L Learning i Obj Objectives ti In this chapter, you will learn about: • Revenue models • How some companies move from one revenue model to another to achieve success • Revenue strategy issues that companies face when selling lli on the th W Web b • Creating g an effective business p presence on the Web • Web site usability • Communicating effectively with customers on the Web E-Business E Business Eighth g Edition Chapter 3 Selling on the Web: Revenue Models and dB Building ildi a W Web bP Presence E-Business, Eighth Edition R Revenue M Models d l W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l • Web business revenue generating models – – – – – • Adapted from traditional catalog-based model Web catalog Digital content Advertising-supported g pp Advertising-subscription mixed Fee-based – Seller established brand image g – Sold through printed information • Mailed to prospective buyers • Web sites expand traditional model – Replace R l or supplement l t print i t catalogs t l – Offer flexibility • Can work for both sale types – Business Business-to-consumer to consumer (B2C) – Business-to-business (B2B) • Order through Web site or telephone • Payment though Web site, telephone, or mail • Can work with one Web site, site separate sites sites, or separate pages E-Business, Eighth Edition 2 • Creates additional sales outlet 3 E-Business, Eighth Edition 4 E-Business, Eighth Edition 6 W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) • Computers and consumer electronics – Apple, pp , Dell,, Gateway, y, Hewlett-Packard,, IBM,, Sun Microsystems • Sell full range g of p products – Dell • Allows product configuration; creates value – Crutchfield and The Sharper Image • Successful S ccessf l mail order e expansion pansion incl includes des Web sites – Best Buy, Circuit City, J&R Music World, Radio Shack • Successful retail store presence expansion • Sell same products E-Business, Eighth Edition 5 W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) • Books, music, and videos – Most visible electronic commerce examples – Amazon.com Web-only retailer • Originally sold only books – Barnes & Noble, Blackwell’s, Books-A-Million, Powell’s Books • Well-established physical book stores – CDnow Web-only online music store – Tower Records, Sam Goody retail stores • Created Web sites to compete with CDnow – CD Universe copied CDnow approach E-Business, Eighth Edition 7 E-Business, Eighth Edition 8 W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) • Luxury goods • Clothing retailers – Clientele reluctant to buy y through g Web – Vera Wang and Versace – Adapt p catalog g sales model to Web – Display clothing photos • Web sites provide information • Shopper purchases at physical store • Heavy use of graphics and animation • Prices, Prices sizes, sizes colors, colors tailoring details – Customers examine clothing online • Place orders through Web site – Evian – Lands’ End online Web shopping assistance • Uses U flflash h animation i ti • Lands’ End Live (1999) – Tiffany & Co – Text chat and call-back features – Lands’ End personal shopper agent (more recent) • Graphics and animation require broadband connection • Learns p preferences and makes suggestions gg E-Business, Eighth Edition 9 E-Business, Eighth Edition 10 W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) • Clothing retailers (cont’d.) • Flowers and gifts (gift retailers) – 1-800-Flowers – My y Virtual Model ((customers tryy clothes)) • Online extension to successful telephone business • Competes with online-only florists • Graphic image built from customer measurements – Lands Lands’ End – Godiva • Two shoppers using different computers • Simultaneously browse Web site together • Offers business gift plans – Hickory Farms and Mrs. Fields Cookies – Online overstocks stores • Offer familiar name brands on Web • Reaches R h more people l th than physical h i l store t – Harry and David – Problem with varying computer monitor color settings • Send fabric swatch on request • Offer generous return policies E-Business, Eighth Edition 11 • Original Web site for informational purposes • Promoted catalog business • Added online ordering feature E-Business, Eighth Edition 12 W b Catalog Web C t l Revenue R Models M d l ((cont’d.) t’d ) • General discounters (completely new businesses) • Highly efficient distribution mechanism – Buy.Com – Firms own written information or information rights g • Borrowed Wal-Mart and discount club sales model • • • • – Many sites sold advertising (originally) • Subsidized extremely low prices • Most sites now out of business – Rely on volume purchasing strategy (now) • Keeps prices low LexisNexis: variety of information services Lexis com: traditional research product Lexis.com: ProQuest: sells published documents’ digital copies Dow Jones newspaper publisher subscriptions – Digitized newspaper newspaper, magazine magazine, and journal content – Fiercely competitive (thin margins: little profits) – Traditional discount retailers • Association for Computer Machinery: digital library • Sellers S ll off adult d lt digital di it l content t t • Costco, Kmart, Target, Wal-Mart • Slow Sl tto iintroduce t d electronic l t i commerce W Web b sites it E-Business, Eighth Edition Di it l C Digital Content t tR Revenue M Models d l – Pioneered online credit card payment processing 13 Advertising-Supported g pp Revenue Models E-Business, Eighth Edition 14 Advertising-Supported g pp Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Successful sites attract specific groups • United States network television – About.com, HowStuffWorks, Drudge Report – Provides free p programming g g and advertising g messages • Web portals • Supports pp network operations p sufficiently y – Yahoo! • Site visitor views problem (measuring and charging) – Stickiness • Keeping visitors at site and attracting repeat visitors • Exposed E d tto more advertising d ti i iin sticky ti k site it • First Web directory • Search engine g results p presented on separate p p page g • Search term triggered advertising – Main p portal sites ((AOL,, Excite,, Google, g , MSN)) – Smaller general-interest sites (refdesk.com) • Obtaining large advertiser problem • More difficulty y attracting g advertisers • C-NET (offers items to a specialized group) – Demographic information • Characteristics set used to g group p visitors E-Business, Eighth Edition 15 Advertising-Supported g pp Revenue Models (cont’d.) 16 Advertising-Supported g pp Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Newspaper publishers • Targeted classified advertising sites – Publish p print content on Web – Internet Public Library Online Newspapers page – More successful at g generating g adverting g revenue – Web site profit potential • Links to worldwide newspaper sites • Specialize in classified advertising – Newspaper’s Web presence – Web employment advertising (CareerBuilder.com) • Provides greater exposure and advertising audience • Print edition sales loss (difficult to measure) • Operating O ti costs t nott covered d by b advertising d ti i revenue E-Business, Eighth Edition E-Business, Eighth Edition • Web directory and search engine advertising approach • Topics of interest; short articles (increases stickiness) • Monster.com M t 17 E-Business, Eighth Edition 18 Advertising-Supported g pp Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Targeted classified advertising sites (cont’d.) – Used vehicle sites • AutoTrader.com, CycleTrader.com, BoatTrader.com • Accepts paid advertising and charge listing fee • Seller ad options: Web site only, print version inclusion – Dedicated following product sites (VetteFinders) • Caters to small audiences – Product P d t sites it useful f l tto buyer b after ft use • Musicians Buy-Line, ComicLink.com, The Golf Cl Classifieds ifi d E-Business, Eighth Edition 19 Advertising-Subscription g p Mixed Revenue Models 20 Advertising-Subscription g p Mixed Revenue Models (cont’d.) • The Washington Post , Los Angeles Times • Subscribers – Pay fee and accept advertising – Typically less advertising – Mixed revenue model variation • No subscription fee charges • Current stories free • Pay for archived articles • Compared to advertising-supported sites • Web sites offer different degrees of success – The New York Times (today) ( y) • Business Week • Bulk of revenue derived from advertising – Mixed revenue model variation – The Wall Street Journal ((mixed model)) • Free content at online site • Requires paid subscription to print magazine • Archived article additional charge (over five years old) • Subscription revenue weighted more heavily – Print edition and online editions • Different model versions E-Business, Eighth Edition E-Business, Eighth Edition 21 Advertising-Subscription g p Mixed Revenue Models (cont’d.) E-Business, Eighth Edition 22 F f T Fee-for-Transaction ti Revenue R Models M d l • ESPN – Leverages g brand name from cable television business – Sells advertising, offers free information – Collects Insider subscriber revenue • Service fee based on transaction number or size • Web site offers visitor personal service – Formerly, human agents provided service • Value chain • Consumers Union (ConsumerReports.org) – Disintermediation – Subscriptions and charitable donations – Not-for-profit organization – Reintermediation • Intermediary (human agent) removed • No advertising • New intermediary (fee-for-transaction Web site) introduced – Free information • Attracts subscribers and fulfills mission E-Business, Eighth Edition 23 E-Business, Eighth Edition 24 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Travel agents – Receive fee for initiating g transaction – Replaced by computers • Online travel agents – Saber system (Travelocity) – Expedia, Hotels.com, Hotel Discount Reservations • All profitable – Orbitz • Five major j U.S. airlines consortium • Generates advertising revenue E-Business, Eighth Edition 25 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) 26 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Automobile sales • Travel agents (cont’d.) – Web site removes salesperson negotiation – Traditional travel agents g being g squeezed q out • Reduces costs • Provides buyers information service • Reduced or eliminated fees – Smaller travel agents specializing (cruises, (cruises hotels) – Reintermediation strategy – CarsDirect.com model • Customers select specific car, site determines price and d fifinds d llocall d dealer l • Travel agents focus on groups – Cruise Web sites – Autoweb.com and Autobytel model • S Site locates local dealers, car sells at small premium over dealer’s nominal cost • VacationsToGo.com, Cruise Specialists – Group travel Web sites – Car salesperson disintermediated – Web site: new intermediary (reintermediation) • WaveHunters.com, WannaSurf E-Business, Eighth Edition E-Business, Eighth Edition 27 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) E-Business, Eighth Edition 28 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Stockbrokers • Insurance brokers – Charge g customers trade execution commission – Web-based brokerage firms (E*TRADE and Datek) – Quotesmith • Internet policy price quotes direct to public (1996) • Independent insurance agents disintermediated • Offer investment advice, advice fast trade execution • Creates competition – Insurance policy information, comparisons, sales sites • InsWeb InsWeb, Answer Financial, Financial Insurance.com, Insurance com YouDecide.com – Discount brokers and full full-line line brokers • Web sites opened for stock trading and information • Transaction T ti costt reductions d ti (like (lik online li auto t b buying) i ) • Stockbrokers disintermediated – Progressive Web site • Provides quotes for competitors’ products too – Major M j iinsurance company W Web b sites it • Offer information or policies for sale E-Business, Eighth Edition 29 E-Business, Eighth Edition 30 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Event tickets – Event p promoters use Web • Ticketmaster, Tickets.com, TicketWeb • Sell original tickets • Customers reside anywhere worldwide – Secondary market tickets • • • • E-Business, Eighth Edition 31 StubHub, TicketsNow Operate as brokers Connect ticket owners with buyers R d Reduce ttransaction ti costs t E-Business, Eighth Edition 32 E-Business, Eighth Edition 34 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Real estate and mortgage loan brokers – Web sites p provide all traditional broker services • Coldwell Banker, Prudential – National Association of Realtors Web site • Realtor.com – IndyMac Bank Home Lending • Offers online credit review, decision in minutes, printing approval letter – Successful Web mortgage brokers • Ditech Di h and dE E-LOAN LOAN E-Business, Eighth Edition 33 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) • Online banking and financial services • Online music – No p physical y p product – Amazon MP3,, Apple’s pp iTunes,, eMusic,, Microsoft’s MSN Music, Napster, Rhapsody, Yahoo!, Walmart.com Music Downloads – Sell single songs (tracks) and albums – Sales revenue source • Easy to offer on Web – Web financial transactions concerns • Trust and reliability of financial institution – Solutions • Fee-for-transaction model • Some sites offer subscription plans • Use existing bank’s identification and reputation (Citibank Online) • Start online bank not affiliated with existing bank (First Internet Bank of Indiana) • Use different name (Bank One used Wingspan) E-Business, Eighth Edition 35 E-Business, Eighth Edition 36 Fee-for-Transaction Revenue Models (cont’d.) O li Vid Online Video • Online music (cont’d.) • Copying control – Problems • • • • • – Use DRM software Digital products easily copied Stores promote own music file format Buyers required to download and install software Software limits number of audio file copies Software does not prevent illegal copying • Three issues hampering sales – Large file size • Reduced by higher Internet connection speeds – Fear F off online li sales l iimpairing i i other th sales l ttypes • Potential serial release pattern impact – Solution – Inability to play on variety of devices • Adopting one standard file format • No N copying i restrictions t i ti • DRM-free MP3 format (Amazon) E-Business, Eighth Edition • DRM not platform compatible 37 E-Business, Eighth Edition 38 Fee-for-Service Revenue Models (cont’d.) F f S i R Fee-for-Service Revenue M Models d l • Companies offer Web service • Professional services – Fee based on service value – Limited Web use • Not broker service • Not based on transactions-processed number or size • State laws prohibit extension of practice • Patients may set appointments • Online games – Major concern – Sales revenue source • Patient privacy • Advertising (older concept) • Pay-to-play premium games • Subscriptions – Significant barrier • Patient P ti t diagnosis di i diffi difficult lt without ith t physical h i l examination i ti – Frequent player y demographics g • 40% over age 35 E-Business, Eighth Edition 39 E-Business, Eighth Edition 40 Subscription p to Advertising-Supported g pp Model R Revenue M Models d l iin T Transition iti • Slate magazine (e-zine) • Need to change revenue model – Upscale news and current events – When Web users’ needs change g • Success expectations were high • Conditions after 2000 – Experienced p writers and editors – Acclaim for incisive reporting and excellent writing – Funding became scarce • Unprofitable growth phase • Initial revenue source – Change Ch model d l or go outt off b business i – Annual subscription • Did not cover operating costs • Now an advertising-supported site – Part of MSN portal • Increases stickiness E-Business, Eighth Edition 41 E-Business, Eighth Edition 42 Advertising-Supported g pp to Advertisingg Subscription Mixed Model Advertising-Supported g pp to Fee-forServices Model • Salon.com • Xdrive Technologies – Acclaim for innovative content – Free disk storage g • Initial revenue source • Initial revenue source (1999) – Advertising-supported g pp site – Needed additional money to continue operations – Advertising-supported Advertising supported • Pages contained advertising • Targeted T t d e-mailil advertising d ti i • Did not cover operating costs • Investors did not provide p • Now offers optional subscription version – Annual fee for Salon premium • Now subscription-supported service • Free of advertising • Downloadable content • Additional content E-Business, Eighth Edition – Monthly y fee dropping pp g • Other similar companies (IBackup and Kela) 43 E-Business, Eighth Edition Advertising-Supported g pp to Subscription p Model M lti l T Multiple Transitions iti • Encyclopedia Britannica • Northern Light – Initial Web offerings – Search engine g ((includes own database)) • Britannica Internet Guide • Encyclopedia Britannica Online • Results include Web site links and abstracts • Initial revenue source • Initial revenue source – Combination (advertising-supported and fee-based) – Paid subscription p site • Individual I di id l article ti l paymentt • Search results page advertising • Low subscription sales – Converted to free advertiser-supported pp site – Did not cover operating costs • Sold educational and scientific products • Now subscription p model • Returned etu ed to mixed ed model ode – Annual, large clients E-Business, Eighth Edition 44 – Subscription plan and free content 45 E-Business, Eighth Edition 46 R Revenue St Strategy t Issues I • Implementations issues – Channel conflict and cannibalization – Strategic alliances and channel distribution management – Mobile commerce E-Business, Eighth Edition 47 E-Business, Eighth Edition 48 Strategic g Alliances and Channel Distribution Management Ch Channel l Conflict C fli t and dC Cannibalization ib li ti • Channel conflict (cannibalization) • Strategic alliance – Company Web site sales activities interfere with existing i ti sales l outlets tl t – Two or more companies join forces • Undertake activity over long time period • Retail distribution partner issues – Levis: stopped selling products on company Web site • Site now p provides p product information • Yodlee – Maytag: incorporated online partners into Web site – Relationship with portal site clients • Site now provides product information • Amazon.com A – Eddie Bauer – Joined with Target, Borders, CDnow, ToyRUs • Online purchases p rchases ret returnable rnable at retail stores • Required compensation and bonus plans adjustments to support Web site E-Business, Eighth Edition • Handleman Company – Manages music inventories (Walmart, KMart) 49 M bil C Mobile Commerce E-Business, Eighth Edition 50 C ti an Eff Creating Effective ti Web W b Presence P • F Few companies i successful f l generating ti significant i ifi t revenues • Organization’s presence – Public image conveyed to stakeholders – Usually not important – NTT’s DoCoMo I-Mode service (Japan cell phone) • Send short messages, play games, obtain weather forecasts • Until growth reaches significant size – Stakeholders – AvantGo (United States) • Customers, suppliers, employees, stockholders, neighbors, general public • Offers channels of information as PDA downloads • Mobile commerce: $400 billion by 2012 • Effective Web presence – Requires larger memory, easier-to-use interfaces, higher screen resolutions – Critical • E-mail, telephone, Web access, entertainment services convergence E-Business, Eighth Edition – Joining Web sites with channel distribution management firms 51 • Even for smallest and newest Web operating firms E-Business, Eighth Edition 52 Identifying y g Web Presence Goals (cont’d.) Id tif i W Identifying Web bP Presence G Goals l • Business physical space • Making Web presence consistent with brand image – Focus on very specific objectives – Different firms establish different Web p presence g goals – Coca Cola pages • N Nott iimage d driven i • Must satisfy many business needs • Fails F il to convey good d presence • Usually include trusted corporate image (Coke bottle) • Traditional position as a trusted classic • Web business site intentionally creates distinctive presence • Good Web site design – Pepsi pages • Usually filled with hyperlinks to activities and productrelated promotions • Upstart product favored by younger generation – Provides effective image-creation features – Provides effective image image-enhancing enhancing features • Serves as sales brochure, product showroom, financial report employment ad report, ad, customer contact point E-Business, Eighth Edition 53 E-Business, Eighth Edition 54 Achieving g Web Presence Goals (cont’d.) A hi i W Achieving Web bP Presence G Goals l • Effective site creates attractive presence • Profit-driven organizations – Meets business or organization g objectives j – Toyota y • Objectives • Good example of effective Web presence • Presence consistent with corporate goal – – – – Attract visitors to the Web site Make site interesting C Convince i visitors i i to ffollow ll site’s i ’ lilinks k Create impression consistent with organization’s desired image – Build trusting relationship with visitors – Reinforce positive image – Encourage visitors to return – Quaker Oats older Web site • Offered little sense of corporate presence – Quaker Oats current Web site • Much M hb better tt E-Business, Eighth Edition 55 E-Business, Eighth Edition 56 E-Business, Eighth Edition 57 E-Business, Eighth Edition 58 Achieving g Web Presence Goals (cont’d.) • Not-for-profit organizations – Web p presence effort g goals • Image-enhancement capability • Provide information dissemination – Successful site key elements • Integrate information dissemination with fund fund-raising raising • Provide two-way contact channel – American A i Ci Civilil Lib Liberties ti U Union i (ACLU) • Serves many different constituencies – Political party Web sites E-Business, Eighth Edition 59 E-Business, Eighth Edition 60 W b Site Web Sit U Usability bilit • Current Web presences – Few businesses accomplish p all g goals – Most fail to provide visitors sufficient interactive contact opportunities – Improve Web presence • • • • E-Business, Eighth Edition 61 H How th the W Web b IIs Diff Differentt Make site accessible to more people Make site easier to use Make site enco encourage rage visitors’ isitors’ tr trust st Develop feelings of loyalty toward organization E-Business, Eighth Edition 62 M ti th Meeting the N Needs d off W Web b Sit Site Vi Visitors it • Simple mid-1990s Web sites • Successful Web businesses: – Conveyed y basic businesses information – No market research conducted – Realize every y visitor is a p potential customer (p (partner)) • Crafting Web presence is an important concern • Web objectives achievement failure – Know visitor characteristic variations – Not understanding Web presence-building media • Visitor at site for a reason • Web objective achievement success – Sites create organization’s g p presence – Sites contain standard information set • History History, objectives, objectives mission, mission product information information, financial information, two-way meaningful communication E-Business, Eighth Edition 63 E-Business, Eighth Edition 64 Meeting g the Needs of Web Site Visitors (cont’d.) Meeting g the Needs of Web Site Visitors (cont’d.) • Web site visitor motivations • Making Web sites accessible – – – – – – – Learning g about company p yp products or services Buying products or services Obtaining warranty, warranty service, service repair policy information Obtaining general company information Obt i i fi Obtaining financial i l iinformation f ti Identifying people Obtaining contact information – Build interface flexibility y • • • • • Optional to use frames Offer text text-only only version Option to select smaller graphic images Option to specify streaming media connection type Option to choose among information attributes – Controversial Web site design • Animated graphics software use • Some S tasks t k lend l d th themselves l tto animated i t dW Web b pages • Visitors have: – Various needs, experience, expectations, technology E-Business, Eighth Edition 65 E-Business, Eighth Edition 66 Meeting g the Needs of Web Site Visitors (cont’d.) • Making Web sites accessible (cont’d.) – Offer multiple p information formats – Web site constructions goals • • • • • E-Business, Eighth Edition 67 T t and Trust d Loyalty L lt Offer easily accessible organization facts Allow different visitor experiences Provide meaningful, meaningful two two-way way communication link Sustain visitor attention and encourage return visits Offer easily easil accessible information abo aboutt prod products, cts services, and their use E-Business, Eighth Edition 68 R ti El Rating Electronic t i C Commerce W Web b Sit Sites • Creates relationship value • Good service leads to seller trust • Review electronic commerce Web sites – Delivery, order handling, help selecting product, aftersale support – Usability, y, customer service,, other factors – Gomez.com • No longer publishes most scorecards – BizRate.com • Satisfactory service builds customer loyalty • Customer C service in electronic commerce sites • Comparison shopping service • Links to low price and good service ratings sites – Problem • Lack integration between call centers and Web sites • Poor e-mail responsiveness p – Unlikely to recover money spent to attract customers E-Business, Eighth Edition 69 Rating g Electronic Commerce Web Site (cont’d.) • Usability testing 70 Rating g Electronic Commerce Web Site (cont’d.) • Customer-centric Web site design – Helps p meet Web site g goals – Avoids Web site frustration – Important p p part of successful electronic business operation – Focus on meeting all site visitors visitors’ needs – Putting customer at center of all site designs • Customers leave site without buying anything – Simple site usability changes • Include telephone contact information • Staff a call center – Learn L about b visitor i i needs d b by conducting d i ffocus groups – Usability testing cost • Follow guidelines and recommendations • Make visitors’ Web experiences more efficient, effective memorable effective, – Usability • Important I t t element l t off creating ti effective ff ti Web W b presence • Low compared to Web site design costs E-Business, Eighth Edition E-Business, Eighth Edition 71 E-Business, Eighth Edition 72 C Connecting ti with ith C Customers t C Connecting ti with ith C Customers t ((cont’d.) t’d ) • Important element of a corporate Web presence • Identify and reach out to customers • Nature of Web communication – Personal contact (prospecting) (p p g) • Employees individually search for, qualify, contact potential customers p – Mass media • Deliver messages by broadcasting – Addressable media • Advertising efforts directed to known addressee – Internet medium • Occupies O i centrall space iin medium di choice h i continuum i E-Business, Eighth Edition 73 E-Business, Eighth Edition 74 Summary • Six main approaches to generate Web revenue – Models work differently – Different business types use different models – Learn more about customers, business environment • Change models • Channel conflict and cannibalization challenges g – Form strategic alliances with other companies – Contract with channel distribution managers • B2C mobile commerce not widely successful • Create effective Web presence to deliver value • Must understand Web communication E-Business, Eighth Edition 75 E-Business, Eighth Edition 76