Chapter 9: Intelligence and IQ Testing Brown Unit 10: The Measurement of Mankind The historical roots of I.Q. testing Phrenology Brain size and intelligence Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 ___________ Revision 2006 PSB Origins of Intelligence Testing Brain Size & Intelligence Paul Broca – (founder of the Anthropological Society) the measurement of head size should answer the most important question of the day – the relative worth of different people! Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB George Cuvier Broca’s Claim Founder of the field of ___________, & the greatest anatomist of his day. Broca dissected Cuvier’s brain on Mayy 15, 1832. Cuvier’s brain weighed 1830 grams (about 400 grams above average). This was the first direct evidence that ___________and brain size go together. Revision 2006 PSB “In general, the brain is larger in men than in women, in eminent men than in men of mediocre talent, in _______races than in _________races. Other things being equal, there is a remarkable relationship between the development of intelligence and the volume of the brain.” “I have noticed for a long time that, in general, those who deny the intellectual importance of the brain’s volume have ______heads.” Revision 2006 PSB 1 Brain Size Broca’s brain = 1,480 grams. Walt Whitman = 1 1,282 282 grams grams. American poet. Franz Joseph Gall = 1,198 grams. Sex Differences Broca measured: 292 male brains = 1,325 grams 140 female brains = 1,144 grams Body mass was not measured. Broca stated that size cannot account for the difference because we know that women __________as intelligent as men. Founder of phrenology. Revision 2006 PSB Gustave Le Bon 1879 “In the most intelligent races, as among the Parisians, there are a number of women whose brains are closer in size to those of gorillas than to the most developed male b i brains. This Thi inferiority i f i it is i so obvious b i that th t no one can contest it for a moment; only its degree is worth discussion. All psychologists who have studied the intelligence of women, as well as poets and novelists, recognize today that they represent the most inferior forms of human evolution and that they are closer to children and savages that to the adult, civilized man. Revision 2006 PSB Le Bon They excel in fickleness, inconstancy, absence of thought and logic, and incapacity to reason. Without a doubt there exist some distinguished women, very superior to the average man, but they are as exceptional as the birth of any monstrosity, as for example, of a gorilla with two heads; consequently we may neglect them entirely.” Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB 1879 Technical Terms Could women be admitted to Harvard University? Could women own property? Could women vote? _______________– the use of bogus biological arguments to reinforce social discrimination. Revision 2006 PSB Moron – ______________ Imbecile – ______________________ Idiot – _________________________ Revision 2006 PSB 2 In a World with Multi-Tasking Shouldn’t This Technical Jargon Be Updated? Moron – barely able to drive and talk on a cell phone at the same time. Revision 2006 PSB Woodsian Idiocy A condition characterized by a driver of a car who causes a vehicular accident due to distraction induced by the use of a cell phone while driving, discloses this fact to the other driver, and is subsequently sued for this disclosure! Imbecile Any individual who tries to drive and text -message at the same time. Revision 2006 PSB Race and Intelligence Dr. John Langdon Haydon Down (1866) Believe that there was a parallel between human fossils, sequence of abilities of adults of lower races and whites afflicted with __________, or races, arrests, of development. Some Caucasian idiots must represents arrests of development and owe their mental deficiency to a retention of traits and abilities that would be judged as normal in adults of lower races. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Trisomy-21 Cesare Lombroso A failure to split the 21st chromosome during meiosis. Down’s syndrome (mongolism) 1/600 births. “…a a great number of typical Mongols are congenital idiots…the child’s aspect is such that it is difficult to realize that he is the child of Europeans, but so frequently are these characteristics presented, that there can be no doubt that these ethnic features are the result of degeneration…” Revision 2006 PSB Founder of criminal anthropology. Atavisms of development result in the spontaneous reappearance of __________features. a b ea e s act on o biological b o og ca co compulsions pu s o s because a Lawbreakers brutish past lurks within them. Individuals born to become criminals can be identified by the stigmata of apish morphology (long arms, receding forehead, prominent chin), and could be incarcerated to prevent a the occurrence of a future crime. (Tom Cruise movie “Minority Report”). Revision 2006 PSB 3 Origins of Intelligence Testing Alfred Binet and his colleague Théodore Simon started modern intelligence testing by developing questions that would predict children’s future progress in the Paris school system. The French government wanted to objectively identify _______and _______learners Alfred Binet and Simon (1904) - first e ge ce test es intelligence Diverse content: object naming word meanings drawing pictures from memory completing incomplete sentences constructing a sentence from three words Revision 2006 PSB Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Lewis Terman Binet The test should not measure specific knowledge acquired in school, but should measure knowledge acquired __________special special training training. 30 items: imitate gestures, follow simple commands, repeat a sentence containing 15 words, tell how two common objects differ, complete a sentence begun by the tester Revision 2006 PSB Originally defined as the ratio of mental age to chronological age, it now represents a person’s performance relative to same-age peers peers. The formula of _____________________ (IQ) introduced by William Stern. Mental Age Chronological Age Revision 2006 PSB Lewis Terman, in the US, adapted Binet’s test for American school children and named the test the Stanford‐Binet h f d Test. Revision 2006 PSB Intelligence Tests Intelligence Quotient IQ=( Intelligence as Abstract Thinking ) x 100 What do I.Q. Tests Measure? An individual’s present _________to perform certain kinds of tasks. Problem of labeling – a child’s past experience i with ith success or failure f il influences his or her achievement motivation. The most potent factor for success is not I.Q., but _______________________. Revision 2006 PSB 4 I.Q. The pine tree is evergreen; the poplar is ____. ________________ Conifer is the botanical term that is parallel with deciduous. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB PRS I.Q. "Its an ill wind that blows nobody good". Matchless (Hobbit) A A. Something bad never does anybody any good. B. Somebody always gets something out of whatever happens. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Vocabulary Unmatched, don’t go together (0). I.Q. Sanctuary Nothing like it it, priceless (+1). (+1) Having no equal, peerless (+2). Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB 5 Vocabulary Peace and quiet, seclusion (0). A place of retreat retreat, a hiding place (+1) (+1). Assessing Intelligence _____________ defining meaningful scores by comparison with the performance of a pretested “standardization standardization group” group Normal Curve A place where birds can’t be harmed (+2). Revision 2006 PSB The Normal Curve the symmetrical bell-shaped curve that describes the distribution of many physical and psychological attributes most scores fall near the average, and fewer and fewer scores lie near the extremes Revision 2006 PSB Stability or Change? Intelligence scores become stable after about seven years of age. In numerous studies such stability of intelligence scores have been ascertained (Angoff, 1988; Deary et al., 2004). Revision 2006 PSB Stability of I.Q. Do I.Q. scores change over time? About 10% of the population exhibit a 15 point change (1 SD) over an interval of 6-8 years. In extreme instances a score may change from a 90 to 150 (or the reverse) over the course of several years. As CA is incremented, your MA may keep pace with your peers, lag behind your peers, or out-pace your peers. There is nothing fixed or ____________about one’s score. However, most people retain their relative standing. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Intelligence Tests The Wechsler Scales David Wechsler developed the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS) and later the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC), an intelligence test for preschoolers. Revision 2006 PSB 6 Wechsler I.Q Tests One drawback on most I.Q. tests is that they are mainly verbal in content. An architect who designs a building is relying l i on his hi or her h intelligence, i t lli yett this ability is not assessed by most I.Q. tests. Wechsler I.Q. tests were one of the first to include performance (non-verbal) items. Revision 2006 PSB Intelligence as Abstract Thinking In 1921, a forum of 14 experts agreed that intelligence consists of the abilities to: Reason abstractly Adapt to novel environmental circumstances Acquire knowledge Benefit from experience Americans tend to view intelligence as: the capacity to reason well and learn quickly (“to think on one’s feet”) the ability to amass large amounts of knowledge Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 What is Intelligence? _________Analysis statistical procedure that identifies clusters of related items (called factors) on a test used to identify different dimensions of performance that underlie one’s total score General Intelligence (__) factor that Spearman and others believed underlies overall mental abilities measured by every task on an intelligence test Revision 2006 PSB Intelligence Tests Group Aptitude Tests During World War I, the U.S. Army developed two tests that could be group-administered. “Alpha” Alpha for those who could read English “Beta” for all other recruits Group tests are now common. Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) American College Test (ACT) Graduate Record Examination (GRE) Revision 2006 PSB What is Intelligence? Intelligence (in all cultures) is the ability to learn from experience, solve problems, and use knowledge to adapt to new situations. In research studies, intelligence is __________the intelligence tests measure … which tends to be school smarts. Revision 2006 PSB The Nature of Intelligence Spearman’s Theory of Intelligence Spearman theorized that individuals differ in general intelligence (g). To explain why correlations among tests are not perfect, he theorized that each test score is also affected by the specific ability being tested (S). Revision 2006 PSB 7 Are There Multiple Intelligences? Assessing Intelligence ____________ ___________Syndrome condition in which a person otherwise limited in mental ability has an exceptional specific skill computation drawing the extent to which a test yields consistent results assessed by consistency of scores on: two halves of the test alternate forms of the test retesting ___________ People with savant syndrome excel in abilities not related to general intelligence. Revision 2006 PSB Assessing Intelligence the extent to which a test measures or predicts what Revision it is supposed to 2006 PSB Assessing Intelligence ____________Validity ___________Validity the extent to which a test samples the behavior that is of interest driving test that samples driving tasks Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Assessing Intelligence Football 10 linemen’s 9 success Greater correlation over broad range of body weights 8 7 6 5 Little correlation within restricted range 4 3 2 1 0 180 250 success with which a test predicts the behavior it is designed to predict assessed by computing the correlation between test scores and the criterion behavior also called criterion-related validity As the range of data under consideration __________, its predictive power diminishes Extremes of Intelligence A valid intelligence test divides two groups of people into two extremes. The mentally retarded (IQ 70) and individuals with high intelligence (IQ 135) are significantly different. 290 Body weight in pounds Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB 8 The Dynamics of Intelligence Mental Retardation Mentally retarded individuals required constant supervision a few decades ago ago, but with supportive family environment and special education can now care for themselves. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Are Intelligence Tests Biased Raven's “Culture-Fair” Test The Nature of Intelligence General Intelligence (g) Neural Speed and Intelligence Person is given a series of matrices and must complete each by selecting the correct symbol for the available choices. Designed to be free of _________bias Recorded time required for brain to react to visual stimuli. Ordered subjects from slowest (1) to fastest (5) on this measure. Subjects with higher conduction speed also had higher scores on an intelligence test. Sample Item Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Brain Function and Intelligence People who can perceive the stimulus very ________tend tend to score somewhat higher on intelligence tests Processing Speed Quick witted, fast-learner… High I.Q. is correlated with rapid inspection time, and high nerve conduction d ti velocities. l iti PET studies show that high I.Q. is correlated with lower rates of brain metabolism. Stimulus Mask Question: Long side on left or right? Revision 2006 PSB Why??? Subjects with high I.Q. have more efficient brains…have to work less hard Revision 2006 PSB 9 Biological Basis of Intelligence Brain size is weakly correlated with intelligence Cerebral cortex development is slower in gifted children Intelligence is intimately involved with working and short-term memory Intelligence is located throughout the brain, but the prefrontal cortex is especially implicated Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Gardner's Frames of Mind Multiple Intelligences Gardner’s theory that there are seven types of intelligence: Linguistic intelligence Logical - mathematical intelligence Spatial intelligence Musical intelligence Bodily-kinesthetic intelligence Interpersonal intelligence Intrapersonal intelligence Revision 2006 PSB Gardner's Frames of Mind Types of Multiple Intelligences Biological Basis of Intelligence In some functional brain imaging studies, brain activity is lower in the highly intelligent (the brain may be more efficient or require less effort) People with higher intelligence also react more quickly (reaction time) Working memory ability and intelligence are highly related Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Gardner's Frames of Mind Types of Multiple Intelligences I Linguistic Intelligence Verbal ability, consists of the skills involved in speaking, listening, reading, and writing Logical-mathematical Intelligence Abstract reasoning ability, consists of the skills necessary for solving puzzles and programming computers Spatial Intelligence Visual ability, consists of the skills involved in orienting oneself in space and navigation Revision 2006 PSB Gardner's Frames of Mind Types of Multiple Intelligences Musical Intelligence Ability to appreciate the tonal qualities of sound, consists of the skills necessary to compose and play l an instrument i t t Bodily-kinesthetic Intelligence Ability to control gross and fine body movements Revision 2006 PSB Interpersonal Intelligence Abilityy to understand others,, social skills Intrapersonal Intelligence Ability to understand oneself, self-insight Revision 2006 PSB 10 Are There Multiple Intelligences? _________Intelligence the know-how involved in comprehending p g social situations and managing oneself successfully ___________Intelligence ability to perceive, express, understand, and regulate emotions Revision 2006 PSB High Emotional Intelligence Yields good techniques for countering negative moods…quick recovery. Able to motivate themselves to work longer and h d harder, delay d l ___________ (correlated ( l t d with ith achievement motivation). Develop a knack for getting along with others, able to coordinate the efforts of several people…negotiate solutions to complex problems…greater career success. Revision 2006 PSB Emotional Intelligence Recognizing and managing one’s own emotions, motivating oneself, restraining _________, handling interpersonal relationships. Some S people l are highly hi hl aware off their th i own emotions, while other seem oblivious to their own feelings. People who are ____in recognizing their own emotions, are also low in emotional expressiveness. Revision 2006 PSB Gender Differences in Emotional Intelligence Males tend to be less skilled at recognizing and expressing emotions. Males tend to over react to criticism, and this mayy lead to emotional withdrawal…prompting some spouses to intensify criticism to induce any reaction…this can backfire!!! Men need to learn that criticism may be motivated by love, and women need to learn that men tend to be hyper sensitive to criticism. Revision 2006 PSB The Nature of Intelligence The Nature of Intelligence Triarchic Theory of Intelligence Analytic - “Components” Comparing, analyzing, and evaluating This type of process correlates best with IQ Creative C ti - “Experiential” “E i ti l” Inventing or designing solutions to new problems Practical - “Contextual” Adapting to the contexts of everyday life Sternberg's Triarchic Theory Sternberg’s theory that there are three kinds of intelligence: analytic, creative, and practical practical. Revision 2006 PSB Sternberg's Triarchic Theory Revision 2006 PSB 11 The Nature of Intelligence Sternberg's Triarchic Theory Sternberg's Triarchic Theory Creativity Intellectual and motivational processes that lead to novel situations, ideas, artistic forms, or products __________Thinking The ability to think flexibly and entertain a wide range of possible solutions. __________Intelligence The ability to size up new situations and adapt to real-life demands. Revision 2006 PSB Practical Intelligence Not correlated with analytic intelligence Not dependent upon academic knowledge Dependent upon ‘tacit’ knowledge: Action oriented Achieves goals individuals personally value Acquired without direct help from others _______________correlates with knowing how to get along with others, higher salary, more promotions, & greater success in life. Revision 2006 PSB Creativity The ability to produce work that is ______and ______________to the task. Recognize which idea is worth pursuing. Sufficient knowledge about a field to advance an idea idea. Preference for novel ways of thinking and the ability to see the big picture. Willingness to take risks and tolerate ambiguity. Intrinsic rewards for creative work. The environment must support creative ideas. Revision 2006 PSB Genetic Influences Heritability the proportion of variation among individuals that we can attribute to genes variability depends on range of populations and environments studied Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB The Great Debates: Nature and Nurture Nature's Influence on IQ Scores The greater the genetic similarity between two individuals, the more similar are their IQ scores. This suggests a genetic component to intelligence. Revision 2006 PSB 12 Adoption Studies Adopted children show a marginal correlation in verbal ability to their adopted parents. Revision 2006 PSB Nurture's Influence on IQ Scores All other things being equal, two individuals raised together will have Q more similar IQ scores than those raised apart. Heredity and I.Q. Identical twins (together) = .90 Indentical twins (apart) = .75 Siblings = .50 Cousins = .15 Parents & biological children = .40-.50 Parents & adopted children = .10-.20 Unrelated individuals (together) = .25 Unrelated individuals (apart) = .00 Revision 2006 PSB Heredity & I.Q. Heredity and environment appear to be equally important. Skeels (1938, 1966) showed that orphaned children hild showed h d a 26 point i t drop d from f age 2 to t age 5 if they remained in an orphanage, and a 29 point increase if they were raised by a substitute ‘mother’. The 55 point difference is attributed to the presence or absence of adult stimulation. This is evidence that the __________ shapes intelligence in important ways. Revision 2006 PSB Environmental Influences on IQ Birth _______ Robert Zajonc (1976) - IQ decreases with increasing birth order (later studies suggested this was due to families with low IQs tending to have more children) __________ Number of school years correlates with IQ (0.5 - 0.6) Students who drop out of school end up with lower IQs than those who stay in, even when starting out with the same IQ Early Intervention Head Start program produces changes in IQ that last a few years Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Revision 2006 PSB Effects of Schooling Children from comparable schools One with 180-day year One with 210-day year Children began study performing similarly At end of study, extended-year children performed better on math (shown here) and reading tests. Revision 2006 PSB 13 Environmental Influences on IQ _______________Effects Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson gave fake data to teachers suggesting some students would experience large increases in IQ These randomly selected students experienced an IQ gain of around 4 points Poverty Arthur Jensen (1977) studied poor families in Georgia and found that children experienced a 1.5 IQ point drop per year Poverty could be associated with malnutrition, exposure to lead, and less breast-feeding Education Self-Fulfilling Prophecy:Three-Step Model The idea that a person’s expectation can lead to its own fulfillment (as in the effect of teacher expectations on student performance) Teachers with low expectations of some students may settle for lower performance from these students. Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Group Differences Stereotype Threat A self-confirming g concern that one will be evaluated based on a negative stereotype Revision 2006 PSB Race Differences in IQ On average, Hispanic and African Americans score lower than Caucasians, and Asian Americans tend to score higher African Americans have been reported to score up to 15 points lower One common interpretation: inferior schooling and other cultural disadvantages Revision 2006 PSB The Great Debates Cultural Influences Asian American students get higher grades and SAT math scores, are more likely to graduate from college, and are more likely to win i various i scholarships h l hi compared d to t their th i peers. However, research shows that their tests scores are about average. Americans, relative to those in Asian countries, may set __________standards and place ________value on educational pursuits. Revision 2006 PSB Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 The Racial Gap Education: The Great Equalizer Cognitive test scores from grades 8 – 16 Initial gap between black and d white hit students was narrowed significantly by the end of college Education has a vital equalizing role Revision 2006 PSB 14 Sex Differences in IQ Few studies have found differences in average IQ _______tend tend to have a wider distribution of IQ Gender Similarities and Differences There are seven ways in which males and females differ on various abilities. 1. Girls are better spellers 2 Girls verbally fluent large vocabularies 2. Girls verbally fluent, large vocabularies 3. Girls are better at locating objects 4. Girls are more sensitive to touch, taste, and color 5. Boys outnumber girls in counts of underachievement 6. Boys outperform girls at math problem solving but under perform at math computation Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Sex Differences in Specific Mental Abilities 7. Women detect emotions more easily than men do Revision 2006 PSB Mental rotation task Differences tend to be small: Women do better on some verbal tasks, including spelling and writing Women talk more than men (F = 20,000 words per day; M = 7,000) Men tend to do better on spatial tasks, especially mental rotation Sex differences could be due to environment Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 Do Exceptional Children Stay Exceptional? Does early ‘ripening’ lead to early ‘rot’? 1925 Terman initiated a longitudinal study of 1,528 children with an I.Q. of 130 or more (30 year follow up). Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 High Intelligence High‐scoring people on intelligence tests—contrary to popular beliefs—tend to be healthy, well adjusted, and unusually successful academically. 90% showed an increase in I.Q. scores Superior health, social adjustment Earned more academic degrees Earned 4 times the average salary No negative side effects were observed for being gifted Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB 15 Adult Cognitive Development Genius and Exceptional Intelligence Lewis Terman (1959) studied 1,500 students with IQs of about 135 or higher Findings from the “Termites” disputed many popular stereotypes of the highly intelligent: Most had above average health, and were taller and heavier than the general population They were highly successful in adulthood They had lower rates of mental illness The best predictor of exceptional career success in musicians is the amount of practice Old belief: all aspects of thinking except the amount of factual information known decline after the mid 20’s. New belief: intellectual ability continues to improve with age until the onset of trauma to the brain. Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 PRS Age and Peak Productivity What confound supported the old idea that IQ dropped with age? Cross-sectional data @ 1970 A. B. C. D. Revision 2006 PSB Age: 20 30 40 50 60 70 DOB 1950 1940 1930 1920 1910 1900 Change from rural to urban environments. Change in the average level of education. Both A and B. None of the above. Revision 2006 PSB IQ Ranges Among Professions Poetry Chemistry Medicine Math 25-29 30-34 34-39 34 39 40-44 Peak –productivity and creativity varies between fields. Revision 2006 PSB Adulthood: Cognitive Development ____________Intelligence one’s accumulated knowledge and verbal skills tends to increase with age _________Intelligence Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2009 ones ability to reason speedily and abstractly tends to decrease during late adulthood Revision 2006 PSB 16 __________________Speed Crystallized intelligence – the ability to utilize previously learned information. Fluid intelligence – the ability to form new concepts, t reason, id identify tif similarities. i il iti As A children grow older, their processing speed increases, this increases the capacity of working memory, and increments in working memory contributes to fluid intelligence. Thus, fluid intelligence correlates with processing speed. This skill declines with old age. Old Age and I.Q. 65-73 years of age – small drop 73-85 years of age – steep drop Pre-death drop – decline in average score may be due to the performance of adults near death (old healthy adults show no decline) Crystallized abilities hold up well with age Fluid abilities show a greater decline with age Revision 2006 PSB Cooperative Group Challenge Only six are used. 1. Stanford-Binet 2. Flynn 3 test bias 3. 4. Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale 5. eugenics 6. validity 7. reliability 8. specific abilities Revision 2006 PSB Q1. 1. According to Spearman, someone’s intelligence is not only dependent on his/her general intelligence or g, but also on his/her _____. Revision 2006 PSB Q2. Q3. 2. The _____ movement sought to purge low-IQ individuals from the gene pool through mandatory sterilization. 3. The most commonly used adult IQ test is the _____. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB 17 Q4. Q5. 4. The _____ of IQ tests indicates whether these tests accurately measure what they purport to measure. 5. According to the _____ effect our IQ scores are a full 15 points above those of our grandparents. Revision 2006 PSB Revision 2006 PSB Q6. 6. When a test predicts outcomes better in one group than in another group, this is known as _____. Revision 2006 PSB 18