OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Student: Vicky Pringels & Gerilynn Gobuyan Activity: Making Pizza Date: September 19, 2012 Activity Analysis for Therapeutic Intervention Directions: This form is to be completed as a group. It requires detailed analysis of the therapeutic activity you present and teach to the class. Complete all sections in complete sentences with thorough descriptions and thought. Provide a brief description of the activity. Identify the major steps, including the time required for each. Section I Activity Description Section II Therapeutic Qualities Energy Patterns: Describe the required energy level in terms of Making pizza starts with preparing a flat, round bread covered with tomatoes or a tomato sauce and cheese. Toppings are then added based on personal preference. 1. Start by gathering necessary ingredients for the pizza from the kitchen including pre-made dough, pre-cut toppings, sauces, and cheese. (5 minutes) 2. Then, preheat the oven to specified temperature depending on your oven (usually 350⁰-400⁰). (1-5 minutes) 3. Next, roll out pre-made dough using a dough roller and form into a circular shape. (3-5 minutes) 4. Apply sauce evenly to the pizza dough leaving a small margin on the outer-side of the dough which will allow the crust to rise and crisp more quickly. (1-3 minutes) 5. Apply shredded cheese evenly to the sauce. (1 minute) 6. Arrange preferred toppings over the layer of cheese. (1-2 minutes) 7. Place prepared pizza in the center of the top oven rack. (30 seconds) 8. Set timer for appropriate cooking time. (10-15 minutes) 9. Remove baked pizza from the oven with caution. (1 minute) 10. Now you are ready to slice the pizza according to your preference, wait for it to cool down, and enjoy! (1-2 minutes) This activity is an IADL that includes planning, preparing, serving, and cleaning up food and utensils. A light level of activity (2-3 (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 light, moderate, or heavy work patterns and provide an explanation for the level specified (refer to description of MET levels in W&S). Activity Patterns: Indicate the patterns of activity expected for successful completion of the activity. Structural/Methodical/Orderly Repetitive Expressive/Creative/Projective Describe required body structures METs) is necessary to complete this activity. The oxygen consumed will be between 7-11 mL/kg/min. Structural/Methodical/Orderly o When making pizza it is necessary to follow the aforementioned steps in order to ensure the pizza is cooked properly. For example, you must put the sauce on the dough before you add the cheese. Repetitive o There are repetitive motions when making pizza including rolling out the dough multiple times to ensure an even pizza surface and continuously putting selected toppings on the pizza. Expressive/Creative/Projective o You can be expressive or creative with your pizza by making various designs with the toppings or personalizing the pizza to fit your unique style. For example, you can write a message or note for a friend by using various types of toppings (e.g., Will you marry me?) There are several body structures needed when making a pizza. First, you will need two hands, all your fingers (including the thumb) and your wrists to grasp and grip both ends of the roller when rolling out the dough. Those same structures are also needed when using the spoon to spread the sauce and when adding the various pizza toppings to the pizza. Fine motor skills are especially necessary for the proper placement and grasp of the different size toppings. When moving the pizza in and out of the oven you will need the other structures in your upper extremity. While all your upper extremity muscles are necessary to complete the transfer of pizza into the oven you will use your supinator muscles and forearm and elbow flexor (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Describe required body functions (have justification and why it’s that) Tactile Components: consider the following Contact with others Materials Equipment muscles for the majority of the movements. The other muscles in the arm and shoulder will help support and stabilize your movements. Your upper extremity joints and muscles are also needed when opening and closing the refrigerator, oven, and pantry. Eyes are important to find where your items are located in the kitchen as well as where to place the toppings on the pizza. You will use your nose to help determine when the pizza is ready to take out of the oven or if it may be burning. Your legs, feet and lower extremity muscles will be needed when walking throughout the kitchen. Your back muscles are important stabilizers when standing in the kitchen and when bending over to place the pizza on the oven rack. Properly functioning wrist, elbow, and shoulder joints are needed to position the arms for movement. Skin should be free of cuts or abrasions to avoid contaminating the pizza. Thermal awareness is important to know when the pizza is too hot to eat. Awareness of body position and space when putting the pizza in the oven will help to avoid burns. A sense of smell will alert you when the pizza is ready or burning in the oven. Visual awareness is important when placing toppings on pizza. Judgment is used to know when it is time to take the pizza out. You should have awareness of where the necessary items are located in the kitchen. You will need cognitive insight on what the proper steps include when making a pizza. Hearing is important to know when the cooking timer goes off alerting you that the pizza is finished cooking or if a smoke detector goes off when the pizza is burning. When working with other individuals, communication is necessary to know each person’s role and placement in the kitchen. Materials needed: - Various food products of different shapes and sizes such as cheese, onions, pepperoni, pineapple, olives, mushrooms, oregano, garlic, sauce, dough, etc. Equipment and Tools needed: (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 - - Performance Patterns: consider the following: Habits Routines Roles The equipment necessary for this activity is a large, square oven to cook the pizza and a tall rectangular refrigerator to keep the ingredients fresh and cool before cooking. Some tools that are necessary include a large square metal or wood pizza pan, a circular plastic or electric timer, a cylindrical dough roller with handles on both ends, a sharp round pizza cutter, a spoon, and plastic, glass or ceramic containers for the ingredients. Roles: - When making pizza your role is a cook and an artist because you want the pizza to taste good AND look good. Habits: - Some habits when cooking a pizza are setting the timer to a certain time that works best for your pizza oven. Most people set the timer for the same amount of time each time they cook a pizza, checking it occasionally to make sure it is not burning. - Another habit people tend to have is picking the same favorite ingredients to put on the pizza each time. Some people love Hawaiian pizza and have a habit of making a Hawaiian pizza every time they make their own pizza, instead of trying something new. Routines: - Following the sequence of steps involved in making a pizza is a routine that everyone follows. This routine includes the following steps: o Rolling the dough o Putting the sauce on the dough o Putting the cheese and toppings on top of the sauce o Placing pre-made pizza in the oven o Setting timer for appropriate cooking time o Removing pizza from the oven (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Population: Discuss for whom and in what way increased occupational performance can be derived from use of this activity. Motor & Praxis Performance Skills Section III Therapeutic Application Sensory-Perceptual Performance Skills o Slicing the pizza This activity would be an excellent and fun activity for a person who has weak fingers or difficulty grasping. Because grasping each individual topping and placing it onto the pizza is very repetitive it would allow that person to strengthen the fingers, hand and wrist muscles which will strengthen their over-all fine-motor movements. This would also be a good therapeutic activity for someone with sensory issues because each topping will have different textures and consistencies. Another option for someone with sensory issues is having the cook use their hands to spread the sauce around the dough instead of using the spoon. There are several motor and praxis skills needed to complete this activity. You will need to use your motor skills to reach for items in the refrigerator and pantry and your praxis stills to walk with those items in your hands to your cooking surface. Bending will take place when opening the oven and you will have to coordinate your body movements to open the door and place the pizza inside the oven. When working with others, you will be continuously adjusting your body posture and positioning to maneuver around people and objects in the kitchen. An important sensory skill is positioning the body in a location far enough so you don’t get burned by the oven, but close enough so you are stable when transferring the pizza onto the oven rack. You will use your hearing to listen for the timer to go off. After the timer goes off, you will need to time the appropriate moment to take the pizza out of the oven (sometimes the pizza is ready to go once the timer goes off, sometimes it needs to cook for another minute or two). Discerning what toppings would be appropriate for your pizza is part of the art of cooking. For example, you probably do not want to put cool toppings like banana slices or avocado on your pizza before you cook it because they do not taste good when they are warm. You will also need to visually determine the proper size of (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Emotional Regulation Performance Skills Cognitive Performance Skills Communication & Social Regulation Performance Skills Identify Precautions and Contraindications the pizza pan as well as the storage container for any leftover pizza. Sometimes pizzas get cooked too long and burn, so it is important to use proper emotional regulation skills to recover from hurt or disappointment if your pizza burns. One should also display appropriate emotions when dealing with others in the kitchen. For example, a polite “excuse me” is better than yelling at someone to get out of your way. Judging the appropriate amount of toppings to add to your pizza is important so the toppings do not weigh down the dough and everything cooks evenly. Selecting tools and supplies needed to cook the pizza as well as cleaning up the space after cooking the pizza are also cognitive skills that will be used. One will need to sequence the tasks needed to make the pizza (i.e. Determine which step should come first and which steps goes last). It is helpful to organize the ingredients before making the pizza so you know you are not missing anything. You can also save time by multi-tasking. For example, you can start cleaning the cooking area once the pizza has been put in the oven. When completing this tasks with others in the kitchen or when making a pizza that you are going to share with someone else, communication is important. You may gesture to others to alert someone if you need help. You will need to maintain acceptable physical space when working with others in the kitchen. Taking turns with the steps is important so that one person does not end up doing all the work. Acknowledging others input when deciding what toppings to put on the pizza will insure everyone’s wants and needs are taken into consideration. Precautions - When cooking, open wounds on the hands or surfaces of skin that come into contact with the food are unacceptable and should be avoided or covered. If someone has an open would they will need to put gloves on to insure there is no (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Grading: Activity sequence, duration, and/or activity procedures contamination. - For someone with a spinal injury, bending, lifting, and twisting are all precautions and one should discuss proper ways to bend, lift, and twist to insure there is no re-injury to the spine. - If someone has low-vision it is important for them to be aware of their surroundings and the location of necessary materials. For example, you do not want them to accidently touch the oven when it is open or hot. Contraindications - Open wounds on face or severe burns to areas of the upper extremities are red flags. Those individuals should not perform this task until the severe wounds have healed. Grading Up There are several ways to make this activity more difficult including having the cooks make the dough and sauce from scratch. This will require more time and steps when mixing the ingredients for the sauce and dough. Shredding the cheese instead of using already shredded cheese, chopping fresh vegetables, cutting the meat into individual pepperoni slices or roll each sausage crumble by hand will also make this activity longer. Lastly, not giving the cooks instructions on how to prepare the pizza, the temperature settings, and the amount of time the pizza should stay in the oven will make it more difficult and therefore you will have to account for more time and probably more steps as they problem solve the best way to complete the pizza. Grading Down - Making your own pizza seems like a pretty simple task, but there are ways to make it even easier. First having pre-made dough eliminates the lengthy and strenuous task of kneading the dough. Buying shredded cheese, pre-cut vegetables, and (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Grading: Working position of the individual pre-cut meat options will also save a few steps and will eliminate using a sharp object for cutting. Also having fewer ingredient options and larger ingredient options would make applying the toppings to the pizza easier. To make it REALLY simple you could buy a pre-made pizza and then the steps to cooking would be cut down tremendously. The steps for a pre-made pizza would include pre-heating the oven, removing the pizza from the packaging, placing the pizza on the oven rack, setting a timer, and removing the pizza from the oven when it is finished. Grading Up - Adding more individuals to a smaller kitchen would make this activity more challenging as each person would have to be more cautious of their body movements in relation to the other people in the kitchen. There would be more obstacles in the way making it more difficult to maneuver. Having the pizza sauce station on one side of the kitchen, the cheese station on another side of the kitchen, the toping station in the dinning room, and finally having the oven located further away from the preparation areas would make this activity more difficult as more motor and praxis skills would be needed to get from “A” to “B.” Grading Down - Having an assistant around to help when needed would make this task easier. For example, having the assistant open the oven door while the cook puts the pizza in the oven would make it less difficult for the cook. Also, allowing the cook to use a stool or chair when preparing the pizza for the oven would be helpful for someone with weakness in the lower extremities. Having all the ingredients set up in a work station that is close to the oven would make this activity easier as there would be less maneuvering throughout the (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Grading: Tools (nothing should be blank) – things you can use over and over again Position Size Shape Weight Texture Grading: Materials – things that are used up Position Size Shape Weight Texture kitchen. Grading Up - To make this more challenging you can use a dough roller with smaller handles. You could use a smaller size knife or a duller knife to make cutting the pizza ingredients more difficult. Having the ingredients in small bowls as opposed to larger containers would make picking up the ingredients harder. Using a knife to cut the final slices instead of a round pizza slicer would be more challenging. Having the cook use a long tong to pick up the small ingredients and place them on the pizza would really work on their fine motor and grasping skills. You could also test their cognitive and sensory skills by not allowing the cooks to use a timer and instead relying on them to check the pizza every few minutes and use their best personal judgment on when it is ready to come out of the oven. Grading Down - To make this activity easier you can use a dough roller with larger handles. You can use large, labeled containers to make discerning the toppings simpler. Using a weighted spoon to spread the sauce on the dough could also be helpful for some people. Using a thin metal pan rather than a thick wood pizza pan would make getting the pizza in and out of the oven easier. Using a pizza slicer would make cutting the pizza slices quicker. Grading Up - You could make different shaped pizzas instead of the traditional circular pizza. You could add more toppings to the pizza or make it bigger and heavier which would make it harder to pick up and place in the oven. Grading Down - Using fewer ingredients will make the pizza lighter and (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 Grading: Nature/degree of interpersonal contact Grading: Extent of tactile, verbal, or visual cues provided by practitioner during activity Grading: Teaching-learning environment Therapeutic Adaptation: Indicate ways in which this activity can be changed to increase occupational performance and state your reasoning. Consider: (don’t leave anything blank) - Orthotic devices easier to place in the oven. Of the ingredients that you choose, having larger diameters would make picking up the toppings easier. Grading Up - Having more people in the kitchen would increase the number of distractions while cooking. Grading Down - Having another person present when making the pizza will allow for the steps to go faster and allow you to have help if needed. Grading Up - Giving no instruction would allow the client to problem solve on their own. Grading Down - The practitioner showing the client how to perform each step would ensure they are doing the activity correctly. Grading Up - Following a video on a computer instead of having an instructor in the room with you would make learning the steps more difficult. Providing a paper with directions but not giving feedback on how to do those steps will create a more challenging environment. Grading Down - One-on-one instruction would make this activity less stressful. - Orthotic devices Using a back brace would help stabilize individuals with back and lower extremity deficits. This would allow them to be more mobile in the kitchen and stand for longer periods of time. Using a long-handled reacher for retrieving items from high shelves can avoid the need to climb on a ladder or step stool. - Prosthetic devices An artificial arm, known as the “myoelectric” arm, can be used to provide the user with fine control of the limb. This artificial (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 - Prosthetic devices Assistive technology Adaptive devices Architectural modifications Environmental modifications Wheelchair modifications - - arm is battery powered and places small electrodes on the skin at the site of amputation and uses the muscle signals from the remaining arm muscles to help move the prosthetic arm. Assistive technology Using an enlarged print digital timer is useful for people with limited vision. Adaptive devices Other useful items include an electric can opener to open the sauce can and a rubber cover that can be slipped over the oven door handle and the refrigerator door handle to provide a better grip. A high stool with a backrest will provide comfort while working on a countertop. A rolling cart can be utilized to transport heavy objects and decrease the number of trips between the kitchen and dining table. Heavy containers can be replaced with lighter plastic ones that do not break. Architectural modifications For people with money concerns something as simple as adding “U” shaped handles to the cabinets to avoid grasping the more difficult knob handles can be a cost effective solution. For people who are permanently in a wheelchair we could discuss lowering the counter tops to be at the wheelchair level as well as re-designing the sink so that a wheelchair can slide under it. Also, redesigning the cabinets like the picture below will make reaching for items easier. (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 - Energy conservation techniques or methods Work simplification techniques or methods Joint protection techniques or methods Body mechanics – consider Proper body mechanics Avoiding static or deforming postures Avoiding excessive weightbearing positions Wheelchair modifications Placing a wooden cutting board on the cooks lap will provide protection of the legs from hot spatters and serves as an insulated table to put hot items on the lap to prevent burns. It also frees up the person’s hands so they can maneuver their wheelchair in the kitchen. - Environmental modifications Generally kitchen floors are tile and can be slippery, so adding a non-slip surface would help reduce the risk of falls in the kitchen environment. For people in a wheelchair the aforementioned wheelchair modification (i.e. wooden cutting) will help conserve energy when moving about the kitchen. Using a container with multiple compartments will allow you to have all the ingredients in one container and decrease the amount of containers thus making cleanup easier. Using a pizza slicer will make dividing the pizza simpler. Having fewer toppings available will make choosing the toppings easier and the actual act of making the pizza quicker. Listening and respecting any signs of pain are important. Pain is an indicator of joint destruction, and therefore activities should be stopped immediately when a person begins to feel pain. Using two hands to carry objects, lightening the load that the person is carrying, or building up the handle on the objects (with a towel or foam) to help distribute the weight of the object across joints will help protect the joints. Push or pull all objects across the counter instead of carrying them can also preserve the joints. Before lifting, reaching, pushing, pulling or carrying objects have the cook remove any objects that are in their way. Next make sure their base of support is wide enough to evenly distribute the body weight. Make sure the cooks are aware of their personal abilities and limits. For example, when objects are too large, bulky or heavy they may obtain assistance. When bending make sure the cooks are (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 How does this activity enhance occupational performance areas? How does this activity enhance the satisfaction of the client and/or caregivers? How does this activity enhance quality of life? Describe in detail each member’s specific duties during the presentation and completion of this form (just the members of the group). How did your view of occupation change throughout this process? Synopsis keeping their back straight and are using their legs to lift them back up rather than their backs. The steps involved in cooking a pizza are similar to the steps needed to cook other foods and thus will enhance the client’s ability to prepare meals independently. Some of these tasks (i.e. grasping toppings) will build up fine motor strength and will help with other everyday tasks. Making a pizza allows a person to personalize their meals and will make eating more satisfying. If they learn how to adapt the steps to do this activity independently they will not have to rely on others for assistance and, in turn, will improve their spirits. Cooking can be therapeutic and considered a form of art. Some find that cooking relieves stress and can actually be very fun. Meal preparation is important in being an independently functioning person and can provide the fine motor skills necessary in other household activities. Gerilynn typed up the outline for our form while Vicky modified it into complete sentences and made sure it flowed. Both members researched different modifications and adaptations for this activity. Both members went shopping for the ingredients and provided tools to complete the activity. Both members participated in setting up the work-space prior to engaging in the activity. Vicky’s view on the occupation of making pizza has changed in that she didn’t realize how many kitchen modifiers are available for people with various disabilities. While cooking may still be difficult, these devices really help make people more independent. Gerilynn’s view of occupation changed in terms of realizing how much modification and adaptation must be done in order for a person with disabilities to perform an activity that is often taken for granted (i.e. cooking). Both Gerilynn and Vicky feel that making pizza is a simple task and found it hard to find ways of making it simpler besides using assistive kitchen devices. Coming up with ways to make this task more challenging (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005) OCCT 506: Clinical Reasoning about Occupation Form #4 was much easier for us. (Modified from Hersch, Lamport, & Coffey, 2005)