Slides - Center for Sex Offender Management

The Role of the Victim and

Victim Advocate in

Managing Sex Offenders

Section 2:

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Learning Objectives

 Identify mistaken beliefs about sexual assault;

 Discuss the prevalence of sexual assault and its impact on victims;

 Identify the different forms of intra-familial abuse and some of the family dynamics unique to incest cases; and

 Identify the importance of cultural competency in working with victims of sexual assault.

2 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Definition of Sexual Assault

“Forced or manipulated unwanted sexual contact between two or more adults or two or more minors, or any sexual contact between an adult and a minor, or between two minors with a significant age difference between them.”

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 3

Myths and Facts

 Most sexual assaults are committed by strangers.

 FACT: 3 of 4 victims know their attacker.

 Assault is avoidable with care and alertness.

 FACT: The attacker is usually someone the victim has reason to trust.

 Sexual impulsiveness or frustration cause rape.

 FACT: Most assaults are planned.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 4

Myths and Facts

 Sexual assault is only harmful if there is visible physical injury.

 FACT: Victims suffer regardless of whether they sustain visible injury; the violation of trust victims suffer can dramatically increase their level of trauma.

 Child abusers usually find victims in places like schoolyards or playgrounds.

 FACT: 90% of child abusers choose to victimize children they already know.

 Women “cry” rape.

 FACT: Less than 8% of claims of sexual assault are found to be unfounded.

5 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Myths and Facts

 The majority of sex offenders are caught, convicted, and in prison.

 FACT: A small number of rapes are reported and a fraction of offenders apprehended and convicted.

 All sex offenders are male.

 FACT: The majority of sex offenders are male, but females do commit some sex offenses, particularly against children.

 Youths do not commit sex offenses.

 FACT: 1/5 of rapes and 1/2 of child molestations are committed by adolescents.

6 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Cross Examination of a

Robbery Victim

 How does this scenario relate to sexual assault?

 Why are sexual assault victims more frequently blamed and not believed?

 If a victim complies with the offender, does that mean she was not robbed?

 Do people “ask” to be sexually victimized?

 What would be a better, more supportive response to a victim of sexual assault?

7 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Fears Resulting in Non- or

Delayed Reporting

 No one will believe him or her.

 She/he will not be treated fairly by criminal justice system.

 Being blamed because of alcohol or drug abuse.

 Exposing her/his private life.

 Retaliation by offender or others.

 When personal attachment exists, getting the offender in trouble.

 In incest cases, breaking up the family.

 If the victim is an illegal alien, deportation, criminal charges, or the removal of children by authorities.

 Offender will act on previously made threats.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 8

Other Reasons for Non- or

Delayed Reporting

 Failure to recognize coercive sex as assault.

 Failure to identify assault by friend or lover as criminal.

 Memory loss, discomfort with details, or fear of exposing illegal behavior.

 Desire to put the situation behind her/him.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 9

Rape Trauma Syndrome: The

Acute Phase

Physical reactions: soreness, fatigue, nightmares, loss of appetite, etc.

Emotional reactions: mood swings, anger, irritability, feeling of numbness, etc.

Denial or recoil phase: the victim tries to forget, seeks out the familiar, avoids talking about the incident or seeking help from doctors or police.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 10

Rape Trauma Syndrome: The

Long Term Phase

Psychological reactions: nightmares, fears, feelings of guilt, self-blame, and anger.

Social reactions: Changing of address and disruption of relationships.

Sexual reactions: Fear of sex altogether or an increase in sexual activity.

11 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Child and Adolescent Victims of Sexual Assault

Child and Adolescent Victims of Sexual Assault

 Children do not fit neatly into theories or categories.

 A child’s reaction varies depending on numerous factors including self-esteem levels, family support, etc.

 Signs and symptoms are warning signs and are not definite indicators of abuse.

 The absence of signs does not mean a child’s disclosure is false.

 Children victims are prone to sexual dysfunction and abusive relationships in the future.

 Children are NEVER at fault for abuse perpetrated against them.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 13

Accommodation Syndrome

 Secrecy

 Helplessness

 Entrapment and Accommodation

 Delayed, Conflicted, and Unconvincing

Disclosure

 Retraction

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 14

Traumagenic Dynamics

Theory

 Traumatic Sexualization

 Betrayal

 Stigmatization

 Powerlessness

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 15

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Intra-Familial Sexual Abuse

Family Dynamics in Parent-

Child Incest Cases

 The child may still feel love for the abuser.

 Secrecy is imposed by the perpetrator through the use of threats and coercion.

 A child’s reaction to the abuse varies greatly.

 Children may prefer the “special” attention to no attention at all.

 They may consider the abuse as “normal.”

 They may feel shame by experiencing sexual gratification during the abuse.

 Negative emotions may lead to self-abusive or outwardly destructive behaviors.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 17

Dynamics of Non-Offending

Parents and Children

 Victim feels angry toward non-offending parent for not protecting her/him.

 Victim feels divided loyalty.

 There may be concurrent abuse of the non-offending parent.

 These parents may be previous victims making them unable to identify signs of abuse.

 The non-offending parent may be dependent on the offender (e.g. financially, emotionally, etc.)

 Even with the abuse, emotional ties between family members are still strong.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 18

Child Disclosure in Incest

Cases

 Children disclose at great risk to themselves.

 Recanting following a disclosure is a common response by a child victim.

 A child’s style of accommodation or coping mechanisms may be used to discredit their disclosure.

 Non-offending parents may not support the child if the parent is dependent on the abuser.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 19

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Sibling Incest

Similar Dynamics in Sibling

Incest Cases

 Victim has less power.

 Offender may use force, coercion, or threats.

 Victim may prefer the attention to no attention at all.

 Victim may not disclose.

 Parents may feel forced to choose between the offender and victim.

 Victim may not recognize the situation as abusive.

 Non-offending parents may collude with the offender, reinforcing denial or minimization.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 21

Dynamics Unique to Sibling

Incest Cases

 Offenders may be victims of abuse (e.g. parent-child incest) themselves.

 Environment is highly sexualized.

 Difficult to distinguish between exploration and abuse when coercion is not explicit.

 Parents reluctant to recognize abusive behavior.

22 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Important Dynamics in Sibling

Incest Cases

 Parents may resent intrusion of others into what they may view as a private family matter.

 Parents should be involved in the treatment of both the offender and the victim.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 23

Dynamics in Partner Rape

 Offenders use a variety of ways to control the victim.

 Offenders try to isolate victim and increasingly demand secrecy.

 There may be a pattern of violence followed by calmness and loving attention.

 Abuse is long lasting, resulting in victim loss of power, self-esteem.

 The victim’s resources and options for escape diminish over time.

 Children, while sworn to maintain secrecy, may act out in destructive ways.

 To the outside world, offenders may present themselves as upstanding citizens.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 24

Disclosure of Marital or

Partner Rape

 Disclosure is difficult because offender uses threats and coercion.

 Victims may choose to endure abuse because it is the least harmful alternative.

 More likely to disclose physical abuse as opposed to sexual abuse.

 May not even recognize violent sexual contact within the marriage as abuse.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 25

Secondary Impact of Sexual

Assault

 Those who share relationships with the offender or victim may experience reactions similar to victims.

 They need their own support systems.

 They need education to better support the victim.

 The revenge reaction by those close to victim must be dealt with.

 If they were also previously abused, they might be dealing with their own feelings triggered by event.

 Their pain should not be underestimated.

26 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Cultural Competency:

Responding with Sensitivity to

Victims from All Backrounds

Understanding Sexual

Assault from a Victim’s

Perspective

Seniors and People with

Disabilities

Older Victims

 Age-related physical conditions may increase a victim’s risk of serious injury.

 Physical coercion can be more easily applied to older victims.

 Older people’s routines and reliance on public transportation can increase their vulnerability.

 Limited income may limit their lifestyle choices and their response to crimes.

 Older victims may be reliant on abusive caretakers.

 They may be reluctant to discuss sexual matters and too ashamed to tell anyone about the abuse.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 29

People with Mental Illness

 The trauma of sexual assault may exacerbate their illness and their symptoms.

 A mental illness can be used to discredit a victim’s disclosure of sexual abuse, especially in the criminal justice system.

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 30

People with Physical

Disabilities

 Reliance on family members or caregivers and limited mobility can contribute to a victim’s vulnerability.

 Communities of people with disabilities can be small and limit a person’s personal care options.

 Predictable routines and reliance on public transportation can also increase a victim’s vulnerability.

 Family members and loved ones may become overly protective of the victim once an assault has occurred.

 After a sexual assault, people with physical disabilities may experience a sense of helplessness and loss of confidence.

31 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

People with Developmental

Disabilities

 People with developmental disabilities may not be able to understand the abuse, available intervention options, sexuality, or the engagement in sexual behaviors.

 Their eagerness to be liked can make them easier to manipulate and more vulnerable to abuse.

 They may be reluctant to report out of fear of not being believed or being blamed.

 They may also be reluctant to disclose abuse by an abusive caretaker because they are dependent on that caregiver.

 There are few community resources for those with developmental disabilities who are sexually assaulted.

32 Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective

Life Experiences of Victims

 Survivors of racism/prejudice/homophobia

 Mistrust of criminal justice/medical systems

 Reluctance to betray her/his community

 Citizenship status

 Language barriers

 Taboos

 Anger

 Gender and sexuality

 Public disclosure

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 33

Conclusion

 Questions

Coming up next:

 Working with Sexual Assault Victim

Advocates

Section 2: Understanding Sexual Assault from a Victim's Perspective 34