Chapter 3.4 Ohmmeters • How can we measure resistance? An apparent simple way is to measure the current I, through a resistor and the voltage V, across it. We can then use Ohm’s Law to calculate V/I. A DC V Rx • If both meters have an accuracy of ±x%, what is the error in this method? What about loading? Recall that the above method assumes an ideal ammeter and voltmeter • What are the internal resistances of the ideal ammeter and voltmeter? Answer: 0 and respectively • We have non ideal meters, therefore the actual meter resistances would have to be considered. – Hence our interest in loading • We also showed that the error is actually its smallest value at FSD. – ± 2x% is in fact the minimum error. • Can we create an instrument that can directly read resistance and avoid these concerns? • Consider the following circuit arrangement: A Rz Rm DC RX • Note that we have a DC power source in this case. • If the voltage of the source is V Volts and the circulating current is I Amps then: • If Rx is zero, i.e, we short circuit the probes and adjust Rz to give a reading of IFSD on the meter, V IRtotal I ( Rz Rm Rx ) • We can say: EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 1 © 2001 I I FSD ; V I FSD ( Rz Rm ); Rz V I FSD Rm • We call Rz the zero ohms adjust. • At this point IFSD is passing through the ammeter. • We mark this as the 0 Ohms position. 0 PMMC SCALE 50A • With the probes open, what is the circulating current? – 0 Amps – This implies resistance • We mark this as the Ohms position: 0 0A PMMC SCALE 50A • How do we determine the intermediate positions? • Since ammeter scale is linear, we can chose other points, 1/5, 2/5, 3/5, 4/5 FSD etc and calculate the corresponding resistance. Example If IFSD is 50A, Rm is 3k and V is 1.5V,calculate the resistance for the positions previously identified. Solution What is Rz? For this position, I = 50 A, therefore: Rz V I FSD Rm 1.5 3000 27k 50 10 6 For the 4/5 position, I = 40 A, therefore: V IRtotal I ( Rz Rm Rx ) 1.5 37.5k 40 10 6 Rx 37.5 30 7.5k ( Rz Rm Rx ) EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 2 © 2001 For the 3/5 position, I = 30 A, therefore: V IRtotal I ( Rz Rm Rx ) 1.5 50k 30 10 6 Rx 50 30 20k ( Rz Rm Rx ) Similarly for the 2/5 and 1/5 positions we get that Rx is 45k and 120k respectively. Our ohmmeter scale now looks like: 45 k 120 k 20 k 20A 30A 10A 7.5 k 40A PMMC SCALE 0A 0 50A Comments • Is scale linear or not? – Scale is non-linear • Crowded at the high resistance end – Where is 200k for example • Called a back-off scale since zero is to the right. • This type of meter is called a series-type ohmmeter. • The ohmmeter has a power source. What happens if the source voltage changes? Let us analyse this using the previous example, but the battery voltage is now 1.4V. What is the true reading for the 20k position on the ohmmeter? Scenario 1 - We don’t re-zero the meter. • The 20k position is associated with 30A through the meter movement. Rz Rm 30k; Rx • • • • • 1.4V 30k 16.7 k 30A What is indicated as 20k on the meter is actually 16.7k in reality. The ohmmeter is over reading. Scenario 2 - We re-zero the meter The new value for Rz is: Rz EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 1.4V 3k 25k 50A 3 © 2001 Rz Rm 28k; 1.4V Rx 28k 18.7 k 30 A • • • • Here, what is indicated as 20k on the meter is actually 18.7k in reality. The ohmmeter is again over reading. It is clear that the source voltage is critical to the performance of the ohmmeter. Commercial meters would have some type of voltage regulator to avoid this. Alternative series ohmmeter • Consider the following circuit. R1 A Rz RX Rm DC • Again Rz is the zeroing resistor and an additional resistor, R1, now acts as the current limiter. Note that Rz is now in parallel with the movement. There are 2 values to be calculated: Rz and R1. • In order to design this ohmmeter, we need to decide ahead of time what resistance represents a 1/2 scale reading. We call that value Rh. Thus by setting Rh = Rx we can draw an equivalent circuit as follows: RE R1 A Rz Rh Rm DC • We can say: RE R1 Rm RZ • If we short the probes, we adjust Rz to make IFSD flow through the meter. EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 4 © 2001 • The total circuit resistance is now RE • When we make Rx= Rh, IFSD/2 now flows through the meter. Remember that we decided that Rh caused a half scale deflection. • Therefore RE= Rh for a current of IFSD/2 V ; 2 Rh I • Therefore , to produce FSD, the total current is IT V Rh • Returning to the circuit: IT Im IZ A RE R1 Rz Rh Rm DC V at I m I FSD Rh I Z IT I m ; V IZ I FSD Rh IT • Thus: RZ I Z Rm I FSD ; Rm I FSD Rm I FSD RZ V IZ R I FSD h • Since Rh RE R1 RZ Rm ; R1 Rh RZ Rm ; • We can now calculate R1. EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 5 © 2001 Example • You are given an ohmmeter of the following design, with Rh = 2000: R1 50 1mA Rz A RX Rm 3V • Calculate (1) (2) (3) Rz and R1 ; The value of Rz to compensate for a 10% drop in battery voltage; and The scale error when measuring 2000 with a low battery as in (2). Solution (1) V I FSD Rh 3 IZ 1 10 3 0.5mA 2000 IZ RZ Rm I FSD 50 1mA 100 IZ 0.5mA R1 Rh RZ Rm 100 50 R1 2000 1.97 k 150 (2) With the drop in battery voltage, the new Iz is: V IZ I FSD Rh IZ 2.7 110 3 0.35mA 2000 Therefore the new Rz is: Rm I FSD 50 1mA 143 IZ 0.35mA The new value of Rh can now be calculated: RZ (4) Rh R1 RZ Rm ; Rh 1.97 k EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 143 50 2.01k 193 6 © 2001 Therefore, when the scale indicates 2000, the true reading is really 2.01k. Is this under or over reading? 2.0 2.01 % error (under) 100 0.5% 2.01 • Note this arrangement has a better tolerance to small voltage drops in the DC source than the previous design. EE11A Handouts 106757476 Prepared by: Mr. Fasil Muddeen 7 © 2001