2011 (2) (33) _ Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies -Economic and Legal Sciences Series Vol. (33) No. (2) 2011
"# " !
$# % $ *
& '
**
) '
***
*) )
(2011 / 4 / 3 "# 21 0 .2010 / 12 / 14 +, -
)
∇
3 4 ∇
$% &' (
# !!" .' + *
, -
*, # !!"
)*
, -* .(3" #* 2) $0 ( .+ !!" *, )! . *,
3
, (55) *, - -> )= .2010 ;2009 7
* (
*, (
(8
, (80) *,
* #B
* #* * #!!" *) : !!" * - -,@
.(!C * ( " #D * #E
>
.' + I + !!" *, )! FG
-H%
+ ) 7, #+ !!" *, J ! -
. !!" H -
= 7I .3" #* 2 $0 (
.'
.$+ ! 0 - 3K. .7* !!" #
3+ # !!" # !!" :
5 '
. 869 8 8
' 8# 8)
6
7
. 869 8 8
' 8 8)
6
7
. 869 8 8
' 8 8(:') ) 75
*
**
***
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
2011 (2) (33) _ Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies -Economic and Legal Sciences Series Vol. (33) No. (2) 2011
The Current Strategic Planning in Tishreen
University According to The Workers' Perspective
Dr. Sameer Sharaf*
Dr. Walid Ameer**
Abeer Ohtera***
(Received 14 / 12 / 2010. Accepted 3 / 4 / 2011)
∇
ABSTRACT
∇
The research aimed at building a strategic planning model for Tishreen University,
based on the theoretical literature of strategic planning, and on the answers of research
sample of administrators and academics about the degree of Application Strategic Planning
Stages at university according to the variables (qualification, and experience).The sample
included 80 administrative members in the academic year 2009/2010. To achieve the
object of the research, a questionnaire has included (55) items, distributed to six Stages for
Strategic Planning (Planning, Analysis, direction, forging, enforcement, and the control).
The findings were the following: The degree of implementation of the stages of
strategic planning in Tishreen University by administrators and academics was average in
all phases of the strategic planning process. In fact, there are differences between the
administrators and academics in qualification and experience. The Research has finally
presented suggestions concerning Tishreen University that it must adopt strategic planning
as a tool for changing and developing administrative work.
Keywords: Strategic Planning, Higher Education, University Management, Planning
Education
*
Associate professor, Finance and Banking Department, Faculty of Economics, Tishreen university,
Lattakia, Syria.
**
Associate professor, planning Department, Faculty of Economics, Tishreen university, Lattakia,
Syria.
***
Postgraduate Student, Economics and Planning Department, Faculty of Economics, University of
Tishreen Lattakia, Syria.
76
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
:
-
*= . -! = 7, M 7 7
, -
% - G
, -
% -
2 B , #
>
" #
>I 7N # I -8. JI *, 3= #7 (
@ - B J . H.
!!" 3 -
8" .G
! C= 7
= H C 3> H #
' #
H *= % % -
% -
2 ( ! -
% . Q . .-
% O* *" " G P , H
*, 8" HI *, Q *, !!" % . # 80
G % J !' -
" . @8 G
HK * B #%
P
> "K !!" H R
& * -
2 >
" #0* JC"
.
, D> J >
" D> 7*
:<#=7 =7
: =7
JI C #Q* !!" 7HD , (% ( 7= Q. K
3 D. *, #
H *
% H !!" )! .ٕ
N JI C *, H )!* = * ! D ! !!"
. Q=!
: &=7
7" #-
% 3 H=! -" N -' # !!" 3 T
# ' )= -
% 7
I C -
I
! @. C 7
= *, H,
-ٕ - I >+ (
(H . #0 G G B
-
% . *, !!" *, V
ٕ .7
= -0 JC J U. U
#Q*D % Q
!C *, &* ) 3 *, -!" C H' #
H* H R
=! !!" H O #C > 0 3
, -
% H # !!"
)* $% &' (
O !!" *, , . 7N #
* + *
. !!" 2 -
= 7= .
: '
:X 2 , + *. W"*
.U !!" )! . ;1
77
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
!!" )! V= ' B )! . ;2
.U
: >7
:X *G' , &
, % H + !!" )! . :' 2
U
+ , [ (α = 0.05) Y , (G
> ) :
N 2
!!" \* . , * 2 0 (
+ !!" )! .
U
. Y *, #+
, [ (α = 0.05) Y , ( G
> ) :
N 2
!!" \* . , 3" 0 (
+ !!" )! .
U
. Y *, #+
: ?#
Q *, #Q, I -
+ H! *G] (
= -
CD -C )=
. , [ (α = 0.05) Y , (
G
> ) :X
.1
!!" \* . , * 2 0 (
+ !!" )!
.
. Y *, #+
. , [ (α = 0.05) Y , (
G
> ) .2
!!" \* . , 3" 0 (
+ !!" )!
.
. Y *, #+
: $
+ !!" )! . R
= #** D> FH *, ,
->*" * &
Q* !!" 7HD =
-
-
' ^
#+ !!" \* . , + !!" )! . FG
.
. Y *,
78
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
:<) !
I #
H * + *
*, $ # 7* -
2 7C J 7
* (868) H * + *
, _* # -
2 B , -"
I #
-
*. ^ @. 3+ * + *
(%11) -" .2010/2009
.( (80) ->K #*! -
* *, HG 7 (16) 7 #(96) -0*
:X Q *, G H -0 & , * + c@ X
"# , ) #7 +A :(1) 2
(%) -0
36.3
29
3@
31.3
25
32.5
26
B.
31.3
25
36.3
29
G C,
12.5
10
R
12.5
10
,
7.5
6
22.5
18
- 5 I
26.3
21
- (10 \ 5) 51.3
41
- 10 N.
100
80
c
* 2
* 3"
.( "# , BC $ D>
) :
:*E F G
R G C, . , *, ' H> -C, 3' )> >*
8 #
HC $ ٕ #
-= 3I 7H &*! #
>" #- C VI #-= Cٕ #Q $ * H8 #0* HE
>
!!" *, )! G8 , 7
, . % -
H ( "
D 7"
- *" )
&
7 -
N &
. . # , " ( (15) *, H=! )! , O #(Cronbach Alpha) f
.
:X *, *" )
79
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
*7 F 2
(2) 2
-
N 0.79
!!"* !!" *
0.95
* *
0.94
B
*
0.87
+ E
> *
0.94
+ D *
0.95
+ !C *
0.98
.. 3'
R
= H*, , . #*" )
, 7 3 .Q*' ->
:
I% ,
:I% ,
= 3"' N8N = (
(
#+ 3+ K. !!" HH G -N2 !0C* O # I ( 7
% #
$ C
= -
J*! J !!" .
H
H -
%
$ #.D 8= &*' H. Y. % *% - K Q. $+ 7N $
>I $ ' #-
% -
2
! -0 7H Q. ( C 7
:QK !!" .(7#2004 # ,) H== ' )= &*' 0 )= > % -
I
! N
*,
*, #% = . 3
7
, " *" * *, #% I H*, )D 3 C 2 = % Q*, . & 7% 3 Q *, (21 #2004 #) 0 .
)! !
" N *
!" 3' B CD #** -
* , ) *, J .- , R" . # @ 3 = )
[ X H*= %*
#!!"* !!" :X N #*> - -!" =! ** !!"
. !C ( " # D # E
> # B
# *
:* . >D B 7
!!" * 7
=* % Y * B H : ;
* % " J f
N 3, >
, 7
H 3
, , # #-
* % # !!" 3" $ + # !!" H
* -+ J I . R
#
" *" % G , . -
* & . !!" *, * . .
H D !
# !!" *, H
-
" ' JC .Q
2 Q>
>"
BH 7
=* % !!" *, O 7= $ $ #' = #, )
80
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
*, ) I -
I , * B , %= & .(Allison, 2005, 54) H
* c I HC H &*! #Q*,
# !!"
#&*' 7" % + E 7, :-
I B @ .
H
C !!"
#+ !!" JC -
* -
,I 7, #%* " *" G J 0
#
) !!" &
#
H*, > > C
B $ &*' " H*, !!" *, 3@
% . , .(104 #2007
.
HH %* . &
3, O
> ^ #* B 0 )= (
#*, D !!" *, #D *, !!" *, &*) &
' B .(69 #1991 #$8) ()D. &*
#% .H #
H!
N2 H
" % " :" 2 ;
,
>I -0 % " #*" HG >
, @ H*, G
= =N
G -
^ -N I .% !!" *, NK - >
.
JC :-N2 O* *N #
H' % D N " 7 *" -
. %
!
- #P
> &
> !0C #
-
@ #, 3 Q= *" %
& E -0 B J w #(Wilkins, 2006, 45) . - #
" >I .+ *
-0 B #+ !!" *, .D , HC
#7
) ' Q
. #+ !!" *, H + * * T ,
D & . #= Q*, . & HC %* P #(44 #2005
H== ' 7N #
H
% 2 E
> * Q . #
H
)! *, 3
I . Hw #
HG * *, 3
I % . , (Garner, 2005)
* O )= H 7, = *, HI -0 J H*,
D C #
H.* &
G Y *, #7
H G Y #
G Y *, " G Y *, '
.(21 #2007 #"[ ) *"
H' ( % + !!" *, H * B :", :
E
> :* B 7
H @ #+ H #
H
H2 8" #% = P8 7
H % + . #+ ' #% E
> #% 2
(58 #2006 # #R) +
- 7N #
C 2 % Y -. * B K :, J
. . ** H : 3
E
> .7
C H
I N. -8>D 7= # #*
!". H % . . - I D -
, *,
D> -
N8N + !" . .(87 #2004 #) 2 >>"
! !" JC #Y 3>I @
+ JC Y 3>I !"
#
H ! @ &
E
> .(44 K2002 #
!=) Y *! #Y ! @
+ Y *! Y
81
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
!" :8" H, . #* -
F -
$ # !" +
.* -
JC #F -
#+
%
( + !!" H + D * :", 65 *, I K JC #Q*, C Q*= 0 #Q !!" 7 $ JI C *, 7 H'
," HK + D * (88 #2004 #) .Q ! -0 J ,
D
D F 8" * )! JC + !!" JC R
#-
D -
!
#+ D *, c I % G
= *, & .+ -+ -
@
*0 + !!" *, 8> Y 7H =! -
w ,D *G' , !
-
.+ % *, 7 U
' JC 7 :* *G' O* #
, & #% JC == , Q > 7 PC R
) U7* *, " )
I -
> -H , G! *
. O
U-@H -
*! B 7 #Q==
.(85 #2007 #"[ ) H * GH Y UD Q
Y ' Y .K* I !C 7
% * B :", ? !C* -!" R" .(74 #1991 #$8) HC 7 ' )= *, Q=
".
J ' FG
= #*D ' R
I #' R
= E
> #Q
I & :
.(109 #2003 #B*,) > -+
:
-
= !!" )! -
I =* &I' -
-
. cC =* & 3
C+ #Q=!
!!" H*, 7= * {
#R' *, - (2010 #
) Y
, !* 7* 3@ Q
Y *, #
. 3, ->*" . !!" *, Q -
.
#
H )!
#7* -
% Q I -8.
2 *, ,
!!" T :
H FG
,
. #7H
% ! G -0
2 *, ,
. #
H,I I H* .
*, 7* # -
% *
,
#Q #= 3I *,
.7H
% + ' E
>
3@H' !!" N *, (2005 #D) -
-H #
. ,-
* #-
# # -
D. # B #' .
# !!" N # B 7H
*, * ! #
* + B
0
, *, H@ 7 # -0 (*
#* 3K. -" . ( (229)
82
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
O #' ' c
!I !!" JI (2003 #&!") -
7 ,* B .
!' #-
* > #
#7HD VC 8"
BH ! 7
T O #H BH 7
= , "2 G .2 ' # !!" : B -
. # J C ( (50) *, -,@
#*" G >
, "K #' ' ,
> . 7=
:
FG
B -*>
!!" *, T : , |56 Y . !!" * 7
= , #
, "
, R. $ ' #Y"' + -
, ( #
* 3+ 8" 7 ' ' ,
> . $ |52 Q T ٕ . %
- = " #@.
. !!" 7HD P> * O
' K -
. *, (O. ) GE D> )! (2003 #*) -
!!" *, V
D> #
!" . H,
. +
)! , ,
:
H 3, FG
-*> .' # " G * #*= 2 H!
(
= . PC : GE D>
E
> #) 3> + G 3= C *" G * #-H WD
#
K #+ 7, * -+ -
JC #=I E
> + !!"
.D*" G -0 J + G Y # ' !!" I8 . (Wagne, 2006) -
#
!!" -
C ' ' C+
#-
*. O* 2
- = " ,
> 3,
' ! !!" *, 7" -
2 Y
#2 ' N !!" -*> #+

C FG
-
. #
WD 3
D #2 -
.+ 80 . . 7
.+ - = ,
> ' !!" 3 80 D . @ 7
I' Y -€ *, -D (Cohen, 2006) . -
7 !!" :
D !!" P*!> )* *G , + (!= H ) .'
!!" -*> I #
H )D #O #
H*. #
CI *, @. !!" ' * B (
H ( &* 7
% 3
= #ٕ !!"
.*= 3% CI J (
" ( *" % 7H
!!" -
*, 3N2 (Tapinos, et.al, 2005) "[ @ -,
G !!" ' R
I N )= -*> # *, 3
D. D % )= 7, ( . ( NK Q . #Q N @ #
*, !!" != -
, BNK >= # !!"
.0 D*" -
G 7 D*" -
% = (
C ,
ٕ
83
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
@* !
= + ! (Thorogood, 2005) N -
Q -*> .!
= + * #$% . 8" !
! & Q #+ !!" JC .D $% &' 7E *,
Q 7 .. & # ) c )*" JI 8" $% &'
.JI
% ! H !
= * !* I H*, C 8" # E -
2 !!" *, N (Singh, 2005) F -
FG
%* RG '
(
=N (
!
! !!" @
FG
-D
-
% >
" = ,
" 3 *, . N2 !!"
. !!" *, R
!!" *, #' #G . N (Golofski, 2003) .* ->"
)!
. H R " -
#D # NK H G -*> .!!" .' 3 -
D* E )!
† ! # ! % -
NK H . #D !!" .
N.
!" 3 !' . *, R., G -0 7 )!
!!" 3 !' 3 #J ' #G ->*" .
H, R +
.+ !!" F !' *, N2 D
7* &*' )! D. V= > JC (2002 #) -
H H, + , 7 *G' , V! $ . c .$>
-
D * ** D> FH 7" I . !!"* V= > JC
7* Q=! #Q #Q8. #Q!" 7 #QHD : !!"
!
!!" 7HD *N FG
^ -*> I .V= >* > 0 D. >

QN 7
" 7I I .Q Q "] , -
E 7 Q!" 7 G * # !!"* @
H *, $> 7* &*' )!
.-+ E #3 * 7
% JC #
7* -
2
-. ' -
7% =
-
FG
^ 8" . #
H ! G -0 J ) # -
% 0 !!"
( C -. . #Q0 = H C *,
3 !!" N
. *, J % 2 *, 3G
Q Q=! *, 7HD
!!" )! . - H' =
-
, B @
!!" )! . Y I8, - $ "N
7*, *," 7 . 84
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
: D>
*G , + 8" H > 7 FG
* ( C, @ C
:X *, FG
-
. #Q
C
) #7 % $ "# ", G 'C :2E 2L
M
"# , , -
+ (
= !!" )! *. H%+ ' 2 , ‡
H% #
-
-
! -" # * + !!"* *. ! _* I # !!" )! 7
" FG
(3) ! B
* -
! *, . I #! T #(3.22) !C * N #! C ! J= #(3.42) * H*I . #! -
- = . #! T #(3.41) !
.(3) T *, O #(2.97) B= ! O # D
< ' " G 2 # :(3) 2
!
,
$
.
!!" )! !
4
0.297
3.18
9
!!"* !!" *
!
5
0.14
3.12
11
* *
!
1
0.22
3.42
13
B
*
!
3
0.299
3.23
7
+ E
> *
!
6
0.21
2.97
9
+ D *
!
2
0.14
3.41
6
+ !C *
55
!!" )! .‡ *. !
3.22
*, * . -= )! .+ H, -= & FG
^, * : + !!"
)! .w =* (4) 3 FG
-
:" O P7
* B -= )! . , % H + !!"* !!" * -=
!!"
7
3
, -*> I #(3.18) * BH ! _* I #! -
.
Q $ 7
I #* )! *, *, * H
D " 3
, -*> .O *, H> # !!" )! + !!" *, 7
D I #-=D* )! .+ K. + !" JC
, N. D% I !!" *, . #C 3>
*D . 7
.
H
" >>" *,
85
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
-*> #(3.12) * * ! _* :" 2 O P
F
O D . # , [ ) ! *, * B C 3 -=D J
3
, -
#$*= &*' ) % B #+ * * R
,
*, -== ' Q 7* Q*D & WD 2 7
, [ R
O #* B C !
2 .
3
, -
# Q WD # !!" )! .w
*, -*> 3"' Q H
, & -N2 * .* )! " G 'C "# $>R 2 ) C :(4) 2
I
& "
> F "#
.
!
G **I
)!
$
(
**I
!
-
\\ \ \ \ \ 3.
7I
3.
(
: !!"* !!" * :' !
1.232
3.49
10
8.8
27.5
30
23.8
!
1.259
3.31
10
18.8
20
32.5
18.8
!
1.247
3.38
12.5
10
22.5
37.5
17.5
!
1.076
3.14
8.8
21.3
21.3
45
3.8
!
1.233
2.81
21.3
21.3
13.8
42.5
1.3
!
1.290
2.58
31.3
17.5
15
35
1.3
!
1.070
3.29
7.5
12.5
35
33.8
11.3
!
!
1.182
1.334
3.29
3.36
3.18
12.5
10
25
41.3
11.3
16.3
7.5
20
36.3
20
14.47
14.18
22.23
37.1
12.12
H
D !!"
7H
.1
.*
!!" H 7
=* W>" ) .2
.
.
* !!"* !" 7 2 7H
.3
!!" *, D D 7
% .4
.
Q $ !!" D% O
.5
.
.+ !" JC " 7
.6
. !!" *, 3KH .7
&> -
@ !!" *, .8
. -I
!!" 2 I E .9
. ' * & ! !
: * * :
N !
!
!
!
1.297
3.04
17.5
18.8
16.3
37.5
10
1.270
3.21
13.8
12.5
30
26.3
17.5
1.353
3.06
17.5
18.8
20
27.5
16.3
1.296
3.06
17.5
16.3
20
35
11.3
86
#
#
>I ) -N2 * 7H
.10
.
7* *,(. #
=N
#
#
>I ) * -N2 * 7H
.11
.
7* *,(. #
=N
#
#
>I ) -N2 !!" ,
.12
(. #
=N
#
#
>I ) * -N2 !!" ,
(. #
=N
.13
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
1.274
1.188
1.265
2.81
3.08
25
12.5
12.5
3.29
22.5
18.8
10
36.3
27.5
17.5
3.8
31.3
27.5
10
23.8
21.3
1.209
3.26
11.3
12.5
31.3
28.8
16.3
1.264
3.19
12.5
17.5
25
28.8
16.3
0.951
3.26
3.8
16.3
37.5
35
7.5
1.151
3.06
11.3
18.8
32.5
27.5
10
13.88
16.39
26.39
30.71
12.75
3.12
-N2 * 2 O
.14
. Q H
, &
* -N2 * 2 O
.15
Q H
, &
Q 7* Q*D & WD R
.16
. @@ *, * 7* 3I !
= R
.17
. Q
H8 *, * 7* C !
= R
.18
. Q
!!" *, &
% . 7H
.19
. 7I J !!" ^
.20
.7
% f
N2 7H
D%
N * & ! !
G 'C "# $>R 2 ) C :(4) 2 !
I
& "
> F "# "
.
)!
!
$
G **I
**I
!
-
\\ \ \ \ \ 3.
7I
( 3.
(
: B
* :
N !
1.225
3.36
10
12.5
28.8
28.8
20
. I !
VC
2 7
.21
!
1.077
3.56
1.3
18.8
25
32.5
22.5
.I
2 7
.22
!
1.172
3.64
2.5
18.8
21.3
27.5
30
.,C
2 7
.23
!
1.136
3.54
6.3
11.3
26.3
35
21.3
.J -= 7I J 2 7
.24
H*
I *= -0 2 ,
.25
!
!
!
1.289
1.355
3.40
3.39
10
12.5
13.8
13.8
28.8
23.8
21.3
22.5
26.3
27.5
.* G -0 J .*
H*
I *= -0 2 ,
.26
.
G -0 J .*
" Q 7= $ , .27
1.286
3.63
10
11.3
13.8
36.3
28.8
!
1.302
3.66
11.3
6.3
20
30
32.5
.
HE
> VC
7
.28
!
1.296
2.94
15
27.5
20
23.8
13.8
.
D% O
.29
!
1.115
3.35
3.8
25
17.5
40
13.8
.
E
> 2 O
.30
' H
2 ) .31
!
!
!
1.121
3.60
7.5
7.5
22.5
42.5
20
1.107
3.30
7.5
17.5
22.5
42.5
10
1.354
3.13
15
20
22.5
22.5
20
8.67
15.7
22.52
31.17
22.04
3.42
87
.J
.
H== &*! +
+ ' , =N ,D '
.32
.
H
I H C
*, ,C + ' 7
.' @ *, * D%
N * & ! !
.33
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
:+ E
> * :J !
!
!
1.252
3.46
8.8
12.5
28.8
23.8
26.3
1.067
3.50
1.3
18.8
30
28.8
21.3
1.175
3.25
3.8
27.5
28.8
20
20
*" *
!" JC
&
7
C + !"
&
P8 C + !"
10
10
55
21.3
.36
.
H
J
, =N * -
*"
2.99
.35
.
H2 J
!
0.934
.34
.* H!
3.8
.37
*
+ 7* 3@ !"
.=
-
, HC
!
!
!
!
!
!
D*D J + !" 7
1.076
3.21
8.8
13.8
33.8
35
8.8
1.018
3.48
3.8
11.3
35
33.8
16.3
1.239
2.69
23.8
20
25
26.3
5
1.163
3.30
7.5
15
36.3
22.5
18.8
1.213
1.288
2.85
2.99
3.17
18.8
18.8
27.5
28.8
.38
.J*
* D* + !" .39
.C *, *
+ !" ^
.40
.
* 3+ I I D%
!" , =N 7* -
C
.41
.!" -D J *
+
!" , =N 7* -
C
6.3
.42
.D* @8 -
@ *
+
-
+ !" C
17.5
17.5
26.3
26.3
12.5
10.41
16.52
32.65
26.66
13.91
.43
.(* -
) D* *
J * & ! !
G 'C "# $>R 2 ) C :(4) 2 !
I
& "
> F "# "
.
)!
!
$
G ( **I
**I
!
3.
-
\\ \ \ \ \ 7I
+ !" D I + ' 7
.44
3.
(
:+ D * :R
" !
!
!
!
!
!
1.220
1.222
2.86
2.73
17.5
21.3
21.3
18.8
26.3
35
27.5
16.3
7.5
8.8
1.332
2.85
20
23.8
20
23.8
12.5
1.317
2.99
20
13.8
26.3
27.5
12.5
1.316
2.84
15
35
16.3
18.8
15
1.376
3.33
15
11.3
26.3
21.3
26.3
18.13
20.67
25.03
22.53
13.77
2.93
88
,C !" J H= !" D -
.+ % 7
.45
.+
!" D I * -
> .K 7
.46
.+
!" D @8 GH 7
.47
+
!" D I 7G8 $ 7% 3
, 7
.48
.+
!" -
. . . @ .Y 3 ! 3>I !!" N #+
R
" * & ! !
.49
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
:+ !C * :R
!
1.352
3.24
13.8
17.5
22.5
23.8
22.5
.+ !" ' .50
!
1.259
3.60
6.3
17.5
16.3
30
30
.@
8 @ !" ) + !" D
.51
1.325
3.38
10
18.8
21.3
23.8
26.3
. R
I D. ' PC
.52
1.289
3.31
10
17.5
27.5
21.3
23.8
1.277
3.38
8.8
18.8
22.5
26.3
23.8
1.272
3.54
7.5
15
23.8
23.8
30
3.41
9.4
17.52
22.31
24.83
26.07
R
* & ! !
3.22
12
16.59
25.65
29.08
16.81
- * & ! !
!
!
!
!
.+ !" .3 @ 3 . @
+ - ' = 7
.53
!" D -
,C ' 7H
.54
. !" 3
,+ 8 -+ " ' 7H
.! B
* -= )! =* FG
-
:" :
OP
F
F
! _* I #! -
. * B -= )! , % H ! $*= !!" J O
H= 7% . * B >>" ( % #(3.18) * BH
' ^ Q ! )! , -
@. = Qw #'
.
H! ' " , *, + ! = 7, ! @.
I * )! *, *, HE
> VC
7
3= > .
D% O "3= > . #
H E
> Q 7= $ , & . PC E >>" O * )! *," 7= -
% E , @ + !!" Q*, .
.* -
"
E
> * -= )! =* FG
-
:, J
O P
_* I #! -
. * B -= )! , % H +
+ E
> R
# , O D . #(3.17) * BH !
, 8. > * B *. + !!" J O ' ! !!" '
+ !" 3
, > . .,C ' D F -
, !!" !"* , O I * )! *, *, H2 J &
7
C
D% *, *
+ !" ^" 3
, > . #
,C +
QC !!" . O . I * )! *, "
* 3+ I I
!!" *, J ^
Q Y"' + -
#
* 3+ -
!= 7 .
D% Y .
. )= +
D * -= )! =* FG
-
:", 65 OP
! _* I #! -
. * B -= )! , % +
D . #+ !!" )! = ! I #(2.93) * BH !!" J O ' ! !!" ' + D * R
# , O
89
.55
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
F -
, !!" , 8. > * B *. +
!" -
. . . @ " 3
, > . .,C ' D
I * )! *, *, "Y 3 ! 3>I !!" N #+
* !!" #$D )! JC + !" JC K , O
% 7" 3
, > . #O )= @ O 7 #$D @ F
JC"
. O . I * )! *, "+ !" D -
.+
+ !!" *, J ^
#+ !" D -
.+ I O
.
I 3 -
.+ !C * -= )! =* FG
-
:", ? OP
_* I #! -
. * B -= )! , % H +
!C * R
# , O D . #(3.41) * BH !
" 3
, > . # 0 + !!" J O ' ! !!" . +
O O * )! *, *,"@
8 @ !" ) + !" D
!" ' 3
, > . #@
+ JC + !" JC ' , JC"
* !!" O . I * )! *, + == C 3>
. 7 HC I #
H!!" I H 7 .^0*
2 ) #7 SR "# (α = 0.05) Y , P
>
C G# 2= :"
F 2L
2 O 2' ) " 2=L T P
"# ", 2 G 'C
U#
' 2 U B) K", Y , * 2 & )D* $
' * 7 2 , ‡
.FG
B (5) PC #(α = 0.05)
" 2=L T P
) #7 SW P
# ", 2 G ', I
E 2 :(5) 2
=
*
*
*
I
0.001
0.018
0.005
F 7I
7.8
4.262
5.7
-
!
c
(
)
-
429.315
2
55.037
>
858.631
-
, :' 77
4237.857
-
, "
!!"* !!" *
79
5096.488
c
501.311
2
1002.622
-
, 117.622
77
9056.928
-
, "
79
10059.550
c
616.957
2
1233.913
-
, 108.235
77
8334.074
-
, "
79
9567.988
c
90
:
N * *
:
N B
*
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
*
*
*
*
0.005
0.006
0.003
0.001
5.639
5.464
6.289
7.516
351.220
2
334.747
-
, 62.285
77
2354.803
-
, "
79
2689.550
c
226.021
2
876.145
-
, 41.368
77
6137.805
-
, "
79
7013.950
c
267.756
2
535.511
-
, 42.574
77
3278.176
-
, "
79
3813.687
c
13599.673
2
27199.346
-
, 1809.362
77
139320.841
-
, "
79
166520.188
c
:J + E
> *
:R
" + D *
:R
+ !C *
- .
.0.05 U ) *
= -
(0.05) Y , G
> - ) (5) 3I 2* ( H + !!" )! . = (* + *
)
* . , (0.05) 0> (F) \ Y I -
(B. #
#
3@
) *
CD
= D> CD ^ .
. Y *, # !!" (6) PC . -
=* (Scheffe) " 7" )D B ! , .* .*
+ !!" )! .+ , = -
. )D > T $
(* + *
) = -
#3@
+ * P
> 3@
* 2 $
2 $ (* + *
) = -
#3@
+ * P
> B. 3@
* 2 $
*) X + !!" \* . , * P
> B. *
Y *, #+ !C # B
# * # !!"* !!"
* , 3@
+ * P
> 3@
* 2 $ ) - #(
.
*, I . D* * Y @ QK B D .(+ D #+ E
>)
!!" * @8 . O* #+ !!" )! . =
.
) #7 C Z " 2=L P
", 2 G 'C "# G5 <5 D>
:(6) 2
%95 =N I
K!"
(I; ! 8"
2 (J)
2(I)
$
J)
*
*
I I 11.74
1.63
0.006
2.025
6.683(*)
4.25
;5.75
0.933
2.004
;0.748
B.
;1.63
;11.74
0.006
2.025
;6.683(*)
3@
;2.24
;12.62
0.003
2.078
;7.431(*)
B.
91
3@
*
!!"
!!"*
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
5.75
;4.25
0.933
2.004
0.748
3@
12.62
2.24
0.003
2.078
7.431(*)
14.83
0.05
0.048
2.960
7.437(*)
6.91
;7.72
0.990
2.929
;0.406
B.
;0.05
;14.83
0.048
2.960
;7.437(*)
3@
;.26
;15.43
0.041
3.038
;7.843(*)
B.
7.72
;6.91
0.990
2.929
0.406
3@
15.43
0.26
0.041
3.038
7.843(*)
14.39
0.22
0.042
2.839
7.303(*)
4.96
;9.06
0.767
2.810
;2.050
B.
;0.22
;14.39
0.042
2.839
;7.303(*)
3@
;2.08
;16.63
0.008
2.914
;9.354(*)
B.
9.06
;4.96
0.767
2.810
2.050
3@
16.63
2.08
0.008
2.914
9.354(*)
12.38
1.63
0.007
2.154
7.008(*)
7.00
;3.64
0.734
2.132
1.679
B.
;1.63
;12.38
0.007
2.154
;7.008(*)
3@
0.19
;10.85
0.061
2.211
;5.329
B.
3.64
;7.00
0.734
2.132
;1.679
3@
10.85
;0.19
0.061
2.211
5.329
9.92
1.15
0.009
1.755
5.535(*)
5.38
;3.30
0.836
1.737
1.040
B.
;1.15
;9.92
0.009
1.755
;5.535(*)
3@
0.00
;8.99
0.050
1.802
;4.495
B.
3.30
;5.38
0.836
1.737
;1.040
3@
8.99
0.00
0050
1.802
4.495
10.02
1.13
0.01
1.781
5.572(*)
4.38
;4.42
1
1.762
;0.020
B.
;1.13
;10.02
0.01
1.781
;5.572(*)
3@
;1.03
;10.15
0.012
1.828
;5.592(*)
B.
4.42
;4.38
1
1.762
0.02
3@
10.15
1.03
0.012
1.828
5.592(*)
68.52
10.56
0.005
11.609
39.539(*)
28.17
;29.18
0.999
11.488
;0.505
B.
;10.56
;68.52
0.005
11.609
;39.539(*)
3@
;10.30
;69.79
0.005
11.915
;40.045(*)
B.
29.18
;28.17
0.999
11.488
0.505
3@
69.79
10.30
0.005
11.915
40.045(*)
B.
3@
* *
B.
3@
B
*
B.
3@
*
E
>
+
B.
3@
D *
+
B.
3@
!C *
+
B.
3@
.
- B.
0.05 U ) &9 *
92
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
2 ) #7 SR "# (α = 0.05) Y , P
>
C G# 2= :
F 2L
2 O 2' ) * T P
"# ", 2 G 'C
M#
' 2 U B) K",
-
H -
! )D , .* #
N 2 , ‡
3" 0 (
+ !!" )! . = (* + *
)
#(ANOVA) &
$
' * 7" #(N.K - 10 #- 10 – 5 #- 5 I)
.(7) FG
-
* T P
) #7 SW P
# ", 2 G ', (ANOVA)I
E 2:(7) 2
=
*
*
E
E
*
*
*
I
0.03
0.017
0.107
0.366
0.016
0.004
0.024
F 7I
3.666
4.272
2.299
1.02
4.385
5.856
3.916
-
!
c
(
)
-
221.534
2
60.434
>
443.068
-
, * :' 77
4653.419
-
, "
!!"* !!"
79
5096.487
c
502.379
2
1004.759
-
, 117.595
77
9054.791
-
, "
79
10059.550
c
269.575
2
539.150
-
, 117.258
77
9028.837
-
, "
79
9567.988
c
34.694
2
69.389
-
, 34.028
77
2620.161
-
, "
79
2689.550
c
185.947
2
701.201
-
, 42.409
77
6312.749
-
, "
79
7013.950
c
251.731
2
503.462
-
, 42.990
77
3310.226
-
, "
79
3813.688
c
7686.981
2
15373.962
-
, 1962.938
77
151146.226
-
, "
79
166520.188
c
:
N * *
:
N B
*
:J + E
> *
:R
" + D *
:R
+ !C *
. - 0.05 U ) *
(* + *
) -
)D (7) 3I 10 #- 10 – 5 #- 5 I) 3" 0 ( + !!" )! .+ 7=
-
#(+ E
> * # B
*) * , E #(N.K -
!!" * . , 3 ) . .(0.05) 0> (F) \ Y I
93
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
#+ D * # * * # !!"* !!" *) :X #(0.05) 0> (F) \ Y I -
(
. Y *, #+ !C *
) I " 7" )D B ! , .* .* CD
= D> CD ^ .(8) *, -
=* (LSD) ) C Z * P
", 2 G 'C "# G# 2E (LSD) D>
:(8) 2
%95 =N I
K!"
! 8"
$
(I;J)
3"(J)
3"(I)
I *,
I 3.88
;6.07
0.662
2.497
;1.095
- 10 \ 5 ;0.86
;9.61
0.020
2.198
;5.236(*)
N.K -10
6.07
;3.88
0.662
2.497
1.095
- 5 I
0.01
;8.29
0.051
2.086
;4.141
N.K -10
9.61
.86
0.020
2.198
5.236(*)
- 5 I
8.29
;0.01
0.051
2.086
4.141
- 10 \ 5 5.71
;8.17
0.725
3.483
;1.230
- 10 \ 5 ;1.60
;13.81
0.014
3.066
;7.701(*)
N.K -10
8.17
;5.71
0.725
3.483
1.230
- 5 I
;0.68
;12.26
0.029
2.910
;6.470(*)
N.K -10
13.81
1.60
0.014
3.066
7.701(*)
- 5 I
12.26
0.68
0.029
2.910
6.470(*)
- 10 \ 5 10.20
;1.39
0.134
2.908
4.405
- 10 \ 5 2.40
;7.79
0.296
2.560
;2.695
N.K -10
1.39
;10.20
0.134
2.908
;4.405
- 5 I
;2.26
;11.94
0.005
2.430
;7.100(*)
N.K -10
7.79
;2.40
0.296
2.560
2.695
- 5 I
11.94
2.26
0.005
2.430
7.100(*)
- 10 \ 5 8.16
;2.28
0.378
2.092
2.937
- 10 \ 5 2.38
;6.81
0.488
1.841
;2.217
N.K -10
2.28
;8.16
0.378
2.092
;2.937
- 5 I
;0.79
;9.52
0.016
1.748
;5.153(*)
N.K -10
6.81
;2.38
0.488
1.841
2.217
- 5 I
9.52
0.79
0.016
1.748
5.153(*)
- 10 \ 5 28.69
;27.98
0.98
14.231
0.357
- 10 \ 5 ;2.60
;52.49
0.031
12.527
;27.541(*)
N.K -10
27.98
;28.69
0.98
14.231
;0.357
- 5 I
;4.22
;51.57
0.022
11.889
;27.898(*)
N.K -10
52.49
2.60
0.031
12.527
27.541(*)
- 5 I
51.57
4.22
0.022
11.889
27.898(*)
- 10 \ 5 - 5 I
*
- 10 \ 5 !!"
!!"*
N.K -10
- 5 I
* *
- 10 \ 5 N.K -10
- 5 I
D *
- 10 \ 5 +
N.K -10
- 5 I
!C *
- 10 \ 5 +
N.K -10
- 5 I
- 10 \ 5 - .
N.K -10
0.05 U ) &9 *
94
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
- 5 I 3" $ (* + *
) -
)D QI * , - 5 I 3" $ P
> - 10 N. 3" $ (* + *
)
$ 3" $ (* + *
) -
)D . # !!"* !!"
3" $ P
> #N.K - 10 3" $ (* + *
) #- 10 – 5 3"
-
-
)D .(+ !C #+ D) * , - 10 – 5
N. 3" $ (* + *
) - 5 I 3" $ (* + *
)
3" $ (* + *
) #- 5 I 3" $ P
> - 10 10 – 5 3" $ P
> #N.K - 10 3" $ (* + *
) #- 10 – 5
. *" , * * , -
:
: #H FG
3, > :
- J , % H ! !!" *, )! ;
O #
, )! > 7 # !!" *,
!!" *, R
# Y ! !!" *, G
I !!"*
' ! )! -
. # !!" *, ) . 7 H.
.!" ,+ * -!" ^ !!" J O Y ! !!"
*, R
, O D . #! !!"* !!" * )! ;
.' ! !!" &* J $ 7G
= &*' ) % B !!"* !!"
.$*= &*' ) % B # ! * * )! ;
( % ! -
. , % H + B
* -= )! ;
.' ! $*= !!" J O
H= 7% ' * B >>"
, % H + E
> * -= )! =* FG
-
;
R
# , O D . #! -
. * B -= )! * B *. + !!" J O ' ! !!" ' + E
>
.,C ' D F -
, !!" , 8. > , % H + D * -= )! FG
-
;
' ! !!" ' + D * R
# , O D . !
, !!" , 8. > * B *. + !!" J O
.,C ' D F -
, % H + !C * -= )! =* FG
-
;
R
# , O D . ! -
. * B -= )! . 0 + !!" J O ' ! !!" ' + !C *
95
3!, #
, #
H *
% H !!" JI
:
8" # !!" *,
3
@ &
f
GH :N
>
+ !" , .
)! , #
*
J !!" =N
)! #!" BH D M #
*
* - I D *
$+ ! 0 - 3 Q' #% + -
J (
@* !!"
#
H2 E
> . -
= -
[ #-
*, 3' B Q.* #
H H
)
= #*,
D + H 7 #Y"' -
2 = , @ H
* -
# 7" >I 7
$ '.' O* 7"
.
* 3= 3
@ #D*" G % J &
*, 3= #&
-I :!
#2006 #
:3
=.=! 7
D :+ 3+ ; # -
N #R .1
.459
.493 #1991 #R , . :3
= . !!" – #$8 .2
*.$> 7* !!" )! V= > ; # .3
.210 – 6#2002#159c#
#
, :
, #3 E .2 ' + !!" ; P
> #&!" .4
.2003
.319# 2005 #' ! #* G :
, .+ 3+ -
; 2 #7
.5
3@ ,3 !!" )! T R
I ; 7
#
.6
#2010# #3 E #
, !* 7* 3@ *, .184
HI8, ' K -
. *, !!" *, GE D> )! ; #* .7
.2003 #' #
* -
* ' #3 E #'
.533 #2007 #
:3
= #4! .+ 3+ ; #
.8
E B. ! #' N R !!"* $ ; # # .9
.153 #2001 #' #
, #' #3
. :' . 3@H' + !!" *, 3N2 ; #D .10
.2005#191 #' #' :
, #3 E .246 #2003 # 3@ . :3
= .+ !!" , 3 ; #3*, .11
H -" @.:3
=#' {
+ 3+ * 3+ FH ; ,#) .12
.2004#101#3‡
.284 #2002 #* $ :
, #=! - 7
D + 3+ ; # != .13
96
Tishreen University Journal Eco. & Leg. Sciences Series 2011 (2) (33) * = >I 7* *
#=! FH + 3+ + .D ; )
! # D!> #. # .14
.726 #2007 #
:3
=
15. ALLISON, M . Strategic Planning For Nonprofit Organization: APractical Guide and
Workbook, USA: John Wiley and Sons, Inc, 317.
16. ANDREAS, T and PETEROS, P. - Strategic Planning and Education: The Case of
Cyprus. International Journal of Educational Management, 2002, 16, 6-17.
17. COHEN, M - Public Sector Strategic Planning; sit Really Planning or Is it Really
Strategy or Is It Really Strategy or Is it Nether or Both?, Dmgt. 2006, Retrieved
from; http//wwwlip.umi.com/dissertations/fullcit/3214543, 76.
18. GARNER, R.-“SWOT” Tactics Basics for Strategic Planning. 2005, Retrieved from:
http://web.ebscohost.com.ezlibrary.ju.edu.jo/ehost/pdf?vid=4&hid=18&sid=ce1128b
6-9a99-4db2-bcc2- 41c740d567cc%40sessionmgr2, 45.
19. GOLOFSKI. S - The Identification of Successful Strategic Planning and
Implementation Strategies Through the Benchmarking, Process Retrieved, 2003, 209.
20. SINGHK, K - The Impact of Strategic Planning Process Variation on Superior
Organizational Performance in Nonprofit Human Service Organization Providing
Mental Health Services. PHD. 2005, Retrieved from; http//wwwlip.umi.com/
dissertations/fullcit, 89.
21. TAPINON, E, DYSON, R. and MENDOWS, M, - The Impact OF performance
Measurement in Strategic Planning, International Journal of Productivity and
Performance Management, 2005, 45,370-384.
22. THOROGOOD, T- Strategic Planning or Managing Change? England Wales. PhD.
2005, Retrieved from; http//wwwlip.umi.com/dissertations/fullcit/f1137921, 117.
23. WAGNE, R, - Conversation on planning; Investigation Relationship Between
Strategies, Actions and Performance, 2006, PHD. Retrieved from;
http//wwwlip.umi.com/ dissertations/fullcit/3220045, 153.
24. WILKINS, J. - Participant Perceptions of Strategic Planning in an Urban School
district: A case study, 2006, EdD. Retrieved from:
http://wwwlib.umi.com/ dissertations/fullcit/3216275, 126.
97