FERNDOWN TOWN COUNCIL
Minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee held on Thursday 8th October 2009 at 1930hrs
(7.30pm) at the King George V Pavilion, Peter Grant Way, Ferndown.
ATTENDANCE LIST
Councillors:
Chairman – Cllr Mrs R Lovett
Vice Chairman – Cllr Mrs C Lugg
Cllr T Cordery
Cllr J Muggleton
In Attendance:
Cllr Mrs L Dedman
Cllr J Wilson
Cllr M Johnson
9 Members of the public
Officers:
Mr Paul Falconbridge - Deputy Town Clerk
_________________________________________________________________________________
PART 1 - PUBLIC SESSION
A member of the public made a short presentation to the committee regarding application number
3/09/0689/FUL.
A member of the public made a short presentation to the committee regarding application number
3/09/0639/HOU.
09/150
APOLOGIES
There were no apologies for absence received.
09/151
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
There were no declarations of interest on any items on the Agenda.
09/152
APPLICATIONS – INSPECTION OF THE DEPOSITED PLANS
The plans were considered by the Committee and its observations were recorded as
listed in the attached schedule on pages 2583 - 2586 of the minutes.
The time being 2044 hrs (8.44 pm) Cllr J Muggleton left the meeting.
09/153
EAST DORSET DISTRICT COUNCIL – PLANNING DECISIONS
The lists of East Dorset District Council planning decisions were noted.
09/154
TREE MATTERS
The lists of East Dorset District Council tree decisions were noted.
09/155
CORRESPONDENCE
There were no items of correspondence.
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
09/156
ITEMS FOR THE NEXT MEETING
A question was asked about the Dormy Hotel site and whether there had been any
further progress with an application for the site. The Committee were informed that the
office had been contacted by the developer and they would like to make a presentation
regarding their proposals in the near future. Once a date for the meeting had been
agreed details would be distributed to Councillors.
The Deputy Town Clerk at the request of the Town Clerk requested that the Committee
look again at delegated powers for officers when dealing with planning applications and
the Town Clerk was asked to prepare a report and a presentation for a forthcoming
meeting.
09/157
DATE OF THE NEXT MEETING
The next meeting of the Planning Committee will be held on Thursday 29th October
2009.
There being no further business, the meeting closed at 2108hrs (9.08 pm).
Chairman ________________________
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
Date: ________
Ferndown Town Council planning applications discussed and comments made at the
meeting of 8th October 2009
1
App No: 3/09/0461/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Central
Applicant: Mr Paul Aldridge, Avon Project Services Ltd, 3 Wren Close, Hightown,
Ringwood, Hampshire, BH24 3RF
Site: Mr John Thorneycroft, 7 Everglades Close, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 9SZ
Proposal: New conservatory to rear and new detached garage
Comment: NO OBJECTION
2
App No:
Applicant:
Site:
Proposal:
3/09/0639/HOU
Ward: Longham Parish
Mr Tony Dade, 33 Foxwood Avenue, Christchurch, Dorset, BH23 3JZ
Mr N Wood, 7 Longacre Drive, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 9EE
Ground floor side and rear extension and raise roof to provide first floor
accommodation to include dormer windows and roof lights
Comment: OBJECT
 Overbearing form of development
 Concerns about a potential commercial use of the workshop described in
the application and subsequent noise pollution
 The rear elevation on the application is over imposing
3
App No:
Applicant:
Site:
Proposal:
Comment:
4
App No: 3/09/0689/FUL
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: Mr Alister Scott, Brennan Williams Lester, 2 Pullman Business Park,
Pullman Way, Ringwood, Hampshire, BH24 1EX
Site: Mr Gary Hughes, Ferndown Nursing Home, 9 Dudsbury Crescent,
Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 8JG
Proposal: Two storey extension and conservatory to rear of nursing home; revised
parking and landscaping
Comment: OBJECT
 Overbearing form of development within the New Road Special Character
Area
 The positioning of the laundry room on the site would cause a significant
noise disturbance to the neighbouring properties
 The car parking provision on the site is inadequate and would cause an
overflow of vehicles into Dudsbury Crescent exacerbating current
congestion problems
 The proposal for dementia care within the development is inappropriate in
this residential area
 The proposal would have a detrimental impact on protected species
5
App No:
Applicant:
Site:
Proposal:
Comment:
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
3/09/0686/HOU
Ward: Ameysford
Mr Mark Cook, 16 Winterbourne Road, Poole, Dorset, BH15 2ES
Mr Steven Moss, 14 Curlew Close, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 9TN
Single storey rear extension
NO OBJECTION
3/09/0733/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Mr Michael Harper, 1 Cliff Drive, Canford Cliffs, Poole, Dorset, BH13 7SD
Mr Michael Harper, 17 Dudsbury Crescent, Ferndown, Dorset
Dormer window on rear elevation
NO OBJECTION
Ferndown Town Council planning applications discussed and comments made at the
meeting of 8th October 2009
6
App No: 3/09/0739/HOU
Ward: Longham Parish
Applicant: Ms Rosalind Smith, Anglia Home Improvements, National Admin Centre,
Norwich, Norfolk, NR6 6EJ
Site: Mrs A McKinstry, 17 St Cleve Way, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 8LE
Proposal: Rear conservatory
Comment: NO OBJECTION
7
App No: 3/09/0781/COU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: Mr Gary Palmer, Goadsby & Harding, Survey and Valuation, 99
Holdenhurst Road, Bournemouth, Dorset, BH8 8DY
Site: 400-402 Ringwood Road, Ferndown, Dorset
Proposal: Change of use from vacant A2 office to D1 to provide dental practice
Comment: NO OBJECTION
8
App No: 3/09/0786/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: David James Architects Ltd, 5 Wolterton Road, Branksome, Poole, Dorset,
BH12 1LR
Site: Mr Ivan Martch, 10 Dudsbury Avenue, Ferndown, Dorset
Proposal: Two storey rear extension to include Juliet balcony, new bay window to
living room and single storey front extension to provide new entrance lobby
Comment: NO OBJECTION
9
App No: 3/09/0799/FUL
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant:
Site: Mr Sean Malherbe, Ferndown Golf Club, 119 Golf Links Road, Ferndown,
Dorset, BH22 8BU
Proposal: Remove existing 1.2m high wire mesh fence on front boundary and replace
with 1.53m high loop top railings coloured black
Comment: NO OBJECTION
10
App No:
Applicant:
Site:
Proposal:
Comment:
11
App No: 3/09/0814/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: Bryan Tomlinson & Associates, 9 Kingsland House, 512 Wimborne Road
East, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 9NE
Site: Rev.Goldenberg, 2 Golf Links Road, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 8BT
Proposal: Erect fence
Comment: NO OBJECTION
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
3/09/0813/FUL
Ward: Ferndown Links
Mr R Jones, Irwin & Jones, Stapehill Crescent, Wimborne, Dorset, BH21 2ED
Mr Antony Cox, 48 Dudsbury Avenue, Ferndown, Dorset
Proposed pitched roof on existing hobbies room
NO OBJECTION
Ferndown Town Council planning applications discussed and comments made at the
meeting of 8th October 2009
12
App No: 3/09/0821/FUL
Ward: Ferndown Central
Applicant: Mr M Hammond, 51, Nutshalling Avenue, Rownhams, Soton, Hampshire,
SO16 8AY
Site: Briton House Properties Ltd, 77-83 Victoria Road, Ferndown, Dorset
Proposal: Provision of 3 additional floors above shops to form 4 storey building to
provide 12 flats above shops
Comment: NO OBJECTION but the Committee would like to see that a condition is placed
within any approval that the balconies described should have some form of
screening to protect the privacy of the residents
13
App No: 3/09/0827/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: Mr Iain Millwood, Birchmore Building Services, 27 Persley Road,
Bournemouth, Dorset, BH10 6DX
Site: Mr Keith Sherren, 8, Fernlea Close, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 8HH
Proposal: Rear extension to garage to form bedroom, rear extension to form
sunroom and alterations to front driveway
Comment: NO OBJECTION
14
App No: 3/09/0829/FUL
Ward: Longham Parish
Applicant: Seven Developments Ltd, Unit 4, Joshuas Vista, 202 Sandbanks Road,
Poole, Dorset, BH14 8HA
Site: 86 Ringwood Road, Longham, Ferndown
Proposal: Erect single detached house with integral garage
Comment: NO OBJECTION
15
App No: 3/09/0840/FUL
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant: Mr D Atkins, Grange Architects, The Boast Shed, Haven Road, Exeter,
Devon, EX2 8DD
Site: Dr James Hickey, 24 Dudsbury Avenue, Ferndown, Dorset
Proposal: Demolish dwelling and erect two storey building to provide 7 flats with
associated on site parking, turning and outbuildings (Re-sub 09/0360 to
allow extra flat)
Comment: NO OBJECTION
16
App No: 3/09/0841/FUL
Ward: Stapehill
Applicant: Mr R Rogers, Look Architecture, 27 Richmond Park Avenue,
Bournemouth, Dorset, BH8 9DL
Site: Mr N Wellstead, 38 Wimborne Road West, Stapehill, Wimborne
Proposal: Retrospective planning application for new chalet dwelling with amended
siting and parking arrangements from approval 3/06/1595
Comment: NO OBJECTION
17
App No: 3/09/0847/HOU
Ward: Stapehill
Applicant: Mr J Whitton, Premier Design Ltd, Main Road, Cherhill, Calne, Wiltshire,
SW11 8UT
Site: Mr K Taylor, Clayford House, Uddens Drive, Ferndown, Dorset, BH21 7BJ
Proposal: Replacement swimming pool enclosure
Comment: NO OBJECTION
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
Ferndown Town Council planning applications discussed and comments made at the
meeting of 8th October 2009
18
App No: 3/09/0850/HOU
Ward: Stapehill
Applicant:
Site: Mr Adan Trimmer, 3 Hayes Lane, Ferndown, Dorset, BH21 2JA
Proposal: Two storey side and rear extension, single detached garage and raise roof to
provide accommodation (Amendment to 3/09/0179)
Comment: NO OBJECTION
19
App No: 3/09/0858/HOU
Ward: Ferndown Links
Applicant:
Site: Mrs & Mrs Dale Edmunds, 46, Dudsbury Crescent, Ferndown, Dorset,
BH22 8JF
Proposal: Raise and extend roof including two rear dormer windows. Erect two storey
rear extension, chimney and replacement garage
Comment: NO OBJECTION
20
App No:
Applicant:
Site:
Proposal:
Comment:
Planning Meeting
8th October 2009
3/09/0859/HOU
Ward: Longham East
Mr K Flack, 46 Jessica Avenue, Verwood, Dorset, BH31 6LH
Mr & Mrs J Rolfe, 113 Wollaton, Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 8QS
Single storey side and rear extension
NO OBJECTION