Interpreting the Peace of Westphalia Title: Interpreting the Peace of Westphalia Subject/Course: World History: The West and the World (CHY4U) Strand: Communities, Local, National, and Global & Methods of Historical Inquiry and Communication Time: 75 min. Grades: 12 Lesson Description This is the introductory lesson to looking at the Westphalian state system by looking at the series of treaties which make up the Peace of Westphalia. The Peace of Westphalia refers to treaties that ended the Thirty Years War. It created the community of states and their sovereignty to create the type of government desired. The lesson looks at the relevance of the Peace of Westphalia, elements of sovereignty, religious conflict between Catholics and Protestants, and the aspirations of individuals in securing additional territory. This is attempted through a primary document of the original translated text of the treaties that were signed in 1648, along with several maps depicting Europe after the Peace of Westphalia. Stage 1: Desired Results Fundamental Concepts/Skills Analyzing and interpreting the text of an international treaty to learn about the themes of sovereignty, conquest, territory acquisition, peace, negotiations, and internationalism. Big Ideas/Essential Question What resulted from the Peace of Westphalia? Ontario Curricular Overall Expectation Communities: Local, National, and Global - Evaluate the factors that have led to conflict and war or to cooperation and peace between and within various communities from the sixteenth century to the present Methods of Historical Inquiry and Communication - Use methods of historical inquiry to evaluate research materials from a variety of sources - Communicate the results of historical inquiries, using appropriate terms and concepts and a variety of forms of communication Ontario Curricular Specific Expectation - Conflict and Cooperation: Assess the reasons for the success or failure of selected approaches to maintaining international order (e.g. the Westphalian state system) - Research: Use a variety of relevant primary sources Communication: Use appropriate terminology to communicate results of inquiries into historical topics and issues Lesson Goals To interpret the following quote: “For better or worse, the Peace of Westphalia marked the end of an epoch and the opening of another. In the political field it meant the final abandonment of the idea of a hierarchical structure of Christian society under the Holy Roman Emperor and the advent of a new system characterized by the coexistence of a multiplicity of sovereign States free form[sic] any external earthly authority. The new system rested on the developing modern international law and on the balance of power, operating between rather than above States.” (Bernhardt, 2000, p.1467) Key concepts and/or skills to be learned/applied: Background Knowledge: Peace of Westphalia, signatories, ratification, reservations, entry into force, primary source, secondary source, sovereignty, article, conquest, territory acquisition, peace, negotiations, internationalism Student Groupings Small flexible groups of 4 Total Group Students will have completed a university or university/college preparation course in Canadian and world studies, English, or social science and humanities Students will have practised formulating questions, selecting and using a wide variety of primary and secondary sources, and analyzing historical events from varying perspectives. Stage 2: Planning learning experience and instruction Instructional Strategies Experiential Learning Guided Instruction Materials Considerations Electronic Image of Churches of Peace Provide any background information to students in groups Smartboard Peace of Westphalia from Consolidated Treaty Series 6 maps Interpreting the Peace of Westphalia English version of Peace of Westphalia Differences between Primary Sources and Secondary Sources Accommodations Based on varying intellectual abilities, the following accommodations may be made Instructional: Students can look into locating and learning about the Peace of Prague 1635 and the Treaty of the Pyrenees 1659 and how they relate to the Peace of Westphalia. The 6 maps are of varying levels of intricacy ranging from concrete to abstract. Any documents are available on-line for use with any assistive technologies Environmental: Post cue sheets in the classroom relating to the topic Assessment: Provide clear directions and divide the assignment into several steps Stage 3: Learning experience and instruction Motivational Hook (10 MINS.): Show the images/article of the Churches of Peace which have been named UNESCO world heritage sites. Explain to students that this is what happened after the the Peace of Westphalia 1648, but today we’re going go back to the original documents which initiated this peace. Questions to pose: Is it important to connect a historical event with events that occurred after the signing of the treaty? How can the effectiveness of an historical event be measured? Open (5 MINS): Place students in teams of 3 to 4 based on varying ability levels. Provide students with an English copy of one-third of the treaty, but explain that the original Latin versions are being circulated so students can observe the way the treaty was written along with the signatories. Handout sheet with a list of questions to consider while reading the portion of the treaty. Body (50 MINS): Ask students to work in their groups with the documents provided and respond to the questions on the handout. Resources are available to look up the definitions of words if necessary. Close (10 MINS): Ask students to hand in their work sheets. These will not be evaluated but formative feedback will be provided in preparation for a future lesson where the groups of students will present their findings. Since each small flexible group received one-third of the treaty, each group will present with two groups so that nine students are presenting the entire treaty. This should provide approximately three presentations of students interpretations of the treaty. Ask students: What did you learn about reading and interpreting the original text of the Peace of Westphalia? Would you prefer to read about the interpretation of a treaty or would you rather see the treaty and interpret it? Link to Future Lessons In future lessons, students will work towards preparing a presentation for the class. Although this work will be done in the groups of 3 to 4, the presentation will occur in a sequence of 3 groups presenting so that the other students will be able to observe how the three parts link together. Assessment Formative assessment on responses to interpretation of the Peace of Westphalia.