Space Travel and Exploration: Dream vs. Reality 7th and 8th Grade Mr. Peter Boettcher Course Description What makes dreams become reality? What do Sputnik, the Apollo missions, NASA, International Space Station and the Spirit and Opportunity rovers on Mars have in common? Is the price for a dream becoming a reality worth the end result? Do we live alone in the solar system/galaxy? Through participation in group and individual work, thought-provoking questions, article and book reading, a simulator, involvement in a debate and completion of a Space Exploration Webquest, students will explore the past, present and future of space travel and exploration, determine the pros and cons of investigating the unknown realm we call space, and create an opinion on whether we live alone or if there are other life forms present. Required Reading: October Sky - Homer Hickam (New and Used starting at $4.00 with shipping through Amazon.com or New for $7.99 through Barnes and Noble) The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must - Robert Zubrin (New and Used starting at $4.00 with shipping through Amazon.com) "NASA - The Vision for Space Exploration " February 2004 www.nasa.gov/pdf/55583main_vision_space_exploration2.pdf Suggested Reading: Information on Astronauts and The Space Shuttle http://kidskonnect.com/SpaceShuttle/SpaceShuttleHome.html http://kidskonnect.com/Astronauts/AstronautsHome.html Space Station Science: Life in Free Fall - Marianne J Dyson Off the Planet: Surviving Five Perilous Months Abroad The Space Station Mir - Jerry M Linenger Cluster: Identity Course Benchmarks Reading: 29 (Making Personal Connections) This student used an understanding of his/her perspective and personal needs as he/she read and researched a variety of fiction and non-fiction sources to find content, themes and solutions and to prioritize them according to his/her own personal philosophy. This student easily connected new information into his/her own frame of reference; empathized with the characters to uncover the subtle motivations; and predicted future choices; mapped the dynamic relationships and their effects of the plot; and was able to articulate the voice and tone of the characters and author throughout the text. Writing: 71 (General writing skills) This student’s work fluidly incorporated real life experiences and research to add intriguing details closely connected to a clear theme/thesis demonstrating a reflective/insightful voice. Advanced uses of content specific vernacular; varied use of sentence structures; seamless transitions between sub-topics; and error-free writing conventions eliminated communication blocks between the writer and the intended audience. In collaborative settings, this student not only made it a point to give frequent, high quality feedback to others, but also enlisted the feedback of others to develop his/her own thought process and writing style. Behavior: 74 (General Behavior) This student set learning goals for him/herself, worked through learning hurdles, followed directions, met deadlines and continuously reflected on their own growth. When in collaborative settings, he/she showed enthusiasm and leadership when responding to both the instructor and fellow students, worked well as part of a group/team, shared responsibility, and contributed positively to the group. Big Picture: 65 (Classifying and Diagnosis) This student was able to identify, select, and classify selected items/processes correctly as a result of thoroughly understanding the attributes of those items/processes. He/she also used current knowledge to further define the items/processes, uncover hidden attributes, diagnose likely causes or effects, and/or prescribe possible solutions to related problems. Application: 40 (Leadership Strategies) This student applied leadership strategies by articulating a clear, informed vision; by using team building strategies to incorporate the diversity of perspectives impacted by his/her objectives; by communicating how factors were balanced and decisions were made; by detailing procedural steps to initiate the plan; by demonstrating delegation skill through matching the strengths of the group to tasks at hand; by using motivational and conflict management approaches to ensure progression toward an end goal; and/or by justly using positive/negative reinforcement strategies to create establish a sense of fairness. Final Project Description The final project for this course will involve students working in small groups to complete a webquest about The Space Race. We have sent rockets into outer space, satellites into orbit, probes to other planets, men to the moon, shuttles routinely take off and we are building an international space station! Would you like to go into space? How about to Mars or Jupiter? The cost of space travel is in the billions of dollars and we have millions of people that are starving and homeless. Should we take care of these people or should we continue our quest for more knowledge of the unknown? You are a state senator, and it is your job to approve the latest funding bill for NASA. Being that you are newly elected, you don’t know that much about space travel. To learn more, so that you may make an informed decision, you and your aides are going to research our government’s past space expenses, as well as those of other countries. You are also going to talk to your constituents (the people who elected you!) and get their opinions. You will learn about all the advancements in space travel and the justifications and costs involved with it. Then you will form opinions as to whether you agree or disagree with these costs. You are going to be put in groups and given a position to defend. After your group has investigated the issues and understood the background information you will begin to formulate your facts and ideas to be presented to the class. Your group will need to present your side of the argument to the class and answer questions. The groups will be seated at individual tables and have all of their facts organized in order to answer questions in support of their assigned roles. Another group will be working against your position at the same time. When giving your facts and opinions you should be firm believers and try to convince the class that yours is the right position. Each week students are to complete a Guiding Question with designated Branching Activity/Activities, a reading activity, and a Show What You Know activity. Theme One: Dreams Becoming Reality. WEEK ONE: What is meant by "The Space Race?" Guiding Question (66): Imagine being your age but living in 1957. You go outside to see what everyone is fussing about and see Sputnik streak across the night sky. You overhear people being in awe but also concerned that this "thing" is spying on them, and wondering why the USA hasn't done anything like this. You sit and ponder for a bit. You get an idea in your head but realize that it is probably only a dream. You need to articulate a dream you have had for the future. Then you need to describe how you made or how you plan to make your dream become reality. Was there anyone you knew supporting you in your quest? Students also need to choose at least one of the following to complete before posting to the Guiding Question: Systems (71): Using the website(s) provided online, research the major events that have taken place during "The Space Race" starting in 1957 with Sputnik. Organize these events into a timeline to include the date, name of the event/mission and who participated in this event. Human Experience (71): Take a look at the TIME - Building Analytical Skills Space Exploration cartoons. Take time to read each one, and then complete the Analysis Rubric for each cartoon. Finally, in a short paragraph, explain why the cartoonist decided to create these cartoons and what type of message(s) are they trying to send to the readers. Identity (71): Put yourself in the shoes of a visiting "alien" from space. Write a letter to the visiting "alien" describing what it is like to be a human on Earth, and what your opinion is about current space exploration, describing why you feel we haven't encountered "aliens" while on the different missions to date. Your letter should include a salutation, body with minimum of 2 paragraphs, a complimentary closing, writer's signature and writer's identification. Invention (71): Though "The Space Race" began with the launch of Sputnik and many Americans wanted the government to respond quickly, many events had to take place before Americans would enter the race. Using the websites provided online, thoroughly describe the person/persons responsible for enabling Americans to go into space, and how their actions led to numerous events that have taken place since. Reading (29): Read through Chapter 6 (page 111)in October Sky. Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (65): Click on the link The History of Manned Spaceflight. Follow the directions provided and working individually, complete the required research and subsequent paper. This is due by the beginning of week three. WEEK TWO: How Can Dreams Become Reality? Guiding Question (74): Can all dreams become reality? Explain why or why not in a well-formed paragraph(s) which uses both outside quotes (possibly from October Sky) and real-life experiences as support. Be sure to cite your work. Students are also to choose at least two of the following: Human Experience 74): Read the description and quotes below and answer these questions in a well-formed paragraph: Did Goddard's dream come true? Why or why not? Did his dream play a role in other aspects of space exploration? Robert Hutchins Goddard (1882-1945), a native of Worcester, Massachusetts, Goddard's family was staying at the suburban home of friends in Worcester when, on October 19, 1899, he climbed into an old cherry tree to prune its dead branches. Instead, he began daydreaming: "It was one of the quiet, colorful afternoons of sheer beauty which we have in October in New England, and as I looked toward the fields at the east, I imagined how wonderful it would be to make some device which had even the possibility of ascending to Mars, and how it would look on a small scale, if sent up from the meadow at my feet." That was when young Goddard decided to pursue the idea of spaceflight. He later wrote "I was a different boy when I descended the tree from when I ascended, for existence at last seemed very purposive." Identity (74): Go to the website links found below and read the interviews of both "Rocket Boy" Homer Hickam Jr. and "Human Space Flight" Gregory H. Johnson. Then, write an entry in your on-line journal describing the dreams each interviewee had, what did they do to pursue their dream, did their dreams become reality why or why not and what roadblocks if any did they encounter while pursuing their dreams. Invention (74): Read the following quote: "I believe this nation should commit itself to achieving the goal, before this decade is out, of landing a man on the Moon and returning him safely to the Earth. No single space project in this period will be more impressive to mankind, or more important for the long-range exploration of space, and none will be so difficult or expensive to accomplish." President John F. Kennedy, speech to U.S. Congress, May 25, 1961. Was John F. Kennedy correct about the difficulty and expense for Americans to have their dream/goal become reality? Are the costs of space exploration necessary in order for this dream to become reality? Why did this dream/goal become reality? In your opinion, why haven't Americans landed on the moon since this dream became reality in the 1960's. Answer these questions thoroughly and don't forget to respond to at least 3 other students' answers. Investigation (74): Read the following quote from Victor Hugo: " There is nothing like a dream to create the future." In a well-developed paragraph describe what you think Victor Hugo meant when he made this comment. Remember to respond to at least 3 other students' answers. Reading (29): Read through Chapter 12 (page 223) in October Sky. Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (65): Click on the link The History of Manned Spaceflight. Follow the directions provided and working individually, complete the required research and subsequent paper. This is due by the beginning of week three. WEEK THREE: Why do We Explore Space? Guiding Question (66): "Why should mankind explore space? Why should money, time and effort be spent exploring, investigating and researching something with so few benefits? Why should resources be spent on space rather than on conditions and people on Earth, or in our own country? You will need to provide answers to these questions after completing at least two of the assignments below. Investigation (65): Read "NASA - The Vision for Space Exploration " February 2004 CLICK HERE: www.nasa.gov/pdf/55583main_vision_space_exploration2.pdf Each student must post five questions they have pertaining to the reading they completed. Then, each student must respond to five other questions posted by classmates. Systems (65): We will be using this page to collect websites that increase our understanding of space exploration. There is a lot of information on the web, some factual and some opinionated. Your assignment is to: 1. Find at least 3 websites (ones that are not linked to this course already) that pertain to space exploration and/or astronomy. 2. Answer these questions about each website: What is the website about? Was the information on the site professionally reported? Who sponsored the site? Was the site made up of mainly facts, opinions or both? 3. Finally, I would like you to conclude by stating whether or not you would recommend the site and for what particular purpose is it best suited. In other words, a site that is not very factual and more opinion based may still be important to look at in order to understand one person's perspective about a certain issue. Human Experience (65): Upon walking on the moon 40 years ago, Neil Armstrong stated, "That's one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind." In a well-developed paragraph(s), explain how you think humans responded to his statement. Do you think it was motivational? Do you feel that it helped persuade others to feel at ease about the money, time and effort being spent on space exploration? Do you think it answers the question why do we explore space? Why or why not. Invention (65): With the success of the Apollo program, NASA delivered great progress in the fields of rocketry and aeronautics, as well as the fields of civil, mechanical, and electrical engineering. Lesser known accomplishments are some of the many spinoffs that came from the Apollo program—partnerships created between NASA and industry to commercialize the technologies developed for the historic missions to the Moon. Find more Apollo spinoffs at http://www.thespaceplace.com/nasa/spinoffs.html. Go to the above site and investigate at least 2 spinoffs that are listed. After looking at these, respond to the following question: Do you feel that the "spinoffs" that have been produced through the different partnerships businesses have had with NASA help to justify our exploration of space. Thoroughly explain why or why not in a well-formed paragraph. You also need to respond to at least 2 other students' answers. Reading (29): Read through Chapter 21 (page 335) in October Sky. Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (71): You will write a letter to President Barack Obama stating your opinion about why you think we are involved in space exploration, why you think it is or isn't a good use of money, time and effort and what you think about the future of space exploration. Your letter should have a salutation, body with minimum of 2-3 paragraphs, a complimentary closing, writer's signature and writer's identification. Theme Two: Are We Alone? WEEK FOUR: How Has Technology Affected Space Exploration? Guiding Question (66): In light of all the technological advances that have been made over the past 20 years, are we in a better position to further the dreams of exploring space more effectively? Will the technological advances allow us to send humans to places like Mars or beyond? Will the new technology allow us to create a viable place elsewhere in the solar system for humans to live? Thoroughly answer these questions in a well-formed paragraph(s). Students are also to complete at least one of the following: Investigation (29): Using any resources that are available, investigate how the past events of "The Space Race' would have been different or changed had current technology been available back then. Use the rubric below to answer this question. Human Experience (29): In the late 1970's many people wondered what was the purpose of the money spent on space exploration? Today the resultant technology is all around us. Students need to investigate the following sites and make a Top 10 list of the technology that has been created due to space exploration that you feel are the most important. Then write a well-developed paragraph explaining why you feel these items are the most important. Next, click on this link and add your list and paragraph to the Technology Top Ten List (a forum) where you and other students will debate about which technologies are the most important. Invention (29): Which part and/or phase of a typical space flight do you feel has technology played an integral role in it being a success or failure? Explain why or how in a detailed paragraph citing examples from different websites you explored. Reading (29): Finish reading October Sky. Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (40): Each student needs to click on the Mars Simulator link, log-in per the directions given at the last F2F, and follow the directions found on the 2nd link for the Mars Simulator. As you progress through your simulator experience, you need to document your experience and findings in your on-line journal. You must include a minimum of 5 entries that include your overall experience, what findings did you make and your plan as you continue your expedition on Mars. These entries must be well-formed paragraphs with complete sentences, correct spelling, grammar and punctuation. WEEK FIVE: Are There Other Places in Space That Could Sustain Life? Guiding Question (66): Are we the only creatures living in the solar system and/or galaxy? Do you think that aliens exist? What evidence has been found to prove that other life may exist somewhere other than Earth? Students need to answer these questions in a well-developed paragraph(s). Students are also to complete at least 2 of the following: Investigation (71): As far as we know, only one planet has life on it — Earth. But is it really possible that our planet is the only life-bearing planet in the entire universe? Some scientists believe that extraterrestrial life does exist, and some even believe that there may be advanced alien life. In this video segment adapted from NOVA, learn about the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ess05.sci.ess.eiu.alone/ After viewing the video clip, you need to respond to the question: Is it really possible that we are not alone in the universe? Use examples and information from the video clip. Once posted, you must respond to 3 other students' posts. Invention (71): Imagine being an alien from somewhere in our universe. Your task is to write a 1 page story about this alien. Where is it from? What features does it have to help it survive its climate? How did they get here? Be very descriptive when developing your character so others can get a good picture of what it looks like. Human Experience (71): Have students discuss the following through posting answers to all 4 questions in well-developed paragraphs and also responding to at least 3 other responses from other students: 1. What conditions are necessary for life as we know it? 2. How does solar system formation affect whether or not life will develop on a planet? 3. How does Earth's atmosphere impact life? 4. What do you think would happen if a giant asteroid hit Earth now? Reading (29): Begin reading The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must through Chapter ___ (page Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (40): Each student needs to click on the Mars Simulator link, log-in per the directions given at the last F2F, and follow the directions found on the 2nd link for the Mars Simulator. As you progress through your simulator experience, you need to document your experience and findings in your on-line journal. You must include a minimum of 5 entries that include your overall experience, what findings did you make and your plan as you continue your expedition on Mars. These entries must be well-formed paragraphs with complete sentences, correct spelling, grammar and punctuation. WEEK SIX: Will Terraforming Allow Us to Inhabit Another Planetary Body in the Future? Guiding Question (71): What is terraforming and will it allow us to create safe environments other places in the universe so that humans can live away from Earth? Is terraforming worth the time and expense? Students need to answer these questions thoroughly. Students must also complete one of the following activities: Investigation (65): You need to watch the following video clips and write a journal entry in your on-line journal thoroughly describing what each clip was about and whether or not you believe what was being discussed in each video. 1. Video clip #1: Could a Saturn moon harbor life? http://www.ted.com/talks/carolyn_porco_could_a_saturn_moon_harbor_life.html 2. Mars Dead or Alive: A Hostile Environment http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ess05.sci.ess.eiu.hostenviron/ Invention (65): Click HERE to go to a website for you to investigate why and how terraforming Mars will supposedly work. After you investigate this site thoroughly, you need to create an argument either for or against the idea of terraforming Mars. In your argument you need to clearly state whether you are for or against the idea using supporting details to defend your position. Feel free to use other sources for information, but only after you have thoroughly looked at the above link. Reading (29): Continue reading The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must through Chapter ___ (page) Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (74): Meet with your team in the group forum. You will work together to complete The Space Race Webquest. You need to assign roles to each group member (post to the forum). Each group member then needs to complete their assigned part following the directions provided on the website. Individual parts need to be completed by next week. Theme Three: Pros and Cons of Space Exploration. WEEK SEVEN: What are the Pros and Cons of Space Exploration/Travel? Guiding Question (71): Over the past 6 weeks you have pondered many aspects of space exploration, from the dreaming stages to potentially inhabiting Mars with many stops in between. Using your knowledge from this course so far, you need to answer the question: What are the Pros and Cons of Space exploration? To answer this question, you need to make a table and list at least 5 pros and 5 cons of space exploration. Once this is completed, you need to look at and respond to 3 other students' lists. Feel free to debate any points that you do not agree with. Reading (29): Continue reading The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must through Chapter ___ (page) Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (74): Meet with your team in the group forum. You will work together to complete The Space Race Webquest. As a group, you need to communicate your progress so far and determine if anyone needs help and who could do more to make sure the project is done for the final F2F. At this point, you need to determine how you want to create your presentation for your argument and begin to put your research together to be presented at the last F2F. WEEK EIGHT: Should humans continue to explore space? Why or Why Not? Guiding Question (29): What are the current dreams for future space exploration? Do you think that these dreams will ever become reality? Why or why not? Answer these questions in complete paragraphs. When completed, respond to at least 2 other students' answers. Reading (29): Continue reading The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must through Chapter ___ (page ) Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (74): Meet with your team in the group forum. You will work together to complete The Space Race Webquest. As a group, you need to communicate your progress so far and determine if anyone needs help and who could do more to make sure the project is done for the final F2F. At this point, you need to determine how you want to create your presentation for your argument and begin to put your research together to be presented at the last F2F. WEEK NINE: What has/will be the Impact of Space Exploration on Our Lives? Guiding Question (29): Click HERE and watch a short video clip on The Future of Space Exploration. When finished, answer the following question in a well-developed paragraph: What impact has space exploration had on lives here on Earth and what type of impact do you envision space exploration having in the future? Reading (29): Finish reading The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must through Chapter ___ (page ) Answer the forum question(s) and provide responses to at least two other student posts. Show What You Know (74): Students need to answer these reflection questions for this course: 1. What are three things/ideas that you have learned from this course? 2. What are three questions that you still need answers for? 3. What changes if any would you recommend for this course? Please complete the class survey. Group Work (74): Students need to put finishing touches on their final projects with their group members and prepare to present at our last F2F meeting. Face-to-Face Plans F2F #1 - Space Exploration and Dreams Items to bring: October Sky, writing utensils, paper, lunch, current events article related to any Astronomy topic. Goals: Getting to know each other, class expectations, define what space exploration is, define what a dream is and how to make dreams become a reality. 9:00-9:30 - Introductions, seating chart, ice breaker activity (M&Ms), plan for the day. 9:30-10:00 Class activity: Share and discuss current events articles students brought to class. Group activity: Brainstorm a list of ideas that define space exploration. (5 minutes) Class activity: Share list with class and compile a class list of ideas. (10 minutes) 10:00-10:30 - Individual work: In a well-developed paragraph, summarize what you think is the future plan (dreams) for space exploration. (5 minutes) Class activity: Share writing with the class and discuss. (10 min) Video clip: How Stuff Works - The Presidential Plan for Space (5 min) Class activity: Class discussion on information seen in the video clip. (10 minutes) 10:30-10:35 - Break 10:35-11:00 - Rocketry - How can we build a permanent human presence in space? a. Introduce students to Newton's Third Law of Motion and discuss. b. Students will view a short video clip of a rocket launch. c. Students need to answer the following questions with the person sitting next to them: 1. How do you think the mass of a rocket affects how much propulsion it needs. 2. What might add mass to a rocket? 3. Ask students how engineers compensate for this added weight. 4. If we wanted to determine how mass affected a rocket, what could we do? 11:00-11:30 - Lunch - Students will view short video clips about Apollo 11 in celebration of the 40 year anniversary. 11:30-12:30 - How does a payload affect a rocket? Activity a. Form groups. b. Set the activity up per directions on sheet. c. Review the basic principle of rocket propulsion. d. Carry out the activity and record data. Reflection & Discussion ◗ Have students share the data. Ask students, based on their observations, to describe how the mass of the payload affected the rocket’s ability to launch from the floor to the ceiling. Ask students if anything surprised them about their data. Transfer of Knowledge In order for students to apply what they have learned, challenge them to a rocket race. Have them use their data to choose the optimal payload size. Test their decision by seeing whose rocket travels the highest. Ask students to write their payload size and an explanation of their choice on a piece of paper and turn it in for assessment. 12:30-1:00 - F2F wrap-up. Class discussion on what was learned today, review of what is expected of students during the on-line component and exit slip writing activity. F2F #2 - Impact of Technology Items to bring: Writing utensils, paper, lunch, current events article related to any Astronomy topic. Goals: Getting to know each other, define the impact of technology on lives and space exploration, gain background knowledge of exploring Mars, its implications and plan for the future, learn how to use Mars Simulator. 9:00-9:30 - Introduce the themes for the day, ice breaker activity (Use your tongue), share current events article. 9:30-10:00 - View short video on Robotic Exploration of Space. After viewing the video, students will get into small groups and discuss the implications that technology has on their lives as well as on the future of space exploration. The last 5 minutes will be time to share with class what was discussed. 10:00-11:00 - The relationship between science and technology activities: Students will learn how technology can help scientists solve a problem. One of the challenges scientists face with any spacecraft is attitude control. Students will be introduced to the problem of attitude control in space and two different ways scientists address it. (I WILL NEED A GYROSCOPE/BICYCLE WHEEL WITH HANDLES) Students will Discuss the technology(ies) that powers satellites and enable(s) them to move through space Be introduced to the concept of “attitude control” and the role technology has in the design of spacecrafts Engage in an angular momentum experiment 11:00-11:30 - Lunch - Students will be introduced and shown a demonstration of the Mars Simulator project that they will complete on-line over the next 2 weeks. 11:30-12:00 - Students will participate in an interactive website that will allow them to learn about the anatomy of a rover to prepare them for the Mars Simulator activity. During this activity students must answer the following questions: Choose two parts of the rover. For each one, describe the job it was designed to do, the challenges for carrying out this job on Mars, and what you think is most interesting about this part of the rover. How does the rover get its instructions or commands? How does it share the images, data, and other information it gets with us on Earth? These rovers move slowly! Can you move across the room at the same rate they do? Why do you think they move at this speed? At the end of this activity, students must write a well-developed paragraph summarizing what they learned from the activity. 12:00-12:30 - View 3 short videos about Mars and have small group/large group discussions about them. 12:30-1:00 - 12:30-1:00 - F2F wrap-up. Class discussion on what was learned today, review of what is expected of students during the on-line component and exit slip writing activity. F2F #3 - The future of space exploration…should it continue? Items to bring: Writing utensils, paper, lunch, completed final project. Goals: Getting to know each other, class expectations, debate the future of space exploration…is it worth the time, effort and money and why? 9:00-9:30 - Introduce the themes for the day, give groups time to finalize projects and prepare for presentations. 9:30-11:00 - Group presentations, debate and evaluations. If students finish early they will complete a writing activity describing whether or not they think the moon landing was real or a hoax. 11:00-11:30 - Lunch - meet with students one-on-one to go over course progress. 11:30-12:00 - Class discussion on October Sky. 12:00-12:30 - Class discussion on The Case For Mars: The Plan to Settle the Red Planet and Why We Must. 12:30-1:00 - Student and class evaluations.