Corporate Record Maintenance The Hows and Whys of Keeping a Corporation’s Minute Book Up to Date April 2014 by Jenna Rucas, Associate Corporate and Commercial Securities and Corporate Finance Commercial Leasing Employment Corporate record maintenance may be the last thing on a business owner's sufficient fact finding has occurred, appropriate details are discovered and mind. Business owners are focussed on running the ins and outs of the business and on making their venture the minute book is updated. In unfortunate circumstances, the minute book may become difficult to update if profitable; they are not often concerned with updating the corporation's minute a shareholder has died or disappeared or if shareholders have since parted book to reflect the current state of affairs. ways. Where a relationship between shareholders has become contentious, a complete and accurate corporate In the course of a corporation's life cycle, many things can occur. Officers and directors of the corporation may come and go, accountants will prepare financial statements for various fiscal periods, a corporation may change its registered address, and the shareholders of the corporation may change over time. According to both Ontario and federal corporate legislation, each of these events ought to be recorded in the corporation's minute book in a specific way and certain events must be reported to either the Ontario or federal government, depending on which statute governs the corporation. It may not be a business owner's priority to ensure that these types of events are recorded. However, when the time comes for a shareholder to sell its shares in the corporation, or for record can avoid the claim that one shareholder or director was unaware that the corporation was taking certain actions, especially where such shareholder or director has signed off on such actions. Additionally, noncompliance with the corporation's governing statute could result in fines being issued to the corporation. In short, keeping the corporate records of a corporation up to date is both legally required and provides certainty in many critical situations. What follows is a list of typical items that should regularly form part of an Ontario corporation’s records and which records should be kept in the corporation’s minute book. • Annual shareholders meetings. The Ontario corporate statute the corporation to obtain a loan from the bank, if the corporation's minute provides that a corporation must hold a shareholders meeting book is not up to date, the transaction may be delayed until such time as annually, at which meeting the directors of the corporation are elected, financial statements for the preceding year are presented appoint auditors until the shareholders are able to meet and to the shareholders by the directors, and either auditors for the corporation are appointed or make such decision, and make banking arrangements for the corporation. Thereafter, directors the shareholders agree to exempt the corporation from the auditor meetings may occur periodically throughout the year, but for smaller requirements set out in the statute. These are commonly called annual resolutions. Minutes corporations, often occur annually in order to appoint officers and approve the financial statements of each shareholders meeting should be recorded and kept in for the preceding year. Similar to shareholders meetings, minutes of the corporation’s minute book. For some small companies, there may only be one or two shareholders each directors meeting should be recorded and kept in the corporation’s minute book. for whom the transaction of such business does not warrant an Alternatively, directors are permitted to sign resolutions in writing setting actual meeting. In such cases, the statute provides that in lieu of an actual meeting, shareholders are out the information above in lieu of a meeting, provided such resolutions are signed by all of the permitted to sign resolutions in writing approving the annual directors of the corporation. resolutions, provided that such resolutions are signed by all of the shareholders of the corporation. Where special meetings of the shareholders are held in between annual meetings in order to transact special business, minutes of such meetings or resolutions in writing in lieu thereof should also form part of the corporation’s records. • Directors meetings. After incorporation, the directors of a 2 • Government filings under the Corporations Information Act (Ontario). Once a corporation is incorporated under Ontario law, the government requires the corporation to file an Initial Return within 60 days of incorporation which sets out the registered address for the corporation, the directors of the corporation and the top 5 officers of the corporation. Each time a change to this information occurs, a Notice of Change form is required to be corporation are required to meet in order to enact by-laws for the filed within 15 days of such change. Each year, an Annual corporation, adopt a form of share certificate (where required by the shareholders), appoint officers, Return must be filed for the corporation which either re-affirms the information presently on file with the government, or provides updated information regarding any maintain a register which records all of the transfers of securities for change to the information above. The Annual Return may be filed by the corporation’s accountants the corporation. All of the registers must be kept up to date in the corporation’s minute book. together with the corporation’s corporate tax return, or it can be filed independently. A copy of all such filings should be kept in the corporation’s minute book for completeness and easy reference. Contravention of the Corporations Information Act (Ontario) can result in a fine to a corporation of up to $25,000, and the inability for a corporation to maintain a proceeding in an Ontario court until such contravention is remedied. on tax advantageous methods and times to draw funds from the corporation. Accountants may, for example, advise that it is a good time to have shareholders draw dividends or designate management bonuses to certain individuals. Recording such matters in the corporation’s minute book serves as evidence that such • Directors and securities registers. Ontario corporate legislation matters were authorized by the corporation’s directors and ought to have occurred, and ultimately requires that a corporation maintain a register of directors serves as support for the tax return filed for the corporation. If in the which includes a list of both past and current directors together with their addresses, and the date future the corporation is audited, properly recorded resolutions maintained in the corporation’s when each such director became and ceased to be a director of the minute book will assist in proving that all matters reported in corporation. This information may become critical in the event that an issue of director liability arises connection with the corporation’s tax position were sanctioned. during a specific time period. Ontario corporate legislation also requires the corporation to maintain a register which records the securities issued by the corporation, including each security holder’s name, address, number and class of securities issued to the security holder, and the date of each such issuance. The corporation must also 3 • Drawing on funds. Corporations depend on accountants to advise • Significant transactions. Corporations engage in and approve various transactions and incur financial obligations which should be documented in the corporation’s minute book. Some such transactions may include purchases and sales of shares in the capital of the corporation, purchases and sales of shares in the capital of other corporations by the corporation, and loans to or from the corporation. In fact, where a bank loans funds to a corporation, it will often ask for evidence in the form of a resolution that the corporation’s directors have approved the borrowing to ensure the loan transaction was properly authorized. A corporation's minute book is a story of its life from beginning (incorporation) to end (dissolution). A minute book’s currency and accuracy are both relied upon by third parties like purchasers, lenders and accountants and perhaps most importantly, are required by law. No part of this article may be reproduced without the prior written consent of McLean & Kerr LLP. Please contact our office manager Brenda Gonsalves at 416.369.6623 or bgonsalves@mcleankerr.com. This article is provided to you by McLean & Kerr LLP to keep you informed of legal issues and developments. This article provides general and summary information and should not be regarded, or relied upon, as legal advice or as a legal opinion. If you do require specific legal advice, we would be pleased to assist you in the context of your own particular facts and circumstances. 4