Curiosity and Powerful Learning Going deeper again Professor David Hopkins Wayne Craig Being a relentless focus on improving the learning outcomes of ‘every student’ in ‘every school’ across the whole system… Monday, 27 February 12 “Story, projection and parable do work for us; they make everyday life possible; they are the root of human thought; they are not primarily or even importantly - entertainment” The Literary Mind - the Origins of Thought and Language, Mark Turner Monday, 27 February 12 The story is always about moral purpose I know if I need extra help or to be challenged to do better I will get the right support My parents are involved in the school I belong here I know how I am being assessed and what I need to do to improve my work I get to learn lots of interesting and different subjects I can get the job that I want I can work well with and learn from many others as well as my teacher I know what good work looks like and can help myself to learn I know what my learning objectives are and feel in control of my learning I use computers to help me learn All these …. whatever my background, whatever my abilities, wherever I start from Monday, 27 February 12 The story so far... Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Literate Numerate Curious Monday, 27 February 12 The AIZ - based on a conventional three phase model Monday, 27 February 12 The AIZ - based on a conventional three phase model Monday, 27 February 12 The AIZ - based on a conventional three phase model Monday, 27 February 12 The AIZ - based on a conventional three phase model Monday, 27 February 12 Maintenance Permanent Structures Management Structure & Processes School Management Team • Committees • Admin/Management/Development • Roles & hierarchies • Fixed & exclusive membership • Bound to rhythm of school year • Identifies professional learning needs Shared Values & Beliefs School Improvement Leadership Team School Improvement Team Development Monday, 27 February 12 Development: temporary membership system • Teams & partnerships • Development/improvement • Change • Cross-hierarchical • Bound by rhythms of development • Developmental professionally • Inclusive membership Fluid Structures Which morphed into the... Powerful Learning School Improvement Strategy Monday, 27 February 12 Inside Out curiosity Fair to Adequate Good to Great Adequate to Good Great to Excellent Monday, 27 February 12 We have made great progress on two of our three goals... Monday, 27 February 12 Writing 3 Monday, 27 February 12 Numeracy 5 Monday, 27 February 12 Reading 7 Monday, 27 February 12 Writing 9 Monday, 27 February 12 Literate Numerate Curious Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Beginning the Curiosity Journey 1. Defining 2. Teaching 3. Going Whole School Monday, 27 February 12 1. Defining Curiosity 1. Read the definitions of curiosity on the cards provided 2. Discuss with colleagues on your table your preferred definition or invent your own 3. Agree a common definition between you Monday, 27 February 12 2. Teaching Curiosity 1. View the Costa video clip 2. Discuss with colleagues your favourite strategy for promoting curiosity among your students 3. Collate these strategies and share with your school staff Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 2. Teaching Curiosity 1. View the Costa video clip 2. Discuss with colleagues your favourite strategy for promoting curiosity among your students 3. Collate these strategies and share with your school staff Monday, 27 February 12 As a result of our work on “Instructional Rounds” we have identified ten Theories of Action that when taken together promote curiosity... Monday, 27 February 12 Four Whole School Theories of Action Prioritise High Expectations & Authentic Relationships If schools and teachers prioritise high expectations and authentic relationships, then curiosity will flourish. Emphasise Enquiry Focused Teaching If enquiry is a defining characteristic of a school’s culture, then the level of student achievement and curiosity will increase. Adopt Consistent Teaching Protocols If we adopt consistent teaching protocols, then student behaviour, engagement, learning and curiosity will be enhanced. Adopt Consistent Learning Protocols If we adopt consistent learning protocols in all classes, then all students will experience an enhanced capacity to learn, and to develop skills, confidence and curiosity. Monday, 27 February 12 Four Whole School Theories of Action Six Theories of Action for the Teacher Prioritise High Expectations & Authentic Relationships If schools and teachers prioritise high expectations and authentic relationships, then curiosity will flourish. Emphasise Enquiry Focused Teaching If enquiry is a defining characteristic of a school’s culture, then the level of student achievement and curiosity will increase. Adopt Consistent Teaching Protocols If we adopt consistent teaching protocols, then student behaviour, engagement, learning and curiosity will be enhanced. Adopt Consistent Learning Protocols If we adopt consistent learning protocols in all classes, then all students will experience an enhanced capacity to learn, and to develop skills, confidence and curiosity. Harness Learning Intentions, Narrative & Pace If we harness learning intentions, narrative and pace so students are more secure about their learning, and more willing to take risks, then achievement and understanding will increase and curiosity will be enhanced. Set Challenging Learning Tasks If learning tasks are purposeful, clearly defined, differentiated and challenging, then all students will experience powerful, progressive and precise learning. Frame Higher Order Questions If we systematically employ higher order questioning, then levels of student understanding will deepen and levels of achievement will increase. Connect Feedback to Data If we connect feedback to data about student actions and performance, then behaviour will be more positive, progress will accelerate, and curiosity will be enhanced. Commit to Assessment for Learning If we commit to peer assessment, and assessment for learning, then student engagement, learning and achievement will accelerate. Implement Cooperative Groups If we implement cooperative group structures and techniques to mediate between whole class instruction and students carrying out tasks, then the academic performance of the whole class will increase. Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 Monday, 27 February 12 + Monday, 27 February 12 succeed because... They excel at what they do not just occasionally but for a high proportion of the time They prove constantly that disadvantage need not be a barrier to achievement They put their students first, invest in their staff and nurture their communities They have strong values and high expectations that are applied consistently and are never relaxed They fulfil individual potential through providing outstanding teaching, rich opportunities for learning and encouragement and support for each student Monday, 27 February 12 They are highly inclusive, having complete regard for the educational progress, personal development and well being of every student Their achievements do not happen by chance, but by highly reflective, carefully planned and implemented strategies They operate with a very high degree of internal consistency They are constantly looking for ways to improve further They have outstanding and well distributed leadership The heart: outstanding leadership practice The Principals of these schools are not by and large iconic – they have taken on challenging schools out of a deep commitment to improving the lot of their students and developing their learning capacity Moral purpose may be at the heart of it but successful Principals need a range of attributes and skills if they are to succeed in dealing with the challenges presented by turbulent and complex communities Have an unrelenting curiosity about student learning and achievement Clear and unshakeable principles and sense of purpose related to student learning Vigilance and visibility; courage and conviction Predisposition to immediate action, letting nothing slip Insistence on consistency of approach, individually and across the organisation Belief in people and commitment to build professional capacity Hold oneself and others to high standards of professional practice Emotional intelligence Tireless energy and persistence Monday, 27 February 12 The “killer” Whole School Theory of Action When teacher directed instruction is infused by a spirit of inquiry the level of student engagement and achievement increases. This is the foundation stone for high quality teaching and the development of curiosity. A greater emphasis on inquiry leads to improved achievement and curiosity is enhanced Monday, 27 February 12 The “killer” Theory of Action again... Leadership works self consciously to ensure that over time the vision of curiosity and spirit of enquiry is pervasive and supported by robust and highly reliable school structures, in so far as they: -focus on specific outcomes which can be related to student learning, rather than succumbing to external pressure to identify non-specific goals such as 'improve exam results'; -draw on theory, research into practice, and the teachers' own experiences in formulating strategies, so that the rationale for the required changes is established in the minds of those expected to bring them about; -recognise the importance of staff development, since it is unlikely that developments in student learning will occur without emphasising the instructional behaviour of teachers; -provide for monitoring the impact of policy and strategy on teacher practice and student learning early and regularly, rather than rely on 'post-hoc' evaluations; -pay careful attention to the consistency of implementation Monday, 27 February 12 Processes for linking Curiosity and School Improvement 1. The curiosity journey is introduced A clear reform narrative for student learning is developed and consistently applied over time, with an urgency that translates the vision of curiosity into clear principles for action 2. Key pedagogic strategies are selected High leverage theories of action related to student learning (e.g. AfL and HRLTP) are selected and implemented strategically 3. Professional learning is placed at the heart of the process Staff development that emphasises non-judgmental peer observation and support through triads, disciplined by clear definitions and protocols that develop professional practice 4. Consistency across the whole school is seen as paramount Leadership works self consciously to ensure that over time the vision of curiosity and spirit of enquiry is pervasive and supported by robust and highly reliable school structures (e.g. PLTs) 5. Cultures are changed and developed A culture of disciplined action and a professional ethos that values curiosity and enquiry is embedded and deepened over time Monday, 27 February 12 3. Going Whole School 1. How would you build curiosity into the school’s own narrative? 2. How would you layer curiosity through the 5 ‘killer app’ processes? 3. How does a commitment to curiosity affect the culture of the school? Monday, 27 February 12 Processes for linking Curiosity and School Improvement 1. The curiosity journey is introduced A clear reform narrative for student learning is developed and consistently applied over time, with an urgency that translates the vision of curiosity into clear principles for action 2. Key pedagogic strategies are selected High leverage theories of action related to student learning (e.g. AfL and HRLTP) are selected and implemented strategically 3. Professional learning is placed at the heart of the process Staff development that emphasises non-judgmental peer observation and support through triads, disciplined by clear definitions and protocols that develop professional practice 4. Consistency across the whole school is seen as paramount Leadership works self consciously to ensure that over time the vision of curiosity and spirit of enquiry is pervasive and supported by robust and highly reliable school structures (e.g. PLTs) 5. Cultures are changed and developed A culture of disciplined action and a professional ethos that values curiosity and enquiry is embedded and deepened over time Monday, 27 February 12 Narrative Implementation School Journey Improvement Dimension Awful to Adequate Adequate to Good Good to Great Environment Orderly Learning Self directed Teaching Practice Consistency Share best practice Models of learning, tools for teaching Curriculum Literacy and numeracy basics Literacy and numeracy across curriculum Cross curricular enquiry projects Assessment Ownership for progress of students Assessment of learning Students set own targets and monitor progress Data Establish systems for data use Monitor student progress through data Formative and student use of data Leadership Developing leadership capacity Distributed leadership System leadership Monday, 27 February 12 Key Pedagogic Strategies Timeline Year 1 Term 1 Year 2 Term 2 cycles of enquiry P1 P2 Term 3 cycles of enquiry Term 4 SC SC Term 1 Year 3 Term 2 Term 3 Term 4 P5 cycles of enquiry P6 cycles of enquiry Narrative Implementation P3 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry P4 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting SC Term 1 Term 2 SC Term 3 cycles of enquiry P7 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry P8 SC Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting P = Priority for development SC = Success checks which take place at the end of work on a priority Monday, 27 February 12 Term 4 Professional Learning Analysis Professional Development Phase Example: Theory of Action - 1 Harness learning intentions, narrative and pace Theory Explain and justify the new approach Demonstrate Show/model how it can be done in practice Practice Teachers practice in their own classes Feedback Teachers receive feedback from their triad (professional learning team) Coaching Supports teachers to improve their practice Monday, 27 February 12 A Measure of Consistency of Implementation - Levels of Use Levels of Use 0 Non-Use 1 Orientation 2 Preparation 3 Mechanical 4a Routine 4b Refinement 5 Integration 6 Renewal Monday, 27 February 12 Behaviours associated with the level of use No interest shown in the innovation; no action taken Begins to gather information about the innovation Begins to plan ways to implement the innovation Concerned about mechanics of implementation Comfortable with innovation and implements it as taught Begins to explore ways for continuous improvement Integrates innovation with other initiatives; does not view it as an add-on; collaborates others Explores new and with different ways to implement innovation Monday, 27 February 12 “Welfarist” school low in control high in cohesion High Cohesion Low Control “Survivalist” school low in control low in cohesion “Hothouse” school high in control high in cohesion Low Cohesion High Control “Formal” school high in control low in cohesion Monday, 27 February 12 “Welfarist” school low in control high in cohesion High Cohesion Low Control Where we are... “Survivalist” school low in control low in cohesion “Hothouse” school high in control high in cohesion Low Cohesion High Control “Formal” school high in control low in cohesion Monday, 27 February 12 “Welfarist” school low in control high in cohesion High Cohesion “Hothouse” school high in control high in cohesion Low Control Where we are headed... Low Cohesion High Control “Formal” school high in control low in cohesion Monday, 27 February 12 “Survivalist” school low in control low in cohesion “Welfarist” school low in control high in cohesion High Cohesion “Hothouse” school high in control high in cohesion Low Control Where we want to be... Low Cohesion High Control “Formal” school high in control low in cohesion Monday, 27 February 12 “Survivalist” school low in control low in cohesion “Welfarist” school low in control high in cohesion High Cohesion Low Control “Survivalist” school low in control low in cohesion “Hothouse” school high in control high in cohesion Low Cohesion High Control “Formal” school high in control low in cohesion Monday, 27 February 12 Pole A (Odd Numbers) Measuring and monitoring targets and test results Respecting authority – Providing direction Category Results (Control) Hierarchy (Control) Pole B (Even Numbers) Raising capability – Helping people learn – Laying foundations for later success Taking initiative and responsibility – Participation at every level – Healthy dissent The school comes first – No-one is bigger than the school – Doing what is expected of you Respect (Cohesion) People come first – Everyone can make a contribution and deserves control over their own destiny Respecting professional autonomy – Creating a space to call your own – Perfecting your patch Connection (Cohesion) Working together – Learning from each other – Sharing resources and ideas – Investing in others Recognising personal circumstances – Making allowances – Toleration – It’s the effort that counts Accountability (Control) Keeping promises – Confronting poor performance – Taking ownership Embedding – Evaluating – Measured reform and taking stock Innovation (Cohesion) Experimenting – Trying new things – Looking to the next big idea Preventing mistakes – Making sure nobody and nothing slips through – Planning for all eventualities Single minded dedication – Relentless pace Reliability (Control) Taking calculated risks for worthwhile goals – Try it and see Seriousness (Cohesion) Warmth – Humour – Repartee – Feet on the ground Setting achievable goals and realistic expectations Ambition (Control) A hunger for improvement – High hopes and expectations – Incremental improvements Investing time with those who can achieve the most Perfectibility (Control) Focusing on the value added – Holding hope for every child – Every gain a victory Dignity – Reserve – Respecting privacy – Keeping a lid on it – Self control Openness (Cohesion) Admitting mistakes – Providing challenging feedback – Letting people know how you feel Promoting excellence – Pushing the boundaries of achievement – World class Social Justice (Cohesion) Creating a pleasant and collegial working environment Mastering your subject – Gaining expertise – Sharing knowledge Keeping up with initiatives – Doing what’s required – Following policy Monday, 27 February 12 Service (Cohesion) Creating opportunities for everyone – Widening horizons – Fighting injustice Making sacrifices to put pupils first Lifelong Learning Admitting you don’t know – Listening to dissent – (Control) Curiosity and humility Independence (Cohesion) Anticipating initiatives – Making them work for us– Picking and Choosing Monday, 27 February 12 MAKING THE LINK TO STUDENT LEARNING Monday, 27 February 12 Personalised Learning Assessment for Learning Learning to Learn Peer Assessment Student Voice Protocols Rubrics Artefacts Heuristics Worksheets Student Learning and Achievement MAKING THE LINK TO STUDENT LEARNING Monday, 27 February 12 The Logic of System Leadership A summary that captures the flow of action Moral purpose Learning Potential of all Students So we need to... Develop student’s repertoire of Learning Skills We do this through... Theories of Action Models of Teaching That are embedded in... Consistency is ensured by... System leadership is... Monday, 27 February 12 Curriculum Context and Schemes of Work Whole School Theories of Action especially Enquiry Sharing Curriculum, Pedagogy and Leadership Across and Between Schools, Networks, Regions, Statewide, and Nationally Reviews Student Needs School Aims Audit Long-listed Priorities Consideration of: urgency need desirability size and scope root and branch links between priorities Selection and sequence of priorities in draft plan PLAN DEVELOPMENT Monday, 27 February 12 Consultation & approval of plan Publicising plan Action plans National & State Policies Teacher' Theory'of' Ac,on'1 Unavoidable Urgent Desirable Large'size'and' scope Small'size'and' scope Strong'roots Weak'roots Weak'links'to' other' priori,es Monday, 27 February 12 Teacher' Theory'of' Ac,on'2 Professional' Learning Whole' School' Theory'of' Ac,on'2 Na,onal/ State' Ini,a,ves curiosity Monday, 27 February 12 curiosity Monday, 27 February 12 Going Deeper... The Powerful Learning Planning Framework Year 1 Term 1 Year 2 Term 2 cycles of enquiry P1 P2 Term 3 cycles of enquiry Term 4 SC SC Term 1 Year 3 Term 2 Term 3 Term 4 P5 cycles of enquiry P6 cycles of enquiry P3 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry P4 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting SC Term 1 Term 2 SC Term 3 cycles of enquiry P7 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry P8 SC Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting P = Priority for development SC = Success checks which take place at the end of work on a priority Monday, 27 February 12 Term 4 The Powerful Learning Planning Framework An example... 2012 2011 Term 1 Term 2 Term 3 Term 4 Expectations & Relationships SC Learning Protocols Term 2 Intentions Pace Narrative SC Tasks SC Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting Monday, 27 February 12 Term 3 Term 4 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry Enquiry Teaching Protocols Term 1 2013 Term 1 SC Feedback & Data SC cycles of enquiry Higher Order Questions Term 2 Term 3 cycles of enquiry cycles of enquiry Term 4 SC SC SC cycles of enquiry Taking Stock - Mini-audit Reporting SC Powerful Learning & Autonomy • Victoria has a proud tradition of school reform and improvement: • 1990s – Self Management • 2000s – Building Capacity • 2010s Autonomy • Autonomy is defined as independence, self governance and making one’s own decisions • But we also know from the evidence in the world’s best performing educational systems that to sustain improvement they; Monday, 27 February 12 Establish collaborative practices around teaching and learning Develop a mediating layer between the schools and the centre; and Architect tomorrow’s leadership Linking Powerful Learning & Autonomy Linking Autonomy to Powerful Learning allows us to: 1.More fully express our moral purpose of enabling every student to reach their potential 2.Ensure that every teacher has the maximum time to teach and to develop their professional competence 3.Maximise resource allocation to ensue that this happens 4.Explore the full potential of the ‘inside – out’ school development strategy 5.Enable leadership to work more effectively with the system both within and outside the school and generate sustainable networks that deepen the impact on student learning 6.Move from external to professional forms of accountability Monday, 27 February 12 Autonomy & System Leadership • Schools should take greater responsibility for neighbouring schools so that the move towards networking encourages groups of schools to form substantive collaborative arrangements • All failing and underperforming (and potentially low achieving) schools should have a leading school that works with them in either a formal grouping Federation or in more informal partnership • The incentives for greater system responsibility should include significantly enhanced funding for students most at risk • A rationalisation of national and local agency functions and roles to allow the higher degree of national and regional co-ordination for this increasingly devolved system Monday, 27 February 12 Autonomy & System Leadership • Autonomous networked schools network to put in place substantive collaborative arrangements • Autonomous networked schools understand they are as strong as the weakest link. Schools that are failing and/or underperforming can expect to receive unconditional support from all network schools • Autonomous networked schools support and accept significantly enhanced funding for students most at risk • A rationalisation of national and local agency functions and roles to allow the higher degree of national and regional co-ordination for this increasingly devolved system Monday, 27 February 12 Leading change ‘You must be the change you wish to see in the world’ Monday, 27 February 12 Professor David Hopkins David Hopkins is Professor Emeritus at the Institute of Education University of London, where until recently, he held the inaugural HSBC iNet Chair in International Leadership. He is a Trustee of Outward Bound and is Executive Director of the new charity ‘Adventure Learning Schools’. David holds visiting professorships at the Catholic University of Santiago, the Chinese University of Hong Kong and the Universities of Edinburgh, Melbourne and Wales and consults internationally on school reform. Between 2002 and 2005 he served three Secretary of States as the Chief Adviser on School Standards at the Department for Education and Skills. Previously, he was Chair of the Leicester City Partnership Board and Dean of the Faculty of Education at the University of Nottingham. Before that again he was a Tutor at the University of Cambridge Institute of Education, a Secondary School teacher and Outward Bound Instructor. David is also an International Mountain Guide who still climbs regularly in the Alps and Himalayas. His recent books Every School a Great School and System Leadership in Practice are published by the Open University Press. www.davidhopkins.co.uk Monday, 27 February 12 Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Cognitive Principle Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Enquiry People are naturally curious but we are not naturally good thinkers; unless the cognitive conditions are right, we will avoid thinking Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Enquiry People are naturally curious, but curiosity is fragile Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Enquiry Move from seeing and structuring curriculum as a series of answers to having questions as the basis of instruction Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Enquiry Monday, 27 February 12 Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Cognitive Principle Brain Rules - John Medina Monday, 27 February 12 Enquiry The more attention the brain pays to a given stimulus, the more elaborately the information will be encoded - and retained Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Monday, 27 February 12 Intentions Learning intentions capture students’ attention and are critical as the introduction to the story of the lesson Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Narrative The human mind seems exquisitely tuned to understand and remember stories - so much so that psychologists sometimes refer to stories as “psychologically privileged” meaning that they are treated differently in memory than other types of memory Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Stories are easy to comprehend Stories are interesting Stories are easy to remember Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Narrative Events don’t happen randomly in stories Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Narrative Structure your lessons the way stories are structured...the story structure applies to the way you organise the material that you encourage your students to think about, not to the methods you use to teach the material Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Narrative Four principles underpin stories - Causality - Conflict - Complications - Character Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham 4Cs Monday, 27 February 12 Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Brain Rules - John Medina Monday, 27 February 12 Pace Peer-reviewed studies confirm...before the first quarter-hour is over in a typical presentation, people usually have checked out Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Why Don’t Students Like School? - Professor Doug Willingham Monday, 27 February 12 Pace Change promotes attention Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Teaching with the brain in mind - Eric Jensen Monday, 27 February 12 Pace We cannot hold much in our shortterm memory, and, mentally, we fatigue easily. Teach in shorter bursts... Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Tasks Monday, 27 February 12 Neuroscience and the Theories of Action Brain Rules - John Medina Monday, 27 February 12 Tasks The current (school) system is founded on a series of expectations that certain learning goals should be achieved by a certain age. Yet there is no reason to suspect that the brain pays attention to those expectations. Students of the same age show a great deal of intellectual variability Curiosity and Powerful Learning Curiosity and Powerful Learning curiosity Teaching Models Vision of Curiosity & Spirit of Enquiry curiosity Whole School Theories of Action Monday, 27 February 12 curiosity curiosity Teacher Theories of Action Teaching Models Our toolbox is the models of teaching, actually models for learning, that simultaneously define the nature of the content, the learning strategies, and the arrangements for social interaction that create the learning contexts of our students For example, in powerful classrooms students learn models for: • Extracting information and ideas from lectures and presentations • Memorising information • Building hypotheses and theories • Attaining concepts and how to invent them • Using metaphors to think creatively • Working effectively with other to carry out cooperative tasks Monday, 27 February 12 the most knowledgable... the wisest Monday, 27 February 12 the most knowledgable... the wisest Monday, 27 February 12