LEADER’S DISCUSSION GUIDE: The Kite Runner A universal tale of betrayal and redemption. In the particular one finds the universal. In the film The Kite Runner by Golden Globe–nominated nominated director Marc Forster, viewers are thrust into the world of 1970s Kabul, Afghanistan, in all its vibrancy and cross cross-cultural cultural glory, as well as the dismal and war war-torn torn Kabul of 2000. Based on the bestbest selling novel of the same nam name, the film is a faithful re-creation of the world and characters first envisioned by Afghan author Khaled Hosseini. The story hinges on a boyhood friendship torn asunder by an act of betrayal, which leads to one man’s journey to right the wrongs of his past. pa The Kite Runner is a modern fable that explores timely issues such as how class divisions and ethnic differences affect relationships, as well as the role of religion in individual lives and society. Further, the film is shot through with timeless them themes es that transcend the particularity of its setting. This study is designed to help you delve into a few of these themes, such as loyalty and sacrifice vs. betrayal, telling the truth vs. keeping secrets, and sin and guilt vs. redemption. Based on: The Kite Runner (Dreamworks,, Sidney Kimmel Entertainment, Participant Productions, 2007), directed by Marc Forster, screenplay by David Benioff. Rated PG-13. C HRISTIANITY T ODAY I N T E R N A T I O N A L © 2007 Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 2 Movie Summary The film opens with Amir and his wife Soraya watching kite flyers in a park in San Francisco,, circa 2000. Upon arriving home, the happy couple finds boxes of Amir’s novel, A Season for Ashes. A long-distance distance phone call cuts in on their celebration, and Amir finds himself talking to Rahim Kahn, a close friend of his father, Baba. Rahim asks Amir tto o come home and promises him that “there is a way to be good again.” The film flashes back to Amir’s childhood in Kabul, Afghanistan, 1978. Children are kite fighting, a national Afghan pastime. Amir’s friend and servant Hassan sets off to “run” a kite thatt has fallen, with Amir following behind. Soon thereafter, Baba tells Rahim Khan that he is concerned that Amir doesn’t stand up for himself. Amir overhears this discussion, and thus the relationship between Amir and Baba is strained. While Baba doesn’t always ways understand or appreciate his son, Rahim Kahn encourages Amir to develop his story-telling ability. The strong friendship of Amir and Hassan is highlighted as the boys watch Western movies at the cinema and as they sit under a pomegranate tree, Amir re reading ading epic Persian tales to Hassan. Hassan also boldly defends Amir against the local bully, Assef, a bigot and a misguided nationalist even at a young age. Soon Amir wins the annual kite kite-fighting tournament, and Hassan runs the loser’s kite for him. When Amir goes looking for Hassan, he finds him cornered by Assef and his cronies. When Hassan refuses to give up the kite, Assef rapes him; Amir watches and does nothing, then runs away. The relationship between the boys becomes painfully strained as Amir is o overwhelmed verwhelmed with guilt. When Amir makes it look as though Hassan has stolen his watch, Hassan does not give him away. Hassan’s father, Ali, tells Baba that they are leaving, despite Baba’s insistence that all is forgiven. When the Soviets invade Kabul, Baba and Amir escape in a tarpaulin-covered covered truck with other refugees. Then the movies flashes forward to Fremont, CA, 1988, with Baba on his way to Amir’s community college graduation. Baba and Amir soon become a regular presence at the local flea market, where ere they hawk their wares alongside other Afghans such as General Sahib and his daughter Soraya. Amir falls in love with Soraya, and shortly thereafter Baba is diagnosed with terminal cancer. Eventually, Amir asks Baba to approach General Sahib, who acceptss the marriage proposal, and Soraya tells Amir about her checkered past. After their marriage, Baba dies, and the movie returns to the opening phone call. Amir decides to go to Pakistan, where Rahim Kahn tells him about Hassan and his wife, and how they were re killed by the Taliban. Rahim also unveils the secret that Baba is Hassan’s father, not Ali, and that Hassan’s son Sohrab is still alive. Amir sets off to rescue Sohrab, which leads to a violent confrontation with the adult Assef. Amir and Sohrab escape and return to America, where their life together with Soraya now begins. —For For more coverage of The Kite Runner,, see Peter Chattaway’s review on www.christianitytoday.com/movies Rated PG-13 The film is rated PG-13. 13. It includes a rape scene involving a child, which is very discreetly done yet disturbing nonetheless. Violence also includes a stoning and a bloody fight scene. 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 3 Discussing the Scenes Select one or more of these themes to discuss: 1. 2. 3. Loyalty and sacrifice acrifice vs. betrayal Telling the truth vs. keeping secrets Sin and guilt vs. redemption 1. Loyalty and sacrifice vs. betrayal (Philippians 2:1–11; 11; John 15:13; Matthew 6:14 6:14–15) The Kite Runner revolves around powerful contrasts, with different characters’ true natures revealing themselves or being revealed throughout the course of the film. Perhaps none of the contrasts is more powerfully portrayed than that of loyalty vs. betrayal in friendships, especially ially in the case of Amir and Hassan, but also in the friendship of Baba and Ali. Scenes to Watch: Amir and Hassan waiting for the kite; Amir and Hassan at the movies; Amir and Hassan facing Assef and his friends The friendships of childhood can have an aalmost lmost magical quality, as imaginary games intermingle with fantastic real-life life adventures. Yet Amir and Hassan’s friendship is fraught with differences: Amir is a Pashtun, Hassan a Hazara. Amir has been born into the elite class, Hassan into the servant class. ass. While equality may not have been a thing to be grasped, the boys nevertheless forge a deep bond as they grow up together in Kabul. [Q] In the film’s opening sequence, Hassan takes off to run down a kite, with Amir trailing significantly behind him. As they wait for the kite to fall, an uncomfortable exchange takes place concerning Hassan’s sincerity and loyalty. How is the inequality in the boys’ status made clear by their external appearance? How does Amir’s condescension and Hassan’s deference come tthrough hrough in each of the boys’ comments? [Q] Both Amir and Hassan are captivated by American westerns in general and Steve McQueen in particular. Why do you think the boys love these films? [Q] On their way home through the market, Amir wraps his arm around H Hassan, assan, which seems to establish their status as pals. Yet how does Amir’s reaction differ from Hassan’s when they are confronted by Assef and his friends? What do we learn about Amir’s and Hassan’s character from this scene? Read Philippians 2:1–11. [Q] Paul aul instructs the believers at Philippi to be united in love, remain humble, and focus on the needs of others. How do Hassan’s actions illustrate Paul’s commands? As believers, what should our motivation for following these commands be? [Q] Paul also encourages rages the believers to imitate Christ in their attitudes and lives. In what ways does Hassan resemble Christ? In what ways does he differ? 1 Scene to Watch: Assef and his cronies corner Hassan; Amir watches Assef rape Hassan and does nothing © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 4 In the most pivotal tal scene of the film, Hassan chooses to remain loyal to his friend Amir despite the unthinkable cost. Meanwhile, Amir betrays his friend Hassan, caving in to cowardice. [Q] How much truth is there in Assef’s accusatory speech? [Q] Why do you think Hassan makes this sacrifice? [Q] Amir knows that his father will be doubly proud if he brings home the loser’s blue kite in addition to winning the kite kite-fighting fighting tournament. How does Amir’s relationship with his father influence his behavior? [Q] How does this scene ene reveal what’s truly important to each of the boys? The relationship between love and sacrifice is a consistent theme in story and in Scripture. On the same night that he was betrayed, Jesus told his followers how much he loves them. Read John 15:13. [Q] How willing would you be to sacrifice yourself yourself—your your reputation, your body, your status, or your life—for for someone else, if you knew that you would be betrayed by that person soon after? What does that say about Christ’s sacrificial love for you? Scene to Watch: Amir reading Hassan’s letter [Q] While Amir sits at an outdoor café to read Hassan’s letter, a cart filled with pomegranates crashes behind him, reminiscent of the pomegranate that Hassan smashed on his forehead when they were boys. What do you thin think k Hassan meant by that gesture? [Q] Why has Hassan written a letter to Amir? [Q] Hassan concludes his letter, “You’ll find a faithful friend waiting for you always.” How does this letter spur Amir to action? Read Matthew 6:14–15. [Q] How do we know that Hassan ssan has forgiven Amir? [Q] Why do these verses compel us to forgive, even when it means forgiving people who have wounded us deeply? 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 5 2. Telling the truth vs. keeping secrets (Genesis 12:10–20; John 8:31 1–38; 1 John 4:18) Secrets can be buried, but that doesn’t mean that they won’t continue to exert an influence one way or another. Sometimes we are tempted to believe that it will be easier for us if we avoid telling the truth, but that concept itself is a lie. Maintaining a deception is generally much harder than facing the consequences of the truth in the first place. Scene to Watch: Rahim Kahn unveils a lifelong secret to Amir Amir—that that Baba is actually Hassan’s father, not the sterile Ali [Q] What circumstances nces cause Rahim Kahn to reveal this secret at last? How do you think this secret impacted Rahim and Baba’s friendship? [Q] What is Amir’s reaction? [Q] How was Baba’s relationship with Ali similar to Amir’s relationship with Hassan? Leader’s Note: In thee novel, Rahim reminds Amir of the cultural context of Baba’s decision: “Please think, Amir jan. It was a shameful situation. People would talk. All that a man had back then, all that he was, was his honor, his name, and if people talked . . .. We couldn’t tell anyone, surely you can see that.” [Q] Given the nature of Afghan culture at the time, why do you think Baba chose to keep this secret from both Amir and Hassan? How do you think this secret affected his relationship with each of the boys? Prior to receiving eceiving God’s covenant, Abram indulged in some deception of his own. Read Genesis 12:10–20. [Q] What lie did Abram suggest to Sarai? [Q] What reasons did Abram give for attempting this deception? [Q] What does this story suggest about the relationship bbetween etween fear and deception? Understanding this, how might deception be avoided? Scene to Watch: Soraya and Amir go for a chaperoned walk so Soraya can reveal her past to Amir prior to their marriage [Q] Soraya tells Amir, “I don’t want us to start with sec secrets.” rets.” What do we learn about Soraya from this interaction? How does she differ from Amir? [Q] Why doesn’t Amir condemn her? [Q] Why do you think that Amir withholds his own secret at this moment? Truth and freedom are directly related. Look at John 8:31 8:31–38. 1 [Q] Who is Jesus addressing in this passage? © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 6 [Q] What is the truth Jesus is asking them to believe? [Q] What freedom does Jesus the Son offer? [Q] How does believing the truth of God’s Word liberate us? How does telling the truth in our lives also liberate us? Scene to Watch: Amir and Soraya at the dinner table with General Sahib and his wife [Q] How might General Sahib’s dislike of Amir’s career choice choice—as as evidenced by his throwing out Amir’s manuscript at the flea market market—suggest that he is a man concerned with appearances? [Q] What is General Sahib worried about in this scene? [Q] How does Amir’s response reveal his personal growth? Fear and love are also intimately related. Read 1 John 4:18. [Q] How has Amir grown in love? [Q] How can we grow in love? 3. Sin and guilt vs. redemption (2 Corinthians 7:10–11; 11; Psalm 38:3 38:3–8; Luke 19:1–9; 9; Proverbs 11:17, 19, 21; Ephesians 1:3–8) Perhaps Amir’s story resonates so strongly with audi audiences ences because it is the story of fallen humanity, of struggling to overcome sin and do the right thing, even when it’s difficult. While ultimately our sin is taken away through Christ’s sacrifice, we all long for redemption in the here and now. Scene to Watch: tch: Rahim talks to Amir in his bedroom [Q] From an early age, Amir is plagued with guilt. In this scene, he feels guilty because he sees himself as responsible for his mother’s death. What does Amir believe his father feels toward him? [Q] How does Rahim Kahn respond? Do you think Amir believes him? [Q] Have you ever felt wrongly responsible for something? How did you get over your false guilt? Read 2 Corinthians 7:10–11. [Q] What is the difference between “godly sorrow” and “worldly sorrow”? 1 [Q] What are the results of godly sorrow? © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 7 [Q] Do you ever assess your sorrows to see which ones are truly godly? Scene to Watch: Amir returns home from the tournament [Q] In contrast to the smiling cheering boy who won the kite kite-fighting fighting tournament with Hassan, Amir now appears quiet and withdrawn when he enters with the blue kite. How do you think Baba’s wide smile and praise exacerbate Amir’s feelings? [Q] What does the expression on Amir’s face as he’s crushed in Baba’s embrace tell you? [Q] What is the effect of Amir’s mir’s secret on his relationship with his father? Guilt is an experience common to all. Read Psalm 38:3 38:3–8. [Q] David is overwhelmed by the weight of his sin. What does this passage suggest about the possible connection between spiritual and physical health? [Q] Why might unabated guilt drive a person to desperate measures? Scenes to Watch: Rahim Kahn’s phone call to Amir at the start of the film; the continuation of their conversation later in the film [Q] Why does Rahim tell Amir “there is a way to be good again”? [Q] How does Amir initially respond? [Q] Rahim continues, “It will not be easy. But you must come.” How is this a fitting description of the redemption process? [Q] What motivates Amir to return to Afghanistan? Read Luke 19:1–9. [Q] Why is Jesus’ behavior toward the tax collector considered revolutionary? [Q] How does Zacchaeus respond to Jesus’ invitation? [Q] What is the relationship between repentance and good works? Scene to Watch: Amir confronts Assef and demands that he release Sohrab [Q] How is Assef’s cruelty demonstrated in this scene? [Q] Though no doubt scared out of his mind, Amir stands his ground, even when Assef reveals his identity. What is the source of Amir’s strength? Q] Assef taunts Amir, saying aying “Run away; that’s what you do best.” Instead, how does 1 Amir respond? © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 8 [Q] How does this scene further Amir’s redemption? [Q] Does Sohrab’s shooting Assef with his slingshot provide a sense of justice? Why or why not? Read Proverbs 11:17, 19, 21. [Q] According ccording to these verses, what happens to those who are cruel and do evil? [Q] What are the benefits of being kind and righteous? [Q] Is this how the world works? If so, how? If not, what do these verses mean? Scene to Watch: Amir and Sohrab engage in a ki kite fight in the park [Q] What does this scene suggest about the quality of Amir and Sohrab’s relationship at this point? [Q] How does the kite-fighting fighting scene here resemble the tournament in Kabul? [Q] When Amir succeeds in cutting the boy’s kite, he asks Sohrab if he wants him to run the kite for him. When Sohrab gives him a hint of a smile, Amir cries out, “For you a thousand times over!” Is this a satisfying conclusion to the film? Why or why not? Read Ephesians 1:3–8. [Q] According to this passage, when did God decide to redeem us? [Q] What did our redemption cost? [Q] What does our redemption in Christ mean? As the Credits Roll [Q] Redemption is one of those big theological terms like sanctification and justification. How can we convey these ideas to unbelievers in a way that is understandable? [Q] How might we take advantage of movies like The Kite Runner to illustrate biblical concepts? cepts? What is incomplete about the picture of redemption offered in this film? [Q] How do you see the transforming power of love in this story? How have you seen the transforming power of love in your own life? [Q] How does the portrayal of Amir’s faith iinn Allah make you feel? What perceptions of God might an unbeliever glean from this film? 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – LEADER’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 9 [Q] Does this movie motivate you to live an obedient life, doing good to others? Why or why not? —Adrianna Adrianna Wright, a graduate of Wheaton College, works for InterVarsity Press. 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com PARTICIPANT’S DISCUSSION GUIDE: The Kite Runner A universal tale of betrayal and redemption. In the particular one finds the universal. In the film The Kite Runner by Golden Globe–nominated nominated director Marc Forster, viewers are thrust into the world of 1970s 0s Kabul, Afghanistan, in all its vibrancy and cross cross-cultural cultural glory, as well as the dismal and war war-torn torn Kabul of 2000. Based on the bestbest selling novel of the same name, the film is a faithful re re-creation of the world and characters first envisioned by Afgh Afghan an author Khaled Hosseini. The story hinges on a boyhood friendship torn asunder by an act of betrayal, which leads to one man’s journey to right the wrongs of his past. The Kite Runner is a modern fable that explores timely issues such as how class divisions ons and ethnic differences affect relationships, as well as the role of religion in individual lives and society. Further, the film is shot through with timeless themes that transcend the particularity of its setting. This study is designed to help you del delve ve into a few of these themes, such as loyalty and sacrifice vs. betrayal, telling the truth vs. keeping secrets, and sin and guilt vs. redemption. Based on: The Kite Runner (Dreamworks, Sidney Kimmel Entertainment, Participant Productions, 2007), directed by Marc Forster, screenplay by David Benioff. Rated PG-13. C HRISTIANITY T ODAY I N T E R N A T I O N A L © 2007 Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – PARTICIPANT’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 2 Movie Summary The film opens with Amir and his wife Soraya watching kite flyers in a park in San Francisco, circa 2000. Upon arriving home, the happy couple finds boxes of Amir’s novel, A Season for Ashes. A long-distance distance phone call cuts in on their celebration, and Amir finds himself talking to Rahim Kahn, a close friend of his father, Baba. Rahim asks Amir to come home and promises him that “there is a way to be good again.” The film flashes back to Amir’s childhood in Kabul, Afghanistan, 11978. 978. Children are kite fighting, a national Afghan pastime. Amir’s friend and servant Hassan sets off to “run” a kite that has fallen, with Amir following behind. Soon thereafter, Baba tells Rahim Khan that he is concerned that Amir doesn’t stand up for hi himself. Amir overhears this discussion, and thus the relationship between Amir and Baba is strained. While Baba doesn’t always understand or appreciate his son, Rahim Kahn encourages Amir to develop his story-telling ability. nd Hassan is highlighted as the boys watch Western movies The strong friendship of Amir and at the cinema and as they sit under a pomegranate tree, Amir reading epic Persian tales to Hassan. Hassan also boldly defends Amir against the local bully, Assef, a bigot and a misguided nationalist even at a young age. Soon Amir wins the annual kite kite-fighting tournament, and Hassan runs the loser’s kite for him. When Amir goes looking for Hassan, he finds him cornered by Assef and his cronies. When Hassan refuses to give up the kite, Assef rapes him; Amir watches and does nothing, then runs away. The relationship between the boys becomes painfully strained as Amir is overwhelmed with guilt. When Amir makes it look as though Hassan has stolen his watch, Hassan does not give him away. Hassan’s father, A Ali, li, tells Baba that they are leaving, despite Baba’s insistence that all is forgiven. When the Soviets invade Kabul, Baba and Amir escape in a tarpaulin-covered covered truck with other refugees. Then the movies flashes forward to Fremont, CA, 1988, with Baba on his way to Amir’s community college graduation. Baba and Amir soon become a regular presence at the local flea market, where they hawk their wares alongside other Afghans such as General Sahib and his daughter Soraya. Amir falls in love with Soraya, and sh shortly ortly thereafter Baba is diagnosed with terminal cancer. Eventually, Amir asks Baba to approach General Sahib, who accepts the marriage proposal, and Soraya tells Amir about her checkered past. After their marriage, Baba dies, and the movie returns to the opening phone call. Amir decides to go to Pakistan, where Rahim Kahn tells him about Hassan and his wife, and how they were killed by the Taliban. Rahim also unveils the secret that Baba is Hassan’s father, not Ali, and that Hassan’s son Sohrab is still alive. Amir sets off to rescue Sohrab, which leads to a violent confrontation with the adult Assef. Amir and Sohrab escape and return to America, where their life together with Soraya now begins. --For For more coverage of The Kite Runner, see Peter Chattaway’s review on www.christianitytoday.com/movies Rated PG-13 The film is rated PG-13. 13. It includes a rape scene involving a child, which is very discreetly done yet disturbing nonetheless. Violence also includes a stoning and a bloody fight scene. 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com MOVIE-BASED BASED DISCUSSION GUIDE GUI – PARTICIPANT’S GUIDE The Kite Runner Page 3 Discussing the Scenes 1. Loyalty and sacrifice vs. betrayal (Philippians 2:1–11; 11; John 15:13; Matthew 6:14 6:14–15) The Kite Runner revolves around powerful contrasts, with different characters’ true natures revealing themselves or being revealed throughout the course of the film. Perhaps none of the contrasts is more powerfully portrayed than that of loyalty vs. betrayal in friendships, especially in the case of Amir and Hassan, but also in the friendship of Baba and Ali. 2. Telling the truth vs. keeping secrets (Genesis 12:10–20; 20; John 8:31 8:31–38; 1 John 4:18) Secrets can be buried, but that doesn’t mean that tthey hey won’t continue to exert an influence one way or another. Sometimes we are tempted to believe that it will be easier for us if we avoid telling the truth, but that concept itself is a lie. Maintaining a deception is generally much harder than facing the consequences of the truth in the first place. 3. Sin and guilt vs. redemption (2 Corinthians 7:10–11; 11; Psalm 38:3 38:3–8; Luke 19:1–9; 9; Proverbs 11:17, 19, 21; Ephesians 1:3–8) Perhaps Amir’s r’s story resonates so strongly with audiences because it is the story of fallen humanity, of struggling to overcome sin and do the right thing, even when it’s difficult. While ultimately our sin is taken away through Christ’s sacrifice, we all long for redemption in the here and now. —Adrianna Adrianna Wright, a graduate of Wheaton College, works for InterVarsity Press. 1 © 2007 • CHRISTIANITY TODAY INTERNATIONAL Visit www.ChristianBibleStudies.com