Student Code/ID: 1027 Unit code Submitted to Mrs Kinley Om Assignment title The study of causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan Word count CHECKLIST I have: Followed the referencing rules set out in the unit outline. Declaration I acknowledge that: this assignment is my own work this assignment is expressed predominantly in my own words the words and ideas of others, where used, are properly used and acknowledged no part of this assignment has been previously submitted for assessment. I understand that by submitting my work to in both soft and hard copy to Royal Institute of Management (RIM), it will be maintained within the premises of Institute’s Academic Policy. Signature Submitted by; Kinzang Dechen Approved by the Academic Committee on ………………………Royal Institute of Management, Semtokha Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Acknowledgement I would like to sincerely thank ma’am Kinley Om, Department of Finance and Business, for supervising me with full dedication and interest; for her constant assistance and close monitoring till the research work has been completed. I would also like to extend my gratitude to Ugyen Lhendup, the course coordinator, for his time and assistance whenever needed. My heart full gratitude goes to the employees of Respect, Educate, Nurture, and Empower Women and Royal Bhutan Police for providing me with the required data, and time for interview. Besides the employees I am thankful to the 150 randomly selected respondents who took their time for filling up the questionnaires. My sincerest appreciation also extends to Mrs. Karma Tshomo for the supportive environment and the helps extended to me in materials and other means. Finally, I cannot forget to thank my close friends for helping me in doing my research. 1 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Abstract The study on rape empirically examines the main causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan. This research will have significant benefit to organizations which are concerned with issues like rape in understanding the cause and consequences of rape. Also, the study will serve as a guide for the general public to get more insight about rape and the precautions they could take to resist it and, it can also serve as blueprint for future researcher, since, there is no prior study conducted on this topic in Bhutan. This study is of great importance as rape is one of the phenomenon which are occurring worldwide through times. For this research, data were collected from 150 randomly chosen respondents using convenience sampling and, in-depth interview with the employees of RENEW. Data were analyzed and interpreted using descriptive statistics such as simple frequency, percentage, mean, median and mode, and final output were presented through bar graphs, pie-charts and tables in IBM SPSS statistics 20 and Microsoft Excel. The findings indicate that the common causes of rape are alcoholism, substance abuse, sexual desire, reading and watching pornography, indecent dressing, unequal power relations (male domination), revenge and punishment, and jealousy. On the other hand aftermath of rape are stigmatization in the society, abuse alcohol, drug abuse behavior, pregnancy, depression and trauma, suicidal tendency and, thoughts of revenge and nightmares. However being novice in research, the scope of this study is limited to the causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan therefore, further research need to be carried out on preventions and precautions in order to resist rape which could be the main helpful research for the benefit of everyone. 2 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Table of Contents Chapter 1 ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 6 1.1 Background ......................................................................................................................................... 6 1.2 Research Problem ............................................................................................................................... 6 1.3 Significance of the study ..................................................................................................................... 7 1.4 Objective ............................................................................................................................................. 7 1.5 Research Questions ............................................................................................................................ 7 Chapter 2....................................................................................................................................................... 8 Literature Review .......................................................................................................................................... 8 Chapter 3..................................................................................................................................................... 13 Description of Research Designs and Methods .......................................................................................... 13 3.1 Research area and target population ............................................................................................... 13 3.2 Source of data and data collection ................................................................................................... 13 3.3 Sample Study..................................................................................................................................... 13 3.4 Data processing tools and interpretation ......................................................................................... 13 Chapter 4..................................................................................................................................................... 14 Ethical Consideration .................................................................................................................................. 14 Chapter 5..................................................................................................................................................... 15 Limitations of the study .............................................................................................................................. 15 Chapter 6 Secondary Data .......................................................................................................................... 16 6.1 Rape cases reported to RBP 2007- 2013........................................................................................... 16 6.2 Rape cases from 2008-2014 as per RENEW ...................................................................................... 17 Chapter 7..................................................................................................................................................... 18 Analysis of Data and Findings ..................................................................................................................... 18 7.1 Sample characteristics of respondents ............................................................................................. 18 7.2 Awareness of Rape............................................................................................................................ 19 7.3 Rape as a criminal offence ................................................................................................................ 19 3 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.4 Rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan ............................................................................... 20 7.5 The main causes of rape ................................................................................................................... 21 Gender * Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Cross tabulation ........................................ 22 Gender * Indecent dressing Cross tabulation ..................................................................................... 25 Gender * unequal power relations (male domination) Cross tabulation ........................................... 27 7.6 The main consequences of rape ........................................................................................................ 29 7.7 Have you ever been sexually abused?............................................................................................... 35 7.7.1 If yes, at what age? .................................................................................................................... 36 7.8 Does a father rape his own daughter? ............................................................................................... 37 7.9 Should a rapist be punished?............................................................................................................. 38 7.10 Can Rape be prevented? ................................................................................................................. 40 Chapter 8..................................................................................................................................................... 41 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................... 41 Chapter 9..................................................................................................................................................... 43 Recommendations ...................................................................................................................................... 43 Reference .................................................................................................................................................... 44 Appendices.................................................................................................................................................. 47 Questionnaire .......................................................................................................................................... 47 4 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan List of Tables Table 1 Table 2 Table 3 Table 4 Table 5 Table 6 Table 7 Table 8 Table 9 Rape cases reported to RBP 2007- 2013 Sample characteristics of respondents Heard about sexual abuse or rape Rape is a criminal offence Gender * Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Cross tabulation Gender * Indecent dressing Cross tabulation Gender * unequal power relations (male domination) Cross tabulation If yes, at what age? Statistics List of Figures Figure 1 Total rape cases reported 2007-2013 (RBP) Figure 2 Rape cases from 2008-2014 as per RENEW Figure 3 Rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan Figure 4 Alcoholism Figure 5 Substance abuse Figure 6 Sexual desire Figure 7 Reading and watching pornography Figure 8 Indecent Dressing Figure 9 Unequal Power Relations Figure 10 Revenge and Punishment Figure 11 Jealousy Figure 12 Stigmatization in the Society Figure 13 Abuse Alcohol Figure 14 Drug Abuse Behavior Figure 15 Pregnancy Figure 16 Depression and Trauma Figure 17 Suicidal tendency Figure 18 Thoughts of Revenge and Nightmares Figure 19 Have you ever been sexually abused? Figure 20 Does a father rape his own daughter? Figure 21 Should a rapist be punished? Figure 22 Can rape be prevented? 5 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 1 Introduction 1.1 Background Rape has become a growing concern despite various precautions and policies made to curb it. As per Sanday (1981) there are two types of culture- “rape-free” and “rape-prone”. “Rape-free societies are those in which rape is either non-existent or infrequent; rape-prone societies are those in which the incidence of rape is high, rape is used as a ceremonial act, and/or rape is used by men as a means to punish or dominate women” (as cited in WHO, 2007). Bhutan too is in the verge of falling under the “rape-prone” culture despite the minimum population of the country. Rape as reported to RBP alone is 47 in 2007 to 71 in 2010 to 76 in 2012 and, 64 in 2013 (RBP, 2013). Rape cases reported to RENEW got increased from 3 in 2008 to 6 in 2012 to 7 in 2013. These reported cases might seem negligible but many cases are forgone unreported. According to Kilpatrick (2000), rape is the most underreported crime in America, which is further supported in Tjaden & Thoennes’ (2006) findings that only one in five women who were raped as adults reported their rape to the police. Though numerous researches have been conducted on rape worldwide, not a single research has been done in Bhutan. So this study intend to answer the queries like what are the causes and consequences behind constant growth of rape in Bhutan and, what are the precautions and safety measures one should inculcate to resist rape through questionnaires collected from 150 randomly selected respondents and in-depth interview conducted with RENEW officials. The findings will confirm whether or not people are conscious about rape and their attitude towards it. 1.2 Research Problem Rape, despite strict laws amended against it in “the Penal Code of Bhutan” classified under chapter 14 - “Sexual Offences” of section 177-214, the figure is still high. One person is raped every seven days (RBP, 2013). On average the rape cases reported to Royal Bhutan Police has increased from 2007 to 2013 i.e. from 47 to 67 respectively (RBP, 2013). As per the record, 6 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan reported rape cases to RENEW have been gradually increasing on an average from 3 in 2008 to 7 in 2013. Age and blood relation come as no bar for one to commit rape, for instance a father rapes his daughters (Dema, 2014), an uncle rapes his niece (Namgyel, 2014), and an old man sexually harasses his old neighbor (Wangdi, 2014). Amongst the type of sexual offence, rape of the minor (child above 12 years of age) has been the highest in list counting up to 30 in 2013, and criminal attempt to rape continuous to be consistent with 7 in 2007 to 7 in 2013 (RBP, 2013). The issue of rape has become a biggest concern for every Bhutanese, which should not be neglected rather should be brought in the front and studied thoroughly in order to eradicate it if not reduce it. Therefore this research tries to study what are the causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan. 1.3 Significance of the study This research will enable to understand the causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan. The study aims to make a substantial contribution to the organizations which deal with rape issues. This study can further assist people from preventing themselves from raping and being raped by being informed about the causes and consequences of rape. For future researcher, the proposed study would benefit and serve as a guide. 1.4 Objective To find the causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan 1.5 Research Questions 7 What are the causes and consequences of rape? How are people reacting to rape; are there any precautions taken to resist rape? Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 2 Literature Review Rape is one of the inevitable social stigmas occurring worldwide through times. “The origins of the word rape are found in the ancient Greek – to steal” (Brown, 2003). Rape as Crake (n.d.) term it in his case study is as “sexual assault” as it is “often associated solely with sexual penetration and sexual penetration is only one form of sexual assault”. Rape is “essentially about people who force themselves sexually upon others, often in very violent ways” Crake (n.d.). In other term, McCabe and Wauchope (2005) define the term rape as the penetration of the anus or vagina by a penis, finger or object or the penetration of the mouth by a penis. If a person is forced to penetrate someone…this is also regarded as rape. Rape and sexual violent acts according to WHO (as cited in Mabasa, 2012) include coerced sex in marriage and dating relationships, rape by strangers, systematic rape during armed conflict, sexual harassment (including demands for sexual favors in return for jobs or school grades), sexual abuse of children, forced prostitution and sexual trafficking, child marriage, and violent acts against the sexual integrity of women, including female genital mutilation and obligatory inspections for virginity. Although rape is a gender-neutral crime, the National Violence against Women Survey (NVAWS) findings indicates that most rape victims are women and most rapists are men. Results from the NVAWS revealed that 17.7 million women and 2.8 million men in the United States were forcibly raped at some time in their lives, with 302,091 women and 92,748 men forcibly raped in the year preceding the survey. (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2006). “Sexual and gender-based violence occurs in all classes, cultures, religions, races, gender and ages” (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, 2003). The Domestic Violence Victims Support Unit (DOVVSU) of the Ghana Police Service reports that on average, 21% of Ghanaian women are forced by their husbands to have sex, 8% of all women have been raped, and 6% of all girls have been raped (of which 78% were defiled by a close relative, acquaintance, or authority figure) (as cited in Aryee, 2013). 8 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan The main causes of rape varies amongst researches. Rape usually is linked with force and aggression as “most modern conceptualizations of rape recognize that it involves both aggressive and sexual behavior” (McCabe & Wauchope, 2005).As per the research by Esere, Idowu, Durosaro and Omotosho (2009) in Lagos, Nigeria, the perceived causes of Intimate Partner Rape/Violence (IPRV) as reported by the women were unequal power relations (45.45%), alcohol and drug dependence (22.73%), jealousy (18.18%). Other causes mentioned by the women included lack of tolerance and patience (9.09%) and stress and disturbed emotion (4.55%). In Declue (2005) review of the book, “The causes of rape: Understanding individual differences in male propensity for sexual aggression”, he aligns with the above findings stating that “rape is more common when the women to be raped are devalued and the perceived costs are very low”, and also when “reproductive consequences not withstanding”. According to Hirschowitz, Worku, and Orkin’ (2000) of the 22,121 reported cases that went to court (in South Africa), only a fifth (19.8%) resulted in the conviction of the accused. The ultimate finding is that the major factors associated with rape have “their roots in the cultural framework of the society which ascribes lower status to girls and women compared to boys and men and uphold male dominance over women” (Esere et al., 2009). The high incidence of rape according to one of the essays “Defining a rape culture” of University of California (2014), also claim is a result of the power imbalance between men and women (where) women are expected to assume a subordinate relationship to men. According to the social science explanation of rape “the motivation to rape has little, if anything, to do with sexual desire… it holds that rape is an attempt by men to dominate and control women… also contends that rape only occurs when males are taught by their culture, directly or indirectly, to rape” (Thornhill & Palmer, 2001). This explanation of rape by social science is opposed by Thornhill & Palmer (2001) by stating: sexual stimulation is a proximate cause of raping and is the common denominator across human rapes of all kinds a woman’s appearance and behavior might have some influence on the risk factors of getting raped 9 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan “physical attractiveness” of the women mostly at the ages of “peak attractiveness” becomes the risk factor as most of the frequent victims of rape are from “late teens and early twenties” Another factor is the differences in “male and female sexuality” where “women are evolved to choose mates carefully and men to be less selective and pursue many partners, including without commitment”. Other contributing factor researchers have found out is alcohol and substance abuse. McDonald (1994) suggests that “connections between violence and drunkenness are socially learnt, and that substance use may act as a cultural excuse for antisocial behavior”. In the influence of alcohol men are more likely to rape and also become victimized. As per Crowell & Burges (1996), “for the victims, alcohol reduces the ability to read social cues and to protect oneself…. the consumption of alcohol may place women in locations where rapes may be more likely to occur, such as nightclubs”. As per some of the respondents of the research conducted by Mabasa (2012) in South Africa, one intention behind rape could be an attempt to “spread HIV infection”. At an individual level factors such as sex and power motives, attitude and gender schemas, social learning, psychopathology and personality traits… may contribute to an act of rape. At a societal level, factors such as sexual scripts and cultural beliefs may play a role in causing rape as per Vicary, Klingaman & Harkness (1995). Rape not just changes the life of the victim and culprit but also the society they live in. As per the analysis by the National Woman’s Study in US found that rape may lead to alcohol and drug abuse in women who previously did not use them (WHO, 2007). “Burnam and colleagues (1988) found that after a traumatic event, 16% of subjects started to abuse alcohol and 19% developed drug abuse behaviors, compared to 8% and 2% of matched controls” (WHO, 2007). Rape as per Thornhill and Palmer (2001) “generates tremendous misery for all of its victims and their mates and families throughout the world”. 10 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Rape (Aryee, 2013) affects the health and wellbeing of women, leading to increased levels of depression, distress, and trauma. Kilpatrick (2004) finds that rape compromises the ability of women to cope with daily life, and Calhoun finds that women may experience anger, thoughts of revenge, and nightmares. Hagen (2010) states that rape victims may also show a “lack of interest in their environment, complete loss of self-esteem, deep helplessness, and despair”. They can also develop chronic difficulties including… low self-esteem, fear, depression, shame and other psychological disorders (McCabe & Wauchope, 2005). As per United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) report, women raped during war are often sentenced to a life with long lasting health problems and many die from injuries, unsafe self-induced abortions, maternal mortality, and suicide (Hagen, 2010). It is also found that the victim may feel “extremely tense, humiliated, and guilty about the experience, may blame themselves for not fighting the perpetrator hard enough, and may develop revengeful thoughts associated with the rape” (Aryee, 2013). Self-loathing and rejection of one’s body often results in self-injurious behavior and suicidal tendencies. Kilpatrick (2004) reported that survivors may have different immediate reactions after rape: some exhibit shock and distress through words and tears, while others have more internalized suffering. Besides interpersonal relationships with intimate partners, friendships and family relationships, can all be affected following sexual assault (Boyd, 2011). In a study conducted by Bloom (2003) a community sample of 1,490 adolescents- aged 12 to 19, were analyzed to investigate the relationship between a history of sexual abuse and adolescent functioning. Both sexually abused girls and boys reported significantly more emotional problems, behavioral problems, suicidal thoughts and attempts than their non-abused counterparts. The results also indicated that the experience of sexual abuse carried far more consequences for boys than for girls regarding the use of alcohol, aggressive/criminal behavior, use of drugs, and the amount of truancy, as well as regarding suicidal thoughts and behavior. Whereas 2.6 percent of the non-abused boys reported a former suicide attempt, this percentage was 13 times higher for the sexually abused boys. 11 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Another consequence of rape could be the “lose time from work” as the survey conducted by NVAWS (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2006) found that 19.4 percent of the female victims and 9.7 percent of the male victims raped as adults said their victimization caused them to lose time from work - to obtain medical treatment, attend court hearings, meet with a psychologist or other mental health professional, and avoid contact with their assailant. Rape survivors experience innumerable negative impacts be it physically or mentally. The impacts of sexual assault go “beyond the individual, to have a collective impact on the social wellbeing of our communities” (Boyd, 2011). Rape as per McDonald, M. (1994) can best be prevented if the “environmental factors” leading to rape is addressed… these environmental factors include certain learning experiences during boys’ upbringing such as the conditions of poverty, limited enduring relationships and father absence. They suggest that the number of boys raised under conditions of poverty in industrial societies could be greatly reduced by taxation policies that lower wealth inequalities, coupled with more taxation revenues being directed at socially disfranchised families. The father-absence rearing environments would decline as McDonald, M. (1994) suggest that if fathers, following divorce, were given tax credits when they resided near their sons and provided sons with emotional and financial support. The other aid for the survivor could be the reactions of family, friends and partners which can help or hinder the recovery of the victim/survivor. Negative reactions can lead to avoidant coping styles associated with less successful recovery, while supportive reactions can assist with recovery and healing as founded by Littleton & Breitkopf (2006). One priority in order to reduce sexual violence could be “equal access to and control of material resources and assistance” and “women’s equal participation in decision-making processes should be reflected in all programs” (UNHCR, 2003). As per the president Barack Obama (2012) “it is up to all of us to ensure victims of sexual violence are not left to face these trials alone. Too often, survivors suffer in silence, fearing retribution, lack of support, or that the criminal justice system will fail to bring the perpetrator to justice” (as cited in The White House Council on Women and Girls, 2014). 12 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 3 Description of Research Designs and Methods 3.1 Research area and target population The target population for this research are the officials of RENEW and the general public in Thimphu area. The total strength in RENEW is 19 employees; the rape victims in Thimphu area is unknown and due to innumerable constraints general public is chosen as target population instead of the victims. Therefore, this research is conducted primarily in Thimphu considering limitation of researcher time and resources. 3.2 Source of data and data collection The study is exploratory in nature and incorporates the use of both Qualitative and Quantitative method. It is based on both primary and secondary data. The primary data includes a set of structured questionnaires (both open and close-ended questions), and relatively unstructured and open ended interview. Basically the main source of primary data was collected from the RBP; RENEW employees, and the general public. For the secondary data, relevant literature review from relevant research journals, publications, books and other relevant information were referred to. 3.3 Sample Study For this study the population comprises the officials of RENEW and the general public of Thimphu. Since the number of rape victims residing in Thimphu is unknown and due to confidentiality and seriousness of issue, the general public is studied through questionnaire instead of the victims. In the case of RENEW, in-depth interview is conducted with the employees. 3.4 Data processing tools and interpretation The data generated from the questionnaires and the interviews are analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) version 20 and Microsoft Excel. Statistical tool such as simple frequencies like mean, mode, percentages, and cross tabulation are used to interpret the data. The final output and explanations are made clear by using bar graphs, pie charts and tables. 13 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 4 Ethical Consideration The respondents were requested to participate as per their will and no force was involved. The data collected are purely for academic purpose and are treated with utmost confidentiality. The researcher reported only on the research findings and no personal conclusions were made. The data sources were acknowledged with in-text citation and end text referencing. Also, the help provided by various groups and individuals for the completion of this research has been properly acknowledged. 14 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 5 Limitations of the study The study sample include only the residents of Thimphu city due to the limitation of time, so the findings collected could only be the views of the people residing in the urban areas and may not reflect the views of the rural areas. The negligible research on the reasons of rape in Bhutan’s context becomes a challenge given the extensive study demanded by the research.. Another challenge to write authentic research could be bared due to the inappropriate respondents i.e. it was impossible despite constant trying to get in contact with the victims of rape. It is outside the scope of this research to study other than the causes and consequences of rape so this research brings future prospects on varies preventions and risk reductions scheme of rape. 15 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 6 Secondary Data 6.1 Rape cases reported to RBP 2007- 2013 Table 1 Rape cases reported to RBP 2007- 2013 Sexual Offence 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Rape 22 11 8 10 12 10 10 Criminal attempt to rape 7 5 18 8 13 12 7 rape of a married person 1 3 4 2 4 7 2 Statutory Rape 4 5 5 4 7 8 5 Rape of a child above 12 years of age 3 3 14 18 17 21 30 Rape of a pregnant woman 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 Gang Rape 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 Gang rape of a married person 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Gang rape of a child below 12 years of age 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Gang rape of a child above 12 years of age 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 Gang rape of a pregnant woman 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Custodial Rape 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 Marital Rape 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Child Molestation 4 4 6 3 1 5 0 Sexual Harassment 2 4 8 18 8 10 3 Incest 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 Indecent exposure 0 1 2 1 1 0 1 Bestiality(sexual contact with an animal) 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Un-natural sex (sexual conduct against 0 2 1 3 0 1 0 47 40 68 71 65 76 64 the order of nature) Total Statistical Yearbook 2009 & Statistical Yearbook 2013, Royal Bhutan Police 16 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Total rape cases reported 2007-2013 (RBP) Figure 1 Total rape cases reported 2007-2013 (RBP) 80 70 68 76 71 65 60 50 64 total rape cases reported (RBP) 47 40 40 30 20 10 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 6.2 Rape cases from 2008-2014 as per RENEW Figure 2 Rape cases from 2008-2014 as per RENEW 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Rape cases 17 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 3 5 6 6 5 7 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 7 Analysis of Data and Findings Since the research is aimed at finding out the main causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan, a set of questionnaire is distributed to sample size of 150 general public of Thimphu, and an indepth interview is conducted with the officials of RENEW. The data collected from these two groups are analyzed into two parts described below. 7.1 Sample characteristics of respondents Table 2 Sample characteristics of respondents Sample Characteristics (in percentage) Gender 54.7% respondents are male 45.3% respondents are female Age 58% respondents are below 25 42% respondents are above 25 2.7% respondents are illiterate 1.3% respondents have primary education Qualification 22.7% respondents have high school education 18% respondents have diploma 48.7% respondents have degree 6.7% respondents have masters and above education Table 2 above shows that from the 150 respondents 54.7% are male and 45.3% are female where 58% respondents are below 25 years and 42% respondents are above 25 years. Of the respondents 2.7% respondents are illiterate, 1.3% respondents have primary education, 22.7% respondents have high school education, 18% respondents have diploma, 48.7% respondents have degree and, 6.7% respondents have masters and above qualifications. 18 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.2 Awareness of Rape Table 3 Heard about sexual abuse or rape Frequency Percent Valid Percent Valid Yes 150 100.0 100.0 The 150 respondents selected randomly were asked whether they have heard of sexual abuse or rape. Table 3 shows that 100% of the respondents have heard of sexual abuse or rape, which indicates that the issues such as sexual abuse and rape are known to everyone. 7.3 Rape as a criminal offence Table 4 Rape is a criminal offence Frequency Yes No Don't know Total Percent Valid Percent 147 98.0 98.0 1 .7 .7 2 1.3 1.3 150 100.0 100.0 Table 4 shows that of the respondents, 98% is aware that rape is a criminal offence whereas 0.7% disagree that rape is a criminal offence, and the rest 1.3% do not know whether rape is a criminal offence or not. In other words, out of 150 randomly selected respondents 147 is aware that rape is a criminal offence with only 1 who is with the perception that rape is not a criminal offence; 2 respondents are unaware whether rape is a criminal offence or not. This data shows that the ratio of people who are informed of rape as criminal offence and the one who are unaware is very vast; more people are informed that rape is a criminal offence. 19 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.4 Rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan Figure 3 Rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan Figure 3 shows that 119 respondents agree that rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan, whereas 17 respondents disagree to the statement and 14 respondents are in dilemma whether rape is becoming a growing concern or not. If calculated in percentage 79.3% agree, 11.3% disagree, and 9.3% do not know about the question “Is rape becoming a growing concern in Bhutan?” 20 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.5 The main causes of rape The respondents are presented with eight factors that causes rape, and were asked to rate it as per their thinking which are alcoholism, substance abuse, sexual desire, reading and watching pornography, indecent dressing, unequal power relations (male domination), revenge and punishment, and jealousy. These causes are derived from various literature reviewed as mentioned in the literature review above. The responds of the respondents are presented in the following tables and figures in detail. 7.5.1 Alcoholism Figure 4 Alcoholism Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) 69.3 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Percent 28.7 .7 Strongly agree agree Neutral 1.3 disagree Alcohol can be concluded to be strongly influencing factor of rape as per the respondents. 69.3% of respondents strongly agree that alcohol is the main factor of rape whereas there is no one who strongly disagree that alcohol can influence both victim and culprit in leading to rape. 28.7 % of the respondents agree whereas only 1.3% of the respondents disagree to alcohol being the cause of rape. In between there are 0.7% of the respondents who neither agree nor disagree. As shown in table the frequency is that 104 respondents strongly agree, 43 respondents agree, 1 is neutral and 2disagree that alcohol can influence both victim and culprit thereby resulting in rape. Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Cross tabulation 21 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Gender * Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Cross tabulation Table 5 Gender * Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Cross tabulation Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Strongly agree agree Neutral Total Disagree Male 53 26 1 2 82 Female 51 17 0 0 68 104 43 1 2 150 Gender Total The above cross tabulation is done in order to find relation in respond to alcohol as the cause of rape with the gender. Out of 150 respondents 82 respondents are male and 68 respondents are female. Out of 62 female respondents none disagree that alcohol can influence both victim and culprit with 51 female respondents strongly agreeing i.e. 75% of female respondents; 17 female respondents rated agree. Out of 82 male respondents 53 strongly agree that alcoholism is one factor of rape with 26 male respondents agreeing to it. 1 male respondent and other 2 disagree that alcohol can lead to rape whereas no female respondents rated in disagree nor in neutral. 7.5.2 Substance abuse Figure 5 Substance abuse 4% 12% 1% Substance abuse 41% Strongly agree agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree 42% 22 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan The second factor of rape asked for rating to the respondents is substance abuse. Substance abuse goes side by side alcohol as the rating for substance abuse is strongly agreed with 41% of the respondents and 42% of the respondents agreed that substance abuse can lead to rape i.e., 62 and 63 respondents respectively. The ones who disagree with it is only 4% and 1% of the respondents strongly disagree with it. 12% of the respondents rated neutral. There are only 6 respondents who disagree and 1 who strongly disagrees, and 18 respondents stand in neutral. 7.5.3 Sexual desire Figure 6 Sexual desire Sexual desire 1.3% Strongly agree .7% Agree 2.7% Neutral 20.0% Disagree 75.3% Strongly disagree 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 Sexual desire is another leading factor of rape. As per the respondents, 75.3% of them rated strongly agree for sexual desire as the main cause of rape with 20% agreeing with it. 2.7% rated neutral, 0.7% disagree and 1.3% strongly disagree that sexual desire is the cause of rape. Of the 150 respondents 113 rated strongly agree, 30 rated agree, 1 disagree, 2 strongly disagree, and 4 neutral to the question that sexual desire is the main factor of rape. 23 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.5.4 Reading and watching pornography Figure 7 Reading and watching pornography Reading and watching pornography 36.7 31.3 20.0 12.0 Strongly agree agree Neutral disagree Reading and watching pornography is the other factor asked to the respondents to rate it whether it can be one contributing factor of rape. The respond in the five-level Likert items were 20% strongly agreeing, 36.7% agreeing, 32.3% rating neutral and 12% disagreeing that reading and watching pornography can lead to rape. There is no single respondent who strongly disagrees with reading and watching pornography causing rape. As shown in the table10 out of 150 respondents, 30 strongly agree, 55 agree, 47 are neutral, and 18 disagree. 7.5.5 Indecent dressing Figure 8 Indecent Dressing Indecent dressing 34.7 27.3 22.7 10.7 4.7 Strongly agree 24 agree Neutral disagree Strongly disagree Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan The respondents were asked whether indecent dressing can lead to rape or not, and of the 150 respondents 41 respondents strongly agree with 7 respondent strongly disagreeing. 52 respondents agree, 16 respondents disagree with 34 respondents rating neutral. The highest is the one agreeing with 34.7% and lowest with 4.7% strongly disagreeing. 27.3% of respondents strongly agree, 22.7% neutral, and 10.7% disagree. Gender * Indecent dressing Cross tabulation Table 6 Gender * Indecent dressing Cross tabulation Indecent dressing Strongly agree Neutral Total disagree agree Strongly disagree Male 23 32 20 5 2 82 Female 18 20 14 11 5 68 41 52 34 16 7 150 Gender Total In the cross tabulation between gender and indecent dressing as the cause of rape there are more male respondents who rated that indecent dressing by women can influence men to rape her. Out of 82 male respondents 23 respondents strongly agree with 32 respondents agreeing that indecent dressing causes rape. On the other hand, there are more rating by female respondents in disagree and strongly disagree Likert scale. 5 out of 68 female respondents strongly disagree to indecent dressing causing rape and 11 female respondents disagree to it. There are only 2 male respondents who strongly disagree to indecent dressing as a factor of rape. In general there are more male respondents voting for indecent dressing by women influencing male to rape whereas female respondents vote against it supporting that women wearing any desired clothes cannot be the cause of rape; in total 67% male respondents strongly agree and agree, 55.8% female respondents strongly agree and agree, 8.5% male respondents strongly disagree and disagree and, 23.5% female respondents strongly disagree and disagree. 25 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.5.6 Unequal power relations (male domination) Figure 9 Unequal Power Relations unequal power relations (male domination) Strongly agree agree Neutral 5% disagree Strongly disagree 11% 20% 28% 36% Figure 9 shows the data of unequal power relations between men and women which can cause rape. Out of 150 respondents 16 responds that male domination can strongly influence men to rape women; 42 respondents rated agree; 54 respondents rated neutral; 31 respondents disagree; 7 respondents strongly disagree that male domination and women submission can cause rape. The respondents who strongly disagree that male domination can lead to rape is very few with only 5% of the respondents. The respondents rating the highest is in neutral with 36%, and next 28% of the respondents in agreeing that difference in power relation is one of the factors of rape. 21% of the respondents disagree to male domination leading to rape whereas 10% of the respondents strongly agree to it. 26 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Gender * unequal power relations (male domination) Cross tabulation Table 7 Gender * unequal power relations (male domination) Cross tabulation unequal power relations (male domination) Strongly agree Neutral disagree agree Total Strongly disagree Male 2 20 30 24 6 82 14 22 24 7 1 68 16 42 54 31 7 150 Gender Female Total As per cross tabulation of gender and unequal power relations between men and women, there are more number of female respondents supporting that male domination can cause rape whereas more male respondents against male domination and female submission as the cause of rape. Out of 82 male respondents only 2 respondents strongly agree against 14 female respondents out of 68 respondents. 24 male respondents disagree that rape is caused by male domination whereas only 7 female respondents disagree with it. Only 1 female respondent strongly disagree against 6 male respondents strongly disagreeing. 7.5.7 Revenge and punishment Figure 10 Revenge and Punishment 40.0 35.3 26.7 24.7 percent 20.0 6.7 6.7 0.0 Strongly agree 27 agree Neutral disgree Strongly disagree Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan The responds of the Likert scale items on the factor- revenge and punishment is very similar. The respondents who strongly agree and strongly disagree is 6.7% with 10 respondents each. The respondents agreeing and disagreeing is 26.7% and 24.7% with 40 and 37 respondents respectively. The highest rating is in neutral with 35.3% with 53 respondents. 7.5.8 Jealousy Figure 11 Jealousy Jealousy Percent 11.3 Strongly disagree 24.7 Disagree 34.7 Neutral 22.7 agree 6.7 Strongly agree 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 Out of 150 randomly selected respondents, the highest rating is in neutral with 52 in number, and least with 10 respondents strongly agreeing that jealousy can cause rape. 34 respondents agree that rape can be because of jealousy whereas more number of respondents i.e. 37 of them disagree with it. 17 respondents strongly disagree that rape is caused due to rape. If calculated in percentage- 11.3% of respondents strongly disagree, 24.7% of respondents disagree, 34.7% of respondents are neutral, 22.7% of the respondents agree, and 6.7% of the respondents strongly agree. 28 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.6 The main consequences of rape The respondents are asked to rate the consequences of rape according to the Likert scale items i.e. strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree, and strongly disagree. The consequences presented to respondents are stigmatization in the society, abuse alcohol, drug abuse behavior, pregnancy, depression and trauma, suicidal tendency and, thoughts of revenge and nightmares. These consequences are derived from the reviewed literature. The data of these consequences are shown in detail in the following tables and graphs. 7.6.1 Stigmatization in the society Stigmatization in the society is the ultimate consequence of rape as per the respondents with 83 respondents rating strongly agreeing and 43 respondents agreeing to it. Of 150 respondents only 3 disagree and another 3strongly disagree thereby remaining 18 rated neutral. Figure 12 Stigmatization in the Society Stigmatization in the society Strongly agree agree Neutral disgree Strongly disagree 2% 2% 12% 55% 29% As shown in the above figure 13 55% of respondents strongly agree, 29% of respondents agree, 12% of respondents rated neutral, 2% each disagree and strongly disagree that rape can lead to stigmatization in the society. 29 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.6.2 Abuse alcohol Alcoholism is the other consequence of rape as presented to respondents. Of the respondents, 46 strongly agree that victims have high chance of going into alcohol with 73 respondents agreeing to it. There are 25 respondents who rated neutral, 6 respondents disagree and no one strongly disagreeing to alcohol as the consequence of rape. Figure 13 Abuse Alcohol Abuse alcohol Abuse alcohol Percent 48.7 30.7 16.7 4.0 Strongly agree agree Neutral disagree If presented in percentage, highest is respondents rating agree with 48.7%, second 30.7% of respondents strongly agreeing, third 16.7% rating neutral, and last 4% of respondents disagreeing that alcoholism could be one of the consequences of rape. 30 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.6.3 Drug abuse behavior Out of 150 respondents, the maximum numbers of respondents agree that victims can develop drug abuse behaviors with 78 respondents and 34 respondents rated strongly agree.2 respondents strongly disagree that drug abuse can be aftermath of rape with 6 more respondents disagreeing. 30 respondents rated for neutral. Figure 14 Drug Abuse Behaviors Drug abuse behavior Percent agree, 52.0 60.0 percent 50.0 40.0 Neutral, 20.0 30.0 20.0 Strongly agree, 22.7 10.0 disagree, 4.0 Strongly disagree, 1.3 0.0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 drug abuse The victims can show drug abuse behavior as per the respondents with 52% agreeing with it and 22.7% of respondents strongly agreeing. 4% of respondents disagree and 1.3% strongly disagree and 20% of respondents rated neutral. 31 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.6.4 Pregnancy Figure 15 Pregnancy 50.0 percent 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 Strongly agree Pregnancy Percent agree Strongly agree 48.0 Neutral disagree Strongly disagree agree Neutral disagree 33.3 13.3 3.3 Strongly disagree 2.0 The fourth consequence of rape presented to the respondents is pregnancy. 48% respondents strongly agree that rape can lead to pregnancy, and 33.3% respondents too agree with it. 3.3% of respondents disagree that rape can cause pregnancy with 2% of respondents strongly disagreeing to it. 13.3% of respondents rated neutral. 7.6.5 Depression and trauma 95 respondents out of 150 respondents strongly agree that aftermath of rape is depression and trauma with another 36 respondents agreeing to it. 11 respondents rated neutral. Only 3 respondents disagree and another 5 respondents strongly disagree that depression and trauma are not really the consequences of rape. Figure 15 below shows the percentage illustration of the respondents of depression and trauma as aftermath of rape to victims. 32 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Figure 16 Depression and Trauma Depression and trauma 63.3 24.0 7.3 Strongly agree agree Neutral 2.0 3.3 disagree Strongly disagree Depression and trauma Percent 63.3% of respondents strongly agree, 24% of respondents agree, 7.3% of respondents rated neutral, 2% of respondents disagree, and 3.3% of respondents strongly disagree that one consequence of rape could be depression and trauma. 7.6.6 Suicidal tendency Figure 17 Suicidal tendency Suicidal tendency Percent disagree 3% Neutral 11% Strongly disagree 4% Strongly agree 56% agree 26% 33 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan The respondents are asked whether suicide could be one consequence of rape. 56% of respondents strongly agree that rape can build suicidal tendency in victims with 26% of respondents agreeing to it. 11% of respondents rated neutral with 3% of respondents disagreeing and 4% of respondents strongly disagreeing that rape lead to inculcating suicidal tendency. 7.6.7 Thought of revenge and nightmares Table 18 Thoughts of Revenge and Nightmares As shown in the above table 22 and figure 19 thoughts of revenge and nightmares were rated by the respondents as the consequences of rape and the result is 54 respondents strongly agreeing, 44 respondents agreeing, 31 respondents neutral, 11 respondents disagreeing, 10 respondents strongly disagreeing. In percentage form: strongly agree- 36%, agree- 29.3%, neutral- 20.7%, disagree-7.3%, and strongly disagree-6.7% of respondents. 34 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.7 Have you ever been sexually abused? Figure 19 Have you ever been sexually abused? 82.7 No 17.3 Yes 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 100.0 Have you ever been sexually abused? Percent The respondents are asked whether they have been sexually abused in their life time whether verbally or physically. Table 5 shows that the ones who have been sexually abused in their life is very few with only 17.3% compared to the ones who have never been sexually abused with 82.7% i.e., 26 and 124 respondents respectively. Figure 3 below shows the graphical representation of the respondents whether they have been sexually abused be it verbally or physically in their life. 35 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.7.1 If yes, at what age? Table 8 If yes, at what age? Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent Valid Missing Total 15.00 2 1.3 9.5 9.5 16.00 1 .7 4.8 14.3 17.00 1 .7 4.8 19.0 18.00 5 3.3 23.8 42.9 19.00 2 1.3 9.5 52.4 20.00 4 2.7 19.0 71.4 21.00 5 3.3 23.8 95.2 24.00 1 .7 4.8 100.0 Total 21 14.0 100.0 129 86.0 150 100.0 System If the respondents have ever been sexually abused (verbally or physically) they were asked to mention the detail like at what age was they sexually abused. Out of 150 respondents only 26 respondents rated yes as shown in table 23, and out of which only 21 of the respondents mentioned the age at when they were sexually abused. The age ranges from 15 to 24. The mean, median and mode of the ages are shown in the table below. 36 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Table 9 Statistics If yes, at what age? Valid 21 N Missing 129 Mean 19.0476 Median 19.0000 18.00a Mode a. Multiple modes exist. The smallest value is shown Out of 26 respondents who are sexually abused only 21 is valid and 5 are missing because they do not remember the age at which they were abused and out of 150 respondents124 respondents have never been sexually abused in their life . The mean of the age the respondents are sexually abused be it verbally or physically is 19. The median is also 19 and the mode is 18. 7.8 Does a father rape his own daughter? Figure 20. Does a father rape his own daughter? The respondents Does a father rape his own daughter? were asked about relationship between a father 46.0 and a daughter i.e., 54.0 Yes whether a father No can rape his own daughter or not, and the above Figure 21 shows that 54% responds 37 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan that a father can rape his own child, and 46% responds that a father cannot rape his own child. Of the 150 respondents 54% agree and 46% disagree with the question- can a father rape his daughter? 7.9 Should a rapist be punished? Figure 21 Should a rapist be punished? When the respondents are asked about whether a rapist should be punished or not, 95% of them agree that they should be punished whereas 4% of the respondents think that the rapists should 38 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan not be punished; 114 respondents want the rapists to be punished and 6 of the respondents disagree. 7.9.1 How should rapists be punished? Of the 96% of respondents agreeing that rapists should be punished they were asked details of how should rapists be punished according to them. The prominent suggestions received are: The deadliest brutal punishment such as death penalty Life imprisonment Should be exposed unclothed in the public Should be made known to public through media Electrocution Capital punishment Punishment according to the penal code of Bhutan. Severe penalty as that of chorten vandalism and murder. Genital part should be destroyed 39 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 7.10 Can Rape be prevented? Figure 22 Can rape be prevented? 89.3 90.0 80.0 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 10.7 20.0 10.0 0.0 Yes No Of the 150 respondents, 134 agree that rape can be prevented and 16 respond that rape cannot be prevented i.e. 89.3% and 10.7% respectively. 40 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 8 Conclusion The research “causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan”, gives an insight about what are the possible reasons behind rape, and what could be the consequences aftermath of rape. Most of the people (as per the data analyzed) have heard about rape (100% of the respondents) and are conscious that rape is becoming a growing concern (79.3% of the respondents). In general people agree that the main causes of rape are alcoholism, substance abuse, sexual ranking causes Percentage of respondents agreeing 1 alcoholism 98% desire, reading and watching pornography dressing. Sexual desire 95.3% Least indecent respondents think that rape can be caused by unequal between 2 and, power men relations and women, revenge and punishment and, jealousy. The study found that 3 Substance abuse 83.3% 98 % of respondents agree that alcohol is the main cause of 4 Indecent dressing 62% rape. Alcohol consumption cannot just influence the culprit 5 Reading and watching 56.7% pornography from raping someone but the victim themselves under influence of alcohol have high 6 Unequal power relations 38.7% risk of getting raped as per the respondents. 7 Revenge and punishment 33.4% 8 Jealousy 29.4% 83.3% of respondents agree that substance abuse can lead to rape, 95.3% of respondents agree to sexual desire, 56.7% of respondents 41 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan agree to reading and watching pornography, 62% of respondents agree to indecent dressing, 38.7% of respondents agree to unequal power relations between men and women, 33.4% of respondents agree to revenge and punishment and, 29.4% of respondents agree to jealousy. The other factors found out are the economical background (poverty), lack of stringent laws Ranking Consequences Percentage 1 Depression and 87.3% against the abusers and, dependency of the victim to the perpetrator. The study also found that people are on average trauma 2 Stigmatization in the being sexually abused during their teens i.e., at the age of 19 as per the mean 84% calculated from data collected. Highly educated or not, many people are so society concerned about rape that they think a 3 Suicidal tendency 82% father would rape his own daughter with 54% of respondents agreeing to it. 4 Pregnancy 81.3% As per the data analyzed the consequences are stigmatization in the 5 Alcohol Consumption 79.4% society, abuse alcohol, drug abuse behavior, pregnancy, depression and 6 Drug Abuse 74.7% trauma, suicidal tendency and, thoughts of revenge and nightmares. 84% of the respondents agree that stigmatization in the society is one of the consequences of rape, 79.4% of the respondents agree to alcohol consumption as the aftermath of rape, 74.7% of the respondents agree to drug abuse, 81.3% of the respondents agree to pregnancy, 87.3% of the respondents agree to depression and trauma, 82% of the respondents agree to suicidal tendency in victim and, 65.3% of the respondents agree to thoughts of revenge and nightmares. The study also substantiates that there are few people who think that rape cannot be prevented with 10.7% of the respondents denying the prevention whereas 89.3% of respondents accept that rape is preventable if effective precautions are taken beforehand. 42 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Chapter 9 Recommendations Based on the findings, the study recommends the following: The organizations such as RENEW which deals with issues of rape should look into the causes and consequences of rape, and try to educate people so that rape can be controlled. Almost all the people have heard of rape but not all know that rape is a criminal offence (0.7% of the respondents think that rape is not a criminal offence and, 1.3% of the respondents do not know whether rape is a criminal offence or not), so it is responsibility of the concerned group such as RENEW, RBP, NCWC and other organizations who deal with rape issues to further educate general public about rape, it’s causes and consequences and, preventions to resist rape. Besides law, men and women are recommended to take their own precautions such as: Both men and women should avoid consumption of alcohol and substance abuse Women should avoid staying out late at night Going to places such as drayangs and parties should be avoided. Avoid being alone and always be in company Women should wear decent dress Avoid company of strangers Safety weapons should be always carried The penalty for the rapist as per the penal code of Bhutan should be revised and made severe so that people will fear the notion of rape. 43 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Reference Aryee, E. (2013). I was raped: the psychological effects of rape among Liberian & Ghanaian women in Ghana. Retrieved from https://tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/35219/1/12.1.Aryee.pdf Bloom, S.L. (2003). Understanding the impact of sexual assault: the nature of traumatic experience. In A. Giardino, E. Datner, & J. Asher (Ed.), Sexual assault: victimization across the lifespan (PP. 405‐ 432). Missouri: Medical Publishing Boyd, C. (2011). The impact of sexual assault on women. Melbourne: Australian Centre for the Study of Sexual Assault. Brown, S. (2003). Feminist history of Rape. Retrieved from http://www.safeplaceolympia.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/A-Feminist-History-ofRape.pdf Crake, M. (n.d.). Who is the rapist? Retrieved from http://www.aic.gov.au/media_library/publications/proceedings/20/crake.pdf Crowell, N.A., & Burgess, A.W. (1996). Understanding violence against women. Washington, DC: National Academy Press. Declue, G. (2005). [Review of the book The causes of rape: Understanding individual differences in male propensity for sexual aggression, by Martin L. Lalumiere, Grant T. Harris,Vernon L. Quinsey,& Marnie E. Rice, and Preventing Sexual Violence: How society should cope with sex offenders, by John Q. LaFord].the Journal of Psychiatry & Law, 33. 44 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Defining a rape culture. (2014). Retrieved from http://sparkleallday.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/rapeculture-1.pdf Dema, T. 2014. 13 minors raped in five months. Kuensel. Retrieved from http://www.kuenselonline.com/13-minors-raped-in-five-months/#.VIEuTTGUdBY Esere, M.O., Idowu, A. I., Durosaro, I. A., & Omotosho, J. A. (2009). Causes and consequences of intimate partner rape and violence: Experiences of victims in Lagos, Nigeria, Journal of AIDS and HIV Research, 1(1), 001-007. Hagen, K.T. (2010). The nature and psychosocial consequences of war rape for individuals and communities, International Journal of Psychological Studies, 2(2), 14-25. Hirschowitz, R., Worku, S., & Orkin, M. (2000). Quantitative research findings on rape in South Africa. Pretoria: Statistics South Africa. Kilpatrick, D.G. (2004). What is violence against women: Defining and measuring the problem. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 19, 1209-1234. Littleton, H., & Breitkopf, C. R. (2006). Coping with the experience of rape. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 30, 106–116. Mabasa, T. (2012). Understanding and preventing rape: perceptions of police officers in inner city Johannesburg. Retrieved from http://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10539/7188/June%20resubmittion%202.pdf ?sequence=2 McCabe, M.P. & Wauchope, M. (2005). Behavioural characteristics of rapists. Retrieved from http://www.hawaii.edu/hivandaids/Behavioural_Characteristics_of_Rapists.pdf 45 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan McDonald, M. (1994). Gender, drink and drugs. Oxford: Berg Publishers. Namgyel, T. (2014). Rapists receives 9 years and 6 months term. Kuensel. Retrieved from http://www.kuenselonline.com/rapist-receives-9-years-and-6-monthsterm/#.VIEwMjGUdBY RBP. (2013). Statistical yearbook 2013. Thimphu: Kuensel Corporation Ltd. The White House Council on Women and Girls. (2014). Rape and sexual assault: a renewed call to action. Retrieved from http://www.scribd.com/doc/202801804/RAPE-AND-SEXUALASSAULT-A-RENEWED-CALL-TO-ACTION-The-White-House-Council-on-Womenand-Girls-January-2014 Thornhill, R. & Palmer, C.T. (2001). The evolutionary biology of rape. Retrieved from http://90.146.8.18/en/archiv_files/20001/E2000_118.pdf Tjaden, P & Thoennes, N. (2006). Extent , nature, and consequences of rape victimization: Findings from the National Violence Against Women Survey. Retrieved from https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/210346.pdf United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. (2003). Gender-based violence against refugees, returnees and internally displaced persons. Retrieved from http://www.unicef.org/emerg/files/gl_sgbv03.pdf Vicary, J.R., Kingman, L.R & Harkness, W.L. (1995). Risk factors associated with date rape and sexual assault of adolescent girls. Journal of Adolescence, 18 (3), 289306. Wangdi, T. (2014). Unbridled libido fetches 45 days in prison. Kuensel. Retrieved from http://www.kuenselonline.com/unbridled-libido-fetches-45-days-in-prison/ 46 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Appendices Questionnaire Dear respondent, I am a post graduate student in Public Administration from the Royal Institute of Management, Semtokha, Thimphu. I am conducting a research on “the causes and consequences of rape in Bhutan” as a partial fulfillment of the course. I would like to request you to kindly complete this questionnaire. This is solely for academic purpose and all personal information provided will be kept confidential. If you have any queries regarding this research, please contact me at dechen.kinzang23@gmail.com. 1. Demographics a) Gender: Male female b) Which age group do you belong to? <25 years old >25 years old c) Please tick ( √ ) the highest year of school completed: Illiterate Certificate Primary Diploma High school Degree Masters and above 2. Have you heard of sexual abuse or rape? Yes 47 No Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan 3. Do you know rape is a criminal offence? (check √ only one) Yes Don’t know No 4. Do you think rape is becoming a growing concern in Bhutan? (check √ only one) Yes Don’t know No If yes Why? (Mention at least one) …………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… 5. Which of the following factors according to you are the main causes of rape? (Place a tick ( √ ) in the relevant box) Questions Strongly agree Alcoholism (influence both victim and culprit) Substance abuse Sexual desire Reading and watching pornography Indecent dressing 48 Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Unequal power relations (male domination) Revenge and punishment Jealousy 6. Why do men rape? Any reason… …………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………. ……………………………………………………………………………………. …………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………. 7. Which of the following are the consequences of rape according to you? Place a tick ( √ ) in the relevant box) Questions Strongly agree stigmatization in the society Abuse alcohol Drug abuse behavior Pregnancy Depression and trauma 49 Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan Suicidal tendency Thoughts of revenge and nightmares 8. What could be the consequences of rape according to you? (Mention at least one) ................................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................ 9. Have you ever been sexually abused (verbally or physically) in your life? Yes No If yes, when (at what age)? …………………………………………………………………………………… 10. Does a father rape his own daughter (s)? Yes No 11. Should a rapist be punished? Yes No If yes how (according to you)? …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… If no why (Mention at least one reason)? 50 Causes and Consequences of Rape in Bhutan …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… 12. Can rape be prevented? Yes No 13. What are the best steps women can take to prevent being raped? (Mention at least one) …………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………. ……………………………………………………………………………………. …………………………………………………………………………………… Thank you for your participation. 51