Nestle Marketing Case Study Almudena Pitarque Spring 2011 COMPANY BACKGROUND Until 1994, Nestle USA utilized only limited Hispanic advertising. However, as the spending of the Hispanic people in the USA grew, they started to think about putting more efforts on that audience. Thus, in 1994, when the Latino population spent over $188 billion annually in the USA, Nestle was planning a major ethnic marketing strategy. They started by looking for an advertising agency, for what they reviewed five possibilities: four California shops and one Dallas agency (Krajewski, 1994). The winner was Siboney USA, based in Dallas, which was awarded with a $10-million account (Castaneda, 1994). Nestle's previous Hispanic Spending had peaked at about $3 million annually. The first brands that Nestle started to target to the Hispanic audience through this agency were Taster's Choice Coffee, Carnation Coffee-Mate, Nestle' Quick, Stouffer's Lean Cuisine, Alpo and Friskies Pet Foods. These first advertising efforts were focused on top Hispanic markets, including Los Angeles, Miami and Dallas. Nestle USA, based in California, has been targeting the Hispanic audience for 17 years (Stuart, 1994). According to Brad Alford, CEO of Nestle USA, the company discovered the Latino Market about 120 years ago, but it was only in the 1990s that they realized their potential. “You cannot live in the United States and particularly in Southern California, where we live, and not know there's a huge amount of Hispanic immigrants living there”, states Alford (Arredondo, 2008). So when the Latino market was booming in the 90s, especially Mexicans, Nestle started to import some Mexican products for domestic distribution. However, these efforts were not accompanied by any advertising or in-store promotions. It was just a trading business at one point. The real advertising efforts started in 1994, although it was still advertising of Latin or American products of the company without any adaptation. Over the end of the 80s, Nestle established a division called “Confections and Emerging Markets” with the function of exploring new opportunities. Since 2005, the Latino market in the United States has become its main focus. When Frank Higgins took over the division that year, things changed drastically. The division started an aggressive strategy to repackage and adapt Mexican brands in order to promote them among Latinos in the United States and begin its introduction to the general market as well (Arredondo, 2008). STRATEGIES AND IMPLEMENTATION The first distinction I would like to make regarding the strategies of Nestle is among three types of products targeted to the Latin market: Latin products imported to the United States without adaptation, Latin products imported to the United States with some adaptation and finally, American products targeted also to the Latin market. In first place, as I have stated before, the company started to target the Latin market in the US by importing Latin products from their home countries with no adaptation, and they keep implementing this strategy among others nowadays. Some Mexican brands that have crossed over into the United States are Abuelita, a Mexican-style and cinnamon-based chocolate brand; La Lechera, a sweetened condensed milk product that has been present in Latin America and Spain for nearly a century; coffeemilk Nescafe Cafe con Leche; and chocolate bar Carlos V (Arredondo, 2008). This last brand was first introduced in 2006 in Southern California through a radio campaign and an in-store program in Hispanic-area grocery stores (Schemelzer, 2006). The company also goes after non-Mexican Latino consumers with products like Maggie seasonings, well known in Central and South America. In second place, we can distinguish those Latin products that have been adapted for Latinos in the US. This adaptation has taken two ways: a simple repackaging and the development of new products. On the one hand, although they have retained their names and are exactly the same product, the labels of those imported Latin products are now printed bilingual, sometimes with a bit of “Spanglish”. On the other hand, some products have been developed in order to be adapted to the new life that Latinos face in the US. CEO Alford points to the fast-paced, pragmatic American lifestyle and states that “as an immigrant, you have to adapt to the new country that you are in. Now Latinos want a way to prepare these products very quickly”. That's why in 2007, both Abuelita and La Lechera debuted in squeeze bottles. Alford states that they're “trying to take those brands and to some grade 'anglicize' them to fit what immigrants face in the US” (Arredondo, 2008). In third place, Nestle is also trying to introduce Latinos to some of its US brands. One initiative is the bilingual website www.MiCocinaLatina.com, which teaches Hispanics how to prepare turkeys and pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving and other special American foods for different holidays. It also offers tips for English-speaking lovers of Latin cuisine (Vinueza, 2010). The second distinction I would like to make in the way Nestle targets the Hispanic market is the kind of Latinos they target. Traditionally, Nestle has been targeting recent arrived Hispanics, Spanish-dominant and who know Nestle from their home countries. Kin Jeffery, CMO of Nestle USA pointed out this: “One of the things we know is that when people migrate to this country from Latin American countries, they are very familiar with the Nestle trademark. There's a high level of trust” (Zmuda, 2008). Juan Motta, Nestlé's head of emerging markets-domestic, noted the past year that Nestlé's focus has been more on unacculturated Hispanics, building on immigrants' brand loyalty to Nestlé products such as La Lechera that they grew up with in Latin America (Wentz, 2010). One special market that they have been targeting among Hispanics are Latino mothers, that are the ones who care about the health and wellness of their families. Two examples of products that have been targeted to Latino mothers are infant-formula brands such as Nan, targeted to low-income immigrant mothers (Jordan, 2004); and Nestle Pure Life, a bottled water brand. In 2010, Nestle did not run general market advertising of this last brand but focused instead on Hispanic advertising (O'Leary, 2010). The company started the “Vive Sanamente” multi-paltform campaign to promote these last brand among Hispanics. The target audience was recent U.S. Hispanic immigrants, moms in particular, who are not acculturated to American products, yet have an affinity for the Nestle name. To do that, the company hired Cristina Saralegui, a veteran journalist who is known as “the Hispanic Oprah”. Five separate 30-second TV spots played out on Hispanic-skewing networks such as Univision, Galavisión and Telefutura with Saralegui dispensing advice on healthy living choices and the benefits of water as opposed to sweetened drinks. The effort also was supported by print ads in Ser Padres, Vanidades, Cosmopolitan en Español and People en Español as well as regional radio spots and interactive websites. Consumers could tell about the healthy changes in the lives registering in the website www.vivesanamentenestle.com, and doing so they entered a contest with over $20,000 in prizes, including a grand prize trip for four to Miami, and dinner with Cristina Saralegui (De Lafuente, 2008). Despite having traditionally targeted unacculturated Hispanics, Nestle is now trying to target also bicultural consumers, as the Hispanic market is growing more through U.S. births than immigration (Wentz, 2010). Thus, at the end of 2009 Nestle started a marketing campaign to target the brand Hot Pockets to young bicultural Hispanics. The problem that Nestle found here is that they wanted to sell a frozen hand-held product to young Hispanics who grew up in a culture full of good food, associated with love and family as well as nourishment. To do that, the company contracted the services of the agency Casanova Pendrill, which seized on the less-appetizing side of that abundance: the leftovers, the agency created a campaign distributed just on the Internet through a video and posters with the Spanglish theme “Cuidado con los leftovers”. This viral campaign exaggerated the problem of leftovers by creating a fictitious horror movie in the form of a movie trailer and posters depicting a hungry but unsuspecting young couple pursued by scary leftovers like a rampaging three-day-old chicken. The message was “Eat what you really want. Hot Pockets.” Nestlé picked Sacramento, in California, as the campaign's test market, leading up to an invitationonly comedy-club performance by a Hispanic comedian hired to develop a routine about food, scary leftovers and young Hispanic males (Wentz, 2010). In April this year, the same agency, Casanova Pendrill, presented its new campaign of Hot Pockets for Nestlé, targeted to the same audience of Hispanic bilingual teens born in the United States. The campaign consists on a viral commercial called “Inappropiate Flirting” in which a chicken tries to flirt with the man who opens the fridge, using both Spanish and English. The message is “Don't let leftovers seduce you. Eat Hot Pockets”. The commercial is being distributed via Youtube, Facebook and different blogs and websites visited by the target audience (“Preestreno de Casanova Pendrill para Nestle”, 2011). Other different media that the company has been using to target its Hispanic audience is the traditional mail. On the Hispanic Heritage Month (September 15- October 15), Nestle sends via mail pamphlets that contain recipes of traditional Latin dishes made with Nestlé products that made the dish easier to make and less time-wasting, understanding the fast-paced life that Latinos face in the United States (Diaz, 2010). Latinos can also look up these recipes in the website www.cocinandoconnestle.com. Furthermore, Nestle sponsors on television a cooking segment called “Cocinando con Nestle”, that airs every Friday morning in Univision as part of the TV show “Despierta America”. The segment features the chef Lorena García preparing easy and tasty recipes made with Nestlé’s popular Latino brands La Lechera, Maggi, Abuelita, Nestlé Media Crema and Nescafé. Recipes featured each week are designed to bring back memories of traditional, rich Latin American cuisine (Vinueza, 2010). The videos are available on the website mentioned earlier and on the company's account on Youtube. Moreover, Nestle USA is trying to reach the Hispanic audience using handheld devices. The company created in 2010 a mobile website and iPhone application that draw sweet and savory recipes from the brand's MiCocinaLatina.com wired website, delivering product and brand engagement to consumers' mobile phones. Both the mobile Web site and the iPhone application present content in Spanish and English. King Hill, president of DigiKnow’s Circle 44 Mobile, the company which developed the application, stated that “the strategy behind making it mobile and building the iPhone app was to address their Hispanic audience, which happens to be more mobile than the rest of us”. According to the Pew Internet & American Life Project, in 2009 more than 47 percent of Hispanics used a handheld device to go online, compared to 28 percent of Caucasians. The mobile website offers full search capabilities of more than 300 recipes for Web-enabled phones. The iPhone application provides similar capabilities, with a user experience optimized for the device’s touch screen. It also offers a twist on standard recipe search: with a shake of the iPhone, the user can generate a random recipe. This development targets Hispanics in general, but specially Hispanic moms, women in their early 20s to mid-fifties and on up to grandmas, the people who run the kitchen (Butcher, 2010). RESULTS AND EVALUATION Nestle is today a good example of the term “glocal”: a global company that acts locally. The overall strategy seems to be working. Nestle is satisfied with the consistent 20 percent annual growth rate in Latino product sales for the last years. In 2008, Nestle USA made over $11 billion in sales, of which five percent were from the US Latino market (Arredondo, 2008). Regarding to particular brands, Nestle Pure Life is one that seems to have achieved good results from the Hispanic market. According to Carolina Rodriguez, the marketing manager of Nestle Waters North America, “Hispanic sales have been a big contributor to the brand’s growth in America”. She also stated that “even when general market sales were not growing, Hispanic sales were going up” (O'Leary, 2010). The two viral compaigns mentioned of the company have had very different results, measured in visits to the videos on Youtube. While the 2009/2010 commercial, with the theme “Cuidado con los leftovers” has just received 1,150 visits since its was uploaded on September 2009, the second commercial, uploaded on April 4th this year and called “Inappropiate Flirting”, has received more than 24,000 visits in just two weeks. As Latin population continues to grow by birth rates, Nestle is planning to study more in deep US born and acculturated Latinos. In 2010, the company joined Latinum, a peer-to-peer business network that is bringing together Hispanic marketers to share everything from dealing with the need for better data to hot topics such as the acculturation of Latino consumers. Juan Motta, Nestlé's head of emerging markets-domestic, said of Latinum, “It's an opportunity to share best practices with others, and pool resources so we can get smarter about things like how the U.S. Hispanic consumer is acculturating.” (Wentz, 2010). MY OPINION I think Nestle is targeting very good the Hispanic audience. This is a natural market for them, because Latino women usually spend more time cooking than other US women, and they have known how to target them with the TV segment “Cocinando con Nestle” and the Nestle Pure Life campaign. Also I liked the idea of adapting some Latino products to the American life by creating a squeeze bottle version. It's a simple idea but it works. Regarding their viral campaigns to promote their brand Hot Pockets, it's a very good idea to target young bicultural Hispanics using just the Internet, as it's were they are and it's cheaper. Moreover, I like a lot the idea that the advertising agency has developed, seizing on the less-appetizing aspects of the leftovers. But I think they didn't took its most with the first campaign. Personally, I don't like it. If they decide to show a commercial just on Youtube and other websites where the audience has to press “play”, it has to be a very good commercial, and I think that one wasn't. However, the second commercial, using the same idea, looks a lot more interesting. In conclusion, the company has been targeting the immigrant unacculturated Hispanic audience for some years, developing a good market among them. But it has just started to target more acculturated Latinos very recently, so it's very soon to evaluate the efforts of the company. We will have to wait to see what other innovative ways apart from videos on the Internet the company will use to reach this relatively new market. References - Butcher, Dan “Nestlé targets Hispanics with Carnation Evaporated Milk mobile site, app”, Mobile Marketer, April 14, 2010. <http://www.mobilemarketer.com/cms/news/advertising/5970.html> - Jordan, Miriam “Nestlé markets baby formula”, The Wall Street Journal, March 4, 2004. <http://buiznt.cob.calpoly.edu/cob/MGT/Pendergast/sp04/Nestle%20Markets%20Baby%20Formula %20To%20Hispanic%20Mothers%20in%20U_S.htm> - Arredondo, Cesar “Latino market is a sweet deal for Nestle”, BNET, July 2008. <http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0PCH/is_5_9/ai_n27953111/?tag=content;col1> - Wentz, Laurel “Marketers join forces to better target Hispanics”, Advertising Age, January 4, 2010. <http://www.latinumnetwork.com/coverage1.php> - Castaneda, Laura “Hispanic ad agency snares Nestle”, The Dallas Morning News, December 9, 1994. - Moore, M. H. “Early Xmas at Siboney”, Adweek, December 12, 1994. - Schmelzer, Randi “Nestle brings Carlos V to Southern California”, PR Week, October 2, 2006. - Wentz, Laurel. “Hot Pockets, Dr Pepper win over bicultural youth”, Advertising Age, January 4, 2010. <http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=47357747&site=bsilive&scope=site > - Zmuda, Natalie “Why bottled water is not all washed up”, Advertising Age, December 8, 2008. <http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=35651663&site=bsilive&scope=site > - De Lafuente, Della “Nestle pitches Pure Life to Latinos”, Hispanic Trending, August 6, 2008. <http://juantornoe.blogs.com/hispanictrending/2008/08/nestle-pitches.html> - Diaz, Denise “Nestle celebrates Hispanic Heritage Month with easy Latin recipes”, Ask Denisa, September 23, 2010. <http://www.askdenisa.com/2010/09/nestle-celebrates-hispanic-heritagemonth-with-easy-latin-recipes/> - O'Leary, Noreen “Nestle challenges Hispanics to drink more water”, Adweek, May 12, 2010. <http://www.adweek.com/news/advertising-branding/nestle-challenges-hispanics-drink-morewater-102313> - “Preestreno de Casanova Pendrill para Nestle”, Adlatina.com, April 1, 2011. <http://www.adlatina.com/notas/noticia.php?id_noticia=40501> - “Denny's names Sibonet USA as Hispanic advertising agency of record”, The Free Library, May 13, 1996. <http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Denny%27s+names+Siboney+USA+as+Hispanic+Advertising+Ag ency+of+Record.-a018276707> - Elliott, Stuart “Spanish-speaking venture formed”, The New York Times, December 9, 1994. <http://www.nytimes.com/1994/12/09/business/the-media-business-advertising-addenda-spanishspeaking-venture-formed.html?scp=3&sq=nestle+hispanic&st=nyt> - Vinueza, Elaine “Cocinando Con Nestle con su chef Lorena García se incorpora al programa matutino Despierta América de Univision”, Hispanic PR Wire, March 26, 2010. <http://www.hispanicprwire.com/news.php?l=es&id=11075> - Krajewski, Steve “Nestle nears end of Hispanic review”, Adweek, December 5, 1994. <http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=9412221698&site=bsilive&scope=site >