OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 2016 TOWN OF MILTON PROPOSED BUDGET 3 Overview Introduction Residents within the Town of Milton enjoy and depend on many municipal services and programs such as firefighting and rescue, parks and roads maintenance, library services, and the recreation staff who run the many programs offered by the Town. The operating budget includes the service levels for these municipal programs and the sources of revenues available to fund them. After considering all other revenue sources, the Town is required to collect the amount of tax required to balance the budget. As in prior years, valuable input on operational priorities was obtained by residents and considered by staff in the development of the 2016 budget. Input channels available to residents throughout the year included the annual budget public input survey as well as the statistically valid resident satisfaction survey conducted as part of the corporation’s strategic planning process during 2015. Residents are also able to provide comments throughout the year by directly contacting the Mayor and Councillors or by registering as a delegate at Budget Committee meetings. The proposed 2016 operating budget, with gross expenditures of $110.5 million, maintains existing programs while providing enhancements across a wide range of municipal services. An area where residents continue to request improvements is that of roadways. A Traffic Technologist was added to the budget to support growth related traffic issues. The 2016 budget also includes increased roadside brushing and maintenance of storm sewers in order to increase the margin of safety on municipal right of ways related to the potential impacts from weather related events. An increase in the crack sealing program has been built into the budget in order to extend the life of the Town’s road network. In line with a growing interest and participation in cycling in the area, bike lane markings have been added to the budget. Also new for 2016 is the addition of various cycling related camps and fitness classes, allowing the Town to take advantage of its new premier cycling facility, while also enhancing the active lifestyle that residents enjoy. Finally, in response to library patron requests, an extension of hours for the Library has also been built into the proposed 2016 budget. Tax Policy Change - Urban Service Area Tax Levy Phase-Out Historically, the Town of Milton has maintained both a general levy for all property owners in the municipality as well as a separate urban levy, which is essentially a surcharge applied to residents in the urban boundary to recover the cost of specific services such as transit, sidewalk plowing and street lighting. In accordance with the motion passed at the December 14, 2015 Council meeting, the urban service area tax levy is now being phased out over a two year period. For 2016, the urban levy is being reduced by 50%, followed by one uniform tax rate starting in 2017. The services, at 50% of the net cost, proposed to be levied to the urban area for 2016 are outlined in the following table. Regular Transit Dynamic Transit Pilot Project Transfer to Transit and Transportation Reserve Sidewalk Plowing Crossing Guards Annual Sidewalk Repair Program Urban Street Lights Net Expenditures $ 1,363,178 $ 20,001 $ 232,073 $ 137,775 $ 284,913 $ 94,538 $ 416,732 Total $ Service 2,549,208 As a result of this phase out, in 2016, rural residents will see an increase of $12.38 per $100,000 of the assessed value of their home on the Town portion of their tax bill. The urban residents will see a decrease of $1.74 per $100,000 of assessment in the Town portion of their tax bill. In 2017, residents will see a similar impact on their tax bill resulting from the second year of the phase out. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 65 Overview Proposed Impact of the 2016 Budget on Tax Bill The Town’s proposed budget results in tax increases in the urban and rural service areas of $15.11 and $28.24 respectively per $100,000 of assessment when combined with the impact of the tax policy change. The overall impact to Milton residents results in a tax increase of 2.00% in the urban service area and 3.88% in the rural service area for Town of Milton services. Decision packages have been prepared by staff for Council consideration and deliberation to alter the proposed tax levy increase. These budget items are included within the Decision Packages section of the budget book and can be found on pages 89 to 106. Summary financial statements of gross expenditures by department and net expenditures by department are included on pages 84 and 85 respectively. The following table illustrates the proposed 2016 taxes per $100,000 of a property’s assessed value, factoring in both the proposed budget increase as well as the impact of the tax policy change. The Library Board prepares and recommends it’s budget to Council. Although the Library Board has discretion over the spending, Council has the ability to approve or amend the proposed budget. The 2016 operating budget includes gross expenditures in the amount of $110.5 million, a 6.6% increase over the 2015 approved expenditures of $103.7 million. The expenditures are offset by non-tax levy revenues of $60.9 million, which have increased 4.0% over the 2015 non-tax levy revenues of $58.6 million. The budget is balanced with the tax levy of $49.4 million for the Town and $0.2 million for the Downtown Business Improvement Area (DBIA). Of the proposed tax levy of $49.4 million, excluding the DBIA, $49.1 million relates to the Town. A further $0.30 million of the levy relates to the Hospital Expansion. The Downtown Business Improvement Area (DBIA) also prepares its own budget. Its tax levy is approved by its Board of Directors and is then recommended to Council for approval. The budget for the DBIA is included on pages 357 to 359. The information presented in the Operating Budget Summary comprises the Town and Library Board only and is exclusive of the Hospital and the DBIA, except where otherwise stated. Proposed Impact on Total Tax Bill per $100,000 of Assessment Share of Tax Bill Urban Area Town of Milton General Hospital Town of Milton Region of Halton * Education Total Urban Area Rural Area Town of Milton General Hospital Town of Milton Region of Halton Education Total Rural Area 2015 Taxes 33.09% 0.22% 33.30% 41.65% 25.04% 100.00% $ 242.52 $ 1.68 $ 244.20 $ 318.26 $ 195.00 $ 757.46 31.84% 0.22% 32.06% 42.33% 25.60% 100.00% $ 214.29 $ 1.68 $ 215.97 $ 316.40 $ 195.00 $ 727.37 Tax Policy Shift ($ 1.74) ($ 1.74) ($ 1.74) $ 12.38 $ 12.38 $ 12.38 Proposed Increase 7.00% 0.00% 1.90% 0.00% 7.00% 0.00% 1.90% 0.00% Proposed 2016 Taxes $ Impact on Total Tax Bill % Impact on Total Tax Bill $ 257.63 $ 1.68 $ 259.31 $ 324.31 $ 195.00 $ 778.62 $15.11 $0.00 $15.11 $6.05 $0.00 $21.16 2.00% 0.00% 2.00% 0.79% 0.00% 2.79% $ 242.53 $ 1.68 $ 244.21 $ 322.41 $ 195.00 $ 761.62 $28.24 $0.00 $28.24 $6.01 $0.00 $34.25 3.88% 0.00% 3.88% 0.83% 0.00% 4.71% * Includes enhanced waste service for urban area. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 66 Overview 2015 Budget Restatements Changes in operations have resulted in restatements of the 2015 approved budget for comparative purposes. The changes reallocate certain costs and revenues between accounts and/or departments and have no net effect on the total approved budget for 2015. The significant restatements include: • Re-alignment and consolidation of marketing and communications functions from various departments to Executive Services. • Re-alignment of Mattamy National Cycling Centre (MNCC) budget within MNCC facility and programs. • Re-alignment of administration costs for the Operations division from the Engineering Administration budget into a newly created Operations Administration budget. • Re-alignment of sports related program costs out of the Active Living budget and into a newly created Sports budget. • Reallocation of budgeted revenues within the Planning and Development Department. • Reallocation of revenues within General Government. • Re-alignment of staffing costs between Parks Administration and Development Engineering to reflect staffing reorganization changes that occurred in 2015. Council Approved Operating Budget Policies and Guidelines In July 2015, Council approved the 2016 Budget Call report, CORS-05115, that established the guidelines for preparing the 2016 operating budget and forecast. The proposed 2016 operating budget conforms to the following guidelines: • Annualization of new expenditures and revenues included in the 2015 operating budget. • Incremental costs associated with extending existing service levels to new growth areas within the community. • Consideration of service enhancements and service reductions as a result of public feedback. • Inflationary impacts in relation to the Municipal Price Index (MPI). The guidelines for the tax impacts, as outlined in the Budget Call report, were that the budget was to be prepared with a range of tax impacts between: • $2.44/$100,000 of assessment value (1% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy), and • $17.09/$100,000 of assessment value (7% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy). The 2016 proposed budget has been prepared with a range of tax impacts as follows: Urban Resident • $3.01/$100,000 of assessment value (1.25% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy), and • $16.85/$100,000 of assessment value (7% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy. When combined with the impact of the tax policy change as discussed on page 65 the impact ranges from $1.27 to $15.11. Rural Resident • $2.92/$100,000 of assessment value (1.29% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy), and • $15.86/$100,000 of assessment value (7% increase to Town portion of the total tax levy). When combined with the impact of the tax policy change as discussed on page 65 the impact ranges from $15.30 to $28.24. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 67 Overview Where Does the Money Go? Mayor and Council - $0.60 Million (0.6%) Over 65% of the Town’s budget is spent on providing transportation (including winter control), parks and recreation, fire, library, planning services, licensing and enforcement, crossing guards and economic development. Another 22% reflects financing of capital through debt payments and transfers to reserves. Less than 10% of gross expenditures are allocated to administration and governance functions. The governing body of the Town of Milton is Town Council consisting of the Mayor and 10 Councillors who represent Milton’s eight wards for a four year term. The Council of the Town of Milton is responsible for: Community Services 18.6% Engineering Services 25.4% • Representing the public and considering the well-being and interests of the municipality. • Developing and evaluating policies and programs of the municipality. • Determining which services the municipality provides. • Ensuring that administrative and controllership policies, practices, and procedures are in place to implement the decisions of Council. • Maintaining the financial integrity of the municipality. Operating Budget Gross Expenditures Mayor and Council 0.6% Library Services 4.4% Executive Services - $5.4 Million (4.9%) General Government 12.1% $109.2 million Executive Services 4.9% External Revenues Transferred to Reserves/Reserve Funds 10.1% Planning and Development 6.7% Corporate Services 8.5% Fire Services 8.7% Information on the services provided by each department is as follows and further details on each department’s budget are included in subsequent sections. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET The Executive Services Department, under the direction of the Chief Administrative Officer, exercises the general management and oversight of the Corporation consistent with the Municipal Act and related legislation. Services provided by the Executive Services Department include: • Mayor and Council support through the Office of the CAO. • The Clerks Division is responsible for by-law enforcement, the crossing guard program, marriage and business licensing and animal and weed control. In addition, this division organizes Council agendas and ensures the smooth flow of Council business. • Economic Development assists with business relocation and set-up, attracts new business investments as well as supporting existing businesses and facilitates economic growth. • Marketing and Communications informs and connects with residents on municipal matters and services, fosters citizen engagement and a broader awareness and understanding of the Town’s programs and services. OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 68 Overview Engineering Services - $27.8 Million (25.4%) The Engineering Services Department is responsible for providing many direct services to the community, such as: • Operation of the Town’s transit service. • Maintenance of parks, sports fields, stormwater management facilities and roadways, including winter control and roadway reconstruction. • Traffic control including traffic signage, speed limit, streetlight maintenance, traffic data and traffic signal timings. • Parking control including parking regulations and enforcement, online parking considerations, parking ticket payments and dispute resolution. • Fleet maintenance which includes repair and maintenance of the Operations divisions vehicles and equipment. • The review and approval of engineering drawings and reports, inspection of all subdivision and site plan municipal services, establishment and enforcement of engineering design standards by Development Engineering and addressing grading issues associated with residential development. • Oversee the construction of roadways, bridges, sidewalks and stormwater management facilities. Community Services - $20.3 Million (18.6%) The Community Services Department offers recreation, sport and cultural services to the residents of Milton. The development, scheduling and maintenance of facilities, recreation and cultural programs and services as well as working with community partners are all part of the department’s responsibilities. Specific roles within this department include: • Planning, design, construction and operation of facilities including the rehabilitation and reconstruction of existing facilities. • Community program planning, development and implementation for children, youth, adults and older adults. • Management and operation of cultural services (Milton Centre for the Arts). • Administration of recreation services such as inclusion opportunities for recreation services (fee assistance, special needs), community development including Milton Community Fund, Affiliation Program, and Space Allocation for community organizations and departmental administrative services including facility scheduling, permitting and program registrations. • Parks planning and project management including design of new parks and reconstruction of existing parks. Planning and Development - $7.3 Million (6.7%) The Planning and Development Department provides direction with respect to the management of growth and development. Currently, this primarily relates to establishing an appropriate policy framework to support balanced and effective decision making with respect to land use planning matters having regard for other corporate priorities including environmental sustainability, urban design, transportation and infrastructure, parks and recreation, cultural heritage and community improvement. This department consists of the following divisions: • The Planning Policy and Urban Design Division establishes strategic policies and regulations to guide the long term development of the Town in a manner that achieves the goals and objectives of the Official Plan. This section also provides administrative support and staff liaison to Heritage Milton. • The Development Review function manages applications for land development including subdivision, condominium, Official Plan and Zoning By-law amendments. It is also responsible for the administration of the Committee of Adjustment. • The Building Services Division ensures that all construction within the Town complies with the minimum required Provincial standards as set out in the Ontario Building Code Act. It also implements and enforces various municipal by-laws such as the Zoning By-law and Sign By-law. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 69 Overview General Government and External Revenues - $24.2 Million (22.2%) The purpose of the General Government Department is to provide funding for various financial expenditures that impact the Town including debenture principal and interest payments, annual transfer of funding to the capital budget, transfers to reserves and contingency. Collection of general Town revenues such as grants, investment income, penalties and interest and interest from Milton Hydro are also included in this department. Fire Services - $9.5 Million (8.7%) The Fire Department is responsible for providing fire services as mandated under the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997. The Act requires municipalities to provide fire protection services and establish a program that includes public education with respect to fire safety and certain components of fire prevention. The Town of Milton is equipped with four fire stations that are strategically located throughout the town to minimize response times. This department is made up of the following divisions: • Firefighting involves fire suppression, extrication of occupants of motor vehicle collisions, technical rescue incidents and confined space rescues. • Fire Prevention focuses on public education, burn permits and fireworks permits and property inspections. • The Support Services Division is responsible for the dispatching of fire services incidents, departmental communications including the updating of mapping and pre-planning documents, radio systems (invehicle, portable and back-up) and pagers/electronic programming as well as the coordination of any specialized equipment and fire station infrastructure maintenance. • Training involves regular, specialized and incident management instruction designed to address core service levels of emergency response. The Milton Fire Department has a wide variety of fleet and equipment with which to serve the community. Repairs and maintenance are managed by dual role staff from within the Training and Suppression Division. Corporate Services - $9.3 Million (8.5%) The Corporate Services Department provides a wide variety of administrative, technical and financial services to all departments of the Town and to the public in general. • The Finance Division is responsible for the preparation and coordination of capital and operating budgets, financial analysis and reporting, development charge administration, investments and debt management and reserve fund administration. This division provides accounting support to the organization and maintains accurate and up-to-date financial records for the Town. They are also responsible for establishing and implementing effective internal controls. • The Human Resources Division develops and implements policies and procedures which attract and retain excellent employees, promote fair and equitable treatment of employees and ensures the Town complies with all applicable Ministry of Labour legislation. This division also provides corporate staff training and development programs. • The Information Technology Division provides, manages and supports a robust, reliable and secure information technology and telecommunications architecture within the Town. This division also provides business system support and project management during the implementation of new or upgrading of existing applications. • The Purchasing and Risk Division facilitates the procurement of goods and services through effective, fair, open and transparent processes. This division also administers insurance claims and monitors and develops policies to protect the Town from adverse risk issues. • The Taxation and Assessment Division provides the administration of the Council approved tax levy through the regular billing and collection of property taxes and management of assessment appeals. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 70 Overview Library Services - $4.8 Million (4.4%) Where Does the Money Come From? The Milton Public Library (MPL) is overseen by the Milton Public Library Board (MPLB). The MPLB is a governance board established by the Ontario Public Library Act, and is a formal policy-setting group that sets goals and objectives to meet the community’s public library needs. The MPL system provides the community with resources, materials, programs and services to support and encourage life-long learning at the Main Library and Beaty branch locations. This is accomplished through a materials library, a life-long learning centre, virtual library services and resources and a service oriented organization. Proposed taxes collected from taxable properties make up 47.2% of total revenue needed for the operating budget. Through Council deliberation and approval of the budget, the amount required from property taxes is determined. Each homeowner pays a share of the total tax required based on the value of his or her home, relative to all other homes; as does each business. The MPL also fulfills two secondary roles: acting as a broker/link to other resources and serving as a community gathering place. Each area of MPL monitors trends and plans for appropriate innovations, service responses, and operational improvements as a result of the dynamic changes taking place in Milton. At just under 22% of the total revenue, user fees form the next significant portion of revenue collected by the Town. This revenue is generated primarily from fees collected for the use of recreation programs and facilities. Sources of revenues to fund the operating budget are illustrated in the following graph and the commentary following the graph provides detailed definitions of these sources of revenue. Taxation 47.2% Payments in Lieu 0.6% Grants 1.1% Recoveries & Donations 3.3% Sources of Revenue $109.2 million Reallocated Revenues 4.7% External Revenues Transferred to Reserves/Reserve Funds 10.8% MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET User Fees & Service Charges 21.5% Financing Revenues 10.8% OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 71 Overview User Fees and Service Charges - $23.4 Million (21.5%) Grants - $1.2 Million (1.1%) User fees recover the costs of municipal programs or services from the individuals or organizations that specifically use the program or service. The user fees included in the operating budget were approved by Council through the 2016 Rates and Fees By-laws, as outlined in By-law No. 0602015 and No. 121-2012, which identifies the building fees. These by-laws provide the authority to collect these revenues. Grants denote the funds received from federal or provincial agencies as well as other organizations. The 2016 budget includes the following grants: Payments in Lieu - $0.65 Million (0.6%) • A conditional operating grant from the Ministry of Health and Long Term Care under the Elderly Persons Centres Act. • Funds received from Arts Presentation Canada, the Ontario Arts Council and a TD Accessibility Grant, Dance Ontario, and Theatre Connects specific to the Milton Centre for the Arts. This revenue source represents the amount of revenue received from other government agencies who own property within the Town of Milton; essentially, it is a cash payment received in lieu of a property tax payment. • A grant from the Aquatics Lifesaving Society to run a “Swim to Survive” program. Financing Revenues - $11.8 Million (10.8%) • An allocation of the Toronto 2015 Sport Legacy Fund for ongoing Velodrome operating costs which is funded through contributions from the Government of Canada and the Province of Ontario. These are revenues received from other sources including the capital fund, reserves and reserve funds, investment income and revenues from Milton Hydro (including the annual dividend and interest payments on a long term note receivable). Long term lease agreements are recorded in this category. • A provincial grant from the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Sport related to an after school program for children and youth. • A multi year grant from the Ontario Sport and Recreation Communities Fund for the development of a Cycling Participation Strategy. • A provincial Public Library Operating Grant and a federal Summer Career Placement Grant. Recoveries and Donations - $3.7 Million (3.3%) This revenue source includes the reimbursement of Town costs through agreements with external agencies. Donations from external parties are also included within this revenue category. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 72 Overview External Revenues Transferred to Reserves/Reserve Funds - $11.7 Million (10.8%) The revenues included in this category represent revenues that are not used directly in the operating budget but are immediately transferred to the appropriate reserve or reserve fund. The inclusion of the revenue in the operating budget is to comply with accounting standards. These revenues include such things as the Ontario Lottery Corporation proceeds and contributions from developers as per Financial Agreements. Reallocated Revenues - $5.2 Million (4.7%) Reallocated revenues denote transfers of revenues between departments to better reflect the true cost of providing Town services by functional/ service area. These revenues are offset by reallocated expenses as they are an allocation of costs from one functional area to another. Taxation - $51.6 Million (47.2%) Taxation represents the amount of property tax that is received by the Town from taxpayers, including the tax levy ($49.1 million) and other taxation ($2.5 million). Other taxation includes items such as Supplementary Taxes which result from changes in a property’s assessed value during the taxation year and Right of Way payments for railway and utility corridors. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 73 Overview Key Factors Impacting the Budget The proposed 2016 operating budget tax levy requirement has increased by $4.5 million over the 2015 approved budget. Assessment growth tax revenue reflects an increase to the taxable assessment base. As the Town grows and more properties are developed, the increased value of the developed properties is captured in the assessment base and provides incremental tax revenue to help pay for the increased need for services as a result of that growth. For the purpose of the 2016 budget, weighted assessment growth of 2.97% has been achieved and will offset $1.3 million of the required tax levy increase. During budget preparation, cost and revenue changes are distinguished amongst three distinct categories: (1) Status Quo/Contractual, (2) Growth/ Volume and (3) Service Level. The intent of presenting the budget impacts in this manner is to highlight the cost of growth versus the costs associated with continuing to service the existing community and changes to the levels of service being delivered. This helps to understand what the key drivers of change are in the budget. The following table illustrates the budget impacts by cost driver: TOTAL TOWN (Excluding DBIA) 2015 Approved Status Quo/Contractual Growth/Volume Service Level 2016 Proposed $ $ $ $ $ MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET 44,859,028 2,238,970 1,846,808 455,362 49,400,168 313,614 9,257 322,871 These represent changes in costs and revenues to maintain existing service levels and quantities. This includes items such as inflationary adjustments, contractual obligations, legislative requirements, changes in user fees, etc. The impact of the Municipal Price Index (MPI) is reflected in this type of change. Typically these items are non-discretionary if existing services are going to be maintained. Putting added pressure on the budget this year are a number of nondiscretionary items such as the estimated foreign exchange impact of $0.13 million resulting from a drop in the Canadian dollar, as well as a reduction in projected investment revenue of $0.35 million due to lower market rates, and an expected decrease in subdivision application revenue of $0.23 million. These are partially offset by adjustments to the winter control budget and an anticipated increase in recoveries from the Region of Halton for roads maintenance. TOWN (Excluding Hospital) HOSPITAL $ $ $ $ $ Status Quo/Contractual Change $ $ $ $ $ 44,545,414 2,238,970 1,837,551 455,362 49,077,297 OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 74 Overview Growth/Volume Change Growth/volume changes are the costs/revenues to extend existing services to newly developed neighbourhoods within the community. There are two main growth related changes in the 2016 budget. The first is an increase in transfers to reserves. Transfers to the Equipment Replacement Reserve were increased following the recommendations outlined in CORS-059-14. The 2016 budget also includes an increase to the Tax Rate Stabilization reserve of $0.07 million to proactively manage the financial impact related to the opening of Fire Station 5 expected in 2019. Growth Related Impact Reserves & Capital Program $ Fire & Protective Services Roads Planning Parks & Community Services Operations & Equipment Traffic Control MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET The table below outlines all growth related changes to the 2016 budget. It also demonstrates that assessment growth revenues are insufficient in offsetting net growth related expenses. Impact Rationale ($ millions) Internal Support Subtotal Assessment Growth Revenues Deficit/(Surplus) The second driving factor in the growth increases for 2016 is related to staffing positions that have been added to the budget to accommodate growth related activity. Further details related to the positions added to the budget are outlined on pages 78 and 79 of the Operating Budget Summary Section. $ $ $ 0.77 Increased transfer to Equipment Replacement Reserve ($0.33), Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve re: Fire Station 5 ($0.07), Library Reserve re: new branch ($0.13), Transfer to Capital Program ($0.13). 0.40 Increased costs for IT software maintenance as well as Finance to allow for ongoing efficient operation of the municipality and ensure municipal service delivery standards are maintained along with growth of Town. 0.42 Adding budgetary dollars in Licensing and Enforcement to be able to respond to public by-law complaints in a more timely manner. Additional firefighters allow for increased immediate reponse capability and part time staff hours to enhance depth of response. 0.14 Increase in Operations staff to support maintenance of growth related roads. 0.07 Staffing related costs to continue to allow for timely reponses to urban planning matters. 0.05 Increase in Operations staff to support maintenance of growth related parks; partially offset by increased revenue from community programs. 0.03 Relates to grass cutting and growth related vehicle operating expenses. (0.03) New Traffic Technologist to support growth in the Town's urban core. Also included, is a growth related increase in parking fine revenues. 1.84 (1.32) 0.52 OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 75 Overview Service Level Change Service Level changes are defined as changes in cost/revenue structure due to increases/decreases to service levels and/or the introduction/ discontinuance of a service. Service level changes are being proposed by various departments through the 2016 operating budget. They represent a change in the level of service provided to the community in comparison to the approved 2015 budget. The net financial impact is an increase in the proposed tax levy of $0.46 million. The following table presents a list of the service level changes contained in the proposed operating budget. Further details on the proposed service level changes can be found within each department’s section of the budget document. Summary of Proposed Service Level Changes Mayor & Council - TAPMO Membership Economic Development - Elimination of This Way Up Marketing Campaign Marketing and Communications - Transit Information Technology Programs Human Resource Programs Transit - Paratransit Contracts Infrastructure Management - Bike Lanes Infrastructure Management - Crack Sealing Operations - Road Side Brushing Operations - Storm Separator Cleaning Operations - Millfoil Harvest Removal Operations - Snow Clearing Operations - Maintenance for Vehicle Wash Operations - Wash Service Pit Recreation Programming Main Library - Open 8 Extra Sundays per year Main Library - Open Monday evenings from 5:00pm to 9:00pm Total MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET Page 111 125 126 156-161 162-163 243-244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 301-304 352 353 $ $ 2016 Impact 254 (5,000) 62,000 22,803 17,150 93,408 80,002 84,171 40,000 42,000 20,000 (4,500) 10,000 25,000 (62,703) 8,234 22,543 455,362 OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 76 Overview Human Resources Complement Changes The Strategic Workforce Plan (CORS-078-15) as presented to Council on December 14, 2015, discussed the need to increase staffing levels to accommodate the rapid growth that the Town continues to experience. As part of this review, staff completed a forecasting exercise to determine what additional positions would be required in 2016 to continue to provide service delivery at existing levels and reduce existing pressures across the organization. The table below highlights the changes in the full time equivalents by department from 2015. Employees by Department Executive Services Corporate Services Engineering Services Community Services Planning and Development Fire Services Library Services TOTAL 2014 36.51 57.44 89.41 181.85 54.00 68.25 44.35 531.81 2015 37.62 58.44 93.61 188.85 54.00 68.80 44.29 545.59 Full Time Complement The 2016 budget includes a net change in FTEs of 14 made up of 15 new full time positions, 1.3 new co-op positions, a reduction of 1.0 FTE due to a contract coming to an end, a conversion of 1.0 FTE to part time hours and a further contract reduction of 0.3. The 1.3 FTE new co-op positions have been added to the 2016 budget across various departments to provide added support in managing workload during critical times of the year. A Project Coordinator, Facilities contract has ended, resulting in a reduction of 1.0 FTE. A full time Library Operations Officer was converted to part time staff hours, resulting in a reduction of 1.0 FTE. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET Change in Method of Service Delivery/ Other 3.77 1.00 (7.46) (0.23) (0.19) (3.12) Growth / Volume 3.33 3.63 4.32 5.95 1.67 2.72 21.61 Service Level 0.68 0.68 1.36 Total 2016 44.71 62.07 98.93 188.01 55.67 71.29 44.77 565.46 With funds received from a multi-year grant from the Ontario Sport and Recreation Communities Fund for the development of a Cycling Participation Strategy, a Cycling Specialist was included in the 2014 budget. This was an 18 month contract position scheduled to end in 2015; however, the work was delayed due to the labour issues with the Halton District School Board in 2015. The work is now scheduled to be completed during 2016, which results in a reduction of 0.3 FTEs in 2016 when compared against the 2015 budget. Details on the 15 proposed new FTEs are outlined on the following page. The annual impact of salaries and benefits for some of these positions are recoverable from sources other than the tax base, such as through the capital budget and user fees. OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 77 Overview Department Staff Positions Benefit to Residents Executive Services 1. Manager, Marketing and Communications (1 FTE) Will enhance communications and branding to build stakeholder, media and government relations. Marketing activities drive revenues and increased utilization of Town programs and services. 2. Municipal Law Enforcement Officer (2 FTEs) Will enable levels of service to be improved along with building capacity to manage the increased number of by-law complaints requiring investigation that rise in line with the Town’s population. 1. Financial Admin Analyst, Finance (1 FTE) To fulfill the recommendations of a business process review to provide Departments additional assistance with purchasing and accounts payable functions. The position will be shared by Engineering and Community Services but report to the Finance Division to ensure adherence to corporate accounting policies and procedures. 2. Budget Analyst (1.0 FTE) Add an FTE to allow the division to be more efficient and provide the resources to meet work deadlines and expectations of various client groups. 3. IT Project Manager (1 FTE) To provide project management for IT enabled solutions versus manual practices that will meet increased demand for these solutions, advance efficiency in the organization and achieve service delivery expectations to the public, with full cost recovery from the capital budget. 4. GIS Technician (0.3 FTE) To meet increased demand, productivity and service delivery needs for GIS enabled solutions by hiring a full time technician versus co-op students to prevent productivity loss during co-op training and recruitment. Corporate Services MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 78 Overview Department Staff Positions Benefit to Residents Engineering Services 1. Traffic Technologist (1 FTE) To allow the Town to have the necessary capacity to support growth as its urban core continues to grow in geographic size and housing density intensifies. 2. Operations Crew Person II (3 FTEs) Required to manage maintenance of new growth related parks and roads. Will allow current levels of service in both parks and roads maintenance to continue in this high profile and visible municipal service. 1. Supervisor, Recreation - Arts convert PT position to FT (0.4 FTE) The conversion of the Supervisor, Recreation – Arts position to full time will allow the department to expand seasonal programs and summer camp activities. 2. Supervisor, Facility Operations (1 FTE) Due to recent growth, the addition of a Supervisor, Facility Operations is recommended to improve management of staff and provide more efficient service delivery. 3. Facility Operator (0.3 FTE) In response to programming demands and the hours of operation of the Mattamy National Cycling Centre, additional facility maintenance hours are required to operate and maintain the facility. Planning and Development Planner, Urban Design (1 FTE) To allow for timely responses to urban planning matters. Fire Services 1. Captain (1 FTE) 2. Firefighter (Acting Captain) (1FTE) To allow for additional incremental staffing, initiating development of a third fulltime apparatus (Station 5) for immediate response capabilities in support of the current two full-time 7/24 hour coverage apparatus. Community Services MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 79 Overview Part Time Complement The part time complement for 2016 includes an additional 5.9 FTEs in order to respond to growth related demands. This increase is a result of the following: • Changes in community programs and recreation facilities (3.3 FTE). • Increase in firefighter part time hours (0.5 FTE). • Increase in hours of operation of Library (0.7 FTE). • Conversion of Library full time staff to part time (0.8 FTE). • Additional crossing guards (0.6 FTEs). In addition to the complement changes as outlined above, the 2016 budget includes a market adjustment of 2.0% to wages for existing Town staff effective July 1st, 2016. Transfer To/From Reserves and Reserve Funds The build out of the 401 Industrial Park is almost complete, resulting in very little industrial and/or commercial land available for development. Although the secondary plan for the Derry Green Corporate Business Park was approved by the Region in March of 2014, growth was delayed due to an outstanding appeal to the secondary plan for this area. Building permit revenue is expected to increase in 2016, as compared to the 2015 budget; however, the delays resulting from the appeal are resulting in a transfer of $0.7 million from the Building Stabilization Reserve Fund. Included in the 2016 budget is an increase in the transfer to the Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve of $0.07 million. The purpose of doing this is to set aside funds to mitigate the increase in the tax impact in 2019 when the new Fire Station 5 is scheduled to open. In 2019, funds can be drawn from the reserve to phase in the impact on the tax levy. A $0.13 million one-time contribution from the Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve is included in the budget to offset the tax rate impact associated with foreign exchange due to the decline in the value of the Canadian dollar . In order to operate in a fiscally responsible manner, the Town of Milton maintains reserves and reserve funds which assist in creating a solid financial position to support the Town’s future cash requirements. Maintaining sufficient balances in the reserves and reserve funds is a critical component of a municipality’s long-term financial plan as it strengthens its financial sustainability. An additional $0.04 million has also been built into the 2016 budget as an increase to the Infrastructure Renewal Reserve. Again, the purpose of doing this is so that funds can be drawn from the reserve in future years to mitigate tax rate increases related to the maintenance and renewal of existing assets. The 2016 proposed operating budget contains transfers to/from the capital fund and reserves and reserve funds. Some of these annual transfers have been indexed by the MPI and/or assessment growth to ensure funds being set aside are not eroded by inflation and/or growth of the municipality. The transfer to the Legal Reserve has been reduced by $0.05 million for 2016 to offset anticipated defence costs associated with an existing claim. Transfers to the Library Services Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve and the Library Capital Works Reserve were increased by $0.13 million in total primarily in order to mitigate significant tax impacts in 2018 and 2019 when the new library branch is scheduled to open. Further details on the Reserve and Reserve Fund balances as well as the schedule of movement for 2016 can be found in the Reserve and Reserve Fund section on pages 406 to 413. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 80 Overview What Does $1 of Municipal Taxes Buy? The total tax-supported expenditures for the major service categories are shown in the chart below. For every dollar, 94 cents is spent on providing core municipal services such as: • Fire and protective services • Roads, including winter maintenance and streetlighting This information is based on the general tax levy and applies to residents in both the urban and rural areas. Urban residents are also subject to a separate urban levy, or surcharge, applied to residents in the urban boundary, which is being reduced by 50% in 2016 due to the tax policy change approved in 2015. For more information on the urban levy and tax policy change, see page 65. • Parks and community services • Transit • Milton Public Library • Financing of capital projects General Levy Coin image © 2016 Royal Canadian Mint. All rights reserved MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 81 Overview Milton District Hospital Expansion Expanding Existing Services into the Growth Areas Through CORS-015-15 Council approved an early issuance of 30 year debentures to fund a portion of the Town’s share of Milton’s hospital expansion project. This early issuance took advantage of historically low interest rates with $0.8 million in principal and interest payments added to the 2016 hospital expansion budget. These payments will be funded through the Milton District Hospital Expansion Reserve Fund for 2016 resulting in no net impact to the tax levy in 2016. Staff will monitor the financial plan in advance of making payment to the Hospital in 2017. As new developments are completed, timing of the expansion of the transit system routes to include the growth areas will need to be considered. In addition, new infrastructure such as roads and parks are being built within subdivisions. There will be additional operating costs related to the maintenance of the infrastructure such as winter control and grass cutting. Future Financial Issues There are a number of issues that the Town will be required to consider and address in future budget preparation. The major issues the Town will face over the forecast period and into the foreseeable future include: Operating Impacts of New Capital Infrastructure The approval of certain capital projects will result in future operating impacts as a result of ongoing operational expenditures to support new or expanded services and maintenance of infrastructure. Through the preparation of the capital budget, departments consider and identify any potential impacts on the Town’s operating budget associated with the proposed capital program. This information is used in preparation of the annual operating budget and forecasts for future years. Further information on the operating impacts of capital jobs in the 2016 budget and their impact on the operating budget and forecast can be found on page 48. It is important to note that the operating impacts of capital jobs in the 2016 budget only present the operating impacts over the next three years. However, there are capital jobs out further in the future that will have a significant impact on the operating budget such as the new Sherwood Community Centre scheduled to open in 2018, Fire Station 5 projected for 2019 and fleet growth related impacts. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET Contributions to reserves should also increase to ensure funds are being set aside for asset management purposes and future replacement/ reconstruction of assets. The operating costs of these services will have an impact on future operating budgets and may cause immediate tax impacts in the year they become operational. Strategic Workforce Plan The strategic workforce plan as outlined in CORS-078-15 discussed staffing requirements for the next five years as benchmarked against data from other municipalities experiencing similar impacts of growth. The data from the study suggested that the Town’s current staffing model is too heavily weighted on part time staff as compared to full time staff. Part time staff bring a lesser degree of stability to the workforce due to a higher turnover rate, thus resulting in additional costs. Over the next five years, concerted efforts will be made to convert part time positions to full time where appropriate. It was also apparent from the review that the number of full time staff employed by the Town of Milton is low compared to other comparable municipalities. A five year rolling Human Capital Plan has been completed and will be adjusted annually so that the Town is able to constantly monitor human resource allocations. It is reasonable to expect that tax levels will need to increase above the rate of inflation in order to accommodate the higher level of resources needed to provide the programs and services to the growing community. OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 82 Overview CN Intermodal Terminal Changing Weather Patterns CN Rail has formally announced their desire to proceed with the development of an intermodal facility in southwest Milton along the existing CN rail line, south of Britannia Road. A fiscal impact study is underway which will consider the potential loss of revenue arising from the use of these lands for an intermodal terminal versus being used for employment land purposes as currently anticipated. This study will evaluate the impacts of not only the loss of employment lands but also the loss of potential employment opportunities and the impacts on the Town’s assessment base. Impacts from extreme weather have recently been experienced in Southern Ontario as well as other parts of Canada and the world. Within the past five years, Milton has been affected financially by a tornado in 2009 and, most recently, by a severe ice storm in 2013. Interest Rates Interest rates remain low by historical standards which presents both opportunities and challenges to the Town. If rates continue on this trend as expected, the Town will continue to realize modest returns on its investment portfolio but can continue to issue debentures for capital works with lower interest payments in future years over the term of the debt. On the other hand, if rates increase then the Town can take advantage of higher returns on investments but will also incur additional expenses for interest costs on debt. This scenario is of particular concern with the future commitment to provide funding for the hospital expansion for which the Town will need to issue significant debt to meet its funding obligation. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET Other municipalities have been affected by these same conditions as well as extreme flooding due to heavy rainfalls within a short period of time. If this trend of extreme weather conditions continues, this could negatively impact the finances of the Town, making it prudent to consider either the establishment of reserves to mitigate the financial risk of extreme weather events or increase the target balance in the Tax Rate Stabilization Reserve. Other Items of Consideration The Town continues to experience growth and changing demographics. This diversity presents interesting challenges in meeting vastly different needs and demands. Considerations in the development of programs and services need to reflect this new reality. OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 83 Gross Expenditures by Department EXPENDITURES Mayor & Council Executive Services Corporate Services General Government Engineering Services Community Services Planning & Development Fire Services Library Services SUBTOTAL TOWN OF MILTON Hospital Expansion DBIA SUBTOTAL HOSPITAL and DBIA TOTAL TOWN OF MILTON EXPENDITURES REVENUE Mayor & Council Executive Services Corporate Services General Government Engineering Services Community Services Planning & Development Fire Services Library Services SUBTOTAL TOWN OF MILTON Hospital Expansion DBIA SUBTOTAL HOSPITAL and DBIA TOTAL TOWN OF MILTON REVENUES TOTAL LEVY REQUIREMENTS 2015 Projected Actuals 2014 Actuals DEPARTMENT NAME 2015 Approved Budget 2016 Status Quo/ Contractual 2016 Base Budget 2016 Growth/Volume Change $ 492,415 4,079,249 7,262,482 25,588,023 27,778,977 17,483,211 6,219,757 8,155,225 4,255,518 $ 539,270 4,213,996 8,165,003 24,865,974 26,705,437 20,036,956 7,012,933 8,803,435 4,571,073 $ 564,270 4,701,097 8,225,515 24,185,992 25,559,962 19,366,028 7,147,572 8,800,407 4,574,613 $ 30,049 304,533 280,184 706,292 1,087,979 455,891 33,906 361,924 86,829 $ 594,319 5,005,630 8,505,699 24,892,284 26,647,941 19,821,919 7,181,478 9,162,331 4,661,442 $ $ $ 101,314,857 315,402 219,255 $ $ 104,914,077 317,114 220,150 $ $ 103,125,456 317,114 220,150 $ $ 3,347,587 775,226 17,350 $ $ 106,473,043 1,092,340 237,500 $ $ 2016 Service Level Change 9,500 $ 360,898 700,169 (659,605) 736,759 470,227 103,608 365,844 115,500 2,202,900 9,257 - $ $ 2016 Proposed Budget % Change Proposed/ P.Y. Approved 254 22,000 44,953 390,081 25,784 30,777 $ 604,073 5,388,528 9,250,821 24,232,679 27,774,781 20,317,930 7,285,086 9,528,175 4,807,719 7.1% 14.6% 12.5% 0.2% 8.7% 4.9% 1.9% 8.3% 5.1% 513,849 - $ $ 109,189,792 1,101,597 237,500 247.4% 7.9% 149.2% 5.9% $ 534,657 $ 537,264 $ 537,264 $ 792,576 $ 1,329,840 $ 9,257 $ - $ 1,339,097 $ 101,849,514 $ 105,451,341 $ 103,662,720 $ 4,140,163 $ 107,802,883 $ 2,212,157 $ 513,849 $ 110,528,889 6.6% $ (10,997) $ (918,981) (2,736,759) (24,652,509) (13,231,893) (11,579,129) (6,146,111) (223,274) (260,618) (21,482) $ (1,196,848) (2,757,582) (23,290,192) (11,753,759) (13,791,836) (6,697,257) (247,158) (243,921) (14,782) $ (1,260,858) (2,698,949) (23,162,126) (11,093,877) (13,133,267) (6,724,104) (248,158) (243,921) (6,818) $ (15,208) (65,074) (414,094) (613,991) (1,640) 24,065 2,304 (18,161) (21,600) $ (1,276,066) (2,764,023) (23,576,220) (11,707,868) (13,134,907) (6,700,039) (245,854) (262,082) - $ (26,827) (322,416) 804,607 (189,238) (612,204) (19,271) - - $ 35,000 (5,000) (88,487) - (21,600) (1,267,893) (3,091,439) (22,771,613) (11,897,106) (13,835,598) (6,719,310) (245,854) (262,082) 0.0% 0.6% 14.5% (1.7%) 7.2% 5.3% (0.1%) (0.9%) 7.4% $ $ (59,760,271) $ (10,231) $ (219,254) (60,000,035) $ (3,500) $ (220,150) (58,580,042) $ (3,500) $ (220,150) (1,108,617) $ (775,226) $ (17,350) (59,688,659) $ (778,726) $ (237,500) (365,349) $ - $ - (58,487) $ - $ - (60,112,495) (778,726) (237,500) 22,149.3% 7.9% $ (1,016,226) 354.4% (58,487) $ (61,128,721) 4.0% 49,400,168 10.1% $ (229,485) $ (223,650) $ (223,650) $ (792,576) $ (1,016,226) $ $ (59,989,756) $ (60,223,685) $ (58,803,692) $ (1,901,193) $ (60,704,885) $ $ 41,859,758 $ 45,227,656 $ 44,859,028 $ 2,238,970 $ 47,097,998 $ - $ (365,349) $ 1,846,808 $ - 455,362 $ 2.6% NOTE 1: Through the 2016 budget, some services were reallocated between departments to better align with the operations of the organization. For comparative purposes, the 2015 approved budget has been restated however, the actuals for 2014 and 2015 have not. Details of the significant restatements are included in the Operating Budget Summary on page 67. MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 84 Net Expenditures by Department 2015 Projected Actuals 2014 Actuals DEPARTMENT NAME Mayor & Council Executive Services Corporate Services General Government Engineering Services Community Services Planning & Development Fire Services Library Services SUBTOTAL TOWN OF MILTON Hospital Expansion DBIA SUBTOTAL HOSPITAL and DBIA $ $ $ 481,418 3,160,268 4,525,723 935,514 14,547,084 5,904,082 73,646 7,931,951 3,994,900 41,554,586 305,171 1 305,172 TOTAL TOWN OF MILTON NET EXPENDITURES $ 41,859,758 $ $ 2015 Approved Budget $ $ 517,788 3,017,148 5,407,421 1,575,782 14,951,678 6,245,120 315,676 8,556,277 4,327,152 44,914,042 313,614 313,614 $ 549,488 3,440,239 5,526,566 1,023,866 14,466,085 6,232,761 423,468 8,552,249 4,330,692 44,545,414 313,614 313,614 $ 45,227,656 $ 44,859,028 $ $ $ $ 2016 Status Quo/ Contractual $ 2016 Base Budget $ $ 23,231 289,325 215,110 292,198 473,988 454,251 57,971 364,228 68,668 2,238,970 - $ 2,238,970 $ $ 2016 Growth/Volume Change 2016 Service Level Change $ $ 572,719 3,729,564 5,741,676 1,316,064 14,940,073 6,687,012 481,439 8,916,477 4,399,360 46,784,384 313,614 313,614 $ 9,500 334,071 377,753 145,002 547,521 (141,977) 84,337 365,844 115,500 1,837,551 9,257 9,257 $ 47,097,998 $ 1,846,808 $ $ $ $ $ 2016 Proposed Budget $ $ 254 57,000 39,953 390,081 (62,703) 30,777 455,362 - $ 455,362 $ $ % Change Proposed/ P.Y. Approved $ 582,473 4,120,635 6,159,382 1,461,066 15,877,675 6,482,332 565,776 9,282,321 4,545,637 49,077,297 322,871 322,871 6.0% 19.8% 11.5% 42.7% 9.8% 4.0% 33.6% 8.5% 5.0% 10.2% 3.0% 0.0% 3.0% $ 49,400,168 10.1% $ $ NOTE 1: Through the 2016 budget, some services were reallocated between departments to better align with the operations of the organization. For comparative purposes, the 2015 approved budget has been restated however, the actuals for 2014 and 2015 have not. Details of the significant restatements are included in the Operating Budget Summary on page 67. Sources of Revenue by Account 2014 Actuals REVENUE SOURCES REVENUE TOWN OF MILTON Taxation (excluding Tax Levy) Payments In Lieu Grants Recoveries and Donations User Fees and Service Charges External Revenue Transferred to Reserves and Reserve Funds Financing Revenue Reallocated Revenue SUBTOTAL TOWN OF MILTON REVENUE HOSPITAL and DBIA Taxation (including DBIA Tax Levy) Payments In Lieu Grants Recoveries and Donations User Fees and Service Charges External Revenue Transferred to Reserves and Reserve Funds Financing Revenue Reallocated Revenue SUBTOTAL HOSPITAL and DBIA TOTAL TOWN OF MILTON REVENUES MILTON 2016 PROPOSED BUDGET $ 2015 Projected Actuals 2015 Approved Budget 2016 Status Quo/ Contractual 2016 Base Budget (3,045,087) $ (631,231) (2,212,299) (3,586,235) (21,299,249) (10,724,911) (11,910,619) (6,350,639) (59,760,271) $ (2,810,780) $ (642,570) (1,626,922) (3,559,710) (22,593,994) (12,351,768) (11,220,424) (5,193,866) (60,000,035) $ (2,581,359) $ (621,242) (1,602,675) (3,333,711) (21,753,830) (11,851,768) (11,830,238) (5,005,219) (58,580,042) $ - $ 378,995 (320,004) (265,557) (593,071) (177,916) (131,064) (1,108,617) $ (2,581,359) $ (621,242) (1,223,680) (3,653,715) (22,019,387) (12,444,839) (12,008,154) (5,136,283) (59,688,659) $ $ (202,718) $ (1,822) (1,980) (8,924) (8,284) (5,757) (229,485) $ (198,592) $ (20,328) (4,730) (223,650) $ (198,592) $ (20,328) (4,730) (223,650) $ (6,828) $ (15,000) 5,328 (776,076) (792,576) $ (205,420) $ (15,000) (15,000) (780,806) (1,016,226) $ $ (59,989,756) $ (60,223,685) $ (58,803,692) $ (1,901,193) $ (60,704,885) $ $ $ 2016 Growth/Volume Change 2016 Service Level Change 83,406 $ (32,309) 12,000 (36,040) (1,311,981) 718,262 216,331 (15,018) (365,349) $ - $ $ (365,349) $ 2016 Proposed Budget - $ 20,000 35,000 (108,487) (5,000) (58,487) $ % Change Proposed/ P.Y. Approved (2,497,953) (653,551) (1,191,680) (3,654,755) (23,439,855) (11,726,577) (11,796,823) (5,151,301) (60,112,495) (3.2%) 5.2% (25.6%) 9.6% 7.8% (1.1%) (0.3%) 2.9% 2.6% $ (205,420) (15,000) (15,000) (780,806) (1,016,226) 3.4% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% (26.2%) 0.0% 16,407.5% 0.0% 354.4% (58,487) $ (61,128,721) 4.0% - $ OPERATING BUDGET SUMMARY 85