Financial Sector Stability Analysis 5.1. Introduction Promotion of an efficient financial system is one of the important objectives of RBI according to the preamble to the Reserve Bank of India Act. The financial landscape of India has grown in coverage and complexity, especially during the 1990s. Apart from commercial banks, there are various types of entities like Cooperative Banks, Regional Rural Banks, Financial Institutions, Investment Institutions and Non-Banking Finance Companies, which form part of the Financial System. To ensure the health of the financial system, RBI on one hand defines the performance norms for these banking and non-banking entities and on the other hand supervises their business operations for assessing their performance and growth. Over the years, the banking policies have moved away from a highly regulated to a more market oriented system and hence it has become very important to have a strong and efficient supervisory system. Thus the need for a good decision support system has become paramount. Apart from the above, orderly development of the financial system is also one of the important focus areas of RBI. The focus of development is to ensure: Adequate banking network across the country Banks / FIs cope with the dynamic changes in the global financial markets Growth in Savings & Banking habits of the people Public confidence in the financial system Availability of credit to Priority Sectors In the light of the above ‘Financial Sector Stability Analysis’ encompassing functions of RBI relating to Regulation, Supervision and Development emerges as one of the distinct subject areas for RBI. 5.2. Scope and Objective One of the key objectives under this subject area is to ensure maintenance of systemic integrity and aid overall development. The diagram below shows various departments in RBI that are engaged in meeting this objective. Financial Supervision, Regulation & Development Developmental Financial Institutions Scheduled Commercial Banks Policy & Regulation DBOD Supervision DBS Industrial & Exports Credit of SCBs IECD Regional Rural Banks Urban Cooperative Banks Regulation and supervision UBD Developmental Lending Regulation & Supervision of DFI's FID Non-Banking Financial Companies Regulation and supervision DNBS Regulation and Supervision RPCD Board for Financial Supervision As depicted in the above diagram, various departments of RBI are involved in achieving the regulatory, supervisory and developmental objectives under this subject area. Hence, the information for analysis flows from the respective departments / entities and helps in arriving at an integrated view on various issues relating to their financial performance, compliance, risk management and meeting developmental objectives. The observations in this chapter relate to SCBs, FIs, UCBs and NBFCs. (RRBs, Central & State Co-op banks are supervised by NABARD though RBI monitors compliance of statutory requirements) 5.3. Business Functions Within the subject area of Financial Sector Stability Analysis of banks and non bank entities, RBI carries out the following main functions: 1. Formulate policy, rules and regulations governing their working and operations. RBI has introduced prudential norms on capital adequacy, asset classification, income recognition & provisioning and risk management 2. Ensure their compliance of statutory requirements. To ensure compliance with the prudential norms, through a set of specially designed returns that are submitted by the banks and institutions. 3. Conduct on site inspection for evaluating the operations 4. Carry out off site surveillance for ensuring effective supervision 5. Monitor and follow-up the redressal of customer complaints and investigation of frauds registered Approve opening of new banks / branches and extension counters within and outside the country. 6. Monitoring entry of NBFCs by registering only those which comply with the entry norms 7. Monitoring the performance of all banks operating in India and international branches of Indian banks 8. Undertake rehabilitation of weak banks to ensure that a sound banking system prevails in the country 9. Ensure availability of adequate resources to priority and rural sectors and their utilization 10. Regulate the foray of banks into Para-banking activities and monitor their performance on a periodic basis 11. Formulating Policy for new types of Para-banking activities and constantly evolving policy on banks investment in government securities 5.4. Analytical Perspective The broad analytical framework in which the above objective is addressed can be classified into analysis encompassing both the micro (entity level) and macro (aggregate level) aspects. The various types of analysis that may be considered are: Trend analysis, Comparative analysis, What if (scenario based) analysis, Ratio analysis, Intra group / sector analysis (i.e. comparing entities of banks, institutions and NBFCs against each other), Cumulative analysis (i.e. at bank group, Term lending institutions, Investment institutions, RRBs, SCBs, UCBs level), Top ‘n’ analysis etc. The above type of analyses helps in drawing important conclusions/generalisations and looking for early warning signals, on the basis of which the supervisory actions may be initiated and/or guidelines be formulated. The information base for the above kind of analysis consists of annual balance sheet, form A, form B, BSR returns, section 42(a) returns and other statutory as well as non statutory returns. The analytical needs outlined above may be further divided into following analytical areas: 1. Financial performance and health: To analyse the financial health of banks, institutions and non-banking financial companies through formulation of prudential norms and performance standards and monitoring their compliance. Here the focus would be to monitor the performance and growth of financial sector within the prudential guidelines issued for their operations. 2. Compliance with statutory requirements: To analyse compliance with statutory requirements by banks, institutions and NBFCs. Though in the era of liberalisation, the statutory requirements are being scaled down, some of the significant requirements include CRR, SLR and submission of periodic information to meet the statutory requirements. 3. Risk Management: To formulate risk management policies and guidelines and to monitor adherence to them. Here the focus is on early identification of the areas of risks for the financial sector as a whole as well as for each individual entity and provide guidelines for their mitigation. 4. Financial system infrastructure: The focus here is to analyse whether the branch network of Banks/NBFCs is adequate, efficient and self-sustaining enough to support the financial system of the country Besides, the analysis would enable RBI to gauge the performance of the various banking entities and to decide upon areas of improvement with respect to demographics and economic activity in the region. 5. Rehabilitation of Weak/Sick/Problem Entities: The focus here is to analyse whether a particular bank / institution / NBFC is prone to becoming sick/weak and identify possible reasons for the same. Such analysis will also help to formulate and implement the rehabilitation strategy for the sick/weak/problem Banks, NBFCs and financial institutions. The causal analysis of such entities over a period of time can assist in suitable modification of the related policy framework. 6. Para-banking Activities of Banks: The focus here is to analyse whether the para-banking activities undertaken by the banks and/or their subsidiaries are synchronizing with the operations of the bank and are profitable in nature, while they extend value added services to the customers. This analysis also helps to ensure that forays of banks into para-banking activities and risks associated with their operations are monitored on a regular basis. 7. Rural Credit and Priority Sector Advances: The focus here is to analyse whether the advances to the rural and priority sectors through various schemes and channels and the utilizations thereof is adequate for the development of these sectors, as also to analyse whether the institutions are adhering to the norms specified for lending to these sectors. The following context diagram depicts the broad information source and the analytical domains as identified above. Financial System Stability Analysis Data on Macroeconomics variables Market Intelligence Reports Supervision Regulation Para Banking Risk Management Rehabilitation Onsite Inspection Reports & Off- site surveillance reports Statutory Requirement Policies and Directives Development Financial Health Infrastructure Development Priority Sector Advances Returns Data & Balance Sheet Data The major business issues and the significant variables that are tracked / studied in each of the above mentioned analytical domains (sub subjects) are explained in detail in the following sections. 5.5. Financial Performance and Health Introduction RBI has defined prudential norms for Capital Adequacy, Asset Classification, Income Recognition and Provisioning to provide benchmarks for monitoring of banks’ performance on these counts. Analytical Issues The key parameters used in the analysis of Capital Adequacy, Non Performing Assets etc. are outlined below. An estimate of the Operational Efficiency and Profitability may be carried out through the analysis of various ratios like, CD ratio, asset and liability items, revenue and expenditure items etc. The main source of information for such analysis is the balance sheet, BSR returns and other non-statutory returns with information on profitability, sectoral deployment, large borrowers, asset quality, capital constitution, deposit profile etc. Some of the significant analyses along with the related variables that are required for supporting the business issues are detailed as under. 1. Capital Adequacy RBI has stipulated certain absolute minimum capital requirements for banks depending on the spread of the bank's area of operations, NBFCs and FIs. This capital requirement is linked to the risk assets of the entity. In case of private sector banks though the minimum capital requirements have been prescribed separately as an absolute amount. Some of the key issues, which need to be addressed, are: Whether adequate capital (stipulated CRAR%) has been maintained for backing the risk assets in the financial system? Whether the computation and constitution of capital funds is as per the stipulated norms? What is the trend and variance in constitution of capital funds and CRAR? What is the impact on Tier I / Tier II capital of Banks with change in CRAR and the given Risk Weighted Assets portfolio? This would help in prescribing future capital adequacy requirements. Variables to be tracked: Details on capital funds including Tier I and Tier II capital - for each Bank/NBFCs/FIs on an half yearly/annual basis Risk Weighted Assets for each Bank/NBFC/FI on half yearly/annual basis 2. Asset Quality RBI has stipulated the norms for the quality of assets being generated in the financial system. For this purpose, the assets of any bank or financial institution are classified into standard, sub-standard, doubtful and loss category based on the overdue status of interest / principal. Further, based on the quality of asset, provisioning norms have also been stipulated. Some of the key issues, which need to be addressed with respect to asset quality norms, are: What is the extent and classification of non-performing assets in the Banks/FIs/NBFCs and whether any Bank (Bank Groups)/FIs/NBFCs is more prone to generating NPAs? What is the extent of deviation of income recognition from the norms by banks / FI’s? Whether adequate provision has been made on the NPAs and what is the status of recoveries of NPAs? What is the percentage composition of NPAs in the total advances and migration pattern of NPAs for each bank over period of time? What is the status of investments - in terms of yield, maturity pattern, provisioning etc.? Variables to be tracked: Total loans and advances, Gross and Net NPAs by entity and age for each year (quarterly for bank group level) Classification of assets in Standard, Sub-standard, Doubtful, Loss by bank and age for each year (quarterly for bank group level) Interest charges on NPAs (not recognized as income) for each bank on a yearly basis Asset-wise Provisioning amount for each bank every year Classification of investments for each bank on annual basis to arrive at maturity pattern, yield, provisioning etc., Constraints The extent of deviation of income recognition norms has to be sourced from reports, which is not in soft form. 3. Deposits & Advances Deposits and Advances form significant parameters of performance for financial entities. The analysis of interest would include, understanding the pattern and composition mix of Deposits and Advances and of deposit holders and borrowers. Further, comparing the trends and growth in deposit base of a financial entity or of a group against the trend in credit off-take would give some meaningful insight on the operations and functioning of the financial sector. Some of the key issues, which need to be addressed with respect to deposits and advances of various financial entities, are: What is the composition and pattern of deposits with respect to their interest rates, maturity, geographical spread and average size and category of deposits (to be viewed by grouping into appropriate buckets)? What is the pattern of advances with respect to their interest rates, industry and category etc. (to be viewed by grouping into appropriate buckets)? How are the banks mobilizing deposits and other resources to meet incremental demand for credit to industry/other sectors and what is the growth pattern in deposits & advances? How are the incremental resources deployed? What is the sectoral and geographical pattern of deposits and advances? How is it changing over a period of time? What is the correlation of industrial and economic growth (production indices, GDP etc) with the credit off take (loans and advances) in various industry segments? What are the growth pattern of Deposits and Advances of various players in the financial system like Banks, NBFCs, FIs etc., and which segment is growing faster? Whether the NOF criterion is being complied with by NBFCs and FIs? What is the composition and pattern of sources and application of funds of FIs and how are they changing over a period? What are the trends of the funded and non-funded advances of banks, FI’s Variables to be tracked: Deposits with classification into type of deposit, interest rate range, maturity period, average size, ownership and geographical pattern from each bank/branch on annual basis (source: BSR returns) Deposits with classification into type of deposit Break-up of advances by industry, category (cash credit, loans, bills etc.) sector, size and lending rate Net Owned Funds for each FI on monthly basis and for each NBFC on a quarterly basis Macro Economic variables like GDP, IIP etc. on periodic basis Sources and Deployment of funds by FIs on quarterly basis 4. Operating Performance Apart from prescribing the prudential norms and monitoring their fulfillment, RBI would also be interested in studying the performance of banks and non-bank entities, both in isolation and in comparison with general economic activity. The analysis would be based on parameters such as profit, revenue, asset turnover ratios, investment details, expense details etc. Some of the key issues that may be considered are: How is the turnover and profitability of the banks changing vis-à-vis developments in the industry and economy (IIP, GDP etc)? How is the profitability and revenue composition changing over a period of time? What is the portfolio of investments by their type (e.g. Government securities, investments in other subsidiaries etc.) and what is the yield on these investments over a period of time? How is the performance of SCBs, Urban Co-operative banks, FIs and NBFCs with respect to certain key indicators (viz. Return on Net-worth, Return on Equity, Return on Working Funds etc.) and how do they compare against each other? To study the operational efficiency and profitability of each segment and entity over a period of time and comparison between segments may be of interest. Variables to be tracked: Derived variables for analysing operational efficiency / profitability. These are available for each entity on a quarterly/ half yearly / annual basis. o o o o o o Staff performance and Efficiency Ratios Profitability and Balance Sheet Ratios Revenue to Assets Ratios Cost to Liability Ratios Asset –Liability Ratios Revenue- Expenditure Ratios Revenue, gross profit, operating profit, net profit for each entity on quarterly / half yearly / annual basis. For SCBs this information is available on bank group level while at bank level – frequency is annual. Liability and Asset Items of each entity (except for NBFCs) on monthly basis. For NBFCs, these details would be available on half yearly basis. Macro Economic variables like GDP, IIP, CPI, Inflation rate etc. on periodic basis. Constraints 1. During the course of user survey, it was stated that the data on specific SCBs being confidential in nature would not be available on a quarterly basis from DBS. However, bank group level data will be available at quarterly intervals. 5.6. Compliance with Statutory Requirements Apart from the prudential guidelines, RBI has also stipulated certain statutory requirements. Banks (including UCBs) and NBFCs have to comply with the SLR (Statutory Liquidity Ratio) requirements. Banks are also required to comply with the CRR (Cash Reserve Ratio) requirements. RBI specifies these requirements from time to time and compliance of the same is vigorously monitored. Further, these entities have to also comply with certain mandatory reporting to RBI, which is also tracked and followed up by RBI. The compliance with such statutory requirements is ensured by calling for fortnightly returns from SCBs, SSCBs, UCBs and RRBs and quarterly returns from NBFCs. In addition to monitoring compliance, RBI would be interested in also understanding the impact of such requirements on the general functioning of financial sector and that of the individual banks. Some of the major business issues, which can be addressed, are: Analytical Issues Whether the required levels of SLR and CRR are being maintained by the concerned entities regularly? Which banks or non-banking entities have been irregular and need close follow-up? What are the trends in frequency and amounts of defaults in maintenance of CRR and SLR? Which are the banks or bank groups or NBFCs that are consistently maintaining excess CRR/SLR? Whether any policy changes is needed? What is the interest paid on CRR reserves and amount of penalties levied in case of defaults in CRR and SLR, for each entity over a period of time? What is the correlation between changes in SLR / CRR requirements and the growth in deposit / advances and profitability of banks, bank groups, NBFCs etc. Variables to be tracked: Net Demand and Time Liabilities - Provisional and Final figures every fortnight for each bank / NBFC. Effective CRR amount - Provisional and Final figures every fortnight for each bank. Effective SLR amount to be maintained – every quarter for each bank / NBFC. Actual CRR maintained – by each bank every fortnight. Actual SLR maintained – by each bank / NBFC for each quarter. Prescribed CRR and SLR as a percentage of NDTL (daily and fortnightly). Interest Amount on cash reserves for banks on fortnightly basis. Penalty amounts levied in case of default in CRR / SLR maintenance – for each bank every fortnight. Number of times a Bank has defaulted on CRR / SLR and NBFC defaulting on SLR in a year and amount of default. Average daily balances maintained by the banks with the average and the total for the fortnight. Deposits, Advances and Profitability figures for each entity on quarterly basis. 5.7. Risk Management Banks / Financial Institutions assume various kinds of risks in their day-to-day operations. It is important to identify, measure and manage these risks. RBI has laid down policies toward risk management and monitors their adherence by these institutions. It also undertakes measurement of their risk exposures on a periodic basis. The various types of credit and market risks arise from Credit concentration, Connected lending, Interest rate sensitivity, Exchange risk exposure, Asset liability mismatches and Operational inefficiency RBI monitors the above-mentioned risks by collecting information through a set of special returns from banks and non-banking entities on a periodic basis. Important statements are on Structural Liquidity, statements on Interest Rate Sensitivity on Domestic and Foreign Assets and Liabilities, statement on connected lending / group lending, statement on large borrowers, frauds and complaints etc. Analytical Issues The objective is to gauge the level of risk of various financial entities and advise appropriate action / guidelines to mitigate the same. Such understanding would be required at individual banks/non-banking entities level, as well as at the group level and overall financial sector level. The essence of analysis is in getting the up-to-date information on the above-mentioned parameters on a periodic basis so that the potential risks are identified and managed before they can actually create an adverse impact on the performance of a financial entity or the financial system at large. Some of the business issues that may be addressed are: Who are the large customers? To which industry the exposures of banks / FIs / NBFCs are large? Whether the banks / FIs are adhering to the prescribed exposure norms? Which are the parties where the exposure norms have been exceeded? What is the extent of exposure on interested parties and subsidiaries? What is the asset class of such exposures? How is the assets and liabilities composition of these institutions? Are there any large gaps with respect to maturity pattern and currency exposure that need to be addressed? What sort of changes in its composition is observed over a period? Are these gaps within the prescribed or desired levels? What is the trend in frauds and complaints registered for each bank? What is the quantum of forex exposure for each Bank / FI and how would the change in exchange rates impact the revenue / expenditure position? What are the ownership composition and its pattern of change for banks, NBFCs and FIs? What is market trend in respect of prices of stocks of listed banks/ FIs / NBFCs? Variables to be tracked The key variables tracked in the areas of risk management are: Large credits and industry exposures by banks on annual basis Loans given to directors, associates and their associate companies by each bank on an annual basis. For cooperative banks, information is available on monthly basis. Liabilities, assets, other products, gross and net gap and cumulative gap – bank group wise (SCBs) on a monthly basis. Foreign currency liabilities, assets, other products, gross and net gap and cumulative gap – bank group wise (SCBs) on a monthly basis. Off balance sheet exposures for each bank / NBFC / FI on an annual basis Outflows, inflows, mismatch and cumulative mismatches for various maturity buckets – for bank group and each FI on a quarterly basis Ownership pattern of Bank / FIs / NBFCs on an annual basis Market rate of scrips of Banks/FIs/NBFCs Number and amount of frauds for each entity (Bank, NBFC, FI) on a quarterly basis Number and type of complaints registered for each entity (Bank, NBFC, FI) on a quarterly basis Constraints The risk management systems in most of the banks are not computerized and hence would pose a difficulty in sourcing the information. In case of SCBs, this information is available with the DBS, which may be sourced bank groupwise. Details on frauds and complaints are not available in electronic format for NBFCs and FIs. 5.8. Financial System Infrastructure Specific permission is required for floating a new bank, entry of a foreign bank, opening a foreign branch by an Indian bank and floating a NBFC. RBI has also laid down norms for branch expansion by banks in India. To ensure optimum financial system network and for facilitating review of existing entry level norms, the following analytical issues may be considered: Analytical Issues: Whether the distribution of commercial and cooperative banks and their branches and non-banking finance companies in the country is adequate vis-àvis the following: Geographical spread (city/state/region) Size of the bank and its branches within a region (population serviced, amount of deposits, advances etc.) Economic activity in the region (industrial output, per capita income etc.) What is the trend in level of advances and deposits of SCBs branch-wise? This can be viewed by bank/bank group/geographical region/population group/economic activity. For FIs/NBFCs and co-operative banks, such data can be analysed for the entity as a whole. What is the share of various categories of branches (Rural/Semi Urban/Urban/Metro) in total number of branches? Which of the Indian banks have international branches country-wise? How are the international branches performing in terms of deposit base, size of advances and profitability? What is the extent of profits repatriated? How many branches were opened and closed during the year and over the years by banks internationally and domestically? How many new banks (category-wise) started operating during the year? Whether the existing entry-level norms for Banks / NBFCs are adequate or need any revision? Variables to be tracked: These important issues are addressed by tracking the following variables: Number of bank branches per city/state/region and country on an annual basis along with the population figures. Classification of branches according to Rural/Semi Urban/Urban/Metro categories and share in total Classification of deposits and advances by interest rate, maturity period, size for each branch on annual basis Number of international branches of a bank in each country on annual basis Key performance variables of international branches of Indian Banks viz. Deposits and Advances, Income and Expenditure, NPA figures, branch profits, number of employees, profitability per employee etc. on annual basis Number of branches opened/closed in each country in a year on an annual basis NBFCs registered/rejected in a year and their respective NOF and deposit amounts Number of new banks licensed/scheduled in a year under each category (SCBs, UCBs, RRBs etc.) Constraints The required data on bank / branch network and profile for Urban co-operative banks is not available in electronic format. The system for urban co-op banks is currently under testing. Details of region-wise economic activity (Industrial output, per capita income etc.) is not available with RBI. 5.9. Rehabilitation of weak /sick/problem entities Identification of sick/weak banking entities, problem cases of NBFCs and timely action for their rehabilitation is an important area addressed by RBI. The following analytical issues are considered: Analytical Issues: How many entities have become sick /weak/problem cases over the years and during the year? Which particular entities are heading towards weakness/sickness? What are the special attributes of entities becoming weak/sick/problem (e.g. location, type, size and type of exposure viz. to a particular segment of business and industry)? What is the financial position of the sick/weak/problem entities under the rehabilitation program? Variables to be tracked: The key variables on which the above issues are analysed are: Net Owned Funds of all weak/sick/problem entities on an annual basis CRAR of all sick/weak/problem entities on an annual basis Net NPA of all entities classified as sick/weak/problem on an annual basis History of Losses of all sick/weak/problem entities on an annual basis Defaults on maturity of deposits of problem NBFCs on a quarterly basis Size of borrowing and nature of business of problem NBFCs on a quarterly basis Constraints The required data is not available in electronic format for SCBs, UCBs and RRBs. 5.10. Para-banking activities RBI approves forays of banks into para-banking activities. Either SCB’s itself may carry out these activities depending on their nature or it may have a separate subsidiary for carrying out the same. RBI monitors these para-banking activities and the relative operations closely to ensure that they are done efficiently and do not adversely affect the health of the parent bank. The information required for the analysis of para-banking activities is collected through the annual balance sheets and income statements of the banks and their subsidiaries: Analytical Issues: What are the types and extent of para-banking activities undertaken by each bank? Which are the Para-banking subsidiaries floated by banks and what is the level of investment? What is the performance of various para-banking subsidiaries of a bank? Variables to be tracked: Profits/losses of each para-banking subsidiary of banks on an annual basis Total NPAs of para-banking subsidiaries and its classification on a annual basis Investment amount in each para-banking subsidiary of a bank on an annual basis Return on Investments in each para-banking subsidiary of a bank on an annual basis Extent of liabilities of subsidiary companies that are borne by the parent bank on an annual basis Constraints Balance sheets of bank subsidiaries are not available in electronic form. Separate data regarding performance / profitability relating to Para-banking activities undertaken departmentally by banks is not available. 5.11. Priority Sector Advances As a Central Bank of the country, RBI plays an active role in the development of rural financial infrastructure and creates an environment conducive for banks’ lending in the rural areas. Apart from rural areas, RBI also plays an important prescriptive role in poverty alleviation programmes of the Government in non-rural areas. All these advances form what is known as Priority Sector advances. Broadly, they include credit to Small Scale Industries, Agricultural Advances and advances given for services like Small Traders, Professional and Self Employed, Retail Trade, Small Road and Water Transport Operators, Housing Loans, Educational Loans and Consumption Loans. RBI monitors these advances on sectoral and regional basis. For foreign banks, advances for exports are also considered as priority sector advances. Special emphasis is given to that portion of priority sector advances which is given to weaker sections like SC/ST, women, disabled persons, marginal farmers, agricultural landless labourers and minorities. RBI also monitors the progress of special programmes announced by GOI like PMRY, SGSY, SJSRY and micro credit through self-help groups. It actively formulates policies, sets targets and ensures compliance with the norms laid down for priority sector advances. To meet this objective, the following analytical issues are addressed: Analytical Issues: To what extent various banks are meeting the norms and targets relating to priority sector advances by sector, by category of borrower, by scheme, by region, by state over time. What is the extent of NPAs in priority sector lending for each bank by sector, by category of borrower, by scheme, by region, by state over time? What is the effectiveness of Lead Bank Scheme and Service Area Approach, in terms of their reach, amount of advances and recovery position? This analysis is done vis-à-vis Annual Action Plans and District Credit Plans. What is the extent of contribution to Rural Infrastructure Development Fund (RIDF) by banks and what is the pattern of its utilization by NABARD? What is the extent of subsidy given by Government of India and its utilization by scheme (like PMRY, IRDP etc.), by bank, by state on annual basis? What is the extent of export credit provided by banks by facility (Post shipment credit, Packing credit etc.) over time? Variables to be tracked: The main variables on which above analysis is sought are: Advances sanctioned / disbursed by banks to priority sector by District/State/ region, by sector, by bank on quarterly basis Beneficiary wise classification of priority sector advances i.e., to SC/ST, Women, disabled persons, minorities and marginal farmers under various schemes by sector, by bank on a quarterly basis Net bank credit to priority sectors on a quarterly basis and its share in total advances NPAs in priority sectors, bank-wise under various sectors, categories and schemes on an annual basis Percentage recovery in priority sectors, bank-wise under various categories and schemes on annual basis Details of sanctions and disbursements at state/district level as per annual action plan (includes district credit plan) on a quarterly basis Contribution to RIDF by banks on annual basis Sanctions and utilizations by NABARD under RIDF scheme from DADs on an annual basis Receipt and Utilization of subsidy in Integrated Rural Development Programme (IRDP), Prime Minister’s Rojgar Yojana (PMRY) and other subsidy bearing schemes by banks on an annual basis Amount of export credit provided by banks under various facilities annually Constraints Delay in receipt of the required information from RRBs and Banks is an area of concern Most of the above data continues to be in manual form and will be a constraint at the time of uploading the data in the data warehouse.