Slide 1 - Clinical Departments - Medical University of South Carolina

advertisement

Preparing Abstracts and Poster Presentations

Keri T. Holmes-Maybank, MD

Division of Hospital Medicine

Medical University of South Carolina

Learning Objectives

• Residents will learn to prepare an abstract for submission to a scientific conference.

• Residents will learn to prepare a poster for presentation at a scientific conference.

• Residents will identify elements of successful abstracts and posters.

• Residents will identify pitfalls of unsuccessful abstracts and posters.

Key Messages

• Successful abstracts and posters are heavily edited.

• Successful abstracts and posters follow the guidelines and goals of the scientific conference.

• Successful abstracts and posters are concise and focus on a few key points.

• Successful abstracts and posters have clearly linked learning objectives and conclusions.

Why give a presentation?

• Share knowledge

• Experience presenting

• Preparation for manuscript publication(34-77% of posters are published in p-r journals)

• Feedback and criticism

• ACGME requires residents to participate in scholarly activity

• Separate yourself from other employment or fellow candidates

What should be presented?

• Clinical practice, education, or research

Common diagnostic, therapeutic, or management dilemmas

• Unique or important teaching points

• Increases awareness of condition

• EBM

• Unusual presentation, complication, management

• Proper or new diagnostic strategy

• Cost effective approach

• Rare

Where to present?

• Society of General Internal Medicine

• Southern Society of General Internal Medicine

• American College of Physicians

• South Carolina Chapter American College of

Physicians

• Society of Hospital Medicine

• Subspecialty organizations

Abstract

• Very concise statement/summary of the major elements of your vignette, research, or innovation

• Submit to scientific organization for consideration of presentation at the organization’s conference

Poster vs. Oral

• Oral

▫ Only top abstracts

▫ Usually 8 minutes followed by question and answer

• Poster

▫ Large formatted

▫ Set up with other presenters in lecture hall

▫ Set time – attendees will walk by and have opportunity to discuss poster

Getting started…

• Ask your attending if good case

• Collect history and physical, progress notes, relevant labs and imaging

• Do literature review

• Start by writing what made you interested

• Write the case presentation

Specifications

• Each organization has its own specifications

▫ Length

▫ Format

• Read directions!!!!

Writing an abstract – 4 C’s

• Concise – no excess wordiness or information

• Clear – readable, well-organized

• Cohesive – flows

• Complete – covers the major points

Abstract Tips

• Active voice, consistent and correct verb tenses

• Simple, short sentences

• Grammar correct - The Chicago Manual of Style:

The Essential Guide for Writers, Editors, and

Publishers

• Eliminate unnecessary words

• Avoid medical jargon

• Generic RX

• Don’t use >3 abbreviations-spell out first, common

• NEVER “first case ever reported”

• EDIT, EDIT, EDIT

Abstract Content Tips

• Clear take home message

• Design around 1-3 key points/objectives

• Simple and concise

• Don’t be emotionally attached to details

• Omit details not essential to the main message

• Want your audience to understand why your case is of interest to them

Scientific Abstract

• Introduction

• Methods

• Results

• Discussion

Innovations Abstract

• Statement of Problem or Question

• Objectives of Program/Intervention

• Description of Program/Intervention

• Findings to Date

• Key Lessons Learned

SSGIM – Vignette Abstract

• Learning Objectives

• Case Presentation

• Discussion

ACP – Vignette Abstract

• Introduction (can omit and go straight to case)

• Case description

• Discussion

SHM – Vignette Abstract

• Case Presentation

• Discussion

• Conclusion

Title

• Interesting

• Short

• Descriptive

• Summary

• Do not give everything away

Authors

• Presenter should be first author

• Attending should be last author

Affiliation

• Medical University of South Carolina,

Charleston, South Carolina

Title

NEW ONSET SEIZURES: REEMERGENCE OF INACTIVE

SARCOIDOSIS

Temeia Martin,MD (Resident); William Moran, MD

Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC

SSGIM - Learning Objectives

• Only 1-3 objectives

• Clear, concise

• Clear link to conclusions

• Action-oriented

▫ Recognize

▫ Diagnose

▫ Assess

▫ Treat

▫ Distinguish

▫ Manage

▫ Identify

• NOT – know or understand

ACP - Introduction

• Describes context of the case and explains relevance and importance

• Usually 3-ish sentences

Case Presentation

• BRIEFLY describe case

▫ Pertinent HPI, ROS pos/neg, PMHx, SocHx,

FamHx, Rx

▫ Pertinent PE findings pos/neg, diagnostic studies, interventions/treatment

▫ Patient outcome

• Only PERTINENT info

Discussion

• Emphasize key points

• Importance of this case

• Different/unique

• Implications: teaching, practice, research?

• Future: do differently?

• ****Make sure is clearly linked to objectives****

• Concise

SSGIM Abstract Criteria

• Clarity of presentation

▫ Concise, complete, organized, well-written, focused objectives

• Significance/relevance to general internal medicine

▫ Unique, interesting. Contextualizes and describes impact on clinical practice in internal medicine, teaching/education or future research

• Teaching value

▫ Offers important diagnosis, physical examination, or management pearls

Why not accepted?

• Poor presentation

• Weak discussion

• Lack of originality

• Inadequate support

• Conclusions not tied to learning objectives

• Objectives not clearly stated

Successful Abstracts

• Follow the guidelines/directions

• Well-written

• Meets goals of conference

• Basis of future work

POSTER PRESENTATIONS

• To distill down to a brief presentation effectively requires clear thinking, careful planning, and concise, efficient communication.

• Best clinical vignette posters are those that make a small number of points(even just one) clearly and succinctly.

Poster Content Tips

• Clear take home message

• Clear why your case is of interest to audience

• Design around 1-3 key points

• Don’t be emotionally attached to the details

• Omit details not essential to the main message

• Do not include abstract unless required redundant

Poster Construction

• Abstract is the basis

• Judicious use of more detail

Poster Tips

• BULLET POINTS – simple and concise - PHRASES

• Orderly, left to right

• Organized - Easy to follow flow of info

• Use white space – not overly dense with text

• AVOID CLUTTER – simple, user friendly

• Use no more than 4 colors

• No more than 3 sizes of font

• No smaller than 24 point

• San Serif fonts:

ARIAL,

Trebuchet MS,

Helvetica

• Make it visual – images, tables

Remember

• Anyone who views your poster walks away with key information

• 10-10 rule (10 seconds from 10 meters) - Draw them in

• Goal to share information and have many viewers

Poster Outline

• Title

• Authors, institution, location

• Follows abstract outline plus conclusions

Title

• Center, All caps, Largest font on poster

• Smaller font for author, institution, city, and state

• Upper and lower case for author, institution, city and state

ACP Introduction

• Describe the clinical context and relevance

• 1-3 sentences/phrases

• Bullet points if possible

Case Presentation

• BULLET POINTS

• Clear, concise

• Only pertinent info

• Do NOT be emotionally attached to details

• Omit any information not relevant to main message

Case Presentation

• Brief

• Relevant HPI

• Relevant PMHx, SocHx, FamHx

• Ros pertinent positive/negative

• PE pertinent positive/negative

• Pertinent Laboratory, biopsy, and imaging

• Hospital course

• Treatment

Discussion

• Importance of this case to audience

• Support your conclusions

• Lessons learned

• Subheadings for your main message:

▫ diagnostic criteria, diagnostic modalities, unusual presentation, description of biopsy results, treatments, guidelines, possible mechanisms

Conclusions

• TAKE HOME MESSAGE

• May be all your audience sees

• Emphasize key points

Images

• ***Real draw to attendees in vignettes***

• ***Center, top (under title) of poster***

• Large, clear

• Use arrows

• Review with radiologist

Figures and Tables

• Use graphs for a purpose NOT to dress up

• Emphasize learning points

• Simple - Not too many columns or rows

• Label graphs very clearly

• Horizontal labels

References

• Really small font

• If necessary can print on separate sheet and attach to bottom right corner

Attendings

• Have your attending review your poster

• Provide constructive feedback

• Rehearse your overview

• Practice for judges questions

Getting Your Poster Made

• Lisa Fennessy, Art Services

• Send the proof to Lisa Fennessy by email – no pdf

• Lisa will print proof same day

• Edit proof (maybe several times)

• Final proof

• Send the final one week before need poster

Etiquette

• Prepare a 1-2 minute summary of your poster

• Dress professionally

• Stand by poster – expected by mtg coordinators

• Be prepared to answer questions from the judges

• Wait for readers to finish

• Make eye contact - Put down any food or drink when discussing poster

• Know the flow of your poster and refer to it

• Don’t get tipsy before or during presentation

ACP Poster Judging Criteria

• Significance – increase understanding of a disease, improve the diagnosis or treatment

• Presentation – logical, interesting, clearly written, free of grammatical problems

• Visual impact – effective, value of figure and graph

• Interview – knowledgeable, conversant

SSGIM Poster Judging Criteria

• Poster Presentation – outstanding organization, excellent poster format, effective illustrations, appropriate amount of words

• Learning objectives – clearly stated learning objectives, tied to conclusions, supported by data

• Content – clear, concise case description, all

RELEVANT patient information, info well organized

• Teaching/educational value – valuable to internists, increases understanding of disease, improves diagnosis or treatment of disease state

• Overall

SSGIM Most Common Pitfalls

• Objectives not clearly stated (content)

• Inappropriate amount of words(too many)

• Conclusions are not tied into learning objectives (conclusions)******

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

Insert Poster Title Here

Your name here

Your institution’s name here

CONCLUSIONS

CASE DESCRIPTION

Figure 1 .

. Figure 2 .

DISCUSSION

REFERENCES

References

• Pierson DJ.How to Write an Abstract That Will Be Accepted for

Presentation at a National Meeting. Respir Care 2004;49(10):1206 –1212.

• Writing a Clinical Vignette (Case Report) Abstract.

Wwwacponline.org/residents_fellows/competitions/abstract/prepare/cli nvin_abs.htm

• Clinical vignette submission info. wwwsgim.org/index.cfm?pageId=1138

• Estrada C. ACP, SGIM Clinical Vignette Competition: Write an Abstact to

Win! www.uab.edu/.../10-01-...

• Ismail MK. How to write an abstract: abstract submission & poster presentation. www.uthsc.edu/Internal/ abstract .ppt

• SGIM 29 th annual meeting. Vignette Guidelines.

• Barrett NF. Developing the successful clinical abstract. www.barrettevaluations.com/_pdfs/clinabst.pdf

• Southern Society of General Internal Medicine. Southern SGIM call for vignette submissions. www.sgim.org/index.cfm?pageId=431

References

• Society of General Internal Medicine. 2013 Annual Meeting

Important Dates. http://www.sgim.org/index.cfm?pageId=1311

• http://www.hospitalmedicine.org/Content/NavigationMenu/

Education/AcademicandResearch/Overview/content.htm

Tulsky A, Kouides R. Abstract Presentations. What do SGIM

Presenter Prefer? J Gen Intern Med 1998;13:417-418 .

• Willett LL, Paranjape A, Estrada C. Identifying Key

Components for an Effective Case Report Poster: An

Observational Study. J Gen Intern Med 2008;24(3):393-397.

• American College of Physicians. Internal Medicine. Preparing a Poster Presentation .

• Hamilton CW. A Stepwise Approach to Successful Poster

Presentations. Chest 2008;134:147-459.

Download