CHANDLER UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT SUGGESTED RESOURCE GUIDE FOR REQUIRED TEXTS EXTENDED TEXT: Fahrenheit 451 Title GRADE LEVEL: Ray Bradbury 0-345-34296-8 Author ISBN 8th Grade Honors SYNOPSIS: Set in a futuristic totalitarian society, Guy Montag is a fireman in a society where firemen burn books. Montag’s lives in a world where technology has replaced passion for the simple things in life, and “one size fits all” has replaced the once valued intellectual thinking. When Montag meets a young neighbor girl, she causes him question his values and he begins to question his personal values and the values of a decaying society. Written in the mid 50’s, Bradbury has accurately predicted where our society is today in terms of the media influence, censorship, thought control, the adverse effects of technology and the lack of intellectual development in our society. BACKGROUND: Bradbury penned 451 in the 50’s before cell phones, reality TV shows, big screen TVs, personal computers, Blue Tooth, and a news media that focused on facts rather than sensationalism and entertainment for profit. TEXT COMPLEXITY ANALYSIS: In the Reader and Task section, include specific concerns, modifications, scaffolding, or opportunities for differentiation—address how the text should be approached for diverse learners (gifted, honors, ELL, SPED). Quantitative: Lexile 890 Qualitative: Rich in figurative language and symbolism. It is an exemplar text. Reader and Task: Most sections are challenging, even for 8th grade honor students. Certain sections are excellent for close reading. MOTIFS AND THEMES: Themes and a possible unit/sub-unit question: We are figuratively guilty of burning books in our society. How do we burn books today? Technology can have an adverse effect on society. Agree or disagree: Although technology appears to improve our lives, in the end, it is ultimately destructive. There is a price to pay for censorship. Should the government regulate censorship in our society? The media has an enormous responsibility in our society. What responsibilities does the media have to society? Motifs: Technology Censorship Intellectualism Media LANGUAGE: Identify important vocabulary. Provide a focus standard for grammar/mechanics that works nicely with the extended text. Vocabulary Acquisition and Use Tier 2 Vocabulary Tier 3 Vocabulary (if applicable) dissident/dissentergenocide utopia status quo hedonism totalitarian taboo heretic heresy Symbolism “Big Brother” Dark Ages First Amendment Mass media Intellectual freedom COMPANION TEXTS: Provide a series of short companion texts that will supplement the extended text and provide students with a deeper understanding of the themes, motifs, or context of the extended text. 1-3 Short Informational Texts Text Title and Author A short description of the text and how it relates to the extended text Label Difficulty: Advanced Grade Level Meant for Scaffolding 1. Let’s Take Back the Internet by Rebecca MacKinnon 1. In this powerful talk from TEDGlobal, Rebecca MacKinnon describes the expanding struggle for freedom and control in cyberspace, and asks: How do we design the next phase of the Internet with accountability and freedom at its core, rather than control? She believes the internet is headed for a "Magna Carta" moment when citizens around the world demand that their governments protect free speech and their right to connection. What is the difference between censorship in 451 and the cyberspace censorship addressed my MacKinnon? 1. 2. Ray Bradbury: Fahrenheit 451 Misinterpreted by Amy E. Boyle Johnson at LA Weekly News 2. Bradbury’s shares his intended major theme, different than the status quo 2. Grade Level 3. Song Critical of Pakistani Generals Is Blocked Online, With No Official Explanation 3. This NYT article can be found at: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/05/world/asia/satirical-songblocked-in-pakistan-but-no-reason-is-given.html?ref=censorship&_r=0 Advanced 3. Grade Level 4. Grade Level By SALMAN MASOOD Published: May 4, 2013 4. Russians Selectively Blocking Internet By ANDREW E. KRAMER Published: March 31, 2013 4. This NYT article can be found at: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/01/technology/russia-beginsselectively-blocking-internet-content.html?ref=censorship 1-3 Short Literary Texts Text Title and Author A short description of the text and how it relates to the extended text Compare and contrast Orwell’s society with Bradbury’s Label Difficulty: Advanced Grade Level Meant for Scaffolding 1. 1984 by George Orwell 1. 2. The Veldt by Ray Bradbury 2. Compare and contrast the themes of the two stories. This is a short story also set in a futuristic society. Similar themes: adverse effect of technology. The Veldt has the different theme of parental permissiveness. 2. Grade Level 3. “Bicycle” by the Flobots 3. Song/Poem Video. Can be used with lyrics alone. Deals with the adverse effects of technology and government control. Also addresses the power of human choice and human good/evil and man’s ability to go against the grain as Montag does in 451. 3. Grade Level 4. The Simple Commandments of Journalistic Ethics 4. In this article, a former NYT writer explains this code of ethics to students. This story can be found on page 715 of McDougal Littell’s Literature (green textbook) 4. Grade Level 5. 5. 5. Roughing It by Mark Twain A humorous memoir about Twains journey through life. He finds he has talent for creating “stirring news” by embellishing the truth. This story can be found in McDougal Littel’s Literature (green textbook) on page 706. 1. Advanced Advanced STANDARDS-BASED ACTIVITIES: These activities will assist in the instruction of the extended text (consider: comprehension, vocabulary, grammar, close reading, etc.). Some materials (rubrics, graphic organizers, printables, handouts, student directions, etc.) will be added to the end of this document. ACTIVITY #1 – SYMBOLISM IN 451 Description In groups students will be given a list of things that can have symbolic meaning: Examples: black, white, sun, vulture, rainbow, feather, hammer, etc Standards Addressed: 8.SL.4 8.RL.4 In groups discuss what they could symbolize and why. Process as a class. Working in groups, give the students a grid chart with the following symbols from 451 listed down the left column. The Phoenix, the sand and the sieve, the Hound, the railroad tracks, the fighter jets, fire (and the lady’s match). Other column headings: possible meanings behind the symbolism. (more than one interpretation is possible) ACTIVITY #2 – CLOSE READING Students read the text independently and annotate key words and or phrases that answer the question “According to Faber, why are books so important?” Description Resources: Copies of the novel Grid charts (one per group) Discuss in groups Read text aloud to students and ask them to again annotate key Discuss new findings in group Resources: Photocopies of pages 83a to 85b Faber’s explanation of why books are important Standards Addressed: 8.RI.2 8.RI.6 Description ACTIVITY #3 – SYMBOLISM IN 451 Summarizing Fiction: Somebody/Wanted/But/So—SWBS: (MacOn, Bewell, & Vogt, 1991) This is a reading strategy that encourages students not to simply retell every part of a story in a summary, but to carefully select the most significant parts. There are four columns in this chart; see the end of this document for more information. 1) Somebody (the name of the character) 2) Wanted—(students must make an inference about motivation) 3) But—(usually this is a conflict or pivotal event in the story) 4) So—(the resolution of the conflict, or change in the character as a result) Description ACTIVITY #4 – SYMBOLISM IN 451 Applying Understanding- Point of View: Direct students to read the classroom text with an eye toward recognizing the narrator’s perspective, then have them create and complete a graphic organizer in which they will quote lines of text and analyze them on the basis of narrative perspective, asking the questions: What is the narrators intended response from the reader? How does the narrator feel about the topic? What is the narrators motivation for creating this narrative voice here? Resources: Fahrenheit 451 Teacher-generated list of openended questions (if desired) Standards Addressed: RL 8.2 RL 8.1 Resources: Fahrenheit 451 Applying Understanding- Point of View graphic organizer Standards Addressed: RL 8.6 RL 8.1 WRITING PROMPTS: Argument/Opinion Prompts: Agree or disagree? Ignorance is bliss. “We must all be alike. Not everyone born equal, as the Constitution says, but everyone made equal. Each man the image of every other; for there are no mountains to make them cower, to judge themselves against.” Agree or disagree: This is our society. Agree or disagree: Although technology appears to improve our lives, in the end, it is ultimately destructive. Agree or disagree: Watching more than two hours of television per day is harmful. (Be sure to cite from the text) Agree or disagree: The social media causes more harm than good. Does Faber accurately portray our society? Agree or disagree: The “political correctness” (PC) movement is an infringement on the 1 st amendment. Agree or disagree: Our society has become desensitized to human suffering? Agree or disagree with Faber: “The most dangerous enemy to truth and freedom is the majority. Informational/Explanatory Prompts: Why did the lady light the match to end her own life? Compare and contrast Montag and Clarisse. What is the symbolism in “the sieve and the sand?” How do we burn books in our society? Why is it important to ask why instead of how? What is wrong with Mildred, Mrs. Phelps and Clara? Mildred has much to lose by sounding the alarm. What does she do it? In the book, what does fire symbolize? Why does Montag not mourn for Mildred? Narrative Prompts: Write about a time when you, like Montag, went against the status quo (or should have gone against the status quo) Montag puts thinks a lot about what his last words will be when he faces the camera. What would your last words be? What do you have hidden behind the grille of the air conditioning vent? How has knowledge been power in your life? Montag contemplated his final words. If you had to give your last words, what would they be? Research Prompts: Research the history of the media’s role in society. Research the adverse effects of technology on society. As outlined by PARCC, the prompts above may occur in a variety of writing environments. Teachers should consider: Incorporating a mix of on-demand and review-and-revision writing assignments Including routine writing, such as short constructed-responses to text-dependent questions, to build content knowledge and provide opportunities for reflection on a specific aspect of a text or texts Integrating of a number of analytic writings that places a premium on using evidence, as well as on crafting works that display some logical integration and coherence. These responses can vary in length based on the questions asked and task performed, from answering brief questions to crafting longer responses, allowing teachers to assess students’ ability to paraphrase, infer, and ultimately integrate the ideas they have gleaned from what they have read. Over the course of the year, analytic writing should include comparative analysis and compositions that share findings from the research project Include narrative writing to offer students opportunities to express personal ideas and experiences; craft their own stories and descriptions; and deepen their understandings of literary concepts, structures, and genres (e.g., short stories, anecdotes, poetry, drama) through purposeful imitation.