Harassment Policy and Procedure Guidance, Principles and Procedures for dealing with Harassment 1. Introduction The Corporation's aim is to have an environment which is conducive to effective work and study, ie all college members should feel comfortable and work and study in a friendly, co-operative way. This is the acceptable and reasonable standard it expects. The Corporation finds harassment in College unacceptable and it will therefore not be tolerated. To prevent harassment in College the Corporation has procedures which make it clear that all forms of harassment will be dealt with. All College members have a right to effective remedies when incidents occur and procedures ensure that quick and effective action is taken. The Policy applies to Governors, students, staff, contractors, visitors and the College Code makes a clear statement about the unacceptability of harassment and warns of the consequences of such behaviour. Harassment could lead to formal warnings and possible dismissal for staff, expulsion for students and barring for visitors and contractors from entering College premises. It is important to recognise that conduct which one person may find acceptable, another may find totally unacceptable. All employees must, therefore, treat their colleagues with respect and appropriate sensitivity. Complaints of harassment will be dealt with seriously, sympathetically and action will be taken promptly to investigate such complaints. Complaints will be carefully tracked and a note of how they are resolved will be kept. 1.1 Background Harassment is a serious problem which has often been dismissed as individuals being over sensitive. It can affect people's health, work, performance, and job prospects. ‘Bullying’ or ‘harassment’ are phrases that apply to treatment from one person (or a group of people) to another that is unwanted and that has the effect of violating that person’s dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating, or offensive environment for that person. It is not the intention of the perpetrators but the deed itself and the impact on the recipient that determines what is harassment. An act of harassment may not affect the person it was directly aimed at but another person may feel harassed by their treatment of that person. Forms of harassment may include: Physical contact RMa/JJe/106758089 unwanted contact, bullying, assault, gestures, intimidation or aggressive behaviour, touching, pestering, following or spying. 1 Verbal/written unwelcome remarks, lewd comments, suggestions and proposals, malicious gossip, jokes, banter, insult or innuendo, hate mail, sectarian remarks, ridicule Non verbal offensive literature or pictures, E-mail, graffiti, computer images, flags or emblems, isolation or exclusion, including from social activities, non co-operation, coercion both sexual or religious. This list is by no means exhaustive. The basis for harassment can be diverse: disabilities, impairments or learning difficulties belief, religious or political views or convictions race ethnicity, skin colour or age real or suspected infection with AIDS/HIV wearing of offensive or provocative insignia subjective assessment of work standard gender, gender reassignment or sexual orientation marriage, civil partnership, pregnancy, maternity Unacceptable behaviour includes: * Spreading malicious rumours, or insulting someone (particularly on gender/race/disability grounds) * Copying memos that are critical about someone to others who do not need to know * Ridiculing or demeaning someone – picking on them or setting them up to fail * Exclusion or victimisation * Making threats or comments about job security or their course of study without foundation. The communication can be in any form. Harassment or bullying may be perpetrated by people within the College on each, by college users on people outside the College or by people from outside college on College users. No form of harassment is acceptable to the College. It is the duty of all staff and students within the College to take responsibility for their own behaviour towards each other and stop behaviour that does not conform with this Policy where and when it occurs. Ultimately the College disciplinary codes will be invoked against those staff or students who harass others. Bullying does not include appropriate criticism of an employee’s or student’s behaviour or proper performance management. 1.2 Harassment and the Law Harassment is unacceptable in College and can be challenged in law, namely: RMa/JJe/106758089 2 Equality Act 2010 Fair Employment Acts 1976 and 1989 Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978 The Criminal Justice Public Order Act 1994 EC Resolution 1990 on the protection of dignity of women and men at work A Code of practice on measures to combat sexual harassment The Protection from Harassment Act 1997 The College is prima facie liable for what their employees do in the course of their employment, whether or not it is aware of their actions. They may avoid liability for harassment amounting to unlawful discrimination only if they can prove they took appropriate measures to ensure offending acts were not carried out. The employer’s liability is in addition to that of the individual employee’s liability for his/her actions. It is important to note that alleged harassers need not realise they are causing distress. They are liable if a reasonable person would know that they were. Causing such distress more than once could be described as bullying. This applies to, sexual orientation, racial or disability discrimination where criminal and/or civil action can be taken. Anyone found responsible for harassment of another may be personally liable, should the complainant undertake legal proceedings. Where possible the harassed person should make it known to the perpetrator that their behaviour is unwanted. Claims from individuals may be brought within the court system as well as, for staff, the tribunal system. No position will be jeopardised nor will they suffer any form of detriment or be victimised by filing a complaint involving harassment. This includes, for staff, terms and conditions, recruitment, promotion or responsibilities. 1.3 Responsibilities It is the duty of every member of the College and those visiting College premises to take responsibility for their behaviour and modify it if necessary as harassment is not acceptable under any circumstances. In the event of a failure to do so, disciplinary action in accordance with the College's disciplinary procedure may be a consequence and anyone found responsible may also be held personally liable should the person who has been harassed undertake legal proceedings. Managers are required to ensure that the policy is effectively applied and that harassment does not occur. The Corporation will ensure that this policy is widely publicised and its contents made known to all staff, students, contractors and visitors. 1.4 Training Information will be provided, to staff as part of the induction process. Specific training will also be provided for managers to ensure they gain the knowledge, skills and awareness of the relevant legislation necessary to operate the College's policy efficiently and effectively and to communicate this to their staff and students. 1.5 Support Framework Harassment, bullying and abuse can initially develop relatively unnoticed or from what was originally believed to be an innocent situation. Once it is recognised the victim may RMa/JJe/106758089 3 well want support. There are a variety of ways this may be available. Below are College, personal or professional references that could be used. College Counsellor who provides confidential support from someone trained to listen and advise, discuss options, talk through procedures. The counsellor will have no formal part in procedures as what is discussed is confidential A line manager who may be able to put things in context or advise on procedures. Where the person in authority causes harassment it may be that their superior would be the one to approach. Union representative who can explain and provide professional expertise and possibly assistance in making a complaint. Tutors/mentors who have a professional responsibility to assist Personnel staff who can advise on procedures, actions or rights If, after an investigation, one of the parties concerned in a personal harassment case has to be removed from the workplace, then as a matter of principle, the alleged harasser will be moved rather than the complainant. 1.6 Review and Monitoring of the Procedure It will be the responsibility of the Personnel and Equality Director to review and monitor the progress of the policy and the procedure on an annual basis and bring about change where necessary. 2. Procedures for dealing with Harassment 2.1 Introduction Complaints of harassment need to be handled in a sensitive manner. The procedure therefore seeks to ensure minimal stress for all concerned, timely resolution of complaints and a degree of flexibility appropriate to individual circumstances. The College will not normally consider a complaint of harassment raised more than twelve months after the series of incidents to which it relates or two weeks in the case of an isolated incident. At all stages of the procedure, the need to maintain confidentiality will be paramount. Information circulation will be minimised to that which is necessary to ensure a fair investigation and hearing. This procedure is separate from the disciplinary procedure, which may be used following the results of the investigation under this procedure. Alternatively, an incident may be serious enough to proceed straight away with the disciplinary procedure. If at any stage in this procedure an employee does not receive a response to a formal complaint in accordance with the specified or agreed time limits, or where the response is inadequate or in appropriate, the employee is entitled to raise the matter under the Corporation's Grievance Procedure. RMa/JJe/106758089 4 It is recognised that in bringing a complaint, the complainant must be protected from further harassment or detriment arising from the alleged incident and associated complaint. College members are encouraged to deal with the unwanted behaviour immediately as it happens by talking to the person informally and pointing out that their behaviour is unacceptable. 2.2 Keeping a record It is important that anyone who believes that they have suffered from harassment should keep notes of the details outlined below for each incident and that they are made as soon after the event as possible. Detailed notes should include the following: * * * * * * * * * 2.3 Date Time Place Name of person harassing them What actually happened How the person actually felt at the time Name of any witnesses Action taken and whether reported to management Any correspondence relating to the incidents and subsequent complaints Stage 1 Informal Resolution Before taking formal action you may wish to speak to someone informally. It is probable that an informal and internal approach may be preferable. The solution should be speedy, effective, confidential and avoid embarrassment. If you are being bullied or harassed by a customer, supplier or someone else with whom you come into contact at work, the matter should be raised with your line manager who will then decide how best to deal with the situation, in consultation with you. In all other cases, talk initially to the person causing offence. This should be as soon after an offence as possible and in a quiet and private place. Make sure you both have time to discuss the issue and make it perfectly clear you find the behaviour offensive and that you want it to cease. Make a note of the meeting and keep it safely in case you need it again. If you feel unable to approach the situation alone then you could ask for the assistance of a colleague, a Trade Union or Student Union representative, a line manager, a tutor or a member of the College management. They will adopt an informal approach with you. If the harassment is from your immediate superior, a subject lecturer or tutor you may wish to ask their line manager for assistance. If the harassment is more of a group issue, discuss the matter with your colleagues or tutor. It may be more appropriate and less threatening to deal with the matter informally. RMa/JJe/106758089 5 The informal reporting of harassment may necessitate investigation. This may be the case where there is a criminal offence or serious misconduct. (The College, in these circumstances may be compelled to act irrespective of the individual’s wishes and deal with the matter formally.) In all events discussions will be held within the confines of the investigation. The appropriate courses of action may then be followed: In certain circumstances it may be determined to involve a neutral third party (a mediator) to facilitate a resolution of the problem and this will be discussed with you if it is appropriate. To take no further action at this stage, but to record any future incidents as recommended above and to keep the situation under review, enabling the employee to seek further advice in the future if necessary. If the offender has not already been approached, then ask the person to stop the offending behaviour and again keep the situation under view. Make a formal complaint. It is worth noting that a third party witnessing harassment can make a complaint of harassment. 2.4 Stage 2 2.4.1 Formal procedure Where an informal approach has failed or the offence is of a serious nature or when an individual prefers to follow a more formal procedure, the individual should put in writing to their line manager, or the next line manager if their immediate manager is implicated. The letter needs to specify that it is a formal complaint giving details of the incident(s). On receipt of the complaint the Line Manager will contact the Personnel and Equality Director to arrange an investigation. The individual has the right to contact their trade union or student union representative to take up your complaint. Anyone affected by harassment may take legal action. Employees may also have the legal right to apply to an Employment Tribunal for a decision on the matter. An application to an Employment Tribunal must be made within three months of the alleged offence or for civil action through County Courts the period is six months. Again, it is worth noting that a third party witnessing harassment can make a complaint of harassment. 2.4.2 Police involvement In cases of an alleged assault or alleged behaviour that is considered to be a criminal offence, the Principal may contact the Police for their appropriate action, if the complainant so wishes and/or if the incident is considered to be a serious criminal offence. 2.4.3 Initial response The investigation will be carried out by a panel comprising of two designated managers and their scribe. Neither should be connected with the case in any RMa/JJe/106758089 6 way. The Personnel and Equality Director should ensure that those carrying out the investigation reflect the nature of the complaint in terms of race/sex/disability as far as possible. This may require consulting a third person. The Personnel and Equality Director can provide advice on this matter. The person against whom the complaint has been made should be informed of the nature of the complaint and details of the procedure involved and advised to seek representation. The investigator will meet with the complainant and the alleged harasser separately and with their respective representatives. Detailed written statements will be taken. Both parties should be given the opportunity to nominate witnesses whom they wish to be interviewed. The investigator will meet anyone else who was present or who has information that is relevant to the issue. Notes of this meeting will also be taken and the individuals called will be able to be accompanied by a friend or union representative. Further interviews may need to take place to clarify or gain further information. The manager will also need to ensure that they have collected all relevant written materials. 2.4.4 Investigating a complaint The investigating managers are required to protect the rights of both parties involved and ensure that both are entitled to a full and fair opportunity to put their version of events. Whilst carrying out an investigation it may be necessary to consider the separation of the parties involved. This could mean temporary re-deployment, changing timetables or for staff, suspension on full pay. All parties must act so as to not aggravate the situation. The persons investigating should RMa/JJe/106758089 make sure that the person is aware of their rights to be accompanied find a suitable quiet room where they will not be disturbed explain that information will remain confidential and the matter will not be communicated further without the knowledge and consent of the complainant listen to the complainant's allegations, clarify understanding and make notes meet with the alleged perpetrator and any witnesses identified by either party be thorough and impartial with due regard to the rights of all the parties involved question objectively and without preconceptions and without trying to reason the situation with the complainant remember you are investigating and not making judgements agree the next stage with the complainant and that they wish to continue with the complaint inform the complainant of the timescale of the procedure gather signed witness statements. 7 Give the commitment to confidentiality for everyone involved in the investigation and instil the need in the other parties involved. Ensure witnesses keep their evidence confidential. Follow the same guidelines as for any meetings involved in an investigation complainant, alleged perpetrator(s) or witnesses. Keep a written record of the complaint the time scales statements including dates, names, frequency of incidents signed notes from meetings agreed by the parties concerned informing the alleged harasser of the allegations against them Inform the complainant and alleged perpetrator(s) of follow up action if applicable. This could involve formal procedures, seeking senior management advice or referral to the Personnel and Equality Director/Student Experience Director. If agreements have been reached these should be stated along with any monitoring or training that has been agreed. 2.4.5 Time limits The panel should normally be completed within 15 working days of the complaint being received. On occasions, it will not be possible to keep within this timescale. In such cases, the complainant and the alleged offender must both be kept informed of any need for an extension and the likely timescale for completion. 2.4.6 Consideration of information The panel will, on completion of the investigation, review the material collected and decide whether the complaint is substantiated. This should then be forwarded to the Personnel and Equality Director to be dealt with, if necessary, as detailed in 2.4.7. In some cases, there will not be any witnesses and it will be one person's word against another's. In these cases, the disciplinary hearing will consider whether on the balance of probabilities, the incidents/actions occurred. In the case of students, then the Personnel and Equality Director should be replaced with Student Services Manager 2.4.7 Further action Formal actions will be taken through the disciplinary procedures and codes for staff or students. The investigation stage of the disciplinary procedures will be counted as having taken place where there has already been an informal investigation, if the: panel recommends that disciplinary action is justified then the Personnel and Equality Director should refer the matter under the Disciplinary Codes and Procedures. The panel’s enquiries will replace the investigative stage of these procedures. The alleged harasser will be entitled to a full hearing. allegation is not substantiated by the panel the Personnel and Equality Director should inform the complainant providing a written statement outlining RMa/JJe/106758089 8 the conclusions if requested. Where working relationships have nevertheless been harmed the panel may make recommendations about rescheduling of work, timetable or responsibilities to the appropriate managers/tutors. Generally the alleged harasser will be transferred although the person harassed may be given first refusal if they so wish. However, it would have to be the person's (victim's) own choice and their reasons for wanting to be the one moved must be given in writing. Panel upholds the complaint but decides disciplinary action would not be justified in the case. The Personnel and Equality Director/Student Experience Director may recommend to a line manager/tutor that they consider transfer of staff or students, training, re-deployment or compassionate leave until a satisfactory outcome can be found. Management action other than to initiate the disciplinary procedure. This could include: intervention by a third person (mediator) to agree working arrangements A recommendation of redeployment of one or both parties, either on a temporary or permanent basis. Should a transfer take place, this must not be on any less terms and conditions of employment, unless action is taken within the disciplinary procedure to demote an individual. Setting up arrangements to monitor the situation. Required attendance on training courses. Making arrangements for both parties to work as separately as possible within the same workplace. If you are unhappy with the way the complaint has been managed you may take out a grievance against the person(s) trying to resolve the situation. In either case you should be prepared to give evidence either in writing or in person. You would also be required to be available for questioning by the disciplinary or grievance panel. At all stages you have the right to be accompanied by a colleague and/or represented by your Union. Contractors/Visitors If any contractors/visitors are found to have harassed on College campuses, the Principal will decide whether or not an individual be allowed back on College premises again or refusal of services by a particular company. Counselling If counselling is recommended, it is not simply for those who believe themselves victims but also for those who behaviour is deemed as unacceptable. 3. Clarification and interpretation Clarification or interpretation is available from the Personnel and Equality Director or Student Services Manager RMa/JJe/106758089 9 4. After Disciplinary Procedure Where a complaint is upheld it may be necessary to re-locate or transfer one party. It is usual that this person would be the perpetrator, however, where practicable, the complainant will be given first choice as to whether or not they wish to be transferred. However, it would have to be the person's (victim's) own choice and they would have to state their reasons in writing why they would prefer to move. Where this occurs it will not lead to any disadvantage to the victim of harassment. Where the perpetrator is transferred it will not be in breach of their contract or conditions of service. This could lead to a constructive dismissal case by the perpetrator. Transfer, even on disadvantageous terms, may be offered as an alternative to dismissal where dismissal would otherwise be the appropriate sanction and the person in such a case would have to write to confirm this as an acceptable alternative to dismissal. A request for transfer may be considered even where a case is not substantiated rather than requiring persons to continue working together when the element of trust no longer exists. After the procedures have been followed, the Personnel and Equality Director or Student Services Manager will check that there has been no further victimisation. 5. Monitoring 5.1 Formal cases of harassment will be handled through the Disciplinary Procedures of the College and records kept in accordance with that procedure. 5.2 Records of complaints/grievances caused by harassment will be logged Personnel and Equality Director and Student Services Manager respectively and form part of the annual reporting cycle. 5.3 Any documentation should be passed to the Personnel and Equality Director for necessary follow-up and filing. Where the complaint remains informal no record will be held but the complainant should hold their own records of the meeting. A record will be made in the complaints book (see 5.2). If a case is not substantiated then no records will be kept on an individual’s file. Reviewed Reviewed by (Minor amendments only) Approved Impact Assessment Next review date RMa/JJe/106758089 By Jenny Jerina/Rachael Makinson Date 21 November 2013 CE Completed 27 November 2013 29 April 2014 November 2016 10