Professional Development to Practice Engaging Student Learners This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Handouts Pre- and Post Tests Critical Design Qualities of Student Work (Schlechty) Student Engagement Graphic Organizer Minds on Fire (Kathleen Cushman) Student Survey (Grant Wiggins) Growth Guides and Growth Guide Organizer Practice Profile, Fidelity Checklist, Action Plan Professional Development to Practice Purpose and Content Learning Objective: Learn to recognize, plan, and apply high student engagement practices, strategies, and techniques for all learning, regardless of grade level or content area. Expectations for the training: Participants will be able to recognize and describe the lesson design qualities that promote engagement. Participants will be able to select and incorporate effective unit and lesson design qualities. Professional Development to Practice Approximate Times for Sections of Presentation Section Appx Time Handouts /Items Needed Antiques Roadshow* 10 minutes (Pretest afterward) Suitcase Mystery* 20 minutes Prepare cases; index cards, pens Part 1: Motivation 30 minutes “Minds on Fire”, chart paper, markers Part 2: Engagement 25 minutes Schlechty Design Qualities, sticky notes Part 3: Checking for Engaging Qualities 1 hour Sticky notes, graphic organizer, access to Internet for Teaching Channel videos, access to Wiggins’ survey and blog Part 4: Enhancing Lessons and Units* 25-30 minutes This could be an optional piece; it involves accessing DESE’s Proven Practices online, or making hard copies for participants to use. Should still make participants aware of this resource. Part 5: SelfAssessment and Reflection 25-30 minutes Chart paper, markers Part 6: Next Steps 20-30 minutes Practice Profile, Fidelity Checklist, Next Steps Planner, Post-test *Optional section Professional Development to Practice Engaging Student Learners Effect Size and Connection to Missouri Teaching Standards The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Effective Teaching/Learning Practices Engaging Student Learners Professional Development to Practice Effect Size Hattie, J. (2009). Visible Learning. New York: Routledge Hattie, J. (2012). Visible Learning for Teachers. New York: Routledge Professional Development to Practice Engaging Student Learners (.48 Effect Size) Hattie, J. (2009). Visible Learning. New York: Routledge Hattie, J. (2012). Visible Learning for Teachers. New York: Routledge Professional Development to Practice Connection to Missouri Teaching Standards Standard 1, Quality Indicator 2: Engaging Students in Subject Matter Standard 4, Quality Indicator 1: Instructional Strategies Leading to Student Engagement in Problem Solving and Critical Thinking Standard 4, Quality Indicator 2: Appropriate Use of Instructional Resources to Enhance Student Learning Standard 5, Quality Indicator 1: Classroom Management, Motivation, and Engagement Professional Development to Practice Opening & Introductions The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice How do I know my students are engaged, and not just compliant? Professional Development to Practice Introductions: Antiques Roadshow Your team has two minutes to locate the oldest item brought by one of your team members today. It might be a coin, picture, ring, etc. The owner of the oldest item will introduce him/herself first, sharing name, school district, and what his/her duties are. Give a brief history of the “antique” being shared. Other team members will then introduce themselves. Professional Development to Practice Session-at-a-Glance Definition and Clarification of Student Engagement Practice Hattie Effect Size Identifying the qualities and conditions of engagement Application of qualities of engagement to a lesson Self-Assessment and Reflection Summarize and Organize Professional Development to Practice Norms Begin and end on time. Be an engaged participant. Be an active listener—open to new ideas. Use notes for sidebar conversations. Use electronics respectfully. Professional Development to Practice Essential Question How do teachers effectively engage students? Professional Development to Practice Guiding Questions What connects motivation and engagement? What are components of high student engagement? What actions, practices, strategies, and techniques promote high engagement for all learners? How can teachers assess lessons and units for engaging qualities? Professional Development to Practice Optional Opening Activity: Suitcase Mystery Use if there is time to open with an engaging activity. Preparation is required beforehand; a suitcase will need to be packed with around a dozen items. For a large group, you may need two suitcases. If the group is very large, this activity is not appropriate. Scenario: The goal is to describe the suitcase and its contents as accurately as possible, because this case has been left behind at the airport in the baggage claim area. In order to help the baggage handlers unite the bag with its owner, participants need to describe the items inside as clearly as possible and match them to the type of person who would use them. The goal is NOT trying to find a name, just the type of person. After describing the outside of the case, open it and have participants select an item for their team to describe. If they choose a pair of jeans, they might record, “They’re light-colored jeans. They are old and worn. They have a tear on the back pocket. The pants are ragged on the bottom.” Have them sketch the item also. They will be talking and trying to surmise who this might be. Ask teams, one by one, to show the item to everyone and read their description. When everyone is finished, come to consensus about who this might be. Collect the index cards and place them in the suitcase. Professional Development to Practice Suitcase Mystery Imagine this suitcase was left at the airport or train station without any identification. In order for the baggage handlers to return the suitcase to its owner, they are going to have to describe the suitcase and items inside as precisely as they can in order to match them to the person who would own them. Professional Development to Practice Suitcase Mystery What words can be used to describe this suitcase? Write a description on your index card, and be as specific as possible. Professional Development to Practice Suitcase Mystery Partner up—choose something from the suitcase…write a description of the item you selected on the other side of your index card. Draw a picture of the item, too. Begin to consider who this person might be… Professional Development to Practice Suitcase Mystery Who was this person? Professional Development to Practice Processing the Suitcase Activity What kinds of thinking and collaboration skills and strategies did you use? Did you change your mind when you began to articulate your thinking? Why? Were you motivated? Engaged? FINALLY: Consider the grade level and content you teach…how might you use a similar activity to begin a unit? Please share. Professional Development to Practice Part One: Define and Clarify “Motivation” The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Thinking About Motivation Create teams of 3 or 4, or table teams. On a sticky note, first answer the following questions solo: Who was your favorite teacher? Why was s/he your favorite? As a team, share your findings and note: What characteristics do your favorites have in common? Each team will share with the larger group. Professional Development to Practice Motivation In general terms, student motivation refers to a student’s willingness, need, desire and compulsion to participate in, and be successful in, the learning process. …Students who are motivated to engage in school select tasks at the border of their competencies, initiate action when given the opportunity, and exert intense effort and concentration in the implementation of learning tasks; they show generally positive emotions during ongoing action, including enthusiasm, optimism, curiosity, and interest. Brewster, Fager 2000 Professional Development to Practice Motivating Students to Engage in Class Activities It only makes sense that the more interesting an assignment is, the more likely students are to immerse themselves in the task and stick with it through completion. Even highly motivated students need school work that actively engages them by building on their interests and prior knowledge. Brewster, Fager 2000 Professional Development to Practice Understanding Motivation: Center of Gravity Summary Move into teams. Read the assigned section of “Minds on Fire” by Kathleen Cushman. Teams complete a “Center of Gravity” summary by recording on chart paper to share aloud-The most important paragraph, and why; The most important sentence, and why; The most important word, and why; A connection between motivation and mastery learning. Professional Development to Practice Motivation: Minds on Fire “To be motivated means to be moved to do something. A person who feels no impetus or inspiration to act is unmotivated, whereas someone who is energized or activated toward an end is considered motivated. In the classroom setting, student motivation refers to the degree to which a student puts effort into and focus on learning in order to achieve successful outcomes.” Saeed, Zyngier 2012 Professional Development to Practice Motivation and Engagement “To assess student motivation researchers also have to examine engagement in and as part of learning, understanding or mastery of the knowledge…high levels of engagement show high levels of motivation.” Saeed, Zyngier 2012 Professional Development to Practice John Hattie’s Concerns “No manner of school reform will be successful until we first face and resolve the engagement problem– Too many students are ‘physically present but psychologically absent’. Students can be easily confused. Many are bored. Students spend 85% of their time listening to a teacher talking”. Professional Development to Practice Part 2: Defining Engagement The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Definition of Engagement In education, student engagement refers to the degree of attention, curiosity, interest, optimism, and passion that students show when they are learning or being taught, which extends to the level of motivation they have to learn and progress in their education. Generally speaking, the concept of “student engagement” is predicated on the belief that learning improves when students are inquisitive, interested, or inspired, and that learning tends to suffer when students are bored, dispassionate, disaffected, or otherwise “disengaged.” Professional Development to Practice Components of Engagement The student is attentive; he/she pays attention to and focuses on the tasks associated with the work being done. The student is committed (without the promise of extrinsic rewards or the threat of negative consequence). The student is persistent. He/she sticks to the task even when it presents difficulty. The student finds meaning and value in the tasks of the work. Phillip C. Schlechty (2011) Professional Development to Practice Engaged students make a “….psychological investment in learning. They try hard to learn what school offers. They take pride not simply in earning the formal indicators of success (grades), but in understanding the material and incorporating or internalizing it in their lives.” Fred Newmann 1992 Professional Development to Practice Discussion: Research on Engagement Teachers and students were asked two questions: 1. What kind of work do you find engaging? Work that allowed for creativity, sparked curiosity, provided an opportunity to work with others, and produced a feeling of success. 2. What kind of work do you hate? Work that was repetitive, required no thought, or was forced on them. Discuss: Recall what we said about our favorite teachers… Strong, Silver, and Robinson (1995) Professional Development to Practice Teachers Can Heighten Student Engagement What research tell us about student engagement: Engagement is associated with student achievement. Teachers can increase and decrease engagement, depending on classroom environment. There are a variety of ways to evaluate student engagement. Parsons, Nuland, Parsons. 2014 Professional Development to Practice “Student Engagement is Malleable” “Student engagement is malleable, and teachers have the ability to design contexts and tasks that encourage or discourage student engagement. Teachers create an engaging environment by fostering cooperation, positiveness, and tasks that are authentic, collaborative, and challenging.” Parsons, Nuland, Parsons. 2014 Professional Development to Practice “The core business of our schools is to ensure that every student, every day, is provided challenging, interesting, and satisfying work.” Phillip Schlechty Professional Development to Practice How do I go about incorporating elements of engagement? What will a lesson look like? Sound like? Professional Development to Practice Lesson Design Qualities Phillip Schlechty proposed a Framework for Lesson Design Qualities of Student Work. 1. Design Qualities of Context These are must-haves 2. Design Qualities of Choice Not all must be present in a lesson Professional Development to Practice Schlechty’s Proposed Design Qualities of Context: Must-Haves Content and Substance Organization and Knowledge Clear and Compelling Product Standards Protection from Adverse Consequences Professional Development to Practice Schlechty’s Design Qualities of Choice: Not All Must be Present Product Focus Affirmation of Performance Affiliation Novelty and Variety Choice Authenticity Lessons may contain a combination of these. Professional Development to Practice Critical Design Qualities Jigsaw After counting off and creating teams, read and summarize Schlechty’s Critical Design Qualities of Student Work in 9 words or less. Record on a Sticky Note. Be ready to share your summary with the group. Handout: Critical Design Qualities of Student Work Professional Development to Practice The Design Qualities Enhance Student Engagement “Student engagement refers to the degree of attention, curiosity, interest, value, and perseverance that students show when they are learning or being taught.” Professional Development to Practice Creating Engaging Lessons Since the design qualities of engaging work are definable and distinct, the next task is to recognize and observe them in practice. Professional Development to Practice Part Three: Identifying and Checking For Engaging Qualities in Teacher Practice The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Students Who Are Engaged… learn at high levels and have a profound grasp of what they learn, retain what they learn, and can transfer what they learn to new contexts. Phillip Schlechty Professional Development to Practice Students Who Are Strategically Compliant… learn at high levels but have a superficial grasp of what they learn, do not retain what they learn, and usually cannot transfer what they learn from one context to another. Professional Development to Practice Unpack “Strategically Compliant” and “Engaged” With a shoulder partner, discuss what teachers will see and hear when students are engaged rather than just compliant. Jot your thoughts on a sticky note. Engaged Compliant Professional Development to Practice Engagement “Student engagement cannot be directly observed and is ‘difficult to define operationally, but we know it when we see it, and we know it when it is missing.’” Newman “Engagement is active. It requires the students to be attentive as well as in attendance; it requires the students to be committed to the task and find some inherent value in what he or she is being asked to do.” Schlechty Professional Development to Practice Application: Identifying and Checking for Student Engagement Using what you have learned about lesson design qualities for engagement and what one would expect to see and hear from engaged students, evaluate the Tiny House video, a building unit, by using the Student Engagement Graphic Organizer. Does Tiny House contain the design concepts of context? Mark all you observe. Does it contain design concepts of choice? Which ones? Does it exemplify an engaging lesson? Handout: Student Engagement Graphic Organizer Professional Development to Practice Organizer for Identifying the Critical Design Qualities Definition Clear and Apparent Missing or Unclear Product Focus Student Engagement Phillip Schlechty’s Design Qualities of Student Work: Context (Must be present) Content and Substance What is to be learned and the level of student interest in the subject or topic Organization of Knowledge How the work is organized— problem solving approach, discovery approach, didactic teaching—with consideration for learning styles that are assumed or are to be addressed Clear and Compelling Product Standards The extent to which students are clear about what they are to do, what the products they produce would look like, what standards will be applied to evaluate these products and their performances, and how much value students attach to the standards that are to be used; that is, do the students believe in the standards and see them as personally compelling? Protection from Adverse Consequences for Initial Failures Extent to which the task is designed so students feel free to try without fear that initial failures will bring them humiliation, implicit punishment, or negative sanctions Definition The opportunity to structure tasks and activities so that what students are to learn is linked to some product, performance, or exhibition to which the student attaches personal value. Affirmation of Performance The possibility of designing tasks and activities so that the performance of students is made visible to persons who are significant in their lives, as well as designing the work in ways that make it clear that the quality of the performance of the student has meaning and value to peers and others whose opinions the student values and cares about. Affiliation The possibility of designing tasks so that students are provided the opportunity to work with peers as well as with parents, outside experts, and other adults, including but not limited to the teacher. Novelty and Variety The possibility of providing students the opportunity to employ a wide range of media and approaches when engaged in the activities assigned and encouraged. Choice The possibility of designing tasks and activities so that students can exercise choice either in what they are to learn or how they go about learning that which it is required that they learn. Authenticity The possibility of linking learning tasks to things that are of real interest to the student, especially when the student is not interested in learning what adults have determined s/he needs to learn. Clear and Apparent Missing or Unclear Handout: Organizer of Schlechty’s Design Qualities Professional Development to Practice Video from Teaching Channel Tiny House https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/tinyhouse-collaborative-project-hth Professional Development to Practice Engaging Students Watch the next video. Once again, look for Schlechty’s Critical Design Elements. This time, watch as a Critical Friend. On an organizer, mark all the design qualities you observe. Compare your organizer with that of a table partner or team member. What necessary elements were missing, if any? How could the lesson be improved? Handout: Student Engagement Graphic Organizer Professional Development to Practice Video from Teaching Channel “Keep it or Junk It” https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/stude nt-run-lesson Professional Development to Practice Checking a Lesson for Engaging Design Qualities The goal is not to redesign each lesson, or to present an alternate plan for writing lesson plans. The goal is to purposely incorporate qualities that will enhance and promote student engagement. Then we can consider the degree of attention, curiosity, interest, value, and perseverance that students show when they are learning or being taught. Professional Development to Practice Teacher Reflection: Checking For and Sustaining Student Engagement Teachers should seek feedback from students as to the success of the teaching, providing criteria for younger or inexperienced student evaluators. Teachers should then reflect on their own performance; how can lessons be changed in order to be more engaging? Professional Development to Practice Getting Feedback: Teachers Need to Evaluate Student Engagement One means of assessment is observation: Do students talk about their learning outside of class? Can students handle mild frustration? Do students have the strategies they need in order to persevere? Do they participate in class discussions? Are they enthusiastic? Do they have a positive attitude? Professional Development to Practice Sample Survey from Grant Wiggins Examine a copy of Wiggins’ online student survey. https://grantwiggins.files.wordpress.com/2014 /10/ae-student-survey-2014-15.pdf What kinds of information and feedback would teachers receive? Handout: Wiggins Student Survey Instrument Professional Development to Practice Activity: Constructing an Engagement Assessment Instrument Consider your grade level and teaching goals. With a colleague or team, create an end-ofunit Student Survey with no more than 4 questions: what questions would you ask students that would indicate students were engaged? When time is called, each team will share one of their questions with the whole group. Professional Development to Practice More From a Student’s Viewpoint What a veteran teacher observed after shadowing students aligns with what Hattie warns about, (too much teacher talk, too little student participation) and what Schlechty’s model suggests needs to be implemented. http://grantwiggins.wordpress.com/2014/10/10/a-veteranteacher-turned-coach-shadows-2-students-for-2-days-a-soberinglesson-learned/ Professional Development to Practice Designing Engaging Work We have learned to recognize and define engaging design qualities in lessons. We have practiced creating an assessment instrument to check for student engagement. The next task is to consider our own lessons and how to enhance them with the design qualities of engagement. Professional Development to Practice Part 4: Enhancing Lessons and Units Using the Design Qualities of Engagement--Accessing and Using DESE’s Proven Practice Documents Featuring the work of Robert J. Marzano, John Hattie, Doug Lemov The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Qualities that Help Increase Student Engagement DESE has provided “Research and Proven Practices” documents on its website to help educators as they review and develop lessons with engaging qualities. These guides provide numerous strategies, techniques, and practices recommended by John Hattie, Robert Marzano, and Doug Lemov. Professional Development to Practice Locating the Documents Access the DESE website In the Search bar, enter either Growth Guide Marzano Growth Guide Lemov Growth Guide Hattie Professional Development to Practice Proven Practices Expert Groups As a team, examine the growth guides for Standard1,Quality Indicator 2: Student Engagement in Subject Matter Complete the organizer by choosing one practice/technique/strategy from each researcher that you could implement to increase student engagement in a current lesson or unit. Be ready to share with the whole group. Professional Development to Practice Part 5: Self-Assessment and Reflection The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Engaging Student Learners What have you taught that started fires in the minds of students? How will you enhance lessons to engage student learners? Professional Development to Practice Self-Assessment: Graffiti Wall Activity As a team, discuss-- and then design a new lesson to share. Use what you have learned about the design qualities of student engagement to create the lesson. Splash a lesson title, grade level, and the main lesson components in an attention-grabbing way on chart paper using markers, “graffiti style.” Post the lesson. Professional Development to Practice Take an Alley Walk Take an “Alley Walk” around the room and, using colored markers, note and applaud appropriate design elements that will increase student engagement. Write in suggestions for other engaging strategies. Use the Schlechty handout and Growth Guide information if needed. Professional Development to Practice Part Six: Where Are You Going? Planning Next Steps The contents of this presentation were developed under a grant from the US Department of Education to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (#H323A120018). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the US Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Professional Development to Practice Practice Profile Professional Development to Practice Implementation Fidelity Engaging Student Learners PRACTICE: IMPLEMENTATION FIDELITY CHECKLIST Instructions: This checklist is designed for frequent checking on the fidelity of implementing the Engaging Student Learners Practice. It is suggested that educators self-monitor their fidelity daily during early implementation. An on-site coach may also observe and use this form to record fidelity. Completed checklists can be discussed during coaching conversations. If the number of ‘Yes’ items is repeatedly fewer than four, (4), then coaching may be beneficial. Teacher… Yes 1 Includes design elements of Content and Substance, Organization of Knowledge, Clear and Compelling Product Standards, and Protection from Adverse Consequences for Initial Failures in lessons. 2 Includes a design element of choice: Product Focus, Affirmation of Performance, Affiliation, Novelty and Variety, Choice, and Authenticity. 3 Monitors students to observe that they are attentive, committed, persistent, and find meaning and value in tasks. 4 Seeks end-of-unit student input and reflection on the qualities of engagement. 5 Refers to the Proven Practices on the DESE website in order to include strategies and techniques to enhance student engagement. Total Partially No If partially or no, explain. Professional Development to Practice Next Steps: Action=Results Next Steps: Actions = Results Content Focus Collaborative Data Teams Effective Teaching/Learning Practices School: _________________________ Common Formative Assessment Data-based Decision-making Date Next Steps Form Written:_______________________________ Teams (e.g. grade level or content): _________________________________________________________________________________ Action Planned What? Responsible Person(s) Who? Timeline When? Resources/Support Needed Results So What? What steps will you take to start implementing? Professional Development to Practice Sources Brewster & Fager. Increasing Student Engagement and Motivation: From Time on Task to Homework Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory. Oct. 2000. Cushman, Kathleen. “Minds On Fire”. Educational Leadership. Dec. 2013/Jan. 2014. 38-43. Culham, Ruth. 6+1 Traits of Writing: The Complete Guide for the Primary Grades. Scholastic, 2005. Dack, Hillary and Tomlinson, Carol Ann. Searching for the Irresistible. kappanmagazine.org. V95 N8. 43-47. Daniels, Kevin. 2014 MSDC Conference presentation. Creating Conditions for the Highly Engaged Classroom and Student. Kevin.daniel@raypec.org Gardiner, Steve. Stop the Pay, Stop the Play. Kappanmagazine.org. 39-42. V95 N8. Hattie, John. Visible Learning: A Synthesis of Over 800 Meta-Analyses Relating to Achievement. 2009. Missouri Department of Education Website. Growth Guide. http://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/02GrowthGuide.pdf Parsons, Seth A.; Nuland, Leila Richey; Parsons, Allison Ward. The ABCs of Student Engagement. kappanmagazine.org. 23-27. V95 N8. Schlechty, Phillip. Introduction to the Schlechty Center. www.schlechtycenter.org. Saeed, Zyngier. How Motivation Influences Student Engagement: A Qualitative Case Study. Journal of Education and Learning; Vol. 1, No. 2; 2012. Accessed 2/25/15. Wiggins, Grant. Blog. http://grantwiggins.wordpress.com/2014/10/10/a-veteran-teacher- turned-coach-shadows-2-students-for-2-days-a-sobering-lesson-learned/ Professional Development to Practice Teacher Resources For research and proven practices with regard to implementing teaching standards in the classroom, see the following: http://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/09-ResearchProvenPracticesMarzano.pdf http://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/10-ResearchProvenPracticesHattie.pdf http://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/11-ResearchProvenPracticesTLAC.pdf https://www.teachingchannel.org/?gclid=CLTb7LCG_sMCFYI6 gQodTE0AUg