FACTORS INFLUENCING STUDENT’S CHOICE OF WEBSITES (94/100)


Interested in cinema
Academical/Professional value UNLIKE websites about music/sport.
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (http://www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
Everyday user for more than three years. LONG-STANDING,
REGULAR CUSTOMER.
-
Interesting for academical/hobby purposes. NEW AND POSSIBLY
REGULAR CUSTOMER.
-
Submitted enquiries for new features and movies to the database.
INVOLVEMENT.
-
Young website, potentially magnificent, great purpose and scope.
DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH.
-
Useful, good quality. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
-
Completely different from any movie database sites. PIONEERING.
-
ORIGINALITY and special features provided.
-
Opportunity to CONNECT with other users with my same likes.
-
Rating movies, reviews: cinephile SATISFACTION.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE WEBSITES: THEIR AIMS AND AUDIENCE (234/250)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
-
Movie database with information and features about latest releases
for all visitors, plus exciting extra features for registered users.
-
Created by Pablo Kurt and a group of individuals.
-
Aimed to be the most accurate, customized and affinity-based
system of recommendation of movies ever created.
-
Is this a web site for movie goers? Of course.
-
Is this a web site for intellectual Ingmar Bergman-fans? Sure.
-
Is this a web site for my kids? Absolutely: This web site is rated G.
-
Is this a web site for my DVD addict roommate? You betcha.*
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
Website dedicated to European cinema. A specific programming to
of preservation of heritage (early) cinema thanks to a network of 28
film archives. **
-
Created by Lobster, a company long-time specialised in the subject,
partnered with European film libraries, sustained with EU funds .
-
Rediscover the childhood of cinema! Films gathered by amateurs,
collectors and archives, rescued from being eaten into or
decomposed.
-
Collection / Library of early movies for online streaming.
Downloading not possible (as a result of an agreement made with
participating film libraries).
-
The rights are only handed over by film libraries for private, strictly
non-commercial showings (a negotiation is required even for
showing in a school or non profit organisation).
-
Therefore, relatively small audience: institutions, film librarians,
investigators, curators, universities and cinephiles of a high
profile.
*Source: www.filmaffinity.com
**Source: www.europafilmtreasures.eu
DESCRIPTION OF THE CRITERIA AND TOOLS/METHODS AVAILABLE FOR EVALUATION (155/150)
CRITERIA: Information Architecture for the Web (Blackboard)
OVERALL IMPRESSIONS
Purpose, audience and
sponsorship clear?
TOOLS/METHODS FOR EVALUATION (ONLY ENTRY PAGES):
http://www.avangate.com/articles/usability-tools_83.htm, Blackboard
CONTENT ASPECTS
DESIGN ASPECTS
Accurate, high quality content, meaningful to the targeted audience?
Effective & visually appealing entry page?
Spell check: http://www.spellcheck.net/cgi-bin/spell.exe
Consistent "look and feel" throughout?
Genuine, authentic, unique resources?
Fonts?
Depth/mix of formats in contents, matching the varied audience needs?
Color check: based in length of words and sentences.
http://www.accesskeys.org/tools/color-contrast.html
Needs of the users addressed?
Website appealing for them?
Model for other web
developers?
Content logically organized?
Readability: http://juicystudio.com/services/readability.php
Graphic design aligned with purpose and audience?
NAVIGATION & USABILITY ASPECTS
MAINTENANCE / CONTENT ENHANCEMENTS
LIBRARY-SPECIFIC RESOURCES
Effective navigation?
Updated & Revised? Reflected in the entry page?
Blogs?
User-friendly?
About site?
Communications?
Image analyser: http://juicystudio.com/services/image.php
Award information?
Electronic Databases?
W3C coding validator (Markup Validation Service): http://validator.w3.org/
Contact info?
Online Catalog?
Accessibility?
WAVE: http://wave.webaim.org/
ETRE http://www.etre.com/tools/accessibilitycheck/
Firefox add-on 1.5.58.0: https://fae.cita.uiuc.edu/report/127149c7e2da2731/
TAW3 0.9.7 http://www.tawdis.net/
Educational materials?
Online Clubs and connections?
Feedback opportunities?
Reference resources?
Speed tester: http://www.linkvendor.com/seotools/speedtester.html
Multimedia resources?
FAQs?
EVALUATION OF THE WEBSITES AND COMPARISON USING CRITERIA IDENTIFIED (860/600)
OVERALL IMPRESSIONS (129)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
First glance: all about cinema. All the audiences represented through
multiple links to wide range of contents.
-
Choose - Discover - Watch: tidy summary addressing the aims of
the website.
-
Sponsors identified by eye-catching Flash images advertising new
Hollywood releases.
-
Simple display of features through the navigation bar.
-
Visitor prompted to watch a movie, with easy access at free cost.
-
Tidy and attractive to a new user for amount and quality of content
featured in links.
-
No registration needed, but access to newsletter provided.
-
User-oriented site, with many features for registered users.
-
Young site with not many contents, but perfectly distributed. Goes
like a clockwork.
-
Included among the TOP 100 UNDISCOVERED WEBSITES OF
THE YEAR 2004 by PC Magazine.
CONTENT ASPECTS (208)
Both are content-oriented websites.
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
Data volume: 175.61 kB
-
Data volume: 22.72 kB
-
All visitors:
-
All visitors have access to:
-

Launch searches by category.

Film archives, movies in collection, documentation.

Read reviews from users/professionals.

Documentation is varied and accurate, but scarce:

Latest releases (information, watch trailers...)

DVD online shop

Ranking lists, lists of awarded movies and many other
features.
Registered users find their links at the top of the left side menu.
There they can:

Rate movies.

Check friends’ and soul-mates last ratings
recommendations. Contact them. (STAND-OUT!)

Update lists.

These features really encourage regular visitors. In my
experience, I check it everyday.
and
-
Spell check successful.
-
Incoherent or missing information: a few details, some rare movies
(ongoing updates).
-
Distribution of contents: very amusing. Perhaps too much content.







Documentary resources (very few).
Current debates (only two).
Original music (accurate).
Network (only a few links provided).
Online shops (of each of the archives).
Downloads (empty).
Glossary (almost empty).
-
Spell check successful.
-
Very young site (April 2008), therefore very few contents, but subject
to enhancement.
-
Exceptional resources, treasures as proclaimed.
-
Distribution of contents: simple as needed.
DESIGN ASPECTS (152)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
Branding linkage by its characteristic slogan.
-
Branding linkage by a clever slogan.
-
Consistent layout and look throughout. Standard sections make it
recognisable. Everyday user feels like home.
-
Minimal design, standard all throughout. Simplicity prevails.
-
Fonts: not impressive but effective enough.
-
Design is visually appealing throughout, but very serious, given the
prevalence of the content over the design.
-
Color check: 2.08% below recommendations in difference and
brightness. Only failure, at the headings.
-
Readability: poor.
-
Fonts: not specially beautiful, and too small.
-
Color check: around 20.5% below recommended standard in color
difference (fore-background). Brightness meets standard.

Gunning Fog index: 12.21
Readability: good.

Flesh-Kincaid Grade index: 8.12

Gunning Fog index (6.16) and

Flesch Reading Ease index: 41.21/100.

Flesh-Kincaid Grade index (3.69) index reflect the number of
years of schooling needed to understand content.

Flesch Reading Ease index: 73.21/100.
-
NAVIGATION & USABILITY ASPECTS (222)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
User-friendly, straightforward: link steps -> beginner users.
-
User-friendly: extremely easy for navigation.
-
Links anchored in the left side menu ensure retrievals and ease up
navigation.
-
Links: effective and efficient, except those empty.
-
Image analysis: width/height, alternate text or long descriptions seldom
provided, but images efficiently displayed.
Image analysis: width/height rarely provided, alternate text or long
descriptions more frequent.
-
Reported errors:
-
Reported errors:
Category




-
layout tables with no
header
alternate text in images
missing
very small text
invalid attributes
Firefox FAE-DHTML report:
Speed tester:


Average: 2.1s
Modem: 0.84
Errors – Errors –
Warnings
Must fix Should fix
Coding quality
188
2
Acc. WAVE
106
-
Acc. ETRE
0
218
2
Acc. TAW3
105
359
55
Category
% Pass


Category
empty links
invalid attributes
-
Firefox FAE-DHTML report:
-
Speed tester:
Errors – Errors –
Warnings
Must fix Should fix
Coding quality
38
35
WAVE
11
-
ETRE
1
18
6
TAW3
5
13
9
Category
% Pass
% Fail
Navigation &
Orientation
80
11 (7 warn)
Text Equivalents
50
50
Scripting
75
25
Styling
100
0
HTML Standards
100
0
% Fail
Navigation &
Orientation
69
19 (11 warn)
Text Equivalents
75
25
Scripting
100
0
Styling
33
66
HTML Standards
50
50


Average: 1.2s
Modem: 0.47
MAINTENANCE AND CONTENT ENHANCEMENTS (102)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
New releases and news from the industry updates in entry page.
-
News and new films highlighted. What’s on: poor updating.
-
DB updates daily with old rare movies (savvy users).
-
Partners, FAQ, Contact Us, Terms of use: present, useful.
-
Enhancements this year: message service, new rating tours,
favourite reviews, links to media whose reviews are included.
-
Enhancements this year: programming for young audiences.
-
Job opportunities offered.
-
ABOUT site accessible, one award reported.
-
Multimedia resources: main content of the site.
-
Contact INFO to make enquiries/suggestions. FAQs listed.
-
Trailers of new commercial releases available.
LIBRARY-SPECIFIC RESOURCES (43)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
No blogs, newsletter or Facebook.
-
Blog, newsletter, Facebook featured.
-
Community-oriented (soul-mates).
-
Online catalog: main content.
-
Awarded films listed, databases updated but not downloadable in
any file format.
-
References (film archives) listed and linked.
-
References not listed.
SUGGESTIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT OF THE WEBSITES AS APPROPIATE (192/400 words)
FILMAFFINITY (www.filmaffinity.com)
-
Content:
-
-
-
-
Content:
An improvement is clearly needed, especially in Documentation
(history of early cinema, biographies, stories about loose and
preservation of particular films or archives...).
New features and community features (i.e. stats/ratings by filmmaker).

More frequent updates.
More information about the industry.

Better depiction of the works of Lobster (site’s author).
Check-compare DB with reliable sources: massive update if
possible, correct mistakes.

Design:

-



EUROPA FILM TREASURES (www.europafilmtreasures.eu)
-
Bigger fonts, colour difference.
Navigation&Technical:

Coding optimisation.

Lists: improve navigation.
-
Maintenance / Content enhancements:

Cinema quizzes.

Trailers of old movies, making-ofs.
-
Design:

Colour brightening.

More appealing: nicer pictures, fonts, background, especially in
entry page.
Navigation&Technical:

No more empty links.

Sitemap in the navigation bar.
Maintenance / Content enhancements:

More cinema quizzes.

More links to companies, archives, universities, and to works of
professionals in the subject.
Library-specific resources:

Newsletter with updates, Facebook.

Posters: enhancement of quality.

Improvement of the online shop.

More documents (legal, manifests, treatises, personal letters).

Subscription to cinema magazines.

Subscription to cinema magazines.
-
Library-specific resources:
st
INTRODUCING MULTIMEDIA – 1 ASSIGNMENT
EVALUATION OF WEBSITES
Jose Carlos Cañizares-Gaztelu