Introduction Gears are machine elements used to transmit rotary motion between two shafts, normally with a constant ratio. The pinion is the smallest gear and the larger gear is called the gear wheel.. A rack is a rectangular prism with gear teeth machined along one side- it is in effect a gear wheel with an infinite pitch circle diameter. In practice the action of gears in transmitting motion is a cam action each pair of mating teeth acting as cams. Gear design has evolved to such a level that throughout the motion of each contacting pair of teeth the velocity ratio of the gears is maintained fixed and the velocity ratio is still fixed as each subsequent pair of teeth come into contact. When the teeth action is such that the driving tooth moving at constant angular velocity produces a proportional constant velocity of the driven tooth the action is termed a conjugate action. The teeth shape universally selected for the gear teeth is the involute profile. Consider one end of a piece of string is fastened to the OD of one cylinder and the other end of the string is fastened to the OD of another cylinder parallel to the first and both cylinders are rotated in the opposite directions to tension the string(see figure below). The point on the string midway between the cylinder P is marked. As the left hand cylinder rotates CCW the point moves towards this cylinder as it wraps on . The point moves away from the right hand cylinder as the string unwraps. The point traces the involute form of the gear teeth. 1 The lines normal to the point of contact of the gears always intersects the centre line joining the gear centres at one point called the pitch point. For each gear the circle passing through the pitch point is called the pitch circle. The gear ratio is proportional to the diameters of the two pitch circles. For metric gears (as adopted by most of the worlds nations) the gear proportions are based on the module. m = (Pitch Circle Diameter (mm)) / (Number of teeth on gear). In the USA the module is not used and instead the Diametric Pitch Pd is used d p = (Number of Teeth) / Diametrical Pitch (inches) 2 Profile of a standard 1mm module gear teeth for a gear with Infinite radius, Rack . Other module teeth profiles are directly proportion . e.g. 2mm module teeth are 2 x this profile Many gears trains are very low power applications with an object of transmitting motion with minimum torque e.g. watch and clock mechanisms, instruments, toys, music boxes etc. These applications do not require detailed strength calculations. Standards AGMA 2001-C95 or AGMA-2101-C95 Fundamental Rating factors and Calculation Methods for involute Spur Gear and Helical Gear Teeth BS 436-4:1996, ISO 1328-1:1995..Spur and helical gears. Definitions and allowable values of deviations relevant to corresponding flanks of gear teeth BS 436-5:1997, ISO 1328-2:1997..Spur and helical gears. Definitions and allowable values of deviations relevant to radial composite deviations and runout information BS ISO 6336-1:1996 ..Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears. Basic principles, introduction and general influence factors BS ISO 6336-2:1996..Calculation of load capacity of spur and 3 helical gears. Calculation of surface durability (pitting) BS ISO 6336-3:1996..Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears. Calculation of tooth bending strength BS ISO 6336-5:2003..Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears. Strength and quality of materials If it is necessary to design a gearbox from scratch the design process in selecting the gear size is not complicated - the various design formulae have all been developed over time and are available in the relevant standards. However significant effort, judgment and expertise are required in designing the whole system including the gears, shafts, bearings, gearbox, and lubrication. For the same duty many different gear options are available for the type of gear, the materials and the quality. It is always preferable to procure gearboxes from specialized gearbox manufacturers 4 Terminology - spur gears Diametral pitch (d p )...... The number of teeth per one inch of pitch circle diameter. Module. (m) ...... The length, in mm, of the pitch circle diameter per tooth. Circular pitch (p)...... The distance between adjacent teeth measured along the are at the pitch circle diameter Addendum ( h a )...... The height of the tooth above the pitch circle diameter. Centre distance (a)...... The distance between the axes of two gears in mesh. Circular tooth thickness (ctt)...... The width of a tooth measured along the are at the pitch circle diameter. Dedendum ( h f )...... The depth of the tooth below the pitch circle diameter. Outside diameter ( D o )...... The outside diameter of the gear. Base Circle diameter ( D b ) ...... The diameter on which the involute teeth profile is based. Pitch circle dia ( p ) ...... The diameter of the pitch circle. Pitch point...... The point at which the pitch circle diameters of two gears in mesh coincide. Pitch to back...... The distance on a rack between the pitch circle diameter line and the rear face of the rack. Pressure angle ...... The angle between the tooth profile at the pitch circle diameter and a radial line passing through the same point. Whole depth...... The total depth of the space between adjacent teeth. 5 6 Spur Gear Design The spur gear is is simplest type of gear manufactured and is generally used for transmission of rotary motion between parallel shafts. The spur gear is the first choice option for gears except when high speeds, loads, and ratios direct towards other options. Other gear types may also be preferred to provide more silent low-vibration operation. A single spur gear is generally selected to have a ratio range of between 1:1 and 1:6 with a pitch line velocity up to 25 m/s. The spur gear has an operating efficiency of 98-99%. The pinion is made from a harder material than the wheel. A gear pair should be selected to have the highest number of teeth consistent with a suitable safety margin in strength and wear. The minimum number of teeth on a gear with a normal pressure angle of 20 degrees is 18. The preferred numbers of teeth (N) are as follows 12 13 14 15 16 18 20 22 24 25 28 30 32 34 38 40 45 50 54 60 64 70 72 75 80 84 90 96 100 120 140 150 180 200 220 250 Materials used for gears Mild steel is a poor material for gears as it has poor resistance to surface loading. The carbon content for unhardened gears is generally 0.4 % (min) with 0.55 % (min) carbon for the pinions. Dissimilar materials should be used for the meshing gears - this particularly applies to alloy steels. Alloy steels have superior fatigue properties compared to carbon steels for comparable strengths. For extremely high gear loading case hardened steels are used the surface hardening method employed should be such to provide sufficient case depth for the final grinding process used. 7 Material Notes Ferrous metals Low Cost easy to machine with high damping applications Large moderate power, commercial gears Power gears with medium rating to Cast Steels Low cost, reasonable strength commercial quality Good machining, can be heat Power gears with medium rating to Plain-Carbon Steels treated commercial/medium quality Heat Treatable to provide Highest power requirement. For Alloy Steels highest strength and durability precision and high precision Good corrosion resistance. Non- Corrosion resistance with low power Stainless Steels (Aust) magnetic ratings. Up to precision quality Hardenable, Reasonable Low to medium power ratings Up to Stainless Steels (Mart) corrosion resistance, magnetic high precision levels of quality Non-Ferrous metals Light weight, non-corrosive and Light duty instrument gears up to Aluminum alloys good machineability high precision quality Low cost, non-corrosive, low cost commercial quality gears. Brass alloys excellent machinability Quality up to medium precision Excellent machinability, low For use with steel power gears. Bronze alloys friction and good compatibility Quality up to high precision with steel Light weight with poor corrosion Light weight low load gears. Quality Magnesium alloys resistance up to medium precision Low coefficient of thermal Special gears for thermal Nickel alloys expansion. Poor machinability applications to commercial quality High strength, for low weight, Special light weight high strength Titanium alloys good corrosion resistance gears to medium precision Low cost with low precision and High production, low quality gears Di-cast alloys strength to commercial quality Low cost, low quality, moderate High production, low quality to Sintered powder alloys strength moderate commercial quality Non metals Cast Iron Acetal (Delrin Wear resistant, low water absorption Long life , low load bearings to commercial quality Phenolic laminates Low cost, low quality, moderate strength High production, low quality to moderate commercial quality 8 Nylons No lubrication, no lubricant, absorbs water Long life at low loads to commercial quality PTFE Low friction and no lubrication Special low friction gears to commercial quality Equations for basic gear relationships It is acceptable to marginally modify these relationships, e.g., to modify the addendum / dedendum to allow Centre Distance adjustments. Any changes modifications will affect the gear performance in good and bad ways... Addendum Base Circle diameter Centre distance Circular pitch Circular tooth thickness Dedendum Module Number of teeth Outside diameter h a = m = 0.3183 p Db = d.cos α a = ( d g + d p) / 2 p = m.π ctt = p/2 h f = h - a = 1,25m = 0,3979 p m = d /n z=d/m D o = (z + 2) x m Pitch circle diameter d = n . m ... (d g = gear & d p = pinion ) Whole depth(min) Top land width(min) h = 2.25 . m t o = 0,25 . m 9 10 Module (m) The module is the ratio of the pitch diameter to the number of teeth. The unit of the module is millimeters. Below is a diagram showing the relative size of teeth machined in a rack with module ranging from module values of 0,5 mm to 6 mm The preferred module values (in mm) are 0,5 0,8 1.0 1,25 6 8 10 12 1,5 2,5 16 20 3 4 5 25 32 40 50 11 Normal Pressure angle (φn) An important variable affecting the geometry of the gear teeth is the normal pressure angle. This is generally standardized at 20o. Other pressure angles should be used only for special reasons and using considered judgment. The following changes result from increasing the pressure angle Reduction in the danger of undercutting and interference Reduction of slipping speeds Increased loading capacity in contact, seizure and wear Increased rigidity of the toothing Increased noise and radial forces Gears required to have low noise levels have pressure angles 15o to17.5o Contact Ratio The gear design is such that when in mesh the rotating gears have more than one gear in contact and transferring the torque for some of the time. This property is called the contact ratio. This is a ratio of the length of the line-of-action to the base pitch. The higher the contact ratio the more the load is shared between teeth. It is good practice to maintain a contact ratio of 1.2 or greater. Under no circumstances should the ratio drop below 1.1. A contact ratio between 1 and 2 means that part of the time two pairs of teeth are in contact and during the remaining time one pair is in contact. A ratio between 2 and 3 means 2 or 3 pairs of teeth are always in contact. Such as high contact ratio generally is not obtained with external spur gears, but can be developed in the 12 meshing of an internal and external spur gear pair or specially designed non-standard external spur gears. (Rgo2 - Rgb2 )1/2 + (Rpo2 - Rpb2 )1/2 - a sin φ contact ratio m = p cos φ R go = D go / 2..Radius of Outside Dia of Gear R gb = D gb / 2..Radius of Base Dia of Gear R po = D po / 2..Radius of Outside Dia of Pinion R pb = D pb / 2..Radius of Base Dia of Pinion p = circular pitch. a = ( d g+ d p )/2 = center distance. Spur gear Forces, torques, velocities & Powers F = tooth force between contacting teeth (at angle pressure angle φ to pitch line tangent. (N) F t = tangential component of tooth force (N) F s = Separating component of tooth force α= Pressure angle d 1 = Pitch Circle Dia -driving gear (m) d 2 = Pitch Circle Dia -driven gear (m) ω 1 = Angular velocity of driver gear (Rads/s) ω 2 = Angular velocity of driven gear (Rads/s) z 1 = Number of teeth on driver gear z 2 = Number of teeth on driven gear P = power transmitted (Watts) M = torque (Nm) η = efficiency Tangential force on gears F t = F cos φ 13 Separating force on gears F s = F t tan φ Torque on driver gear T 1 = F t d 1 / 2 Torque on driver gear T 2 = F t d 2 / 2 Speed Ratio = ω 1 / ω 2 = d 2 / d 1 = z 2 /z 1 Input Power P 1 = T1 .ω 1 Output Power P 2 = η.T 1 .ω 2 Spur gear Strength and durability calculations Designing spur gears is normally done in accordance with standards the two most popular series are listed under standards above: The notes below relate to approximate methods for estimating gear strengths. The methods are really only useful for first approximations and/or selection of stock gears (ref links below). — Detailed design of spur and helical gears is best completed using the standards. Books are available providing the necessary guidance. Software is also available making the process very easy. A very reasonably priced and easy to use package is included in the links below (Mitcalc.com) The determination of the capacity of gears to transfer the required torque for the desired operating life is completed by determining the strength of the gear teeth in bending and also 14 the surface durability, i.e., of the teeth ( resistance to wearing/bearing/scuffing loads ) .. The equations below are based on methods used by Buckingham.. Bending The basic bending stress for gear teeth is obtained by using the Lewis formula σ = Ft / ( ba. m. Y ) F t = Tangential force on tooth = Wt (alşo used) in [N] σ = Tooth Bending stress (MPa) b a = Face width (mm) = F (in some books) Y = Lewis Form Factor m = Module (mm) Note: The Lewis formula is often expressed as σ = Ft / ( ba. p. y ) Where y = Y/π and p = circular pitch When a gear wheel is rotating the gear teeth come into contact with some degree of impact. To allow for this a velocity factor is introduced into the equation. This is given by the Barth equation for milled profile gears. K v = 6,1 / (6,1 +V ) V = the pitch line velocity in m/s and when d is in m/s, 15 V = d.ω/2 (m/s) Or when d is in mm, V = πdn/60,000 (m/s) Note: This factor is different for different gear conditions i.e., K v = ( 3.05 + V )/3.05 for cast iron, cast profile gears. The Lewis formula is thus modified as follows σ = K v.Ft / ( ba. m. Y ) In general, for AGMA STRESS EQUATION KV = [A + (200 V)1/2]B / A Where B = 0,25 (12 – QV)2/3 and A = 50 + 56 (1-B) σ = [Wt/(bmtJ)] (KO KV KS KH KB) (14-16) KO = The Overload Factor, (Figures 14-17 and 14-18) KV = The Dynamic Factor, (Eq.14-27) KS = The Size Factor, (KS = 0,8433 [bmt (Y)1/2]0.0535 ) 14-10. KH = Km = The Load Distributıon Factor, and KB = The Rim-Thickness Factor. 16 Surface Durability This calculation involves determining the contact stress between the gear teeth and uses the Herz Formula σ w = 2.F / ( π .b .l ) σ w = largest surface pressure F = force pressing the two cylinders (gears) together l = length of the cylinders (gear) b = halfwidth = d 1 ,d 2 Are the diameters for the two contacting cylinders. ν 1, ν 2 Poisson ratio for the two gear materials E 1 ,E 2 Are the Young's Modulus Values for the two gears To arrive at the formula used for gear calculations the following changes are made F is replaced by F t/ cos α d is replaced by 2.r l is replaced by W The velocity factor K v as described above is introduced. Also an elastic constant Z E is created 17 When the value of E used is in MPa then the units of Cp are √ MPa = KPa The resulting formula for the compressive stress developed is as shown below The dynamic contact stress c developed by the transmitted torque must be less than the allowable contact stress Se. (α = φ.). Note: Values for Allowable stress values Se and ZE for some materials are provided at Gear Table r1 = d1 sin φ /2 r2 = d2 sin φ /2 Important Note: The above equations do not take into account the various factors which are integral to calculations completed using the relevant standards. These equations therefore yield results suitable for first estimate design purposes only... 18 Design Process To select gears from a stock gear catalogue or do a first approximation for a gear design select the gear material and obtain a safe working stress e.g Yield stress / Factor of Safety. /Safe fatigue stress Determine the input speed, output speed, ratio, torque to be transmitted Select materials for the gears (pinion is more highly loaded than gear) Determine safe working stresses (uts /factor of safety or yield stress/factor of safety or Fatigue strength / Factor of safety ) Determine Allowable endurance Stress Se Select a module value and determine the resulting geometry of the gear Use the Lewis formula and the endurance formula to establish the resulting face width If the gear proportions are reasonable then - proceed to more detailed evaluations If the resulting face width is excessive - change the module or material or both and start again The gear face width should be selected in the range 9-15 x module or for straight spur gears-up to 60% of the pinion diameter. 19 Internal Gears Advantages: 1. Geometry ideal for epicyclic gear design 2. Allows compact design since the center distance is less than for external gears. 3. A high contact ratio is possible. 4. Good surface endurance due to a convex profile surface working against a concave surface. Disadvantages: 1. Housing and bearing supports are more complicated, because the external gear nests within the internal gear. 2. Low ratios are unsuitable and in many cases impossible because of interferences. 3. Fabrication is limited to the shaper generating process, and usually special tooling is required. 20 21 Lewis form factor,Y. Table of Lewis Form Factors for different tooth forms and pressure angles No Teeth Load Near Tip of Teeth 14 1/2 deg Y y 20 deg FD Y y Load at Near Middle of Teeth 20 deg Stub 25 deg Y y Y 14 1/2 deg y Y y 20 deg FD Y y 10 0,176 0,056 0,201 0,064 0,261 0,083 0,238 0,076 11 0,192 0,061 0,226 0,072 0,289 0,092 0,259 0,082 12 0,21 13 0,223 0,071 0,264 0,084 0,324 0,103 0,293 0,093 0,377 0,12 14 0,236 0,075 0,276 0,088 0,339 0,108 0,307 0,098 0,399 0,127 0,468 0,149 15 0,245 0,078 0,289 0,092 0,349 0,111 0,32 16 0,255 0,081 0,295 0,094 0,36 17 0,264 0,084 0,302 0,096 0,368 0,117 0,342 0,109 0,446 0,142 0,512 0,163 18 0,27 19 0,277 0,088 0,314 0,1 20 0,283 0,09 21 0,289 0,092 0,326 0,104 0,399 0,127 0,377 0,12 22 0,292 0,093 0,33 23 0,296 0,094 0,333 0,106 0,408 0,13 24 0,302 0,096 0,337 0,107 0,411 0,131 0,396 0,126 0,509 0,162 0,572 0,182 25 0,305 0,097 0,34 26 0,308 0,098 0,344 0,109 0,421 0,134 0,407 0,13 27 0,311 0,099 0,348 0,111 0,426 0,136 0,412 0,131 0,528 0,168 0,588 0,187 28 0,314 0,1 29 0,316 0,101 0,355 0,113 0,434 0,138 0,421 0,134 0,537 0,171 0,599 0,191 30 0,318 0,101 0,358 0,114 0,437 0,139 0,425 0,135 0,54 31 0,32 0,067 0,245 0,078 0,311 0,099 0,277 0,088 0,355 0,113 0,415 0,132 0,32 0,102 0,415 0,132 0,49 0,115 0,332 0,106 0,43 0,086 0,308 0,098 0,377 0,12 0,443 0,141 0,156 0,137 0,503 0,16 0,352 0,112 0,459 0,146 0,522 0,166 0,386 0,123 0,361 0,115 0,471 0,15 0,534 0,17 0,102 0,393 0,125 0,369 0,117 0,481 0,153 0,544 0,173 0,49 0,156 0,553 0,176 0,105 0,404 0,129 0,384 0,122 0,496 0,158 0,559 0,178 0,390 0,124 0,502 0,16 0,565 0,18 0,108 0,416 0,132 0,402 0,128 0,515 0,164 0,58 0,352 0,112 0,43 0,101 0,361 0,115 0,44 0,522 0,166 0,584 0,186 0,137 0,417 0,133 0,534 0,17 0,14 0,185 0,592 0,188 0,172 0,606 0,193 0,429 0,137 0,554 0,176 0,611 0,194 22 32 0,322 0,101 0,364 0,116 0,443 0,141 0,433 0,138 0,547 0,174 0,617 0,196 33 0,324 0,103 0,367 0,117 0,445 0,142 0,436 0,139 0,55 34 0,326 0,104 0,371 0,118 0,447 0,142 0,44 35 0,327 0,104 0,373 0,119 0,449 0,143 0,443 0,141 0,556 0,177 0,633 0,201 36 0,329 0,105 0,377 0,12 37 0,33 38 0,333 0,106 0,384 0,122 0,455 0,145 0,452 0,144 0,565 0,18 39 0,335 0,107 0,386 0,123 0,457 0,145 0,454 0,145 0,568 0,181 0,655 0,208 40 0,336 0,107 0,389 0,124 0,459 0,146 0,457 0,145 0,57 43 0,339 0,108 0,397 0,126 0,467 0,149 0,464 0,148 0,574 0,183 0,668 0,213 45 0,34 50 0,346 0,11 55 0,352 0,112 0,415 0,132 0,48 60 0,355 0,113 0,421 0,134 0,484 0,154 0,491 0,156 0,603 0,192 0,713 0,227 65 0,358 0,114 0,425 0,135 0,488 0,155 0,496 0,158 0,607 0,193 0,721 0,23 70 0,36 75 0,361 0,115 0,433 0,138 0,496 0,158 0,506 0,161 0,613 0,195 0,735 0,234 80 0,363 0,116 0,436 0,139 0,499 0,159 0,509 0,162 0,615 0,196 0,739 0,235 90 0,366 0,117 0,442 0,141 0,503 0,16 100 0,368 0,117 0,446 0,142 0,506 0,161 0,521 0,166 0,622 0,198 0,755 0,24 150 0,375 0,119 0,458 0,146 0,518 0,165 0,537 0,171 0,635 0,202 0,778 0,248 0,105 0,38 0,14 0,175 0,623 0,198 0,553 0,176 0,628 0,2 0,451 0,144 0,446 0,142 0,559 0,178 0,639 0,203 0,121 0,454 0,145 0,449 0,143 0,563 0,179 0,645 0,205 0,65 0,207 0,181 0,659 0,21 0,108 0,399 0,127 0,468 0,149 0,468 0,149 0,579 0,184 0,678 0,216 0,408 0,13 0,474 0,151 0,477 0,152 0,588 0,187 0,694 0,221 0,153 0,484 0,154 0,596 0,19 0,115 0,429 0,137 0,493 0,157 0,501 0,159 0,61 0,704 0,224 0,194 0,728 0,232 0,516 0,164 0,619 0,197 0,747 0,238 23 200 0,378 0,12 0,463 0,147 0,524 0,167 0,545 0,173 0,64 300 0,38 0,122 0,471 0,15 Rack 0,39 0,124 0,484 0,154 0,55 0,534 0,17 0,554 0,176 0,65 0,175 0,566 0,18 0,66 0,204 0,787 0,251 0,207 0,801 0,255 0,21 0,823 0,262 24