Women Empowerment Through Business Member Organizations W OMEN EMPOW ERMENT THROU GH BU SI NESS MEMBER ORGANI ZATI ONS: PHILIPPINES LANDSCAPE TH IS COU NTRY BRI EF DES CRI BES TH E BUSI NESS E NVI RO NM ENT FOR W OME N ENTR EP RENEUR S I N T HE PHI LI PPI NES . IT HI GH LIG HTS T HE K EY P LAY ER S AND TH EI R I NITI AT I VES AT PR OMO TI NG W OMEN ’S ENT R EPR ENEURSH IP AND OUT LI NES T HE G AI NS , G AP S AND P ERSI ST ENT CH ALLENGES TH AT STI LL NEED TO BE ADDR ES SED . IT CO NCLU DES BY FOCUS I NG O N W H AT BUSI NES S M EM BER O RG ANIZ AT IO NS CAN DO TO IMP RO VE TH E P AR TI CIP AT IO N OF W OMEN ENTR EP RENEU RS AND T O M AK E MOR E E QUI T ABLE T HE BENEFITS DU E TO W OMEN AND T O T H E W I DER CO MMUNIT Y . OVER VI EW : T HE B USI N ESS ECOSYST EM FOR WOMEN The Philippines is categorized as a lower middle-income economy in South East Asia with a population of 99.4 million1 and overall population sex ratio (male/female) of 1.01. Labour force participation rate is 53 % for women, compared to 81 % for men. Women earn an average of 79 % of what men earn. 2 The WEF 2015 Global Competitiveness Report ranked the Philippines 47t h out of 144 economies based on 2014 data. Its estimated GDP of U$ 284.9 billion GDP, and a GDP per capita of U$2,865. 3 Doing Business 2015 ranked the Philippines at 95 out of 189 economies with a score of 62.08, a regress from its 86th rank in 2014, and below World Economic Forum (2015). Global Competit iveness Report, 2015-2016. 2 World Economic Forum (2014). The Global Gender Gap Report 2014, p. 302 1 3 World Economic Forum (2015). Global Competitiveness Report 2015-2016:17. the regional average score of 63.19. This ranks the Philippines 4t h among 6 comparative economies, trailing Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam. Its GNI per capita is estimated at US$ 3,270 4. Medium, small and micro-enterprises (MSMEs) are considered a leading engine of job creation in the Philippines. The Global Entrepreneurship Monitor showed that four out of 10 adult Filipinos, aged 18 to 64 are engaged in business, approximately accounting for around 19 million (39.2%) of the national population (2006-2007). It likewise had the least gender gap among business owners (55% male, 45% female). Women are more active in starting a business than men, comprising 51% of new business owners. Data, however, suggests that as women start a business, the husband takes on full-time involvement until the business has stabilized. Women predominantly own nascent enterprises (69%), men own established businesses (66%). This trend reflects the traditional view of the man as the breadwinner in the Filipino family, while women are seen to go into business only to augment family income, usually pursued after marriage. Results that reflect only a small incidence of single females going into business corroborate this. 5 World Bank (2015). Doing Business 2015: Philippines. Washington, DC. USA. Economies are ranked from 1 to 189 by the ease of doing business ranking. The ranking of economies is determined by sorting the aggregate distance to frontier (DTF) scores. An economy’s distance to frontier score is indicated on a scale from 0 to 100, w here 0 represents the worst performance and 100 the frontier. 5 Imelda M adarang and Cielito Habito. Global Entrepreneurship M onitor. Philippine Report 2006-2007. 4 As of 2009, there are 780,437 business enterprises operating in the country. Of these, 99.6% are micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) and the remaining 0.4% are large enterprises Of the MSMEs, 91.4% (710,822) are micro, 8.2% (63,529) are small, and 0.4% (3,006) are medium enterprises. MSMEs comprise 60 percent of Philippine exporting firms and contribute 25 % to the country’s total exports revenue. MSMEs are able to contribute in exports through subcontracting arrangement with large firms, or as suppliers to exporting companies. 6 The informal sector is officially defined as “poor individuals who operate businesses that are very small in scale and not registered with any national government agency. Being unregistered, informal sector workers are presumably outside the reach of government services. Thus, while most of them operate without paying their taxes, they could be exposed to exploitative working conditions, including low wages, violation of workers’ rights, hazardous working environment, and lack of social protection. 8 Informal companies also pose unfair competition to formal enterprises. The 2014 Global Gender Gap report also indicated that 69 % of firms have female participation in ownership, and 33 % have women as top managers. The World Bank Global Findex 2014 reveals that 31.3% of Filipino adults own a formal account, up by 4.7 percentage points from the baseline figure of 26.6% reported in the 2011 Findex. Formal account refers to an account held in financial institutions such as banks, cooperatives or microfinance institutions and can be a mobile money account as well. The increase in account ownership is slightly higher for men, although the overall percentage with account is still higher for women (37.9%) than men (24.4%). 7 Women are more engaged in microenterprise development with unregistered or unregulated establishments making up 62% of microenterprises sub-sector of MSMEs. 9 When disaggregated according to size of firms, small firms experience major constraints in terms of “access to finance” and “high electricity rates”. Medium-sized firm share similar constraints with the added obstacle of ‘tax rates’. Large firms are more affected by crimes, theft and disorder as well as the bureaucratic procedures of licensing and permits. Gaps and Constraints Business owners and top managers in 1,326 firms ranked the following top ten business environment constraints. Across all types of enterprises, the ‘practices of the informal sector’ is the top constraint as shown in the graphs below. Figure 1. Top 10 Business Environment Constraints Definition according to the Social Reform and Poverty Alleviation Act of 1988 (RA 8425) cited by Philippine Commission on Women(2013). In the Women’s Empowerment, Development and Gender Equality Plan, 2013 – 2016, page 29. 9 Philippine Commission on Women (2012). GREAT Women Project. Why are We Pursuing Women’s Economic Empowerment? – A S it uationer on Philippine Ent erprises and Women. Manila, Philippines. August 2012, p. 2. 8 6 Philippine Commission on Women (2012). GREAT Women Project. Why are We Pursuing Women’s Economic Empowerment? – A S it uationer on Philippine Ent erprises and Women. Manila, Philippines. August 2012, p. 3. 7 “ Number of Filipino Account Holders Increased” (April 28, 2015) in http://w ww.bsp.gov.ph/publications/media.asp?id=3715 2 given to women’s reproductive responsibilities over the enterprise, especially where there is tension or conflict between the spouses or the woman has small children; the women’s lack of technical and financial capacity; and the women’s lesser competitive nature and poor marketing strategies. 12 Policy Framework A series of laws and policies were issued to spur gender-fair practices in entrepreneurship. The major policies are: In the Philippines, bureaucratic requirements and regulations discourage firms from entering the formal sector, which explains why a huge bulk of economic activities (about 80 per cent are considered as part of the informal sector)10 The Magna Carta for Small Enterprises (RA 6977 of 1991, amended by Republic Act 8289 in 1997, and further amended by RA 9501 in 2008) is geared towards the development of the Filipino entrepreneurial spirit by providing a business environment conducive for MSMEs. 13 Enterprises are categories into the following: For women entrepreneurs, the key constraints are their lack of social preparation and technical skills. Many women venture into business without a thorough market analysis and feasibility study of the enterprise to be set up. A common observation among aspiring entrepreneurs is the tendency to avall themselves of government financial assistance or dole- outs, despite their lack of skills and technical and social preparation to do so. Experienced entrepreneurs also point to the lack of business discipline and low level of interest of women to experiment and learn new things to improve their products. They have very little incentive or interest to be competitive and expand their markets. 11 Micro: not more than PhP3 million, small: PhP3 million to PhP 15 million, medium: PhP15 million to PhP100 million. The law laid down the principles of: Minimal set of rules and simplification of procedures and requirements; Participation of private sector in the implementation of SME policies and programs; Coordination of government efforts; Decentralization of regional and provincial offices to coordinate with local governments. The Department of Trade and Industry’s business name registration profile showed that The law also created these mechanisms: there were more women-registered businesses The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise (around 54 p e rc e nt) c ompa re d to me n (46 Development (MSMED) Council that is percent) in 2010. However, at renewal time chaired by DTI, with members among 6 after five years, men outnumbered the government agencies and 3 women (55 percent versus 45 percent). This representatives from the private business indicates that some women were unable to sector; one from the banking sector and sustain their businesses. Some of the factors one from the labour sector nominated by accounting for this situation are the priority labour groups. 10 World Bank ( 2010) data cited in the Women’s Empow erment, Development and Gender Equality Plan, 2013 – 2016, page 29 12 Philippine Commission on Women (2013). Women’s EDGE, page 41. 11 Philippine Commission on Women (2013). Women’s Empow erment, Development and Gender Equality, page 61. 13 http://philippines.smetoolkit.org/philippine/en/file/ content/6887/en/magnacartaformicrosmallandmediume nterprises.pdf 3 Small Business Guarantee and Finance Corporation, or SB Corporation, which shall have primary responsibility of implementing comprehensive policies and 12 programs to assist MSMEs in all areas, including but not limited to finance and information services, training and marketing. The SB corporation is authorized with a capital stock of ten billion pesos (U$200+Million), the initial capital of one billion pesos shall be established from a pool of funds to be contributed in the form of equity investments in common stock by the Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP), the Philippines National Bank (PNB), the Development Bank of the Philippines (DBP) in the amount of Two hundred million pesos (approximately U$4.5 Million) each. Lending institutions are also mandated to allocate 8% of its total portfolio to SMEs; 6% for SEs, 2% for MEs). An Act Providing Assistance to Women (RA 7882 of 1995 — provides for women with existing micro and cottage business at least one (1) year, with a daily inventory of goods worth not more than twenty-five thousand pesos (P25,000 or U$550)14 or with any business equipment with a book value of not more than Fifty thousand pesos (P50,000 or U$1,100) shall have priority to obtain a loan not exceeding the value of her business equipment at prime interest rate or at the rate of twelve per cent (12%) per annum, whichever is lower from any government financing institution; That only women with good track record in sales shall be eligible to obtain such loan. The Magna Carta of Women (RA 9710 of 2009) states that all possible assistance shall be provided to women in their pursuit of owning, operating and managing business enterprises towards the promotion of their economic rights and independence. Assistance shall focus on the availability of the following: credit, training and technology, information, packaging and marketing, and social protection. The “Go Negosyo Act” (Republic Act 10644) was signed into law on 15 July 2014, and took effect on 13 January 2015. The law seeks to promote “job generation and inclusive growth through the development of MSMEs” in the country through the following:15 Establishment of “NEGOSYO Centres” or common facilities in all provinces, cities and municipalities to promote “ease of doing business and facilitate access to services for MSMEs within its jurisdiction. Technology transfer, production and management training, and marketing assistance for MSMEs. Establishment of a Philippine Business Registry Databank under the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) to serve as a database of all business enterprises in the country. Establishment of a Start-up Fund for MSMEs “to provide financing for the development and promotion of MSMEs in priority sectors of the economy to be sourced from the MSME Development Fund and BMBE Fund. Re-composition of the MSME Development Council and its additional functions. The MSMED Council shall encourage publicprivate partnerships (PPPs) in the establishment and management of Negosyo Centres. Coordination and collaboration with the Local Government Units (LGUs) and other agencies and organizations is imperative to avoid duplication of efforts and to foster coordinated action. Key Players/ Actors The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) is the primary government agency with the dual mission of facilitating the creation of a business environment wherein participants could compete, flourish, and succeed and, at the same time, ensuring consumer welfare. DTI reported that three out of five beneficiaries who accessed DTI’s Enterprise http://w ww.dti.gov.ph/dti/index.php/programsprojects/negosyo-center/go-negosyo-act 15 14 Approx imately U$1=PhP45 as of October 2015 4 The Department of Labour and Employment (DOLE) serves as the policy-advisory arm of the Executive Branch in the field of labour and employment. It is the lead agency mandated to develop the competencies and competitiveness of Filipino workers, to deliver employment facilitation services for full and decent employment, and to promote industrial peace based on social justice. Some of its centres e.g. the Occupation Safety and Health Centre, Bureau of Women and Young Workers, Bureau of Rural Women and Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA) have training programs for workers that support MSMEs. Development Program last year were women entrepreneurs. DTI services that were availed of included entrepreneurial skills and technology upgrading and training; product design; market matching; participation in trade fairs, international expositions and business missions; among others. 16 Women entrepreneurs also increased their access to the financing programs of the Small Business Corp., the SME financing guarantee arm of DTI. Women comprised 43% of those who availed of small business loans in 2014 equal to P274 million, a dramatic increase from 17% in 2009 that came to only P37M in 2009. 17 DTI’s Export Management Bureau (EMB) is the lead agency tasked to develop, promote, and expand export trade. Among its services are: a) Frontline Services for inquiries and requests for assistance; b) Export Assistance and Business Matching Service; c) Specialized Consultancy Services; d) Business Missions Facilitation Services; e) Regional Interactive Platform for Philippine Exporters (RIPPLES); f) Doing Business in Free Trade Area (DBFTA); g) Philippine Export Competitiveness Program (PECP). EMB has updated the Directory of Philippine Exporters as of 2014. It highlights priority merchandise exports like electronics, food, garments, furniture, fashion accessories, and other consumer goods. Likewise, it features services providers of top Philippine services exports in the fields of animation, game development, healthcare information management, IT services, and other services including construction and related engineering services, audio-visual, and education, among others The Philippine Commission on Women (PCW) is the national women’s machinery that spearheads gender-responsive policy development, capacity development and coordinate gender-responsive programming by all government agencies, including those in the economic development sectors. It is also the lead oversight agency for the implementation of the Magna Carta of Women. It has led a convergence project on gender-responsive economic empowerment. The People’s Credit and Finance Corporation (PCFC) is a government corporation created as an alternative banking, financing and credit system that will provide affordable credit to the marginalized sector of the country. By virtue of the Social Reform and Poverty Alleviation Act (R.A. 8425), it was designated as the vehicle for microfinance service delivery exclusively for the poor and was authorized to mobilize financial resources from both local and international sources. It pursued wholesale lending coupled with institutional capability development as the strategy towards poverty reduction. It is also the executing agency of the United Nation’s Development Program’s (UNDP) Microstart Program for institutional development. 16 http://w ww.dti.gov.ph/dti/index.php/resources/22featured-article/290-recognizing-the-vital-role-of-womenin-phl-grow th-dti-remains-supportive-of-women-seconomic-empowerment The Department of Social Welfare and Development provides livelihood/capital assistance to poor families in the informal http://www.dti.gov.ph/dti/index.php/22-featuredarticle/290-recognizing-the-vital-role-of-women-in-phlgrow th-dti-remains-supportive-of-women-s-economicempow erment 17 5 sector Kapit- Bisig La b a n sa Ka hira p a n – Comprehensive and Integrated Delivery of Social Services (KALAHI– CIDSS) and the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (4Ps) of the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD). They promote microentrepreneurship and provide the corresponding support resources to the program beneficiaries. developed modules on entrepreneurship training, i.e., the Business Start-up Course (BSuC) and the Business Improvement, Survival, and Expansion Course (BISEC). These modules, first given in March 1999 at the Women's Centre in the Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA, helped crystallize TESDA's Program of promoting entrepreneurship. TESDA sustained the entrepreneurship training and start up program into a project called Sari-Sari Store Training and Access to Resources Program (STAR) Program in collaboration with Coca Cola Philippines. As of September 2015, the STAR program has helped over 36,000 women in 46 locations through access to resources, peer mentoring and basic entrepreneurship training, especially in post-disaster areas. In the coming years, the STAR program target is to benefit 200,000 women who will own and operate convenience stores and food stalls by 2020. Among the private business sector, the key players are: The Women’s Business Council of the Philippines (WBCP) was established in 1997 to promote women-led and women-owned enterprises through networking and through the use of technology. Its purposes are: To influence economic policies and advocate programs to address women’s business concerns in such areas as technology development, training, and access to markets and finance. To monitor the status of women in the economy and to advocate or undertake programs to advance the status of women workers, entrepreneurs, owners or executives. To forge business alliances and establish commercial networks among womenowned, women-led or managed business and with other business groups. Noticeably, employer groups such as the Philippine Chamber of Commerce and Industries (PCCI) and the Employers’ Confederation of the Philippines (ECOP) have limited services for women’s entrepreneurship. One of its program officers opined that nevertheless, these organizations are open to receiving and supporting some projects if a good proposal that benefits women will be submitted to them. 18 The WBCP also trail blazed the generation of benchmark data on Asian women in business through the conduct of a Three Country Study (Malaysia, Thailand and the Philippines) in partnership with the Asian Institute of Management, the United Nations Development Programme and the United Nations Office of Project Services. It participated as the private sector partner of the Department of Trade & Industry and Philippine Commission on Women in the Organizing Committee of the APEC Women and the Economy Forum (APEC-WEF) that was held in September 2015 in Manila. W OM EN ENTREPRENEURS’ ACCESS TO SERVICES Women Entrepreneurs’ Needs Access to Credit and Financing. Most women in the informal sector and micro entrepreneurs are not served by government financial institutions (GFI) and micro finance institutions (MFIs) for many reasons. One is the cost of Phone Interview with Hermogena RamosAquino, Chairperson of the Training Committee, Employers’ Confederation of the Philippines., October 27, 2015 18 It collaborated with the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), WBCP 6 service delivery versus the capacity of women to meet the stringent requirements, such as minimum loanable amount, quality of collateral, repayment terms, number of years of business experience, submission of business plans, and consent of the husband. Overindebtedness, multiple borrowing, and credit burdens also affect the women’s capacity to access services. unit (LGU) in which they are located. However, since there are no regulated, standardized registration procedures at the LGU level, the time and cost required in registering a business may vary from one LGU to another. The need to simplify business registration is vital in encouraging micro and small enterprises to register and obtain licenses that will formalize them as business establishments. At present, it is estimated that it will take an entrepreneur 48 days to complete the 11 required procedures. Faster and broader program implementation. The implementation of the government's enterprise development laws and programs in terms of their targeting and reach need to be hastened. For example, a special credit window has yet to be created for women micro-entrepreneurs as per Republic Act No. 7882 or Assistance to Women Engaging in Micro and Cottage Business Enterprises Law. At present, most women access credit from microenterprise lending windows of government and those operated by nongovernment organizations (NGOs) that have small, non-collaterized loan ceilings. At the local level, there is a need to harmonize the implementing guidelines and circulars on microenterprises from various concerned national government agencies. Initiatives for Business Development Services The Philippine Franchise Association, a member of ECOP (Employers’ Confederation of the Philippines), is providing training and mentoring services to entrepreneurs and would-be entrepreneurs in order to encourage them to grow their business via franchising. It offers business mentoring, trade promotion and networking to its members, 30 % of who are women. They specifically targetted the provincial areas of the Philippines were there are fewer economic opportunities. The programme is called Franchising Regional Enterprises by Women (FREE Women) Project, the first phase of which was funded by the US Embassy in Manila. Its beneficiaries are women entrepreneurs, women-beneficiaries of entrepreneurship programs by government agencies and NGOs, graduating students with awardwinning business ideas and graduate students who are 35 years and below taking graduate studies in business and entrepreneurship. The second phase involved mentoring a select few beneficiaries and prepare them to participate in the Incubation Pavilion of .19 Franchise Asia Philippines 2015 Broader access to information/ awareness of macro perspective and potential of their businesses. Women entrepreneurs have limited information and awareness of the macro perspective and potential of their businesses. Their capacity to increase their productivity and profitability is limited because they lack information and training in product development and product costing, as well as access to affordable market windows. Access to strategic business resources is further hindered by the remoteness of their area and poor infrastructure, such as communication and transport facilities, farm- or factory-tomarket roads, and the like. Gender Responsive Economic Actions for the Transformation of Women (GREAT Women) Need for less bureaucratic and less costly business registration. In the Philippines, every firm must register at both the local and national levels. At the local level, all businesses are required to secure a mayor's permit or municipal license from the local government http://www.itcilo.org/en/thecentre/programmes/employersactivities/world-map-goodpractices/promoting-womenentrepreneurship-through-franchising 19 7 Project, 2006-2012, is a convergence project led by the Philippine Commission on Women (PCW) in partnership with 19 national government agencies and over 40 local government units in eight provinces as pilot sites. It received technical and financial support from the Canadian government that amounted to (Cdn$ 7 Million) in development assistance. Private social enterprises and business groups were likewise engaged in selected areas to provide interventions to women micro-entrepreneurs. The project focused on building capacities of partners to be able to look at the needs of women entrepreneurs from a gender perspective. The assistance was heavy on entrepreneurial skills training, technical assistance on product development, production equipment, marketing including packaging and labelling, subsidies in social protection (health insurance), environment management practices and providing access to financial support. Since 2006, the GREAT Women Project reached out to some 9,000 women micro-entrepreneurs, capacitated 18,302 government officials and other stakeholders on various areas of gender-responsive economic governance and evolved a ‘GREAT’ Women Brand which is now a platform that brings women’s products to new markets. In 2015, the project started implementing another six-year plan that aim to make Filipino women’s microenterprises more sustainable and competitive. 20 alliances. The program also assists in establishing common service facilities that will allow the beneficiaries access to low-cost inputs, wider market, and higher technology; and that will promote the setting up of selfhelp mechanisms for social security among informal workers. DOLE also launched the “Balik Pinay! Balik Hanapbuhay! Program” in 2011 to enable women overseas Filipino workers (OFW returnees) to start and to operate livelihood undertaking for self-employment. The Program consists of livelihood skills training and the distribution of the starter kits. With a $539,000 budget allocation, it aims to prioritize 2,400 women beneficiaries accessing short-period training on production skills with entrepreneurship and business management, marketing linkage and networking services, business advisory, and consultancy services, social protection services and other alternative social protection schemes and job referral system covering local labour markets to ensure the employability of target women beneficiaries. In 2013, the Program was expanded to include women OFWs in the Migrant Workers and Overseas Filipinos Resource Centres (MWOFRC). In four years, the Program has reached more than 4,000 beneficiaries who have established their own business or used the gained skills for employment. The Philippine Centre for Entrepreneurship (PCE), a non-stock, non-profit organization, has been conducting its ‘Go Negosyo’ advocacy and education to nurture the entrepreneurial spirit and culture among Filipinos. The word “negosyo” is the Filipino term for “business.” For the past 10 years, it has conducted caravans, seminars, multi-media (TV and web) campaigns and books to popularize entrepreneurship as an alternative to unemployment, job seeking or migration. It provides links to partner entrepreneurs' businesses, to business opportunities, to entrepreneurship-related training programs, and to funding sources. Now on its 7th year, it The Department of Labour and Employment (DOLE) has an Integrated Livelihood Program for informal sector workers that provide productive resources such as equipment, raw materials, and tools that can be used by eligible beneficiaries; as well as training, orientation, and advisories on entrepreneurship development, business planning, productivity improvement, worker’s safety and health, networking, and business 20 This section had inputs from the Luvy Villanueva, GREAT Women Project Director based at the Philippine Commission on Women. 8 women entrepreneurs dubbed ILAW (light) to mean Inclusive Lending for Aspiring Women Entrepreneurs. The loan product was conceived with the assistance of Women’s Business Council of the Philippines (Womenbizph) and a MOA was signed between the two groups to promote this access to finance to women in business. Sole proprietorships, partnerships and corporations, which are women-led, are qualified to borrow. has been organizing the GO NEGOSYO Filipina Entrepreneurship Summit with the international celebration of the Women’s Month, which usually attracts more than 5,000 attendees. This annual event features an awarding of inspiring female entrepreneurs who are exemplary in the field of business and the individual mentoring sessions provided by expert entrepreneurs. CARD (Centre for Agrarian Reform and Development) is an institution that comprises both NGO and a bank. It is committed to empower socially-and-economically challenged women and families through continuous access to financial, microinsurance, educational, livelihood, health and other capacity-building service that train them as responsible citizens for their community and the environment. It was organized on December 10, 1986 as a social development foundation. It established its credit arm in 1990, the Landless People's Development Fund (LPDF), an adaptation of the Grahmeen Bank. Eventually, its ultimate vision of establishing a formal banking institution owned, controlled and managed by its landless rural members was formally launched in September 01, 1997. CARD Bank, Inc. is now a microfinance-oriented rural bank that has 54 branches and with 329 Micro Banking Offices (MBOs) located nationwide that serves more than 900,000 clients across the country. 21 IM PROVING BM O’S ASSISTANCE TO W OM EN IN BUSINESS Filipino women entrepreneurs, led by the Women’s Business Council of the Philippines, projected the following recommendations during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Women and the Economy Forum (WEF) in 2015: 22 At both the national and local levels, there is a need for stronger monitoring and evaluation systems to track gender equality, in addition to women's economic empowerment. The lack of sexdisaggregated data at all levels makes it difficult to ascertain how men and women are differently affected and benefitted. A stronger monitoring and evaluation system for gender equality in economic development is necessary. Along with data, consider opportunities for BMOs in the following areas: a) increasing formality by implementing business-friendly registration procedures and tax structures; and b) desegregation, as well as increased women’s participation in innovative and growing sectors of the economy. Considering that both women and men are involved at many different stages of the value chain, be it as workers or entrepreneurs, in marketing, and as consumers, BMOs can employ genderresponsive value chain analyses to product Mapping of financial services For credit and capital, women turn to government financial institutions, rural banks, non-government agencies and microfinance institutions as major sources of microcredit or microfinance loans. From July 2004 to April 2008, a total of Php 93.75 billion had been released to finance the livelihood projects of 3.95 million active microfinance clients. The Development Bank of the Philippines recently launched a special loan for 22 http://www.bworldonline.com/content.php?sectio n= Opinion&title=closing-gender-gaps-in-the-apecregion&id=116837 http://w ww.mixmarket.org/mfi/cardbank#ix zz3q8njC000 21 9 can be creative ways to engage them in the value chain of production and distribution of goods and services. or service development, and increasingly use them as a basis for strategic interventions, to enhance capacity growth and competitiveness. BMOs can facilitate women entrepreneur’s affordable access to innovative technology that can change the way to do business, connect with others, innovate, and build networks and relations. The establishment of information and communications technology infrastructure that will connect more businesswomen to customers and markets, value chain support, mentoring and networking initiatives, as well as e-commerce programs. Mothers are able to work from home because of virtual office setups and online communication tools. It is also easier for women to build their start-up businesses because technology helps substantially reduce their capital requirement. BMOs can identify role models among their women members who can serve as inspiration for young women in pursuing their goals and objectives. BMOs such as WBCP can pursue continuous mentorship and training programs on various areas of entrepreneurship. BMOs and government can support and promote more inclusive businesses, particularly those with women empowerment in their business strategy. Support can be in the form of providing direct capital to inclusive businesses and social enterprises that are women-owned or women-led, and offer products and services benefiting women and girls. 23 Increase women’s representation in BMO board. The presence of women on corporate boards can enhance firm performance and taps women’s potentials. BMOs can have increasing consultations with low-income women’s organizations in order to discover more effective ways of economically empowering them. There CONCLUSIONS AND RECOM M ENDATIONS BMOs, in collaboration with DTI and other government agencies, have to invest more resources and expertise in undertaking a systematic analysis of gender issues to illustrate the link between women’s empowerment and innovation towards better firm performance and economic growth. Through data and case studies, businesspeople can be made to realize that women empowerment can serve as a mechanism to achieve inclusive growth and promote corporate social responsibility. WBCP will have to train and organize more women to engage mainstream BMOs such as ECOP and PCCI to be more inclusive in investing in gender-responsive entrerprises and allocating more spaces for women in decision-making so that the specific recommendations in the previous section can be fully explored. Brief prepared by Ms. Luz Lopez Rodriguez. Women Empowerment Through Business Member Organization Series. International Training Centre of the ILO, 2015. Coordination: Ms. M. Carolina Marques Ferracini Produced by the International Training Centre of the ILO and the Dutch Employers Cooperation Programme in 2015. For further information, please contact Ms. Jeanne Schmitt, ITCILO Programme for Employers’ Activities actempturin@itcilo.org http://w ww.bworldonline.com/content.php?section= Opinion&title=closing-gender-gaps-in-the-apecregion&id=116837 23 10