The “Iron Curtain” (black line) Nikita Khrushchev (Soviet leader, 1953-64) denounced Stalin’s “cult of personality” in a closed meeting of the 20th Congress of the CPSU in February 1956 but was shocked when anti-Stalinist riots broke out in Poland and Hungary Soviet tanks crush the uprising in Budapest in October 1956; 3,000 Hungarians were killed, and 200,000 fled the country In 1961 the “Berlin Wall” plugged the last gap in the Iron Curtain The death strip at Potsdam Square, Berlin, 1982 Soviet tanks intervene in Czechoslovakia, August 1968, ending the “Prague Spring” The West German Chancellor Willy Brandt (SPD) pursued Ostpolitik (shown here in 1970 honoring the dead of the Warsaw Ghetto) Brandt welcomes Leonid Brezhnev to Bonn in 1973 to promote detente Brezhnev (Soviet leader, 1964-82) sought to reduce the cost of the arms race, so he agreed at the Helsinki Conference in 1975 to promote “security and cooperation” in Europe and to respect the principles of the UN “Universal Declaration of Human Rights” (1948) Erich Honecker of East Germany confers with West Germany’s Helmut Schmidt at Helsinki Pope John Paul II celebrates mass in Gdansk, Poland, in June 1979, inspiring the growth of “Solidarity” Lech Walesa addresses a Solidarity rally at the Lenin Shipyards in Gdansk, 1980. The podium is decorated with pictures of the Virgin Mary and John Paul II. General Jaruzelski appears on Polish TV in December 1981 to declare martial law, banning “Solidarity” •Mikhail Gorbachev became the Soviet leader in 1985 and proclaimed a new gospel of glasnost (openness) & perestroika (restructuring) President Reagan greets Gorbachev in Washington, Dec. 1987 ECONOMIC FAILURES OF COMMUNIST EAST GERMANY Strip mining for brown coal near Leipzig GDR foreign debt 1972 $1 billion 1980 $13.9 billion 1989 $20.6 billion Estimated ratio between average household income in East and West Germany 1970 64% 1983 46% Lech Walesa addresses a mass rally of “Solidarity” in 1988 (in January 1989 the government recognized it legally) The “Goddess of Democracy” in Tiananmen Square (Beijing, June 1989): China had pursued economic modernization since 1976, but the Communist Party retained all power A lone protester blocks the advance of tanks sent to crush the demonstration on June 5, 1989; estimates of the death toll in the following days range from 200 to 3,000 The Hungarian and Austrian foreign ministers dismantle the “Iron Curtain” near Sopron, 27 June 1989 East Germans scale the fence of the West German embassy in Prague, 28 September 1989 (140,000 made it to the West) Honecker and Gorbachev celebrate the 40th anniversary of the founding of the GDR, East Berlin, 7 October 1989: “When we fall behind, life punishes us immediately.” Demonstration by 120,000 in Leipzig, 16 October 1989 Demonstration by 500,000 in East Berlin, 4 Nov. 1989 THE FALL OF THE BERLIN WALL, November 8/9, 1989: The old regime abdicated with a TV press conference vaguely endorsing freedom of travel Police intervene against peaceful demonstrators in Prague, November 17, 1989 [Vaclav] “Havel to the Castle” (Prague, November 1989) Only in Romania did the Communist dictator, Nicolae Ceauşescu, order security forces to open fire on protesters; he was deposed and killed in December 1989. PROTEST LEADERS SOON BECAME ELECTED PRESIDENTS Lech Walesa addresses the Polish parliament, December 22, 1990 Vaclav Havel discusses Czech entry to the EU with Jacques Delors in Brussels, March 1991 Gorbachev and German Chancellor Helmut Kohl in Moscow, 1990 (economic aid purchased a Soviet evacuation of East Germany) Elite KGB troops confront independence demonstrators in Lithuania, 1990 (they used lethal force) The Azeri-Armenian war of 1989-1994 Since 1994 Armenian troops have controlled most of NagornoKarabakh, but negotiations over its legal status continue Boris Yeltsin addresses demonstrators against the Communist coup in Moscow, 1991 The “Commonwealth of Independent States” (1992) The expansion of NATO as of 2004. Croatia & Albania joined in 2009, but talk of membership for Ukraine and Georgia is fading. POTSDAMER PLATZ TODAY WITH THE SONY CENTER REFLECTIONS ON THE COLLAPSE OF COMMUNISM Communism had achieved successes in smokestack industries but fell far behind the West in the 1980s in computing and communications technology. The USSR blundered by seeking to match U.S. military spending with a much weaker economic base. Gorbachev’s career suggests an answer to Machiavelli’s old question, “Is it better to be loved or feared?” Economic stagnation alone cannot explain regime collapse (see North Korea and Cuba). Hundreds of thousands of incredibly brave citizens throughout Eastern Europe gave their tottering regimes a big push by coming out onto the streets. For many, nationalism filled the emotional vacuum left by the collapse of Communism.