RECAPP Facility Evaluation Report Calgary School District #19 Lord Beaverbrook High School B2705A Calgary Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) Facility Details Building Name: Lord Beaverbrook High Scho Address: 9019 Fairmount Drive S. E. Location: Calgary Building Id: Gross Area (sq. m): Replacement Cost: Construction Year: B2705A 27,506.51 $88,188,000 1966 Evaluation Details Evaluation Company: Altus Group Evaluation Date: September 13 2011 Evaluator Name: Gary Bowen Total Maintenance Events Next 5 years: 5 year Facility Condition Index (FCI): $10,708,162 12.14% General Summary: Lord Beaverbrook High School is a split two-storey concrete and masonry block structure with a partial basement, originally constructed in 1966, and owned by the Calgary Board of Education. The original building has a total floor area of approximately 26,684 square meters. Two former courtyards were covered in 1979, resulting in a concrete-framed, two-storey addition with a total floor area of approximately 626 square meters. A single-storey, concrete-framed addition was added on the north end of the building in 1985, which has a total floor area of approximately 196 square meters. This brings the total area in 2011 to 27,506 square meters. The school is used for typical classroom teaching purposes and includes a variety of shop classrooms for vocational studies. As of September 30, 2010, the total number of classrooms is 99, with a weighted enrolment of 2,106 students (87% provincial Utilization). Structural Summary: Structural drawings were not available for review during the assessment, however the building's foundations are reported to consist of a poured concrete assembly with concrete grade beams and pad footings. The structure consists of reinforced, poured concrete floors and load-bearing concrete/masonry block walls or concrete columns. The suspended second and third levels have pre-cast concrete T-beams with concrete topping. The roof structural frame is comprised of pre-cast concrete T-beams spanning between load-bearing masonry block walls or concrete columns. Recommended structural work identified during the assessment includes: - Repair of a suspended concrete walkway east of the school, which has visible cracks. - Repair of the bases of metal handrails on either side of the suspended walkway, where corrosion was visible. - Sealing of through-slab conduit penetrations in various locations in the building. - Repair of exterior concrete stairs adjacent to the loading dock - Repair of the loading dock bumpers. The previous inspection (2006) recommended the study and remediation of moisture ingress at the east end of the basement level. This was subsequently reported to be an issue with the sump pump and not water entering through the structure. This has reportedly been resolved by the renewal of the sump pump. Overall the structure is in acceptable condition. Envelope Summary: Exterior cladding consists of a combination of clay brick and pre-cast concrete panels. Rooftop mechanical penthouses are clad with pre-finished metal siding. All flat roof sections consist of either built-up roofing or a modified bitumen membrane assembly. The sloped roof of the exercise room is covered with asphalt shingles. There is currently a roof renewal program in progress. Main entrance doors have single-pane glazing and are set in aluminum frames. Remaining exterior doors are painted wood set in wood frames. Windows are fixed and operable with doubleglazed (not sealed) units set in aluminum frames. Recommended envelope work identified during the assessment includes: - Repointing of brick cladding in some locations - Repainting of deteriorated metal siding finishes - Replacement of damaged sections of metal siding - Repair of a stucco-clad panel above a shop classroom - Replacement of deficient sealant in construction joints - Repainting of wood panels below window units. A window edging that fell off the library was recently re-framed (Not replaced entirely). - Replacement of failed window units. Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 2 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) - Repainting of metal copings, the installation of copings where absent at the east end of the school. - There is inadequate fall protection available on the roof - a report into available roof anchors is reported to be available but was not presented. - Skylight repairs are required. It was reported that some units are leaking at their junction with the roof membrane (notably the art room). - Roof membrane - there have reportedly been 9 service calls due to roof leaks since 2008. However as of inspection date (September 13th 2011) the roofing is in the process of being completely replaced - projected completion date of October 1, 2011. Overall the building envelop is in acceptable condition. Interior Summary: Classrooms and corridors typically have vinyl tile flooring. Carpeting is provided in the library and administration area, while the main boiler room and other service areas have painted/sealed concrete floors . It is the intention of the school to replace much of the carpeted areas with tile to concrete areas, and linoleum to timber floor areas (a phased program has been implemented). This is especially necessary in the libraries, band areas, main office, and other small rooms. Wood flooring is provided in the main and ancillary gymnasiums as well as several adjacent storage rooms. The majority of the interior walls consist of painted gypsum board or painted masonry block. The majority of the building has either a suspended acoustic panel ceiling system, painted gypsum board ceilings or acoustic ceiling tiles. Recommended work to interiors includes: - Replacement of interior fire doors - Replacement of shower partitions in the men's locker room - Repainting of masonry block walls in shop classrooms - Repainting of sealed concrete floors in mechanical and service rooms - Refinishing wood flooring on the main gymnasium stage is also recommended. The main gym floor has been resurfaced so many times that replacement will be required when it is next due for resurfacing (2014) - Repainting of the ceiling in the men's shower room. - Replacement of stained ceiling panels throughout the school. - Replacement of missing baseboard sections throughout the corridors - Replacement of chain-link covered storage area partitions with gypsum board partitions - Replacement of missing fire stopping from a number of wall and floor penetrations. - Upgrading of the existing hydraulic elevator - Replacement of welding booths - Study and reconfiguration of a non-code compliant classroom (former storage room) to improve egress - Various upgrades to improve barrier free access It should be noted that there is known to be asbestos material in the drywall and the gym and that the maintenance staff are fully aware of this. A report detailing locations of asbestos in the school is reported to be available but was not presented. It appears that the asbestos risk is being well managed by maintenance staff. Overall the interior is in acceptable condition. Mechanical Summary: Lord Beaverbrook High School was originally constructed in 1966 with the addition of the library in 1979 and the welding shop in 1985. The majority of the sanitary, and rain water drainage piping is original to the construction of the building. The domestic hot water was replaced in 2009 with three AO Smith MasterFit Storage Water Heaters. There are backflow prevention devices (BFPs) present on the boiler feed water supply, fire protection riser, humidification supply, and the domestic water supply. Domestic hot water is provided by a steam converter connected to the central heating plant. The building is heated by two Cleaver Brooks steam boilers (12,554 MBH each). A third Peerless steam boiler (615 MBH) provided additional heating capacity to the system but was removed circa 2000 and replaced with the three large Hot Water Tanks. Steam is converted to heating hot water or heating glycol via converters located in the main boiler room. Heating distribution is through original piping to convectors, fan coils, and unit heaters. The hot water heating distribution system is reported to be original. It was observed during the property assessment that the school does not have a sufficient buffer for the glycol system, and a 250 gallon tank will be required. Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 3 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) No work was done on the boilers in 2009 but in 2010, the school sized and installed a new condensate tank, replacing the previous tank which was undersized and prone to over-filling. Three central air handling units located in the south mechanical penthouse supply tempered ventilation air to the original building. The central air handling unit contains a hot water heating and chilled water cooling coils. The gymnasium addition is served by a separate heating-only air handling unit. Bathrooms, kitchen and shop areas throughout the building are equipped with independently operated roof-mounted exhaust fans. The HVAC controls are pneumatic throughout the building and a central building management control system operating the boilers, central air handlers, and chilled water plant. The building has a standpipe system complete with fire hoses for life safety. The automotive paint booth is protected by a wet-pipe sprinkler system. The following are recommended actions for the next five years: - Install a larger buffer tank (250 gallon) for the glycol system - Replace the ventilation mixing chambers (VAV boxes) in each classroom as they are failing and obsolete with no replacement parts readily available. The hot deck cooling systems are original to the building and half of them do not work. - Remove corroded chimney for the incinerator that is no longer in service. Overall, the mechanical systems in the building are in acceptable condition. Electrical Summary: The building was upgraded to a 2000 Amp, 277/480 Volts service in 2004 which feeds the entire building. The electrical sub-panels and wiring are generally original to the construction of the building. All observed panels were at or near capacity. All observed wiring was in conduit. Interior lighting is still provided by a combination of T-8 and T-12 fluorescent technology throughout the building. Exterior lighting is provided by high pressure sodium fixtures around the building. Sodium lighting in the dance hall was replaced in Summer 2010. Emergency lighting, installed in approximately 1980, is connected to battery packs throughout the building. Exit lighting in the building is provided by original incandescent exit fixtures. The building is protected by a Pyrotronics Cerberus fire alarm panel installed in 1996. Detection in the building is by manual pull stations, heat and smoke detectors. The building has a Silent Knight security system, which is externally monitored, a Norstar Meridian telephone system, a custom address system, Bell fibreoptic internet service, and a local area network with hardwired and wireless connections. The electrical panels are outdated and there is no spare capacity. Replacement of the panels is recommended. Overall the electrical systems in the building are in acceptable condition. Condition Rating 1 - Critical 2 - Poor 3 - Marginal 4 - Acceptable 5 - Good 6 - Excellent Rating Guide Performance Unsafe, high risk of injury or critical system failure. Does not meet requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have high operating/maintenance costs. Meets minimum requirements, has significant deficiencies. May have above average operating maintenance costs. Meets present requirements, minor deficiencies. Average operating/maintenance costs. Meets all present requirements. No deficiencies. As new/state of the art, meets present and foreseeable requirements. Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 4 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S1 STRUCTURAL A1010 Standard Foundations* The building foundations presumably consist of cast-in-place concrete pad footings and perimeter grade beams with conventional steel reinforcement. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 APR-12 A1030 Slab on Grade* The main floor of the Lord Beaverbrook High School (where grade-supported) and the basement level floor are comprised of cast-in-place concrete slabs-on-grade which are presumed to be conventionally reinforced. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 A2020 Basement Walls (& Crawl Space)* The basement walls of the school are comprised of cast-in-place concrete which are presumed to have conventional steel reinforcement. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 APR-12 B1010.01 Floor Structural Frame (Building Frame)* The floor structural frame of the building is comprised of load-bearing masonry block or cast-in-place concrete walls or columns which support roof and suspended floor structures. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B1010.02 Structural Interior Walls Supporting Floors (or Roof)* Load-bearing interior walls throughout the building are comprised of masonry block or cast-in-place and reinforced concrete. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B1010.03 Floor Decks, Slabs, and Toppings* Portions of the main floor (where suspended) and the suspended second and third levels in the building have pre-cast concrete T-beams with concrete topping. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 5 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B1010.04 Balcony Floor Construction (& Decks)* A painted, steel-framed balcony is situated on the east side of the 1985 addition, which is located at the north end of the school. The balcony is used to store mechanical equipment associated with the adjacent welding shop. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1985 0 JAN-07 B1010.05 Mezzanine Construction* The majority of the shop classrooms on the north end of the school have cast-in-place concrete mezzanines which are supported by concrete columns and load-bearing masonry block walls. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 B1010.07 Exterior Stairs* Several poured concrete stairs are situated on the building perimeter. This includes two stairs on the east end and three on the west side. Most of the stairs are exposed and unfinished; however the stairs at the main entrance (east end) are finished with granite tile. The majority of the stairs have base-mounted, painted metal handrails placed along their outer edges. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 APR-12 Replace concrete steps adjacent to loading dock Concern: Concrete steps adjacent to loading dock have degraded badly and signs of corrosion in reinforcement bars are evident. Recommendation: Replace failed flight of 6 steps. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and proper function. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 High $2,904 Updated: APR-12 B1010.09 Floor Construction Fireproofing* Suspended floor soffits in mechanical spaces throughout the school have a spray-on fireproofing material. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 6 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B1010.10 Floor Construction Firestopping* Conduit penetrations through floor slabs and decks are sealed on their perimeter with a fire-rated material. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor 1966 0 Event: Repair Floor Firestopping MAR-13 Concern: Several voids were observed around through-slab conduit penetrations between the suspended floors of the school. Recommendation: Seal around voids in floor slabs where necessary. Consequences of Deferral: Potential migration of smoke or flame in the event of an emergency. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Medium $9,994 Updated: MAR-13 B1010.11 Other Floor Construction* - Loading Platform A raised concrete platform is provided in a loading/receiving area on the west side of the school. The platform is comprised of cast-in-place concrete and appears to be grade-supported. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 7 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B1010.11 Other Floor Construction* - Suspended Walkway A suspended walkway complete with stairs and base-mounted, painted metal rails is situated on the east side of the building. The walkway exits from the building's second floor and is comprised of a cast-in-place concrete slab supported by cast-in-place concrete columns. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Repair suspended concrete walkway cracks (100 m) and handrail bases Concern: Several cracks were observed at suspended concrete walkway. Corrosion is visible on the bases of the handrail. Recommendation: Fill concrete cracks and repair handrail bases. Consequences of Deferral: These defects can have an imminent impact on the appearance and potential effective life of the total structure. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2014 Low $3,500 Updated: MAR-13 B1020.01 Roof Structural Frame* The roof structural frame for the majority of the building is comprised of pre-cast concrete T-beams spanning between load-bearing masonry block walls or concrete columns. The 1985 addition at the north end of the building, the 1979 additions over the library, and the roof-mounted mechanical penthouse have metal roof decks supported by open-webbed steel joists. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B1020.04 Canopies* Exterior canopies are provided at the building's main entrance on the east end, and a main level entrance at the building's southwest corner. Each canopy is comprised of cast-in-place concrete supported by concrete columns. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 8 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S2 ENVELOPE B2010.01.01 Precast Concrete: Exterior Wall Skin* Pre-cast concrete panels with an exposed aggregate finish are provided along upper elevations on the school's south, east and west ends. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 B2010.01.02.01 Brick Masonry: Ext. Wall Skin* A clay brick veneer is provided on the lower portions of each building elevation, and all sides of the gymnasium at the northeast corner of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Repoint Brick Cladding (approx. 500 m2) Concern: Minor deterioration of mortar joints was observed in isolated areas on brick-clad surfaces during the assessment. No significant amount of damage to the brick was noted. Recommendation: Repoint damaged mortar joints as necessary on the school perimeter. Consequences of Deferral: Ongoing deterioration resulting in potential air and moisture infiltration into the building envelope. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $47,340 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 9 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2010.01.06.03 Metal Siding** [1966 and 1990] Pre-finished metal siding encloses the exercise room east of the main gymnasium. Roof-mounted mechanical penthouses are also enclosed with pre-finished metal siding. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 40 MAR-13 Repaint Metal Siding on Penthouses (approx. 1500 m2) Concern: The painted finish on the metal-clad penthouses on the roof of the school were observed to be peeling, or stained from the previous removal of graffiti. Recommendation: Repaint the metal siding on each penthouse on the roof of the building. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and potential exposure of unfinished surfaces to external elements. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $30,000 Damaged Metal Siding Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace 50m2 damaged siding and repaint 500 m2 metal siding on North side of exercise room. Concern: Metal siding on the north end of the exercise room has sustained minor impact damage. No perforations or tears as a result of this impact were observed during the assessment. Extensive paint peeling was observed. Recommendation: Replace 50m2 damaged portions of metal siding on the north end of the exercise room and peeling paint approximately 500m2 metal siding. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $16,500 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace Metal Siding (approx 2000 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $260,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 10 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2010.01.08 Cement Plaster (Stucco): Ext. Wall* - Exterior Canopies Exterior canopies on the south and east sides of the school have a painted plaster finish on structural concrete elements. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 APR-12 B2010.01.08 Cement Plaster (Stucco): Ext. Wall* - North Wall Panels Sections of stucco paneling finished to resemble adjacent pre-cast concrete panels are located on the north end of the building, next to the shop classrooms. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Replace Damaged Stucco (50 m2) Concern: The stucco finish on paneling located above shop classrooms on the north side of the building is worn and generally deteriorated. Reports of moisture ingress into the building in this area was not reported by site personnel as a result of the damaged stucco. Recommendation: Replace damaged stucco where necessary above shop classrooms on the north side of the building. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and potential moisture ingress into the building. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 High $3,500 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 11 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2010.01.11 Joint Sealers (caulking): Ext. Wall** Sealant is provided in construction joints, between cladding types and around window and door units on the school perimeter. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1985 20 MAR-13 Replace Deficient Sealant (approx. 2000 m) Concern: Sealant around window units and in construction joints was observed to be cracked, separated and non-pliable. Sealant between pre-cast concrete panels exhibited no major deficiencies. Recommendation: Replace deficient sealant around window units and in construction joints on the building perimeter. Consequences of Deferral: Potential air and/or moisture infiltration into the building envelope. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Low $61,016 Updated: MAR-13 B2010.01.13 Paints (& Stains): Ext. Wall** Plaster canopies and stucco wall panels have a paint finish. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 15 MAR-13 Repaint painted finish wall panel and canopies (400 m2) Concern: The existing paint on the exterior wall was observed to be dirty and wet. Recommendation: Repaint wall panels and canopies. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appearance and may lead to poor waterproofing of canopies and wall panels. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2014 Low $8,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 12 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2010.01.99 Other Exterior Wall Skin* - Wood Panels Painted wood panels are placed below each exterior window on the school perimeter. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Repaint Wood Panels (approx. 600 m2) Concern: Painted finishes on wood panels were observed to be worn or wearing thin, revealing exposed wood surfaces. Recommendation: Repaint wood panels below each exterior window on the south, east and west sides of the school. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and potential exposure of unfinished wood surfaces to external elements. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $12,624 Updated: MAR-13 B2010.02.03 Masonry Units: Ext. Wall Const.* Exterior back-up walls are generally comprised of load-bearing masonry block. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B2010.02.05 Wood Framing: Ext. Wall Const.* The exercise room east of the main gymnasium presumably has wood-framed exterior walls. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B2010.03 Exterior Wall Vapour Retarders, Air Barriers, and Insulation* Architectural drawings were not reviewed as part of the assessment; however it is assumed that the exterior wall assemblies of the school are equipped with a vapor retarder and insulation. The type and extent of materials used in the exterior wall assemblies are unknown. Based on this vintage of school, an air barrier was likely not included as part of the wall assembly. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 B2010.06 Exterior Louvers, Grilles, and Screens* Pre-finished metal louvers are situated on the perimeter of mechanical penthouses on the roof level. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 13 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2010.09 Exterior Soffits* Recessed entrances on the school perimeter are equipped with soffits clad with pre-finished metal. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 B2020.01.01.02 Aluminum Windows (Glass & Frame)** - 1966 Section All exterior windows on the school perimeter are comprised of both fixed and operable, unsealed double-glazed units set in aluminum frames. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 MAR-13 Replace Exterior Windows (approx. 56) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $64,803 Updated: MAR-13 B2020.01.01.02 Aluminum Windows (Glass & Frame)** - 1979 Section All exterior windows on the school perimeter are comprised of both fixed and operable, unsealed double-glazed units set in aluminum frames. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1979 40 APR-12 Replace aluminum windows (65 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2019 Unassigned $75,218 Updated: APR-12 B2020.01.01.02 Aluminum Windows (Glass & Frame)** - 2001 Section All exterior windows on the school perimeter are comprised of both fixed and operable, unsealed double-glazed units set in aluminum frames. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 1985 40 APR-12 Replace aluminum windows( 28 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2025 Unassigned $32,402 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 14 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2020.01.01.02 Aluminum Windows (Glass & Frame)** - Clearstory Windows (Above Library) Aluminum clearstory windows above the school library. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 40 MAR-13 Replace Failed Windows (approx. 25) Concern: Seals on several exterior windows were noted to have failed, most noticeably on clearstory windows above the school library. Recommendation: Replace the failed window units. Consequences of Deferral: Potential air infiltration into the building or heat loss during winter seasons. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Medium $28,930 Updated: MAR-13 B2030.01.01 Aluminum-Framed Storefronts: Doors** The main entrance on the east end of the building, and a southwest corner entrance have aluminum-framed pivot doors with sealed glazing units. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2000 30 MAR-13 Replace aluminum storefront doors (2 entrances) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2030 Unassigned $18,936 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 15 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B2030.01.10 Wood Entrance Door** - 1966 Section The remaining student entry doors on the building perimeter, including secondary exit and service doors, are comprised of painted wood set in painted wood frames. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace Wood Entrance Doors ( 25 units) Concern: Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $30,245 Updated: APR-12 B2030.03 Large Exterior Special Doors (Overhead)* A total of ten manual chain-driven overhead doors are provided on the north end of the building. All overhead doors consist of insulated sectional metal with glazed inserts. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 0 0 JAN-07 B3010.02.01.01 Asphalt Shingles** Asphalt shingles are provided on the sloped sections of roof on the exercise room east of the main gymnasium. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 25 MAR-13 Replace asphalt shingle roofing (600 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $28,000 Updated: MAR-13 B3010.04.04 Modified Bituminous Membrane Roofing (SBS)** A modified bitumen membrane assembly has been installed on the flat roof of the school throughout 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008 and 2011, totalling 16,428m2. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2004 25 APR-12 Replace 2ply SBS roofing(16,428 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2029 Unassigned $2,893,000 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 16 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B3010.08.02 Metal Gutters and Downspouts** Mechanical penthouse roofs are sloped to direct storm water to metal downspouts which discharge onto lower level flat roof sections. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Penthouse Eavestroughs and Downspouts (220 m) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $5,800 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 17 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B3010.11 Roof Covering Other* - Copings Pre-finished metal copings generally enclose each flat roof section. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Add Metal Copings (100 m) Concern: Metal copings are missing from a section of parapet wall near the east end of the school. No significant amount of deterioration of pre-cast concrete panels was observed as a result of the missing coping. Recommendation: Install metal copings where missing on parapet walls near the east end of the school. Consequences of Deferral: Ongoing deterioration of exposed horizontal surfaces of precast concrete, and potential moisture infiltration into the building envelope. Type Year Cost Priority Preventative Maintenance 2012 Medium $6,312 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Reseal and repaint metal copings (approx 500 m) Concern: Metal copings on the perimeters of flat roof sections had peeling and flaking finishes. Sealant between each section of metal coping has also failed. Recommendation: Repaint metal copings and replace deficient sealant between coping joints as necessary. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and ongoing deterioration, potentially resulting in additional damage from exposure to external elements. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $10,520 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 18 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) B3020.01 Skylights** Approximately 34 skylights are distributed above classrooms at the centre and northeast corners of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 25 MAR-13 Repair Leak in Art Room Skylight (1 unit) Concern: Site personnel reported a minor leak through a skylight into the art room near the northeast corner of the school. Recommendation: Repair the skylight leak. Consequences of Deferral: Ongoing moisture infiltration into the building. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Medium $1,000 Crack in Skylight Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace Skylights (34 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $110,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 19 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S3 INTERIOR C1010.01 Interior Fixed Partitions* Interior fixed partitions are typically comprised of painted masonry block walls or painted gypsum board. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Replace Storage Area Partitions (approx. 500 m2) Concern: Wood-frame partition walls with chain-link mesh sheathing are provided on the lower floor of the school to enclose a storage area. The exposed wood framing is considered a fire hazard. Recommendation: Replace the wood-framed enclosure with a drywall enclosure which would extend to the underside of the floor soffit above. Consequences of Deferral: The current configuration posses a potential fire hazard for the school. Type Year Cost Priority Code Repair 2012 Medium $34,643 Updated: MAR-13 C1010.03 Interior Operable Folding Panel Partitions** Operable folding panel partitions are provided in the cafeteria, library, both main and ancillary gymnasiums, the theatre seating area and the weight room overlooking the main gymnasium. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Folding Panel Partitions (6 partitions, approx. 120 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $138,864 Updated: MAR-13 C1010.05 Interior Windows* Interior windows provided in corridors or administrative areas are single-glazed and set in metal or wood frames. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 20 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C1010.07 Interior Partition Firestopping* Minor damages or gaps in interior partitions were observed. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Repair Partition Firestopping Concern: Minor damage or gaps in interior partition walls was observed during the site visit, including unsealed voids around fire wall penetrations. Recommendation: Repair gaps and seal around voids in fire walls as necessary. Consequences of Deferral: Possible fire hazard and clear passage for the migration of smoke and/or flame in the event of an emergency. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Medium $12,471 Penetrations - Firestopping Updated: MAR-13 C1020.01 Interior Swinging Doors (& Hardware)* Interior doors on classrooms generally consists of solid core wood doors with standard door knob hardware. The doors are set in painted wood frames. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 21 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C1020.03 Interior Fire Doors* Interior fire doors in corridors and stairwells consist of solid core wood set in painted metal frames. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Replace Interior Fire Doors (approx. 100) Concern: Interior fire doors in corridors and stairwells are original to the construction of the building and were without fire rating labels on both door and frame. The majority of the doors have also sustained considerable damage from prolonged and excessive use. Recommendation: Replace the fire doors. Consequences of Deferral: Non-compliance with fire code regulations, and ongoing deterioration resulting in increased repair and maintenance costs. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Medium $95,000 Updated: MAR-13 C1020.04 Interior Sliding and Folding Doors* Metal roll-up or sliding doors separate the kitchen area from a classroom at the southeast corner of the school, and a classroom from the library at the centre of the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 2000 0 APR-12 C1030.01 Visual Display Boards** - Blackboards Blackboards (both fixed and operable) are generally provided in each classroom and shop area. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 20 MAR-13 Replace Blackboards (120) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $54,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 22 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C1030.01 Visual Display Boards** - Whiteboards Whiteboards are provided in classrooms and shop areas. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2010 20 MAR-13 Replace Whiteboards (60) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2030 Unassigned $27,000 Updated: MAR-13 C1030.02 Fabricated Compartments (Toilets/Showers)** - Shower Partitions Showers include pre-finished metal partitions. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1985 30 MAR-13 Replace 4 Shower Stall Partitions Concern: Pre-finished metal shower partitions in the men's locker room have sustained considerable abuse and impact damage from students. Recommendation: Replace the men's shower stall partitions. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Medium $5,000 Updated: MAR-13 C1030.02 Fabricated Compartments (Toilets/Showers)** - Toilet Partitions Pre-finished metal toilet partitions are provided in each multi-student washroom in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1985 30 MAR-13 Replace Toilet Partitions (40 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $48,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 23 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C1030.06 Handrails* Base-mounted, painted metal handrails are provided along the open edge of mezzanines in shop classrooms, and along staircases throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 C1030.08 Interior Identifying Devices* Classroom and wayfinding signage was observed throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 MAR-13 C1030.10 Lockers** - 1966 Painted metal lockers for student use are provided in corridors, locker rooms and shop classrooms throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Original Lockers (40) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $18,000 Updated: MAR-13 C1030.10 Lockers** - 2010 Painted metal lockers for student use are provided in corridors, locker rooms and shop classrooms throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2010 30 MAR-13 Replace Lockers (1200) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2040 Unassigned $540,000 Updated: MAR-13 C1030.12 Storage Shelving* Operable (rolling) storage compartments of metal and wood fabrication for filing purposes are provided adjacent to the kitchen area. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 24 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C1030.14 Toilet, Bath, and Laundry Accessories* Accessories include mirrors, soap and paper dispensers. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 MAR-13 C2010 Stair Construction* The majority of the staircases in the building are constructed with cast-in-place concrete which presumably have conventional steel reinforcement. Steel staircases are provided in the library and in shop classrooms along the north end of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 C2020.01 Tile Stair Finishes* Main staircases leading from the various floors of the school are typically finished with quarry tile flooring. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 JAN-07 C2020.05 Resilient Stair Finishes** Staircases leading from the drama room adjacent to the theatre stage have rubber treads and risers. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 20 APR-12 Replace Resilient Stair Finishes (12 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $1,052 Updated: APR-12 C2020.06 Carpet Stair Finishes** Stairs in the library leading to the counseling area have carpeted steps. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 2000 10 MAR-13 Replace Carpet Stair Finishes (16 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $1,300 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 25 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C2020.08 Stair Railings and Balustrades* Stair railing and balustrades are observed installed and meet code requirement. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 APR-12 C2020.10 Stair Painting* Stairs in mechanical spaces typically have painted/sealed finishes. Metal stairs in the library have painted metal stringers, landings and handrails. Staircases leading to mezzanines in shop classrooms have painted stringers with exposed and unfinished metal grille treads. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1990 0 MAR-13 C3010.02 Wall Paneling** Acoustical wall paneling is provided in the theatre seating area at the east end of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2000 30 APR-12 Replace Acoustical Wall Panel (300 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2030 Unassigned $68,801 Updated: APR-12 C3010.06 Tile Wall Finishes** Ceramic tile wall finishes are provided in washrooms throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 APR-12 Replace Ceramic Tile Wall Finishes (925 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $231,440 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 26 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C3010.09 Acoustical Wall Treatment** Acoustical wall treatment is observed at music rooms. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1995 20 APR-12 Replace acoustic wall treatment (70m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $16,054 Updated: APR-12 C3010.11 Interior Wall Painting* - Concrete Walls Painted concrete or masonry block walls are located in corridors, mechanical spaces and several classrooms in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1990 0 MAR-13 Repaint Shop Classrooms (2500 m2) Concern: Painted masonry block walls in shop classrooms along the north end of the school were observed to have scuffed, scratched and worn finishes. Recommendation: Repaint the masonry block walls in the shop classrooms (approximately 2,500 square metres). Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Low $138,573 Updated: MAR-13 C3010.11 Interior Wall Painting* - Gypsum Board Walls Painted gypsum board walls are generally provided in office and meeting rooms, classrooms and several corridors. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 27 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C3020.01.02 Painted Concrete Floor Finishes* Painted concrete floors are provided in the main mechanical room. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1990 0 MAR-13 Repaint Concrete Floors (approx. 300 m2) Concern: Concrete floors in the main mechanical room and adjacent service rooms were noted to have worn finishes with deteriorated paint in high traffic areas. Recommendation: Repaint concrete floors in the main mechanical room and adjacent service rooms. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and potential exposure of unprotected concrete surfaces. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 Low $27,714 Updated: MAR-13 C3020.02 Tile Floor Finishes** Ceramic, granite and quarry tile flooring is provided in washrooms, the entrance vestibule at the main east entrance, and in the main kitchen area, respectively. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 50 APR-12 Replace Floor Tile ( 1300 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $218,816 Updated: APR-12 C3020.03 Terrazzo Floor Finishes* Terrazzo flooring is situated in the main entry corridor adjacent to the main east entrance and administration area. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 28 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C3020.04 Wood Flooring** Hardwood flooring is provided in the main and ancillary gymnasiums, the gymnasium stage, and various storage rooms adjacent to the gymnasiums. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1985 30 MAR-13 Refinish Gymnasium Stage Floor (approx. 300 m2) Concern: Hardwood flooring on the gymnasium stage was observed to be scuffed, scratched, and generally worn. Recommendation: Refinish the hardwood flooring on the gymnasium stage. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Low $21,000 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace Wood Flooring (1450 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $311,182 Updated: APR-12 C3020.07 Resilient Flooring** Vinyl tile flooring is provided in classrooms, corridors and meeting rooms throughout the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1985 20 APR-12 Replace Vinyl Tile Flooring (approx. 17000 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $912,084 Updated: APR-12 C3020.08 Carpet Flooring** Carpet flooring is provided in the library, theatre seating area and the staff administration area. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 15 APR-12 Replace Carpet Flooring (1750m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $93,891 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 29 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C3030.06 Acoustic Ceiling Treatment (Susp. T-Bar)** The majority of the classrooms, corridors and other office/meeting rooms have a suspended T-bar grid ceiling with in-laid acoustic panels. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 25 MAR-13 Replace Stained Ceiling Panels (approx. 200 m2) Concern: Several stained ceiling panels were observed in corridors and classrooms. The staining is presumably the result of former plumbing and/or roofing leaks. Recommendation: Replace the stained ceiling panels. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and potential for future air quality/environmental concerns (i.e., mould growth). Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2012 Medium $9,300 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace T-bar ceiling (approx. 23800 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $1,092,607 Updated: MAR-13 C3030.07 Interior Ceiling Painting* - Concrete Ceiling Exposed structural ceilings in shop classrooms, mechanical rooms and gymnasiums have a painted finish. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 30 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) C3030.07 Interior Ceiling Painting* - Gypsum Board Ceiling Painted gypsum board ceilings are provided in washrooms, entrance foyers/vestibules, and the kitchen area . Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor 1966 0 MAR-13 Event: Repaint men's shower room ceiling (approx. 50 m2) Concern: Peeling and flaking finishes were observed on the painted ceiling of the men's shower room, adjacent to the ancillary gymnasium. Recommendation: Repaint the shower room ceiling in the men's locker room. Type Year Cost Priority Repair 2013 Medium $1,100 Updated: MAR-13 C3030.09 Other Ceiling Finishes* - Acoustic Ceiling Tile Acoustic tile ceilings are typically provided in small office and meeting rooms throughout the building and at the top of stairwells. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 0 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 31 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D1010.01.02 Hydraulic Passenger Elevators** A single hydraulic passenger elevator provides access to the lower floor, main floor and second floor of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Refurbish and Modernize Hydraulic Elevator (1) Concern: Site personnel reported considerable down-time and mechanical problems associated with the hydraulic elevator servicing the school. Elevator controls and cab finishes also appeared to be original to the installation of the elevator in 1966. Recommendation: Upgrade elevator controls, cab finishes and other related equipment to improve the reliability and operational efficiency of the elevator. Cab control upgrades should also include panels to support barrier-free usage by handicapped persons. Consequences of Deferral: Additional down-time and increased maintenance and repair costs. Type Year Cost Priority Preventative Maintenance 2012 Medium $103,930 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Replace Hydraulic Elevator (1 Unit) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $207,859 Updated: APR-12 D1010.02 Lifts** Aboveground hydraulic lifts are provided in shop classrooms associated with vehicle repairs, painting, etc. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 25 APR-12 Replace lift (1 Unit) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $16,806 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 32 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S4 MECHANICAL D2010.04 Sinks** There are a number of miscellaneous sinks in the building. Sinks in the classrooms, staff room, and kitchen areas are typically stainless steel. The sinks in the janitor's rooms are iron and enamel. Sinks in bathrooms are enamel. Vitreous china hair wash sinks are provided in the cosmetology area. The majority of the sinks observed are original. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace sinks (80) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $119,370 Updated: APR-12 D2010.05 Showers** There are built-in multiple-stall showers (4-stalls divided by metal panels radiating from central stainless steel water supply pipe) in the main boys and girls change rooms. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace showers (6) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $12,763 Updated: APR-12 D2010.08 Drinking Fountains/Coolers** There are non-refrigerated vitreous china drinking fountains throughout the building. The building also has one stainless steel refrigerated drinking fountain on the second floor. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1980 35 APR-12 Replace Drinking Fountains (10) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $16,068 Updated: APR-12 D2010.09 Other Plumbing Fixtures* Emergency eye wash stations in chemical labs and industrial shops Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 33 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D2010.10 Washroom Fixtures (WC, Lav, Urnl)** - Floor Mounted Urinals There are floor-mounted vitreous china urinals throughout the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 APR-12 Replace urinals (45) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $72,311 Updated: APR-12 D2010.10 Washroom Fixtures (WC, Lav, Urnl)** - Tankless Water Closets There are tankless vitreous china water closets throughout the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 APR-12 Replace water closets (75) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $121,093 Updated: APR-12 D2010.10 Washroom Fixtures (WC, Lav, Urnl)** - Lavatories There are wall hung, vitreous china lavatories in washrooms throughout the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace lavatories (60) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $76,213 Updated: MAR-13 D2020.01.01 Pipes and Tubes: Domestic Water* Domestic water piping is copper throughout the building. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 34 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D2020.01.02 Valves: Domestic Water** Domestic Water and Shut off Valves Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 MAR-13 Replace Valves (150) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $86,790 Updated: MAR-13 D2020.01.03 Piping Specialties (Backflow Preventers)** There are backflow prevention devices on the domestic water supply (estimated 2002), fire protection riser (estimated 2002), humidification supply (estimated 2002), and the boiler feed water supply (estimated 1998). Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 2002 20 MAR-13 Replace Backflow Preventors - 4 Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2022 Unassigned $21,884 Updated: MAR-13 D2020.02.02 Plumbing Pumps: Domestic Water** Domestic water recirculation pumps serve various areas of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 1966 20 MAR-13 Replace Domestic Water Pumps (8) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $14,442 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 35 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D2020.02.06 Domestic Water Heaters** Hot Water is provided by three AO Smith Masterfit Storage Water Heaters Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2009 20 APR-12 Replace 3 Domestic Water Heaters Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2029 Unassigned $23,670 Updated: APR-12 D2020.03 Water Supply Insulation: Domestic* Domestic water pipe is insulated. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 MAR-13 D2030.01 Waste and Vent Piping* Waste and vent piping is generally cast iron and original to the construction of the building. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 D2030.02.04 Floor Drains* Floor drains in mechanical rooms, shower rooms, janitors rooms Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 MAR-13 D2040.01 Rain Water Drainage Piping Systems* Rain water drainage piping is generally cast iron and original to the building construction. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 D2040.02.04 Roof Drains* The roof incorporates roof drains which are each fitted with gravel/debris strainers. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 36 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3010.02 Gas Supply Systems* The natural gas supply is provided below grade on the west side of the building. The piping feeds the central heating boilers, hot water heaters and packaged rooftop units in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 MAR-13 D3020.01.01 Heating Boilers & Accessories: Steam** - Boilers Heating is provided by two Cleaver Brooks steam boilers (12,554 MBH each). Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace 2 steam boilers, 12554 MBH each Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $650,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3020.01.01 Heating Boilers & Accessories: Steam** - H.W. Storage Tanks Three heating hot water storage tanks are located in the boiler room. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2009 35 MAR-13 Replace heating hot water storage tanks (3) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2044 Unassigned $30,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3020.01.01 Heating Boilers & Accessories: Steam** - Heating Coils Heating Coils are provided for domestic hot water generation. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2010 35 MAR-13 Replace Heating Coils (2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2045 Unassigned $21,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 37 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3020.01.02 Feedwater Equipment* A resized condensate tank was installed in 2010. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 6 - Excellent 2010 0 MAR-13 D3020.02.02 Chimneys (& Comb. Air): H.W. Boiler** The boilers exhaust through a common chimney flue. Combustion air ducting is provided. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace boiler chimney and combustile air ducting (approx. 200m) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $136,760 Updated: MAR-13 D3020.02.03 Water Treatment: H. W. Boiler* Pot feeders for chemical treatment are connected to the boiler water supply piping Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 38 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3020.03.02 Chimneys (& Comb. Air): Furnace* - Incinerator There is a chimney for the incinerator that is no longer in service. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor 1966 0 MAR-13 Disused Rusted Chimney - Remove Event: Remove and Dispose of (1) Incinerator Chimney Concern: Chimney servicing the incinerator is no longer used and has been rusting for a number of years Recommendation: Remove and dispose of chimney and repair roof penetration. Consequences of Deferral: Possible leaks may occur if chimney continues to degrade Type Year Cost Priority Preventative Maintenance 2012 Low $15,780 Updated: MAR-13 D3030.06.02 Refrigerant Condensing Units** Air conditioning for the building is provided by a 22.5 ton York rooftop condensing unit. The condensing unit provides cooling to the three main air handling units located in the south mechanical penthouse. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2004 25 MAR-13 Capacity Size Capacity Unit 22.5 Ton N/A Replace (1) Rooftop Condensing Unit Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2029 Unassigned $68,380 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 39 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3040.01.01 Air Handling Units: Air Distribution** - Central Units Three central air handling units provide tempered ventilation air to the majority of the building. The units include a central common mixing chamber, humidification sections, heating and cooling coils. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Central AHUs (3) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $145,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3040.01.01 Air Handling Units: Air Distribution** - Gymnasium Unit A heating-only interior air handling unit provides tempered ventilation air to the main gymnasium. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace main gymnasium air handling unit (1) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $35,351 Updated: MAR-13 D3040.01.04 Ducts: Air Distribution* Painted galvanized sheet metal ductwork throughout building Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 40 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3040.01.06 Air Terminal Units: Air Distribution (VAV/CV Box)** Mixing chambers c/w heating and cooling coils are provided in each classroom. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace mixing chambers (approx. 100) Concern: The mixing chambers (hot deck systems) are failing and approximately half do not work, resulting in poor temperature control. These units are obsolete and replacement parts are no longer available. Recommendation: Replace the mixing chambers with new mixing boxes c/w heating/cooling coils. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2013 Medium $140,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3040.01.07 Air Outlets & Inlets: Air Distribution* Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1966 0 APR-12 D3040.02 Steam Distribution Systems: Piping/Pumps** Steam distribution is through original piping to converters, steam unit heaters and other terminal heating devices. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 APR-12 Replace Steam Distribution System (300m of Piping) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $62,358 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 41 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3040.03.01 Hot Water Distribution Systems** Heating distribution is through original piping to convectors, fan coils, and hot water unit heaters. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 APR-12 Replace heating hydronic distribution system(27,507m2 x $93.06) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $2,693,120 Updated: APR-12 D3040.03.04 Glycol Systems* Heated glycol is piped to air handling units in the mechanical penthouse. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Replace glycol buffer tank with larger tank (1) Concern: It was noted by site personnel during the property assessment that the school does not have a sufficient buffer for the glycol system, and a larger 250 gallon buffer tank will be required. Staff noted that there may be access issues when installing the larger tank which will increase the normal costs for this work. Recommendation: Replace the existing buffer tank with a larger, suitably sized tank. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2014 Medium $20,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3040.04.01 Fans: Exhaust** - General Building Exhaust General building exhaust (including washroom and kitchen areas) is provided by various roof mounted axial exhaust fans. The average estimated installation date of the observed exhaust fans is 1990. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 30 MAR-13 Replace exhaust fans to kitchen, washroom and service rooms (approx. 10) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2020 Unassigned $52,600 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 42 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3040.04.01 Fans: Exhaust** - Shop Areas Exhaust for the shop areas in the building is provided by a number of high volume roof mounted centrifugal exhaust fans. The average estimated installation date of the observed exhaust fans is 1990. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1990 30 APR-12 Replace Shop Area Exhaust Fans (10 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2020 Unassigned $58,912 Updated: APR-12 D3040.05 Heat Exchangers** Two shell and tube heat exchangers converts steam into heating hot water and heating glycol supplying the heating system in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace (2) heat exchangers Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $60,000 Updated: MAR-13 D3050.01.02 Packaged Rooftop Air Conditioning Units (& Heating Units)** A variety of natural gas fired rooftop make-up air units provide tempered air to the shop spaces on the north side of the building. Rooftop make-up air units are interlocked with the shop exhaust systems. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1985 30 MAR-13 Replace rooftop air conditioning units Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2029 Unassigned $140,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 43 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3050.05.01 Convectors** Primary heating is provided to perimeter classrooms, offices, and the gymnasiums by wall mounted convection heaters. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 APR-12 Replace convector heaters (100 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $72,693 Updated: APR-12 D3050.05.02 Fan Coil Units** Auxiliary heating at the majority of the building entrances is provided by recessed fan coil units. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace fan coil units (7 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $36,820 Updated: APR-12 D3050.05.06 Unit Heaters** Primary heating in utility rooms and stairwells by hot water heaters. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace unit heaters (9 units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $47,115 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 44 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D3060.02.02 Pneumatic Controls** The majority of the building controls are pneumatic and provide no energy management functions. Control air is provided by a Quincy compressor (installed in 2005) located in the boiler room. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 APR-12 Replace Pneumatic Controls (27,506 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $168,320 Updated: APR-12 D3060.02.05 Building Systems Controls (BMCS, EMCS)** A building management control system is present controlling boilers, central air handling units, and the cooling system. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2005 20 MAR-13 Replace BMCS (heating, cooling and ventilation units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2025 Unassigned $120,000 Updated: MAR-13 D4010 Sprinklers: Fire Protection* The automotive paint booth is protected by a wet-pipe sprinkler system. A recent upgrade included for additional sprinkler coverage to stairwells, Zone Z01 (944m2) and the Stage / Drama areas, including associated corridors. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 2009 0 APR-12 D4020 Standpipes* The building is equipped with a cast iron standpipe system complete with fire hoses throughout the building. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 D4030.01 Fire Extinguisher, Cabinets and Accessories* Fire extinguishers are located at fire hose stations and other locations throughout the building. Fire extinguishers have an estimated average installation date of 1990. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1990 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 45 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S5 ELECTRICAL D5010.02 Secondary Electrical Transformers (Interior)** Secondary transformers provide 120/208 Volt power to lighting and receptacles in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 40 MAR-13 Replace secondary transformers Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $32,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5010.03 Main Electrical Switchboards (Main Distribution)** The main electrical service is 2000 Amps, 277/480 Volts, 3 Phase. The main electrical switchgear was replaced in approximately 2004. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2004 40 MAR-13 Replace main electrical switchgear (1) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2044 Unassigned $157,800 Updated: MAR-13 D5010.05 Electrical Branch Circuit Panelboards (Secondary Distribution)** The majority of the electrical sub-panels in the building are original to the construction of the building. Observed panels had little to no spare capacity. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Secondary Distribution Panelboards (approx. 100) Concern: Electrical panels are well past their expected service life and replacement parts are not available. There is little to no spare capacity in the panels. Recommendation: Replace branch circuit panel boards. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of power due to electrical panel failure. Inability to accommodate additional electrical loads to meet future educational program requirements or changes. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2013 Low $500,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 46 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5010.07.01 Switchboards, Panelboards, and (Motor) Control Centers** Motor control center serves the fans, pumps, and emergency equipment in the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace motor control center Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $26,300 Updated: MAR-13 D5010.07.02 Motor Starters and Accessories** Individual motor starters are also provided for fans and pumps. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace motor starters Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $15,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5020.01 Electrical Branch Wiring* The building wiring is generally original, having been added as required. All wiring observed was in conduit. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 D5020.02.01 Lighting Accessories: Interior (Lighting Controls)* Lighting controls include line voltage and low voltage switching and were generally observed to be original. No major deficiencies were reported. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 MAR-13 Page 47 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5020.02.02.02 Interior Fluorescent Fixtures** - Basement Interior lighting in the basement is provided by fluorescent fixtures using T12 technology. Fluorescent lighting was installed in approximately 1970. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1970 30 MAR-13 Replace basement fluorescent lighting (1400 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $125,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5020.02.02.02 Interior Fluorescent Fixtures** - Main & 2nd Floors Interior lighting on the first and second floors is provided by fluorescent fixtures using T8 technology. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 6 - Excellent Event: 2005 30 MAR-13 Replace Main & Second Floor Interior Fluorescent Fixtures (24,100 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2035 Unassigned $2,155,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5020.02.02.04 Interior H.P. Sodium Fixtures* Interior lighting in the main gym is provided by sodium lighting fixtures. Rating 5 - Good Installed Design Life Updated 2000 0 APR-12 D5020.02.02.05 Other Interior Fixtures* Interior lighting in the shop areas is provided by suspended high-bay mercury vapour fixtures. Rating 5 - Good Installed Design Life Updated 1985 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 48 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5020.02.03.02 Emergency Lighting Battery Packs** Building emergency lighting is provided by incandescent lamps powered by battery packs. Emergency lighting was installed in approximately 1995. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1995 20 MAR-13 Replace emergency lighting battery packs (approx.100) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $120,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5020.02.03.03 Exit Signs* Incandescent exit signs were observed at corridors and entrances. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 MAR-13 D5020.02.10 Theatrical Lighting* Stage lighting is provided in the Gym. Rating 5 - Good Installed Design Life Updated 1990 0 MAR-13 D5020.03.01.04 Exterior H.P. Sodium Fixtures* Exterior lighting around the building is provided by a mixture of wall- and soffit-mounted high pressure sodium fixtures. Rating 5 - Good Installed Design Life Updated 2000 0 JAN-07 D5020.03.02 Lighting Accessories: Exterior (Lighting Controls)* Photocells control exterior lighting. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 2000 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 MAR-13 Page 49 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5030.01 Detection and Fire Alarm** The building has manual pull stations, heat detectors, and smoke detectors connected to a monitored Pyrotronics Cerberus fire alarm panel which controls fire alarm bells throughout the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 1996 25 MAR-13 Replace Fire Alarm system (27,506 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2021 Unassigned $842,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5030.02.02 Intrusion Detection** The building is equipped with a Silent Knight security system, complete with motion detectors throughout the building. The system is externally monitored. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2000 25 MAR-13 Replace Security System (27,506 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2025 Unassigned $800,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5030.02.04 Video Surveillance** Video surveillance devices are provided in some locations. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 25 MAR-13 Replace 1 Video Surveillance System Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $31,560 Updated: MAR-13 D5030.03 Clock and Program Systems* The building is equipped with a Simplex 2350 Master Time System that controls the bells. Clocks observed in the classrooms were not part of the system. The master clock was installed in approximately 1980. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1980 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 APR-12 Page 50 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5030.04.01 Telephone Systems* The building is equipped with a Nortel Meridian telephone system. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 1986 0 JAN-07 D5030.04.04 Data Systems* The building is serviced by a Bell fiberoptic internet system. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good 2002 0 JAN-07 D5030.04.05 Local Area Network Systems* The computer system on-site has Category 5 data wiring throughout the building. The building also contains wireless local area network antennas. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good 2000 0 MAR-13 D5030.05 Public Address and Music Systems** The building is equipped with a custom PA system. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1989 20 MAR-13 Replace Public Address and Music Systems (27,506 m2) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $75,000 Updated: MAR-13 D5030.06 Television Systems* The building is equipped with a coaxial cable TV system. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 MAR-13 Page 51 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) D5090.02 Packaged Engine Generator Systems (Emergency Power System)** A 40 kW Kohler natural gas fired emergency generator provides power for the emergency lighting, exit lights, and fire alarm system in the building. The transfer switch was replaced in 2005. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace emergency generator (1) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $52,600 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 52 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S6 EQUIPMENT, FURNISHINGS AND SPECIAL CONSTRUCTION E1020.02 Library Equipment* Book scanners are observed at library entrance. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1990 0 APR-12 E1020.03 Theatre and Stage Equipment* Stage lighting and controls, manually-operated folding curtains and drapes are provided on the theatre stage and main gymnasium stage. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 APR-12 E1020.05 Audiovisual Equipment* Pull-down overhead projection screens are typically provided in each classroom. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1990 0 APR-12 E1020.07 Laboratory Equipment* Lab equipment is observed at school lab room. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1990 0 APR-12 E1030.01 Vehicle Service Equipment* A drive-in vehicle paint booth is located in a shop classroom situated on the north end of the school. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 53 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) E1030.03 Loading Dock Equipment* Loading dock is equipped with heavy timber bumpers Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Replace loading dock bumpers Concern: Timber bumpers have degraded and failed due to age, water ingress and wear. Recommendation: Replace timber load dock bumpers. Consequences of Deferral: It may lead to an unsafe working situation / building damage if not replaced. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2012 High $5,260 Updated: MAR-13 E1090.03 Food Service Equipment* Food preparation equipment, including commercial-grade stoves, ovens, dish washers, fume hoods and preparation tables, are located in the kitchen area at the southeast corner of the school. The majority of this equipment has a commercial quality stainless steel finish. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 E1090.04 Residential Equipment* Residential-type equipment used in the building includes refrigerators, stoves and dish washers, washing machines and dryers in the teachers lounge and home economics classrooms. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 JAN-07 E1090.07 Athletic, Recreational, and Therapeutic Equipment* Operable (folding) basketball equipment is provided in the main and ancillary gymnasiums which is mounted to the ceiling. A wall-mounted, electronic scoreboard is also provided in the main gymnasium. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 54 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) E2010.02 Fixed Casework** - Classrooms & Shop Areas Fixed wooden casework with laminated finishes are typically provided in each classroom and shop area in the school. The vintage of the casework varies from the construction of the original portion of the school in 1966. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace Casework (approx. 30 classrooms) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $207,859 Updated: MAR-13 E2010.02 Fixed Casework** - Kitchen Cabinets Original wood kitchen cabinets are provided in the food science area. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1966 35 MAR-13 Replace the kitchen cabinets (approx. 20 m) Concern: Wood cabinets in the food science area are worn and deteriorated. They also do not fit the updated layout being planned for the food science classroom. Recommendation: Replace kitchen cabinets with proper configuration to meet requirements of revised food science area layout. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2013 Medium $32,000 Updated: MAR-13 E2010.03.01 Blinds** Operable blinds are provided between window glazing or mounted on ceilings in front of windows, typically in each classroom and office area. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 APR-12 Replace Operable Blinds (180 Units) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $37,872 Updated: APR-12 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 55 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) E2010.05 Fixed Multiple Seating** Fixed multiple seating is provided in the theatre area at the east end of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 5 - Good Event: 2003 35 APR-12 Replace multiple seating in theatre (320) Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2038 Unassigned $117,824 Updated: APR-12 F1010.02.05 Grandstands and Bleachers** Folding (retractable) metal bleachers are provided on the mezzanine overlooking the main gymnasium. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable Event: 1966 30 MAR-13 Replace Metal Bleachers Type Year Cost Priority Lifecycle Replacement 2016 Unassigned $30,000 Updated: MAR-13 F1020.03 Other Integrated Construction* There are 15 units welding booths in the welding shop classroom at the north end of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 1996 0 MAR-13 Replace Welding Booths (approx. 15) Concern: Welding booths were observed to have sustained excessive damage, including perforations and considerable damage to finished surfaces. Recommendation: Replace the welding booths in the shop classroom at the north end of the school. Consequences of Deferral: Loss of aesthetic appeal and poor protection from welding activities. Type Year Cost Priority Failure Replacement 2014 Low $23,670 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 56 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) S8 SPECIAL ASSESSMENT K4010.01 Barrier Free Route: Parking to Entrance* Handicapped parking stalls, complete with base-mounted pole signage, is provided in the staff parking lot east of the school. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Add 12 Handicapped Parking Stalls Concern: No handicapped parking stalls are provided in the student parking lot to the west of the school. Furthermore, the two handicapped parking stalls in the teaching staff parking lot appeared to be insufficient in size. Recommendation: Add handicapped parking stalls, complete with signage, in the student parking lot west of the school. In addition, re-size the handicapped parking stalls in the teaching staff parking lot east of the building. The re-distribution of adjacent parking stalls may be required. Consequences of Deferral: Non-conformance with current barrier-free standards and poor accessibility for handicapped persons. Type Year Cost Barrier Free Access Upgrade 2012 $6,312 Priority Medium Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 57 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) K4010.02 Barrier Free Entrances* No barrier-free entrances are provided on the perimeter of the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor Event: 1966 0 MAR-13 Install Barrier-Free Entrances (2 ramps & 4 automated door openers) Concern: Staircases are located at each entrance to the school which are closest to both the student and staff parking lots. Automated entry is also not provided at entrances to the building. Recommendation: Provide a ramp at the main (east) building entrance from the staff parking lot, and a ramp leading from the student parking lot to the southwest entrance of the school. Automated dooropeners should also be installed at these entrances on exterior and vestibule doors. Consequences of Deferral: Non-compliance with current barrier-free standards and poor accessibility for handicapped persons. Type Year Cost Barrier Free Access Upgrade 2012 $49,886 Priority Medium Updated: MAR-13 K4010.03 Barrier Free Interior Circulation* The school is equipped with an elevator which services a portion of the lower floor, main floor and second level of the building. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 2 - Poor 1966 Event: Install wheelchair lifts (2) 0 MAR-13 Concern: A portion of the school's lower floor in the area of the music room, and the theatre stage are not accessible to wheelchair users. Recommendation: Provide a wheelchair lift in a stairwell leading to the lower floor of the building in the area of the music room. An additional wheelchair lift is required to access the theatre stage. Consequences of Deferral: Non-compliance with current barrier-free standards and poor accessibility for handicapped persons. Type Year Cost Barrier Free Access Upgrade 2013 $33,257 Priority High Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 58 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) K4010.04 Barrier Free Washrooms* The school is equipped with a barrier-free accessible washroom. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 JAN-07 Page 59 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) K4020.03 Other Codes* A classroom is located on the main floor, immediately north of the space above the music room. This classroom was previously used as storage and currently presents a safety hazard for students due to the absence of a nearby means of egress (i.e., dead end). Rating Installed Design Life Updated 3 - Marginal Event: 0 0 MAR-13 Reconfigure Classroom Based On Study Recommendations Concern: A classroom is located on the main floor, immediately north of the space above the music room. This classroom was previously used as storage and currently presents a safety hazard for students due to the absence of a nearby means of egress (i.e., dead end). Recommendation: Based on the findings of the Study, reconfigure the classroom, if feasible, to meet code requirements. An allowance to complete the reconfiguration provided. Consequences of Deferral: In its present location and configuration, the classroom represents a potential safety hazard for students and teaching staff. Type Year Cost Priority Code Repair 2012 Medium $40,000 Updated: MAR-13 Event: Study Classroom Location Concern: A classroom is located on the main floor, immediately north of the space above the music room. This classroom was previously used as storage and currently presents a safety hazard for students due to the absence of a nearby means of egress (i.e., dead end). Recommendation: A study should be conducted to determine whether the use of this space as a classroom is feasible and recommend needed reconfiguration to meet code, or whether it should be abandoned completely. Consequences of Deferral: Potential safety hazard for students and staff occupying this space. Type Year Cost Priority Study 2012 Medium $7,000 Updated: MAR-13 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM Page 60 of 61 Calgary - Lord Beaverbrook High School (B2705A) K4030.01 Asbestos* Suspected asbestos-containing materials identified within the building include drywall joint compound, mechanical pipe insulation, pipe elbows, and acoustic ceiling tile. Materials appear to be well controlled and managed. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 APR-12 K4030.02 PCBs* Equipment suspected to contain PCBs include original light ballasts, transformers and other miscellaneous electrical equipment. Rating Installed Design Life Updated 4 - Acceptable 0 0 JAN-07 K4030.04 Mould* No visible signs of suspected mould growth were observed or reported in the building during the site visit. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 1966 0 APR-12 K5010.01 Site Documentation* No site plan was reviewed during this assessment. Assessor: Gary Bowen, Altus Group Evaluation Date: Sept. 13, 2011. Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 2011 0 MAR-13 K5010.02 Building Documentation* No floor plans were reviewed during this assessment. Assessor: Gary Bowen, Altus Group Evaluation Date: Sept. 13, 2011 Rating 4 - Acceptable Installed Design Life Updated 2011 Report run on: March 21, 2013 10:03 AM 0 MAR-13 Page 61 of 61