THE CITY OF KIGALI DEVELOPMENT PLAN (CKDP) 2012/13-2017/18 DRAFT REPORT 10/21/2013 City of Kigali Forward 1 Acknowledgement The development of the City of Kigali Development Plan (CKDP) would not have been possible without the conscientious work and strong support of a number of institutions, individuals and City of Kigali. Much gratitude goes to the Mayor of The City of Kigali for providing the stewardship in development of this CKDP. The personal contribution and commitment by both the Vice Mayors in charge of Economic and Financial Affairs and also Social Affairs deserve special mention as they played a pivotal role to ensure that the CKDP captured the aspirations of the City of Kigali. The Executive Secretary and Director General ensured that all logistical support needed in the development of the CKDP was in place at all times. Great appreciation goes to the City of Kigali Technical Team comprising of the Directors of Planning, Infrastructure Development, Urban Planning, Good Governance, Health, ICT, Communication, EDPRS Monitoring and Evaluation Facilitator from MINECOFIN, Officer in Charge of Legal affairs, Education, Revenue Collection Internal Auditor and many others. This CKDP is a product of the input from these knowledge and experience endowed brains of the City of Kigali who have a good grasp of dreams and aspirations of the City. Also great appreciation goes to the City of Kigali Councilors for their political goodwill and support in the formulation of the priorities and strategies. Without their support, cooperation and contribution, this development plan would not have been possible. Special acknowledgement goes to MINECOFIN for organizing the training and organized various forums to discuss progress of the CKDP and exchange ideas with other stakeholders. The contribution and guidance by MINECOFIN staff in the National Development Planning and Research Unit (NDPR) was immense and invaluable. The National Institute of Statistics provided data that formed the basis of formulation of this CKDP Most of all, this CKDP would not have been successful without the cooperation, knowledge and contribution of the institutions and individuals and any other person who contributed who may not have been mentioned. To all, thank you very much. 2 List of Abbreviations & Acronyms BRT BTC CBD CBOs CCTVs CKDP CoK CSOs DBL DDP DHS DRC DU EAC EDPRS EICV ENR EWASA GDP HIV/AIDS ICT IFMIS IT JMEC JRLO KPL MDGs MIDIMAR MIGEPROF MINAGRI MINALOC MINEAC MINECOFIN MINELA MINICOM MINIJUST MININFRA MINISANTE MINISPOC MYICT MW NCPD NGOs : Bus Rapid Transport : Belgium Technical Cooperation : Central Business District : Community Based Organizations : Closed Circuit Televisions : City of Kigali Development Plan : City of Kigali : Civil Society Organizations : Dedicated Bus Lanes : District Development Plans : Demographic and Health Survey : Democratic Republic of Congo : Dwelling Units : East African Community : Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy : Enquête Intégrale sur les Conditions de Vie des ménages : Environment and Natural Resources : Energy, Water and Sanitation Authority : Gross Domestic Product : Human Immuno Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome : Information, Communication & Technology : Integrated Financial Management Information System : Information Technology : Joint Monitoring and Evaluation Committee : Justice, Reconciliation, Law & Order : Kigali Public Library : Millennium Development Goals : Ministry of Disaster Management : Ministry of Gender & Family : Ministry of Agriculture & Animal Husbandry : Ministry of Local Government : Ministry of East African Community : Ministry of Finance & Economic Planning : Ministry of Land & Natural Resources : Ministry of Trade & Industry : Ministry of Justice : Ministry of Infrastructure : Ministry of Health : Ministry of Sports & Culture : Ministry of Youth and ICT : Mega Watts : National Council of People with Disability : Non Governmental Organizations 3 NISR ONATRACOM : National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda : Office National de Transport en Commun OSC PFM PWDs PLWH PSCBS PSF REMA RFTC RHA RMF RNP RTDA RURA RWF SEZ SMS SSPs SWGs TVET UN USD WATSAN : One Stop Center : Public Financial Management : People with Disabilities : People Living with HIV/AIDS : Public Sector Capacity Building Secretariat : Private Sector Federation : Rwanda Environment Management Authority : Rwanda Federation of Transport Cooperatives : Rwanda Housing Authority : Road Maintenance Funds : Rwanda National Police : Rwanda Transport Development Agency : Rwanda Utilities and Regulatory Agency : Rwandan Franc : Special Economic Zones : Short Messaging Services : Sector Strategic Plans : Sector Working Groups : Technical, Vocational Educational Training : United Nations : United States Dollars : Water and Sanitation 4 Table of Contents Forward ........................................................................................................................................... 1 Acknowledgement .......................................................................................................................... 2 List of Abbreviations & Acronyms................................................................................................. 3 Chapter 1: Introduction ................................................................................................................... 6 1.1 Background of the City Development Plan .............................................................................. 6 1.2 Rationale for the CKDP ............................................................................................................ 7 1.3 Geographic Location of the City of Kigali ............................................................................... 8 1.5 Methodology Adopted ............................................................................................................ 10 1.6 City of Kigali Stakeholders ..................................................................................................... 10 1.7 CKDP Development Context............................................................................................. 12 Vision 2020 ................................................................................................................................... 12 1.8 7 Year Government Program ............................................................................................. 14 1.9 Millennium Development Goals ........................................................................................ 15 Chapter 2: Overview of City of Kigali ......................................................................................... 15 2.0 Demographic and Economic Profile of City of Kigali ...................................................... 16 Demography, Gender and Poverty............................................................................................ 16 Unemployment .......................................................................................................................... 17 2.1.3 Energy .............................................................................................................................. 17 2.1.4 Urbanization ..................................................................................................................... 17 2.1.5 Transport .......................................................................................................................... 17 2.2. Achievements/Milestones in the last Five Years ................................................................... 17 2.2.1 Transport .............................................................................................................................. 17 2.2.2 Urbanization/Housing ...................................................................................................... 18 2.2.3 Water and Sanitation ........................................................................................................ 18 2.2.4 Social Protection .............................................................................................................. 19 2.2.5 ICT ................................................................................................................................... 19 2.2.6 Education ......................................................................................................................... 19 2.2.7 Health ............................................................................................................................... 19 2.2.8. Youth............................................................................................................................... 20 2.2.9 Public Financial Management .................................................................................... 20 2.3 Development Challenges in the City of Kigali ................................................................... 21 2.3.1 Transport .......................................................................................................................... 21 2.3.2 Water and Sanitation ........................................................................................................ 21 2.3.3 Urbanization/Housing ...................................................................................................... 21 2.3.4 Environment and Natural Resources ............................................................................... 22 2.3.5 Social Protection .............................................................................................................. 23 2.3.6 ICT ................................................................................................................................... 23 2.3.7 Education ......................................................................................................................... 24 2.3.8 Health ............................................................................................................................... 24 2.3.9 Youth................................................................................................................................ 25 2.3.10 Private Sector Development .......................................................................................... 25 2.3.11 Public Financial Management........................................................................................ 26 2.3.12 Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order ......................................................................... 26 Chapter 3: The Strategic Framework ............................................................................................ 28 5 3 . 1 V i s i o n ................................................................................................................................. 28 3.2 Mission of the City of Kigali .................................................................................................. 28 3.3 Goals for City of Kigali .......................................................................................................... 28 3.4 Administrative Structures of City of Kigali ........................................................................ 29 3.5 Roles and responsibilities of the city of Kigali ....................................................................... 29 3.6 City of Kigali and Sector Priorities and their Implementation ............................................... 29 3.6.1 Transport .......................................................................................................................... 29 3.6.2 Water and Sanitation ........................................................................................................ 30 3.6.3 Urbanization/Housing ...................................................................................................... 31 3.6.4 Environment and Natural Resources ............................................................................... 32 3.6.5 Social Protection .............................................................................................................. 33 3.6.6 Health ............................................................................................................................... 34 3.6.7 ICT ................................................................................................................................... 34 3.6.8 Education ......................................................................................................................... 35 3.6.8 Education ......................................................................................................................... 35 3.6.9 Youth................................................................................................................................ 35 3.6.10 Public Financial Management........................................................................................ 36 3.6.11 Public Sector Development............................................................................................ 37 3.6.12 Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order ......................................................................... 37 3.7 Contribution to EDPRS 2 Thematic Areas/Priorities ............................................................. 38 Chapter 4: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN .............................. 42 4.1 Institutional Roles and Responsibilities .................................................................................. 42 4.1.1 Central Government Ministries and Agencies ................................................................. 42 Chapter 5: MONITORING AND EVALUATION ...................................................................... 46 Chapter 6: COST AND FINANCING OF THE DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLAN .............. 47 References ..................................................................................................................................... 48 Annexure 1: City of Kigali Priorities ............................................................................................ 49 Annexure 2: City of Kigali Targets .............................................................................................. 59 Annexure 3: Sector Outcomes ...................................................................................................... 66 Annexure 4: Cross Cutting Issues ................................................................................................. 68 Annexure 5: Challenges and Priorities of the City of Kigali ........................................................ 70 Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Background of the City Development Plan The first Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy (EDPRS 1) ended in 2012 which provided the basis for preparing the second EDPRS to guide the country‟s medium-term development aspirations over the period 2013/14 to 2017/18. EDPRS 2 will provide priorities for public spending, 6 together with key performance targets, projected financing and needs as well as monitoring and evaluation plans. In line with Vision 2020 objective of transforming Rwanda into a middle income country by 2020, the overall objective of EDPRS 2 is to increase the quality of life of all Rwandans through rapid and sustainable economic growth (11.5% per annum) and accelerated poverty reduction (to below 30%). However, in the City of Kigali, the average poverty level is 14.8% and the target is to reduce it to below 10% in the next five years. To meet these objectives, EDPRS 2 will be developed around four strategic thematic areas (Economic Transformation, Rural Development, Productivity and Youth Employment, and Accountable Governance), which will drive rapid and sustainable economic growth, as well as fast poverty reduction. EDPRS 2 will be implemented through a set of Sector Strategies and District Development Plans, which have been fully aligned to the priorities and themes of EDPRS 2. The City of Kigali Development Plan, Sector Strategic Plans (SSPs) and District Development Plans contributes to the achievement of the four thematic areas while paying attention to areas deemed as foundational and also mainstreaming key cross-cutting issues which the EDPRS 2 identified as Environment and Climate change, Gender, HIV/AIDS, Capacity Building, Disability and Social Inclusion and Regional Integration. Data from EICV 3 Report, 2011, DHS 4 among other sources has identified critical areas which require serious attention and massive investment to achieve development levels desired for City of Kigali. The current City of Kigali Development Plan 2008-12 and the Self Assessment Reports 2011 of the three districts namely, Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge provides a good basis for review and development of the new planning dispensation 2013-2018. This CKDP has been developed through an elaborate and conscious process of aligning the Sector Strategic Plans priorities with those of the City of Kigali. The aim is to achieve an integrated and coordinated development agenda for the City of Kigali and national economy. According to Organic Law N°10/2006 of 03/03/2006 determining the structure, organization, and the functioning of the City of Kigali is a real local government bestowed with administrative, legal autonomy, and especially with financial autonomy. This therefore gives the authorities the mandate to plan the City development plans, mobilize resources and monitor the implementation of those plans. It is in this respect that the City is designing this development plan along with other development plans for the 3 districts within the City namely; Gasabo, Nyarugenge and Kicukiro. 1.2 Rationale for the CKDP The Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy (EDPRS) 1 come to an end in 2012/13 planning period. Among the lessons learnt from the implementation of the EDPRS 1 was inconsistency between the Sector Strategic Plans, District Development Plans with the national development agenda set by the Ministry of Finance & Economic Planning. The inconsistency was both in identification of priority actions and timeframes when these actions were to take place. This would lead to duplication of effort or financing lapses at the district level as their district plans were inconsistent with Sector Plans which in real sense are the real 7 financing agents on behalf of the Government. In view of this, MINECOFIN has prepared an elaborate roadmap that guided the development of the EDPRS 2 to eliminate or reduce the challenges encountered in the EDPRS 1. Through consultative meetings, the City of Kigali has identified top priorities which will translate the City into a city of character, vibrant economy and diversity, green transport, affordable homes, enchanting nature and diversity, and sustainable resource management.1 The CKDP has been guided by the EDPRS 2 principles i.e. innovation, focus on emerging priorities, inclusiveness and engagement, district led development and sustainability. 1.3 Geographic Location of the City of Kigali Kigali is the capital and largest city of Rwanda. It is geographically located at the heart of Rwanda with a latitude of 1º 58‟S and a longitude of 30º 07‟ E. The city is built on numerous hills, sprawling across four ridges with valleys in between. The commercial centre is located on one of these ridges, with the administrative centre on the other. Economic Hub Kigali has been the economic, and transport hub of Rwanda ever since it became the capital upon independence in 1962. It has a population of over 1.135 million2. The rapidly growing city, Kigali is the country‟s most important commercial centre and main port of entry. It is serviced by an efficient International Airport and connected to neighboring Uganda, DRC, Tanzania and Burundi by tarmac roads. Safety Tipped as one of the safest and friendliest of African capitals, Kigali is blessed with a moderate high altitude climate that belies its tropical location, and is conveniently located within three hour‟s drive of the main tourist sites in Musanze and the Akagera National Park. The Rwandan capital provides both a comfortable and welcoming introduction to the Land of Thousand Hills and an ideal springboard from which to explore this beautiful country. Services and Recreation 1 2 District Physical Plans of Gasabo and Kicukiro Census 2012 Provisional Results 8 Kigali is a cosmopolitan city, with everything available for a diversity of interests, needs, and tastes, Hotels, Restaurants, Banks, Bureau de change/Forex Bureau, Bookshops, Markets and shopping, Souvenir shops, Car Rentals, Sports Clubs, Swimming Pools, and Night Clubs. The available hotels range from 1-Star to 5-Star rated establishments, and other not rated but comfortable Guest Houses and hotels. City of Kigali boasts a wide range of hotels catering to all tastes and budgets, and an assortment of fine restaurants. The city restaurants offer a variety of different cuisines, from the African Dishes, International Cuisine, to Italian, Ethiopian, Indian and Chinese Menu. Touristic Sites The City of Kigali sight-seeing tour includes the following sights; Gisozi Genocide Memorial Site, the Kaplaki Curio shops, the military memorial of the Belgian troops massacred during the genocide, Dr.Richard Kandt House, now turned into Rwanda Natural Museum and the Mt. Rebero panoramic viewing point. Habitat Scroll of Honor Award The Habitat Scroll of Honor award was launched by the United Nations Human Settlements Programme in 1989. It is currently the most prestigious human settlements award in the world. Its aim is to acknowledge initiatives which have made outstanding contributions in various fields such as shelter provision, highlighting the plight of the homeless, leadership in post conflict reconstruction, and developing and improving the human settlements and the quality of urban life. City of Kigali was conferred this Award in 2008 for its many innovations in building a model, modern city symbolized by zero tolerance for plastics, improved garbage collection and a substantial reduction in crime. City of Kigali is the first city authority to win this prestigious award in Africa. 9 1.5 Methodology Adopted The development of City of Kigali Development Plan has been an elaborate process which was done through intensive consultations with City of Kigali Officials, including the Mayor, the two Vice Mayors (Economic and Financial Affairs and Social Affairs) and very close collaboration with MINECOFIN. In order to provide a strong planning ground, Self Assessments Reports from the 3 districts of the City of Kigali namely; Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge were perused and emerging challenges and achievements were taken into consideration. Key consultations with stakeholders like MINALOC and other key stakeholders who have a direct or indirect interest in the City development; NISR, GMO, MYICT, MINEAC, MIDIMAR, REMA, MINISANTE, PSCBS among many others. The mandate of the City of Kigali as defined in Article 11 (2 & 3) of Organic law N°10/2006 of 03/03/2006 includes coordinating development activities and following up implementation of the national policy in the Districts of City of Kigali. It is this perspective that the development of the 3 district DDPs was done consciously and with close collaboration to avoid or reduce duplication. The success of the Development Plan would not have been realized without reliable data for planning purposes. A desk review of the EICV3 Report 2010 which highlights the demographic characteristics of the 3 districts was the initial step. This enabled the process to identify key areas that require attention to take City of Kigali to the next level. Other documents reviewed included the City of Kigali Master Conceptual Plan, District Developments for the 3 districts (Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge), previous City development Plan (2008-12), City of Kigali Health Sector Strategic Plan, and Self Assessment Reports 2012 for the 3 district, among other documents. The Sector Strategic Plans for Transport, Urbanization, Environment & Natural Resources, Public Financial Management, Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order, Social Protection, Education, Health and Water and sanitation were consulted to provide information on the Sector Priorities in the City of Kigali. Consultative meetings with key officials within the City of Kigali and other stakeholders were instrumental in elaborating the development plan. These included Directorate of Planning, Infrastructure, Health, Water and Sanitation, Social Protection, Good Governance, Youth, Urbanization, Environment etc whose input has been directly included in this document. Additional data related to prerogatives proper to the City were contributed by the technical units of City of Kigali Council. This contribution was made during planning workshops and individual interviews with Consultants entrusted with coordinating the whole exercise and drafting the provisional document. The document was discussed by the stakeholders and thereafter submitted to the leadership of the City of Kigali i.e. the City of Executive Committee and the City Council for final review and validation. 1.6 City of Kigali Stakeholders 1. MINALOC 10 MINALOC is the parent ministry of City of Kigali and is charged with the overall policy formulation, implementation and monitoring. In this City Development plan, MINALOC jointly with MINECOFIN plays a very significant role of overall coordination of development of EDPRS 2. In fact, MINALOC co –chair the National Steering Committee on the EDPRS 2. Through the decentralized system, MINALOC has actively been involved in the development of this CKDP through elected leaders in the City Council. The Mayor and the two Deputy Mayors have shepherded and midwived the CKDP through consultation and validation of City priorities and strategies. MINALOC has the overall responsibility in the implementation of the City of Kigali Development Plan 2013-18. 2. MINECOFIN MINECOFIN is responsible for setting the overall development agenda of the country through the EDPRS 2. The Ministry took a pivotal role to ensure that the CKDP and other DDPs have been developed smoothly and in line with the VISION 2020 targets. This was done through capacity building to the DDP Consultants, facilitation of meetings, monitoring of progress and quality control. The efficacy of CKDP would not have been realized without aligning the City priorities and Sector priorities. MINECOFIN supported and made available the SSPs to the districts to align their priorities to Sector ones. 3. MINELA/REMA Through the Environment Sector Strategic Plan, the City of Kigali was able to recognize its role in environmental management systems in City of Kigali. Various environment laws and policies have been given cognizant in the development of this CKDP. Issues of waste Management, wetland rehabilitation, sanitation, pollution control, greening have been guided by the overriding environment policies and laws developed by MINELA and REMA. 4. NISR CKDP process has relied mainly on quantitative economic data provided by the National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda. NISR conducted trainings on the EICV reports and usage of the same data and its implications in the development plans. All the CoK challenges identified in this Plan are borne out of the results of the data from EICV, DHS which was provided by the NISR. 5. MININFRA Infrastructure development is a key priority identified in this development plan which is an important driver towards sustainable economic development and poverty reduction. The Ministry of Infrastructure provided the strategic guidance through its own SSP for formulating roads, energy and housing strategies in this CKDP. 6. Rwanda Housing Authority The RHA mandate is to promote housing development in Rwanda. One of the key priorities in this CKDP is urbanization/housing whose strategies have been developed under the guidance of the One Stop Centre (OPC) under the Department of Urbanization in the City of Kigali. Rwanda Housing provided the broad policy guidelines for housing development in the City of Kigali. The RHA has also conducted studies on the housing sector in the City which has complimented this CKDP. 7. EWASA 11 Through EICV Report, it is evident that water and energy are major concerns for Kigali residents. Though, water and energy is a preserve of the 3 districts, it is important to note that the City has undertaken major strides in trying to illuminate the City through street lighting. It is also noteworthy that though the City of Kigali does not involve directly in water and electricity connection, it has the mandate to oversee the implementation of these amenities by the districts. 8. Development Partners a) Belgium Technical Cooperation b) UNWomen c) GIZ d) UNDP e) Arab Development Bank f) Chinese Government 1.7 CKDP Development Context Vision 2020 The Vision 2020 is a result of a national consultative process and a broad consensus on the necessity for Rwandans to clearly define the future of the country. The Rwandan population is expected to double to around 16 million by 2020. Given that the major aspiration of Vision 2020 is to transform Rwanda‟s economy into a middle income country (per capita income of about 1,240 USD per year, from 220 USD in 2000), this will require an annual growth rate of at least 11.5 %. This will not be achieved unless we transform from a subsistence agriculture economy to a knowledge -based society, with high levels of savings and private investment, thereby reducing the country dependence on external aid. The revised indicators and targets VISION 2020 by the Cabinet which have been captured comprehensively through this CKDP are as follows; Urbanization population has been revised from 30%-35%. This means that 35% of the Rwandan population will live in the urban areas. Through this CKDP, strategies have been proposed to improve affordable housing and other infrastructure to increase urbanization. To increase urbanization in the districts of Gasabo and Kicukiro which have predominantly huge areas that are rural, through guidance of the City, strategies have been proposed within their DDPs to increase clustered (imidugudu) to increase urbanization. To increase gender equality in decision-making positions to 80%, the CKDP has proposed various strategies on women empowerment especially the poor. Through empowerment programs, economic capacity is increased which gives women the confidence to undertake leadership positions. City of Kigali being the commercial and administrative hub of Rwanda occupies an enviable and pivotal position in economic direction that Rwanda must take. The City generates over 50% of the GDP and this underscores the importance of the City in the contribution to the revised average GDP growth of 11%. Through this CKDP, strategies have been proposed for infrastructural development which will form as a catalyst to 12 accelerate the GDP. Construction of road network, ICT, sewerage systems, housing etc will act as important infrastructure to attract investors for sustainable development and accelerated economic growth. Most of the industries are located in City of Kigali and therefore the City will have to contribute to the revised growth rate of the industry sector of 20% of the GDP. Various strategies proposed through this CKDP and the 3 districts DDP have identified the growth of the industrial sector as key to the national development. Establishment of the Special Economic Zones and collaboration with the private sector have been identified as key priorities in the next five years of the CKDP. The service sector revised target is 55% of the GDP. Nyarugenge district has been identified as the financial hub of the City of Kigali while Gasabo and Kicukiro districts are identified as administrative and knowledge hub respectively. Various strategies will be explored in collaboration with MINECOFIN and other stakeholders in the financial sector to not only support existing financial players in the City but also to encourage more to set up shops in Kigali. Commercial banks, pension funds, insurance companies and other financial institutions play a big role in the service sector. Hospitality and tourism industry also contribute greatly to the service sector. The implementation of the CKDP will spur the development of the service sector because infrastructural development will require financing and insurance services while urbanization will create demand for services such as education, entertainment, health services. While developing this CKDP, it was realized that most of the City of Kigali operations are manual with attendant inefficiencies attributed to manual systems. In this CKDP various strategies to boost use of ICT in the City has been proposed. It is envisaged that the shift from manual operation will result to many operations like tax payments, penalties, licence fees will be done electronically therefore contributing to the achievement of the revised target of the percentage of payment transaction done electronically to 75%. Road infrastructure has been given serious attention through this CKDP which will contribute to the achievement of the revised percentage of roads in good condition to 85%. According to the EICV 3, average satisfaction with all weather road network in Kigali is 76%. Again, this satisfaction is unevenly distributed because Kicukiro is at the level of 65%. To achieve 85%, the revised target for VISION 2020, the City of Kigali has made elaborate new road construction, rehabilitation and maintenance of the new and existing roads. Through the 3 districts, plans have also been made to improve murram roads to increase road network in good condition. Sanitation has been identified as a key challenge facing the City of Kigali. The revised target for access to improved sanitation facilities is 100%. To achieve this, the City has a herculean task to increase access to sanitation from the current 7% on use of flash toilets. This will be achieved through a two-prong approach. One, the upgrading of the informal settlements and implementation of planned urban development will definitely increase access to sanitation as these projects will have in-built modern sanitation systems. Two, the construction of the sewerage system in Kigali and the implementation of the localized sewer systems by house developers will contribute greatly to access to good sanitation in City of Kigali. The revised VISION 2020 target for percentage forest cover of land area) is 30%. However, due to the uniqueness of the City with many commercial and housing development, the Environment and Natural Resources Strategic Plan, has recommended 13 that the City forest cover can only be increased through agro forestry while retaining existing forests. Through the greening and beautification in this CKDP, strategies have been proposed to initiate planting of flowers, ornamental trees and fruits to increase the forest cover in the City. Revised poverty (% under poverty line) target is 20% though the average poverty level in the City is 14.8% . Various programs have been proposed under the social protection sector to reduce extreme poverty in the City. The relocation of people living in informal settlements and high risk areas poses a great risk to poverty reduction. Provision of services in these areas is impractical thus increasing vulnerability to poverty. The women and unemployed youth in the City also increase to poverty levels within the City. Establishing programs that target these groups in the City will boost their productivity and income generation and help to address poverty in the City and achieve the revised target of 20% and less than 10% for the City of Kigali. In this CKDP, a number of cross-cutting issues including, gender equality and sustainable environmental and natural resource management etc which have a direct influence on the achievement of VISION 2020 have been addressed. . Vision 2020 is to be achieved in a spirit of social cohesion and equity, underpinned by a capable state. Rwanda‟s ongoing development will have, at its core, the Nation‟s principal asset - its people. 1.8 7 Year Government Program Pursuant to Article 118 of the Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda, as amended to date, the Prime Minister has to present to Parliament, the Government Programme within a period of thirty (30) days after assuming office. It is in line within this provision that, on 13 th October 2010, the then Prime Minister, Right Honorable Makuza Bernard, presented to Parliament, both Chambers, in a joint session, the Government Programme for the new mandate of His Excellency the President of the Republic, Paul KAGAME, elected to lead Rwanda from 2010 to 2017. This Programme is implemented around the four pillars upon which was built on the previous mandate Programme namely: Good Governance- Political administration, Social Mobilization, Laws to promote Development, National Security and Sovereignty, Foreign Affairs, Youth Development, Gender Development, Civil Society Development, Media. Justice- Justice in general, Fighting Genocide, Fighting injustice and corruption, Upholding Protection for Human Rights Economic Development- Agriculture and Animal Resources, Trade, Industry and Tourism, Infrastructure, Improved Settlement, Private Sector, Cooperatives, and Investment Development, Land, Forestry, Environment and Natural Resources and ICT. Social Wellbeing- Labour Promotion, Health and Population Increase Control, Social Security, Protecting Vulnerable People, Sports and Leisure , Education, Research and Technology and Culture. 14 The overall goal is to shift Rwanda from a poor country to a middle income country. The CKDP has been developed in cognisance of this 7 Year Government Program to ensure that it supports and compliments attainment of the 7 Program Goals. 1.9 Millennium Development Goals The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) are eight goals that in September 2000, all 193 UN Member States have agreed to achieve by the year 2015 in order to encourage development by improving social and economic conditions in the world's poorest countries. The eight Millennium Development Goals are: GOAL 1: Eradicate Extreme Hunger and Poverty GOAL 2: Achieve Universal Primary Education GOAL 3: Promote Gender Equality and Empower Women GOAL 4: Reduce Child Mortality GOAL 5: Improve Maternal Health GOAL 6: Combat HIV/AIDS, Malaria and other diseases GOAL 7: Ensure Environmental Sustainability GOAL 8: Develop a Global Partnership for Development As a member of UN, as a country looking for a better life for its population, Rwanda has made tremendous strides in trying to achieve these MDGs. This CKDP takes note of the milestones achieved, consolidate and build on the gains through elaborate strategies. It should be noted that the City‟s direct role in achievement of the MDGs is reflected in the oversight role it has over the 3 districts (Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge). As earlier noted, the CKDP only captures activities that are funded directly through the CoK and leaves out activities that are funded directly to the districts. Therefore, the CoK through its supervisory role has ensured that the 3 districts DDPs have captured aspirations of the MDGs in their development agenda in the next five years. Chapter 2: Overview of City of Kigali The City of Kigali has undergone phenomenal growth in the last few years and most importantly after the genocide of 1994. The current EICV 2 report captures this development which has been highlighted here below. 15 2.0 Demographic and Economic Profile of City of Kigali Demography, Gender and Poverty According to the 2012 Population Census Provisional Results, Gasabo District has the highest population (274,342 males and 256,565 females) and Nyarugenge (148,242 males and 136,578 females) and Kicukiro (162,755 males and 156,906 females). 27.7% of the households in City of Kigali are female headed households, 10.3% are headed by people with diasabilities while 19.3% are headed by widows. Kicukiro district has the least poverty levels at 8.3% while Gasabo, 26% and Nyarugenge 10.1%. The poverty levels are high in Gasabo (poverty 26% and extreme poverty 13.2%), Nyarugenge (10.1% and 3.6%) and Kicukiro (8.3% and 2.8%) This demographic characteristics are very important for planning purposes. They provide both opportunities and challenges for the development of City of Kigali. 16 Unemployment Unemployment levels are high in Kicukiro district 13% compared to the other districts in City of Kigali. Gasabo and Nyarugenge districts are endowed with many public and private institutions which provide avenues for employment in these districts. It is noteworthy the Kigali CBD is located in Nyarugenge district while most government ministries are located in Gasabo district. 2.1.3 Energy The primary fuel used for lighting in the three districts is electricity but Gasabo has lower electricity connectivity than the other districts while charcoal is the primary source of fuel for cooking purposes. High usage of charcoal as a source of energy for cooking has environmental implications of deforestation. 2.1.4 Urbanization Kicukiro district has the highest unplanned urban housing (76.6) while at the same time it has highest modern planned residences in City of Kigali. There is a high proliferation of slums in Kicukiro district in Gatenga, Nyarugunga, Gahanga. Single house dwelling (above 60%) is the common types of houses in Kigali. According to EICV 3 on house ownership, majority of the residents in City of Kigali especially in Gasabo (61%) district are house owners while another big proportion are tenants. The tenant occupation is high in Kicukiro and Nyarugenge district. 2.1.5 Transport The road network in City of Kigali is generally good as over 90% of the residents have access to all weather roads. However, access to means of transport is low especially in Kicukiro district where only 50% can reach a stage within 20 minutes. It means many residents of the district walk for long distances to get transport or they use motorbikes and bicycles to reach their destinations. This situation is critical as the EICV 3 Report also indicated that vehicle (car, motorcycle, bicycle) was low in the districts. This implies that most residents rely on public transport which was inaccessible. 2.2. Achievements/Milestones in the last Five Years 2.2.1 Transport Over the last five years, the City of Kigali has undergone phenomenal development growth especially in infrastructure development. Notable infrastructural development has been done in road construction and rehabilitation as well pedestrian sidewalks. These projects have been comprehensively been undertaken to take care of the diverse road users- motorists, pedestrians, cyclists and PWDs. In this sector the following has been achieved; Asphalt roads network has increased from 106 km to over 200 km. 31.7 km of stone paved roads was constructed 99.2 km of sidewalks was constructed Tow new bus terminus of Kimironko and Kicukiro were constructed while Nyabugogo and Remera termini were rehabilitated 20 ravines of 9.8km were constructed The above projects were completed on time worth of Rwf. 68 billion. In the same period, different feasibility studies were undertaken on various roads (over 360 km) in the City of Kigali. To ease traffic congestion, the City encouraged investors to purchase higher capacity buses and over 200 Coasters were imported. The formation of the Rwanda Federation of Transport 17 Cooperatives has boosted the investment of public transport in the City. Regulations governing motorcycles were introduced and they were also encouraged to form cooperatives with remarkable success. Traffic lights were also installed to facilitate to allow for the free flow of traffic. 2.2.2 Urbanization/Housing The Kigali Conceptual Master Plan (KCMP) developed by American urban planners OZ International, was a remarkable milestone in the last five years. The Master Plan which has won five International Awards so far provides a roadmap for the development of the City up to 2030. Detailed master plans for Nyarugenge, Kimironko and Gahanga have also been developed by Singaporean company S C Surban. The detailed plans for Kimihurura, Rebero, Kanyinya and Masaka have also been developed. The implementation of the master plan has been on course with the expropriation of new CBD 9.7 ha in Kiyovu. The One stop Centre (OSC) was established to facilitate investors acquire construction permits with ease which has contributed to improvement of investment climate in Rwanda. According to World Bank Doing Business Report 2013, Rwanda was ranked 52 and also cited as one of best business reformers. Since its inception, the OSC has approved over 64 projects in commercial buildings, residential apartments, schools, hotels and other infrastructural projects. The construction of the City of Kigali also commenced during this period and the building is near completion and occupation before the end of the 2012/13 financial year. In real estate development, the Akumunigo, Rugarama, Batsinda, Kinyinya, Gacuriro, Special Economic Zones, Industrial area, Ubumwe area in Muhima and Kimisange site have been secured and construction works commenced. During this period, many households were resettled in rural settlements to allow modern urban development. To enhance the City‟s „green and clean‟slogan, several greening projects was undertaken along major roads with a total distance of 43 km, development of green gardens covering 15 hectares and construction of aesthetic retaining walls along the major roads which has contributed greatly to greening and beautification. The City also organized a cleanliness and environment protection contest which has contributed to the increase of number of youth cooperatives promoting the city‟s greening campaign. Street lights on 40 km were also installed. 2.2.3 Water and Sanitation It is important to note that the City of Kigali has no big role in the provision of water in the City. This role is jointly taken by EWASA and the 3 districts that comprise the City of Kigali i.e. Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge. However, the City has a major responsibility in the sanitation and waste management. In the last 5 years, the design study for sewerage system for CBD1 and CBD2 has been finalized and it is awaiting implementation in the ensuing financial periods. The Nyanza landfill has continued to serve and the City has undertaken its maintenance and management. A new landfill has been designed and established in Kigali Sector which will ease the pressure on the Nyanza site. Design of compost site was also undertaken. Other achievements in this sector are the construction of public toilets and installation of street bins in collaboration with the private sector. 18 2.2.4 Social Protection The CoK has been actively involved in supporting the vulnerable groups in the City. Over the last 5 years, the City has supported the creation of cooperatives of different groups especially the poor and unskilled women and youth. Technical assistance has been offered to these cooperatives in designing projects, marketing skills, business plans etc. In conjunction with Imbuto Foundation, and RDB, the City of Kigali helped to create a weaving cooperative of women in Gitega. Many women involved in unsustainable activities in the City have joined this Agaseke Project. Over 5,000 women have joined and trained in weaving baskets, trays, earrings, beads and paper necklaces. This Project has attracted many development partners like UN Women. These activities have helped not only protecting these women from social vulnerability but it has also prevented them from sliding back into illicit activities which they were previously involved. 2.2.5 ICT The following achievements have been realized in the City of Kigali in the ICT sector; The City has installed an internal document tracking system that facilitates the employees to share documents freely and in real time. This has increased efficiency as information can be accessed more easily by the staff quickening decision making and implementation. Upgrading of the website Installation of the server with a huge capacity Implementation of the One Laptop Per employee Installation of Management Information System in urban planning which facilitates online application for construction licenses Installation of DIS Tax Software in revenue collection management Adoption of fibre optics for internet Installation for Intranet for all staff emails management Procurement of many ICT equipments like computers, printers, scanners etc. 2.2.6 Education It is also important to note that the development of education in the City is a preserve of the districts while the City of Kigali role is inspection to ensure quality of education is maintained in the schools. Overall, education has made tremendous progress in the last 5 years. Through the districts many classrooms under the 9YBE spearheaded by the Ministry of Education. Inspections have been carried out on teaching methods in primary and secondary schools to improve on the quality of education. The One Laptop per Child (OLC) project has been successful among the schools in Kigali. Reading and writing competitions has been held taking advantage of the newly opened Kigali Public Library in Gasabo District. Net primary school enrolment has improved to 93.9 % while net secondary enrolment is 42%. The literacy level in the City is 89%. 2.2.7 Health Health services were decentralized to the districts and construction of health centres was done at that level. In collaboration with CTB and AIMF, three health centres were constructed in Rugarama, Busanza and Bumbogo while seven hospitals and health centres (Muhima, Kibagabaga, Betsaida, CORUNUM, Nzove dispensary, Gitega, Mwendo) were expanded. 19 Health insurance services have also been expanded in the City with the support of Intrahealth and it has reached over 92%. Public health rules were formulated and disseminated which has improved health and hygiene in public facilities like hotels, restaurants, schools etc. Regular inspections to these establishments including places of worship have been intensified to reduce hygiene related diseases. A mobile health unit was launched with the support from Global Forum which enables health workers to offer subsidized medical services to remote parts of the City. 2.2.8. Youth Youth unemployment, delinquency and drug abuse have been identified as the major challenges afflicting the youth in the City of Kigali. Over the years, the City has undertaken proactive measures to address these challenges. Some of the achievements can be enumerated as below; The City has facilitated the creation of many youth cooperatives among the youth. Of great importance are the cooperatives that participate in the cleaning, greening and beautification of the City. Other cooperatives that the City has facilitated their creation are motorcyclists, taxi drivers, market traders, shopkeepers, etc. This has contributed immensely to the cleaning, greening and beautification of the City. These cooperatives have complimented the City‟s efforts in making the City „clean and green‟. The other great achievement is the performance contracting the City has done with these cooperatives. Over 80 cooperatives have signed the contracts with the Mayor of Kigali and an evaluation is done to see whether they have achieved their commitments. The City recognizes the high achievers and this motivates them to achieve more in their respective activities. This has resulted to highly motivated and positively sensitized youth in the City. The youth have developed a high sense of patriotism and responsibility. 2.2.9 Public Financial Management The PFMS requires that all government financial transactions are properly recorded in accounting records that are transparently available to all citizens and organisations within Rwanda, and have been subject to independent audit. The PFMS also sets clear rules and procedures for procurement which have to be adhered to in order to protect public funds. The City‟s procurement systems have not been very effective and transparent which has led to over accumulation of pending payments to suppliers. The procurement plan was prepared by the procurement team but it used to be approved without much scrutiny by the officers concerned. However, over the last years, the City has improved compliance with PFMS to over 70%. The audit queries have greatly reduced while audit recommendations have been implemented. Most of the staff is now sensitized on the procurement procedures and they are strictly observing which has reduced the delays in acquiring goods as well as reduced the period for effecting payments. Transparency and professionalism have also been inculcated in the recruitment process to ensure that the City gets the right cadre of staff. Recruitment is now done through advertisement following directives from Prime Ministers and Public Service Commission. 20 2.3 Development Challenges in the City of Kigali 2.3.1 Transport According to the EICV Report, only 24% of the City population takes less than 20 minutes to get to a stage for public transport. This indicates that the road network and public transport are two critical issues that have to be addressed in the City of Kigali. The same Report shows that over 70% of the City commuters either walk long distances or use motorbikes to access public transport. This scenario translates to not only high transport costs but also high transit time from one point of town to the other. Time and cost and inhibit efficiency and increases cost of living in the City with a direct effect on urban poverty. Drastic measures to build new, rehabilitate and expand existing road network have been contemplated in this CKDP in the next five years. Because of the rapid development of City of Kigali, there has been a massive increase in the number of motor vehicles plying within and out of Kigali. This has created serious strain on the transport infrastructure. Increase of population from less than 1 million in 2007 to over 1.2 million in 2012 has also exerted a lot of pressure on other infrastructural facilities like energy, water and sanitation etc. The population is projected to rise to close to 2 million within the EDPRS 2 period. The pedestrian walkways are limited and it makes it difficult for the City residents who want to walk or jog. 2.3.2 Water and Sanitation As indicated by the ECIV 3 Report, 2010, only 8.2% of the city population using flashes toilets. This situation is caused by the lack of centralized sewerage system and prevalence of unplanned housing development in City of Kigali among other factors. The runoff impact of unmanaged storm water on people and environment is another critical challenge facing the City of Kigali. Poorly maintained infrastructure causes erosion of usable land, increases flooding, and endangers private and public infrastructure including human life. Combined with poor liquid and solid waste collection in urban settlements, runoff also carries pollutants such as hydrocarbons, heavy metals, bacteria, sediment, pesticides and fertilizers into streams or groundwater threatening environmental health. The ongoing fast urban growth in Kigali increases storm water volumes, erosion risks and the danger of inundations all over the country (WATSAN Policy 2010)3. The City of Kigali has undertaken considerable efforts to maintain the urban environment clean and plastic bags are forbidden within the country as directed by the Rwanda Environmental Management Authority. The challenges in the City arise at all stages of waste collection, storage and disposal. According to ENR Sector Strategy 2012, Kigali‟s waste contains still 70% of organic, biodegradable waste. Currently, waste sorting, composting and recycling activities have been initiated. The City operates a dumpsite which receives about 400 tons per day of solid, not sorted waste or 140‟000 tons per year. Deep seated fires, methane explosions, landslides and leakages threatening rivers and groundwater are some of the common problems of such basic dumpsites. 2.3.3 Urbanization/Housing According to the Housing Market Study 2012, the City of Kigali has a supply gap of 344,068 units by 2022 in different housing typologies like social housing, affordable housing, mid range housing and premium housing. This translates to an average of over 30,000 units must 3 WATSAN SSP 2013-18 21 be constructed every year to meet this demand. Further, the houses that are currently under construction are not affordable to majority of the citizens. Existing housing stock in good condition amounts to 42,710 DU. Housing stock that is upgradable amounts to 71,487 DU. The following is the housing demand under different categories; Social Housing- 21,718 DU (12.62%) This is a housing typology that is affordable by households below the poverty line, earning less than Rwf.35, 500 per month (USD 59 per month). It has been recommended that this type of demand be addressed by the government through a subsidy system. Affordable Housing: 93,081 DU (54.11%) This is demand for households earning between RWF 35,500 to 200,000 per month (USD 329 per month). It is the largest segment of the market. These households have some payment capacity and could access a special rental market which may include, for instance, rent-toown leasing mechanisms etc. In this category, the Report on Housing Demand in City of Kigali recommends that upgradeable housing may be included. Mid-range Housing 56,433 DU (32.8%) This subcategory includes a wide variety of income segments from approximately RWF 200,001 per month (USD 330 per month) up to 2,500,000 RWF per month (USD 4,111 per month). It is the second largest segment and most of it may be eligible for traditional mortgage financing. Premium Housing: 801 DU (0.46%) This is housing demand for the highest income segments of Kigali, with monthly income of RWF 2,500,001 and above. From the above, it is clear that affordable housing is a great challenge in the City of Kigali. Other challenges that require attention in the next five years are as follows; development of more commercial buildings, development of public parks and plazas, installation of more street lighting, improvement in the greening and beautification 2.3.4 Environment and Natural Resources City of Kigali has an important role to play in developing the sustainable environment. Most environmental degradation is as a result of industrial development which naturally occurs in the urban centers first before they permeate into the rural. The following challenges have been identified in this sector; Depletion of forest covers through human settlements and other economic activities. City of Kigali forest land has not been spared by the infrastructural developments in the area. Conservation of forests in the City is always overtaken by the need to build infrastructure and other commercial buildings. Existence of wetland areas. The productive and regulatory functioning of ecosystems must restored, maintained or enhanced by rehabilitating, conserving and sustainably managing critical ecosystems and biodiversity within the City of Kigali. With the enactment of the wetland law, City of Kigali will continue to work closely with other actors to ensure that the wetland areas in the City are protected. City of Kigali will continue collaboration with MINICOM, PSF and other stakeholders to oversee the relocation of industries from Gikondo valley to reduce on the environmental pollution 22 (water and air) emanating from these industries. The KCMP has identified how these wetlands can be conserved and bring economic value. Environmental sustainability principles and climate change issue must be addressed effectively and mainstreamed into all city activities, policies, programmes, plans and budgets. This is to endeavor to reduce climate change effects and water related disaster risks and climate impacts like droughts and floods to protect the economy and society. City of Kigali is an important stakeholder in this process. Periodic floods and droughts (extreme events) already cause major socio-economic impacts and reduce economic growth in Rwanda and in particular, City of Kigali. Major flood events occurred in 1997, 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009, where rainfall resulted in infrastructure damage, fatalities and injuries, landslides, loss and damage to agricultural crops, soil erosion and environmental degradation. A study of the Nyabugogo River Plain found that flood damages occur each rainy season, which lead to direct (damage) and indirect effects, particularly to informal settlements4. It is therefore important to integrate climate change strategies in this development plan. 2.3.5 Social Protection The 2005 Social Protection Policy defines social protection, as “a set of public and private initiatives that provide income or consumption transfers to the poor, protect the vulnerable against livelihood risks and enhance the social status and rights of the marginalized; with the overall objective of reducing the overall social and economic vulnerability of the poor, vulnerable and marginalized groups.” Rwanda‟s definition of social protection incorporates four principles: protection, prevention, promotion and transformation. Social protection is protective - it provides essential support to those living in poverty. It is also preventive - it puts in place a safety net that can be activated to catch people in danger of falling into poverty. It is promotive – it supports poor people‟s investment so that they can pull themselves out of poverty. It is transformative – it aims to improve the social status and rights of the marginalized5. Some of the challenges that have been identified in this sector are as follows with respective priorities; The existence of informal settlements and people settling on high risky hilly areas poses a great challenge to the City of Kigali as it renders these populations vulnerable to natural shocks and calamities of life such as landslides, floods, disease out breaks etc. The second challenge under this sector is high level of urban employment average 12%, prevalence of vagrants and beggars on the City streets. Unemployment has its negative social results like crime, prostitution, social disorder etc. 2.3.6 ICT According to the EICV3 results, the average percentage of households in City of Kigali who owned at least one mobile phone is 80.4% while those who own a computer is 10.6%. The number of households that have never used a computer in the City is very high at 75% while those who use internet regularly is only is 8.6%. This information reveals that ICT penetration 4 5 Economics of Climate Change in Rwanda, 2009 SSP Social Protection, 2012 23 in City of Kigali is still low except for mobile phone. Currently, most of the CoK operations are manual which slows down service delivery and rapid results to the City residents. 2.3.7 Education According to the EICV Report, 2010, City of Kigali has an average of 93.9% net primary school enrolment rate (children 7 to 12 years old), 42.0% net secondary school enrolment rate (children 13 to 18 years old), 21.7% for computer literacy rate for persons 15 years and older and 87% literacy rate for persons 15 years and older. The Vision 2020 has a target of 100% enrolment target for primary school and 60% for secondary schools which is also the target for the City. The Ministry of Education has developed the Education Sector Strategic Plan which guides and supports the achievement of the EDPRS objectives, in line with the Seven Year Government Programme and the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), specifically the goals on achieving Universal Basic Education and promoting gender equality. This ESSP becomes the basis for City of Kigali Development Plan in addressing the provision of affordable and quality education to City dwellers. It is important to note that though education is a very important sector in the national development agenda, the CoK is restricted to inspectorate role only. The strategies for the development of education in the City are aptly elaborated through the 3 DDPs which are annexed to this CKDP. This is borne from the fact that MINEDUC channels funding for education projects directly to the districts. However, it has been pointed out that the reading and writing culture in Kigali is low. While opening the first public library in Rwanda, Her Excellency the First Lady said “This library is much more than a building filled with shelves of books; it‟s a gateway and window to the world. On the pages of the countless books are opportunities for our youth to create a limitless universe, one where they satisfy their curiosity and feed their imagination while developing personal values,” The First Lady noted that the cultivation of a reading culture through the library was part of the government‟s wider development agenda. The CoK recognizes the power of reading and writing as the adage goes „you are what you read‟. In this regard, during the next five years, the City in collaboration with the Ministry of Sports and Culture will initiate construction of public libraries in each of the three districts in Kigali. Reading and writing competitions will also be conducted among the city schools. 2.3.8 Health The City of Kigali Strategic Plan for Health Development (2012-16) has identified the following as major challenges facing the health sector in City of Kigali; Uneven distribution of health centers in the Sectors (Sectors 35 to 29 HC while 10 sectors have no public or licensed HC); • One health center covers an average of 40,000 inhabitants (standard = 20,000); • Poor geographical access to health centers in the rural areas of City of Kigali; • Congestion and overcrowded and always characterized by long queues in health centers in the City center. • Lack of enough skilled personnel in the health facilities in City of Kigali. • Lack of sufficient medical equipments in the health facilities. It has also been proposed that Kibagabaga hospital which is the district hospital for Gasabo district to be elevated to a provincial hospital. This leaves the district without a district 24 hospital. In the same breath, Muhima hospital has been elevated to be a Centre of Excellence in Maternity and Neonatology while Masaka Hospital has been elevated as a National Teaching and Referral Hospital to take over the mandate from CHUK. It is therefore clear that all district hospitals in City of Kigali have acquired new status which leaves a gap in the medical chain. This calls for more resources to upgrade some health centers into district hospitals. Over 20 health centers are required to be constructed in City of Kigali in the next five years in order to improve the access of medical services to the City residents. This requires massive resource mobilization from MINISANTE and Development Partners in order to realize the standard of one health center covering an average of 200,000 inhabitants. 2.3.9 Youth Most of the problems facing today‟s youth are not restricted to only rural or urban youth, but affect young people generally. Most discussions on youth in Rwanda and elsewhere have focussed on issues such as drug abuse, crime, violence, sexuality and poverty. In addition to these, today‟s youth are afflicted by new challenges which include; An Identity Crisis: Who am I? Lack of self confidence and low self esteem: I am worthless A sense of hopelessness: Where am I going? Confusion and ambiguity concerning moral issues: What is right and wrong? The negative impact of the electronic media: Entertainment? Competitiveness in education: the uneven playing field: Excellence by whom? Not Me. The above challenges affect the youth in Kigali. Some of the youth cannot be employed in gainful employment as they have no skills. 2.3.10 Private Sector Development The Private Sector Development Strategic Plan (PSDSP) 2013 has extolled all its key institutions and stakeholders to follow the following mission while aligning private sector priorities in their development plans; Unlock the constraints to private sector-led investment and growth in terms of infrastructure, skills, finance, market failures and regulation through an ongoing process of listening and feedback To increase the quality and quantity to a broader range of industries in additional to traditional sectors The increased investment will deliver more secure and well paid jobs for Rwandans by increasing the number of jobs created in the formal sector be they from large, medium and small enterprises. It is therefore incumbent upon the City of Kigali to align its private sector priorities to the above vision so that the private sector can further develop and grow in the City and generate more quality jobs. 25 2.3.11 Public Financial Management The PFM Sector Strategy 2012 envisages that effective and efficient Public Financial Management (PFM) must operate throughout the Government sector. The strategy emphasizes that essentially the government must ensure that: All public revenues stipulated by law are properly levied and collected All expenditures incurred within the public sector are properly authorised and are spent in accordance with approved budget decisions and government financial regulations and rules All government financial transactions are properly recorded in accounting records that are transparently available to all citizens and organisations within Rwanda, and have been subject to independent audit The citizens of Rwanda are assured that their publicly provided finances are being spent wisely on the delivery of desirable public services and that every possible effort has been taken to eliminate corrupt and fraudulent practices In this context, the Government‟s strategy for implementing effective and efficient PFM can be summarised as follows; The creation at the central core of government of an Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS) which will be under the direct control of MINECOFIN. This will be the home of all key accounting information on Budgets, Budget Execution and Revenues. The development of other specialised IT financial information systems, such as payroll, human resources, tax & customs revenues, debt management, etc, which will all be linked to the central IFMIS A government review process which ensures that all laws, regulations and rules are regularly reviewed to ensure that they remain relevant, effective, efficient and conducive to the delivery of excellent standards of public services. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, ensuring that public sector staff fully understand their PFM responsibilities, and have been given the opportunities to develop their PFM knowledge and capacities. The aim is to ensure that a properly trained cadre of PFM staff is operating throughout all areas of the public sector6. According to Article 74 of the Organic Law No 37/2006 of 12 September, 2006 on State Finances and Property, all public bodies are responsible for ensuring implementation of the instructions of the Auditor General of State Finances aimed at improving the effective management of finances of the entities. The Auditor General‟s Report 2010-11 for City of Kigali revealed that contrary to the above requirement, an assessment of implementation of previous audit recommendations revealed that only 39% of the recommendations were implemented. This exposes the City of Kigali to State Finances and Property risks of misappropriation and accountability. In the next five years i.e. during this CKDP period, the City shall endeavour to implement in full the recommendations of the Auditor General Reports and achieve a compliance of 100%. 2.3.12 Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order The Sector‟s goal is Strengthened rule of law to promote accountable governance, a culture of peace, and enhanced poverty reduction. This means strengthening the consolidation of the norm (established in international law and in the Rwandan Constitution) 6 PFM Sector Strategy, 2012 26 that the law must apply equally to everyone. Everyone in Rwanda should have equal access to the protection the law affords, and should be equally bound by the responsibilities the law imposes. Access to justice is a fundamental right, as well as a key means to defend other rights. It is essential for poverty eradication and human development as well as a means to address inequalities in power, an important precondition to achieve MDGs, etc. Article 11 (5) of the Law establishing City of Kigali bestows the Mayor of Kigali with the legal mandate of ensuring the security of people and their property in the City of Kigali. The Mayor chairs Security meetings of City of Kigali. In this regard, the City shall work closely with JRLO Sector especially the Rwanda National Police on the following strategies to ensure safety, law and order is maintained and adherence to human rights; Over the years, the City has been involved in a myriad of litigation cases which drains the institutional resources and goodwill from the litigants. In this CKDP period, the City proposes to reduce litigation costs by adopting alternative dispute resolutions. With support from MINIJUST, the City will endeavor to utilize out of court settlements, mediation, negotiation and arbitration as strategies to resolve disputes. Community participation and awareness of crime prevention improved. World over, cities are the high targets for crime and Kigali is not exceptional. The City will create awareness through various administrative levels to prevent or reduce crime in the City. Crime prevention capacity improved. The City of Kigali will continuously work with RNP in installing CCTVs cameras for security surveillance. The City will also sensitize private institutions to have modern security installations in their buildings and premises to prevent crime. 27 Chapter 3: The Strategic Framework This five-year City Development Plan provides a clear roadmap in the City‟s implementation of its priorities and strategies. The Kigali City Development Plan reflects the vision mission statement for the City and captures the national goals of economic growth and poverty reduction: 3.1 Vision The Centre of Urban Excellence in Africa” 3.2 Mission of the City of Kigali “To Build and Sustain a City of Character, Vibrant Economy and Diversity through Strong Partnership with Stakeholders to Provide Responsive, Rapid and Effective urban development Kicukiro Knowledge Hub Gasabo Administrative Hub Nyarugenge Financial Hub 3.3 Goals for City of Kigali City of green transport City of affordable homes City of enchanting nature and diversity 28 City of sustainable resource management 3.4 Administrative Structures of City of Kigali The Council of the City of Kigali The Executive Committee of the City of Kigali The Security Committee of Kigali The Executive Secretariat of Kigali 3.5 Roles and responsibilities of the city of Kigali Coordinating the activities of strategic plan Coordinating development activities of the district Follow-up of the implementation of the national policy in the districts Ensuring the security of the people and their Providing services which are delivered at administrative structures in the city of Kigali. 3.6 City of Kigali and Sector Priorities and their Implementation 3.6.1 Transport According to the Transport Sector Strategic Plan 2013-18, the sector contributes considerably to poverty reduction and growth and serves as a support to other economic sectors. It contributes 7% to the GDP and represents 15% of total service delivery. In order for City of Kigali to develop an integrated transport system during the EDPRS-2 time period that serves the aspirations and expectations of the city residents, the bottom-up approach will be used and efforts will be made to involve all relevant stakeholders like the 3 Districts (Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge), Ministry of Infrastructure, Rwanda Transport Development Agency (RTDA), Rwanda Utility and Regulatory Authority (RURA), Road Maintenance Funds (RMF), ONATRACOM, RFTC, bus operators, taxi operators, motorcycle taxi operators and other stakeholders. According the TSSP, the total paved roads in the City are only 153 Kms while the unpaved ones are 864 29 Kms. This shows that 85% of the roads in Kigali are not in motor able condition and this reduces economic development and accelerates poverty. Persistent traffic jams and congestion on existing roads is also prevalent on the City roads. So far, the public transport serving the city routes has not been effective to provide seamless flow of people within and out of the city. In fact, during peak hours i.e. morning and evening there is overcrowding in bus stages is a common phenomena. To address, priorities and strategies have been identified to be given attention in the next five years as below; Strategies Construct 28.4 km of asphalt roads Construct 100 km stone paved roads Rehabilitate 29.5 km Maintain all paved roads Expand 17 km along the major public transport corridors Construct 6 interchanges road junctions Create dedicated bus lanes on expanded roads Secure 17 km land for Bus Rapid Transport (BRT) corridor Improve Nyabugogo intercity bus terminal Construct pedestrian bridges Construct sidewalks on the existing and new roads Build capacity for civil engineers and other infrastructure development professionals Promote gender equity in construction projects Mainstream HIV/AIDS awareness in construction projects Priorities Improve Road network Reduce Traffic Congestion Integrate public transport system Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building Gender & Family HIV-AIDS 3.6.2 Water and Sanitation Data from the EICV 3 reveals that very few Rwandan households (1.7%) have installed flush toilets (8%) in City of Kigali. The Water and Sanitation Strategic Plan 2013-18 has elucidated that the prevailing practice remains that water is used for cooking and washing (grey water, discharged mostly on surface) while the excreta is disposed with waterless latrines (92.2%), which is a rational solution considering the scarcity of the average water supply. Rwanda has not yet invested sufficiently in collective (water-borne) sanitation systems for densely populated urban areas, except 3 small sewerage systems in Kigali for about 700 households‟ altogether. Major hotels, hospitals and some industries have installed their own 30 (pre-) treatment systems. A conventional sewerage and treatment system for Kigali‟s centre is in the planning process and will be implemented in this CKDP period in CBD1 and CBD2. To address the above the following priorities and accompanying strategies have been proposed; Strategies Construction of new sanitary landfill and recycling center in Kigali Sector Construction of incinerator plant Construction public toilets in petrol stations and designated areas Implement wastewater and storm water master plan in affected areas Construction of centralized sewerage system Integrate disability friendly toilets in public toilets Build capacity for waste management and recycling techniques Promote gender in waste recycling activities Priorities Improve solid waste management Improve access to sewerage and sanitary facilities Improve storm water drainage system Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building Gender & Family 3.6.3 Urbanization/Housing The EICV 3 reveals that unplanned urban housing in the City of Kigali is average 65.8% while modern planned area is 2.6%. This has led to mushrooming of single house dwelling 64.7%. This scenario poses the challenges of providing infrastructure for water supply, sanitation and waste water, power, waste management, drainage and storm water management. The high concentrations of such dwellings also pose the risks of evacuation in case of emergencies or calamities. The KCMP reckons that, based on analysis of natural constraints at the regional scale including topography soils, wetlands and forests approximately 50% of the land in Kigali is ill suited for new development based on scientific and ecological principles. Specifically, 25,785 hectares (or around 35% of the area in Kigali) are located in slopes that are greater than 20%, and 10,109 hectares (or 14% of land area) are located in wetlands leaving 37,000 hectares for development7. The Vision 2020 has set a target of 35% urban population in Rwanda. The development of this CKDP has taken into consideration the above constraints while proposing the following priorities and strategies to address housing/urbanization issues in the City in the next 5 years. 7 KCMP 2007 31 Strategies Create 1,744 ha land bank to support affordable housing Facilitate investors to implement affordable housing projects on identified sites through OSC Create 25 ha land bank and facilitate investors for commercial building development Secure land bank for 2 public parks and plazas Install 85 km street lights to new and existing roads Integrate beautification and greening in all road construction projects Build capacity for urban planning and other housing development professionals Promote investment of housing to regional housing developers Prioritize Gender, PWDs, PLWH in social housing Promote green energy technologies in new housing development and street lighting Mainstream HIV/AIDS awareness in housing projects Integrate disability friend toilets in all commercial development housing Priorities Increase access to affordable housing Increase commercial buildings development Establish public parks and plazas Increase street lighting on existing and new roads Improve greening and beautification Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building Regional Integration Disability & Social Inclusion Gender & Family Environment & Climate Change HIV/AIDS 3.6.4 Environment and Natural Resources By protecting the economy and society from water disasters and climate impacts like droughts and floods, it helps to preserve incentives for investment and protection of investments in the City. Gikondo Valley has over the years overseen the proliferation of an industrial area where many economic activities which have created employment and also boosted Rwanda‟s export base. However, the enactment of wetland law has rendered the valley unfit for industrial production. It is envisaged that the industries will be located to Special Economic Zones 32 (SEZ) by MINICOM and the City of Kigali jointly with other stakeholders shall undertake to rehabilitate the valley. This five-year program will enhance natural storage through wetlands rehabilitation, sub-surface water storage, and rainwater harvesting. These activities will bring forth a number of ancillary benefits, such as increased water use efficiency and in the case of wetlands, increased carbon storage. Rehabilitation of wetland areas in the City of Kigali will create space for storm water and reduce flooding while contributing to national life. The CoK intends to create artificial dams for recreation and nature in the City. Priorities Rehabilitate wetland areas Strategies Rehabilitate Gikondo Valley and Nyabugogo wetland areas 3.6.5 Social Protection Rwanda‟s definition of social protection incorporates four principles: protection, prevention, promotion and transformation. Social protection is protective - it provides essential support to those living in poverty. It is also preventive - it puts in place a safety net that can be activated to catch people in danger of falling into poverty. It is promotive – it supports poor people‟s investment so that they can pull themselves out of poverty. It is transformative – it aims to improve the social status and rights of the marginalized. The integration of these four dimensions of social protection will be critical to supporting many households to sustainably graduate out of extreme poverty during the EDPRS2 period. The purpose of this strategy is to guide the work of all social protection actors during the EDPRS2 period, supporting harmonization of efforts behind the agreed policy and a common set of objectives, in order to maximize impact. In realization of the above principles, the City has identified people living in informal settlements and high risk areas as a priority under the social protection sector. Often, the inhabitants of these places are poor, through the protective and preventive principles, the City intends to upgrade the informal settlements while relocated those in the hilly areas to cushion them from more vulnerability to poverty. Priorities Reduce informal settlements Reduce settlements on high risk areas Strategies Upgrade at least 2 informal settlements Relocate people living in at least 2 hilly areas Provide special mechanisms for relocation of women, PLWH and the PWDs Cross-Cutting Issues Disability & Social Inclusion Gender & Family 33 3.6.6 Health The elevation of Muhima hospital to a Centre of Excellence in Maternity and Neonatology and Masaka Hospital to a National Teaching and Referral Hospital has left a gap of district hospital within the two districts. The health value chain in Rwanda identifies a health out post or dispensary as the first contact with the patient. The patient can then be referred to a health centre, later to a district hospital before being transferred to a referral hospital for various serious complications. In the absence of a district hospital, this chain has a gap that has to be filled urgently. It is there therefore critical that two hospitals are constructed in the two districts within the next five years. HIV-AIDS pandemic continues to pose challenges not only on the health care but also on the socio economic aspects of the City. HIV-AIDS victims exert pressure on scarce health resources while it also creates a population that is economically dependent as some of them are not actively in economic activities that can generate income. The City undertakes to map these populations that are exposed to HIV-AIDS in order to put early preventive and protective measures well in advance. It has been noted that many youngsters and people of other ages throng the City for their first time in search of opportunities. They are excited with the urban life and when they get jobs, they become vulnerable to engage themselves into illicit sexual activities which predispose them to the HIV-AIDS. Mapping of such groups of populations will be critical in addressing the pandemic. Strategies Construct two District (Nyarugenge & Kicukiro) Hospitals Map key population highly exposed to HIV-AIDS infection Build capacity for health workers both public and private Priorities Expand Health infrastructure Mapping key population highly exposed to HIVAIDS infection Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building 3.6.7 ICT The ICT Strategic plan establishes a framework in which to fit the existing and proposed solutions, infrastructure investments and determines a framework for setting priorities. It also identifies the core systems and supporting resources and investment required over the medium term, it identifies the management and technical policies that determine the means and the ground rules by which information systems will be developed and managed. The City of Kigali is poised to be the hub of ICT in Rwanda and linking Rwanda into the global ICT network. Continued use of manual systems in the City hamper service delivery and reduce 34 economic growth. Through this CKDP, the City intends to implement the following priorities identified and accompanying strategies. Priorities Improve navigation in the City Improve use of IT 3.6.8systems Education in management of city affairs Strategies Install navigation system in the City Install ICT systems to manage city affairs Build capacity on use and utilization of ICT systems Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building 3.6.8 Education Education is a critical factor in accelerating economic development. However, most of the sector activities are funded and executed at the district level. Therefore the priorities and strategies for this sector in relation to Kigali are captured in two districts of the city i.e. Nyarugenge and Kicukiro. It is noteworthy that the current public library is located in Gasabo District. Strategies Establish public libraries in the 2 districts Conduct reading competitions in the 3 districts Promote participation of girl child in reading/writing competition Promote access of reading materials for visually impaired Priorities Promote reading and writing culture Cross-Cutting Issues Gender & Family Disability & Social Inclusion 3.6.9 Youth Youth is a very important sector in this CKDP and the EDPRS 2 development agenda. In fact, the sector is also identified as a key thematic area to accelerate economic development through youth employment and productivity. The youth must only be employed but they must be engaged in productive and gainful employment. The revised Vision 2020 target envisages 35 that the economy must generate 1.7 million off-farm jobs. These jobs will mainly be in the agro-processing, agri-business, manufacturing and service sector and must benefit the youths. Strategies Establish Kigali Employment Service Centre Prioritize youth with disabilities and HIV-AIDS Promote gender equity in employment Build capacity for youth to participate in Hanga Umurimo Promote youth cooperatives in cleaning, greening and beautification Priorities Reduce youth unemployment Cross-Cutting Issues Disability & Social Inclusion Gender & Family Environment & Climate Change 3.6.10 Public Financial Management Effective and efficient Public Financial Management (PFM) must operate throughout the Government sector. Essentially the government must ensure that: All public revenues stipulated by law are properly levied and collected All expenditures incurred within the public sector are properly authorised and are spent in accordance with approved budget decisions and government financial regulations and rules All government financial transactions are properly recorded in accounting records that are transparently available to all citizens and organisations within Rwanda, and have been subject to independent audit The citizens of Rwanda are assured that their publicly provided finances are being spent wisely on the delivery of desirable public services and that every possible effort has been taken to eliminate corrupt and fraudulent practices In the context of the knowledge society that is being developed in Rwanda, the City of Kigali has identified the following priorities with correspondent strategies for the next five years to accelerate economic growth and reduce poverty by prudently managing the public resources; Priorities Increase compliance with public financial management systems Strategies Implement auditor general recommendations Build capacity for employees on PFMS Cross-Cutting Issues Capacity Building 36 3.6.11 Public Sector Development The Private Sector Development Strategy aims to achieve accelerated, broad based, diversified economic growth, the creation of new jobs and increasing returns from the existing jobs as well as increase incomes for self employed. The objective is to build a broad consensus across the private sector, the civil society and the GoR on the vision of a private sector capable of delivering rapid and sustained pro-poor growth in the country. Towards this end, the KCDP has identified the need to have a vibrant private sector in the City to achieve accelerated growth not only of the City but the Rwanda in general. The revised Vision 2020 target for industry growth rate is 14% while the 7YGP is 12% while the revised target for service sector growth rate is 13.5% and growth national investments (GDP) is 20%. To achieve this, the private sector must take its rightful place and play its rightful role in the Rwandan economy. For the private sector to grow, the Government and the City of Kigali must create a well functioning enabling environment and investment climate that is attractive to the private sector. The following priorities and related strategies have been proposed; Priorities Empower private sector Strategies Train youth and women on Financial Literacy Promote investment in tourism Support women and youth employment projects Promote gender equity in the trainings Cross-Cutting Issues Gender & Family 3.6.12 Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order The JRLO SSP has identified Alternative Dispute Resolution and arbitration systems as methods to hasten justice administration. However, they exist only at the higher levels of the justice system. However, these are insufficient so that many civil litigants have no option but to bring their case to the formal justice system. The City of Kigali has identified the prolonged legal battles in courts not only consume time and money but they also contribute to poverty. Most of the disputes arise from land which could be utilized for development but this process takes longer causing the litigants to postpone investment and thus reducing economic growth and increasing poverty. Strategies Use of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms (e.g. mediation, arbitration, negotiation etc) Priorities Reduce litigation cases 37 3.7 Contribution to EDPRS 2 Thematic Areas/Priorities This section sets out how the City of Kigali Development Plan will contribute to each of the EDPRS Thematic Areas: rural development (to which it is a key contributing sector); economic transformation, rural development, productivity and youth employment and accountable governance. Economic Transformation Thematic Area The City of Kigali Development Plan is a core strategy to contribute to the country‟s economic transformation and achieve a growth rate of 11.5 % and become a middle income economy in the year 2020. City of Kigali must play its pivotal role as the hub of commercial and financial services not only in Rwanda but in the EAC. City of Kigali currently contributes over 60% of Rwanda‟s GDP. It therefore puts the city under a very unique position to ensure that this contribution is enhanced through elaborate measures/strategies that contribute to the economic transformation of the Rwandan economy. All big players in the Rwandan economy have set shops in Kigali and strategies must be developed to retain them as well as attract more in the various sectors of the economy. The City of Kigali will have a key role to play in: Facilitating economic growth through infrastructure development According to the Revised Vision 2020 targets, it is envisaged that for Rwanda to attain the middle economy status, the rate of growth in Agriculture sector must be 8.5% (currently 5.6%), Industry: 14% (currently 9.5%), Services: 13.5% (currently 10.2%). To achieve this, the Vision has projected that the relative share of industry and services will need to increase as follows; Agriculture: 25% (currently 34%), Industry: 20% (currently 17%) and Services: 55% (currently 49%). This paradigm shift of the economic focus from agrarian led economy to industry and services led economy will require the City of Kigali to invest heavily in infrastructural development to be able to attract investors both local and foreign. Many infrastructural projects have been proposed in this CDP that will act as a catalyst and basis for economic acceleration. The construction of 24.8 km asphalt, 100 km stone paved and rehabilitation of 29.5 km will stimulate economic growth by providing efficient and fast transport system within the City. Further expansion of the major roads will reduce congestion in the City and increase efficiency. Massive investment in housing and commercial development has been envisaged in this CDP. A progressive economy must be able to provide affordable housing for the urban citizenry failure to which mushrooming of slums may arise with their unpleasant results. Over 1,744 ha land bank has been earmarked for affordable housing which will further support the economic growth of Rwanda. The commercial development is set to utilize 25 ha. Other infrastructures proposed are landfill, sewerage system, ravines, incinerators, parks and plazas etc. The establishment of the One Stop centre is to facilitate investors acquire construction permits with ease to support the housing development. Two district hospitals and public libraries will be constructed within the next five years. All these infrastructure will lead to the economic growth as they will also create many and diverse employment opportunities. Ensuring economic growth through reliable and sustainable road network. A lot of man-hours are lost in traffic jams and dilapidated or undeveloped road network. It increases the cost of doing business and reduces efficiency and speed. Within the EDPRS 2 38 period, a lot of flagship projects are envisaged to open up the City to other developing areas and also increase the transition to other provinces that also link Rwanda to neighboring countries. Some of these projects are expansion of city road networks, development of city by-passes to better discharge traffic construction of interchanges, construction of dedicated lanes for public transport (Bus Rapid Transport (BRT), development of peripheral terminals for public transport, introduction of intelligent transport system and electronic ticketing for urban transport among others. There is strong international evidence that road network contribute to reduced inefficiency in transport which in turn accelerates economic development. Rural Development Thematic Area The City of Kigali Development Plan will directly contribute to the achievement of three of the Vision 2020 targets to meet the reduction in rural poverty: food security score for the rural population; number of off-farm jobs and percentage of adult population accessing financial institutions. Contribution to Rural Development Primary Objectives The City of Kigali Development Plan will contribute to all three rural development primary objectives: rural poverty is significantly reduced in all Districts in City of Kigali especially Gasabo which has a big proportion of rural; proceeds of growth are equitable; and economic transformation occurs within the rural population. Rural Poverty is Significantly Reduced in all the three Districts of Kigali through the shared roles of Gasabo- Administrative hub, Nyarugenge- Financial hub and Kicukiro- knowledge hub. EICV3 shows that poverty headcount and depth is higher in rural urban district of Gasabo than the predominantly urban districts of Kicukiro and Nyarugenge. By creation of more jobs in the administrative hub of Gasabo district, the development plan will contribute to rural poverty reduction. Infrastructure development projects planned for Gasabo District will create employment opportunities while improving the standards of living through electricity supply, improvement of roads etc. Proceeds of Growth are Equitable By defining different roles to the City of Kigali districts as cited earlier, equitable growth will be promoted. Kicukiro will attract educational institutions within the district which will in turn contribute to demand for housing and other services leading to overall growth of the district. Gasabo district will have administration offices for national government and other private players. This will also stimulate demand for houses and other amenities which will also lead to overall growth of the district and the City. Nyarugenge being the financial hub for financial services like banks, insurance etc will attract high cadre professionals working in the district who will equally demand social amenities that will push up economic growth within the district and spillover effects to other sectors and districts. Economic Transformation Occurs within the Rural Population The growth of City of Kigali has spillover effects to not only the neighboring districts but also the far flung districts. Construction projects within the City will attract labor from all over the country. The growing population will require food supplies and other services that must be produced by the districts near City of Kigali. These effects will spill over to districts like Kamonyi, Bugesera and Rwamagana. Further, pressure of accommodation within the City will force some of the residents to create buffer housing stocks within these districts which 39 will definitely contribute to economic transformation within these rural populations because of the local enterprises and trade. According to the Kigali Conceptual Master Plan (KCMP), it is projected that the City of Kigali will create 2.3 million jobs by 2040 from the current 0.5 (2011). To achieve this, it is anticipated that the City of Kigali must create at least 1 million jobs within this EDPRS 2 (2013/14-2017/18). Though the Government has put all efforts to reverse the rural urban migration, young people are still flocking the city in search of employment opportunities. It is therefore imperative that this development plan must stimulate growth in the overlying rural areas of the City to promote rural development. Productivity and Youth Employment According to the National Youth Policy 2006, youth in Rwanda are defined as the largest segment of the population, aged 14-35. According to EICV3, 4,159,000 youth constitute 39% of the entire population in Rwanda. Arguably, for the Rwandan economy to flourish and to achieve its objective of becoming a middle-income country by 2020, this fraction has to be given special attention. Given the continued importance attached to youth, EDPRS II will guide Rwanda‟s aspiration of medium-term development from 2013 to 2017; one of the guiding themes for EDPRS II will be Productivity and Youth Employment. A central EDPRS II objective is to increase the quality of life of all Rwandans through rapid economic development and sustainable economic growth at 11.5% per annum and accelerated poverty reduction below 30%8. The City of Kigali Development Plan will contribute to productivity and youth employment through: Kigali Employment Service Centre which is a flagship project under this CKDP to promote youth employment. The Center will act as an interface between the young job seekers and employers. The City of Kigali will establish a platform where information on job opportunities emerging from various institutions public, private, NGOs, CSOs and others is made available to the youth in the City. Employers would be required to post their job offers through the Centre. The Center will avail this information to the youth through various channels like notice board, websites, emails, SMS, social networks e.g. face book, twitter etc. Employment on public works: Public works are predominantly manual and require people who are physically endowed to do manual works. Young people possess these traits and will benefit immensely from public works: many infrastructural projects are envisioned in this development plan in the next five years. These projects are in the roads, energy, water and sanitation, greening and beautification of the City, waste management, ICT, numerous commercial buildings and residential housing development. These public works will provide massive employment opportunities both direct and indirect for the youth. This means that by 2017/18, approximately over 20,000 youth can be expected to be employed each year on these public works. The buildings that will be constructed in the City will require cleaners, messengers and other non-skilled jobs for the youth doubling the employment opportunities for the youth. 8 Youth SSP, 2012 40 Skills Enhancement through TVET: Though majority of the public works comprise of casual labor which require minimal skills, there is need to enhance the skills of the youth in some of job cadres that require some basic skills like artisans. These jobs include masons, carpenters, welders, plumbers, electricians, painters etc. The youth must acquire these skills from the technical and vocational education centers in order to become employable. Once the youth acquire such skills, it enhances their chances of increasing productivity and opportunities of being employed by the private sector in more sustainable employment. Through the 3 districts, the CoK will ensure that they establish TVET centers within the current planning regime to provide the technical skills to meet the growing demand for skilled labor in Kigali and Rwanda in general. The City of Kigali council will help boost the short term productivity of poor youth and women by encouraging them to save through cooperatives where they are employed. The city will encourage the youths to form employment associations and link them to construction companies where they can provide not only labor but also equipments like shovels, spades, wheel barrows, mattocks to the contractors. This will improve their income generation with long term productivity. Accountable Governance According to JRLO SSP, the following outcomes have been proposed to be achieved in the next five years; Improved citizens‟ scores on the provision of services in all sectors Increased access to timely and fair justice Increased rate of conclusion of court cases Improved progressive development/ performance towards achievement of a corruption free environment The City of Kigali is directly related to the implementation and achievement of the above outcomes for the following reasons; i) One of the prime functions of the City is to provide services to the citizens that contribute to their well being. These services include among others efficient transport system, sanitation, construction of houses, street lighting etc. If these services are not delivered effectively, it can lead to public disquiet and social disorder; ii) The City is confronted with many litigation cases involving disputes that arise in the course of implementation of its mandate as provided by the law; During the CKDP period, the City will endeavor to reduce conflicts arising from the implementation as much as possible. Whereas this is plausible, it is not practical in the justice administration as one party will always feel aggrieved and declare a dispute. To reduce litigation in courts which has its own financial and loss of goodwill costs, the City will explore alternative dispute resolutions as strategies to increase a timely and fair justice to the citizens. With support by MINIJUST, the City will engage in out of court settlements, mediation, negotiation and arbitration to settle arising disputes. 41 Chapter 4: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN 4.1 Sequencing of interventions, including details of the interdependencies between programs and how they should be sequenced 4.1 Institutional Roles and Responsibilities The degree to which this plan gets translated into bankable results depends on the robustness of and functional coordination between the implementing institutions. Clarifying institutional roles is an essential first step in enhancing coordination. This section outlines the roles and responsibilities of the key CKDP institutions in the implementation of the development plan. 4.1.1 Central Government Ministries and Agencies 1. City of Kigali Council The City of Kigali has the overall responsibility in the implementation of the development plan. The City of Kigali also has the mandate to coordinate, monitor and evaluate development actions of the 3 Districts, as well as those initiated by the City. Actions scheduled for implementation of the Development Plan for the City of Kigali will also be coordinated and evaluated at national level by Central Government and especially by MINECOFIN and MINALOC as line ministries. 2. District Authorities of Gasabo, Kicukiro and Nyarugenge The 3 districts of City of Kigali are the key partners in the implementation of the City of Kigali Development Plan. Most of the activities in this development plan will be jointly and concertedly be implemented through the 3 districts 3. Ministry of Local government MINALOC Ministry of Local Government (MINALOC) - overseeing decentralization of sectoral and fiscal functions; coordinating the Vision 2020 Umurenge, a key flagship programme of the EDPRS; sets criteria and coordinates the Local Governments‟ Performance Contracts monitoring; and responsible for community development and social protection. MINALOC will particularly play a key role in ensuring that the development plan integrates the key objectives of decentralized development and community development programmes. 4. Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning (MINECOFIN) MINECOFIN responsible for macroeconomic management, resource mobilization and allocation for public investments, planning and coordinating economic activities across sector Ministries and more recently ensuring population issues are integrated into sector priority 42 setting. The Ministry has the overall responsibility to spearhead development of EDPRS 2 which will guide Rwanda towards the Vision 2020. In this respect, MINECOFIN will monitor the implementation of the development plan and ensure that the priorities within the DDP are in line with Sector priorities to ensure harmonized development and reduce duplication of effort. MINECOFIN will also be critical in financing or assisting in the funding for projects initiated by the City. 5. Ministry of Infrastructures MININFRA Road infrastructure development, energy infrastructure, water, urban planning and human settlements are under the policy direction of MININFRA and have significant contribution to the development of the City. Through this development plan, roads infrastructure, energy, urbanization and housing have been given priority. The Ministry will be critical to prioritize the road, energy in their budgetary planning and avail necessary resources like funds and human resources. The ministry will take overall responsibility for integrating infrastructural activities under this CKDP in their priority areas. 6. MINELA This is the central Government Ministry responsible for ENR policy formulation and implementation, coordination and monitoring. MINELA has 4 main roles i.e.: 1) Providing leadership through policy formulation and sector coordination to all actors; 2) Ensuring that sustainable natural resources and environmental management principles are mainstreamed in all policies and programmes; 3) Programming, Information and Communication for better utilization and development of natural resources and environment; 4) Monitoring and Evaluation of Natural Resources and Environmental Programmes. The Directorate of Policy, Planning and capacity building will be responsible for monitoring and follow-up, providing technical and operational support to district offices. It will also, through sub-sector professionals, liaise with specialized agencies including REMA in the follow-up and monitoring of specific programmes or sub-programmes. 7. Ministry of Sports and Culture In this CKDP, it has proposed that the City will preside over the promotion of reading and writing among the City dwellers through public library services. Currently, a public library exists within Gasabo District and it is envisaged that the City will through the districts establish a public library in the other two districts of the City. Public library services are a preserve of the Ministry of Sports and Culture and therefore, joint and concerted efforts will be necessary to the achievement of this strategy. 8. Ministry of Youth and ICT (MYICT) 43 The establishment of the Kigali Youth Employment Centre puts the MYICT as a critical ministry in the implementation of this CKDP. This centre will be critical in reducing youth unemployment which is a key objective in the MYICT strategic plan. Close collaboration with the Ministry and key youth institutions like the National Youth Council (NYC), Youth Employment Services (YES) Rwanda etc will be instrumental to the success of the Youth Employment Service Centre. 9. Rwanda Environment Management Authority (REMA) This is the overall national authority responsible for overseeing the implementation of environmental policy and law. Strategies used include education and sensitization on environmental conservation through formal and informal education as well as through practical demonstration; law enforcement and monitoring, as well as capacity building support to other institutions. City of Kigali has proposed many infrastructural projects like roads, by passes, interchanges, buildings, landfill, compost plants, incineration plants etc. These projects require environmental certification from REMA. 10. Ministry of East African Cooperation The regional protocols regarding the management of inter-city conventions within the EAC. The main area of collaboration is in the implementation of such conventions as well as positioning City of Kigali as a regional hub and also attracting regional bodies to set up offices and programs in City of Kigali. 11. Justice Institutions (essentially MINIJUST): MINIJUST has responsibility for technical guidance and coordination of legislation initiated from line ministries. On social protection, the City has proposed radical laws to reduce vagabonds in the City and require MINIJUST to follow up the enactment of such laws. Non-traditional justice institutions – particularly the Abunzi (Community mediators) are playing a key role conflict resolution at community level, including resolution of land related conflicts in City of Kigali. 12. National Police While the City has proposed many strategies to boost economic development in Kigali, security is an important pillar to such development. The Mayor has a defined responsibility of ensuring that peace, law and order are maintained in the City. The DDP has also proposed to have electronic transport management which will monitor traffic within the City. The collaboration with the policy is vital for achievement of these noble plans. 13. Civil Society Organizations (NGOs, CBOs) 44 Civil society organizations will be mobilized and supported to design thematic and/or area specific action plans and activities to implement the programmes and sub-programmes within their areas of operation. Where capacity gaps are identified, interventions will be undertaken for key identified CSOs to facilitate them to develop such needed skills, institutional support and logistical resources for the implementation of specific actions of this plan. More importantly, CBOs, informal associations and other grassroots based CSOs are expected to support the implementation of the community driven development activities. As part of the DDP sector coordination enhancement, detailed mapping of CSO operations will be undertaken, needs assessed/ identified, and strategies to support them implemented at all levels. 14. Private Sector Agencies In accordance with the GoR‟s policy of private sector-driven economic development and indeed as highlighted within the EDPRS, the private sector has critical roles to play in the implementation of the CKDP. Private sector agencies will be mobilized and sensitized, through the Private Sector Federation (PSF) and its district offices, to integrate the CKDP priorities into their activities and strategies for development. Specific incentives to encourage best practices in services and industries and value adding investments in the agricultural sector, will be developed and made available to the sector actors, subject to budget provisions. An important category of private sector that will be engaged more proactively are the cooperatives and micro finance institutions which are interacting with the poor, trade and industrial sectors at increasing scales. According to Private Sector Development Strategy crafted by MINICOM, the CoK as well as the districts are required support the identification and purchase land for industrial development, provide incentives to the investors that are consistent with RDB investment code, improve enabling environment for micro informal and household enterprises, support creation of new businesses and enhance skills development. The City of Kigali through various activities outlined in this CKDP will play an important role to the implementation of the above objectives. 15. Donors and other Development Partners Beyond providing financial support, development partners (donors, international NGOs) are expected to participate very actively in the implementation of the CKDP. As a part of the refined focus and support to the implementation of the EDPRS, the implementation of the City development plan will draw from the experience of EDPRS formulation and rely on the participatory partnerships with development partners like BTC, World Bank, African Development Bank, UNWomen, and UNDP etc. 45 Chapter 5: MONITORING AND EVALUATION In order to improve the rate of project implementation during the plan period, Monitoring and Evaluation will need to be conducted at different levels with clearly defined roles to boost ownership and sustainability. I I The monitoring and evaluation of the City of Kigali Development Plan will present unique challenges that will require careful thought to ensure an effective monitoring and evaluation framework is put in place. This is because the main role of City of Kigali is overseeing of implementation of the development projects by the Districts. It would therefore mean that the CoK will not only monitor and evaluate the implementation of the CKDP but will also do the same for the 3 districts to ensure overall implementation of the development plans to achieve overall economic development and reduction of poverty in City of Kigali as a province. It would therefore require that the City to monitor and evaluate at the District level to see whether the implementation is being accordingly. The Joint Monitoring and Evaluation Committee (JMEC) which comprises of Planning Team, Advisor to the Mayor and Director of Good Governance will be revitalized and its mandate widened to not only focus on public sector programmes but also on NGO and CBO funded projects. The committee will also consider including 2 members from the Civil Society. This partnership of all stakeholders in the development process in the City will be extended down to the cell level for wider ownership and sustainability. In addition, the JMEC will work closely with the National Steering Committee which will appoint a joint committee for Monitoring and Evaluation Committee to ensure that a coordinated approach is adopted to monitor public sector projects through reports and joint inspections. 46 Chapter 6: COST AND FINANCING OF THE DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLAN 47 References 1. Decentralization Sector Strategic Plan 2012 2. Draft ICT Strategic Plan (2013/14-2017/18 3. Draft Social Protection Strategic Plan, (2013-2018) 4. Environment and Natural Resources Strategic Plan, (2013-18) 5. Gahanga Urban Design Draft Report, 2013 6. Gasabo District Physical Development Plan 2012 7. Housing Market Demand Survey Report, 2012-2022 8. Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order II Strategic Plan (2013-18) 9. Kicukiro District Physical Development Plan 2012 10. City of Kigali Development Plan 2008- 2012 11. Kigali Conceptual Master Plan 2007-2030 12. Kimironko Urban Design Draft Report, 2013 13. Nyarugenge District Physical Development Plan 2012 14. Public Financial Management Sector Strategic Plan 2012 15. Rwanda Demographic Housing Survey 2010 Report 16. Rwanda EICV 3 2010 Report 17. Strategic Planning Paper for Transport Sector for EDPRS 2 18. Urbanization Sector Strategic Plan, 2013 19. Youth Sector Strategic Plan 2012 48 Annexure 1: City of Kigali Priorities CoK Priority Cok Output Output Transport 28.4 Km of asphalt Road network road constructed improved in CoK Road network 100 km of stone improved in CoK paved road constructed 29.5 km of asphalt roads rehabilitated Existing and new roads maintained 17 km along the major public transport corridors expanded 6 interchanges constructed in major junctions Dedicated Bus Lanes (DBL) on expanded roads created Land for Bus Rapid Transport (BRT) corridor of 17km secured City Priority Actions 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 Commencement Construction Commencement Construction of Progress Construction of Progress Construction of Commencement of Progress Construction Construction of Progress of Progress Construction Construction of Completion Construction of Completion Construction of Commencement Construction Commencement Rehabilitation Commencement Construction of Progress Construction of Continuous maintenance of Progress Construction of Commencement of Progress Construction Construction Continuous Continuous maintenance maintenance on Progress on Progress Construction Construction of Completion Construction Continuous maintenance on Completion Construction of Traffic congestion reduced Tendering process Commencement of Progress and design Construction Construction commenced on Progress Construction Integrated public transport Commencement of Construction Road network improved in CoK Road network improved in CoK Traffic congestion reduced Integrated public transport on of Commencement of Dedicated lanes Dedicated lanes Construction established on established on completed roads completed roads Commence feasibility study 49 of Expropriation commenced Expropriation completed Nyabugogo intercity bus terminal improved 3 pedestrian bridges erected Sidewalks on the existing and new roads erected Infrastructure development professionals capacity enhanced Gender equity in construction projects promoted HIV/AIDS awareness in construction projects promoted Integrated public Commencement transport Construction of Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction Integrated public Commencement transport Construction Integrated public Commencement transport Construction of Progress Construction of Progress Construction on Completion Construction on Progress Construction of Improved professionalism in infrastructure development Sensitization campaigns and provision of protective materials Recruit, train, motivate and retain civil engineers, quantity surveyors etc Recruit, train, motivate and retain civil engineers, quantity surveyors etc Sensitization Sensitization campaigns and campaigns and provision of provision of protective protective materials materials Water &Sanitation New sanitary landfill and recycling center constructed Incinerator constructed on on Progress Construction on Recruit, train, motivate and retain civil engineers, quantity surveyors etc Enhanced gender Impose gender quota Impose gender Impose gender Impose gender parity in every contract quota in every quota in every quota in every contract contract contract Reduced HIVAIDS prevalence among construction workers Recruit, train, motivate and retain civil engineers, quantity surveyors etc on Progress Construction on Completion Construction Improved solid Commencement waste Construction management of Progress Construction on Completion Construction Improved solid Commencement waste Construction management of Progress Construction on Incinerator installed and commissioned 50 of Recruit, train, motivate and retain civil engineers, quantity surveyors etc Impose gender quota in every contract Sensitization Sensitization campaigns and campaigns and provision of provision of protective protective materials materials Public toilets constructed Improved access Commencement to sanitary Construction facilities of Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Eco friendly toilets constructed in available open spaces All existing (wastewater and storm water) ravines constructed Improved access Commencement to sanitary Construction facilities of Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Commencement Construction of Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Progress Construction on Sewerage system, Centralized in CBD1 and CBD2 sewerage constructed system improved Commencement Construction of Progress construction on Progress construction on Completion Construction of Disabled friendly toilets constructed Commencement Construction of Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction Waste management operators trained Promote gender in waste recycling activities Storm water drainage system improved Social inclusion enhanced Proper waste handling improved Income generation among women promoted Conduct training on transportation, handling and disposal of solid and liquid waste Impart Recycling skills 51 Conduct training on transportation, handling and disposal of solid and liquid waste Impart Recycling skills Conduct training on transportation, handling and disposal of solid and liquid waste Impart Recycling skills Conduct training on transportation, handling and disposal of solid and liquid waste Impart Recycling skills on Conduct training on transportation, handling and disposal of solid and liquid waste Impart Recycling skills Urbanization/Housing 1,744 ha for affordable housing expropriated Access to Identification of Commencement Continuous affordable housing land through of expropriation expropriation increased zoning process Continuous expropriation Continuous expropriation to Commencement of Progress 3,000 affordable Access affordable housing Construction construction housing units at increased Akuminigo Rugarama sites developed on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Access to Commencement of Progress affordable housing Construction construction increased on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on 2,000 affordable units in Kinyinya, Gacuriro and Batsinda ( RSSB) constructed Affordable Housing conference conducted 25 ha identified for commercial building development Awareness on 1st Conference held Conference in investment in Kigali EAC Partner opportunities in States and other affordable housing African Cities disseminated Construction of Construction of Commercial commercial commercial building buildings buildings development Conferences in Conferences in Conferences in Asia, Europe and Asia, Europe and Asia, Europe and US US US Construction commercial buildings of Construction commercial buildings of Construction commercial buildings of Construction of Construction recreational recreational facilities facilities Safety on the city Commencement Progress roads increased Installation Installation of Construction recreational facilities on Progress Installation of Construction recreational facilities on Progress Installation of Construction recreational facilities on Progress Installation of Greening the Watering the green Watering the green Watering increased 2 sites developed for parks and plazas 85 km of new roads installed with street light Modern irrigation Recreational facilities improved and Watering the green Watering 52 on the system for City gardens adopted Nursery beds for ornamental trees and flowers established Modern technology of streets cleaning/sweeping adopted Urban planning professionals capacity enhanced beautification improved Greening beautification improved gardens Green energy technologies in new housing development and street lighting promoted Housing development opportunities to regional housing developers promoted Gender, PWDs, PLWH in social houses ownership prioritized HIV/AIDS awareness in housing projects promoted Reduced consumption non-renewable energy and Planting ornamental and flowers green gardens gardens gardens green gardens of Planting trees ornamental and flowers of Planting trees ornamental and flowers of Planting trees ornamental and flowers of Planting trees ornamental and flowers of trees and Cleaning sweeping and Cleaning sweeping and Cleaning sweeping and Cleaning sweeping and Cleanliness enhanced Cleaning sweeping Improved professionalism in urban planning development Recruit, train, motivate and retain urban planners, GIS experts, Architects etc Recruit, train, motivate and retain urban planners, GIS experts, Architects etc Install solar panels Install solar panels of in commercial in commercial buildings and street buildings and lights street lights Recruit, train, motivate and retain urban planners, GIS experts, Architects etc Recruit, train, motivate and retain urban planners, GIS experts, Architects etc Recruit, train, motivate and retain urban planners, GIS experts, Architects etc Install solar panels Install solar panels Install solar panels in commercial in commercial in commercial buildings and street buildings and street buildings and lights lights street lights Increased integration EAC Construction of Construction of Construction of Construction of Construction of houses by EAC houses by EAC houses by EAC houses by EAC houses by EAC investors investors investors investors investors Increased inclusion social Allocation of Allocation of Allocation of Allocation of Allocation of houses to women, houses to women, houses to women, houses to women, houses to women, PWDs and PLWH PWDs and PLWH PWDs and PLWH PWDs and PLWH PWDs and PLWH Reduced HIV- Sensitization AIDS prevalence campaigns and provision of protective materials 53 Sensitization Sensitization campaigns and campaigns and provision of provision of protective protective materials Sensitization campaigns and provision of protective materials Sensitization campaigns and provision of protective Disabled toilets integrated in all commercial development Increased inclusion social Provision for disabled friendly toilets in commercial buildings Environment and Natural Resources areas Landscaping Gikondo Industrial Wetland and improved Park and beautification of Nyabugogo the riparian zone wetlands rehabilitated Social Protection Two informal settlements upgraded Vulnerability of people living in informal settlements reduced Residents from at Vulnerability of least two high risk people living in high risk zones areas relocated reduced Women Projects for unemployment women and vulnerability employment reduced promoted Special mechanisms for relocation of women, PLWH Increase inclusion materials Provision for disabled friendly toilets in commercial buildings Provision for disabled friendly toilets in commercial buildings Landscaping Landscaping and and beautification of beautification of the riparian zone the riparian zone Provision for disabled friendly toilets in commercial buildings materials Provision for disabled friendly toilets in commercial buildings Landscaping Landscaping and and beautification of beautification the riparian zone of the riparian zone Conclude Study on Upgrade by Upgrade by Upgrade by Upgrade by informal settlements in priorities priorities identified priorities identified priorities identified the City identified through through the study through the study through the study the study Conduct Study high risk areas on Relocate by priorities identified through the study Initiate handicraft, Initiate handicraft, mushrooms etc mushrooms etc projects projects social Mapping of vulnerable Mapping of groups and providing vulnerable groups special mechanisms and providing special mechanisms 54 Relocate by Relocate by Relocate by priorities identified priorities identified priorities identified through the study through the study through the study Initiate handicraft, Initiate handicraft, Initiate handicraft, mushrooms etc mushrooms etc mushrooms etc projects projects projects Mapping of vulnerable groups and providing special mechanisms Mapping of vulnerable groups and providing special mechanisms Mapping of vulnerable groups and providing special mechanisms and the PWDs provided Youth Kigali Employment Service Centre established Employment of youth with disabilities and HIV-AIDS prioritized Gender equity in employment promoted Youth Link youth with Link youth with Link youth unemployment prospective employers prospective prospective and vulnerability employers employers reduced with Link youth prospective employers with Link youth prospective employers with Increased inclusion with Link with Link with Youth participation in Hanga Umurimo promoted Youth cooperatives in cleaning, greening and beautification and other activities promoted Increased youth Build capacity for enterprises youth to develop bankable business plans Build capacity for youth to develop bankable business plans Build capacity for youth to develop bankable business plans Build capacity for youth to develop bankable business plans Build capacity for youth to develop bankable business plans Increase youth Form youth productivity cooperatives for cleaning, greening, beautification and other activities Form youth cooperatives for cleaning, greening, beautification and other activities Form youth cooperatives for cleaning, greening, beautification and other activities Form youth cooperatives for cleaning, greening, beautification and other activities Form youth cooperatives for cleaning, greening, beautification and other activities social Link youth with Link youth with Link disabilities and HIV- disabilities AIDS to prospective HIV-AIDS youth and disabilities to HIV-AIDS employers prospective prospective prospective employers employers employers Increased gender Link female and male Link female and Link female and Link female parity youth to prospective male youth to male youth to male youth employers prospective prospective prospective employers employers employers ICT Operational youth and disabilities to HIV-AIDS Navigation and tracking system 55 youth and disabilities to HIV-AIDS and to prospective employers and Link female and to male youth to prospective employers navigation system established Modern technology in city operations adopted increased Operational efficiency increased Install management software Tax Install Performance management dashboard Install Travel Install Install Project and management Governance risk portfolio software and compliance management software software Install Reporting and analytics software Use and Utilization of ICT systems capacity enhanced ICT adoption and Train staff on ICT Train use increased systems installed ICT staff on Train staff on ICT Train staff on Train staff on ICT systems systems installed ICT systems systems installed installed installed Education Public libraries in the 3 Districts established Reading and Identify land for Carry out Mobilize resources Commence writing culture public libraries in 3 feasibility study for construction Construction promoted districts for construction Reading and writing competitions conducted annually in City schools Participation of girl child in reading/writing competition Reading and Identify partners for Piloting writing culture the venture project in promoted schools Increased gender Promote girl parity participation reading/writing competition the Conduct few competition child Promote girl child in participation in reading/writing competition 56 1st Conduct competition annually Promote girl child participation in reading/writing competition Progress construction on the Conduct the competition annually Promote girl child participation in reading/writing competition Promote girl participation reading/writing competition child in promoted Access of reading materials to visually impaired initiated Health Two District (Nyarugenge & Kicukiro) Hospitals constructed Population highly exposed to HIVAIDS infection mapped Health workers capacity for both public and private enhanced Increased inclusion social Provide Braille‟s in Provide Braille‟s Provide Braille‟s in Provide Braille‟s Provide Braille‟s in public libraries in public libraries public libraries in public libraries public libraries Access to health Construction care increased commences Progress construction on Progress construction on Completion construction of HIV-AIDS prevalence reduced Study undertaken to Preventive and Preventive and Preventive and Preventive map the populations protective measures protective measures protective protective adopted adopted measures adopted adopted Professionalism and quality of health care improved Recruit, train, motivate and retain doctors, pharmacists nurses, community health workers, midwives and other health cadres Recruit, train, motivate and retain doctors, pharmacists nurses, community health workers, midwives and other health cadres Private Sector Development Increased financial Provide training on Provide training Financial literacy inclusion financial literacy on financial among youth and literacy women enhanced Increased Provide incentives Provide incentives Investment in employment for investors for investors tourism/hospitality opportunities promoted 57 Recruit, train, motivate and retain doctors, pharmacists nurses, community health workers, midwives and other health cadres Recruit, train, motivate and retain doctors, pharmacists nurses, community health workers, midwives and other health cadres Provide training on Provide training financial literacy on financial literacy Provide incentives Provide for investors incentives for investors and measures Recruit, train, motivate and retain doctors, pharmacists nurses, community health workers, midwives and other health cadres Provide training on financial literacy Provide incentives for investors Women and youth employment projects supported Increase women Provide and youth support productivity Public Financial Management Increased Compliance with efficiency PFM regulations management increased technical Provide technical Provide support support Implement in recommendations of from OAG office technical Provide technical Provide support support technical Implement recommendations from OAG office Implement recommendations from OAG office Implement recommendations from OAG office Implement recommendations from OAG office Train employees on procurement procedures, assets management and other PFM systems Train employees on procurement procedures, assets management and other PFM systems Train employees on procurement procedures, assets management and other PFM systems Train employees on procurement procedures, assets management and other PFM systems public Awareness and use Increased compliance of PFMS among employees increased Train employees on procurement procedures, assets management and other PFM systems Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order Alternative dispute Litigation costs Conclude MoU with Continuous use of Continuous use of Continuous MINIJUST ADR ADR of ADR resolutions options reduced (out of court settlements, mediation, negotiation and arbitration) adopted 58 use Continuous ADR use of Annexure 2: City of Kigali Targets CoK Output Output Indicator Targets Means of Verification Baseline 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 153 km 7.2 km 8.4 km 5.1 km 5.9 km 1.8 km Transport 28.4 km of new asphalt roads constructed No. of Kms. 100 km of stone paved road constructed No. of Kms 22.87 km 22.87km 22.87km 15.69 km 15.69 km 29.5 km of asphalt roads rehabilitated No. of Kms 6.96 km 4.6 km 5.3 km 6.6km 6 km All new and existing roads maintained No. of Kms 281.4 km 56.28km 56.28km 56.28km 56.28km 56.28km 17 km along the major public transport corridors expanded No. of kms 21 km 3.4 km 3.4 km 3.4 km 3.4 km 3.4 km 6 interchanges in major junctions constructed Numbers Nil Dedicated Bus Lanes (DBL) on expanded roads created No. of kms 59 Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Land for Bus Rapid Transport (BRT) corridor of 17km secured Nyabugogo intercity bus terminal improved No. hectares % 3 pedestrian bridges erected Numbers Sidewalks on the existing and new roads erected No. of kms of Infrastructure development No. of Staff professionals capacity enhanced Gender Equity in construction No of projects promoted female/male employed HIV/AIDS awareness in construction No. of Nil projects promoted sensitization meetings, materials distributed 20% 20% 1No 1 No 1 No 25Kms 50 Kms 75 Kms 5 5 5 20% 40% 100Kms 157 kms 5 5 Phase 1 Phase 1 Expropriation Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Governance Dept/GMO Reports Health Dept/CNLS reports Water and Sanitation Landfill and recycling center constructed Phases Final Phase 1 Design Complete Incinerator constructed Numbers Nil 1 No. 60 Phase 1 Phase 1 Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Supervisors Report Commissioning Numbers Public toilets in petrol station constructed Eco friendly toilets constructed in Numbers available open spaces Existing (wastewater and storm water) ravines constructed 6 6 6 6 6 Nil 1 2 3 4 5 of Nil 5 5 5 5 5 of Nil 100 200 300 400 500 Numbers 1 2 3 4 5 No. of hectares No. of units 150ha 250ha 350ha 450ha 544ha 150 units 500 units 700 units 850 units 800 units No. of units 100 units 300 units 400 units 600 units 600 units Reports MoUs 5ha 5ha 5ha 5ha 5ha Expropriation Report Kms Sewerage system, in CBD1 and Kms CBD2 constructed Waste Management operators Trained Gender in waste recycling promoted Urbanization Affordable Housing Investors Conference conducted 1,744 ha secured for affordable housing Affordable housing units at Akuminigo Rugarama sites developed Affordable units in Kinyinya, Gacuriro and Batsinda ( RSSB) through private sector and PPPs 25 ha identified for commercial building development Report MoUs 2 No. trainings No. women No. hectares Final Design Complete of 61 Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Training reports GMO/Governa nce depts. Conference Report Expropriation Report Reports and MoUs and 2 sites developed for parks and plazas 85 km of new roads installed with street light Numbers Modern irrigation system for City gardens adopted Nursery beds for ornamental trees and flowers established Modern technology of streets cleaning/sweeping adopted Urban planning professionals capacity enhanced Green energy technologies in new housing development and street lighting promoted Housing development opportunities promotion to regional housing developers enhanced No. hectares No. hectares Kms Gender, PWDs, PLWH in social housing prioritized HIV/AIDS awareness in housing projects promoted Disabled toilets integrated in all commercial development of Reports and MoUs Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report Reports of Reports No. of kms 10Km 20km 20km 20km 15km Reports No. of staff No. of solar Nil panels installed 50 100 200 300 400 OSC /Infrastructure Dept Reports No. of Units from EAC house developers No. of Nil housing units taken by these groups No. of Nil sensitization meetings and materials distributed No. of toilets constructed 500 1,000 2,000 4,000 5,000 OSC Reports 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 GMO/MINAL OC/CNLS/NC PD Reports 5 5 5 5 5 CoK Health Dept CNLS Reports 10 20 30 40 50 OSC Reports/NCPD 62 Environment and Natural Resources No. of Gikondo Industrial Park and hectares Nyabugogo wetlands rehabilitated Social Protection Two informal settlements upgraded Numbers 1 2 1 2 Residents from at least two high risk areas relocated Numbers Kigali Employment Service Centre established No. of youths employed 100 150 200 250 300 Projects for women and youth employment promoted No. of women employed 100 150 200 250 300 Special mechanisms for relocation of women, PLWH, and PWDs provided Number relocated under special mechanisms No. of youth Nil employed 1,000 3,000 5,000 7,000 10,000 No. of youth Nil PWDs and LWH employed 50 100 150 200 250 Youth Kigali Employment Service Centre established Employment of youth with disabilities and HIV-AIDS prioritized 63 CoK Governance Dept Reports CoK Governance Dept Reports CoK Governance Dept Reports CoK Governance/ GMO Dept Reports CoK Governance/ GMO Dept Reports/NCPD/ CNLS CoK Governance Dept Reports CoK Governance Dept Reports/NCPD/ CNLS Gender equity in youth employment promoted Youth participation in Hanga Umurimo promoted 120 200 300 400 500 CoK Governance Dept Reports % of usage 10% 20% 40% 80% 100% No. of IT systems installed and utilized No. of staff trained on new IT systems 1 2 3 4 5 CoK Dept of ICT CoK Dept of ICT Youth cooperatives in cleaning and beautification and other activities promoted ICT Operational navigation system put in place Modern technology in city operations adopted Use and utilization of IT systems capacity enhanced No. of Nil females and males employed No. of youth participated and financed No. of 80 cooperatives CoK Dept of ICT Education Public libraries established in the 3 Districts Reading and writing competitions conducted annually in City schools Participation of girl child in reading/writing competition promoted Access of reading materials to visually impaired initiated Numbers 1 No. of participants 1 No. of girls participating No. of visually impaired accessing 64 2 3 1 2 4 5 CoK Good Governance CoK Good Governance/ GMO CoK Good Governance/ NCPD CoK/Good Governance, NCPD, KPL Health Two district ( Nyarugenge and Kicukiro) hospitals constructed Population highly exposed to HIV-AIDS infection mapped Health workers capacity for both public and private enhanced Private Sector Development Financial Literacy among youth and women enhanced Investment in tourism promoted Number 1 Final Reception Report, Supervisors Report No. of people identified No. of health workers trained No. of women and youth trained No. of investors in tourism No. of women and youth cooperatives supported Women and youth employment projects supported Public Financial Management % 55% Compliance with PFM regulations increased No. of Awareness and use of PFMS employees among employees increased trained PFM 69% 75% 85% 90% 100% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% on Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order % 0% Alternative dispute resolutions options (out of court settlements, mediation, negotiation and arbitration) adopted 65 Annexure 3: Sector Outcomes Sector Outcome Transport 108 km of City of Kigali unpaved roads upgraded to paved road for bus routes Feasibility study and preliminary design on the construction of City of Kigali Ring road cum Expressway Development of a Business model for bus operation under route franchising approach for City of Kigali 90 km of Dedicated Bus Lanes (DBLs) for exclusive use by Dedicated Right-ofWay Buses in 16 bus routes without expropriation 30 km of Dedicated Bus Lanes (DBLs) for exclusive use by Dedicated Right-ofWay Buses in bus routes with expropriation Detailed Design Study for a BRT system for City of Kigali District Output City Priority Actions 2013-14 2014-15 Road network in the Commencement Progress on city improved of construction construction Traffic congestion Commencement Commencement reduced of the Study of Construction 2015-16 Progress construction Progress construction Public transport Business model integrated developed and implemented Public transport DBL without integrated expropriation identified Business model developed and implemented DBL on identified routes implemented Business model developed and implemented DBL on identified routes implemented Public transport Commencement integrated of Construction Progress construction on Progress construction 2016-17 on Progress construction on Progress construction 2017-18 on Progress construction on Progress construction Business model developed and implemented DBL on identified routes implemented on Progress construction Development of 10 km of BRT corridor in the City of Kigali Develop PPPs and improve 700 100 Automated smart fare collection Public transport 10 Automated system in bus shelter integrated smart fare collection system installed Integrated Smart ticketing system with Public transport 100,000 micro processing ability (1,000,000 cards) integrated integrated smart ticketing with micro- 70 Automated smart fare collection system installed 600,000 integrated smart ticketing with micro- processing 66 10 Automated smart fare collection system installed 100,000 integrated smart ticketing with micro- processing 30 Automated smart fare collection system installed 300,000 integrated smart ticketing with micro- processing on Business model developed and implemented DBL on identified routes implemented on Progress construction Public transport Detailed design Detailed design Development of integrated study study 5 km of BRT commenced commenced corridor in the City of Kigali Improvement of 1,000 bus shelters in City Public transport Develop PPPs Develop PPPs Develop PPPs of Kigali integrated and improve 100 and improve 300 and improve 500 on on Development of 17 km of BRT corridor in the City of Kigali Develop PPPs and improve 1000 100 Automated smart fare collection system installed 1,000,000 integrated smart ticketing with micro- processing Establishment of a Public Transport Public transport Operation control centre integrated Establishment of an Improved Intercity Bus Terminal in City of Kigali Development of Bus Sleeping Ground by upgrading existing taxi park Development of 100 km of High Quality footpath on both side of roads with shade tree at 10 m interval including wheel chair access facilities for disables Development of Bicycle parking at 25 sites 3 number of Park-and-ride facility (open lot parking) peripheral area Public transport integrated Public transport integrated Public transport integrated processing ability installed Taskforce for public transport operation control centre established Construction commenced Construction commenced Construction commenced Public transport Construction integrated commenced Public transport Construction integrated commenced 67 ability installed ability installed ability installed ability installed Task force Task force Task force Task force recommendations recommendations recommendations recommendations implemented implemented implemented implemented Progress construction Progress construction Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on Progress construction on on on on Annexure 4: Cross Cutting Issues CROSS CUTTING ISSUE Gender & Family Disability and social inclusion Capacity Building CHALLENGE STRATEGIES Gender inequality especially in construction project contracts awarded by CoK. % of women to be employed will be imbedded in new contracts with City contractors. Priority on less manual works like painting etc priority to be given to women Gender friendly work environment e.g. maternity leave etc. to be adhered to. Eradication of street families, urchins and vagabonds Gender insensitivity in access to toilets and sanitary facilities by both private and public offices within the City Lack of street lighting which may result to GBV Low implementation of guidelines for access to buildings by disabled Lack of pathways dedicated for disabled Lack of parking lots dedicated to disabled Low access to transport for disabled Gikondo transit center to be strengthened Improve the Human Resource Strategy which is designed around a policy on rewards and compensation, recruitment, selection, induction, mentoring, professional development and performance management to better motivate the City employees and to support career development needs of 68 Construction of public toilets Sensitization campaigns to private especially banks to provide sanitary facilities for women from within Installation of more street lights on the City roads Strict implementation of the guidelines Creation of pathways, parking lots for disabled Encourage private sector to buy buses with seats reserved fro disabled Develop a sustainable human resource strategy aimed at attracting and retaining staff in the COK employees; Environmental, Climate Change and Disaster Management HIV/AIDS and Non Communicable Diseases Regional Integration Address capacity gaps in urbanization/housing and infrastructure technical experts i.e. urban planners, architects, quantity surveyors, engineers etc Address capacity gaps in environmental health experts within the CoK Flooding in wetland areas like Nyabugogo Landslides in high risk zones Wetland areas in Gikondo and Nyabugogo Outbreak of fires, earthquakes etc. Green energy issues Pollution in the city Prostitution Rural urban migration creating vulnerability to infection Regional offices for different institutions set up in CoK Regional conferences, workshops conducted in CoK 69 Deliberately head hunt for these cadre of staff locally or outside and provide incentives for retention Deliberately head hunt for these cadre of staff locally or outside and provide incentives for retention Construction of water ravines and improvement of the drainage system Relocation of the people Rehabilitation of the areas Implementation of health and safety rules in construction Construction of trees to absorb gas emissions Implement the environmental laws Women empowerment projects Sensitization to new employees in Kigali especially in construction sites Support MINEAC to lobby regional offices Collaborate with RDB and other stakeholders Annexure 5: Challenges and Priorities of the City of Kigali Sector Challenges Priorities Targets Innovations for EDPRS 2 Transport Limited Constructing Asphalt accessibility to roads and stone paved all weather roads road network Continuously maintaining all existing City roads Traffic Expanding existing single Congestion carriage way to dual carriage way and 4-lane to 6-lane dual carriageway Improving major junctions (Interchanges, roundabout, traffic lights, etc.) Inefficient Developing efficient and Public effective public transport transport system for CoK system 28.4km of new asphalt roads constructed 9 100km of stone paved road constructed10 29.5km of asphalt roads rehabilitated11 All existing roads maintained Purchasing machine for producing/shaping cobblestones 17km along the major public transport corridors expanded12 Private-Public Partnership model of financing a) Roads in good condition: 85% (V2020) b) 106 Km of tarmac and stone-paved roads (7YGP) 6 major junctions: Gishushu, Gisementi, Giporoso, Nyabugogo, SEZ and AirportRwamagana road junctions improved Dedicated Bus Lanes (DBL) on expanded roads created Land for Bus Rapid Transport (BRT) corridor of 17km secured Nyabugogo intercity bus terminal improved 3 pedestrian bridges erected Sidewalks on the existing and new roads erected 9 For more details, see annex 1 For more details, see annex 2 11 For more details, see annex 3 12 For more details, see annex 4 10 70 Sector Challenges Priorities Targets Innovations for EDPRS 2 (15km) Water and Sanitation a) Access to improved sanitation facilities: 100% (Vision 2020 & 7YGP) b) Access to clean water: 100% (Vision2020 & 7YGP) Urbanization a) 13 Urban population : 35% (Vision Lack of an appropriate solid waste treatment facilities Low access to sanitary facilities in the City Limited proper storm water drainage system Lack of centralized sewerage system Annual deficit/demand of affordable housing units Constructing new sanitary landfill and recycling center Public-Private Partnership reviewed in provision of public transport services New sanitary landfill and recycling centre constructed Recycling of waste One incinerator constructed Constructing an incinerator Constructing public toilets Implementing wastewater and storm water master plan Constructing Sewerage system Creating Land Bank to provide affordable land to support affordable housing - Public toilets construction at each petrol station ensured - Eco friendly toilets construction in open spaces in the City ensured - At least 3 ravines constructed each year13 - Sewerage system, in CBD1 and CBD2 constructed 1,744ha secured for affordable housing Gasabo- 1,200ha Kicukiro- 349ha Nyarugenge- 175ha Ravines to be constructed will be identified later after a careful assessment of urgent needs 71 Recycling of waste Treatment of wastewater (Sewerage Treatment Plant) Private-Public Partnership model of financing Sector 2020) and 30% (7YGP) Challenges Priorities Targets Innovations for EDPRS 2 estimated at 30,000 units Facilitating investors to Implement affordable housing projects on identified sites - 3,000 affordable housing units at Akuminigo and Rugarama sites developed - 2,000 affordable units in Kinyinya, Gacuriro and Batsinda - Groups housing initiatives supported Need for more developed commercial buildings Lack of public parks and plazas Need for more street lighting Need for more greening and beautification Facilitating investors to acquire sites for commercial building development Developing land bank for public parks and plazas 25 ha identified for commercial building development Identification of cheaper alternative construction materials and technologies to make housing affordable Private-Public Partnership model of financing Install roads with street lights Adopting beautification and greening appropriate technology Existence of nonrehabilitated wetland areas Rehabilitating the wetland areas 85km of existing asphalt and stones paved roads installed with street light14 Irrigation system for City gardens adopted and botanical gardens developed Greening and Landscaping Master Plan developed Appropriate technology of streets cleaning/sweeping adopted Gikondo Industrial Park and Nyabugogo wetlands rehabilitated b) To mobilize investors to build up affordable Houses (7YGP) Environment and Natural Resources Forest cover : 30% of land 14 For more details, see annex 5 72 2 sites developed for parks and plazas Private-Public Partnership model of financing Using Solar energy for street lighting Public-Private Partnership Sector area (V2020 &7YGP) Challenges Priorities Existence of informal settlements on fragile hill slopes/high risk areas Prevalence of Social Protection a) Poverty (% under homeless, poverty line) (%): 20 delinquents, (V2020&7YGP) street vendors, and people b) Gini Coefficient with disability (income disparity): 0.350 (PWD) needing support Need for more Health a) Life expectancy (Yrs): health 66 (V2020) & 58 infrastructures (7YGP) b) Infant mortality rate: 30 Need for mapping (V2020 & 7YGP) c) Maternal mortality rate population at per 1,000: 2 (V2020 & high risk of 7YGP) HIV-AIDS infection Targets Upgrading informal settlements and relocating people living in on fragile hill slopes/high risk areas -Two informal settlements upgraded Supporting people with disabilities and other vulnerable groups - PWD (KUREMERA) economic empowered - Research on street vendors and beggars conducted - Establishment new rehabilitation and transit centres by districts facilitated Constructing health infrastructures Two District (Nyarugenge & Kicukiro) Hospitals constructed Mapping key population highly exposed to HIVAIDS infection Mapping key population highly exposed to HIVAIDS infection conducted and recommendations implemented 73 - Residents from at least two fragile hill slopes/high risk areas relocated Innovations for EDPRS 2 Sector Challenges Priorities Private Need for vibrant and empowered private sector a) Industry growth rate: 14 (V2020) & 12 (7YGP) b) Service sector growth rate:13.5(V2020) c) Growth national investments (GDP): 20% (V2020) Youth 1.7m off firm jobs created (7YGP) ICT a) Internet usage: 50% (V2020) b) Mobile subscription people: 60% (V2020) Targets Empowering private sector - Training on Financial Literacy provided with focus on women and youth conducted - Environment for tourism investment promoted - Projects for women and youth employment supported Urban - Reduce unemployment unemployment - Providing quick link between job seekers and job offers - Providing basic training on job seekers Insufficient Improving tracing system tracing system of locations of locations Continued use Adopting modern of manual technology in city systems in management affairs management of city affairs 74 - Kigali Employment Service Centre established and functioning Operational navigation system put in place Tax collection management software installed Performance Management Dashboard installed Travel Management Software installed Governance risk and compliance software installed Project and Portfolio Management software installed Reporting and Analytics software installed Innovations for EDPRS 2 Sector Challenges Priorities Targets Education Need for more Promoting reading and reading and writing culture writing culture among City dwellers - Two District Public libraries establishment ensured - Reading and writing competitions/festivals conducted annually in schools - Debate Clubs formation in each secondary school ensured Need for more compliance with PFM regulations Need for reduced litigation Increasing compliance with PFM regulations Compliance level increased to 100% Adopting alternative dispute resolutions options (out of court settlements, mediation, negotiation and arbitration) Litigation cases reduced by 50% Literacy level: 100% (V2020) & 90% (7YGP) Public Finance Management Justice, Reconciliation, Law and Order 7YGP: to enact laws on mediation and establish a National Authority in charge of Mediators‟ functioning and empowerment 75 Innovations for EDPRS 2 Alternative Dispute Resolutions Options Annex 1: Details about new asphalt roads to be constructed 28.4km of new asphalt roads to be constructed comprise of: 1. Kagugu-Batsinda-Nyacyonga : 7.2km 2. Nyamirambo-Rebero-Nyaza: 8.4km 3. Kimisange-Cyumbati –Nyamirambo : 3.9km 4. Cyumbati-Nyamirambo : 1.2km 5. Rubirizi-Busanza-Kanombe: 5.9km 6. Niboye-Kabeza: 1.8km 76 Annex 2: Details about new stone paved roads to be constructed 31.37km of stone paved road will be identified later 68.63km of stone paved road to be constructed comprise of: NYARUGENGE DISTRICT No Road Location 1 Roads in Biryogo area 2 Roads in Quartier Tarinyota Two roads parallel to the main asphalt road from Biryogo (kuri 40) up to 3 Rwezamenyo market 4 Rwezamenyo roads accessing perpendicularly to the main asphalt road 5 Roads in Rwezamenyo area 6 Nyamirambo stadium - Kimisagara 7 Ryanyuma- Akumunigo 8 Ryanyuma-Akumunigo (2nd) 9 Muhima Hospital- Resident Hotel 10 Access to Muhima Metropolitan police Head office 11 Kacyiru Public Library - King King Faical Hospital 12 Kacyiru Primary school-Police Kacyiru 13 Road Behind Police Hospital 12 Road Gisozi connecting two existing asphalt roads TOTAL Length (km) 0.489 0.847 2.129 0.945 1.628 0.727 0.993 4.3681 1.095 0.598 3.006 0.829 0.421 0.783 18.859 KICUKIRO DISTRICT No Length (km) 8.915 2.255 1.863 2.379 1.188 0.949 0.922 18.471 Road Location 1 Roads in Kimisange area 2 RBS-New Jerusalem-Kagarama 3 Roads in Kagarama area 4 Roads in NIBOYE area 5 Roads in ZINIA area 6 Round about Gikondo- Marembo 7 Chez Mironko-Marembo TOTAL GASABO DISTRICT No 1 2 3 4 5 6 Road Location Roads in Gisimenti Zone Roads in REMERA zone Roads in Migina zone Road between Remera tax park and Mushumbamwiza Roads surrounding KIMIRONKO Market Roads surrounding the asphalt road towards Kimironko prison 77 Length (km) 2.351 1.6028 3.102 2.635 2.6608 2.365 7 8 9 10 Roads in KIMIHURURA area Roads surrounding KIBAGABAGA Hospital Roads in Kibagabaga Zone Roads in GACULIRO Zone TOTAL Annex 3: Details about roads to be rehabilitated 29.5km of asphalt roads rehabilitated comprise of: 1. Rehabilitation of City Centre Roads (Commercial area): 6.96km 4.7863 1.378 4.2793 6.140 31.300 2. Rehabilitation of Chez Lando -KIE-Chez Lando : 4.6km 3. Rehabilitation and expansion to dual carriage way of Main Roundabout-Serena-BKCentenary House Loop: 5.3km 4. Kanogo-Nyabugigi (poids lourds): 6.6km 5. Kiyovu roads network: 6km 78 Annex 4: Details about roads to be expanded 17km along the major public transport corridors to be expanded comprise of: 1. Expansion and upgrading to dual carriage way of Rwandex-Sonatubes-Prince House + overlaying for Kanogo-Rwandex: 12.2km 2. Expansion and upgrading to dual carriage way of Nyabugogo-Muhima-Main Roundabout: 4.8km 79 Annex 5: Details about roads to be installed with street light 85km of roads installed with street light comprise of: 1. MAGERWA –GATENGA: 1.97km 2. SONATUBES -COTRACO-KICUKIRO HEALTH CENTER : 2.15km 3. RWAHAMA -KIST Branch (Remera): 450m 4. Cercle Sportif - Gikondo (CGM) : 2.4km 5. RWAHAMA -BIBARE SUBURB ROADS-MUSHUMBA MWIZA: 1.79km 6. BEAU SEJOUR Hotel - RUKIRI- GISHUSHU (traffic light) : 1.5Km 7. NYAMIRAMBO stadium: 650m 8. GAKINJIRO-KAGUGU : 2.8km 9. Cadillac -Kimihurura -Ombousman's office : 1.6Km 10. ETO MUHIMA -HOTEL OKAPI-QUINCAILLERIE BETA : 0.4Km 11. YAMAHA -POLICE HEADQUATER : 0.4Km 12. SONATUBES -GISIMENTI : 1Km 13. Amahoro National Stadum- Hotel Tech-Prince House: 500m 14. Nyanza Genocide Memorial Site- Brigade Nyabarongo : 10Km 15. Nyamirambo -Akumunigo : 3.318km 16. Nyamirambo suburb roads (zone Belge) : 807m 17. Rwampara -Gikondo CGM: 2.386Km 18. Bralirwa-Ziniya-Police Kicukiro-Kiosk Allelua: 1km 19. Kibagabaga (Hospital) -Nyarutarama : 3.711Km 20. Gishushu-INILAK -Shell Petrol of SONATUBE : 4.566Km 21. Contrôle Technique -Gishanga- Goboka: 2.605Km 22. Kacyiru Police Hospital-King Faycal Hospital: 3.150km 23. Police Headquarters (Kacyiru): 347m 24. Republican Guard Camp: 500m 25. Police Denys- Former Post office location: 600m 26. RBS-KICUKIRO DISTRICT-JUCTION MUYANGE-FORMER (PAM ) Stones paved road: 5Km 27. Mamans Sportives – President’s Office (Kacyiru) : 2.826km 28. Kimihurura -ATES- Kabindi stones paved road: 2.145km 29. Cadillac -RPF Headquater- Assemble- de Dieu (church)-PM’s Office: 1.8km 30. MURINDI-KABUGA (routes en Béton) : 8km NuVision (Kabuga)-Nyagasambu :13km 80