CELEBRATE the STRUGGLE EMPOWERING STUDENTS TO DEVELOP A DEEP UNDERSTANDING OF ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS, PROCESSES, AND VOCABULARY IN ENGLISH BOOK A Kindergarten through Grade 5 SOL Vocabulary Resources “We can, whenever and wherever we choose, successfully teach all children whose schooling is of interest to us. We already know more than we need to do that. Whether or not we do it must finally depend on how we feel about the fact that we haven’t so far.” Ron Edmonds Prepared for the Professional Learning Network of the VIRGINIA ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENTS by Dan Mulligan, flexiblecreativity.com February 2014 Critical Common Core and College & Career Words McREL researchers estimate 85% of achievement test scores are based on the vocabulary of the standards. Students from poverty, ELL students, and other at-risk students are particularly in need of learning these words in ways that meet their specific learning needs. CRITICAL VERBS Analyze Comprehend Describe Draw Infer Organize Suggest Trace Articulate Contrast Determine Evaluate Integrate Paraphrase Support Cite Delineate Develop Explain Interpret Refer Summarize Compare Demonstrate Distinguish Identify Locate Retell Synthesize Argument Connotative Language Central Idea Interaction Metaphor Rhetoric Theme Simile Tone CRITICAL NOUNS Alliteration Analogy Conclusions Connections Evidence Mood Stanza Trace Figurative Language Illustrations Point of View Structures Details 2 THE RESEARCH There are a large number of critical words our students must master to be successful with the standards. The definitions of the word critical tell us the story. As we head into the regular use of the Revised Virginia Standards of Learning, it is essential that our students master these words. It will be absolutely necessary for them to automatically know the definitions without utilizing precious working memory. If they must search their brains to understand what the questions on the assessment are asking of them, they are wasting precious time and brain space needed to analyze their readings and answer the questions. Although the SOL have vocabulary standards that expect increases in academic vocabulary, the place to begin is with these critical words. Critical also is defined as “now or never.” As many as thirteen of the critical words can be found in the math kindergarten standards. There is much catching up to do for students in higher grades, but imagine what can be accomplished if your staff begins now. The students who are comfortable with these words will be the most successful in mastering the standards. Here is the plan: process the critical words in enough different ways to get them stored in the brain in multiple places. The result of this is easier access to the definition. Continue to rehearse the processing in enough formats over time and the words become as automatic as who, what, why, how, and where! Differentiate opportunities for students to interact with each word, add movement, 2D and 3D graphic organizers, use mind mapping, concept mapping, and vocabulary word maps. All of these and more provide many opportunities for differentiation and long-term memories. Teaching the vocabulary of the SOL and College & Career Ready Standards is urgently needed to assist students in understanding what is expected of them as they tackle complex texts, learn to read more closely, add to their vocabularies, improve speaking and listening skills, and become well-rounded learners and members of society. Your students may recognize words like determine, analyze, and distinguish, but do they understand these words well enough to quickly and completely answer a standardized test question? For example, can they respond to a question that says “determine the point of view of John Adams in his ‘Letter on Thomas Jefferson’ and analyze how he distinguishes his position from an alternative approach articulated by Thomas Jefferson”? 3 SAMPLE ITEMS (CIRCLE/HIGHLIGHT EACH CRITICAL WORD) Mathematics – Grade 3 Strand: Number and Number Sense – Fractions Give a fraction that represents each point on the string compared to the whole. A B C D E Point A _______ Point B _______ Point C _______ Identify another fraction equivalent to the fraction represented by point A _______ Identify another fraction equivalent to the fraction represented by point A _______ Mathematics – Grade 5 Strand: Geometry A closed garden in the shape of a rectangle has a length of 13 cm and a width of 5.3 cm. Part A: Draw a diagram of the garden and find its area in square centimeters. After drawing your diagram and stating the area, explain your thinking: ____________________ Part B: A smaller rectangular garden has dimensions that are half the measurements of the original. Find the ratio of the area of the original garden to the area of the smaller garden. After finding the ratio, explain what your answer tells us: ____________________ 4 English Language Arts – Grade 4 Strand: Comprehension of fiction materials Which piece of dialogue supports the story’s main theme? A. “Let us stay here to‐ night,” they said, “and see what we can find in the morning.” (paragraph 7) B. “Go back quickly and comfort my friend your mate, and say that I am coming.” (paragraph 16) C. “Sooner or later these men will get our young.” (paragraph 31) D. “Why do you come at this hour of the night?” (paragraph 33) English Language Arts – Grade 8 Strand: Comprehension of nonfiction materials “The Story of My Life” and “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave” share many ideas about the human condition/character. What is a major central idea that is shared by both passages? Explain the importance of the shared central idea for each narrator. Discuss similarities and differences in the role of the shared central idea for each narrator. Use details from both passages to support your response. In your response, be sure to: identify a central idea shared by both passages, “The Story of My Life” and “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave” explain the importance of the central idea to each narrator explain the similarities and differences in the importance of the central idea for each narrator use details from both passages to support your response Write your response in complete sentences. 5 IDENTIFY THE WORDS TO TEACH Find out which words are "your" words. Read the VA SOL for your grade level, highlighting the words you think your students won't know. Then go back to each year prior to yours and highlight those words. Next, create a pre-assessment for your students with these critical words and glue it in their Interactive Notebook. A simple list of words followed by columns marked "Yes" (I understand), "No" (I don't understand) and "Maybe" (I might understand) is a start. Use this information and your professional judgment to decide which words have not yet been mastered and require instruction. Teach the words in the order they are presented in the VA SOL. Begin with the verbs presented at the earliest grade levels. The VA SOL doesn’t use the word analyze until fifth grade, but in subsequent grades it is used 80 more times. If you teach any grade above fifth, analyze is a critical word for your students to know and use with facility. VOCABULARY EXERCISES RECOMMENDED BY MEMORY AND EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH What Educators Can Do to Improve Vocabulary? Teaching specific terms in a specific way is probably the strongest action a teacher can take to ensure that students have the academic background knowledge they need to understand the content they encounter in school. The more students understand the academic terms in content standards, the easier it is for them to understand information they may read or understand about the topic. On the other hand, without a basic knowledge of these terms students have difficulty understanding information they read or hear. A six-step process for teaching vocabulary: 1. The teacher provides a description, explanation, or example of the new term. 2. Ask students to restate the description, explanation, or example in own words. 3. Ask students to construct a picture, symbol, or graphic representing the term. 4. Engage students periodically in activities that help them add to their knowledge of the terms in their notebooks. 5. Periodically ask students to discuss the terms with one another. 6. Involve students periodically in games that allow them to play with the terms. 6 Create a Glossary of Critical Content Terms: 7 REVIEW ACTIVITIES AND GAMES It is important to give students opportunities to reexamine their understanding of the academic terms that have been presented to them. 1. FREE ASSOCIATION Teacher calls out a term and asks students to take turns as a class, in small groups, or in pairs-saying any word they think of that is related to the term. After a few seconds the teacher says, “stop.” The last person to say a word must explain how the word is related to the word provided by the teacher. An alternate to oral free association is to ask students to write their responses. When time is called students exchange papers with a partner and explain all of the words on their lists. 2. WHAT IS THE QUESTION? Science Math English Sports & Arts General 100 Earthquake Fraction Adverb Mona Lisa Peanut Butter 200 Rain Decimal Setting Lance Armstrong chocolate 300 Photosynthesis Parallel Antonym Van Gogh Luke Skywalker 400 Gravity Equation cvc pattern Michael Jordan Walt Disney 500 Decibel Hypotenuse Maya Angelou Impressionist jaguar This game is modeled after the popular game Jeopardy! It requires a simple game matrix similar to the one above. Terms are placed in each cell. The cells can be covered with sticky notes. Place students in teams or pairs. Select a team leader who will raise her hand and provide the answer that the team agrees upon. 8 3. PYRAMID PILE-UP This game is modeled after the television show The $100,000 Pyramid. It helps students focus on the attributes of concepts represented by or associated with terms as they try to determine what the terms in a list have in common. The object of the game is for a clue giver, who sees one category at a time on the game board, to list words that fit that category until teammates correctly identify the category name. As you reveal the first category, tell the clue giver to begin to list terms that pertain to that category. For example, for the category liquids, the clue giver might say, “water, milk, soda, tea, coffee…” and keep listing terms until the guessers name the category“liquids.” 200 points 100 points 50 points 50 points 100 points 50 points 50 points 4. MOTOR MOUTH In this game, teams of students are given a list of terms that have been organized into categories. Typically, the words in the list are related by meaning, such as “parts of a cell,” or “things associated with the Civil War.” To play each round, each team designates a “talker” who is provided with a list of words under a category title. The talker tries to get the team to say each of the words by quickly describing them. The talker is allowed to say anything about the terms, “talking a mile a minute,” but may not use any words in the category title or any rhyming words. The talker keeps talking until the team members identify the first term in the category. The talker then moves quickly to the next term in the category until all terms have been guessed or time has been called. For additional Information read: Building Background Knowledge for Academic Achievement: Research on What Works in Schools by Robert Marzano and Debra Pickering 9 5. CREATING A VOCABULARY CARD Have students write a word on a three-by-five-inch card and then brainstorm and write related words on the same card. For instance, for baseball, students might write “bat,” “ball,” “cap,” “diamond,” and other baseball-related words. The vocabulary card works best with “big” words, such as those found in works with a heavily Latinate vocabulary. Frankenstein, Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail and the Declaration of Independence all qualify. Students can pick a word from their reading to work with or the teacher can select words. The first step is to divide the word into prefix, root, and suffix—not syllables. Explain that not all words have prefixes and suffixes, but that some will have more than one prefix or suffix. This distinction is not an easy concept for students to grasp. Antirevolutionary, for instance, has seven syllables but only one prefix, two suffixes, and one root word. Model this for students. The next step is to find the meaning of each part of the word. This puts students into territory where they have been before—usually not very successfully. They have memorized lists of prefixes and suffixes and their meanings, but, for the most part, this exercise hasn't much advanced their knowledge. But now they are not memorizing; they are digging, performing a kind of literacy detective work. They discover how to identify the prefix in the dictionary: the in with the hyphen after it; the suffix tion with the hyphen before it. Then students are asked to“Find the etymology,” Explain that they're looking for the history of the word. “What language was this word before it became English?” This research can be challenging. When they look for the root word for inconceivable, for instance, they'll discover that while the root word is conceive, the root of conceive is ceive. Be prepared to help. Next, students do a quickdraw of the concept of the word, not the definition. A picture of the definition of pedestrian is a person walking. A picture of the concept could be a foot. See figure 1 for inconceivable.) Figure 1 To help students establish connections among words, ask them to find three words with the same root. They can usually do this by looking on the same dictionary page as their word, it is helpful to direct them to other parts of the dictionary to help them to understand the power of prefixes and suffixes. So a student investigating inconceivable is led to the related words receive, conceive and conceivability. Finally, direct students to the text they're reading to discover how the author used the word. Ask them to identify the part of speech (frequently a function of the suffix) and to write the definition as the author intended it. Armed with an understanding of the 10 history, concept, and context, students begin to understand the power and nuances of English. After they have completed this, give them a five-by-eight-inch card and these instructions: 1. Write the root of the word in capital letters in red in the middle of the card. Draw an arrow and write the meaning of the root and the language of its origin. 2. Write the prefix in black to the left of the root. Draw an arrow and write the meaning of the prefix. 3. Write the suffix in blue to the right of the root. Draw an arrow and write the meaning of the suffix. 4. In the lower left corner, write three words with the same root. 5. Put your quickdraw in the lower right of the card. 6. Write the author's definition and part of speech at the top of the card. 7. When the students finish their cards, put them up on the bulletin board. As students examine the cards their classmates have produced, they are not so much collecting new words as they are developing an understanding of how the English language works 6. ILLUSTRATED VOCABULARY Introduce a quick version of the vocabulary card. Students divide the word into its parts, find the meaning of each part, and then appropriately illustrate the parts. The students do a “quickdraw” on a sheet of white paper. As with the vocabulary card, ask them to draw concepts rather than illustrations. (See figure 2 for an illustration of geologist. The object on the left next to the glasses is a magnifying glass intended to facilitate close study.) Figure 2 11 7. THE WORD BIOGRAPHY One way to help students understand that words have histories is to ask them to delve into the origins of a word created from someone's name. Give students a list of words that originally were someone's name: guillotine, bloomers, derrick, pasteurize, macadam, boycott, mesmerize, watt, maudlin—there are many possibilities. Students are asked to research the person and then, adopting the persona of their character, create five artifacts that illustrate both the person's life and the word his or her name became. They can create business cards, advertisements, or catalogs—their imagination is the limit. Keeping in character, they can write letters to each other. Amelia Bloomer created a catalog of several styles of her garment—striped, polkadotted, even a flip-down lace creation. She also made business cards. Rudolph Diesel had the complete package for a booth at the Tulsa Engine Convention: booth license, price list, catalog, sign, business cards. Joseph-Ignace Guillotin wrote to his parents, explaining the humaneness of his invention and asking them to come see it. Sometimes, students bring together a couple of these people. In one inspired work, the Fourth Earl of Sandwich recognized the marketing potential of Louis Pasteur's invention combined with his: “I would like to propose a plan,” he writes. “Your new drink teamed with my new ‘sandwich' marketed to poker players worldwide. The perfect combination to quench the players' hunger and thirst without ever having to leave the cardtable.” 8. ILLUSTRATED OPPOSITES These assignments create ways to make the abstraction of language concrete. Give students antonyms: ebullient and grounded; energetic and insipid; haughty and humble. Ask them to illustrate the words and their relationships, using the words themselves. Ebullient was written in brightly colored bubble letters, with springs and bouncy circles; grounded on a straight black line, the bottom part of the word in black; the upper part in green. Energetic filled the entire page with brightly colored letters crammed together and a large exclamation point behind it. Its opposite, insipid, was written in gray narrow letters, centered in the page with nothing around it. (See figure 3 for an example of haughty and humble.) Figure 3 12 9. BIOPOEM This activity helps students grasp the way that language evolves and changes. Put students to work with the Internet or Oxford English Dictionary to trace the etymology and changing meanings of a word. Here is the form for the biopoem: First name Four traits that describe the person Relative of Who feels Who needs Who fears Who would like to see Resident of Last name. The student who researched the word electricity traced the word back to its 1646 meaning, “attract by friction.” She learned that the term's “family tree” has two major branches; elek, meaning “friction, heat” and tron, meaning “water” and “diffusion.” The biopoem used these two parts for the first name and last name. Eleck Shock, current, vital,magnetic Relative of anatomy, atom, contemplate, epitome Lover of friction, lightning, heat Who feels hot, shocking, active Who needs chemical action, magnetism, energy Who fears water, rain, diffusion Who would like to see stimulation, technology, mechanics Resident of cities Tron 10. ABC BOOKS As with all types of learning, the more relevant new words are made to students' lives, the more likely they are to take hold. ABC books can be used in many ways to make learning meaningful. One way is a community-building project at the beginning of a school year. For each letter of the alphabet, the Figure 4 students find an appropriately descriptive word for themselves. Students elaborate on the word by writing some sentences and creating an illustration. Students will often use the dictionary and thesaurus to find the exact word to describe themselves, especially as they get toward the end of the alphabet. They share new words with their classmates and asked others' opinions about whether the word accurately describes them. They were expand their vocabulary and having a great time doing it. Students discover powerful words from all parts of the alphabet. One student described her anger as “caustic.” Illustrating her word with a photograph of a burning car in a war zone, she wrote a caption that connects her anger burning within with the hurtful sarcasm it can inspire, thus drawing a link between two definitions of the word. (See figure 4.) 13 11. CONCEPT DEFINITION MAPPING EXAMPLES 14 DIRECTIONS: AFTER STUDYING THE SAMPLE CONCEPT DEFINITION MAP ABOVE, CREATE YOUR OWN EXAMPLE ON THE TEMPLATE PROVIDED ON THE PREVIOUS PAGE. 15 12. LIST-GROUP-LABEL – effective for activating prior knowledge and helping learners make connections. Directions: 1. Write a content-area word on the board or an overhead transparency. 2. Explain to students that their complete understanding of the word’s meaning is important for success in the next area of study. 3. Ask students to generate words and phrases that they associate with this term. As students volunteer responses, others in the class will notice a pattern in the words and volunteer their own words. 4. Aster developing a list of 15 – 30 words or phrases, ask students to consider what the words have in common and to organize them into categories. 5. Once students have completed classifying the words, ask them to explain the rationale behind the groupings. 6. Use this discussion to broaden students’ understanding of these concepts and how to apply this understanding when solving problems. Example: Measurement meter ruler rectangle foot inch width area quart liter mass scales mile paper clips protractor 13. PRE-LESSON PREDICTIONS 1. Before a lesson, the teacher selects some key vocabulary that will be used in the learning experience. The teacher lists these terms in columns, grouping them by parts of speech; that is, all of the nouns are listed in one column, verbs in another, and so on. Students work in teams to discuss the meaning of the words. 2. Next the teacher models for students a few ways the words in different columns can be combined to form simple sentences. The teacher asks students to explain which combinations “make sense”, which do not, and why. 3. Based on the lists, students are asked to predict what the lesson may be about. 4. After the lesson, students revisit their lists and identify how they actually related to the lesson. Example: Try making sentences from the lists of words about Measurement created in the List-Group-Label activity. 16 14. CONCENTRATION Adapted from a strategy developed by the National Education Association, Metric Concentration is an example of how mathematics teachers can help students store what they have learned about metric equivalents. The components of the game include not only pairs that match but also distracting pairs. Consequently, the game goes beyond asking students to rely on memory alone. To win, students must think about metric principles. Variations include matching picture, term, and/or description. 17 15. DIRECT LEARNING/THINKING ACTIVITY (DL/TA) This strategy is similar to K-W-L in both concept and versatility. It encourages active learning through activation of prior knowledge, predicting, and checking for accuracy of predictions. It provides students with a system of organizing their thoughts, encourages students to focus on the topic, and gives them a purpose for learning. Directions: 1. Instruct students to preview the lesson – noting the title, any subheadings, and graphic organizers – and complete the first two sections of the form. This will focus students on the topic. Discussing these sections will expose misconceptions. 2. Ask students to fill out the third section, which requires them to formulate predictions about what they will study and sets the purpose for learning. 3. After the lesson, students should reflect on their predictions, confirming or rejecting earlier predictions about the subject matter. 4. Ask students to complete the last section of the form. This helps to reinforce understanding and to correct misconceptions. 18 16. GROUP SUMMARIZING Class summaries help learners review and remember information. Summarizing information requires students distinguish between key concepts and subordinate ideas. It also requires the ability to condense information. Summarizing is a sophisticated skill; therefore, modeling this skill is critical. Directions: 1. Have students survey the notes on the lesson. 2. Divide the chalkboard/note page into four parts (Description, Patterns, Uses, and Interesting Facts). 3. Ask students to volunteer information for each category. Record the information in sentence form. Class discussion is a key part of the process. Students need to understand which concepts are most important and how they can be stated clearly. 4. Class summaries are then developed from the recorded information. 19 17. WORD SORT VARIATION A variation of Word Sorts is to provide sets of four or five terms. In each set, three of the four terms are related in some way. The student explains the relationship and identifies one term that is unrelated to the others. Example: Each list of terms below has one unrelated term once the relationship among the other terms is identified. Create sample sets of terms for use in school with staff: 20 VOCABULARY STRUCTURES FRAYER MODEL 21 22 23 24 NOTES PAGE 25