PSYCHOLOGY AN EXPLORATION Second Edition CHAPTER 5 memory Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White why study memory? Without memory, how would we be able to learn anything? The ability to learn is the key to our very survival, and we cannot learn unless we can remember what happened the last time a particular situation arose. Why study forgetting? If we can learn about the ways in which we forget information, we can apply that learning so that forgetting occurs less frequently. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Learning Objectives • • • • • • • • • • • • • LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12 5.13 Memory and the three processes of memory Sensory memory Short-term or working memory Long-term memory Different types of long-term memory Kinds of cues that help people remember How recall and recognition differ How long-term memories are formed False memory syndrome Different causes of forgetting How and where memories are formed in the brain How does amnesia occur? What are the facts about Alzheimer’s disease Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Memory and Its Processes LO 5.1 Memory and the three processes of memory • Memory – Active system that receives information from the senses – Organizes and stores it – Retrieves information from storage Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Memory and Its Processes LO 5.1 Memory and the three processes of memory • Processes of Memory: – Encoding Converts sensory information to a form usable in the brain’s storage systems – Storage Holding onto information for some period of time – Retrieval Recalling stored information in a form that can be used Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Models of Memory LO 5.1 Memory and the three processes of memory • Information-processing model – Information is processed across three stages – Encoding, storage and retrieval Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Models of Memory LO 5.1 Memory and the three processes of memory • Levels-of-processing model – Information is “deeply processed” – Processed according to meaning rather than just sound or physical characteristics of words – How well item is remembered depends on depth remembered Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Models of Memory LO 5.1 Memory and the three processes of memory • Parallel distributed processing (PDP) model – Simultaneous processing, memories stretched across brain – Able to retrieve many aspects of a memory at once – Roots in artificial intelligence model Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.1 Three-Stage Process of Memory Information enters through the sensory system, briefly registering in sensory memory. Selective attention filters the information into short-term memory, where it is held while attention (rehearsal) continues. If the information receives enough rehearsal (maintenance or elaborative), it will enter and be stored in long-term memory. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Sensory Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • First stage of memory • Information enters nervous system through sensory systems – Encodes information into neural messages Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Sensory Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • Two types of sensory memory studied: – Iconic Visual sensory memory – Echoic Auditory sensory memory Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Iconic Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • Visual sensory memory • Lasts only a fraction of a second • Helps visual system view surroundings continuously – Long enough for brain stem to evaluate importance Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Iconic Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • Partial report method (Sperling 1960) – Revealed iconic memory captures information all at once Masking – Information is pushed out of iconic memory quickly – Replaced by new information Eidetic imagery – Ability to access a visual memory for 30 seconds or more Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.1 Three-Stage Process of Memory Information enters through the sensory system, briefly registering in sensory memory. Selective attention filters the information into short-term memory, where it is held while attention (rehearsal) continues. If the information receives enough rehearsal (maintenance or elaborative), it will enter and be stored in long-term memory. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.2 Iconic Memory Test Sample grid of letters for Sperling’s test of iconic memory. To determine if the entire grid existed in iconic memory, Sperling sounded a tone associated with each row after the grid’s presentation. Participants were able to recall the letters in the row for which they heard the tone. The graph shows the decrease in the number of letters recalled as the delay in presenting the tone increased. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Echoic Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • Brief memory of something just heard • Allows memory to remain long enough for meaningful conversation – Capacity Limited to what can be heard at any one moment Smaller than capacity of iconic memory Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Echoic Memory LO 5.2 Sensory memory • Allows memory to remain long enough for meaningful conversation – Duration Lasts longer than iconic 2 to 4 seconds Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Once these piano strings have been attached to the tuning pins, the piano can be tuned. Tuning a piano requires the use of echoic sensory memory. What other occupations might find a good echoic memory to be an asset? Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Memory system in which information is held for brief periods of time while being used – Selective attention Ability to attend to one stimulus apart from total sensory input Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Memory system in which information is held for brief periods of time while being used – Selective attention “Cocktail party effect” – Able to hear own name mentioned across a noisy room Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Memory system in which information is held for brief periods of time while being used – Selective attention Two stage process – Stimuli filtered based on physical characteristics – Processed based on importance Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Each person at this gathering is involved in a conversation with others, with dozens of such conversations going on at the same time all around. Yet if a person in another conversation says the name of one of the people in the crowd, that person in the crowd will be able to selectively attend to his or her name. This is known as the “cocktail party effect.” Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Working Memory – Not really short term memory but a process – Active system that processes information in short-term memory – Consists of three processes: Central “executive” - controls other processes “Sketchpad” - visual “Recorder” - auditory Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White This woman must hold the phone number she is reading in short-term memory long enough to dial it on the phone next to her. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Capacity of short term memory is 7+/−2 chunks of information • Young adults can hold three to five items without strategy to retain information Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Unfamiliar words, information result in further reductions – Digit-span test Series of numbers is read to subjects Subjects are asked to recall the numbers in order Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.3 Digit-Span Test Instructions for the digit-span test: Listen carefully as the instructor reads each string of numbers out loud. As soon as each string is ended (the instructor may say “go”), write down the numbers in the exact order in which they were given. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Unfamiliar words, information result in further reductions – Chunking Combining information into meaningful units or chunks More information can be held in STM Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Maintenance rehearsal – information to be remembered is repeated over and over mentally – maintains it in short-term memory STMs tend to be encoded in auditory form Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Short-Term Memory LO 5.3 Short-term or working memory • Duration of STM – 12 to 30 seconds without rehearsal • STM is susceptible to interference – e.g. if counting is interrupted, count is lost Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White It is very important for this pharmacist to count out the number of pills in the prescription accurately. Short-term memory allows her to remember the last number she counted, but if she is interrupted, she will have to start all over again. Short-term memory is very susceptible to interference. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Long-Term Memory LO 5.4 Long-term memory • System of memory into which information is placed to be kept permanently • Physical change in brain takes place with LTM storage • Elaborative rehearsal – Information transferred from STM to LTM by making it meaningful – Deeper processing occurs with LTM Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White These students are rehearsing for a concert. They will use maintenance rehearsal (repeating the musical passages over and over) until they can play their parts perfectly. The movements of their fingers upon the strings of their instruments will be stored in long-term memory. How is this kind of long-term memory different from something like the memorized lines of one’s part in a play? Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Types of LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • Procedural (nondeclarative) memory – Includes memory for skills, procedures, habits, and conditioned responses – These memories are not conscious Implied to exist because they affect conscious behavior Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Types of LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • Declarative memory – Contains information that is conscious and known – Memory for facts Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Procedural (Nondeclarative) LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • Includes emotional associations, habits, simple conditioned reflexes – May or may not be in conscious awareness • Anterograde amnesia – Damage to hippocampus – New memories cannot be made – Usually does NOT affect procedural LTM Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Procedural knowledge, such as tying one’s shoes, often must be learned by doing, as it is difficult to put into words. Once this child learns how to tie shoes, the knowledge will always be there to retrieve. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Procedural (Nondeclarative) LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • Implicit memory – Memory not easily brought into conscious awareness Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.4 Tower of Hanoi The Tower of Hanoi is a puzzle that is solved in a series of steps by moving one disk at a time. The goal is to move all of the disks from peg A to peg C; the rules are that a larger disk can not be moved on top of a smaller one and a disk can not be moved if there are other disks on top of it. Amnesia patients were able to learn the procedure for solving the puzzle but could not remember that they knew how to solve it. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Declarative LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • All the things that people know • Semantic memory – General knowledge, such as language and information learned in formal education • Episodic memory – Knowledge of personal information Not readily available to others Includes daily activities and events Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Declarative LTM LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • Semantic and episodic memories are forms of explicit memory – Memory that is consciously known Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.5 Types of Long-Term Memories Long-term memory can be divided into declarative memories, which are factual and typically conscious (explicit) memories, and nondeclarative memories, which are skills, habits, and conditioned responses that are typically unconscious (implicit). Declarative memories are further divided into episodic memories (personal experiences) and semantic memories (general knowledge). Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White LTM Organization LO 5.5 Different types of long-term memory • LTM organized in terms of related meanings and concepts. • Semantic network model – Model of memory organization – Assumes information is stored in a connected fashion – Related concepts are stored physically closer to each other than those not related Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.6 An Example of a Semantic Network In the semantic network model of memory, concepts that are related in meaning are thought to be stored physically near each other in the brain. In this example, canary and ostrich are stored near the concept node for “bird,” whereas shark and salmon are stored near “fish.” But the fact that a canary is yellow is stored directly with that concept. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Retrieval Cues LO 5.6 Kinds of cues that help people remember • A stimulus for remembering • Encoding specificity – Retrieval of information is improved If related situation available when the memory is first formed is available when the memory is being retrieved – Example: Best room to take a test in is the room the material was learned in Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Retrieval Cues LO 5.6 Kinds of cues that help people remember • Encoding specificity – State-dependent learning Easier to recall memories if in same physiological or psychological state as in when memory was made Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White When this bride and groom dance together later on in their marriage, they will be able to recall this moment at their wedding and the happiness they felt at that time. State-dependent learning makes it easier for people to recall information stored while in a particular emotional state (such as the happiness of this couple) if the recall occurs in a similar emotional state. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Recall LO 5.6 Kinds of cues that help people remember • Recall – Information to be retrieved must be “pulled” from memory – Few external cues • Retrieval failure – Recall has failed temporarily – Tip of the tongue phenomenon Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Recall LO 5.6 Kinds of cues that help people remember • Serial position effect – Remember information at the beginning and end more accurately than information in the middle – Primacy effect Best remember information at the beginning of a body of information – Recency effect Best remember information at the end of a body of information Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White These people are waiting to audition for a play. The person who auditioned first and the one who auditioned last have the greatest chance of being remembered when the time comes for the director to choose. The serial position effect will cause the impression made by the actors who come in the “middle” to be less memorable. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.8 Serial Position Effect In the serial position effect, information at the beginning of a list will be recalled at a higher rate than information in the middle of the list (primacy effect), because the beginning information receives more rehearsal and may enter LTM. Information at the end of a list is also retrieved at a higher rate (recency effect), because the end of the list is still in STM, with no information coming after it to interfere with retrieval. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Recognition LO 5.7 How recall and recognition differ • The ability to match information or a stimulus to a stored image or fact • Usually easier than recall • Tends to be very accurate for images • False positive – Error of recognition – Recognize a stimulus not actually in memory Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Eyewitness Testimony LO 5.7 How recall and recognition differ • Elizabeth Loftus – Memory researcher also trained as a lawyer – Information provided after event can affect memory accuracy of initial event – Eyewitness testimony not always reliable Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Dr. Elizabeth Loftus is an internationally known expert on the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. She is often called on to testify in court cases. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Automatic Encoding and Flashbulb Memories LO 5.7 How recall and recognition differ • Automatic encoding – Information enters long-term memory with little or no effortful encoding • Flashbulb memories – Automatic encoding – Unexpected event with strong emotional associations – Emotions enhance formation of long-term memories Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Fans of entertainer Michael Jackson may remember the moment they heard of his death on June 25, 2009. Events like this are so emotional for many people that the memories for the event are stored automatically, as if the mind had taken a “flash” picture of that moment in time. Such “flashbulb” memories seem to be very accurate but are actually no more accurate than any other memory. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Constructive Processing of Memories LO 5.8 How long-term memories are formed • Constructive processing – Retrieval of memories altered, revised, or influenced by newer information • Hindsight bias – Memories get revised to reflect new information – Falsely believe, through revision of older memories that one correctly predicted the outcome of an event Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White These men may engage in “Monday morning quarterbacking” as they apply hindsight to their memories of this game. Their memories of the game may be altered by information they get afterward from the television, newspapers, or their friends. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Memory Retrieval Problems LO 5.8 How long-term memories are formed • Misinformation effect – Misleading information that becomes part of memory – Alters memory of the event itself – Even if information is provided in a different format, it can be incorporated Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Reliability of Memory Retrieval LO 5.9 False memory syndrome • False memory syndrome – Creation of inaccurate or false memories through the suggestion of others – Often while the person is under hypnosis – False memories are established in the brain in the same manner as real memories – False memories must be plausible in order to hold Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Forgetting LO 5.10 Different causes of forgetting • Curve of forgetting – Graph with distinct pattern – Forgetting is very fast immediately after learning – Later tapers off gradually • Distributed practice – Spacing of material to be remembered with breaks – Much better recall than mass learning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.9 Curve of Forgetting Ebbinghaus found that his recall of words from his memorized word lists was greatest immediately after learning the list but rapidly decreased within the first hour. After the first hour, forgetting leveled off. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Forgetting LO 5.10 Different causes of forgetting • Encoding failure – Failure to have processed information into memory – Information does not get past sensory memory – See penny often but difficult to recall details Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.10 Which Penny Is Real? Most people do not really look at the face of a penny. Which of these pennies represents an actual penny? The answer can be found on the next slide. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.10 (continued) Which Penny Is Real? Most people do not really look at the face of a penny. Which of these pennies represents an actual penny? The answer is A. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Forgetting: Memory Trace Decay Theory LO 5.10 Different causes of forgetting • Physical change in the brain that occurs when a memory is formed – Decay Loss of memory Due to the passage of time Memory trace is not used Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Forgetting: Memory Trace Decay Theory LO 5.10 Different causes of forgetting • Physical change in the brain that occurs when a memory is formed • Disuse Another name for decay Memories not used will eventually decay and disappear Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White The fact that this woman can remember the things shown in the pictures even after many years makes it unlikely that the memory trace decay theory can explain all forgetting in long-term memory. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Forgetting: Interference Theory LO 5.10 Different causes of forgetting • Proactive interference – Older information prevents or interferes with retrieval of newer information • Retroactive interference – Newer information prevents or interferes with the retrieval of older information Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.11 Proactive and Retroactive Interference If a student were to study for a French exam and then a Spanish exam, interference could occur in two directions. When taking the Spanish exam, the French information studied first may proactively interfere with the learning of the new Spanish information. But when taking the French exam, the more recently studied Spanish information may retroactively interfere with the retrieval of the French information. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Table 5.1 Reasons for Forgetting Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Neuroscience of Memory LO 5.11 How and where memories are formed in the brain • Procedural memories seem to be stored in the cerebellum • PET scans suggest short-term memories are stored in the prefrontal cortex and temporal lobe • Consolidation – Changes in structure and functioning of neurons when a memory is formed Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Amnesia LO 5.12 How does Amnesia occur • Retrograde amnesia – Loss of memory for the past – Memory loss coincides with injury or illness Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Amnesia LO 5.12 How does Amnesia occur • Anterograde amnesia – Inability to form new long-term memories Senile dementia – Form of anterograde amnesia though retrograde amnesia may also be present Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Alzheimer’s Disease LO 5.13 What are the facts about Alzheimer’s disease • 5.3 million Americans have Alzheimer’s (Alzheimer’s Association, 2010) • The most common type of dementia – 60 to 80 percent of all cases of dementia • Brain forms large number of betaamyloid protein deposits (plaques) – Strands of protein become twisted Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Alzheimer’s Disease LO 5.13 What are the facts about Alzheimer’s disease • Risk factors include diabetes, obesity, smoking, high cholesterol • Treatments slow but do not stop the disease • Involvement in new learning on daily basis stimulates brain derived neurotropic factors Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White