Attachment 1: Report of Eligibility Submitted as evidence of compliance with the Requirements of Affiliation for Free-Standing Institutions Abroad, established by the Commission on Institutions of Higher Education within the New England Association of Schools and Colleges. Submitted as an integral part of the Kazakhstan Institute of Management, Economics and Strategic Research (KIMEP) application for Candidacy with the New England Association of Schools and Colleges Commission for Institutions of Higher Education Updated April 2007 2 Table of Contents NEASC Requirements Title Introduction Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement Requirement 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Page 1 1 1 3 3 4 6 6 7 7 8 9 10 11 12 15 15 16 16 18 18 List of Figures Title Figure Figure States Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure 1: KIMEP Collegiate Level Educational Programs 2: KIMEP Degree Programs and Comparable Degrees Offered in the United 3. KIMEP Advising System 4: 2006-7 enrollments by degrees and/or programs 5: KIMEP Student Population, 1999-00 to 2009-10 (projected) 6: Location of Key Information for Requirement 12 in 2005-7 Catalog 7: Non-Commercial JSC KIMEP Governance Structure 8: KIMEP Board of Trustees 2005-7 Academic Year 9: KIMEP Budget Statement for Academic year 2006-7 in US Dollars 10: KIMEP Academic year Funding Bases 2002-3 to 2006-7 11: Total KIMEP Budget 2001-2 to 2006-7 12: KIMEP: Income, Costs and Surplus, 2006-7 to 2009-10 (USD) 13: KIMEP Graduates, 1994-2006 Page 2 3 5 9 10 11 12 14 16 17 17 18 19 1 Introduction Introduction This Report of Eligibility has been prepared by the Kazakhstan Institute of Management, Economics, and Strategic Research (KIMEP) to demonstrate institutional compliance with the Requirements of Affiliation for Free-Standing Institutions Abroad as established by the New England Association of Schools and Colleges (NEASC) and its Commission on Institutions of Higher Education (CIHE) as published in the document ‘Candidacy for Accreditation by Free Standing Institutions Abroad’ (2004). The Report is structured to directly follow each of the Requirements listed in p9-14 of the above document. Each requirement is listed and KIMEP’s response to it presented. This is an updated version of the report submitted to NEASC June 2005 to take account of changes. Requirement 1. The institution has formally adopted a statement of mission, which demonstrates that the fundamental purposes of the institution are educational, and which is also appropriate to a degree-granting institution and appropriate to those needs of society it seeks to serve. KIMEP was founded in 1992, not long after the historic collapse of the Soviet Union. The objective of KIMEP, as an institution of higher education, was to assist the newly independent Kazakhstan (a former Soviet republic) in the transformation from its centrally-planned, communist past to a freemarket oriented democratic state. KIMEP’s charge, therefore, was a unique one; supporting and aiding Kazakh society during these momentous economic and political changes. From this charge was born the KIMEP slogan, “Education to Change Society.” To date, KIMEP has been successful in training students to become leaders in the public and private sectors in Kazakhstan. Furthermore, KIMEP operates with integrity in all of its affairs and with complete financial transparency. As the Institute has developed, further revisions were made to the Mission Statement in 2005. The current mission fits directly with the previous Mission but reflects KIMEP’s international aspirations more accurately. The 2005 Mission was approved by the KIMEP Council and the Board of Trustees in June 2005. The current mission is as follows: KIMEP is a non-profit institution of higher education. Its mission is to develop welleducated citizens and to improve the quality of life in Kazakhstan and the Central Asian region through teaching, learning, the advancement of knowledge in the fields of business administration and social sciences, and through community service. In addition, KIMEP aspires to serve the international community by welcoming foreign students to study and by developing extensive international linkages. To fulfill this mission we offer graduate and undergraduate degree programs of the highest level of international educational standards in business, economics, finance, accounting, public administration, political science, international relations, journalism and mass communication to outstanding students, who are equal to graduates of universities anywhere in the world. We seek to select students from among those who demonstrate leadership, talent and language capabilities, irrespective of their financial means, gender or ethnic origin, or any other subjective criteria. Requirement 2. The institution offers one or more collegiate-level education programs, consistent with its mission, that lead to degrees in recognized fields of study and that require at least one year to complete. KIMEP offers a number of collegiate-level programs leading to both Graduate and Undergraduate degrees. In particular, KIMEP offers four bachelor’s degrees, seven master degrees and a doctoral degree. Since the original eligibility report was submitted, two masters programs - the Executive MBA and MA TESOL – were launched in Spring 2007. The doctoral program (DBA) was launched in the Spring of 2006. These are shown in Figure 1 below. 2 Figure 1: KIMEP Collegiate Level Educational Programs Name Bachelor Programs: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration and Accounting (B.Sc) Bachelor of Arts in Economics (BAE) Bachelor of Arts in Social Sciences Bachelor of Arts in International Journalism Graduate Programs: Master of Business Administration (MBA) Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) Master of Arts in Economics (MAE) Master in Public Administration (MPA) Master in International Relations (MIR) Master of Arts in International Journalism and Mass Communications (MAIJMC) Executive MBA MA TESOL Specialization College Duration Accounting, Finance, Management, Marketing, Operations Management and Information Systems Public Policy Economics, Business Economics, Resource and Environmental Economics International Relations, Political Science, Public Administration, Central Asian Politics International Journalism Bang College of Business Four Years College of Social Sciences Four Years College of Social Sciences Four Years College of Social Sciences Four Years Accounting, Finance, Marketing, Management, Operations Management, Information Systems Accounting, Finance, Management, Marketing, Operations Management, Information Systems International Economics, Public Policy Economics, Financial Analysis Public Policy, Research & Information Technology, Public Management, Public Finance, Natural Resource Management Political Science, International Relations, Central Asian Politics Public Relations, Media Management, Print and Broadcast Journalism Accounting, Finance, Marketing, Management, Operations Management, Information Systems, Economics Teaching English Bang College of Business Two Years Bang College of Business Four Years College of Social Sciences Two Years College of Social Sciences Two Years College of Social Sciences College of Social Sciences Two Years Two Years Bang College of Business 21 months Language Center Two Years In line with the mission, the academic programs leading to these degrees prepare students for leadership roles for the economic, business, and political future of Kazakhstan. In addition, these programs are all licensed by the Ministry of Science and Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Detailed information about the academic programs at KIMEP can be found in Part III of the 2005-07 Catalog, under the heading of Academic Units and Programs (pp. 68-203). Two new programs were launched in Spring 2007. These expand both the range and scope of KIMEP’s degree programs. The new programs are: MA TESOL (48 credits), offered by the Language Center. Full details of this new program can be found in the KIMEP 2007-8 Catalog; Executive MBA (42 credits), offered by the Bang College of Business and which is of twentyone months duration. Details of this new program, as initially envisaged are included in the KIMEP 2005-07 Catalog (pp. 134 - 138). Full details of the revised program can be found in the KIMEP 2007-8 Catalog. 3 Requirement 3 . The institution offers academic programs that are comparable in terms of length, curriculum, objectives, learning outcomes, and degrees awarded to those offered by regionally accredited institutions in the United States. KIMEP prides itself in its leading role in Kazakhstan and the immediate region in offering an education modeled on the North American credit based system. Degree programs are comparable in: Length; Curriculum; Objectives; Learning outcomes; to those offered by institutions in the U.S. Figure 2 lists each degree awarded by KIMEP, as well as the comparable degree offered in the United States. Figure 2: KIMEP Degree Programs and Comparable Degrees Offered in the United States KIMEP Degree BSc BAE BSS BAIJ MBA MPA MA MIR MAIJMC DBA Ex. MBA MA TESOL Credits Approximate length 129 122 129 129 63 60 48 51 54 57 42 48 4 years 4 years 4 years 4 years 2 years 2 years 2 years 2 years 2 years 4 years 21 months 2 years Comparable US Degree BA or BS BA or BS BA or BS BA MBA MPA MA or MS MA, MS or MIR MA DBA /PhD Ex. MBA MA TESOL KIMEP degrees are comparable to those offered at regionally accredited institutions in the United States. Undergraduate academic degree programs are credit-based, ranging from 122 to 129 credits necessary for completion. Included in these totals is the required 48-credit General Education program. Curriculum structure involves course groupings of core, cognate, and elective courses, as well as department, college, and university requirements. Graduate degree programs are also credit based, ranging from 42-63 credits as shown in Figure 2 above. Academic Programs Curricula are established by each department, and debated and approved by the College Councils. Programs are then forwarded to the Senior Vice President of Academic Affairs for onward discussion within the KIMEP Academic Affairs and Education Policy committee. Once approved by this committee, Program curricula go to the KIMEP Council for final approval and adoption. The KIMEP Council also gives consideration to financial constraints, as well as to the environment and market needs of the academic programs. In addition, market surveys are periodically undertaken to gauge the opinion of students, faculty, and the at-large community about the missions, objectives and learning outcomes of KIMEP programs. Detail on the mission, goals and objectives of each program are listed in Catalog 2005-07 with the exception of the MA TESOL, which is yet to be launched. Learning outcomes are discussed under Requirement 5. Requirement 4. The institution awards the bachelor’s, master’s, or doctor’s degree or, if it grants only the associate’s degree, includes at least one program leading to a degree in liberal arts or general studies or another area of study widely available at the baccalaureate level of regionally accredited colleges and universities in the United States. KIMEP currently awards Bachelor’s, Master’s and Doctor’s degrees. As mentioned above, to demonstrate compliance with requirement #2 and #3, Bachelor’s degrees awarded by KIMEP include Bachelor of Science in Business Administration and Accounting (B.Sc), Bachelor of Arts in Economics (BAE), Bachelor of Social Sciences (BSS), and Bachelor of Arts in International Journalism (BAIJ). Master’s degrees awarded include Master of Business Administration (MBA), Master of Arts in Economics (MA), Master in International Relations (MIR), Master in Public Administration (MPA), and Master of Arts in International Journalism and Mass Communications (MAIJMC). A Doctoral program was launched in Spring 2006. The Executive MBA and MA TESOL were launched in 2007. 4 Degree programs offered at KIMEP (summarized above) are listed, along with major fields, minor fields, and areas of specialization in the Academic Colleges and Departments section of the KIMEP Catalog 2005-7 (pp. 25-27). Executive MBA and DBA programs are described in detail in the 2005-7 KIMEP Catalog (pp. 134,138). Requirement 5. The institution has, for each of its educational programs, clearly objectives appropriate to higher education in level, standards, and means for achieving them, including a designated course of studies degree requirements, adequate guidance to degree candidates requirements, and adequate grading or evaluation procedures. defined and published quality, as well as the acceptable for meeting in the satisfaction of Objectives Statements of program objectives are clearly defined and published in the KIMEP Catalog. Curricula for undergraduate degrees include General Education requirements previously totaled 50 credits (KIMEP Catalog 2005-2007). The General Education program has been substantially revised in Fall 2006, with the 48 credit new program taking effect in Fall 2007. It includes a small number of courses (in English, Kazakh history and language, and computer literacy) required of all students, and a requirement for the study of courses in a range of disciplines representing diverse areas of human enquiry: social sciences, natural sciences, humanities, fine arts, and quantitative methods. Each program is supported by: a well qualified international faculty (mostly Western trained); a well structured advising system, both on-line and paper based; a computerized admissions, registration and study-tracking system; quality assurance systems at department, college and KIMEP levels; a well conceived continuous assessment system; computer, library and other information resources; required and elective instruction in English. Advising KIMEP considers student advising to be essential in allowing students to successfully navigate creditbased programs. Academic advising is an ongoing process that involves student-advisor interaction throughout the student’s education at KIMEP. Among the subjects students and advisors can discuss are: Students’ choice of major field Students’ academic progress and current standing Major field requirements General Education requirements Course prerequisites Registration procedures Suitable study load Selection of courses Study hints / preparation for examinations Coping with academic difficulties Career plans / What to do after graduation Adjustment to life at KIMEP The advising system works as shown in Figure 3 and described below. Newly entering students receive information on the processes for advising and registration during the pre-entry University Life orientation course. Advising for these students occurs as part of their initial registration process. Since the Fall 2006 intake entering students are advised centrally at the KIMEP Advising Center, within the Office of the Registrar. Faculty training is provided on the curriculum structure and the advising system prior to each registration period where necessary. From a student’s second semester at KIMEP, he/she is allocated a faculty advisor by the relevant College. This advisor remains with the student for the duration of his/her studies at KIMEP College Advising Centers have been created in both degree-granting Colleges, staffed by trained College administrative and student peer advisors. These Centers act as clearing houses for information on the College’s programs of study. They provide support to students who are confused about the advising process and assistance in locating faculty help if the assigned advisor is unavailable. 5 Faculty are in their offices to assist students during designated advising hours. The student’s options are discussed and agreement reached on the course of study to be followed, ensuring a match between the student’s needs and abilities and curriculum requirements. A Course Selection Form is completed by the student and discussed with the advisor, listing courses the student wishes to register for in the upcoming semester. This document is signed by the student and faculty member. One copy is kept by the faculty member and the other taken by the student to the College Advising Center where the student is given access to the online registration system. Alternatively, the faculty member can open registration for the student The student is then free to register online via the KIMEP website or using the parallel paperbased system. The information once entered is passed automatically to the Office of the Registrar and recorded in the student’s record. In cases where the student is unable to meet with the assigned faculty member, the College Advising Center will locate alternative advising resources. During the semester, faculty are required to set office hours during which advisees can confer on any issues they may have throughout the semester. The faculty member acts as a first point of reference on a wide range of issues. Figure 3. KIMEP Advising System Incoming Students Faculty Advisor Training First Semester Advising by KIMEP Advising Center Assignment of Faculty to Advisees by College Advisor Monitors Student Progress, Meetings if Necessary Second semester and Later students AdvisorStudent Meeting on Course Selection Student Registers For Courses Course Selection Form College Advising Center/ Faculty Opens Registration Grading and Evaluation Full details on KIMEP’s grading policy are given in the KIMEP Catalog 2005-7 (p.34-37). A continuous assessment system is used to evaluate student performance in all classes. Such instruments as quizzes, tests, writing assignments, and term papers are assigned throughout the semester and graded according to the letter grading scale. The proportional weights of these instruments are determined ahead of time, and clearly explained by faculty members to students. In addition, the manner in which the final grade is determined is clearly stated in the course syllabus. The course syllabus is a contract between the student. KIMEP has an institution wide system of monitoring learning outcomes which assesses: Real time performance via the continuous assessment systems employed by instructors Course exit performance, measured by overall performance and final examinations Program exit performance, measured by final degree outcome From the perspective of: Students via satisfaction surveys Faculty via satisfaction surveys with student performance and the KIMEP working environment KIMEP Management via faculty evaluation and program outcome monitoring Employers via periodic surveys of their experience with KIMEP graduates they employ KIMEP’s arrangements for assessing the degree to which learning objectives have been achieved is being continuously improved as programs further mature. The process has been greatly enhanced by the introduction from 2005 of a systematic program of institutional research, which since Fall 2006 has been led by a full-time Director of Quality Assurance and Institutional Research. 6 Requirement 6. The institution awards only degrees appropriate to each graduate’s level of attainment. KIMEP guarantees the integrity of its degrees by assuring that credentials are awarded only to students who have fulfilled program requirements satisfactorily. Clear graduation requirements, a high-quality, well-structured curriculum, qualified international faculty and a series of quality control checks combine to ensure that all KIMEP graduates have attained a certain level of knowledge, skills, and academic achievement. Graduation requirements are stringent and non-negotiable. In order to graduate from KIMEP, students must satisfy all General Education requirements (see requirement #9), as well as all Department, College, and KIMEP requirements. All financial obligations to KIMEP must also be paid. In addition, undergraduate students seeking a baccalaureate degree must, within a maximum period of ten years, earn the required amount of credits required by the given department, and must have a cumulative grade point average (GPA) of 2.0 representing a “C” or “Satisfactory”. Baccalaureate degree seekers must also have 48 credit hours from the collection of general education required and elective classes (see requirement #9), and must meet all requirements for the given degree in the student’s major field of study. In order to receive credit for a given course, undergraduates must earn a grade of at least “D-“. Graduate students seeking a Master’s degree must complete the required number of credits within a maximum period of five years. Master’s degree seekers must also have a cumulative GPA of 3.0 representing a “B” or “Good”, (or the College of Social Sciences 2.67), and must meet all programmatic requirements in the relevant major field of study. In order to receive credit for a given course, graduate students must earn a grade of at least “B-“. In addition to the above-mentioned graduation requirements, KIMEP assures the integrity of its degrees by implementing a well-structured curriculum, an advising system that includes an on-line tracking system, and relevant, quality faculty staffing each academic department. Quality assurance committees at the department and college levels monitor, among other things, degree requirements and instructional quality. A standardized, evaluation system (required for each course at KIMEP) allows students to evaluate instructors upon completion of each course. Previously this was done online. Since Fall 2006 manual distribution methods have been used to increase participation These teaching evaluations serve as a key mechanism to monitor the effectiveness of faculty teaching. As a final guarantee of integrity for KIMEP degrees, a number of clearance steps must be passed in order for students to graduate in a given year. At the end of the spring semester, after final grades have been submitted, a departmental committee recommends all graduating students to the College Dean. The Dean then reviews this list and presents the list to the College Council. College Councils, in turn, send recommendations of graduates to the KIMEP Council for final approval. Requirement 7. The institution offers its instructional programs entirely or predominantly through coursework that includes face-to-face instruction. The vast majority of coursework for all KIMEP programs is conducted through face-to-face instruction. Classes are conducted on campus and are led by a qualified instructor. The only exceptions to this rule are the four to six courses offered at any one time via a web-based platform facilitated by the Distance Learning program in the College of Continuing Education. Of these courses, only two have been offered in a graduate degree-bearing program (Master of Public Administration) and one in the BSc program, and the institution has no immediate plans to significantly expand participation in this delivery format. In 2004, the College of Continuing Education (CCE) launched an Internet based Distance Learning program intended to support its professional certificate program, the ‘Open Enrollment and Certificate Program’. A platform with the rigor and functionality necessary to support degree programs was deliberately implemented to enable its use in the other colleges should they choose to in the future. KIMEP utilizes the open source “Modular Object Oriented Distance Learning Environment” (MOODLE) platform, located on a dedicated Distance Learning server. MOODLE is a password protected online learning environment enabling both student-instructor and student-students communication, cooperation and interaction. It is a platform utilized by over a thousand institutions worldwide. Since its implementation in the CCE, the platform has been used to deliver approximately two to four professional certificate courses at a time. Courses in the CCE follow an abbreviated eight-week semester so the annual online course total is approximately twelve to twenty four. Some instructors 7 have expressed interest in using the platform as a ‘support mechanism’ to courses taught face-to-face in other programs and the platform is made available for this purpose as well. Currently the Executive MBA is using the platform in this way. Requirement 8 The institution uses English as a principal language of instruction and operation, sufficient to permit an evaluation by the Commission and to ensure the ability of its graduates to continue their education in other regionally accredited U.S. institutions. The primary language of instruction and operation at KIMEP is English. KIMEP was established specifically to offer a high-quality, North American style education (in English) within the Republic of Kazakhstan. Nearly all of the courses offered at KIMEP are taught in English, with the rare exception of perhaps the History of Kazakhstan course, and Kazakh language courses. In all its documentation, KIMEP routinely describes the offering of a ‘North American’ or ‘Westernstyle’ education and meeting these high standards. Implicit in these references to “North American” or Western-style’ is the provision of programmatic course offerings in the English language. Explicit documentation of KIMEP’s compliance with the English language requirement for candidacy appears in the Mission and Profile of the Language Center in the 2005-07 Catalog (p. 233), as well as the “Outstanding Faculty” description on page 28. Requirement 9 The institution, in addition to study of the areas of specialization proper to its principal educational programs, requires a coherent and substantive program of general education at the postsecondary level, comparable to those offered by institutions in the United States, as either a prerequisite to or a clearly defined element in those programs; documents a commitment and resource base sufficient to facilitate students’ achievement of the goals of general education. The General Education program at KIMEP provides an important foundation that supports and enhances each of the university’s degree programs. As with universities in the United States offering such programs, KIMEP realizes the need to broaden student’s educational experience beyond the narrow confines of an individual major area of study. The KIMEP General Education requirement mandates that all bachelors’ students successfully complete 48 credits within the General Education program, which is structured as follows: * * * * * Twenty-four (24) credits in required courses: English language – 12 credits Kazakh language – 6 credits Kazakh history – 3 credits Introductory computing/IT – 3 credits University Life (an orientation course) – 0 credits Twenty-one (21) credits in discipline-specific electives, distributed as follows: One course (3 credits) in sciences One course (3 credits) in ethics and philosophy One course (3 credits) in either Business/Economics or Social Sciences, depending on the student’s major field of study One course (3 credits) in mathematics and statistics Two courses (6 credits) in history, culture and fine arts One course (3 credits) in information technology * Three further credits in unspecified General Education courses (e.g., additional English, additional discipline-specific elective course, foreign language, applied arts, physical education) Students are strongly guided to complete as much of their General Education program as possible in their first year at KIMEP. Most academic departments expect a student to have taken and passed the General Education English course sequence before taking content area courses in the major field. A full current listing of courses meeting the requirements in the “discipline-specific elective” category above can be found in the General Education Program description in the KIMEP 2007-08 Catalog. To support its General Education program, KIMEP utilizes faculty, library resources, and physical facilities available to all KIMEP students, irrespective of their degree program enrollment. In the 8 Spring 2007 124 faculty members taught General Education courses at KIMEP. All library resources are available to students enrolled in these courses. Requirement 10 The institution has adopted a statement specifying the potential students it wishes to serve, and admits qualified students to its programs under admission policies consistent with this statement and appropriate to those programs. KIMEP has thorough and clear admission policies for both undergraduate students and graduate students. In addition, admission policies differentiate between those students educated within Kazakhstan, and those foreign students from outside the Republic. While admission policies are summarized below, detailed information regarding the KIMEP admission policies is found in the 200507 KIMEP Catalog on page 33. At the strategic level, the target group of potential students is as follows: “KIMEP aims to be a leader in the CIS and by extension the international community in the provision of business and social science education based on the North American model. We seek to serve all who share in our vision of ‘Education to Change Society’ and wish to become active participants in this transformation in Kazakhstan, Central Asia and beyond. KIMEP seeks to select students on merit, who demonstrate leadership, talent and language capabilities regardless of age, race, gender, ethnic origin, or financial means”. At the operational level, a statement identifying potential students appears on page 33 in the 2005-07 Catalog, and is as follows: “KIMEP seeks to enroll students who have demonstrated the potential to succeed and have shown evidence of their capability to contribute to the KIMEP community. Criteria for admission to both undergraduate and graduate programs include such qualities as academic standing, knowledge of English, work experience, and achievements combined with leadership, creativity and extracurricular activities. For individuals entering as first year undergraduate students, high school achievements, the results of national complex test , TOEFL and the KIMEP English proficiency test and the particular characteristics of each applicant will be considered. For students entering as first year graduate students, undergraduate achievement and the results of entrance examinations including English proficiency tests will be considered.” Furthermore, a statement of non-discrimination also appears in the 2005-07 Catalog (p. 33), and is as follows: “KIMEP and the KIMEP Admissions Committee do not discriminate against any individual or group on the basis of race, ethnicity, nationality, religion, gender, social or sexual orientation, creed, marital status, physical disabilities, remote area location, age or any other subjective criteria.” In order to maintain quality and integrity of admissions, admissions are considered at three different levels: Criteria are established by programs within each of the colleges. The College Councils of each college approve those criteria. The College Councils makes recommendations to the KIMEP Admissions Committee. The College Admission Committee ensures that criteria and college requirements have been met, and makes recommendations to the KIMEP Admission and Scholarship Committee The KIMEP Admission and Scholarship Committee is appointed by the KIMEP Council. This committee implement the criteria established by the College Admissions Committee and assure consistency across the university. They also ensure that entrance examinations have been conducted fairly and properly and that there is a general compliance with Ministry of Education guidelines. This committee further determines the material resources are available to support newly admitted students. In addition, admissions requirements for both undergraduate and graduate students enable KIMEP to select the most promising applicants within a given applicant pool. For undergraduates, the required materials for the application packet include the standard application, application fee, identification materials, other supplemental materials, as well as high school transcripts, national complex test scores, and English proficiency exam scores. Aspiring graduate students must submit the application, application fee, copy of undergraduate transcripts, identification and other supplemental materials, two letters of recommendation, an essay (MAIJMC program), as well as scores from the KIMEP 9 Graduate Entrance Exam (MBA and MA program) and the English entrance exam. One program (MPA program) requires a personal interview. GMAT or GRE scores can be substituted for the KIMEP Graduate Entrance Examination discussed above. To be accepted by KIMEP, as undergraduate students applicants must sit the KIMEP English Entrance Test (KEET) comprised of 100 questions, for which students are given 1.5 hours to complete. The exam consists of grammar questions (50%), vocabulary, usage and idiom questions (25%), and reading comprehension (25%). Minimum English entrance scores for admission into KIMEP vary by program, and vary by intake period. For the March 2006 admissions period, the minimum entrance exam score for program acceptance was 65 for all undergraduates (one exception is journalism for whom it is 50). Students, who score up to 9 points below the minimum acceptance score on the KEET, may be admitted on a provisional basis. The provisional admission is for one full-time semester, and passing this program for those students who failed the KEET, a “pre-KIMEP” program is in place for exam preparation. Such students enroll full-time for a semester to reach the required competence in English. For those students who score adequately on the KEET, a new English program is to be implemented from summer 2007. During July and August, students admitted to KIMEP must attend a pre-degree 5 hours-a-day, 6-week English course. After successfully fulfilling the requirements of this, students will take during the 1st semester of their 1st year, Academic Speaking and Academic Listening and Note-taking Skills 1. Upon successful completion, students proceed to Semester 2 in which they must take Academic Listening and Note-taking Skills 2 and Academic Reading and Writing. Similar conditions apply to graduates wishing to enter KIMEP. In addition, KIMEP offers preparatory programs for high school students that specifically target the English entrance exam as well as the subject matter on the Kazakhstan national complex test. Requirement 11. Has students enrolled in and pursuing its principal educational programs at the time of the Commission’s evaluation. The KIMEP student profile is diverse, and the population is growing as academic programs grow. In recent years the student profile has become increasingly international. For the academic year 20062007, from a total of 3803 applications submitted, 2156 students were admitted and 1033 new students were enrolled for studies. The breakdown by of enrolled students by program is summarized in Figures 4a and 4b. Figure 4a - Undergraduate Enrollment 2006-7 2000 1824 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 797 800 658 600 400 200 146 0 BAIJ Source: KIMEP Registrar BAE BSS BSC 10 Figure 4b - Graduate Enrollment 2006-7 350 304 300 250 200 150 100 48 50 8 13 DBA Executive MBA 22 24 30 MAIJ MIR MA 0 MPA MBA The phenomenal growth in the student population demonstrates the public’s confidence in KIMEP. As can be seen in the following graph, the student population has increased by 100% since 2002-03. Current forecasts aim for a population of around 4,900 students by academic year 2009-10. Figure 5: KIMEP Student Population, 1999-00 to 2009-10 (projected) 6000 4900 5000 4550 4700 4045 4000 3378 2855 3000 2250 2000 2000 1500 1100 1000 750 0 1990-00 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 Source: Office of the Registrar, KIMEP Strategic Planning Team Note: 2007-2010 figures are projected. Requirement 12. Has available to students and the public a current and accurate catalog or comparable official publication setting forth purposes and objectives, entrance requirements and procedures, rules and regulations for student conduct, programs and courses, degree completion requirements, full-time and part-time faculty and degrees held, costs, refunds, and other items related to attending or withdrawing from the institution. The KIMEP Catalog and the conditions stated therein are considered a legal document for studies at KIMEP that binds both parties (KIMEP and Student) towards fulfilling their obligations. The KIMEP Catalog provides students, faculty members, administrators and all other interested persons with the 11 details of graduate and undergraduate studies at KIMEP. It offers an insight into KIMEP, its policies, academic programs and auxiliary services. The 2005-2007 Catalog furthermore provides detailed descriptions of academic policies and procedures, rules and regulations, academic departments, programs, curricula and organizational structures of the Institution. Every student is strongly encouraged to read the Catalog carefully and must abide by the rules and polices published by KIMEP. A copy of the 2005-2007 Catalog is included with this Report of Eligibility. Key issues set out in Requirement 12 are located in the Catalog as shown in Figure 6 below. The new edition of the Catalog to be published for AY 2007-2008 contains the same range and depth of information. Figure 6: Location of Key Information for Requirement 12 in 2005-7 Catalog Element Page Number KIMEP Profile 24 Entry Requirements 33 Procedures, rules and regulations for student conduct 62-67 Programs and courses 68-203 Degree completion requirements: B.Sc 79-99 BAE 162-169 BSS 149-157 BAIJ 195-198 MBA 100-123 MPA 188-193 MA 170-180 MIR 159-161 MAIJMC 199-203 DBA 124-133 ExMBA 134-138 To be included in 2007-2008 Catalog MA TESOL Faculty Costs, refunds, and other items related to attending or withdrawing from the institution Source: KIMEP Catalog, 2005-2007. 271-282 58-59 Requirement 13. Has a charter and/or other formal authority from the appropriate government agency authorizing it to grant all degrees it awards; has the necessary operating authority for each jurisdiction in which it conducts its activities, and is operating within its authority. If the institution is not legally eligible for local government approval, it otherwise documents its standing and significant support from the local community and other relevant communities of interest. KIMEP was established in accordance with the Resolution # 580 of the President of Republic of Kazakhstan of January 14, 1992. This new institution was to be staffed by a mix of foreign and national instructors and was to operate according to the high academic standards of North American and European academic institutions. The first Charter was established in the same year. KIMEP has always been a non-profit institution. Until President of Kazakhstan issued Decree N 1178 dated institution ‘KIMEP under the President of the Republic Stock Company KIMEP. The Joint Stock Company 2003 it was a state institution. In 2003, the August 28 on the reorganization of the state of Kazakhstan’ into the non-commercial Joint ‘JSC KIMEP’ was established based on the 12 Foundation Agreement of June 4, 2004. The Charter was revised and a new Charter was established at this point. As a non-profit organization the JSC KIMEP does not and cannot pursue a goal to get a profit, cannot allocate net profit between shareholders and can use any surplus only for the development of the JSC KIMEP. (KIMEP Charter, article 1.6). This directly fits with legislation. As stated by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Non Commercial Organizations”, article 16.1: a non commercial joint stock company is a legal entity that issues shares with the purpose of attracting resources for the implementation of its activity, the profit of which could be used for the development of the company only. What this means is that any surplus has to be reinvested into the development of the Institute. Furthermore, it is not possible for this status to be changed without a change in the legal framework under which the non commercial JSC KIMEP was established. As stated by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Non Commercial Organizations”, article 16.1, as a non-commercial JSC KIMEP cannot be reorganized into a commercial organization. KIMEP acts on the basis of its foundation documents and the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan. As a higher educational institution KIMEP also acts on the basis of the KIMEP Catalog and other documents regulating academic processes and internal rules. According to the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan the institution has a right to grant diplomas and certificates of the established form, including state ones, and award corresponding degree and qualifications to its graduates. The Institution and its academic programs are licensed and also attested by the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The support of the Government of the Republic is further demonstrated by its shareholding in the non commercial JSC structure and membership of representatives on the Board of Trustees as discussed further below. Requirement 14 Has a governing board that includes representation reflecting the public interest that oversees the institution, working to assure the fulfillment of its mission and advance the institution’s level of quality; assures that fewer than one-half of the board members have any financial interest in the institution, including as employee, stock-holder, or corporate director. The governance structure of KIMEP is summarized in Figure 7 and the key elements explained below. The role of the President is discussed in detail under Requirement 15 below, while the roles of the various Vice-Presidents are self-explanatory. This reflects a reformed organizational structure approved by the KIMEP Council March 2007, which aimed at increasing support for the President, developing a focus on advancement and further development of the governance structure. This will take effect in June of 2007. Further changes in the ownership of KIMEP are planned with the creation of a Foundation which will hold 100% of the shares of KIMEP in trust for perpetuity. This will replace the General Meeting of Shareholders in the governance structure. This is discussed in detail in Attachments 4a-4d of the self study submission. Figure 7: KIMEP Governance Structure General Meeting of Shareholders Board of Trustees Executive Committee President KIMEP Council President’s Administration Executive Vice President Vice President Administration & Finance Vice President Academic Affairs Associate Vice President Administration & Finance Associate Vice President Academic Affairs Administrative Departments Colleges Vice President Advancement Dean of Student Affairs Advancement Departments Student Services 13 General Meeting of Shareholders Office of the President / The General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS) is the supreme body of the JSC “KIMEP” (Charter, President’s administration art.6.1). An annual General Meeting of the GMS is held once a year and there are also mechanisms for extraordinary meetings to be held as and when necessary. There are two shareholders in the JSC ‘KIMEP’ entitled to attend the General Meeting of Shareholders: Dr Chan Young Bang, President of KIMEP (holding 60% of shares) A representative of the Committee on State Property and Privatization under the Ministry of Finance of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan ( holding 40% of shares). The GMS has exclusive competence over the following issues drawn directly from the KIMEP Charter, (art.6.3). “Making amendments to the Charter of the JSC “KIMEP” or approval of its new version; Voluntary reorganization or liquidation of the JSC “KIMEP”; Adoption of a decision on changing the number of declared shares of the JSC “KIMEP”; Defining the number and term of office of the Counting commission of the JSC “KIMEP”, election of its members and early termination of their office; Defining the number of members and term of office of the Board of Trustees/the Board of Directors, election of its members and termination of their authority ahead of time, defining the amount and conditions of bonuses for the members of the Board of Trustees/the Board of Directors, excluding civil servants; Designation of the auditing organization conducting the audit of the JSC “KIMEP; Approval of annual financial statements of the JSC “KIMEP”; Adoption of decision on participation of the JSC “KIMEP” in establishment or activities of other legal entities by transferring part or several parts of assets that in total constitute twenty-five and more per cent of all the assets held by the JSC “KIMEP”; Approval of decisions on major transactions and transactions in which the JSC “KIMEP” has an interest; Making decision to increase obligations of the JSC “KIMEP” for the sum that constitutes up to twenty-five and more per cent of its own capital; Defining the form of notification of the shareholders of the JSC “KIMEP” regarding convocation of the General Meeting of Shareholders and making a decision on placing the information in periodical press; Approval of the method(s) for determining the value of the shares when they are redeemed by the JSC “KIMEP” in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on securities market; Approval of the agenda of the General Meeting of Shareholders; Defining the procedures on information disclosure to the shareholders concerning the Company's activities, including determination of the periodical press; Introduction and annulment of a “golden share”. It is prohibited to delegate authority on issues under the exclusive competence of the GMS to the competence of other bodies (Charter, art.6.5). Board of Trustees The next level of authority is the Board of Trustees, the managing body of the JSC “KIMEP”. Exclusive competence issues of the Board are as follows, drawing directly from the KIMEP Charter, art.6.21. “Determination of the priority directions of the development of the JSC “KIMEP”, approval of the strategies and plans for development of the JSC “KIMEP”; Making decision on convocation of an annual and extraordinary General meetings of shareholders; Making decision on allocation of shares of the JSC “KIMEP” and their price within the limits of the number of declared shares; Making decision on redemption of the allocated shares by the JSC “KIMEP”; Preliminary approval of the annual financial statements of the JSC “KIMEP”; Election and determination of terms of power of the Chair of the Executive Committee (President of the JSC “KIMEP”), and also termination of his authorities ahead of time; Determination of salary and premium bonuses for the Chair of the Executive Committee of the JSC “KIMEP” (The President of the JSC “KIMEP”); Determination of fees for appraiser and audit company; Making decisions on establishment and liquidation of the branches and representative offices of the JSC “KIMEP” and approval of regulations concerning their activities; Increase in liabilities of the JSC “KIMEP” up to ten and more percent of its equity capital; 14 Appointment of the registrar company of the JSC “KIMEP” in case of termination of the contract with the previous registrar company; Identification of information about the JSC “KIMEP” or its activity that constitutes official, commercial or other type of secret protected by law; Making a decision on main transactions or transactions in which the JSC “KIMEP” has an interest; Making decisions on the JSC “KIMEP” participation in creation and functioning of other companies”. The current members of the Board of Trustees of KIMEP are shown in Figure 8 below. Figure 8: KIMEP Board of Trustees, 2005-7 Chairman of the Board : Vacant Board Members: Chan Young Bang, PhD, President of KIMEP Lee Kyung Jae, Bachelor of Mechanics, Vice-President, USKO International, Kazakhstan Daniel Connelly, Bachelor of Arts, Chief Executive Officer, Citibank Kazakhstan Chae Ho Kim, Honorary Doctor of KIMEP, BA Economics, Chairman of Hae Kwang Co., Ltd., Seoul, Korea Andrew Wilson, MBA, Vice-President of Eurasia Foundation, Central Asia Nadezhda Pogorelova, Diploma of Higher Education, General Director, “Economical Center” Company, Kazakhstan Igor Tupikov, MBA, President of the JSC “Buran Boiler”, Kazakhstan Victor Khrapunov, Honorary Doctor of KIMEP, Mayor of East Kazakhstan Oblast Grigoriy Marchenko, Diploma of Higher Education, Chairman of the Board of the National Bank of Kazakhstan Daulet Sembayev, Honorary Doctor of KIMEP, Deputy Chairman of the Kazcommercebank Board of Directors Eduard Utepov, Candidate of Science, First Deputy Chairman, Committee on State Property and Privatization of the Ministry of Finance of the RK Kalimzhan Ibraimov, Diploma of Higher Education, Head of the Department, Committee on State Property and Privatization of the Ministry of Finance of the RK Elena Saharova, Diploma of Higher Education, Deputy Head of the Department, Committee on State Property and Privatization of the Ministry of Finance of the RK Winfred L. Thompson, Ph.D. Chancellor of American University of Sharjiah Hartmut Fisher, Ph.D. Professor of Economics, University of San Francisco, California, USA Jaemin Han, Ph.D. Professor, Associate Dean, Graduate School of Business, Korea University As can be seen above, the members of the KIMEP Board of Trustees possess a wide variety of experience, competencies, and academic backgrounds. Each is a well-respected member of the community at large. In recognition of the fact that KIMEP is an academic institution, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan did not take advantage of its right to appoint representatives proportionate to its shareholding. KIMEP continues to work hard to diversify the membership of the Board and is currently focused on increasing academic representation, targeting world-class academicians for membership. In addition, the President of KIMEP is the only member of the Board of Trustees with a direct personal financial interest in the University. The bylaws of the Board of Trustees, KIMEP and College Councils are available on the KIMEP web-site www.kimep.kz under “Authority”. KIMEP Council The Charter of JSC KIMEP (clause 6.43) provides for the establishment of a University Senate, called the KIMEP Council which is the highest collective decision and policymaking body within the Institution. The composition of this council is derived from administration, faculty and students. The members and composition of the Council are determined in accordance with procedures established in the KIMEP Council by-laws. Members of the Board of Trustees shall have the right to participate in the Council’s meetings as observers. The Council functions in accordance with its own by-laws found on the KIMEP website www.kimep.kz under “Authority”. Policies governing academic, non-academic, administrative, finance and budgeting activities are formulated and approved by this Council. Under the KIMEP Charter, this Council has the exclusive 15 right to review and approve student tuition fees amongst other matters. The Council has a number of standing committees, which primarily concentrate on with matters of policy and monitoring. Academic resolutions passed by the College Councils including introduction of new academic programs that require major financial considerations are submitted to the KIMEP Council for final approval. In addition, the creation and elimination of academic and support units, modification of faculty code of practice, budget and resource allocations etc require the final approval of the KIMEP Council. Requirement 15. Has a chief executive officer whose full-time or major responsibility is to the institution and who possesses the requisite authority. In the KIMEP governing structure, the office of President fulfils the functions of Chief Executive Officer. Chan Young Bang, Ph.D. is the President and Chair of the Executive Committee of KIMEP. According to the Charter, the President is authorized to: Ensure the fulfillment of the provisions of KIMEP Charter; Organize the implementation of the decisions of the General Meeting of shareholders and the Board of Trustees/the Board of Directors; Conduct general management and control of KIMEP and be responsible for the efficiency of its work; Supervise the work of the Executive Committee and the Council of KIMEP; Provides overall directions for educational and research policies; Consider and approve financial policies and major expenditures; Supervise budgeting and auditing works; Distribute the responsibilities, authorities and duties among the members of the Executive Committee; Exercise hiring, displacement and firing of the JSC “KIMEP” staff (with the exception of cases stipulated by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan), apply awards and disciplinary punishments, determine salaries and redundancy payments in accordance with the Staff Schedule of the JSC “KIMEP”, determine bonuses for employees of the JSC “KIMEP” except for members of the Executive Committee; Implement standards of academic and administrative ethics; Approve documents which regulate the internal activities of KIMEP, apart from those that must be approved by the Council of KIMEP; Determine the procedures of utilization of the reserve capital of KIMEP; Appoint the Chairs of the branch and representative offices of KIMEP; Act on behalf of KIMEP in contacting with outside parties without any letter of attorney; Issue a letter of attorney ensuring the right to act on behalf of KIMEP in contact with the third parties. The position of the President of KIMEP is a full time position. An Individual Labor Contract with Dr. Chan Young Bang was signed by the Chairman of the Board of Trustees Mr. A. Peterson in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “About Joint Stock Companies”(art.59.2) Dr. Chan Young Bang does not work full-time for any other company or organization in Kazakhstan. However, he is the owner of two companies in Kazakhstan: the JSC “USKO International” and “Buran Boiler” LLP. Any potential conflict of interest between KIMEP and Dr. Chan Young Bang is controlled by rules and procedures established at KIMEP. There is a strong system of various committees at different levels (departments, colleges, institution). This system makes the Institute open and transparent to any target audience (students, faculty, staff, partners, sponsors, and official bodies) and helps to foster an environment which nullifies any opportunities to misuse authority by KIMEP officials, including the President, for monetary or other personal gain. Requirement 16 Has an administration, faculty, and professional staff who collectively have significant experience in American higher education and are prepared to ensure the institution meets the Standards for Accreditation. KIMEP maintains a full-time faculty and a cadre of administrative staff sufficient to control and manage academic and non-academic affairs, and to provide stability and on-going quality improvement. Because KIMEP, by choice, has introduced an American style education for all its academic programs, extra care has been given to recruit North American trained or experienced faculty and administrative staff. Key positions such as President, Vice Presidents, Deans, Chairs, directors of academic programs etc are held by mostly North American trained professionals. In 16 addition, a majority of the international faculty are either qualified American citizens or are educated in the USA and Canada. These are documented in 2005-2007 KIMEP Catalog. As a testimony to its commitment to developing an American style of education with quality control, KIMEP has developed its administrative structures, student support systems, education policies and procedures, the Faculty Code of Practice, Tenure and Promotion system, bylaws for Board of Trustees, KIMEP and College Councils by drawing directly on higher education practice in the USA. KIMEP regularly receives visiting faculty from international organizations such as Fulbright, the USA State Department, Princeton-in-Asia, Civic Education Project (CEP), DAAD (Germany) and TACIS of the European Union. In the years 2000-2006, KIMEP received around 40 visiting faculty members, most of them with terminal degrees from these organizations. These faculty members were involved in teaching, research and development of academic programs at KIMEP. In the 2004-2005 academic year, around 20 new faculty members with PhD degrees, many from the USA joined the professorial ranks of KIMEP. In Fall 2006, 19 faculty with PhDs from western countries joined KIMEP. It is planned that about 20 additional PhDs will join KIMEP in Fall of 2007. KIMEP has a target of making its PhD ratio approximately 60% of all faculty, which it aims to achieve by Fall 2007. Requirement 17. Devotes all, or substantially all, of its gross income to the support of its educational purposes and programs. KIMEP devotes all of its gross income to the support of its function as an institution of higher education. Approximately 55% of income is directed toward staff payroll, while the remainder is devoted to such indirect academic support activities as administration/marketing (20%) and capital expenditures focused on facility improvement (24%) as shown in Figure 9 which gives figures for academic year 2006-7. Figure 9 - 2006/7 Budget Elements (figures in $1000s) Other Expenditure Capital expenditure Expenditure Payroll Scholarships Other Income Income Tuition fees 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 Requirement 18. Documents a funding base, financial resources, and plans for financial development adequate to carry out its stated purposes. KIMEP is a self-sustaining, debt free institution that supports itself from its revenues. Funding is derived from six sources: Student tuition fees Corporate support and donations Executive training programs Support from donors such as the Soros Foundation, USAID, TACIS of the EU, Eurasia Foundation etc Investment by founding President Chan Young Bang Rental incomes 17 To illustrate this, and to document a funding base and available financial resources, the academic years from Fall 2002 to Spring 2006 can be viewed as recent examples. Figure 10 provides the Academic Year funding bases for KIMEP for 2002-2003 to 2006-2007. Figure 10: KIMEP Academic Year Funding Bases 2002-3 to 2006-7(US Dollars) 2002-2003 Tuition Fees 2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 5593714 6809525 8855560 12517164 16553000 Donor and Corporate Support* 180126 227077 241556 354004 190000 Rental and other Revenue 327247 392217 350000 524633 644500 Investment by Dr.Bang 400000 700000 0 0 0 6501086,31 8128818,86 Source: KIMEP Accounting Department 9447115,59 13395800,61 17387500,00 Note: All dollar figures rounded to the nearest 1,000 * Donor and Corporate Support provided by USAID, Soros Foundation, Eurasia Foundation, Exxon Mobil, LG, Procter and Gamble and others. As can be seen in Figure 10, KIMEP receives sizeable funding from tuition (including student-paid tuition, as well as corporate trilateral contracts and scholarships), institutional support from corporate donors, corporate grants for faculty, rent, and individual investment by Dr. Bang, KIMEP’s President. Figure 11 shows the total KIMEP annual (academic year) budget from AY 2001-2002 through 20062007. As can be clearly seen, KIMEP’s total annual budget has seen significant and consistent increases over the past four academic years. Figure 11: KIMEP Budget 2001-2 to 2006-7, Million US Dollars 17,38 18 16 14,04 14 12 9,45 10 7,46 8 6 6,14 4,23 4 2 0 2001-2 2002-3 2003-4 2004-5 2005-6 2006-7 Source: KIMEP Budget and Finance Committee KIMEP has also implemented a number of plans for financial development. The first of these is a plan to increase student tuition by 18 percent for academic year 2007-8 and enrollment resulting in a significant increase in annual revenue ($3.3 millions if using AY 2006-2007 as an example). A second thrust for future financial development includes plans to cultivate alumni support. Alumni giving is a major source of funding for universities in the U.S., and remains an underutilized potential financial resource for KIMEP. A third plan for financial development involves the further development of the Business Advisory Council which is composed of prominent business individuals. This council has increased KIMEP’s connections with outside businesses, and, combined with an intensified fundraising effort, is expected to generate additional donated revenue in the coming academic years. The fourth major direction for KIMEP’s financial planning revolves around expanding current executive training programs. The Executive MBA program targets top corporate executives. Numerous professional development business certificates are offered. KIMEP currently has an 18 executive training program that generates around $250,000 annually. Executive training remains a promising market, and KIMEP plans to expand its executive training offerings. This expansion, in the near future, is expected to increase revenue from executive training programs significantly. KIMEP is also in the process of further developing its financial forecasting capacity. The KIMEP Strategy Committee has adopted a model to accurately forecast the sustainable development of the institution to 2010. This will shape future financial planning in the Institute and is aimed at ensuring, amongst other factors: Continuing improvements in the quality of education offered; Ensuring adequate funds for future capital investment and contingencies; Capping the growth of KIMEP to around 4,900 students registered by 2009-10. An early version of the forecast has produced promising results, as Figure 12 demonstrates. Figure 12: KIMEP: Income, Costs and Surplus, 2004-5 to 2009-10 (USD) 35 31,4 29,56 30 26,35 25 20 17,3816,95 15 10 25 22,5 21,59 13,81 12,99 9,4 9,4 5 0 0,01 2004-5 0,82 0,91 0,43 2005-6 2006-7 Total Income 2007-8 Total Costs 1,35 2008-9 1,84 2009-10 Surplus Source: KIMEP Strategy Committee 2007-8 to 2009-10 figures projected. Requirement 19. Has financial records that relate clearly to the institution’s educational activities and has these records externally audited on a regular schedule; if auditing procedures differ from those generally used in the United States, provides financial records reconciled to accounting practices common to American higher education. All KIMEP financial records and statements are audited annually by an independent Certified Public Accountant. Audit documents from 2001 are documents of public record. Each year, the accounts are published in the mass media and on the KIMEP website and are available to any party on request. Requirement 20. Has graduated at least one class in its principal educational programs before the Commission’s evaluation for accredited status. If the institution has graduated its first class not more than one year before the Commission’s evaluation, the effective date of accreditation will be the date of graduation of that first class. KIMEP graduated its first class of students in 1994. As can be seen in Figure 13, the number of annual graduates from KIMEP stabilized at around 200 1997-2002, with major expansion since 2003. The 1994 graduating class (81 students) consisted of 69 graduates of KIMEP’s Master of Business Administration (MBA) program and 12 graduates of the Master of Arts (MA) in Economics program. The 2006 graduating class (468 students) is indicative of substantive enrollment increases from 1992, as well as the expansion of programmatic offerings. In 2006 there was the following division of graduated students: BSc-195 students BSS-41 students 19 BAE-36 students BAIJ-2 students MBA-105 students MA-19 students MPA-18 students MIR-10 students MAIJMC- 13 students ExMBA- 29 students Figure 13: KIMEP Graduates, 1994-2006 600 532 522 497 500 468 400 300 196 200 100 191 209 182 194 189 147 81 97 0 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Source: Office of the Registrar, KIMEP