AV Jennings House Prepared by: Context Pty Ltd Address: 7 Leura Grove, Hawthorn East Name: House Survey Date: 22 Nov. 2012 Place Type: Residential Grading: Individually Significant Architect: Edward Gurney (attributed) Builder: A V Jennings Extent of Overlay: To title boundaries Construction Date: 1940 Historical Context AV Jennings, builders A V Jennings, founded in 1932 by Albert Victor Jennings, was Melbourne's first project builder, Australia's largest private home builder and the largest and most influential provider of house and land packages (Built Heritage 2012:135; NT citation B7247). The company was known for providing superior brick homes at an affordable price. The company's most notable pre-war housing estates were located in Ivanhoe (Beauview and Beaumont estates) and Murrumbeena (Beauville Estate). During the interwar period, no A V Jennings estates were built within the current City of Boroondara, although one suburban dwelling was constructed at 7 Leura Grove, Hawthorn (1940). This house is the company's earliest identifiable project within the City (Built Heritage 2012:135). The designer of all of the AV Jennings houses from late 1932 until 1939, and many after that time, was their in-house designer, Edgar Gurney. Garden (1992:19) notes that while Guerney was 'essentially designing houses for the middle market, he nevertheless exhibited an awareness of the latest trends in home architecture'. The majority of his designs in the 1930s were in the Old English style and a conservative interpretation of the Moderne style (a standard, hip roof house with Moderne detailing). Garden goes on: 'Few of his homes could be described as avant-garde, but he did include one flat-roof modern house at Beauville [Estate, Ivanhoe] and of particular interest architecturally is the flat-roofed, functional Bauhaus which he designed for himself at 17 Melcombe Road, Ivanhoe.' In 1943, the company headquarters moved to Trent Street, Burwood. From the early 1940s, A V Jennings began to move away from private housing, in favour of a general contracting service, which incorporated projects for the Housing Commission of Victoria and experimentation with prefabricated houses. An example was the prefabricated plywood house at 55 Birdwood Street, Balwyn (c1940s; demolished), presumably designed by architect Edgar Gurney, and commissioned as a proto-type by plywood manufacturers Romcke Pty Ltd. This house was praised as the first wholly prefabricated house in Australia. In addition to these houses, the company's activities in the 1940s were limited to a small number of houses in Balwyn North and additions to its headquarters in Burwood (Built Heritage 2012:135). A V Jennings is most notably known for their planned community developments in the post-war decades (NT citation B7247). In the mid-1950s A V Jennings built four residential estates located around Melbourne, intended to re-establish the company as providers of high-quality housing. One of these estates was the Trentwood Estate in Balwyn North, in which cul-de-sacs branched off the central street, Trentwood Avenue. The estate was progressive for its inclusion of a commercial strip, kindergarten and baby health centre and RSL clubrooms (Built Heritage 2012:135). History In August 1938, Harry Cole, horticulturalist, purchased over one acre (Crown portion 105A, Parish of Boroondara) of land bounded by Leura Grove to the south and Saint Helens Road to the north. Cole subdivided the land from 1939, and sold 7 Leura Grove to Frank A G Norton, professional photographer, in April 1940 (LV:V6237/F278). The house was sold to Louis Pogonowski in November 1950 (LV: V6378/583). Garden (1992:48) states that the two-storey house at 7 Leura Grove was built in 1940 by A V Jennings. Jennings was simultaneously building Beauview Estate in Ivanhoe, yet venturing into other markets. Built Heritage (2012:135) notes that this house is the company's earliest identified project within the City of Boroondara. Considering its similarities to houses designed around this time by AV Jenning's in-house designer, Edgar Gurney, it is believed that he designed the 7 Leura Grove house as well. Description & Integrity The house at 7 Leura Grove, Hawthorn East, is a two-story cream-brick Moderne house set on a slight rise behind a generous front yard. The front yard is enclosed by a low brick fence (now rendered) with pyramidal tops to the piers. It curves inward at the east side, to sweep in along the entrance drive. The house has a flat, concrete-slab roof. The central, two-storey mass is surrounded by projecting single-storey wings. The front (south) wing has the most dramatic projection, and curved walls which mirror the curved corner of the east side of the facade. There is a decorative band at the top of the curved wall, of recessed bricks with projecting soldiers. The projecting curved wing has a simple, horizontal metal balustrade set on a projecting concrete slab, creating a broad terrace accessed via a door with a decorative metal screen. The front door, at the south-east corner of the house, appears to have a similar metal screen. Windows are a combination of fixed and casement timber windows, with a horizontal band of glass block highlights on the curved corner (at first-floor level). The projecting curved bay has a continuous curved picture window along its entire length, clearly demonstrating the capabilities of steel framing. There is a flat-roofed garage attached to the east side of the house, which appears to be original. It retains double ledged timber doors. A later carport has been added to the front. While a small band of cream bricks are visible above the door to the first-floor terrace, the rest of the walls have been bagged with cement slurry. It is likely that the majority of the bricks are cream-coloured, but there may be clinker brick accents, like other AV Jennings houses of this style and era. Comparative Analysis The Moderne, or Streamlined Moderne, style was introduced to Australia in the 1920s via the USA, but also shares some traits with European Modernism of the time, such as flat roofs, corner windows (exhibiting steel's capabilities). It was first used for commercial buildings, before being translated to residential buildings from the early 1930s. Moderne buildings generally have asymmetric massing, strong horizontal lines sometimes strengthened by a parapet and flat roof, ribbon windows, rounded corners and semicircular wings jutting out from the central mass. Many Australian designers compromised the strong horizontals by including a hipped tiled roof, though the more avant-garde and purist approach was to have a flat roof. Stylistically, three houses included in the Schedule to the Boroondara Heritage Overlay compare most closely with 7 Leura Grove. The first is 15 Walbundry Avenue, Balwyn North, of 1936 (HO189). This two-storey, rendered Moderne house has similar massing, with a curved corner to the two-storey part of the facade, and a projecting curved single-storey section to the right, used as a terrace. These two flat-roof, curved volumes are set in front of a more conservative, hipped roof body of the house. Windows are modern, steel-framed with a porthole near the front door. The house retains its low, rendered front fence. The second is 2 Beatrice Street, Glen Iris, of 1941 (HO370). This two-storey cream-brick Moderne house has an asymmetrical massing, parapeted walls concealing the flat roof, projecting semi-circular bays at ground-floor level with terraces on their roof, and a flat concrete hood above the windows. It is believed that the original windows have been replaced by the current timber casements. The third is 89 Studley Park Road, Kew, of 1940-41 (HO347). It is another two-storey cream-brick Moderne house with asymmetrical massing, curved corners, particularly fine steel windows with curved plate glass, etched-glass porthole windows, and a curved projecting single-storey bay. The roof is hipped and tiled, but is largely hidden by a high brick parapet. 7 Leura Grove compares well in its massing and detailing with the above examples. It represents the purist end of the style, with a wholly flat roof. The windows lack the quality of the curved steel-framed windows seen at 89 Studley Park Road. The bagging of the face brick compromises its presentation, but this alteration is fairly simple to reverse (with a careful acid wash). Further afield, the development of the Moderne style by Edward Guerney is seen at the two 1930s AV Jennings estates in Ivanhoe: Beaumont and Beauview. The Beaumont Estate of 1936-39 (Banyule, HO4) comprises houses in the Olde English style of clinker brick, and Moderne in clinker, apricot and cream brick (one of these three the dominant material with accents of the others). While most of the houses have pitched roofs, a handful show more influence from International Modernism, with flat roofs hidden by a parapet. The roofs were constructed of hollow-block reinforced concrete slabs. Other indicators of this style include corner windows, curved balconies and glass blocks. With their sculptural, three-dimensional form, these houses were given pride of place on corner blocks (6, 17 and 25 Melcombe Avenue; no 17 was Edward Guerney's own house). In comparison with the slightly later 7 Leura Grove, the Beaumont Estate houses are far more severe and rectilinear. Only 6 Melcombe Road has small curve concrete balconies. At the Beauview Estate (Banyule HO91), construction began in 1939, and was halted by the war. The house at 20 Beauview Parade shares with 7 Leura Grove a prominent projecting curved bay with a terrace on top, while the roof is a combination of hipped and flat sections (the face brick has also been given an unfortunate bagged finish). Other houses have pitched roofs and are in a variety of styles. AV Jennings also constructed houses for individual clients in the area, such as the house at 4 Maltravers Road, Ivanhoe (City of Banyule, HO2) of 1939-40. It is a two-storey cream-brick house with a clinker-brick base, with a flat roof, and a band of recessed details along the top of the parapet. Also similar to 7 Leura Grove, it has a large curved wall to one side of the facade. Assessment Against Criteria Criteria referred to in Practice Note 1: Applying the Heritage Overlay, Department of Planning and Community Development, September 2012, modified for the local context. CRITERION A: Importance to the course, or pattern, of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (historical significance). This is the first known house to be built by the AV Jennings Construction Company in the City of Boroondara, and one of its last individual residential commissions prior to World War Two. Founded in 1932 to provide high-quality brick houses at affordable prices, the company began building individual houses but expanded into entire housing estates by the mid-1930s. The company went on to have a significant presence in the area with the Trentwood Estate in Balwyn North, and became Australia's largest private home builder and the largest and most influential provider of house and land packages. CRITERION B: Possession of uncommon, rare or endangered aspects of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (rarity). This was the first AV Jennings house built in the City. CRITERION C: Potential to yield information that will contribute to an understanding of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (research potential). Not applicable CRITERION D: Importance in demonstrating the principal characteristics of a class of cultural or natural places or environments (representativeness). The house at 7 Leura Grove is a representative and largely intact example of a Moderne style two-storey residence of the late interwar period. CRITERION E: Importance in exhibiting particular aesthetic characteristics (aesthetic significance). The house exhibits typical features of the Moderne style, including asymmetric massing, rounded corners, strong horizontal lines strengthened by the parapet and steel railing to the terrace, ribbon windows to the single-storey, semi-circular wing at the front, horizontal bands of glass blocks, and a flat concrete roof. CRITERION F: Importance in demonstrating a high degree of creative or technical achievement at a particular period (technical significance). Not applicable CRITERION G: Strong or special association with a particular community or cultural group for social, cultural or spiritual reasons. This includes the significance of a place to Indigenous peoples as part of their continuing and developing cultural traditions (social significance). Not applicable CRITERION H: Special association with the life or works of a person, or group of persons, of importance in the City of Boroondara's history (associative significance). The design of the house is attributed to AV Jenning's in-house designer, Edgar Gurney. Gurney designed in many popular styles of the interwar period, but a small number were more avant-garde interpretations with flat roofs and complex massing, including his own house at 17 Melcombe Road, Ivanhoe, as well as 7 Leura Grove. Statement of Significance What is Significant? The cream-brick Moderne house at 7 Leura Grove, Hawthorn East, is significant to the extent of its 1940 fabric. The house was constructed by developer AV Jennings for owner Frank Norton, a professional photographer. The design is attributed to Jenning's in-house designer, Edgar Gurney. The front fence and the attached garage contribute to the significance of the place. The carport is not of significance. How is it significant? The house at 7 Leura Grove is of local historical and representative significance to the City of Boroondara. Why is it significant? Historically, the house is significant as the first known house to be built by the AV Jennings Construction Company in the City of Boroondara, and one of its last individual residential commissions prior to World War Two. Founded in 1932 to provide high-quality brick houses at affordable prices, the company began building individual houses but expanded into entire housing estates by the mid-1930s. The company went on to have a significant presence in the area with the Trentwood Estate in Balwyn North, and became Australia's largest private home builder and the largest and most influential provider of house and land packages. (Criterion A) The house at 7 Leura Grove is a representative and largely intact example of a Moderne style two-storey residence of the late interwar period. It exhibits the aesthetic characteristics of this style, including asymmetric massing, rounded corners, strong horizontal lines strengthened by the parapet and steel railing to the terrace, ribbon windows to the single-storey, semi-circular wing at the front, horizontal bands of glass blocks, and a flat concrete roof. While its presentation has been compromised by bagging of the cream face bricks, its overall composition is still clearly legible. It is also one of the small number of avant-garde Moderne houses built by AV Jennings in the interwar period, and appears to be part of the oeuvre of Edgar Gurney, whose own house in Ivanhoe was designed in this style. (Criteria D, H) Grading and Recommendations Recommended for inclusion in the Schedule to the Heritage Overlay of the Boroondara Planning Scheme as an individually significant place. Recommendations for the Schedule to the Heritage Overlay (Clause 43.01) in the Boroondara Planning Scheme: External Paint Colours Is a permit required to paint an already painted surface? Internal Alteration Controls Is a permit required for internal alterations? Tree Controls Is a permit required to remove a tree? Victorian Heritage Register Is the place included on the Victorian Heritage Register? Incorporated Plan Does an Incorporated Plan apply to the site? No No No No No Outbuildings and fences exemptions Are there outbuildings and fences which are not exempt from notice and review? Prohibited uses may be permitted Can a permit be granted to use the place for a use which would otherwise be prohibited? Aboriginal Heritage Place Is the place an Aboriginal heritage place which is subject to the requirements of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006? No No No Identified By Built Heritage (2012), 'City of Boroondara Thematic Environmental History'. References Built Heritage (2012), 'City of Boroondara Thematic Environmental History', prepared for the City of Boroondara. Garden, Don (1992), Builders To The Nation, The A.V. Jennings Story, Melbourne. Land Victoria (LV), Certificates of Title, as cited above. National Trust citation B7247, 'Beauville Estate', http://www.nationaltrust.org.au/vic/Home, January 2013. viewed online at