Motion Specific Concept: Projectile Motion Concept Presentation Nate Mohanlall, HS Physics OISE/UT Instructor: Maria Price 1. Background Information Gravity causes objects to accelerate downward. A projectile is an object moving in a vertical plane, under the influence of the force of gravity. The factors that affect the trajectory of a projectile motion are the initial velocity and the launch angle. The shape of the path of a projectile is parabolic and information such as maximum height, time of flight and horizontal range can be calculated. A complete mathematical representation of Projectile Motion is tested in both the grade 11 and 12 curriculum. It is recommended that teachers focus on both qualitative and quantitative understanding of the basic concepts and problem solving strategies. Teachers should also use many projectile-related applications and technologies to explain the concepts. 2. Curriculum Placement Elementary Curriculum The concept of Projectile of Motion is explored ONLY in grade 2 in the elementary curriculum. Grade 2 : Structures :Specific Expectations 2.2 investigate and describe different kinds of movement (e.g., by observing how toys and other everyday objects move) 3.2 identify ways in which the position of an object can be changed (e.g., by pushing, by pulling, by dropping) Secondary Curriculum There is no mention of this kind of motion in grade 9 or 10 science curriculum. Projectile of Motion is introduce in grade 11 (SPH3U) and taught in detailed in grade 12 physics course (SPH4U).The big ideas of the kinematics and dynamics units in SPH3U and SPH4U are summarized below. In the secondary curriculum students use mathematical representations to solve problems involving Projectiles Motion as it applies to real world situation Grade 11 Physics: Big Ideas Kinematics Motion involves a change in the position of an object over time. Motion can be described using mathematical relationships. Many technologies that apply concepts related to kinematics have societal and environmental implications. Grade 12 Physics: Big Ideas Dynamics Forces affect motion in predictable and quantifiable ways. Forces acting on an object will determine the motion of that object. Many technologies that utilize the principles of dynamics have societal and environmental implications. 3. Misconceptions Students develop personal “theories of motion” by generalising the ideas they acquire from observation of objects in everyday situations (Keeports, 2000) Misconception # 1: Heavier objects fall faster. Strategies use to address misconception: Demonstration: Use two balls with different masses and release from same height for tactile and visual learners Use Applets to demonstrate with explanation for visual and auditory learners. Explanation: By viewing the applets, demo and explanation students can conclude that heavier objects hit the ground at the same time as lighter ones.(Air resistance is ignore) Misconception # 2: If one object is dropped from a specific point and another is projected forward from the same point, then the projected object will take longer to reach the ground. Strategies use to address misconception: Demonstration: Drop one object from a specific point and another is projected forward from the same point for tactile and visual learners and while auditory learners listen for the number of sounds they hear - one or two - when the object hit the ground. Use Applets to demonstrate with explanation for all learners. Explanation: By viewing the applets and doing the demo students can conclude that both objects hit the ground at the same time. (Air resistance is ignore) Misconceptions # 3 Parabolic Motion: Showing the parabolic nature of projectiles leads the student to believe they are quite different from linear falling or horizontal motion Strategies use to address misconception: Demonstration: Use Applets to demonstrate for visual learners. Tactile learners can use chalkboard to sketch Explanation: An easy way to deal with this is to plot the motion of a freely falling object and a horizontally moving object on the same graph. When the intersection points at the same time, are connected, the result is a parabola Misconceptions # 4 Parabolic Motion: At the peak of its trajectory, the velocity of a projectile is always momentarily zero. The acceleration of the object is also zero, at the peak. Strategies use to address misconception: Demonstration: use chalkboard to sketch parabolic path to show all learners Explanation: Have students look at the horizontal and vertical velocity vectors throughout parabolic flight. Demonstrate that the velocity is not zero as there must be some horizontal motion still (it doesn’t stop in midair).If you throw an object in the air, it stops briefly (speed is zero) but acceleration is not zero (gravity doesn’t “lock-off”). Its role is to change the direction of the velocity vector. Misconception # 5: Students believe that the greater the angle of projection, the greater the horizontal distance travelled by a projectile. Strategies use to address misconception: Demonstration: Use Applets to demonstrate for visual learners. Tactile learners can use chalkboard to sketch projectile path Explanation: Seeing the animation students will quickly realize that the maximum horizontal range possible is at 45 degrees and as the angle increase or deceases the range decreases. 4. Lesson Sequence Description of Activity Teaching/Learning Strategies -Group work -Independent work(Graphic organizer) -Demo Projectile Motion(to reinforce concept quiz) Expectations Addressed Learning Styles Assessment A1.5 A1.10 A1.12 Kinesthetic/Tactile Visual Linguistic Intrapersonal Diagnostic 1. Discuss how objects release from the same height and projected horizontally and with different masses hit the ground the same time. 2. Parabolic motion and angle of projection 3. Comparing Horizontal Range :Using formula to verify maximum possible range using different angles and a fixed initial velocity -Animation B2.1 B2.2 Visual Auditory Kinesthetic/Tactile Interpersonal Formative Day 4: -Direct Instruction student involved Day 1: 1. Diagnostic lab :Projectile motion 2. Vocabulary : Complete graphic organizer using textbook B1.1 B2.1 - observe students as they complete graphic organizer and perform lab Concept quiz Day 2 and 3: 1. Problem Solving -Analyzing more complex projectile motion -Analyzing the motion of objects projected horizontally -Class work -Investigation Group work Textbook -Gizmos -Independent work Parallel Questions(DI) -PhysicsTool box B1.2 B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 - Checking for understanding Questioning of students based on their mathematical knowledge - Solve for maximum range using formula - Complete questions using Gizmos worksheet -concept quiz Formative Kinesthetic Visual Auditory - Concept circle Checking on students problem solving skills mathematical analysis of projectile motion - assignment (Parallel Questioning, DI) Summative - Quiz, Test 5. Advance Preparation/Materials needed Prepare Power Point Presentation and search for applets/ animations and other internet resources that will be used to target all learners. Gathering of materials to illustrate demo in the classroom Prepare Parallel Questions(DI) Prepare test, quiz (concept) and assignment 6. Applications and Societal Implications Sports e.g. base ball is a projectile game-the pitcher throws a ball at the batter, who hits it to an open area in the field. The outfielder catches the ball and throws it to second base. The runner is out. All aspects of this sequence involve projectile motion Weapons-the most complex form of projectile widely known in modern life is the rocket or missile. Missiles are unmanned vehicles, most often used in warfare to direct some form of explosive toward an enemy. Forensic -Ballistics (gunfire pattern undergoes projectile motion) is a significant part of police science for the purpose of crime-solving, because it allows lawenforcement investigators to determine when, where, and how a firearm was used. Forest Fire-water hose and water bomber uses projectile motion to out forest f ir e . Circus/fireworks- at a circus human cannon and fireworks undergoes projectile motion Drop food in disaster areas with airplane- the package release from a moving airplane will trace the path of a projectile. 7. Assessment and Evaluation Assignment- formative and ongoing Quiz-short quizzes on concept not calculation Test- problem solving testing mathematical representation and algebraic manipulations and concepts Lab- formative and summative and ongoing 8. Essential Expectations Grade 12 A1. Scientific Investigation Skills A1.5 conduct inquiries, controlling relevant variables, adapting or extending procedures as required, and using appropriate materials and equipment safely, accurately, and effectively, to collect observations and data A1.10 draw conclusions based on inquiry results and research findings, and justify their conclusions with reference to scientific knowledge A1.12 use appropriate numeric (e.g., SI and imperial units), symbolic, and graphic modes of representation (e.g., vector diagrams, free-body diagrams, vector components, and Algebraic equations) B1. Relating Science to Technology, Society, and the Environment B1.1 analyse, on the basis of research, a technology that applies concepts related to kinematics (e.g., devices used to measure speed in sports; rocket accelerators; motion-detecting sensors for security systems; speedometers in automobiles) [IP, PR, AI, C] B2. Developing Skills of Investigation and Communication B2.1 use appropriate terminology related to kinematics, including, but not limited to: time, distance, position, displacement, speed, velocity, and acceleration [C] B2.6 plan and conduct an inquiry into the motion of objects in one dimension, using vector diagrams and uniform acceleration equations [IP, PR, C] B2.8 use kinematic equations to solve problems related to the horizontal and vertical components of the motion of a projectile (e.g., a cannon ball shot horizontally off a cliff, a ball rolling off a table, a golf ball launched at a 45º angle to the horizontal) [AI, C] 9. Annotated References On-Line Resources http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/curriculum/elementary/scientec18currb.pdf. http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/curriculum/secondary/2009science11_12.pdf http://www.explorelearning.com/index.cfm?method=cResource.dspDetail&ResourceID=523 http://www.physicsclassroom.com/mmedia/vectors/bds.gif http://www.lon-capa.org/~mmp/kap3/cd060.htm http://www.walter-fendt.de/ph14e/projectile.htm http://www.falstad.com/mathphysics.html http://www.physicsclassroom.com/mmedia/vectors/mzi.cfm Print Resources 1. Hirsch, Alan J., et al, Physics 12, Toronto, ON, Nelson Thomson Canada Ltd., , 2003, Dynamics 2. Keeports, D. (2000). Addressing physical intuition-a first day event. The Physics Teacher,38, 318-319.