Warm Up: Use the questions below to help guide a group discussion and introduce the activity. Does anyone have a guess about when our salmon eggs will hatch? What makes you say that? Do you have any evidence to back up that prediction? Scientists use evidence to develop their predictions. Do you think the hatchery has any idea when their fish eggs will hatch? How do they know? Did they call a psychic to tell them what day to expect the eggs to hatch? Hatchery staff record careful observations about egg development and the conditions of the rearing environment. What factors might influence our salmon eggs as they’re developing in the tank? How is this different for salmon eggs developing in rivers or streams? Temperature greatly influences the rate of egg development. Eggs in rivers are exposed to predation, silt, and greater fluctuations in water quality and temperature. Can you think of any differences between how embryos of salmon and humans develop? Fish are coldblooded and the surrounding water temperature determines how quickly the eggs develop. Humans are warm-blooded and develop internally, so the temperature stays relatively constant during development. What species of salmon is in our tank? Are there other species of salmon? Would our Coho eggs develop at the same rate as Chinook salmon? What if we put them in the same tank, under the same conditions? Envirionmental factors such as temperature aren’t the only thing that control the rate of egg development. Genetics also play an important role. Coho are genetically different from Chinook salmon, so they develop at different rates, even under identical conditions. Activity: Recording Daily and Accumulated Temperature Units: Have students record the tank water temperature twice daily, using the form provided (Table 1. Daily and Accumulated Temperature Units). It is important to record temperatures daily to calculate ATUs. For weekend temperatures simply estimate using averages of Friday and Monday information. Daily temperature units (also called thermal units and degree days) are calculated by taking the day’s average temperature and subtracting 32. Each day’s temperature units are added to the previous day’s to represent the accumulated temperature unit. For Example: Let’s say you record an average daily temperature of 47F the first day eggs are in your tank, and your SITC coordinator told you the eggs you received already had an ATU of 400. Record a daily temperature unit of 15 (47 - 32 = 15) for the first day, and an ATU of 415 (400 + 15 = 415). Days at School 1 Date 1-22-15 1-23-15 AM Temp PM Temp Average Temp Daily Temp Units (Avg temp - 32 F) Accum. Temp Units Notes 46 48 47 15 400 415 @pickup from hatchery Eggs in tank at school! Predicting Hatch Date Using the information provided about ATUs required for salmonids to reach important developmental stages (Attached, Table 3), have students predict how many calendar days it will take for their eggs to hatch. Coho generally require ~800 ATUs before hatching. Students will also need to know the ATUs the eggs received at the hatchery and the target daily temperature for raising Coho eggs (47F). Record the students’ predicted hatch date(s) very visibly on the outside of the tank, so the rest of the school knows when to expect the salmon. Offer a prize if the students’ prediction is accurate, or prepare a birthday serenade for the baby alevin (Happy Hatch-Day To You!). Have fun with it, and help students get egg-cited to meet their new salmon friends! Wrap Up: Follow up on any questions from the warm-up that students struggled with. You can also ask: Can you think of anything that might happen over the next few weeks that would make you want to change your prediction? What would happen if our power went out and the chiller stopped working? Do you think all the other classrooms that have salmon tanks will sing Happy Hatch-day on the same date as our class? Why or why not? Do you think temperature only affects salmon when they are in the developing egg stage of their life cycle? How might temperature affect adult salmon? Extensions Beyond the Hatch Date Predict the date your fish will be “swum up” or emerged from the gravel (~1600 ATUs), when they will be ready for tease feeding (~1380 ATUs), and when they will be ready to be fed 2% of their body weight (~1470 ATUs). Compare your class data with another school. Hatchery Mix-Up Instead of predicting the hatch date for the Coho eggs, tell the students there was a mix-up at the hatchery. We’re not sure if we received Coho or Chinook eggs! Have students determine which species they have after the eggs hatch, by comparing their calculated ATUs with the developmental information in Table 3. Adapted from: Salmon Egg Incubation in Alaska http://www.adfg.alaska.gov/static/viewing/pdfs/sic_atu_log_sheet.pdf http://www.pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/education/documents/sicinter-secinter/sic_intermediate_unithandouts_5.pdf http://www.ipm.ucdavis.edu/WEATHER/ddconcepts.html When will they hatch? Worksheet from Meredith Gannon (Sacajawea Elem) School-wide prediction calendar from Jayne Salisbury (Pioneer Elem) Table 1. Daily and Accumulated Temperature Units (DTUs and ATUs) Days at School Date 1-16-15 1-17-15 1-18-15 1-19-15 1-20-15 1-21-15 1-22-15 1-23-15 1-24-15 AM PM Average Temp Temp Temp 47F 48F 47F 47F 48F 49F 48F 49F 48F 47F 48F 48F 48F 47.5F 47.5F Daily Temp Units (Avg temp - 32 F) 48 – 32 = 16 48 – 32 = 16 48 – 32 = 16 47.5 – 32 = 15.5 47.5 – 32 = 15.5 Accum. Temp Units 631 647 663 679 694.5 710 Notes @pickup from Lewis River Hatchery @ Columbia Springs @ Columbia Springs @ Columbia Springs @ Columbia Springs @ Columbia Springs Table 1. Daily and Accumulated Temperature Units (DTUs and ATUs) Days at School Date AM Temp PM Temp Average Temp Daily Temp Units (Avg temp - 32 F) Accum. Temp Units Notes Table 2. Accumulated temperature units (ATUs) required to reach important embryonic developmental stages in commonly cultured salmonids in Alaska. ATUs in °C CHINOOK SALMON To eyed stage To hatch To emergence CHUM SALMON To eyed stage To hatch To emergence COHO SALMON To eyed stage To hatch To emergence PINK SALMON To eyed stage To hatch To emergence SOCKEYE SALMON To eyed stage To hatch To emergence ARCTIC CHAR To eyed stage To hatch To emergence RAINBOW TROUT To eyed stage To hatch To emergence STEELHEAD To eyed stage To hatch To emergence ATUs in °F 280 480-540 900-1000 504 864-972 1620-1800 300-350 475-525 900-1000 540-630 855-945 1620-1800 220 400-500 700-800 396 720-900 1260-1440 350-400 550-650 900-950 630-720 990-1170 1620-1710 230 500-550 900-1000 414 900-990 1620-1800 200 475 700 360 855 1260 210-240 300-320 500-580 378-432 540-576 900-1044 250-270 360 600 450-486 648 1080 When will they hatch? You can predict when salmon will hatch by keeping track of the water temperature. Salmon eggs prefer temperatures from 45oC to 58oC. The higher the temperature, the faster the embryos inside the eggs will develop. People who raise salmonids in hatcheries know when each batch of eggs will hatch because they know how much thermal energy the eggs must get to develop fully. The thermal energy comes from the heat in the water and can be measured as accumulated temperature units, or ATUs. Beginning on the day the eggs are fertilized, the temperature units for every day are added. When the sum of the daily temperature units (DTUs) reaches the required total, the eggs will hatch. The required total for coho salmon is between 720-900 ATU. Predict when our salmon eggs will hatch: Our salmon eggs were fertilized at the hatchery on Dec. 3, 2014. They spent the time at the fish hatchery in 44 degree water. As of Jan.20, the eggs had 695 temperature units. They need between 720 and 900 temperature units to hatch. 1. How many accumulated temperature units do our salmon need to hatch? ______ - 631 = ________ ________- 631 = ___________ The salmon need between ______ and ______ temperature units. 2. Water Temperature – 32 = DTUs (Our water temperature is 47 degrees) _______ - 32 = ________ 3. Our fish get _____ temperature units each day. They need between ______ and ______ more temperature units. _____ ÷ ______ = ____more days _____ ÷ ______ = ____more days 4. Count from Jan. 20 on the calendar. Our fish should hatch between __________ ________ and _________________. Salmon in Schools PREDICT the date our salmon will hatch! Our salmon should hatch between January 26, 2015 and February 7, 2015. Write your teacher’s name and room number on the day you PREDICT the salmon will hatch. The classroom that comes closest to predicting the correct date will win a very LARGE box of YUMMY FISH CRACKERS! January 2015 Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday 21 22 23 Pick-up Date Saturday 24 25 26 27 28 31 29 30 February 2015 Sunday 1 Monday 2 Tuesday 3 Wednesday Thursday Friday 4 5 6 Saturday 7 8 9 10 11 13 14 Salisbury Room 9 Valentines Day! 12