Development of an Auditory Function/ A-V Techniques Developed by: Beth Walker, M.Ed., C.E.D., LSLS Cert. AVT Kathryn Wilson, M.A., CCC-SLP, LSLS Cert. AVT Megan Katz, MS, CCC-SLP, LSLS Cert. AVT Presented by: Megan Katz, MS, CCC-SLP, LSLS Cert AVT Sherri Vernelson, M.Ed., LSLS Cert AVEd Agenda Auditory Processing, Neuroplasticity of the Auditory System and Critical Period for Development of Auditory Function Normal Auditory Development Speech Acoustics Auditory-Verbal Techniques and Strategies Guide to the Development of Auditory Skills Assessment Development of an Auditory-Verbal Program Learner Outcomes Examine research on auditory brain development and how this impacts auditory learning of children with hearing loss. Identify and sequence specific auditory behaviors that occur in the development of spoken language and will identify components of a detailed model of auditory learning. Apply information about specific formant frequencies of individual phonemes to the auditory learning of spoken language. Identify factors that affect the auditory reception of spoken language and select appropriate strategies and techniques for assisting auditory perception of particular features of spoken language. Predict levels of development in speech, language, cognition and communication in relation to level of auditory development. Develop A-V lesson plans including goals, activities, strategies and carry-over ideas for specific cases. Auditory Brain Development & Auditory Processing We know what you are thinking…. What a fun, exciting, interesting, motivating, attention-grabbing, fascinating way…. to start the day!!! The goal for children in an AV approach is spoken language. The MOST effective modality for acquiring/teaching spoken language is HEARING. What do we know about the relationship between listening, literacy and success in reading? Auditory Brain Development It’s all about the BRAIN! The ears are just the way in… Quick Quiz… We’ll answer these & other REALLY important questions Measurable differences in brain organization and neural activity is caused by ______ ______. Research by Sharma indicates that the brain waves of children who begin wearing hearing aids or cochlear implants by _____ years of age reflect a normal response to sound. What is developmental synchrony? Is there a critical period for the development of auditory function? A-V Principles 1 & 2 Newborn hearing screening programs & 21st Century technology allow access to the auditory centers of the brain Access is a good thing! In fact, it is great! Is it enough? Easy Math… Early identification + early & appropriate technology + appropriate intervention by parents & professionals during the period of maximum neural plasticity = potential for achieving high levels of speech, language, reading, literacy & success in school. Neuroplasticity----Current Research The infant brain has neural plasticity. Complete maturation of the central auditory pathways is required for the normal development of spoken language in children. The period of greatest neuroplasticity is the first 3 ½ years of life (Sharma et al, 2002; 2004; Sharma, Dorman, and Kral, 2005). Children implanted by 12 months of age may demonstrate more benefit than children receiving implants later on in the period of maximum neural plasticity (Sharma, Dorman, and Kral, 2005). When children acquire skills at or near the time that they are intended to do so biologically, this is called developmental synchrony. Making the Connections… A baby’s brain continues growing beyond the womb—not just in size, but in forming connections Born with 100 billion neurons. By 3 years of age babies have about 15,000 synapses per neuron, three times the synapses of adults. What happens to synapses that are not accessed? Making the Connections… “Babies are citizens of the world.” Neurons in the auditory cortex Laborers with no job assignments As the infant is exposed to spoken language, different clusters of neurons in the auditory cortex are recruited to respond to different phonemes Neuron clusters fire only when a nerve from the ear carries a particular sound By 12 months of age a child’s “auditory map” is established Making the Connections… Training OR Learning? For the young child,meaningful contexts are crucial for the auditory processing of spoken language. “The hearing-impaired child’s auditory abilities develop ‘because emphasis is placed on listening throughout all waking hours so that hearing becomes an integral part of his/her personality.” (Pollack, 1985) It’s All About Experience Experience & Vocabulary Vocabulary size correlated with quantity of maternal “talk” 20 months of age—offspring of talkative mothers averaged 131 more words than children of less talkative moms At age two, the gap doubles Critical factor—number of times the child HEARS different words TV doesn’t produce same results. Why not? Information within context seems to stimulate neural circuitry What happens when the auditory centers of the brain are not accessed early? Decreased ability to use sound meaningfully (cross-modal reorganization) Physiological changes Psychosocial factors When the hearing aids are OFF what happens? Auditory Processing of Spoken Language “The auditory processing ‘whole’ is greater than the sum of current knowledge of its hypothesized parts.” (Cole,1992, 2006) Components of auditory processing models Peripheral hearing structures are responsible for analysis and conversion of speech/acoustic information to nerve impulses for transmission to the brain Preliminary processing in the brainstem Brief memory storage required Localization and selective attention Auditory cortex receives input Higher level analysis includes: phonetic, phonological, syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic/contextual processing Take Home Points… We hear with the ____. Neuroplasticity is greatest during the first ___years What is the purpose of hearing aids and cochlear implants? What happens when the auditory centers are not stimulated early? Full maturation of the central auditory pathways is a must for________. References Bock, P., (2005). How do babies learn to talk? Retrieved on July 1, 2007 from http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/pacificnw/2005/0306 Cole, E., & Flexer, C. (2007). Children with hearing loss: Developing listening and talking birth to six. San Diego CA: Plural Publishing Sharma, A., Dorman, M.F., Kral, A. (2005). The influence of a sensitive period on central auditory development in children with unilateral and bilateral cochlear implants. Hearing Research, 2-3, 134-143. Sharma, A., Dorman, M.F., & Spahr, A.J. (2002). A sensitive period for the development of the central auditory system in children with cochlear implants: Implications for age of implantation. Ear and Hearing. 23(6), 532-539. Sharma, A., Martin, K., Roland, P., Bauer, P., Sweeney, M.H., Gilley, P., et al. (2005). P1 latency as a biomarker for central auditory development in children with hearing impairment. Journal of the American Academy of Audiology, 16, 564-573. Let’s Talk about Hearing Age Relationship between age at first amplification and a child’s chronological age Calculated from the day the child begins wearing amplification Hearing age is the term used to put progress in perspective Listening experience Mixed hearing history Other Terms Cochlear Implant Age = length of time since CI “hook-up.” A-V Age = length of time enrolled in Auditory-Verbal Therapy Language Age = level of understanding and use of language Application John is an 11 month old boy whose moderately severe bilateral hearing loss was diagnosed at two months of age. He began wearing hearing aids at 3 months of age and began AVT at the age of 5 months. What is John’s hearing age? What is his program (AVT) age? At a chronological age of 3 years 8 months, John obtained the following scores on standardized measures of language: PLS-4 101 98 Lang. 100 3 years, 7 months Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III AC AE Total A.E. SS 92 A.E. 3 years, 3 months Discuss the test results for John in relation to: Chronological Age Hearing Age Program Age Application Cate is 4 years, 6 months of age. Her severeprofound bilateral hearing loss was identified at 13 months of age, and she was subsequently fitted with hearing aids at 15 months. What is her hearing age? Cate received a cochlear implant at 2 years, 6 months and began AVT at the same time. Note: Cate was enrolled in a TC program from 16 –28 months of age. What is Cate’s CI age? AVT age? At 4 years, 6 months of age, Cate has an expressive vocabulary of 284 words. She consistently uses 3-word combinations spontaneously such as “I want cookie” “no want that” and “I do it.” She can recall 3 critical elements, identify objects when given related descriptors and can identify segments of sequence stories. She demonstrates accurate vowel production and uses /p/, /m/, /w/, /h/ correctly in spontaneous speech. Cate uses all suprasegmental features of speech appropriately. Discuss Cate’s present level of functioning in relation to her: Chronological Age CI and AVT Age Stages of Auditory Development Follow the normal sequence of development A basic premise of Auditory-Verbal education is that limited-hearing children need the same foundation of listening experiences as a normal-hearing child regardless of the age at which intervention occurs Auditory Detection or Attention 0-2 months Distance Hearing 2-4 months Localization 4-6 months Presence & absence of snd. Begins to startle to snds at increasing distances “Orienting Perceives reflex” differences in Infant searches sounds for snd. Modifies speech to match what was heard First responses are to gross snds. Recognizes mother’s voice Localizationdevelops during 1st years of listening Reacts differently to different tones of voice Imitates nonspeech sounds Begins to u’stand source of snds & learns there are all kinds of snds. Stops crying to listen & listens to his own snds. Enjoys being whistled or sung to Monitors own vocal play Begins to listen w/ varying degrees of attn. Enjoys a few noise-makers Discrimination 5-7 months Auditory Self-Monitoring 8-10 months Auditory Ident. Association 9-11 months Auditory Memory 9-12 months Labels what was heard Remembers what was heard Object selection Recalls critical elements Auditory Sequencing 10-18 months Auditory Processing months Auditory Understanding 18-48 months 48-72 months Remembers what was heard in the correct order Makes cognitive judgments about what was heard Compre-hends auditory information in a variety of settings Speech Acoustics Let’s Review… Why should we know this? Knowledge of speech acoustics helps us: Bridge the disciplines of audiology and habilitation Judge what speech information is available to a child through hearing Teach parents what the child can do or has the potential to do with his/her aided hearing Select strategies to facilitate the processing of spoken language through audition “ah” “eye” “save” /s/ /e/ /v/ “mean” /m/ /i/ /n/ “tide” /t/ /ai/ /d/ Multimedia FUN! http://www.utdallas.edu/~thib/EARRINGFINAL/EARRING WEB_files/frame.htm http://hctv.humnet.ucla.edu/departments/linguistics/Vow elsandConsonants/course/chapter1.1/chapter1.1.htm#fou r http://hctv.humnet.ucla.edu/departments/linguistics/Vow elsandConsonants/course/chapter8/speechbird/speechbird .html http://www.oraldeafed.org/movies/heardiff.html Auditory-Verbal Strategies and Techniques Position to maximize auditory input Sit behind the child? In front of the child? On top of the child??? Beside the child? On which side? Position to maximize auditory input Optimal distance is Within ___ inches of the HA microphone Within ___ inches of the CI microphone Come close to me at 6 dB…… Amplification should be set so that child can easily hear you at a distance of ___ Maintain Favorable Auditory Learning Environment This means controlling ___ & ___ In which of the child’s learning environments can the adult exert control over these factors? How? Positioning Favorable Auditory Environments GREAT website! Contains audio files for demo of FM with/without hearing aid, what a CI sounds like, simulations of auditory neuropathy, etc. http://www.utdallas.edu/~thib/EARRIN GFINAL/EARRINGWEB_files/frame.htm Attention Getters The “Listen!” Cue Audition FIRST Not show and tell but Tell and Show Why hearing first? Sing What You Say/Parentese Get Closer Helps for PROCESSING through Audition CLEAR Speech Speak Suthun: i.e., a slightly slower rate of speech Acoustic Highlighting: more to less Lowlighting/Whispering: Why? Helps for Processing WAIT Time + Expectant Look The ___ the child, the more wait time needed The Expectant Look says… Repetition: Why? Pause before challenging word/s Helps for Processing Word position in sentence Give a choice What DID you hear? And if you must… A-V-A Sandwich or “Put it back into hearing” Give visual context for auditory input Point to the picture/object Natural gesture Facial expression Adjust set size Helps for Confident Listening Modeling Converse slightly above child’s linguistic level Diagnostic Teaching, NOT testing Known →unknown, audible →less audible Other Strategies The absent-minded therapist Let child be the teacher Prerequisites Knowledge of… Auditory processing, neuroplasticity of the auditory system and a critical period for development of an auditory function Normal Auditory Development Speech Acoustics Auditory-Verbal Strategies & Techniques Assessment of Listening Skills Current Models of Auditory Learning Cole and Flexer (2007) Dickson, C. (1999) Estabrooks (1998) Pollack, Goldberg, Caleffe-Schenck (1990) Romanik, S. (1990) Simser (1993) Walker (1995, rev. 2009) Auditory Learning Guide (ALG) (Walker, 1995) Framework for the development of an auditory function Based on the work of Simser, Romanik & Foreworks Curriculum Comprehensive chart Not an exhaustive list The ALG is useful for… Establishing Goals Planning therapy sessions Documenting progress Parent Education Professional collaboration Auditory Learning Guide Five levels: Sound Awareness Phoneme Level Discourse Level Sentence Level Word Level Concurrent development Timelines are color-coded Auditory Learning Guide CONSIDERATIONS: Therapist’s skill level/experience Residual hearing/aided thresholds Age at implantation Perception vs. production Sound Awareness DETECTION ONLY, “LOW LEVEL” With optimal amplification, may complete work on all steps in one week Begins with detection of ANY speech sound Quickly progresses to detection of all sounds Close range to Distance Includes detection of wide variety of environmental sounds at various distances Environmental Sounds Indoor Sounds vacuum cleaner, knock on the door, washing machine, dryer, teapot whistling, hair dryer, TV, radio, smoke alarm, blender, telephone Softer Sounds clock ticking, cat’s meow/purr, broom sweeping, pages being turned, coins or keys clinking Environmental Sounds Human Noises Musical Instruments laughing, sneezing, coughing, crying, whistling, walking, snoring drum, bells, horn, piano, tambourine Outdoor Noises thunder, fire engine, airplane, train, car horn, garage door, dog barking, rain Sound Awareness Conditioned Response Exposure/Modeling at 16 months Most children consistent: ~24 months Audiological Evaluations More efficient More reliable More thorough Ling 6 Sound Check Daily checks help monitor: Amplification Middle Ear Status Phoneme Level What? Why? When? Examples: Alternating vowels Identification of consonants varying in manner of production Discourse Level Connected spoken language Conversational context: Discourse Dialogue Combine with Sentence and Word Level Discourse Level Year 1 Imitate motions of nursery rhymes/songs with accompanying vocalization To identify songs/rhymes To identify the last word read in a passage Easier to process larger units of language For individuals who can read Helps develop good phrasing and improves fluency To answer common questions Discourse Level Year 2 To follow a story illustrated by sequenced pictures. First step toward processing a story through listening alone To identify an object from several related descriptors (closed set) Begin with identifying items by function To follow a conversation with the topic disclosed. Tell the child what the topic is or let him choose Discourse Level Year 3 To answer questions about a story with the (topic disclosed). Precursor to story retelling Leads to recalling events, sequencing events and ultimately retelling a story To answer questions about a story with the (topic disclosed); story is teacher audio-taped. To recall details of a story (topic disclosed). No questions to prompt memory; details don’t have to be in correct sequence To sequence the events of a story (topic disclosed). Start with 3 events and move to 4, 5, more Discourse Level Year 4 To retell a story with the topic disclosed, recalling all details in sequence To make identification based on several related descriptors (open set). To follow a conversation of an undisclosed topic No prompts; completely open set Child is processing well by this stage To retell a story about an undisclosed topic, recalling as many details as possible. To process information while listening with competing stimuli. (taped voice with taped competing stimuli). Sentence Level “Stimulus-response” context Develops auditory memory MUST give child a communicative reason to respond Use imitation as a strategy After step 3? 6?, “work” at this level is often unnecessary Sentence Level Examples of Critical Elements One: Where’s the kittycat? Two: I need a red ball. Look under the table. Three: Mommy wants two pretzels. Four: Color the big star yellow and orange. More on Critical Elements Independent or Group practice Create an activity Be ready to share with the group Word Level Perception of individual words Progression: Acoustic features of the target Word placement In the context of phrases or sentences Word Level Vocabulary Development Program(NOT “skill-based” exercises with single words) 1. Learning to Listen sounds 2. Power Word list 3. Lexicon One 4. “Theme-based” units, Children’s Literature Units (Ling Basic Vocabulary & Language Guide) Content of Learning to Listen Sounds Learning to Listen Sounds contain all the suprasegmental features, early developing vowels and consonants. Why do we begin with the Learning to Listen Sounds rather than the animal and vehicle names? Criteria for Mastery Suprasegmentals Child must be able to imitate sounds that vary in duration, intensity, and pitch. Let’s name sounds with: Long duration Brief interrupted duration Loud intensity Quiet intensity High pitch Low pitch Varied pitch Criteria for Mastery Child must be able to imitate two back vowels, two mid-vowels and at least one front vowel. Let’s identify: Back vowels Mid vowels Front vowels Criteria for Mastery Child must be able to imitate a nasal, fricative, and plosive. Child must demonstrate spontaneous use AND identify Learning to Listen Sounds in a set of 10-12 How long should it take to complete the goal? Do we do Learning to Listen Sounds with “late starters?” Strategies for input? Strategies for identification? Power Words More Up Mama, Daddy Go Stop Bye-bye No All gone Hot/cold Mine/me Off/on Look Blow Go away Move Open First Lexicon First 30-60 words that young children acquire. Need a core vocabulary before child can produce two-word combinations First Lexicon includes nouns, pronouns, adjectives, verbs, position/location words and words to indicate denial and rejection Learning Contexts & Teaching Approaches Informal Learning •Happens in normal, everyday events and interactions •Should occur at home and school •All learner types Embellished Informal Teaching •Seize the moment •Use of strategies to embellish the normal situation •Should occur at home and school •All learner types Semi-Formal Teaching Formal Teaching •Adult directed, pre-planned activities •Developmentally appropriate •Specific goals and objectives •Use of strategies •Typically done at school •Delayed & remedial learners •Adult directed •Deliberate, direct, methodical •Specific goals and objectives •Use of strategies •Happens in traditional educational setting •School age remedial learners Types of Learners Developmental Delayed Within one yearof learners 1-2 years behind Three types English Language Skills of typically developing peers peers Remedial Greater than two years behind peers, scattered language skills Learning/Teaching Informal learning context Primarily semiformal, also need informal Formal learning, with generalized to informal Educational Placement Mainstreaming by kindergarten may be a challenge due to language gap one hr/pd per year of language delay Social mainstreaming Fully mainstreamed by preschool/kinderg arten Types of Learners Delayed and Remedial Learners CAN “catch up” with focused language intervention that follows a developmental sequence Lesson Plan Development Lesson Plan Development in the A-V Approach How do you know what to do when a child has a spoken language delay? Do you use a specific model for spoken language development? What model do you use for development of language? Why should you? Let’s Put it all together… You will need: Normal Development Resources: Language Development Vocab development Speech Development ALG Chart Blank Lesson Plan Forms A-V Teaching Behaviors: Establishing Goals Develop your road map What’s your destination? Long Term goals How ya gonna get there? Short term goals Lesson Planning and A-V Teaching Behaviors “Writes thorough, specific goals, specifying weekly targets and ideas for effective carryover.” “Demonstrates continuity in planning from session to session.” “Plans for parent education in each session.” Six-Step Guide To The Development of an Auditory Function in an A-V Approach With the parent: Evaluate the child’s present level of auditory development within the context of a detailed model for normal auditory development Determine next appropriate target Compare acoustic characteristics of the target with child’s auditory potential (audiological information) Select sense modality (consider hearing 1st) Develop the target through informal learning-formal teaching Evaluate progress toward goal often Lesson Plan Development: Point to Ponder Hearing children learn language through listening as they seek to extract meaning from their environment (Ling, 1986) What, in the child’s mind, is the reason to listen during this activity? Lesson Plan Development: Point to Ponder What is your major focus? Helping the parent to integrate new strategies into established daily routines? Helping the parent integrate new activities that promote listening into his schedule? Both? Neither? Lesson Plan Development: Point to Ponder Hearing children develop auditory behaviors in conjunction with speech, language and cognitive goals Integrate goals within one activity rather than teaching each area in an isolated activity Develop auditory behaviors in coordination with “hearing age” rather than chronological age until the gap is closed Lesson Plan Development: Point to Ponder Develop through: Informal Learning? Embellished Informal Teaching? Semi-formal Teaching? Formal Teaching? Meet Veronica ALG goals Strategies used Parent education How did Veronica respond? What would you do next? Independent Practice Consider: Learning context Type of learner Current level of development Select appropriate activities: Listening age Chronological age interests What are the next steps? Assessment of Listening Skills Purpose Speech Perception Testing is an essential feature of a comprehensive evaluation Compare various devices Document progress Device check Intervention planning Selection of strategies Testing Considerations Cognitive level Vocabulary level Speech production skills Chance level Acoustic feature specificity Appropriateness of materials Attention to task Speech Perception Tests Test of Auditory Comprehension Early Speech Perception Test—closed set/word level CID Sentences—open set/sentence level Glendonald Auditory Speech Perception Test (GASP)—closed set/word and open set/sentence level PBK-50 (kindergarten word lists)—open set/word level WIPI (Word Intelligibility by Picture Identification)—closed set/word level NU-CHIPS (Northwestern University Children’s Perception of Speech)—closed set/word level IT-MAIS (Infant-Toddler Meaningful Auditory Integration Scales) MAIS (Meaningful Auditory Integration Scales) Mr. Potato Head—closed set/sentence level SERT (Sound Effects)—environmental sounds MAC (Minimal Auditory Capabilities Test) Lexical Neighborhood Test (LNT) Multisyllabic Lexical Neighborhood Test (MLNT) open set/word recognition APT HI (Auditory Perception Test for the HI) SPICE (Speech Perception Instructional and Curriculum and Evaluation: For Children with Cochlear Implants and Hearing Aids) LIFE (Listening Inventory for Education Communication Skills Checklist (Med-EL) Early Speech Perception Test (Low Verbal Version) Used to estimate speech perception abilities in children (age two and up) with limited verbal abilities Determines if the child has the ability to identify words in small closed sets, based on patterns as well as phonemes Toy or picture stimuli Early Speech Perception Test (Standard Version) Sets are larger First section examines pattern perception abilities (monosyllabic, spondee, trochee & multisyllabic words). Spondee word subtest Monosyllabic word subtest CID Everyday Sentences Used to assess speech recognition at a sentence level. Key words are used to derive a percent correct score Considerations: cognitive level, vocabulary level, speech production skills Phonetically Balanced Kindergarten (PBK)50 Word List Monosyllabic word lists Presented auditory-only; open set Can derive percent word correct or percent phoneme correct Considerations: vocabulary level, speech production level Word Intelligibility by Picture Identification (WIPI) Compares the child’s ability to perceive words in three conditions Speechreading w/ hearing aids, without hearing aids and auditory only w/ hearing aids Stimuli are pictures of single syllable words in a closed set of 6 Chance level-17% Considerations: cognitive level, vocabulary Lexical Neighborhood Test & Multisyllabic Lexical Neighborhood Test Designed to assess word recognition. The LNT has single syllable words and the MLNT uses 2 & 3 syllable words. All words were selected from those known by 3 to 5 year old normal hearing children Each has an easy and a hard list Consideration: child’s speech production skills Reference: Kirk, K.L (1998).Assessing Speech Perception in Listeners with Cochlear Implants: The Development of the Lexical Neighborhood Tests. The Volta Review, 100, 63-85. Northwestern University Children’s Speech Perception Test (NU-CHIPS) Uses monosyllabic words to assess the child’s perception skills 4 choice/50 words - one presentation each Point to picture of target word represented on picture plate Chance level: 25% Consideration: vocabulary level, cognition Common Phrases Test Uses monosyllabic words 50 words per list - one presentation each Child repeats correct word Chance level: 2% Considerations: vocabulary, cognition Informal Assessment Tools Ling Six Sound Test task of 6 sounds presented at normal conversational level each sound represents critical information in a different frequency range optimal information in minimal time Why do we use the task? Predict the ability to recognize various speech features monitor changes in hearing d/t ME dysfunction measure changes in aided performance day to day measure the effects of distance observe changes in audibility between hearing aids and hearing aids in combination with FM Informal Assessment Tools Early Learning to Listen Sounds Early Phrases/Simple Directions time to eat wave bye-bye put it in give it a kiss Body Parts ah vs. bu bu bu meow vs moo p p p vs. bu bu bu nose, eyes, ears, mouth, etc Daily Performance Ongoing diagnostic teaching The AVT must be able to assess why a child is having considerable difficulty with particular goals and drop back to lower steps on the hierarchy. When a child is demonstrating competency with particular goals/skills, the AVT must be able to move on to new areas (goals/skills that can be accomplished with support). AVT must know prerequisite skills as well as those 1-2 levels above the selected target. Data collection regarding child’s performance Responses to auditory information New sounds produced (spontaneous or imitated) New words comprehended and used Areas of concern Mistakes made in auditory perception or speech errors Child’s behavior Likes and dislikes for particular activities Areas that need to be addressed in future sessions