Operationalising the Multipurpose Cash Grant: A toolkit IASC Geneva, November 20th, 2015 With the support of: Enhanced Response Capacity Grant Stream 1: Operationalising the MPG Vulnerability and Targeting MPG Toolkit Coordination Information management Deployments Stream 1: Understanding the Protection Implications of Cash Analysis and M&E Tools Evidence Deployments The Toolkit: What, Why and How • An MPG is a transfer (either regular or one-off) corresponding to the amount of money a household needs to cover, fully or partially, a set of basic and/or recovery needs. • MPGs are by definition unrestricted cash transfers. • The MPG will contribute to meeting survival or basic needs, but can also include other oneoff/recovery needs. Introduction • Why Multipurpose Cash Grants? • What, why and for whom this toolkit? R e s p o n s e D e s i g n a n d P l a n What is the impact of the crisis How will we phase out Who needs what Can it be acquired locally by paying for it How and what will we monitor How will we work with government Programme Implementation Needs Assessment How much (quantities and cost) S i t u a t i o n & To whom will we give it Can we deliver cash Coordination and Preparedness How will we give it (together) Programme Design Operational Feasibility What are the protectionrelated risks and benefits What does the government think How much will we give Grant Design What it the specific objective How will cash needs change over time and space What can people make up on their own Do we have the capacity to do our part What other assistance is being provided R e s p o n s e A n a l y s i s R e s p o n s e D e s i g n a n d P l a n How will we phase out What is the impact of the crisis Who needs what Can it be acquired locally by paying for it How and what will we monitor How will we work with government Programme Implementation Needs Assessment How much (quantities and cost) S i t u a t i o n & To whom will we give it Can we deliver cash How will we give it (together) What are the protectionrelated risks and benefits Programme Design Operational Feasibility What does the government think How much will we give Grant Design What it the specific objective How will cash needs change over time and space What can people make up on their own Do we have the capacity to do our part What other assistance is being provided R e s p o n s e A n a l y s i s Situation & Response Analysis • What it is Situation Analysis Operational Feasibility Needs Assessment Protection Risks/Benefits Market Situation Analysis In-depth Multi-sector Market Assessment Delivery mechanisms Vulnerability Assessment Political feasibility Cost of surviving (MEB) Organizational Capacity So what’s different? Challenges • Challenges ways of working • Multi-sectoral not siloed • Priorities not sectors Solutions • Collaborate across sectors and agencies • Be pragmatic • Iterate Next steps • For needs assessment – Vulnerability assessment – The cost of surviving/living or Minimum Expenditure Basket • For operational feasibility – Multi-sector market assessments – Protection risks and benefits analysis Living in a warehouse Immediate Effect Immediate Cause (Why?) Secondary Cause (Why?) Tertiary Cause (Why?) Can’t afford rent Lack of cheap housing options Discrimination by landlords Lack of cash Unfinished buildings because of local economic depression Perception that whites can’t be trusted No working adults Illegal to work Part 1.2 Vulnerability Analysis from a crisis-specific socio-economic perspective Minimum Expenditure Basket • Defined as what a household needs and its average cost over time. • The MPG will contribute to meeting the MEB, but can also include other oneoff/recovery needs. Part 1.3 Multi-Sector Market Assessment • • • • What is a market? Why market assessment? What is a multi-sector market assessment? How to do a multi-sector market assessment? Situation Analysis Operational Feasibility Needs Assessment Protection Risks/Benefits Market Situation Analysis In-depth Multi-sector Market Assessment Delivery mechanisms Vulnerability Assessment Political feasibility Cost of surviving (MEB) Organizational Capacity MULTIPURPOSE CASH GRANT Water and Sanitation Livelihoods Shelter Core relief items Protection Health Food Security Education PART 2. TRANSFER DESIGN R e s p o n s e D e s i g n a n d P l a n How will we phase out What is the impact of the crisis Who needs what Can it be acquired locally by paying for it How and what will we monitor How will we work with government Programme Implementation Needs Assessment How much (quantities and cost) S i t u a t i o n & To whom will we give it Can we deliver cash How will we give it (together) What are the protectionrelated risks and benefits Programme Design Operational Feasibility What does the government think How much will we give Grant Design What it the specific objective How will cash needs change over time and space What can people make up on their own Do we have the capacity to do our part What other assistance is being provided R e s p o n s e A n a l y s i s December Prices November January February MEB Predictable monthly household needs (rent, food, sanitation and hygiene items) October March Unpredictable shocks to income/consumption (population movements, policy changes) Predictable regular and one-off seasonal needs (seeds and tools, school supplies, winter clothes, winter energy costs, dry season water costs) Cash needs September April August Crisis or recovery sector-specific needs (shelter materials, livelihood inputs, emergency medical care) July June May Availability MPG Transfer Value 700.00 600.00 500.00 Education GAP 400.00 300.00 Communication Transportation MEB 200.00 Health Clothes Water WASH 100.00 Shelter (rent) 0.00 Food Seeds/Tools (one off) 100.00 200.00 Needs Available 22 PART 3. RESPONSE DESIGN AND PLANNING R e s p o n s e D e s i g n a n d P l a n How will we phase out What is the impact of the crisis Who needs what Can it be acquired locally by paying for it How and what will we monitor How will we work with government Programme Implementation Needs Assessment How much (quantities and cost) S i t u a t i o n & To whom will we give it Can we deliver cash How will we give it (together) What are the protectionrelated risks and benefits Programme Design Operational Feasibility What does the government think How much will we give Grant Design What it the specific objective How will cash needs change over time and space What can people make up on their own Do we have the capacity to do our part What other assistance is being provided R e s p o n s e A n a l y s i s 1) Context & programme objectives 2) Key stakeholders' roles and responsibilities 3) Targeting strategy: determining eligibility 4) Selected or preferred delivery mechanisms and financial service providers 5) Implementation procedures 6) Programme quality 7) Exit strategies Part 3.1 Common Targeting Approaches Consult stakeholders Choose methods/mechani sms based on SWOT analysis Re-assess and update Monitor, evaluate, adjust Define/fine-tune eligibility criteria Find those eligible and define preliminary lists Distribute Review and adjust lists Sensitisation and two-way communication throughout process Part 3.2 Common Delivery Approaches CDA: Principles • Intent is to make the same delivery services available to the maximum number of agencies. • Timeliness. • Cost-efficiency and cost-effectiveness gains. • User-friendliness from both a beneficiary and agency perspective. • The ability to meet agency and donor accountability, traceability and reporting requirements. PART 5. COORDINATION R e s p o n s e D e s i g n a n d P l a n What is the impact of the crisis How will we phase out Who needs what Can it be acquired locally by paying for it How and what will we monitor How will we work with government Programme Implementation Needs Assessment How much (quantities and cost) S i t u a t i o n & To whom will we give it Can we deliver cash Coordination and Preparedness How will we give it (together) Programme Design Operational Feasibility What are the protectionrelated risks and benefits What does the government think How much will we give Grant Design What it the specific objective How will cash needs change over time and space What can people make up on their own Do we have the capacity to do our part What other assistance is being provided R e s p o n s e A n a l y s i s STRATEGIC COORDINATION Strategic Coordination Response Analysis (cash for what?) Links relief, recovery and development Fundraising & advocacy with government/donors Coordination between cash interventions and among cash & in-kind interventions : (are needs being met?) Unified approaches to achieve scale/costefficiencies and effectiveness Technical Coordination Multi-sector market assessments (RAF) Demonstrating impact (common M&E, Value for Money) Common understanding of need and where cash appropriate (MEB/gap analysis/transfer rate) Common design for costefficiencies/effectiveness (targeting, delivery mechanisms) MULTIPURPOSE CASH GRANT Water and Sanitation Livelihoods Shelter Core relief items Protection Health Food Security Education