Atlantic County Economic Development Advisory Commission

advertisement

Atlantic County Economic Development Advisory

Commission

SWOT Analysis and Force Field Analysis

Summary Document

December 19, 2013

Facilitated by

Dr. Lewis Leitner

Dean, School of Graduate and Continuing Studies at

Richard Stockton College

In September and October 2013, the Atlantic County Economic Development Advisory

Commission, (EDAC), along with selected guests, conducted a Strengths, Weaknesses Opportunities and Threats (SWOT) analysis and Force Field Analysis focused on economic development. Dr. Lew

Leitner, Dean, School of Graduate and Continuing Studies at Richard Stockton College, facilitated the analysis. The sessions were held at the Stockton Carnegie Center in Atlantic City. At their November

2013 meeting, the EDAC had an opportunity to review the preliminary document and recommend any additions, changes or modifications to Dr. Leitner.

A SWOT analysis is a structured planning method used to evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses,

Opportunities and Threats that may confront a project or organization. A Force-field analysis is a useful tool that provides a framework for systematically analyzing the factors found in complex problems.

The participants in this process were informed, knowledgeable and diverse. Although participants recognized that that Atlantic County faces significant economic development challenges in the immediate years ahead, a majority believed that the region had sufficient economic development assets and resources, that if properly channeled, coordinated and managed could help ensure a sustainable economic future.

The group readily identified several local economic development strengths. The county is located along the Atlantic Ocean is graced with beautiful beaches, wildlife areas, and open space. The local gaming industry, although suffering from declining revenues and increasing competition from other locales, is still a $3 billion industry. It remains the foundation for a year round tourism and hospitality economy.

Other key economic development assets include the FAA William J. Hughes Technical Center, which is home to the nation’s largest aviation testing facility, The Richard Stockton College of New Jersey and

Atlantic Cape Community College, agriculture, Atlantic City International Airport and major medical and health care facilities. Atlantic County also has close proximity to major metropolitan markets and a good transportation infrastructure.

These strengths were contrasted with the region’s perceived economic development weaknesses.

These include an outdated notion of “home rule” which hampers coordination and cooperation between the urban core and suburban municipalities, lack of a regional economic development planning effort, lack of funding and resources, and most important, the lack of economic diversity. The local economy is too dependent on its gaming and hospitality industry which has seen significant contraction in recent years, with little chance, if any, that gaming revenues will reach the levels they achieved prior to 2009.

The group identified several economic development opportunities that would help to maximize strengths and minimize weaknesses. Chief among these is the development of a local aviation research industry in cooperation with the FAA and Stockton, as well as establishing Atlantic County as a center for health care and health research.

As with any region, the best laid plans can be torn asunder by unforeseeable events or changing circumstances. The Atlantic County economy is highly vulnerable to the effects of natural disasters, terroristic events, changes in state and federal policies and rising fuel costs. The impact of new technologies such as Internet gaming are not yet full knowable.

Both positive and negative forces will need to be confronted if the goal of a strong, diversified sustainable local economy is to be achieved. These forces vary in significance and can be substantial or ordinary. Persistent, hard core poverty in Atlantic City is an example of the former. Perceptions of

safety and cleanliness are examples of the latter. In either case, they must be recognized and taken into account when developing a regional economic development policy.

This SWOT/Force Field Analysis is intended to be a starting point rather than an end. In discussing the preliminary findings at its November meeting, the EDAC strongly recommended that responsibility for regional economic development be vested in a private nonprofit and that it be private sector driven and capable of focusing long term. It should be capable of being the “one stop” center for all local economic development efforts such as business retention, business attraction, planning and coordination.

It should be able to make long term policies and plans that extend beyond election cycles and changes in political leadership and have a strong, regional perspective. This entity could be created new or be already established. The duties and responsibilities of this entity as they relate to economic development, as well as a means of funding it, will need to be outlined in subsequent EDAC meetings.

The Atlantic County Chamber already has such an entity in place that could serve this purpose and discussions with the Chamber are underway.

The EDAC considers the establishment or designation of this agency a high priority that should be finalized early 2014.

Strengths

Ocean, Beach and Boardwalk

Oceanfront tourism: beach and boardwalk, Atlantic coastline

Destination resort

Hospitality and Tourism industry

Gaming Industry

Hotels, Casinos , Convention Venues, Class A Entertainment

CRDA--funding and development

Atlantic City Alliance --$30 million marketing budget

Geographic proximity to major population centers – huge % of disposable income of the U.S.

Major retail center--The Walk

Aviation and Federal Aviation Administration

FAA Technology Center, AC airport facility, Stockton Aviation Research and Technology Park

Transportation infrastructure (highways, rail, bridges, ACY and PHL)

Government Support

Congressional leadership on critical committees

County government leadership in relation to state

Power of Partnership

Stockton College and Atlantic Cape Community College

Other educational institutions

Health care industry

Historic model

Development partners

Town and “country”

Agriculture

Open space

Untapped local talent

Weaknesses

Lack of Cohesive leadership

Ineffective city government

Lack of coordination between political subdivisions

No single lead entity

Tendency to over promise

Lack of positive self-image

Lack of Cooperation and Coordination

Poor team work

Poor political climate

Lack of positive cooperation in the A.C. market

Too many silos

Lack of Plan/Strategy

Inability to respond effectively to changing economic conditions

Lack of a practical vision

Lack of focus

Lack of long range plan

Reactive, not proactive approach (up until recently)

Atlantic & Cape May Counties do not coordinate marketing efforts

Lack of Funding/Resources

Lack of incentives for new or expanding businesses

Lack of private investment

Lack of financial resources

Lack of Economic Diversity

Casino industry downturn; some casinos aging poorly

Lack Economic of diversity

Lack of innovation

Seasonal economy

Dependent on outside visitors

Wasted, non-engaged talent

Lack of Training and Employment

Limited number of quality full time jobs

Workforce skill level is low – few trained in manufacturing or other higher skills

High unemployment

Infrastructure

Need for infrastructure improvements

Perceived lack of safety and security

Geographical location is remote

Not a hub for freight and other transportation-dependent industries

Opportunities

Economic Development

Expand training and education opportunities

Expand healthcare

Housing opportunities

Conversion of casino tower rooms to condos

Expand shoulder season opportunities

Create winter attractions

Expand event-based marketing

Expand sports & recreation opportunities

Expand golf opportunities.

Expand cultural and artistic opportunities

Develop and support wine-related tourism opportunities

Build a year-round water park

Coordinate with State attractions – museums, etc.

Expand county parks

Further development of eco-tourism, Delaware bay

Attract new businesses and industry

Grow Aviation Research and Technology Park

Expand professional job force

Support workforce development

Attract clean industry, light manufacturing

Support expansion of current industry

Internet gaming

Boutique casinos

Sports betting

Continued expansion at “The Walk”

Increasing Visitation

Conventions

Transportation access to outer markets

New customers

Marketing the region

Regional brand and consistent PR

Threats

Economic

Slow/no U.S. economic recovery

Unique outside political interference

Competition from many other tourism destinations

Rising energy costs

Acts of terrorism

Natural disaster

Online retail growth hurts local retailers

Cost of healthcare at national level

Potential development of new entertainment destinations in north/central NJ

$4-$5 gasoline

Ocean pollution

Demographics

Aging Northeast U.S. population

Declining property values

Young adults leave and do not return to area

Home entertainment (cocooning)

Political

Congressional inaction regarding R & D in aviation

Aviation expansion: competition from Virginia, Florida, Oklahoma

Gaming

Internet gaming

Substantial competition from Northeast region including online gaming

Casino disinvestment

Positive Forces Behind Goal Achievement

Gaming industry

Internet gaming

Ease of traffic flow

Congressional leadership on critical committees

Tourism, beach, art attractions Sports betting

Location

FAA

Natural resources

Trenton needs us to succeed

Engaged business community Participation of people when asked

Stockton College

Community college (ACCC)

National initiatives (aviation & healthcare)

CRDA

What’s left of 5 year 150k ACA spend

Community based organizations Governmental financial incentives

EDAC Chamber of Commerce– CDC private

Coordinate existing gov’t finance sources to encourage targeted development: CRDA,

EDA, State tax incentives,

Local/county incentives, finance training programs

GOAL:

 

A

 

GROWING

 

AND

 

THRIVING

 

MIXED

 

ECONOMY

 

IN

 

ATLANTIC

 

COUNTY

Security/safety concerns Lack of diverse economy Lack of private investment

Cost of doing business

Lack of responsibility

Cost of government

Lack of strategic plan with consensus

Dysfunctional government

Challenged location

Lack of cooperation

Apathy

Single agenda not advanced

Length of time for approvals of new projects

Low population base

Image and lack of credibility to get the job done

Poverty, low wage base

Lack of cooperation between levels of government

Lack of trust in local leadership and direction

Social dysfunction leading to cost escalation

Lack of a formalized, comprehensive transparent public/private entity that can be the catalyst for positive economic development

Too much focus on tourism; a detriment to other opportunities

Inertia, lack of bias for action

Negative Forces Against Goal Achievement

Participants

Shaukat A. Azad Steven J. Batzer

Jelani

Kim Butler

Frank J. Glaser

Sharon Gordon Joseph D. Kelly Michael A. Goloff

John Lamey

Jill T. Ojserkis

Gabriel A. Staino

Freeholder Alex Marino

Michael C. Epps

Howard J. Kyle

Thomas E. Milhous

Richard. C. Perniciaro

Matthew Levinson Freeholder Formica

Izzy Posner Rich Baehrle

Freeholder Charles Garrett Dr. Peter Mora

Linda Gilmore

Robert J. Molineaux

Leo Schoffer

Download