 Truman presented a proposal to the
Congress earlier in the election year, which would guarantee the rights of blacks, which created the rift in the Democratic Party.
 During the Democratic Convention, a total of 35 delegates (all of Mississippi and half of Alabama) walked out.
 The Democratic Party ticket was split, and out emerged the States Rights Democratic
Party and the Progressive Party


“In 1948, the Democrats and Republicans only received only 92% of the electoral votes. This situation was due to a bolt form the Democratic National Convention of delegates form several southern states who protested the strong civil rights plank in the Democratic platform. These delegates formed a States’ Rights or
“Dixiecrat” party which received the 38 electoral votes of Alabama, Louisiana,
Mississippi, South Carolina, and one vote from Tennessee,” (Porter & Johnson, 419).



Widely believed that the fractionalization of the Democratic Party would essentially cause Democrats to concede the race to the Republicans.
Yet the Dixiecrat revolt actually helped solidify for Truman the northern urban,
African American coalition, it allowed him to duck the old claim by liberals and African
American leaders that the Democratic party was led by Southern racists.
 The split gave Truman the appearance of holding the party’s center

 World Peace Party
 Found fault in the presidential administration of the Truman presidency.
 Held the Truman administration primarily responsible for the Cold War and organized the Progressive Citizens of America in 1947
 The delegates, composed of pacifists, reformers, New Dealers, and a few
American Stalinists) selected Henry
Wallace to run for President

 The party platform rejected the Marshall
Plan for European economic recovery and the Truman
Doctrine of containment and urged negotiations with Russia to end the
Cold War
 Yet it is a well known fact that the American voter does not vote on foreign policy and issues



Many American liberals believed that Truman had turned his back on the New Deal, the Roosevelt legacy, and the New Dealers themselves.
 As Roosevelt’s Secretary of Agriculture from 1933-1940,
Wallace was considered one of the primary innovators of the New Deal programs. He was even chosen as the Vice president in 1940, but was dropped during the 1940 campaign in favor of the less controversial Truman.
During the summer of 1947, Wallace was very prominent, and seemed to be a serious candidate for the presidency.
 Received support from Labor groups, middle class liberals, farmers, northern African Americans, and communists (who eventually became the his most visible supporters, and led to a decline in support from other sectors of his supporters, especially labor).




The States Rights Democratic Party disagreement with the Democratic Party mostly stemmed from civil rights disagreements.
 Did not want a civil rights supporter to be elected
Nominated South Carolina governor J. Strom
Thurmond
Hoped that there would be a big enough split to cause the election to be thrown into the
House of Representatives and that the vote of the South would swing the balloting to an opponent of civil rights legislation.



Candidacy based upon a split from the
Democratic party in regards to opposition to federal intervention in regards to segregation legislation and practices.
Fully believed and supported the southern segregation laws, which disenfranchised many blacks and poor whites.



During the Republican
Convention held in Philadelphia, voters of the Republican party selected New York Governor
Thomas E. Dewey
 Many Republicans actually wanted Dwight Eisenhower to carry the Republican ticket, but his political affiliation was not known at the time, and he refused the nomination (some believe his refusal was a sign a loyalty to his friend Truman).
The party platform contained many of Republican party leader
Senator Robert Taft objectives .
 Included support of public housing, need for public health, farm programs, and conservation of natural resources.

 Also worked to build a support coalition that would include organized labor, moderate liberals, and northern urban
African Americans
 The campaign strategy was to aggressively satisfy each of these groups, that by granting specific concessions they would earn their votes
 Sought to move to the left and focus on building a coalition of groups that centered on organized labor and northern African Americans

 Instead of aiming his campaign attack at the defected members of the Democratic
Party or his Republican opponent, Dewey,
Truman went after the 80 th Congress
 With the country currently in the mist of a labor strife, a rise in the cost of living and taxes during the Cold War
 Truman called Congress back for an early session before the election in an effort to fix some of the economic problems.
○ Called on Congress to increase the minimum wage, broaden the Social Security system, and establish a national health care system.



Gallop poll early in 1948 reported that the approval rating for the job Truman had done as a president was at 36%
The Gallup, Roper, and Crossley polls all predicted that Dewey would defeat Truman by a significant margin, but in fact, just the opposite happened.
 The Crossley, Gallup, and Roper organizations all used quota sampling . Each interviewer was assigned a specified number of subjects to interview.
Moreover, the interviewer was required to interview specified numbers of subjects in various categories, based on residential area, sex, age, race, economic status, and other variables.

Candidate Crossley Gallup Roper
Truman
Dewey
Others
45
50
5
44
50
6
38
53
9
Election
Results
50
45
5


The Chicago Tribune felt so confident in the polls that the night of the election, the paper went ahead and printed the following morning's edition with a banner headline that Dewey had defeated Truman.
What went wrong? Outside of the quota constraints, each interviewer was free to pick his subjects any way that he pleased. It is now generally accepted that this freedom of choice created selection bias in favor of Dewey. At the time, evidently, republicans were slightly easier to find and interview than democrats.
 Also stopped polling a week prior to the election, essentially missing the
American voters shift away from the third parties back to the major parties.

The Progressive
Landscape
From New York, Wallace received 8.25% of the popular vote
-California, 4.73%
-North Dakota, 3.80%
-Washington, 3.50%
-Montana, 3.26%

Presidential election results map. Blue denotes states won by Truman/Barkley; Red notes those won by
Dewey/Warren; Orange denotes those won by Thurmond/Wright (including a faithless elector in Tennessee ). Numbers indicate the number of electoral votes allotted to each state.





1. Party Mandate

FALSE
During the 1946 elections, the voting of the American people indicated a shift back to the right, more conservative policies.
2. Contest

FALSE
Within the Democratic Party there was contestation from both sides of the party, from the left (Progressives) and the right (Dixiecrats)
3.Incumbency

TRUE
The incumbent, Truman, was the sitting president
4.Third Party

FALSE
There was a strong third party vying for votes, the States
Rights Democratic Party earned 2.41% of the popular vote and 39 electoral votes.




5. Sort Term Economy TRUE
 The recession of 1948-1949 started in November of 1948, and the economy was actually experiencing a post war boom
6.Long term economy FALSE
 Post World War II, Truman was the first president tasked with transitioning the nation into a peacetime economy, so during his first term there was a negative growth.
7. Policy Change

FALSE
The Marshall Plan was a foreign policy and the Executive Order
9981, which abolished segregation in the military could be seen as only as small part of the greater civil rights package that he presented in 1948, but was not really considered until later in his second term.

 8. Social Unrest TRUE
 There is no sustained social unrest during the term
 9. Scandal TRUE
 The incumbent administration is untainted by major scandal
 10. Foreign/ military failure TRUE
 Although he did struggle through the Korean
War, his was overconfident in the ability of the military to quickly achieve military in Korea




11. Foreign/ military success TRUE
 Truman successfully led the United States out of
World War II.
12.Incumbent charisma TRUE
 On the campaign trail one of the biggest noted difference between Dewey and Truman, was their charismatic qualities. Truman came off as much more relatable to the people when he took his cross country campaign tour.
13. Challenger charisma

TRUE
As noted above, Dewey’s personality was much more reserved and constrained.

 The Republican Convention was the first convention to be televised
 The failure among pollsters, most notably Gallop, Roper, and Crossley, to predict the winner caused a reform in polling techniques.

 One of the biggest reasons the Republican party is believed to have lost the
1948 election was due to overconfidence.
 Their acceptance of the
1946 midterm elections in which Republicans won dominantly in addition to Dewey’ s conservative campaign strategy which was premised on avoidance of mistakes.

Truman’s ability to build support among a broad urban-liberal-black-labor coalition aided his victory.