Crime Prevention Strategy & Action Plan prepared in accordance with the NSW Department of Justice Guidelines for the purpose of seeking endorsement as a Safer Community Compact prepared in accordance with the 4 December 2014 NSW Department of Justice Guidelines in order to request a Community Safety Compact Table of Contents 1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................ 3 2 MARRICKVILLE CRIME PRIORITIES ...................................................... 4 3 PROFILE OF THE PRIORITY CRIMES ..................................................... 5 3.1 Theft – Steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling ..................... 5 3.2 Assault – non-domestic violence related assault ........................... 6 4 HOW THE PRIORITY CRIMES WERE SELECTED .................................. 8 4.1 Theft - steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling ...................... 8 4.2 Assault - non-domestic violence related assault .......................... 10 5 SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS: ..................................................................... 13 5.1 Newtown Station .............................................................................. 13 5.2 Marrickville Station .......................................................................... 13 5.3 King Street and Enmore Road ........................................................ 14 5.4 Illawarra Road and Marrickville Road ............................................. 14 6 STAKEHOLDERS.................................................................................... 15 6.1 Safety issues identified by local businesses and community organisations ............................................................................................ 15 6.2 Feedback on the draft Crime Prevention Strategy – LACs and SIM Committee Members ................................................................................ 16 7 MONITORING AND EVALUATING ......................................................... 17 7.1 Evaluation and data collection........................................................ 17 8 CRIME PREVENTION ACTION PLAN .................................................... 18 2 1 INTRODUCTION Marrickville Council has prepared the Marrickville Crime Prevention Strategy and Action Plan (the Plan) to address some of the priority categories of offences in Marrickville. The Plan is based on review of available data and liaison with local agencies including local police and those providing family and youth support. The main categories of crime addressed in the Plan are those that occur with the highest frequency, those that have been raised by local service providers, and those that Council can have an impact on. The Plan has been prepared using the NSW Department of Justice guidelines and template and is specifically intended as a submission to the Department to secure a Safe Community Compact and to obtain a grant to implement it. The Plan proposes a number of actions that will contribute to achieving some objectives of Our Place: Our Vision Marrickville Community Strategic Plan. Theft is considered one of the main areas that Council can collaborate with local police and achieve results. In 2009 - 2010 Council participated in the Inner West Theft Reduction Program with funding from the (then) NSW Attorney General’s Department. The program involved an education campaign against theft from motor vehicles and an audit of priority locations using the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design principles. As part of the program immobilisers were provided to owners of older cars to limit motor vehicle theft in the area. Marrickville Council has not applied for, or received, funding for crime prevention programs since 2010. In this Plan Council intends to focus on theft from dwellings (steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling). Incidents of steal from dwelling have increased by 11.6% over the last five years and incidents of break and enter dwelling, while stable, remain high in comparison to other local areas. Marrickville Council has also chosen to focus on non-domestic violence related assault, and particularly assault that is alcohol related given the potential for this category of crime to result in serious harm and possible death. Marrickville has a large and popular entertainment precinct on King Street and Enmore Road Newtown, and a number of smaller pub clusters, all with extended trading hours. Further local police say that numbers visiting Newtown have increased since the NSW Government introduced the 1 am lock out in Kings Cross and George Street City early in 2014. This Plan has been drafted using the template published by the NSW Department of Justice, and in accordance with the associated guidelines. Input from community members and the Safety in Marrickville have been used to identify the priority crimes for Marrickville, and strategies and actions to address these crimes and for potential funding by the Department. 3 2 MARRICKVILLE CRIME PRIORITIES Over the last ten years, the offences shown in Table 1 have consistently been the most frequent based on the number of recorded incidents in Marrickville. The three categories of crime have generally been above the NSW average and higher than nearby local areas with similar characteristics to Marrickville. While the incidents and rate of these crimes is decreasing in Marrickville, they are still high in comparison to other crimes and the incidents recorded in other areas. These crimes impact significantly on Marrickville communities and there are actions that can be taken to achieve an improvement. Table 1: Most frequent offences in Marrickville - of the 19 major offence categories - number, rate & quintile* ten years ending 30 Jun 2014 YE 30 JUN 2005 YE 30 JUN 2006 YE 30 JUN 2007 YE 30 JUN 2008 YE 30 JUN 2009 YE 30 JUN 2010 YE 30 JUN 2011 YE 30 JUN 2012 YE 30 JUN 2013 YE 30 JUN 2014 Incidents of theft 4680 6271.4 1 5015 6693.7 1 4988 6577.4 1 4818 6239.1 1 3606 4586.9 1 3869 4846.0 1 3080 3814.1 2 3190 3918.9 1 3557 4354.3 1 3200 3917.3 1 Incidents of malicious damage to property 1035 1386.8 3 1167 1557.3 3 1352 1784.0 2 1273 1649.7 2 1278 1625.8 2 1067 1337.9 2 1050 1300.2 2 913 1121.8 1 935 1144.6 2 885 1083.4 2 Incidents of assault 873 1170.0 3 981 1309.6 2 902 1190.2 3 775 1004.3 3 758 964.6 3 666 834.0 3 741 917.4 3 723 888.1 3 682 834.9 3 705 863.0 3 Where quintile 1 refers to the top quintile (that identifies Councils that have the highest rate of incidents), quintile 5 refers to the lowest quintile (that identifies Councils that have the lowest rate of incidents) Council has previously obtained grants for programs to address motor vehicle theft and steal from motor vehicle, and to implement out of school hours programs for youth. Council continues to run out of school hours programs for children and youth in Marrickville through its community development activities. Council has received significant funding in recent years to address graffiti and has a graffiti removal program in place. Council also contributes to a program run by the Marrickville Youth Resource Centre to assist young offenders charged with graffiti offences and discourage them from reoffending. In this Crime Prevention Strategy and Action Plan, Marrickville Council has decided to focus on programs related to: Theft – specifically steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling, and Assault – specifically non-domestic violence related assault, the majority of which is alcohol related or occurs in areas where crowds are attracted by the clustering of alcohol establishments. These priorities are chosen as the ones that Council can work on with local agencies and achieve the most success. The following criteria, have also been used to identify these priority offences for Marrickville: The number and rate of offences are above or near the State average The trend is upwards in over the last five years or stable Marrickville experienced a higher number and rate in these offences compared to NSW or other areas with similar demographics Council (if funding is obtained form the NSW Department of Justice) and local agencies (specifically the Local Area Commands) have the expertise and commitment necessary to make an impact 4 There is a realistic chance that the two strategies Council is proposing can reduce the priority offences because: o Access control accompanied by awareness campaigns can be effective in reducing both break and enter dwelling and steal from dwelling offences1, o There is a growing body of evidence from both Australia and overseas that shows community-based strategies can reduce alcohol-related assault in entertainment precincts2, and o The proposed strategies are based on the NSW Department of Justice’s factsheet, handbook and cost guidelines for the offences – this documentation is based on a review of successful interventions aimed at crime prevention. 3 PROFILE OF THE PRIORITY CRIMES 3.1 Theft – Steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling Council has chosen to combine these two sub-categories of theft into one strategy as the impact on residents can be similar (in that people and their home/possessions are at risk) and the impact of the proposed strategy will be similar (in that people and their home/possessions will be safer). There are similarities in the way these two subcategories are addressed in relation to crime prevention. Both categories can, therefore, be addressed by the one strategy and suite of actions that represent a more efficient and effective use of funding. Data on incidents of steal from dwelling and incidents of break and enter dwelling are provided in Table 3.1. Steal from dwelling is an emerging issue for Marrickville and while there is a downward trend in incidents of break and enter dwelling, the number and rate is still significantly high enough to warrant attention. There was a significant increase in incidents of steal from dwelling over the five years ending 31 December 2013. No trend is indicated in the data for the two years ending 31 December 2013, as the rate of incidents has been stable. Marrickville has moved into the top quintile and has moved in up in ranking against NSW councils. Marrickville is experiencing a higher rate of incidents of steal from dwelling than wider NSW and other areas with similar characteristics. There was a small decrease in the rate of incidents of break and enter dwelling in the five years ending 31 December 2013. No trend is indicated in the data for the two years ending 31 December 2013, as the rate of incidents has been stable. Marrickville has moved down from the top quintile to the second top quintile for incidents of break and enter dwelling, and has slipped slightly in ranking against all NSW councils. Despite the downturn in incidents of break and enter dwelling Marrickville is still experiencing a higher rate of incidents than wider NSW and other areas with similar characteristics. 1 Handbook on access control and awareness campaigns to prevent residential burglary, Australian Institute of Criminology for NSW Department of Justic 2 Handbook on strategies to prevent alcohol related assault in entertainment precincts, Australian Institute of Criminology for NSW Department of Justice 5 The combined rates of theft offences related to dwellings indicate there is still a need to focus resources on these types of theft. Council can coordinate audits of dwellings, and the public domain around dwellings, in identified hotspots. Council can then implement programs to reduce the level of theft related to dwellings. Table 3.1: Marrickville priorit y sub-categories of theft - number, rate & quintile* trend and ranking - 1July 2009 to 31 December 2013 2009 Steal from dwelling Break and enter dwelling 3.2 2010 2011 2012 2014 206 296 228 259 305 262.0 370.2 282.4 318.0 373.4 4 4 4 3 4 475 555 385 322 445 604.1 694.6 476.7 395.6 544.7 5 4 4 3 4 Five year trend Two year trend Rank 2009 Rank 2013 Up 11.6% Stable 99 50 Down 3.6% Stable 55 60 Assault – non-domestic violence related assault Council has chosen to focus on non-domestic violence related assault because of the number and clusters of alcohol establishments in the LGA where this crime is occurring. Assault is either directly related to alcohol consumption in these areas or to the crowds that are attracted to such areas. Statistics on incidents of non-domestic violence related assault and are provided in Table 3.2. Incidents of non-domestic violence related assaults remain high in comparison to other person related offences in Marrickville (such as domestic assault and sexual assault). Non-domestic violence related assault has consistently recorded the highest number of incidents of all assaults over the previous ten years in Marrickville. Incidents of non-domestic violence related assault are decreasing in NSW and Marrickville. The rate has declined in Marrickville from 1170.0 to 863.0 in the last ten years and was slightly lower than the State average of 880.4 at 30 June 2014. The rate of decline has been faster in Marrickville than in NSW (3.3% pa compared to 1.7%pa). The majority of incidents of non-domestic violence related assault occur in or around alcohol venues as shown in the following data (and on the hotspot map in Section 3): 38% road/street/footpath 25% residential 11% retail/wholesale 6% licensed premises in Marrickville LGA 6% public transport – rail 6 14% other In Newtown 22.5% of incidents of non-domestic violence related assault occur in licensed premises. The decrease in incidents of non-domestic violence related assault may reflect lower rates of alcohol related assault and assaults in pub precincts that have been influenced by the introduction of stronger licensing restrictions, better policing and agreements through the local liquor accords for alcohol establishments in the LGA. 30 June 2013 figures indicate that the rate of non-domestic violence related assault is stable. However, non-domestic violence related assault ranks high among all 61offences recorded for Marrickville, at eighth highest. When ranked against all NSW councils, Marrickville is about mid-way for but Marrickville in consistently in the second highest quintile and has moved from 78th in 2009 to 68th in 2013 the ranking. The high rate of non-domestic violence related assault is likely related to the significant number of alcohol and entertainment premises around King Street and Enmore Road, Newtown, and other smaller clusters. Many alcohol establishments have extended opening hours and social research shows a link between extended trading hours and increased levels of alcohol related violence. Alcohol related assault represents about 40% of non-domestic violence related assaults in Marrickville. This figures rises to more than 80% in the Newtown area. The number and rate of non-domestic violence related assault could, therefore, be influenced by the type of controls that have been introduced in response to high levels of public violence resulting from the clustering of alcohol premises with extended hours and better policing that has been introduced at peak times. The relatively high rate of incidents of non-domestic violence related assault indicates there is still need to focus resources on this type of assault. Council can continue to be involved by imposing conditions of development consent that are endorsed by local police, and by working with police in the identified hot spots on specific programs. 7 Table 3.2 Marrickville incidents of non-domestic violence relate d assault - number, rate and quintile * 1 Jul y 2009 – 31 December 2013 Nondomestic violence related assault 4 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 453 367 431 372 362 576.2 459.6 533.7 457.0 443.1 2 2 2 3 2 Five year trend Two year trend Rank 2009 Rank 2013 Stable Stable 78 68 HOW THE PRIORITY CRIMES WERE SELECTED The priority crimes were selected using the BOCSAR data on incidents that is presented and discussed in Section 2 and the following additional information based on community input, advance BOCSAR data for Marrickville and BOCSAR hotspot maps. 4.1 Theft - steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling Incidents of steal from dwelling were identified as a priority offence by MLAC and NLAC, where people are literally walking in off the street through open, or unlocked, doors and windows. Mail theft and theft of car keys are also raised as a concern by the LACs, and both crimes are a subset of steal from dwelling. Mail theft can lead to fraud and the theft of motor vehicle keys can lead to either theft from or theft of motor vehicles). Most of the residential area of Marrickville is affected by incidents of steal from dwelling (refer to hotspot maps below), and to a lesser extent break and enter dwelling (reflecting the lower number of incidents of this offence). As would be expected the industrial areas in the centre of Marrickville and to the south east of the LGA are not affected by theft from dwellings. The high density hotspots appear to be focussed on the two heavy rail lines and main bus routes (along major roads), and particularly adjacent to Stanmore, Petersham, Dulwich Hill and Marrickville Rail Stations. Smaller hotspots are clearly located around St Peters and Tempe Stations. Also prevalent are the areas of Camperdown and Newtown close to universities and entertainment precincts, and around Marrickville Town Centre that is an active shopping and entertainment precinct. The hotspots cover areas that experience high visitation and are hotspots for other categories of crime. Local police indicate that some offenders use public transport to access and leave the scene of an offence. Marrickville has nine railway stations and is well served by public buses. This may have an influence on why Marrickville experiences a higher rate of theft offences related to dwellings that other areas that have a similar community profile. This may also influence why the hotspots become less dense as they move away from the rail stations and high activity areas. Given the community profile of Marrickville residents – generally higher income, higher employment and higher education than the NSW average – the residential areas here are likely to be relatively quiet during the day, especially on a weekday, 8 and there will be limited casual surveillance. The lack of activity and casual surveillance is one factor that contributes to opportunistic crime such as steal from dwelling and break and enter.3 The profile of offenders indicates that they could come from within Marrickville and other areas. In the circumstances strategies directed at the victims are considered more appropriate as it will be easier for Council to identify them and interact with them. Table 4.1: Summary of incidents of steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling year ending 30 June 2013 Offence Hot spots Priority times Offenders What contributes to rate of incidents Steal from dwelling Almost all of the residential areas are affected (see hotspot map below). 68% during the hours of 6am to 6pm -during the day and corresponding to when many residents are out of the dwelling Not available (assume it would be similar to the data for break and enter dwelling) Premises unsecured, such as windows and doors open, doors left unlocked Lack of access control measures such as weak doors 70% on a week day corresponding to when residents are less likely to be home Break and enter dwelling Covers slightly less of the residential areas and has less high density – probably reflecting the lower rate of break and enter dwelling 66% during the hours of 6am to 6pm 71% on a week day (see comments on steal from dwelling above) Balcony doors left open – particularly in apartments Mail boxes not emptied or not large enough to accommodate mail 88% male 10% < 24 55% 20 - 39 45% Aboriginal 40 NonAboriginal Marrickville LGA has nine rail stations and is well served by public transport A majority of dwellings would be unoccupied for many hours during the day 14% unknown The strategies and actions recommended in relation to steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling will be targeted at hotspots are aimed at a reduction in the number of offences and include: Housing and public domain audits in hot spots using the CPTED principles Subsidised anti-theft devices such as window and door locks Awareness raising for householders 3 9 The recommended programs will support current crime prevention measures by local police, such as assistance to implement CPTED principles at local businesses by the Newtown LAC Crime Prevention Officer. Crim e Maps | BOCSAR 20/ 10/ 14 9:08 AM Incidents of Theft (Steal from dwelling) from Jul 2013 to Jun 2014 Density High Medium Low Crim e Maps | BOCSAR 20/ 10/ 14 9:05 AM Map data Report ©2014 a mapGoogle error http:/ / crim etool.bocsar.nsw.gov.au/ bocsar/ Page 1 of 1 Incidents of Theft (Break & enter dwelling) from Jul 2013 to Jun 2014 Density High Medium Low Map data Report ©2014 a mapGoogle error 4.2 Assault - non-domestic violence related assault http:/ / crim etool.bocsar.nsw.gov.au/ bocsar/ Page 1 of 1 Incidents of non-domestic violence related assault were identified by MLAC and NLAC as a priority offence, specifically in relation to the entertainment precinct around King Street and Enmore Road, Newtown and some of the smaller centres that have pub clusters. Local police have been vigilant in policing the pub precincts and establishing local liquor accords, possibly contributing to the stable rate of incidents experienced in the last five years. Stronger liquor licensing and 10 development controls have been applied when alcohol venues have applied for, and been granted, extended hours. Incidents of non-domestic violence related assault are focused around the entertainment precincts and smaller clusters of pubs that have extended trading hours. The high density hotspot occurs around the Newtown precinct, with a smaller high density hotspot around the hotel cluster in Marrickville.. Other less dense hotspots occur on Marrickville Road near Dulwich Street, Dulwich Hill, Sydenham Station, and New Canterbury Road near Livingstone Road, Petersham. Newtown Rail Station is within the Newtown hotspot and Marrickville Rail Station is located within the Marrickville hotspot. (Refer to hotspot map below) The hotspots cover areas that experience high visitation and are hotspots for other categories of crime. The profile of offenders and victims indicates that they could come from within Marrickville and other areas. In the circumstances strategies directed at offenders and victims are considered appropriate. Strategies and actions will be focused on the in the venues where it is considered most offenders and victims will spend time, and surrounding streets and nearby rail stations. Table 4.2: Summary of incidents of non-domestic violence related assault year ending 30 June 2013 Offence Hot spots Priority times Offenders & Victims What contributes to rate of incidents Non-domestic violence related assault Majority are confined to entertainment precincts on King Street and Enmore Road Newtown, and the vicinity of the intersection of Illawarra and Marrickville Roads Marrickville (see hotspot map below). 53.2% at night Offenders 59.9% weekday 90.7% Male Alcohol related 86.5% at night 45.4% of male offenders aged 40+ Alcohol related 58.9% weekend 40% of female offenders aged between 20 and 29 In Newtown 61.9% of incidents of non-domestic violence related assault in 2012-2013 were alcohol related, in comparison only 39.3% of incidents were alcohol related for the whole of Marrickville 81.3% of offenders non-Aboriginal Others suggested by local police: Marrickville Road near Dulwich Street, Dulwich Hill Victims Sydenham Station 37.7% of female victims aged between 18 and 29 New Canterbury Road near Livingstone Road, Petersham 70% Male 40.6% of male victims aged 40+ Alcohol and the clustering of venues are a factor in the number of incidents – the higher number of incidents occur in areas where there area more venues 94.7% of victims non-Aboriginal 11 Crim e Maps | BOCSAR Density High 20/ 10/ 14 9:03 AM Incidents of Assault (Non-domestic assault) from Jul 2013 to Jun 2014 Medium Low Map data Report ©2014 a mapGoogle error The promotional material and media program is recommended to address nondomestic violence related assault, particularly alcohol related assault and anti-social behaviour that are related to other offences such as malicious damage to property. Newtown LAC has suggested the program and licensing police would hand the filled reusable water bottles out to patrons exiting alcohol establishments on King Street and Enmore Road during their shift. The establishments could also hand out the plastic, reusable bottles to encourage patrons to intersperse their alcoholic drinks with water and have water fountains on the premises to enable refilling. The messages and graphics (that could be developed by local community groups and agencies) would encourage patrons to be mindful about their drinking and social behaviour. http:/ / crim etool.bocsar.nsw.gov.au/ bocsar/ Page 1 of 1 The recommended program would support current crime prevention by local police that include increased patrols in alcohol precincts during peak periods. 12 5 SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS: The hotspot locations identified for non-domestic violence related assault and steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling offences are centred on train stations and their surrounding areas. In particular Marrickville and Newtown Rail Stations and nearby streets: Illawarra Road, Marrickville Road, Enmore Road and King Street. The following analysis has, therefore, been undertaken on these locations. 5.1 Newtown Station Newtown Station is located on the boundary of Marrickville, within the City of Sydney Local Government Area, and people in Marrickville use it regularly. Ticket access entry/exit gates control access to the platforms and the tracks are fully fenced. There is CCTV surveillance of the entrance and exit and natural surveillance from overlooking apartment buildings, the café (with outdoor seating) at the entrance, the ticket officer, the patrolling transport officers (from time to time) and street lighting. The train lines are located below street level and can’t be seen from the street. The limits of the station defined through the use of unified tiling and fencing. The space management within this defined area results in a well-kept appearance, with no litter or graffiti at the entrance to the station or on the platform. There is, however, graffiti on the fencing opposite the platform. Overall the feeling at the station was very orderly and well maintained as shown in the following photos. The station has been redeveloped in recent years but there is no data available yet as to whether improvements have had an impact on safety and in particular incidents of offences recorded in and around the station. The area around the station is one where a high rate of incidents of non-domestic violence related offences are committed. Many of these incidents are related to nearby alcohol establishments that are operating with extended hours, and not necessarily related to the station. 5.2 Marrickville Station Marrickville Station is located within the Marrickville LGA and used regularly by people in Marrickville. Access to the station platforms is not controlled and is gained at street level from Station Street, and via stairs from Illawarra Road. The tracks are fully fenced. There is CCTV surveillance of the entrance/exit and platforms, but limited natural surveillance with only one shop and a café on the corner of Station Street. The rest of Station Street contains closed shops and the back of residential properties fenced with 1.8m high fences. The train lines are located below the street level of Illawarra Road but at grade with Station Street and other surrounding streets, so that natural surveillance of the platforms is limited. Apartment buildings being developed around the station may increase natural surveillance of the station platforms. The station and platforms have emergency help points but no transport officers on site. It is not known how often transport security officers and Police patrol the station and surrounds. The limits of the station are defined through the use of low rail fencing. The space management within this defined area results in a well-kept appearance, with no litter 13 or graffiti at the entrance to the station or on the platform. There is, however, graffiti on the fencing opposite the platform and on the fences at the rear of nearby residential properties and the area outside the station on Station Street is not an attractive area. There are plans to redevelop Marrickville Station and provide ticket entry/exit gates and lift access. It is not know when these will be implemented. The area around the station is one where a high rate of non-domestic violence related assault, theft and steal from person are recorded. 5.3 King Street and Enmore Road King Street and Enmore Road have a large number of small retail businesses. There also cafés and restaurants, some of which provide outdoor seating. There are some vacant business premises. There is a large amount of graffiti that is typically found away from the busy main roads, along side streets and lanes in the residential areas adjacent to the business areas. There are also a few walls with large street art pieces. The mall on King Street next to the station was fitted with CCTV and many of its shops displayed CCTV signage. Some of the alcohol premises have CCTV and security guards at night. However, other areas of King Street and Enmore Road did not appear to be equipped with CCTV. 5.4 Illawarra Road and Marrickville Road Illawarra Road and Marrickville Road have a similar proportion of shops, cafés and restaurants to King Street and Enmore Road, but less pubs. The pubs are operating extended hours. The amount of graffiti is considerably less and the amount of outdoor benches on the streets is comparatively higher. 14 6 STAKEHOLDERS 6.1 Safety issues identified by local businesses and community organisations There is a ‘fear of crime’ in general, especially in Newtown and South Marrickville. Media stories of crime such as bag snatches and shootings fuel fear. Inadequate street lighting is also leading to a fear of crime at night particularly at bus stops and railway stations. South Marrickville including Marrickville station is an area in need of safety policy implementation. Illawarra Road near Marrickville Station on weekend evenings is a concern due to numbers of intoxicated people in this area. The issue of public intoxication was also raised as a concern for Crystal Street, Petersham. Concerns for disadvantaged young people in Marrickville who tend to have difficulties engaging with the local community, education and training. There are concerns for young people around social media. These concerns centre on cyber-bullying as well as the legal implications of social media activity including uploading photos. There is concern as to how these legal implications can impact on their future. Domestic violence particularly against women and children is a concern for key community support organisations in Marrickville. Road safety is a concern specifically the pedestrian crossing on West St, Lewisham near Petersham Park and Parramatta Road. It is difficult to see pedestrians at this crossing and this can cause a significant number of accidents. Other road safety issues include uneven footpaths and young cyclists not sharing footpaths. Suggestions on ways to improve safety in Marrickville Community events such as the Saturday markets in Newtown increase a feeling of connectedness. Ongoing funding is needed to support growth in the services for young people in the area. Currently funding is needed to sustain projects that provide after hours entertainment. More education is required in schools around respectful relationships and alcohol and drug use earlier in life. There is a call for realistic drug and alcohol education such as being given information on how to drink or take drugs safely as well as what to do in the event of a drug and alcohol related emergency. A campaign to encourage young cyclists to use a bell when on the footpaths and in parks. Implement Neighbourhood Watch groups. 15 6.2 Securing your home whether at home or out by being aware and proactive about safety. Including using gates and shutters to prevent a break-in. Employing security guards to the outside of licensed premises as well as police patrols in car parks and transport premises are viewed as beneficial and make the community feel safer. Feedback on the draft Crime Prevention Strategy – LACs and SIM Committee Members Stealing of pushbikes has become an issue as more and more people are riding bikes to work, shops and places of education. People are not using adequate locking devices – chains can be easily cut with a pair of bolt cutters and does not take long. The bolt cutters can be carried in a backpack. D locks are more effective. An education program around the use of D locks in preference to bike chains may be useful. Insurance statistics may help determine a narrower area of where the risk is. Involvement in White Ribbon day is one way of addressing domestic violence assault - local agencies and communities can participate. Aboriginal victim support group is one way of building capacity of victims to resist domestic violence related assault. Surveillance cameras in strategic locations, such as the area around Newtown Station and the Hub, the rail underpass at Petersham Station and at the top of the stairs at Marrickville Station would be useful in tracking the movements of offenders. An analysis on suburb-by-suburb and even at street level would enable Council to pinpoint and focus on the critical hot spots and sections of the community with more direct intervention. The impact of traffic, which is significantly high in Marrickville, is not canvassed in the Strategy. This has a major impact on personal safety particularly for older residents that may have dementia, have hearing difficulty or just be slow. Need to speak to children in schools to address (prevent) drug problems and should involve local police. Need to work across Divisions of Council to get a coordinated approach, especially with crimes such as graffiti, theft encouraged by environmental design and traffic safety. Police youth liaison officer to work with CDAT on programs for young drug offenders Talks on a range of topics with older people in CALD communities has been successful – could consider a talk around safety from crime – particularly fraud. Community Affair is a good way of distributing information to a wide range of people and agencies. Information sharing among agencies is useful to know what offenders have been released into the community. Council could run a “crime prevention day’ similar to ‘white ribbon day’. A hotline for gullible and lonely people may help avoid scams and fraud for some people. 16 7 MONITORING AND EVALUATING The key performance indicators of the projects will be the changes in the number of criminal incidents in the targeted area or in the target population. These rates will be monitored at regular intervals throughout the projects’ implementation. The strategies will also be monitored in financial terms so as to keep within a specified budget. Responsibility for the monitoring and evaluating of the projects will be with Marrickville Council primarily with the Community Safety Officer in charge of the projects. Agreement from other relevant agencies regarding access to data will also be negotiated. Both NLAC and MLAC will be negotiated with to provide data on crime levels within the specific geographic area where the projects are being conducted. The timeframes for each of the projects will be at one, two and five years; this is because the effects of these projects should be seen for a number of years even after the project has been completed. Reviewing these projects after six months or one year allows Council and other stakeholders to address issues that may be occurring and make any necessary changes to ensure the ongoing success of the projects. As this plan and these projects have been founded upon the statistics published by BOCSAR, the selected timeframes will give a good comparison between current and previous data from BOCSAR, as BOCSAR crime trends are compared both as a two year and a five year trend. This five year review will also coincide with the review of Marrickville’s Community Safety Plan (2019-2023). 7.1 Evaluation and data collection Reported crime statistics in the target location will be compared against state wide trends and trends in neighbouring areas. If the target offence has historically occurred during particular times of day/year appropriate comparative data will be used. Situational crime prevention approaches such as CPTED and awareness campaigns will be evaluated by the difference in criminal incidents in the target site in comparison to criminal incidents in a site within the hot spot that is not taking part in the project (e.g. control site). Data will also be collected from residents and users of the target areas regarding their opinions about the project focussing on comparing their feelings of safety in the area before and after the implementation of the project. Research will be conducted throughout the process of the project to monitor demographic, land use and activity changes to the target areas to ensure the correlation between crime changes and the implemented project. Police data will also be used to guarantee no displacement of offending or an increase in another offence type in the target location. 17 8 CRIME PREVENTION ACTION PLAN Target Offence: Steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling/other theft Project: Audits of dwellings and public domain in hotspots with recommendations for improvement and subsidised provision of anti-theft devices in conjunction with a community awareness campaign through local media and social media Rationale: Audits, recommendations and security devices will raise awareness of individual householders to improve their crime prevention actions A media campaign through community radio, local press and social media will reach a wide local audience Signage in signage in strategic locations will act as a constant reminder to lock doors and windows and maintain surveillance Objective: Reduce incidents of steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling by 10% over the next two years (1July 2015 to 30 June 2017) Lead Agency and Partners: Marrickville Council, MLAC, NLAC Expected Outcome: Reduction in the area and density of hotspots over the two year period (1 July 2015 to 30 June 2017) Sustained reduction of 10% in incidents of steal from dwelling/break and enter dwelling Action Housing and public domain audits in hotspots using the CPTED principles - Identify security and surveillance weaknesses and provide eligible households with subsidies to install security devices (such as door and window locks) Performance measures Number of audits undertaken Time frames Number of recommendations implemented Six months to finalise audits & provide advice Number of dwellings advised to fit security devices Review in six & twelve months Number of dwellings that improve surveillance and outdoor security (such as bin location) Funding required $25 000 to employ project officer one day per week for 12 months Milestones Audits undertaken Advice provided to householders Agreement to fit devices as advised Security device subsidies: $100 x 100 dwellings = $10 000 Agreement to improve surveillance 18 Action Performance measures Time frames Funding required Milestones Six months to distribute and fit devices – concurrent with audits Installation: 1 hour at $50 x 100 dwellings = $5000 All security devices fitted No cost – Council to supply staff time Initial campaign undertaken Subsidised devices to dwellings that have been audited 100 dwellings fitted with security devices Undertake media campaign to raise community awareness Number of broadcasts, articles, tweets, views and shares Monitor and record events weekly Number of written feedback and responses Provide a quarterly report Target Offence: Non-domestic violence related assault Project: Distribution of promotional material at alcohol and entertainment venues and on nearby streets. Licensing police will distribute paper cups or reusable plastic bottles with water and message printed on them – reusable plastic bottles will be given to certain licensed premises to encourage the consumption of water and other non-alcoholic beverages. The plastic bottles will be printed with messages to remind patrons of the dangers of intoxication and anti-social behaviour. Target peak periods around alcohol and entertainment hotspots Rationale: The increase in the availability of water and non-alcoholic beverages during the later hours of the evening at licensed premises combined with the reminders of patron responsibilities and penalties that apply for breaches of licensing and criminal laws should help to reduce alcohol consumption at these times. This should in turn reduce alcohol related and crowd related violence in and around these premises. The reminders printed on the cups should also act as a reminder for the staff at these premises to utilise and abide by their RSA training. This project relates to the special conditions imposed on some venues by the Liquor Act 2007. Objective: Reduce incidents of non-domestic violence related assault by 10% over the next two years (1 July 2015 to 30 June 2017) Lead Agency and Partners: Council, NLAC, Newtown Liquor Accord, Newtown Local Businesses (Venue management task group). Expected Outcome: Reduction in the area and density of hotspots over the two year period (1 July 2015 to 30 June 2017) Sustained reduction of 10% in incidents of non-domestic violence related assault 19 Action Agree on message content and obtain materials Performance measures Required promotional materials obtained on time and within budget Time frames Number of broadcasts, articles, tweets, views and shares Milestones Three months 5 000 500ml plastic bottles x $1.00 each = $5000 Promotional materials produced and delivered to NLAC From beginning of second month No cost – Council to supply staff time Initial campaign undertaken No additional cost for police on duty All promotional material distributed Agreement of all partners on messages Undertake media campaign to raise victim and offender awareness Funding required Activity each month for six months Feedback from police Response from patrons recorded Distribute promotional materials and talk with patrons Number of venues covered Number of streets and lanes covered Monthly throughout campaign Weekly form beginning of fourth month to end of sixth month Council staff time to observe, monitor and report 100 hours at $50 per hour = $5000 20