Week 1 THE NATURE OF BUSINESS COMMUNICATION LEARNING OBJECTIVES: • • • W T To understand the complexity of ‘business’ in today’s world To appreciate the role of persuasion in business communication To be aware of the key guiding principles of business communication HAT IS BUSINESS COMMUNICATION? The most obvious answer, of course, is to say that it is communication in business contexts. However, if we think through this answer more critically, we realize that there are many things we need to understand first before we get a fairly sophisticated understanding of business communication. First of all, you may have noticed that we used the word ‘contexts’. It is plural, not singular. If business communication occurs across different contexts, then it follows that the demands for effective communication may vary from one context to another. Therefore, it is important to know that ‘context’ influences the shape of business communication. he meaning of “business” is not simple So, what then do we mean by ‘business’? The It is simplistic to think of business simply easiest answer is: it is about making money. as all about gaining profit. Business However, this is a simplistic way of looking at communication, thus, must account for the meaning of ‘business’. In recent years the complex ways people and institutions especially, because of increasing attention to deal with money nowadays. the environment, technology, and socioeconomic problems, people have dealt with money in rather complex (and yes, different) ways. Some people use money to find cure for cancer patients, to save some trees or to prevent human trafficking around the world. In their quest or effort to achieve those goals, they may not talk about money at all as they ask you for your time, your power or your energy to be used to convince people to take part in social development projects. 1|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore The lines become blurred when organizations of different types work together for common causes. The Save the Children organization, for example, a worldwide organization dedicated to providing basic services to children in poor countries such as education and healthcare, works very closely with huge corporations such as Mastercard. So while business may indeed be primarily about money, or exchange of money to be precise, there is more to business than simply people and companies raking them in. For example, Amadou Diallo, CEO of DHL Global Forwarding South, Asia Pacific, notes that any global business has the responsibility to serve the communities within which it operates: Corporate social responsibility is very much a part of today’s business agenda, but the significance of the act needs reinforcement. As part of the global business community, we should aim to create an agenda for change based on sustainable development, and be a trusted and respected partner within the communities we operate in to win our stakeholders’ trust. 1 Clearly, business communication is needed to help companies “create an agenda for change”, “be a respected partner”, or “win…stakeholders’ trust”. What then do we make out of “business” contexts? Let us consider the following communicative events to find out more about business communication: A multinational company explains to its employees in the Philippines why retrenchment is the solution to negative sales. A female company Vice-President for Sales makes a PowerPoint presentation in Korea for a media technology innovation. A tourist in Singapore calls on the manager of a local bank to complain about bad service rendered by an employee. A pilots’ union in an airplane company demands a salary increase in exchange for its members to go back to work. A European clothing brand describes its partnership with an environmental watchdog through a print advertisement. 1 (Diallo, A., 2010) 2|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore Indeed, it looks like the business contexts above have varying objectives: to explain, make a sales pitch, complain, demand, and advertise. There are also other considerations: the explanation happens in the context of decreasing sales, the female executive makes the sales pitch in Korea, the complaint is done by a tourist in a local Singapore bank, and so on. However, if we look deeper into the contexts, we find out that they share one similarity: all of them hope to convince their readers and listeners to accept their information, ideas and/or arguments. The role of persuasion may be more clear or obvious in some contexts than others, but persuasion is the ultimate goal of all. B usiness is about persuading people For example, it is obvious that the main objective of the female sales executive above is to convince her audience of the desirability of the innovation and, perhaps, to get them to purchase it. However, persuasion may not be as obvious with the clothing company advertising its decision to tie up with an environmental organization for a series of environmental projects. Nevertheless, ultimately there is persuasion in the advertisement: to improve its international profile, it aims to convince readers that the clothing company is going green. The advertisement, therefore, must be truthful and believable. Even the environmental partner must be trustworthy, or else people will readily cast doubt on the partnership. What about the tourist in Singapore making a complaint? Here, the tourist must be persuasive as well; the complaint must be well-reasoned or sensible so that it does not come across as being plain grousing. To the question then about what we may mean by “business” in business contexts, it may be that it is not simply about money, but about the work of persuasion in these contexts. Business may have many contexts, but in most of these the aim is to use persuasion, although what persuasion means and what it entails depend on where it is used. 3|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore C ommunication in business contexts is essentially persuasive Thus, if business communication is communication in business contexts, then we are talking here of Persuasion is at the heart of communication which is essentially purposive and/or business communication. persuasive. To put it in another way, persuasion is at the heart of business communication. Although there are cases where persuasion may not be obvious (e.g., information giving, clarifying an information) in ES2002, you will learn thus learn about the persuasive nature of business communication. Report writing, letter writing, formal oral presentations, networking, giving feedback: in all these, the main objective is to find out how to communicate persuasively. C ommunication that is persuasive must be effective too However, we must strive to be effectively persuasive. Indeed, the goal of business communication is essentially persuasive, but we must make sure that it is effective. We can think of ‘persuasive’ and ‘effective’ as two sides of the same coin. To sell a product, for example, we must use strategies that we think are effective in convincing the customer to buy the product. But only when the customer buys it can we say that we have been truly effective. In other words, to make sure that persuasion becomes effective, the role of the audience (e.g., the customer, the ones in the receiving end of communication) is very important. Business communication that is persuasive Thus, business communication that is is a careful attempt at understanding how persuasive is a careful attempt at best we can deliver our message so that understanding how best we can deliver people will respond to it -- or act on it -our message so that people will respond to it -- or act on it -- positively. positively. 4|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore L OOKING FORWARD IN THE SEMESTER With the points above, ES2002 will thus be guided by the following principles: 1. Business communication is essentially persuasive communication. To be persuasive in the business contexts, the message must be delivered effectively through an audience-centred approach. This can be accomplished by making sure that the following communicative principles are adhered to: CONTENT What is the message you want to deliver to your specific audience? o Message and/or purpose of communication is clear. o Content is relevant. o Information is correct and complete. DELIVERY OF CONTENT How will you deliver your content to your specific audience? o o o o Organization is clear and appropriate Language use is clear, concise and correct Style and tone are appropriate Packaging (e.g., formatting, use of non-verbal communication) is purposive and appropriate 2. Audience-centred critical thinking, intercultural and interpersonal, and listening skills are helpful skills in accomplishing persuasive business communication. Critical thinking skills o Discriminating between relevant and irrelevant information o Organizing information o Ask probing questions about ideas, arguments and information 5|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore Intercultural and interpersonal communication skills o Appreciating cultural differences o Deploying different types of interpersonal skills across cultures o Recognizing and avoiding stereotypes in communication exchanges Listening skills o Listening genuinely to other people’s concerns and argument o Identifying and clarifying a person’s main point or argument in a conversation or discussion The specific contexts of learning persuasive business communication in the course are the following: Reports (with executive summary) Letter writing Mini-lectures Oral presentations Feedback sessions Networking with people SUMMARY OF FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES Effective audience-centred message through clear and appropriate content and delivery will be the main teaching and learning points in ES2002. Critical thinking skills, intercultural and interpersonal skills, and listening skills are helpful skills in the effective delivery of message. 6|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore TUTORIAL EXERCISES ACTIVITY 1 Read the commentary on the right by Daphne A. Jameson of Cornell University on the recent global economic crisis spurred by the collapse of two major investment banks, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers, which in turn led to more economic problems around the world. The words she uses should be familiar to you now after you have read the introductory notes above. These are words and phrases you should learn in the course because they refer to basic and important practices in business communication. The ____________ of Business Communication [I]n many ways the current situation does seem to be a series of communication failures. Managers who had inside information about the problems failed to persuade others to take appropriate action. Executives failed to convey the bad news to shareholders and boards but instead reconfigured it as good news. Corporate directors and government regulators failed to listen carefully to alternative or minority viewpoints (Labaton, 2008). Investors failed to ask probing questions rather than However, she reminds us of the bigger accepting at face value what they were told. issue we need to know when we learn Bankers, realtors, and brokers failed to explain and apply these concepts. In your information clearly and fairly, especially technical group, discuss the commentary and find out what the bigger issue us. or legal information being communicated to nonexpert audiences. Consumers failed to read What does it say about the role of contracts and mortgage documents carefully and business communication in today’s to question passages that were not clear. No one, world? it seemed, could imagine the worst-case scenario. If business communication is essentially persuasive All these actions are forms of communication: to communication, what does the persuade, convey, reconfigure, listen, ask, explain, commentary remind us of when we read, question, and imagine. The people involved persuade people? either couldn’t or wouldn’t communicate what was Complete the title of the necessary. In sum, although the financial commentary. instruments and economic models were complex and some people acted unethically or illegally, the most widespread underlying factors that led to the current crisis were communication failures at every level of business organizations, the government institutions that support them, and the publics they are supposed to serve (Jameson, 2009, p.499). 7|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore ACTIVITY 2 Read the following letter 2 by S Ramadorai, former CEO and Managing Director of Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), one of the world’s leading IT services consultancy firms with more than 130,000 global workforce and a turnover of around $6 billion. Our interest in the letter should revolve around how he packages his accomplishments at TCS which, in turn, reveals his perspective of what a global business company should be about. The prompts on the right will help you and your groupmates pick up some of these business values and relate them to our discussion of the nature of business communication above. Dear TCSers, I write this on the eve of my retirement as CEO and MD of this wonderful institution we call TCS. I cannot help but look back with a tremendous sense of fulfillment and pride, upon the long, eventful and exciting journey of the past 37 years. Inspite of the belief in ourselves, we could never have imagined that the TCS of the 1970's that struggled to create credibility for itself in the market, would experience such exponential growth and achieve global leadership of being amongst the top 10 IT services companies of the world. This same belief tells me that the best is yet to come. The hard work and sheer brilliance of all of you TCSers, has powered this success and it humbles me to think of the collective intellectual capital that we have built over the years. In the days when we were only setting up the business, the only thing we had going for us was our 'can do' attitude; we worked hard at earning the trust of our customers and delivering more than what was our 'can do' attitude; we worked hard at earning the trust of our customers and delivering more than what was expected. This has been the hallmark of the TCS way of doing things. This is the DNA that has passed on and I am happy to see it alive even today. I truly believe that this customer centric way of thinking is what will keep us fired up, keep us innovating and keep us ahead of the pack. It has been the beacon that guided us for the last 40 years and so it will, for the next forty and beyond. 2 Mr Ramadorai begins his letter with the personal pronoun “I”. What do you think does this accomplish? Mr Ramadorai shifts to “we” in this sentence. What is the advantage of using “we” here over “I”? What is the tone of this last sentence? This time the letter shifts to “you”. Why do you think is this strategic? What do you understand by the “can do” attitude? Why the use of “DNA” here? What does the author try to highlight? How does a customer centric way of thinking encourage innovation? Used with permission from the office of S Ramadorai. 8|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore Another value that has been fostered within TCS is its nonhierarchical and open culture, where people and ideas have complete freedom to interact. This is a vital prerequisite for the collaboration and innovation that we seek, now and for the future. A work environment that helps bring out the best in people and promotes their professional growth is something that must be nurtured. My advice to young TCSers is that there is a great deal of merit in rolling up your sleeves and getting your hands dirty. Learning and leading by doing, builds the capacity to shoulder responsibility and helps to build up a huge vocabulary, upon which you can draw as you grow in your career. A non-hierarchical culture is viewed positively here. What does this say about the impact of hierarchy on business communication? TCS’ story is one that includes tremendous growth and expansion, but growth with profitability, aggressive global targets with a fundamental respect for our ethical governance model. The technological strength we enjoy today has been achieved because we have fiercely worked towards innovating, collaborating and creating a knowledge base. A leadership lesson I learnt and have applied to those around me is that when you empower, enable and energize those around, you enrich their lives and help them achieve their potential. A manifestation of this philosophy is visible in the promising next generation of leaders at TCS who are confidently charting the course ahead. Led ably by Chandra it gives a great sense of satisfaction to see TCS in good and safe hands. Key adjectives used in the paragraph are “tremendous”, “aggressive”, “ethical” and “fierce”. What work values are portrayed by these words? Another greatly energizing aspect of my tenure has been the way our business objectives were always finely tempered with a societal agenda – one that moved away from tokenism, and writing out contribution cheques alone, to one that involved the minds and souls of our TCSers. The TCS Maitree movement 3 What does “rolling up your sleeves and getting your hands dirty” connote? Why do you think is there a need to mention it here? “Chandra” is Natarajan Chandrasekaran, the new CEO of TCS. What if the author used “Mr Chandrasekaran” instead of “Chandra”? Would it have mattered at all? What is the problem with “writing out contribution cheques”? 3 Here is a description of Maitree from the company website: “Our approach to social initiatives entails being proactively involved and working at the root level. Some of the projects we have undertaken include working with the differently-abled, aiding under-privileged children across various schools in Mumbai, and helping rural community in Vazapur, among others. Many programs initiated by Maitree, like employment opportunities for the differently-abled, HIV/AIDS sensitization, peer education, Green Audits to check the excess consumption of energy resources have now been accepted as best practices by the organization” (TCS Maitree). 9|Page ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore serves as a great vehicle in this regard, and a reminder of our Group’s fundamental belief that profits are meaningful when accompanied by the wellbeing of the communities in which we operate, and the development of society at large. This is the glue that binds us all and I hope that this feeling of pride in TCS may always fuel your efforts and may the responsibility that accompanies it, humble you always. I must confess that I feel the same sense of excitement today about technology as when I joined this organization. IT will continue to change the world and all of you and TCS will be playing a part. So while I will step away from my executive role soon, and a chapter will end in my life’s journey, another chapter will open up. I would continue to remain associated with TCS as its Vice-Chairman, and as a non-executive Member of the Board. And equally importantly for me, serve as a brand ambassador for this great company, and as a mentor and coach to the next generation of leadership at TCS. As we go about our jobs, our families make big sacrifices, without them we would not be able to give our best to our professions. As I acknowledge the wonderful support of my own family, I do hope that you too will find ways to show your own appreciation to your loved ones. May God bless you and TCS, With my warmest wishes, S Ramadorai Here Mr Ramadorai is making a stand on what kind of profits is desirable. What do you understand by this position? What is a brand ambassador and how does communication figure in this role? How does Mr. Ramadorai end his letter? What feeling or attitude is conveyed by the last paragraph? Interestingly, the author signs off as “S Ramadorai”, not as “Ram” by which he is also called. Does this conflict with his constant use of “I” and “you” in the letter? Bibliography Diallo, A. (2010, May 15-16). Building sustainable communities. The Business Times Weekend , p. 15. Jameson, D. (2009). Economic crises and financial disasters: The Role of Business Communication. Journal of Business Communication , 46 (4), 499-509. TCS Maitree. (n.d.). Retrieved July 3, 2010, from TCS: http://www.careers.tcs.com/CareersDesign/Jsps/WorkingatTCSMaitree.jsp 10 | P a g e ©Centre for English Language Communication National University of Singapore