Doc# 533566410 MINUTES Meeting title: Chair: Secretary: Meeting Date: Meeting Details: Intended purpose of document: Technical Plenary 15 Omar Elloumi, Alcatel-Lucent (ATIS) omar.elloumi@alcatel-lucent.com Karen Hughes, ETSI, karen.hughes@etsi.org 2015-01-19/23 Face-to-face meeting Miami, USA Decision Discussion Information Other <specify> oneM2M Notice The document to which this cover statement is attached is submitted to oneM2M. Participation in, or attendance at, any activity of oneM2M, constitutes acceptance of and agreement to be bound by terms of the Working Procedures and the Partnership Agreement, including the Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Principles Governing oneM2M Work found in Annex 1 of the Partnership Agreement. © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 1 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 1 Opening of the meeting Welcome Omar Elloumi, the newly elected TP Chair, opened the meeting and welcomed the participants to the 15th Technical Plenary of oneM2M. Victoria Mitchell the TIA (host) representative welcomed the participants to Miami and went through some logistical details for the week. Omar drew the participants attention to the oneM2M notice on the cover page of the agenda. 2 Review & Approval of Agenda TP-2015-0571R03 TP-2015-0571R04 Agenda Agenda Chair Chair TP-2015-0571R03 was NOTED TP-2015-0571R04 was APPROVED Meeting Logistics TP-2015-0570R06 Weekly Schedule Secretariat This is a working document and will be updated throughout the meeting week. TP-2014-0521R06 was NOTED TP-2014-0562R02 Voting List for TP15 Secretariat TP-2014-0562R02 was APPROVED Introduction of Observers There are three observers expected to attend this TP meeting: 3 OIC will be represented by Mr Jooyeol Lee. Fraunhofer will be represented by Mr Saied Tazari. Jasper Wireless will be represented by Mr Chris Steck. Objectives of this Meeting Finalize initial release – It was decided in the MARCOM group that the name of this release will be Release 1 Initial discussions about next release (duration & scope) Perform WG elections Call for nominations for leadership positions of: Security Management Abstraction & Semantics Protocols vice chair © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 2 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 4 Review and Approval of previous Minutes TP-2014-0560 Minutes_TP-14 TP-2014-0560 was APPROVED 5 Review Open Action Items TP-2015-0572 TP14 Action update Secretariat This contribution is for information only. TP-2015-0572 was NOTED New Actions 6 A-TP-015-001 Enrico Scarrone Update the templates and MoW documentation to reflect the agreements in TP-2015-0583R02 A-TP-015-002 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0581 A-TP-015-003 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0580 A-TP-015-004 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0565R04 A-TP-015-005 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0579R01 A-TP-015-006 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0001R04 A-TP-015-007 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0569R03 A-TP-015-008 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0596R01 A-TP-015-009 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0599R04 A-TP-015-010 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-2015-0577 A-TP-015-011 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-20150587R01 A-TP-015-012 Secretariat Add the next meeting dates to the outgoing LS in TP2015-0602R01 A-TP-015-013 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-20150602R01 A-TP-015-014 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0566 Reports from Ad-Hoc Groups None Election of Officials Following the submission of candidates for the election of officials for the Requirements, Architecture and Testing Working Groups, the following results have been achieved: Architecture WG Nicolas Damour, Sierra Wireless (ETSI) was appointed Chair of the Architecture WG by acclamation Hongbeom Ahn, LG Electronics (TTA) & Mitch Tseng, Huawei (CCSA) were appointed Vice Chair of the Architecture WG by acclamation Testing WG © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 3 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 JaeSeung Song, KETI (TTA) was appointed Chair of the Testing WG by acclamation Jason Yin, Huawei (CCSA) was appointed Vice Chair of the Testing WG by acclamation It was noted that there is still an open position for Vice Chair of the Testing WG and it was decided to hold an election for this position during the next TP meeting Requirements WG Elections will be held on Tuesday 20th during the coffee breaks. 7 Consideration of Input documents / Items for Action at Opening Session The Chair formally opened the nomination period for the leadership positions of: 8 Security Management Abstraction & Semantics Protocols vice chair Security vice chair Input documents TP-2015-0566 Update_Milestone_Dates_of_WI-0016 China Mobile TP-2015-0566 was APPROVED A-TP-015-014 TP-2015-0565 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0566 Work Item LWM2M Interworking Proxy ALU (TIA) There was support expressed for this work item however some questions raised over the solution diagrams and scenarios. Further discussion and clarification is needed. ARC & MAS Working Groups will work on this work item and a revision will be brought to the TP TP-2015-0565 was NOTED TP-2015-0575 Release 2 Work Items Best Practices MoW (Enrico Scarrone) There was a request to clarify that the 2nd release will be based on the approved version of Release 1 CR process for updates of different versions – is one CR sufficient for one or more documents or will each document need a separate CR. More offline discussion needed as this has not yet been addressed in the M&W group. The concept of Document Editors was raised – this needs to be clarified It was suggested that the work item creation for the maintenance of releases could be automated – more offline discussion needed on this TP-2015-0575 was NOTED TP-2015-0567 Work Item for Architecture Maintenance Nicolas Damour, WG2 Vice-Chair ZTE & Ericsson would like to be added as a supporting company Rajesh has volunteered to continue to act as Rapporteur for this TS © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 4 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 Request that it was clarified in the scope that this is linked to Release 1 Need also need to clarify that this is linked to TS-0001 Architecture WG will work on the CRs this week TP-2015-0567 was NOTED TP-2015-0568 Work Item for Architecture Nicolas Damour, WG2 Vice-Chair Refinements and Small Improvements Criteria of what can be agreed as ‘small’ changes was questioned. Should the work item be limited to just the Release 1 – it could include other Releases once they have been ratified and published TP-2015-0568 was NOTED TP-2015-0569 Work Item for CMDH Extensions Nicolas Damour, Sierra Wireless Qualcomm would like to be added as a supporting company. Other companies have added their support via email. It was felt that the input of the GSMA would be very valuable. The Chair explained that the GMSA had been invited to this meeting as observers however they were unable to attend. They have indicated that they may attend the next TP meeting. It was suggested that a LS should be sent to relevant bodies (GSMA, 3GPP, 3GPP2...) Title & schedule will be updated Further discussion needed in the Architecture and Requirements Working Groups TP-2015-0569 was NOTED TP-2015-0001R01 Work Item: Generic Interworking NEC Some editorials noted It was clarified that this is for Release 2 and it was suggested that in future the Release should be put in the scope of a new work item. This issue will be discussed during the Methods of Work Ad Hoc meeting. Further offline discussion needed TP-2015-0001 was NOTED TP-2015-0576 OIC introduction for oneM2M Jooyeol Lee OIC Standard WG Chair The TP Chair thanked Mr Lee for taking the time to attend and present the work of OIC to this meeting. More details requested on the specification however it was explained that these specifications are not publically available and only OIC members have access to them. A way for non-members to access the specifications was requested so that the participants would have an idea of what currently exists. It was pointed out that oneM2M is based on openness and all specifications and documents are freely available online. It was felt that TP needs to discuss interworking with OIC with the oneM2M Legal Group before any decision on the next steps can be taken. Offline discussions will be welcome and an ad hoc discussion may be held during the week. TP-2015-0576 was NOTED P-2014-0563 Comments from 3GPP2 on Aubergine Release © 2016 oneM2M Partners 3GPP2 TSG-SX Page 5 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 It was agreed that this contribution will be discussed in Architecture working group and will be resubmitted to the interim meeting The open comments will be addressed at a later date. As agreed previously, the Secretariat will reply to all those bodies who provided comments to the Candidate release and without giving any details as to the resolution of these comments, will point the contributor to the download area where they may access the Release 1 documents TP-2015-0563 was NOTED TP-2014-0561 Reply LS from 3GPP TSG GERAN 3GPP TSG GERAN This is related to a previously received LS from ITU-T (TP-2014-0522 ) and a reply will be prepared by the Security Group and presented to TP. There is no action needed TP-2015-0561 was NOTED TP-2015-0564 oneM2M Semantics Introduction NEC It was suggested that this information should be shared with other vertical bodies and further discussion on this should take place. This work will be backed up with use cases. It was suggested that interaction was needed with the ‘domain experts’ and it was felt that this should happen very soon. A decision needs to be taken as to who the people that should be contacted are. TP-2015-0564 was NOTED 9 Initial discussions about next release (duration & scope) This discussion is related to the contribution TP-2014-0546 which had been presented during TP14. 10 Consideration of Input documents / Items for Action at Interim Session Update on WG1 elections Mr Yong-Suk Park, announced his withdrawal as a candidate as a vice chair of the Requirements. The Chair thanked Mr Park for his contribution to the work of oneM2M both in the meetings and during the recent showcase event and he thanked KETI for their continued support within oneM2M. Following this, the Chair announced the election results for the Requirements Working Group Shelby Kiewel, iconectiv (ATIS) was appointed Chair of the Requirements WG by acclamation Rajesh Bhalla, ZTE, (CCSA) & Jörg Swetina, NEC Europe Ltd. (ETSI) were appointed Vice Chair of the Requirements WG by acclamation TP-2015-0574 MARCOM Input on Release Naming MARCOM It was agreed that oneM2M will adopt Release 1 as the official release name. TP-2015-0574 was APPROVED TP-2015-0583 Release Maintenance, Small Enhancement and Feature Work Items © 2016 oneM2M Partners MoW (Enrico Scarrone, MoW convenor) Page 6 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 It was confirmed that the decision on what is a small technical enhancement will be taken by consensus, however some concerns were raised It was suggested that these enhancements should also be applied to the previous however it was felt that offline discussion is needed to resolve this and find a way forward. It was suggested that there be an indication of when a CR is a ‘Mirror CR’ – there was support for this and it will be discussed. The concept of other categories of CRs was brought up and it was agreed that this should be studied further Revision expected which will clearly show the one remaining open point. Other proposals were felt to be agreeable and will be taken as a working assumption. TP-2015-0583 was NOTED TP-2015-0583R01 Release Maintenance, Small Enhancement and Feature Work Items MoW (Enrico Scarrone, MoW convenor) It was agreed that Option A should be used as the current working assumption . The templates should be updated and provided as soon as possible. TP-2015-0583R01 was NOTED TP-2015-0583R02 was NOTED A-TP-015-001 TP-2015-0578 Enrico Scarrone Update the templates and MoW documentation to reflect the agreements in TP-2015-0583R02 Release 2 planning consideration TP leadership It was suggested that even if a work item is introduced late in the work flow, it should have the same priority as other work items. Work items which are not progressing or which are behind schedule should have a lower priority or be dropped. Suggested that the market view should be developed later in the life cycle of the release as we some promising work items may not be as important as was thought at the start It was felt that the stable draft documents should be made available and visible on the public website. If a feature is stable then this should be communicated clearly. There was support for the idea of candidate releases. Further discussion needed TP-2015-0578 was NOTED Question raised on the relationship between oneM2M and the verticals – will there be a TS for each one to show what oneM2M can do for them. It was suggested that the way forward could be with a TR – it was further explained that the way that this is treated in 3GPP is with TRs which are maintained and which are known as 9series CRs. TP-2015-0581 WID-0015 update InterDigital Need to remove the TS part of the schedule TP-2015-0581 was NOTED TP-2015-0581R01 was APPROVED A-TP-015-002 Secretariat © 2016 oneM2M Partners process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0581 Page 7 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 TP-2015-0580 WID-0001 update InterDigital TP-2015-0580 was APPROVED A-TP-015-003 TP-2015-0573 Secretariat process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0580 Update Scope of WI-0017 LG Electronics It was agreed that this should be an input contribution, there is no need to update the work item for this. The text is an ‘action’ rather than part of the scope. TP-2015-0573 was NOTED TP-2015-0565R03 Work Item LWM2M Interworking ALU (TIA) Title updated to remove ‘Proxy’ Ericsson (ETSI), KDDI (TTC) are added as supporting companies TP-2015-0565R03 was NOTED TP-2015-0565R04 was APPROVED A-TP-015-004 TP-2015-0579R01 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0565R04 Work_Item_for_Testing_Framework Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd TP-2015-0579R01 was APPROVED A-TP-015-005 TP-2015-0001R03 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0579R01 Work Item: Generic Interworking NEC TP-2015-0001R03 was NOTED TP-2015-0001R04 was APPROVED A-TP-015-006 TP-2015-0569R03 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0001R04 Work Item for Efficient Communications Nicolas Damour, Sierra Wireless TP-2015-0569R03 was APPROVED A-TP-015-007 TP-2015-0596 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0569R03 WI-0017_Update NTT NEC would like to be added as supporters for this Work Item Online editing TP-2015-0596 was NOTED © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 8 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 TP-2015-0596R01 was APPROVED A-TP-015-008 Secretariat TP-2015-0599R03 process the updated Work Item in TP-2015-0596R01 Work Item on Industrial Domain Enablement Toshiko Matsumoto (Hitachi) It was suggested that oneM2M should send a liaison to IIC as they are working on similar issues InterDigital would like to support this Work Item TP-2015-0599R03 was NOTED TP-2015-0599R04 was APPROVED A-TP-015-009 TP-2015-0577 Secretariat process the new Work Item in TP-2015-0599R04 LS from oneM2M on LwM2M specified Objects WG5 MAS TP-2015-0577 was APPROVED A-TP-015-010 TP-2015-0587 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-2015-0577 Liaison Statement Out to GSMA - Efficient Communications Work Item Nicolas Damour, Sierra Wireless Edited online TP-2015-0587 was NOTED TP-2015-0587R01 was APPROVED A-TP-015-011 TP-2015-0602 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-20150587R01 Reply LS to ITU-T SG17 on Simple Encryption for IoT WG4 TP-2015-0602 was NOTED TP-2015-0602R01 was APPROVED A-TP-015-012 Secretariat Add the next meeting dates to the outgoing LS in TP2015-0602R01 A-TP-015-013 Secretariat Process the agreed Liaison Statement in TP-20150602R01 12 Reports from Working Groups WG-1: Requirements TP-2015-0590 WG1 status report to TP15 © 2016 oneM2M Partners Joerg Swetina (NEC) REQ vice chair Page 9 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 TP-2015-0590 was NOTED TP-2015-0591 CR pack for TS-0002 (Requirements) Joerg Swetina (NEC) REQ vice chair TP-2015-0591 was APPROVED TP-2015-0592 CR pack for TS-0011 (Definitions) Joerg Swetina (NEC) REQ vice chair TP-2015-0592 was APPROVED WG-2: Architecture TP-2015-0604 WG2 Status Report at TP15 Nicolas Damour, WG2 Chairman TS-0007 will not be included in Release 1 and will be put on the agenda for the TP15.1 call on Friday 30 January TP-2015-0604 was NOTED TP-2015-0606 CR Pack TS-0001 Nicolas Damour, WG2 Chairman TP-2015-0606 was APPROVED WG-3: Protocols TP-2015-0593 WG3 Status report WG3 / PRO Chairman TP-2015-0593 was NOTED TP-2015-0002R02 CR Pack TS-0004 v0.8.0 WG3 Chairman TP-2015-0002R02 was APPROVED TP-2015-0594 CR Pack TS-0008 v0.6.0 WG3 PRO Chairman TP-2015-0594 was APPROVED TP-2015-0595 CR Pack TS-0009 v0.6.0 WG3/PRO Chairman TP-2015-0595 was APPROVED TP-2015-0607R01 Draft_baseline_TS-0010_V0_5_0 MQTT Protocol TS Rapporteur TP-2015-0607R01 was APPROVED WG-4: Security TP-2015-0601 WG4 Status Report at TP15 © 2016 oneM2M Partners WG Chair Page 10 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 TP-2015-0601 was NOTED TP-2015-0597 CR Pack TS-0003v0.9.0 WG SEC TP-2015-0597 was APPROVED WG-5: Management Abstraction and Semantics TP-2015-0584 WG5 MAS report at TP#15 Yongjing Zhang (Huawei, WG5 Chair) TP-2015-0584 was NOTED TP-2015-0585 CR pack for TS0005 for TP#15 Yongjing Zhang (Huawei, WG5 chair) TP-2015-0585 was APPROVED TP-2015-0586 CR pack for TS0006 for TP#15 Yongjing Zhang (Huawei, WG5 chair) TP-2015-0586 was APPROVED WG-6: Testing TP-2015-0588 TST WG progress report at TP15 TST WG Chair TP-2015-0588 was NOTED Ad Hoc Group – App-ID TP-2015-0605 TP App ID Ad Hoc Status Report Shelby Kiewel - iconectiv TP-2015-0605 was NOTED All the approved specifications will be added to the Agenda for ratification during the TP 15.1 conference call. The Chair thanked all the participants for their hard work on these specifications. 14 Review Current Programme Status As not all input was received in time, the current WPM Convenor was unable to produce the WPM report. The report will be Postponed until TP 15.1 on 30 January. Roland will take over the responsibility of the role of WPM Convenor and will produce the Release Description Document for Release 1 15 Release Planning TP-2015-0578R02 Release 2 planning considerations © 2016 oneM2M Partners TP leadership Page 11 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 It was agreed that the features will be maintained by WPM and regular updates will be provided to TP If no progress is being made on a feature, there is a risk that the feature may be removed from a release It was agreed that this can be taken as a working assumption for the Release 2 planning. TP-2015-0587R02 was NOTED TP-2015-0587R03 was NOTED and is the working assumption for the Release 2 planning 16 Review of Objectives for the Meeting Finalize initial release – It was decided in the MARCOM group that the name of this release will be Release 1 Initial discussions about next release (duration & scope) Perform WG elections Call for nominations for leadership positions of: Security Management Abstraction & Semantics Protocols vice chair In addition nominations for the position of one vice chair for the TST Working Group was opened All objectives have been achieved 17 Planning of Next Meeting TP-2014-0524 Invitation to TP 16_Sophia-Antipolis ETSI Information on TP 17 – Japan Mr Yukio Yamanaka from TTC , provided some details on the TP 17 (18-22 May 2015) which will be hosted by TTC and ARIB and will be held in Sapporo, Japan. The official invitation will be issued very soon. Mr Yamanaka announced that there will be a Showcase event in Tokyo after TP 17 and it will be held in Japanese for the Japanese industry. 18 Any other business Mitch Tseng, Huawei, informed that participants that TIA will be holding a showcase event in Dallas in June 2015. The proposal is still under discussion so this is for information only. 19 Closure of meeting The TP Chair thanked the oneM2M Partners for inviting the participant to the Release 1 celebration event on Thursday evening. He thanked the host TIA for the excellent facilities and for their help throughout the week. Omar congratulated the participants for their hard work and dedication to getting the oneM2M Release 1 ready. He explained that this new TP team are very open to new ideas and suggestions and would welcome any input from the members. As TP Chair, Omar will be attending some parts of all the working group meetings during the TP meeting weeks to get an idea of how the work is progressing. © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 12 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 Annex 1 First Name Last Name Organization Partner Hongbeom Ahn LG Infocomm TIA Marylin Arndt ORANGE ETSI Kurt Bantle Spirent Communications ETSI Eric Barnhart Georgia Tech Research Institute TIA Martin Bauer NEC Corporation (TTC) TTC Rajesh Bhalla ZTE Corporation (ETSI) ETSI Josef Blanz Qualcomm UK Ltd (ETSI) ETSI Richard Brennan Telxxis LLC (TIA) TIA Timothy Carey Alcatel-Lucent (TIA) TIA Ziyao Cheng China Mobile Communications Corporation CCSA Sungchan Choi KETI TTA Heedong Choi LG Electronics (TTA) TTA Vinod Choyi Interdigital Communications (ETSI) ETSI Francisco da Silva Huawei Technologies Sweden AB ETSI Nicolas Damour Sierra Wireless SA ETSI Claus Dietze Giesecke & Devrient GmbH ETSI Lijun Dong Interdigital Communications (ETSI) ETSI Omar Elloumi Alcatel-Lucent (ATIS) ATIS Francois Ennesser Gemalto N. V. (ETSI) ETSI Raymond Forbes Ericsson LM (ETSI) ETSI Shingo Fujimoto Fujitsu Ltd. (TTC) TTC Yoshinori Goto Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp. (NTT) TTC Russell Haines Toshiba Research Europe Ltd ETSI Philip Hawkes Qualcomm Inc, (ATIS) ATIS Xuan He Hitachi (China) Research & Development Corporation CCSA Roland Hechwartner Deutsche Telekom AG ETSI Klaus Hemberger Bundesnetzagentur ETSI © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 13 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 Darold Hemphill Ericsson Inc. (ATIS) ATIS Changwei Hu China United Network Communications Group Company Limited CCSA Karen Hughes European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) ETSI Yoshihisa Ito Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp. (NTT) TTC Puneet Jain Intel (ATIS) ATIS Sookhyun Jeon Telecommunications Technology Association (TTA) TTA Seungmyeong Jeong LG Electronics Mobilecomm Research North America (ATIS) ATIS Ilkka Keisala TeliaSonera AB ETSI Shelby Kiewel iconectiv ATIS Yongjin KIM Modacom TTA Ki Young Kim LG Electronics (TTA) TTA Youngbu Kim National IT Industry Promotion Agency (NIPA) TTA Seonhyang Kim Dt&C TTA Seongyoon Kim LG Electronics Mobilecomm France ETSI Jaeho Kim KETI TTA Peter Kim Telecommunications Technology Association (TTA) TTA TAIZO KINOSHITA Hitachi Ltd. TTC Young Jun Ko Modacom TTA Victor Kueh Huawei Technologies UK (ETSI) ETSI Michael Kurz Deutsche Telekom AG ETSI hwang kwang-tae Kaon Media TTA Gyu Myoung Lee Modacom TTA Jooyeol Lee Samsung Electronics (TTA) TTA Kanghae Lee Telecommunications Technology Association (TTA) TTA Anthony Lee VIA Telecom (TIA) TIA Anatoli Levine Spirent Communications ETSI Guang Lu InterDigital Communications (TIA) TIA Michele Lupano Telecom Italia SpA ETSI Patricia MARTIGNE ORANGE ETSI © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 14 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 Toshiko Matsumoto Hitachi Ltd. TTC Gerry McAuley European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) ETSI Keith Miller Intel (TIA) TIA Victoria Mitchell Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) TIA Catalina Mladin InterDigital Communications (ATIS) ATIS Peter Niblett IBM Europe ETSI Sungjin Park Samsung Electronics (TTA) TTA Yong-Suk Park KETI TTA Soochang PARK Institut Mines-Telecom ETSI Mireille PAULIAC Gemalto N. V. (ETSI) ETSI Daniel Quant Multitech ETSI Woo Seop Rhee Modacom TTA Changho RYOO Telecommunications Technology Association (TTA) TTA Erick Sasaki Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp. (NTT) TTC Enrico Scarrone Telecom Italia SpA ETSI Jae Pil Seo National IT Industry Promotion Agency (NIPA) TTA WEIXIANG SHAO ZTE Corporation (CCSA) CCSA David Shrader Ericsson Inc. (ATIS) ATIS JaeSeung Song KETI TTA Chris Steck Jasper Wireless n/a Joerg Swetina NEC Europe Ltd. (ETSI) ETSI Yuan Tao Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd (CCSA) CCSA Mitch Tseng Tseng InfoServ, LLC TIA Nobu Uchida Qualcomm Japan Inc. (ARIB) ARIB Laurent Velez European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) ETSI Mihai Voicu ILS Technology LLC TIA Dragan VUJCIC Oberthur Technologies ETSI Guotong Wang VIA Telecom (TIA) TIA Hao Wu ZTE Corporation (CCSA) CCSA Yukio Yamanaka Telecommunications Technology Committee (TTC) TTC © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 15 (of 16) Doc# 533566410 Nick Yamasaki KDDI Corporation TTC Takefumi Yamazaki Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp. (NTT) TTC Nari Yang Modacom TTA Jiaxin Yin Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd (CCSA) CCSA Qi Yu Huawei Technologies UK (ETSI) ETSI Yongjing ZHANG Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd (CCSA) CCSA Jun Zhang Haier Group R&D Center CCSA Wei Zhou Datang Telecom Technology@Industry Holdings Co., LTD CCSA © 2016 oneM2M Partners Page 16 (of 16)