Chapter VI. Propulsion of Ships The propulsion system of a ship is to provide the thrust to the ship to overcome the resistance. 6.1 Introduction • Propulsive Devices (reading p205-209) Paddle-Wheels: While the draft varying with ship displacement, the immersion of wheels also varies. The wheels may come out of water when the ship is rolling, causing erratic course-keeping, & they are likely to damage from rough seas. Propellers: Its first use was in a steam-driven boat at N.Y. in 1804. Advantages over paddle-wheels are, 1) not substantially affected by normal changes in draft; 2) not easily damaged; 3) decreasing the width of the ship, & 4) good efficiency driven by lighter engine. Since then, propellers have dominated in use of marine propulsion. Paddle Wheels Propulsion (Stern) Paddle Wheels Propulsion (Midship) Propeller (5-blade) Propeller (5-blade) & Rudder Jet type: Water is drawn by a pump & delivered sternwards as a jet at a high velocity. The reaction providing the thrust. It’s use has been restricted to special types of ships. Other propulsion Devices: 1. Nozzles (Duct) Propellers: main purpose is to increase the thrust at low ship speed (tug, large oil tanker) 2. Vertical-Axis Propellers: Advantage is to control the direction of thrust. Therefore, the ship has good maneuverability. 3. Controllable-Pitch Propellers (CCP): The pitch of screw can be changed so that it will satisfy all working conditions. 4. Tandem and Contra-rotating Propellers: It is used because the diameter of a propeller is restricted due to limit of the draft or other reasons (torpedo). The efficiency of the propeller usually decreases. Jet Propulsion Nozzle Propellers Vertical-Axis Propellers Vertical-Axis Propellers Controllable Pitch Propellers (CPP) Contra-rotating Propellers • Type of Ship Machinery 1. Steam Engine (no longer used in common) Advantages: 1) good controllability at all loads, 2) to be reversed easily, & 3) rpm (rotations per minute) matches that of propellers Disadvantages: 1.) very heavy 2.) occupy more space 3.) the output of power per cylinder is limited 4.) fuel consumption is high 2. Steam Turbine Advantages: 1.) deliver a uniform turning torque, good performance for large unit power output, 2.) thermal efficiency is high. Disadvantages: 1.) is nonreversible; 2.) rpm is too high, need a gear box to reduce its rotating speed 3. Internal combustion engines (Diesel engine) Advantages: 1.) are built in all sizes, fitted in ships ranging from small boats to large super tankers, (less 100 hp ~ >30,000 hp); 2.) High thermal efficiency. Disadvantages: 1.) Heavy cf. gas turbines; 4. Gas Turbines (developed for aeronautical applications) Advantages: 1.) Do not need boiler, very light; 2.) Offer continuous smooth driving, & need very short “warm” time. Disadvantages: 1.) expensive in cost and maintenance 2.) need a gear unit to reduce rpm. 5. Nuclear reactors – turbine Advantages 1.) do not need boiler, fuel weight is very small 2.) operate full load for very long time (submarine) Disadvantages 1.) weight of reactor and protection shield are heavy; 2) Environment problem, potential pollution. • Definition of Power Indicated horsepower (PI): is measured in the cylinders (Steam reciprocating engines) by means of an instrument (an “indicator”) which continuously records the gas or steam pressure throughout the length of the piston travel. PI pm L A n / 550 pm - mean effective pressure (psi) L – Length of piston stroke (ft) n – number of working strokes per second A – effective piston area (in2) n – number of cylinders Brake Horsepower (PB): is the power measured at the crankshaft coupling by means of a mechanical hydraulic or electrical brake. PB 2 nQ / 550 where Q – brake torque (lb-ft) & n – revolutions per second. Shaft horsepower (PS): is the power transmitted through the shaft to the propeller. It is usually measured aboard ship as close to the propeller as possible by means of a torsion meter . d S G n 4 PS 13, 033bLS where dS – shaft diameter (in), G – shear modulus of elasticity of shaft material (psi), θ – measured angle of twist (degree), LS – length of shaft over which θ is measured & n – revolution per second Delivered horsepower (PD): the power delivered to the propeller. Thrust horsepower (PT): PT T VA / 550 T – Thrust delivered by propeller (lb) VA – advance velocity of propeller (ft/s) Effective horsepower (PE , or EHP): RT – total resistance (lb) Vs – advance velocity of ship (ft/s) PE RT Vs / 550 • Propulsion Efficiency Total propulsion efficiency T PE PS PS can also be replaced by PB or PI A more meaningful measure of hydrodynamic performance of a propeller is: a quasi-propulsive coefficient, D PE D , PD S PD , PS where S is the shaft transmission efficiency and thus, T DS . S - 98% for ships with main engine aft - 97% for ships with main engine amidship - smaller if a gear box is used. 6.2 Propeller Geometry and Terminology Face Back Hubcap Boss Number of Blades: 2, 3, 4, 5 ,6 Boss Hubcap Shaft • The face surface of a blade is a portion of a holicoidal surface • The helicoidal surface: Considering a line AB perpendicular to a line AA’ and supposing that AB rotates with uniform velocity about AA’ and at the same time moves along AA’ with uniform velocity, the surface swept out by AB is a helicoidal surface. Pitch: P when the line AB makes one complete revolution and arrives at A’B’. It traveled an axial distance AA’, which represents the pitch of the surface. The propeller blade is part of that surface and the pitch is also called the pitch of the blade. Pitch angle tan 1 P or tan P 2 r 2 r Pitch ratio: PR P D tan PR A P o 2 r p180 Expended Area AE Developed Area AD Boss: (aka, Hub) Boss diameter – The blades at their lower ends or roots are attached to a boss which in turn is attached to the propeller shaft. The maximum diameter of this boss is called the boss diameter . The boss diameter is usually made as small as possible and should be no larger than the size sufficient to accommodate the blades and satisfying the requirement of strength. It is usually expressed as a fraction of the propeller diameter. At one time propeller blades were manufactured separately from the boss, but modern fixed pitch propellers have the boss and blades cast together. However, in controllable pitch propellers it is of course necessary for blades and boss to be manufactured separately. • Blade outline: it is decided by propeller series diagrams. • “Expanded blade outline” • Blade sections: they are radial sections through the blade. The shape of these sections is then shaped when laid out flat. •Blade thickness •Blade width (Chord) •Leading edge •Trailing edge P181 figure 10.5 • Rake (a blade is perpendicular or titled w.r.t the boss ) • Skew (the skewness of a blade w.r.t. the center line) • Pitch ratio P PR D In case that the pitch, P, is not constant, then the pitch is defined as P = Ptip (the pitch at the tip of a propeller). • Blade area ratio = AD /A0 AD - Total (developed) blade area clear of that of the boss A0 D 2 / 4 6.3 Theory of Propeller Action • Assumptions: 1) replacing the propeller with a stationary actuating disk across which the pressure is made to rise; 2) neglecting the rotational effect of propeller 3) neglecting vortices shed from the blade tip, & frictional loss. VA D VA(1+a) VA(1+b) • Momentum Conservation Force = net momentum flux (horizontal) T Q VA 1 b VA Q 1 a VA A0 = VA Af = 1 b VA Aa (mass conservation) T QVAb A0VA2 1 a b • Energy Equation V P V 1 b 2g 2g 2 A 2 A 2 A0 P T , b 2 b VA T 1 , T A0 b 2 b VA2 A0 2g 2 1 a 1 b or a b 2 2 2 Ideal Efficiency of a propeller (no friction & no rotationary velo. considered) VA A0 TVA TVA 1 I QP TQ 1 a VA A0 1 a A0 1 1 1 a 1 b / 2 Defining the thrust loading coeff., CT , as I A0VA2 1 a b T CT 1 4 1 a a 2 2 1 2 VA A0 2 VA A0 1 1 CT Thus, a 2 2 & I 1 1 CT With the increase in CT , the ideal efficiency decreases. CT 0 1 2 3 4 I 1.00 0.827 0.732 0.667 0.618 • Extension of momentum theory Consider the rotation of the flow passing through the propeller disc., the reduced ideal efficiency becomes, 1 a ' I & a ' 0. 1 a 2 2 2 1 a ' 1 2 where 2 is the rotation velocity of flow after the propeller, & is the rotation velocity of the propeller. • Blade Element Theory In the momentum conservation of a propeller, no detailed information can be obtained with regard to the effects of the blade section shape on propeller thrust and efficiency. The total velo. at radius r , Vr VA VT , Thrust: VT 2 rN . dT d L cos d D sin Resistance: d F d L sin d D cos Moment: q dF r & d L and d D f f is a function depending on section shape (wing section theory). For a propeller, the relative advance velocity of the fluid at the disc, is VA 1 a & the rotation velocity is r 1 a ' . a & a’ are determined by experiments aVA VA α α’ Vr r r 1 a ' a ' r 6.4 Similarity Law for Propellers Although theoretical studies and CFD on propellers are very important and provides valuable guideline for designing propeller, a great deal of knowledge concerning the performance of propellers has been obtained from propeller model tests. Hence, it is necessary to examine the relation between model and full-scale results as the case of resistance. In open water (not behind a ship), T f , D,VA , g , n, p, n - rotational speed, D - diameter of propeller p - pressure in water, - dynamic viscosity VA - speed of advancing, T - Thrust Using D.A, the non-dimensinal formula is given by, VA D T p VA VA f , , , 2 1 n2 D 4 nD V A 2 gD VA VA D p Froude #: , Euler #: 1 , Reynolds #: 2 gD 2 VA Advanced ratio: J VA , Thrust coeff. : nD KT T n2 D 4 V The Advanced ratio is related to the slip ratio 1 A . nP Define Q as the Torque to drive a propeller Q The torque coeff .: K Q n2 D5 In open water, the propeller efficiency coeff.: TVA K VA J KT o T . 2 nQ K Q 2 nD 2 K Q When all the dimensionless parameters are the same for the two geometrically similar propellers, the two propellers will be dynamically similar. Ds Scale ratio: Dm For the same Froude #: VAs VAm Ds Dm For the same advance ratio (most important) 1 ns VAs Dm 2 indicating the model rotating faster. nm VAm Ds p p For the same Euler # : 1 1 2 2 2 VA m 2 VA s If the cavitation performance is not an issue, this number is not of importance & may be neglected in the dynamical similarity. ps pos H s w pos - water surface pressure, H s is the depth of a propeller. VA m pm 2 VA s 2 In general, m s , Because 1, ps ps . pm ps and pm pom H m w . pom has to be negative, thus the model test is carried out in a vacuum (cavitation) tunnel. VAs Dm vs 1 For the same Re: , VAm Ds vm which is contradict to the similarity of Fr. Therefore, it is almost impossible to satisfy the Fr & Re similarity laws simutanously. Similar to the assumption made in model resisrtance tests, we assume viscous force is independent of other dynamic forces. Hence, it may be computed separately. In reality, viscous force is usually a small portion of the total force. The smilarity of Re is neglected in propeller model tests. Therefore, propeller model tests follows Fr & J (advance ratio) similarity laws. If the cavitation is relevant, then the Euler number should be the same as well. 6.5 Propeller Model Test A test on a model propeller is run either in a towing tank or a running flow in a water tunnel (cavitation tunnel) without a model hull in front of it, which is called “open water” tests. 1) VA – velo.of flow 2.) n - rotation of motor 3.) po - pressure can be controlled Measure VA , Q, T, and n. Development of cavitations of a propeller in a cavitation tunnel T Q Trust coeff. KT , Toeque coeff. K Q , 2 4 2 5 n D n D TVA KT J Open - water efficient o . 2 nQ K Q 2 Testing results 0 KQ KT J VA nD VA P Slip ratio 1 , Pitch ratio , section types & # of blades. nP D Purpose of open-water tests • It is usually to carry out open water tests on standard series of propellers. Their features (such as # of blades, blade outline shape, blade area ratio, blade section shape, blade thickness fraction, boss diameter & pitch-diameter ratio) are systematically varied. The result data are summarized in a set of particular diagrams, which can be used for design purposes. We will study how to use these diagrams later for designing a propeller. •Studying the efficiency of a propeller and find a propeller with better efficiency •Studying the extent and development of cavitations over a propeller.