PARTICIPANT’S WORKBOOK Team Building For Public Health Professionals SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM Sustainable Management Development Program Division of Global Public Health Capacity Development Coordinating Office for Global Health U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention http://www.cdc.gov/globalhealth/SMDP/ TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Team Building CONTENTS Introduction Sustainable Management Development Program Acknowledgements v v Team Building About this Course Target Audience Learning Objectives Icon Glossary vi vi vi vii Introduction to Team Building What is a Team? Qualities of High Performing Teams 1 2 Building and Managing a Successful Team Methods for Building Effective Teams Typical Problem Behaviors Within Teams Remedies for Common Team Problem Behaviors Alignment 4 5 7 8 Conclusion Summary Congratulations! What’s Next? Resources 10 10 11 11 Appendices Appendix A Team Assessment Tool Appendix B Antidotes to Problem Behaviors Appendix C Glossary of Terms Course Evaluation Form 13 14 16 18 CONTENTS | iii TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS iv | CONTENTS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Introduction SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM The CDC Sustainable Management Development Program is dedicated to strengthening health systems globally through improved public health leadership and management in low resource countries. We do this by building country capacity to achieve a lasting impact, advancing the science base through applied research and evaluation, and developing strong partnerships and providing strategic leadership. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Hanna Cooper, MPH, CPCC, ACC. Julie-Anne Odell Concepts and ideas have also come from the following: The Center for Right Relationship, http://www.centerforrightrelationship.com/ Gottman, John M. The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work: A Practical Guide from the Country's Foremost Relationship Expert Three Rivers Press; 1 edition (May 16, 2000). Sue Walden, ImprovWorks, http://www.improvworks.org/ Team Diagnostic International, http://www.teamdiagnosticassessment.com SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM | v TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Team Building ABOUT THIS COURSE The goal of this course is to enable you to work more effectively as a team member or team leader. TARGET AUDIENCE This course is designed for supervisors and managers in public health services, typically at district-level. It is expected that you have responsibilities for forming, leading, or participating in teams. While the course may be conducted with an intact work team, the course is designed as a survey of team building skills for a group without previous working relationships. There are no prerequisites to this course. LEARNING OBJECTIVES When participants complete this workshop they will be able to: Describe the importance of effectively functioning teams as an essential element to successful public health programs. Describe how to create more effective working relationships among team members. Create positive and productive team agreements and norms. Select specific skills and tools when creating alignment within diverse teams. Choose effective responses to resolve common problem behaviors present in teams. vi | ABOUT THIS COURSE TEAM BUILDING ICON GLOSSARY The following icons are used in this workbook: TIP: SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION TO HELP PERFORM A TASK MORE EASILY EXERCISE ICON GLOSSARY | vii TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS viii | ICON GLOSSARY TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Introduction to Team Building WHAT IS A TEAM? Exercise 1: Opportunities and Challenges to Teamwork Think about the teams-both personal and professional-that you have been a part of. In your experience, what opportunities, and challenges have you experienced when working within teams? Write your answers below: Opportunities Challenges More and more frequently, teams are used as a core method of accomplishing work tasks. A team is defined as two or more people coming together to accomplish a specific task. Examples of teams: Project teams Coalitions Management team WHAT IS A TEAM?| 1 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Leading experts in team dynamics discovered other opportunities and challenges to working with others. These include: Opportunities Challenges Leveraged diversity Don’t measure up to potential Harnessed knowledge/wisdom of individuals Increased participation Problem behaviors Gained organizational buy-in More creative responses/solutions Greater productivity Lack of clarity/shared accountability for goals Ineffective decision making Poor implementation and followthrough Lack of empowerment and organizational support QUALITIES OF HIGH PERFORMING TEAMS An assessment developed by Team Diagnostic International identified qualities of high performing teams: results strengths (strengths related to accomplishing the task such as having a purpose/goal, boundaries, direction, and support) and relationship strengths (strengths related to managing team relationships such as interpersonal and facilitation skills). Relationship Strengths Results Strengths Camaraderie Accountability Communication Alignment Constructive Interaction Decision Making Optimism Goals and Strategies Respect Proactive Trust Resources Values Diversity Team Leadership Source: Adapted from Team Diagnostic International: http://www.teamdiagnosticassessment.com 2 | QUALITIES OF HIGH PERFORMING TEAMS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Exercise 2: Behaviors 1. Describe behaviors you expect to observe in each type of team below. High Relationship Low Relationship High Results Low Results 2. What is the impact of high or low relationships or results within a team? Exercise 3: Team Reflection 1. Take a moment to think about your own work team. You may find that there are both high and low levels of relationships and results. Make a note of your observations in the grid. High Relationship Low Relationship High Results Low Results 2. In general, which box do you think best represents your team? QUALITIES OF HIGH PERFORMING TEAMS| 3 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Building and Managing a Successful Team METHODS FOR BUILDING EFFECTIVE TEAMS Similar to good public health program implementation, you’ll be more successful in achieving your ends if you start with an assessment and invest in planning up front. This is true whether you are working with an existing team or creating a new one. Just as in public health program development, there are many ways to assess and plan the working relationships within a team, depending on the context, your resources, and the team itself. Exercise 4: Team Assessment 1. What areas of a team should be assessed? Write your answers below. What to Assess? 2. What methods can you use to assess team functioning? Write your answers below. Assessment Methods 3. What questions could you ask in your assessment? Write your answers below. Potential Questions to Ask 4 | METHODS FOR BUILDING EFFECTIVE TEAMS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Exercise 5: Creating Team Agreements 1. What types of working agreements should be developed when creating an effective team? Write your answers below. Team Agreements 2. How might you want to use assessment and design principles within teams you are currently working with? Use Appendix A to conduct a team assessment when you return to your workplace TYPICAL PROBLEM BEHAVIORS WITHIN TEAMS Sometimes teams exhibit habits that might get in the way of being at their best. Some reasons include: 1. Teams are made up of people. 2. Working as part of a team is complex. 3. Being on a team takes highly developed interpersonal, meeting and facilitation skills. 4. The workplace is full of stress: o Trust is low o High degrees of cynicism and uncertainty due to economic realities o Sense of powerlessness can exist TYPICAL PROBLEM BEHAVIORS WITHIN TEAMS| 5 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS There are four typical problem behaviors that commonly occur in teams. This work comes from an American researcher, John Gottman, who researched these behaviors in couples, but they also apply to teams. Blaming/Criticism Attacking the other person rather than the behavior Contempt Belittling other through name calling and hostile humor Defensiveness Refusing to recognize your contribution to the problem Withholding/Obstructing Cutting off communication by being unresponsive or refusing to engage with others Source:Adapted from John Gottman The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work: A Practical Guide from the Country's Foremost Relationship Expert Exercise 6: Problem Behaviors 1. Which of these behaviors have you used? Which one(s) do you dislike the most? 2. How do these behaviors affect teams? 6 | TYPICAL PROBLEM BEHAVIORS WITHIN TEAMS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS REMEDIES FOR COMMON TEAM PROBLEM BEHAVIORS Notice your own patterns. Which problem behaviors do you regularly use? What is the impact when you use them? Notice and bring problem behaviors out in the open to help defuse them. Look for the request behind the complaint. The problem behavior may be an unskillful attempt to request change. Don’t take it personally. Instead of focusing on who is doing what to whom, focus on what is trying to happen in the system. Acknowledge and appreciate team strengths: team strengths and successes when they occur to build up a resevoir of positivity within the team and prevent problems. Revisit the groundrules you established with your team Caution! Use these terms as an opportunity to have a common language with your team and to name behaviors that are unhelpful. Do not label people! What else might you do when you encounter problem behaviors on teams you are working with? How do these ideas apply in your situation? How can you use this concept of problem team behaviors in teams that you are currently a part of? How can you address some of the challenges of working with teams? Refer to Appendix B to help overcome problem behaviors in your workplace. REMEDIES FOR COMMON TEAM PROBLEM BEHAVIORS| 7 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS ALIGNMENT An important part of working together within a team is the ability to see the potential in others and in their ideas. This requires taking the time to acknowledge and find some value in each suggestion. We are trained to look for what doesn’t work. Identifying problems is a big part of many of our jobs. However, in the long run this can have the effect of limiting our perspective to only our ideas and ways of doing things. Rather than aiming for 100% agreement within a team, a focus on alignment promotes increased creativity, team participation, and honors diversity within the team. Alignment means looking for a common underlying set of beliefs or purpose. With this type of perspective, disagreement can actually become a creative act. Yes, and. . . is a process that requires you to listen and acknowledge the richness of someone else’s contribution. It can be a method to create alignment. While it is artificial in normal conversation to use these words constantly, Yes, and. . . can even be powerful as an attitude as much as a set of words. Exercise 7: Yes, And … 1. Find a partner and practice using the Yes, and. . . model in the training session. How did this attitude affect the outcome of your conversation? 2. How can you apply this idea of Yes and in your teams? 8 | ALIGNMENT TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Exercise 8: Individual Development Plan Think about the concepts and skills discussed in today’s course. How could you improve the effectiveness of your own team? Answer these questions. 1. What challenges am I currently facing in my work teams? 2. How might I use this skills from this workshop in my work setting? 3. .What two strategies have I learned about working with teams? 4. What is one skill from today that I’d like to improve upon? 5. What would assist me in further developing my team building skills? By ___________, I will ________________________________________ (date) (action to further develop my skills) Signed: _______________________________ Today’s Date ALIGNMENT| 9 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Conclusion SUMMARY Successful teams create and maintain strong relationships to produce results that support the team’s objectives. By using intentionally assessing and designing your working relationships, addressing problem behaviors, and looking for ways to build alignment, you’ll be well on your way to having more effective work teams, and ultimately greater impact on important public health programs. CONGRATULATIONS! You’ve completed this introduction to the importance of team building. You should be able to: Describe the importance of effectively functioning teams as an essential element to successful public health programs. Create more effective working relationships among team members. Create positive and productive team agreements and norms. Select specific skills and tools when creating alignment within diverse teams. Choose effective responses to resolve common problem behaviors present in teams. 10 | SUMMARY TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS WHAT’S NEXT? Complete the Individual Development Plan that you began today by setting realistic target dates for the ideas you want to implement. Consider conducting a workshop with your work team to introduce these methods and conduct a team assessment. Learn more about handling conflict and the dynamics of positive and productive team relationships by observing successful teams in your own work setting. RESOURCES Beaudoin, Marie-Nathalie, and Walden, Sue. Working with Groups to Enhance Relationships. Whole Person Associates, Duluth, MN 1998. Bens, Ingrid. Advanced Team Facilitation. GOAL/QPC, 2000. Center for Right Relationship Training: Global resources for those working with teams. http://www.centerforrightrelationship.com/ Gottman, John M. The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work: A Practical Guide from the Country's Foremost Relationship Expert Three Rivers Press; 1 edition (May 16, 2000). Lenccioni, Patrick. The Five Dysfunctions of a Team. Jossey-Bass, 2002. Patterson, Kerry, Grenny, Joseph, McMillan, Ron, Switzler, Al, Covey, Stephen R. Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes are High. McGraw-Hill, 2002. Scott, Susan. Fierce Conversations. Berkley Trade, 2004. Team Diagnostic International Training: Assessment tool for teams. http://www.teamdiagnosticassessment.com WHAT’S NEXT? | 11 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Appendices 12 | APPENDICES TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS APPENDIX A TEAM ASSESSMENT TOOL What to Assess? Team structure Team members Team history The results strengths of the team (accountability, alignment, decision making, goals and strategies, ability to be proactive, resources, team leadership, etc.) The positivity strengths of the team (camaraderie, communication, constructive interaction, optimism, respect, trust, values diversity, etc.) Methods Interviews Surveys Review existing team materials (agenda, minutes, reports, products) Observation Questions to Ask What are the strengths and challenges of the team? What are the priorities/goals of the team? What are the roles and responsibilities of each team member? What ground rules are in place for the team? What is the decision making process for the team? How are meetings structured? (minutes, agenda, etc.) How is leadership responsibilities shared? What incentives are in place to reward achievement and success? How does the team function under stressful conditions? What is the overall vision of the team? What is the team tolerating/putting up with? Team Agreements Define team priorities, goals, and vision Set team agreements and ground rules Define roles, responsibilities and leadership Outline decision making process/accountability Build in accountability APPENDIX A TEAM ASSESSMENT TOOL | 13 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS APPENDIX B ANTIDOTES TO PROBLEM BEHAVIORS You may find yourself engaging in problem behaviors. Try these methods to create a more constructive work environment. If you use BLAME: “It’s THEIR fault.” Shifting the responsibility for a problem onto someone else. “If only they did their job, we wouldn’t have this problem.” Try this Use “I” statements rather than “you” statements. Instead of blaming say: I feel ______________________________________________ about this behavior____________________________________ and I want you to________________________________________ DEFENSIVENESS: “It’s not my fault.” This could be vocal, but subtle forms of defensiveness include not acknowledging the feedback from others and withdrawing. WITHHOLDING: “Forget about it” This could be practiced by silence. More subtle forms of withholding are not speaking up about something, avoiding people, and not answering messages in a timely manner. Practice the 2% rule. If only 2% of what they are criticizing about you were true, what part of it could you accept responsibility for? Be open to influence and learning from others. CONTEMPT: “You IDIOT!” Contempt is demeaning the other person (eye rolling, swearing, personal attack, sarcasm, hostile humor, name calling). It is being disrespectful. Subtle forms of contempt are going around the chain of command, hostile gossiping and undermining people. Make a commitment to the other person to stop doing it. 14 | APPENDIX B Ask yourself if you are overwhelmed by the conversation and tell the other person if you are. Request a brief break and let the other person know that you will initiate talking at a specific time. Take a few moments to figure out what you want to say and return to the issue with them at the agreed upon time. Be open to influence and suggestions from others. Check and see if you are overwhelmed by the conversation when you do it and ask for a break if you are. Resume when you can continue without losing control. Then address the behaviors you want to see changed using the “I feel…when you ….and I want,” format presented above for blaming. ANTIDOTES TO PROBLEM BEHAVIORS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Consider the following questions. Write down your responses, and arrange a time to discuss them with your team. Where do the 4 problem behaviors show up at work or on your team? What situations trigger them? What problem behaviors are you most likely to use? What situations trigger it? Make a plan for how you will handle it differently in the future. What will you do to avoid using the problem behaviors? See antidotes listed above. Think of at least two ways you could strengthen relationships at your job. APPENDIX B ANTIDOTES TO PROBLEM BEHAVIORS | 15 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS APPENDIX C GLOSSARY OF TERMS ALIGNMENT Common underlying set of beliefs or purpose. ASSESSMENT The systematic collection, review, and use of information for the purpose of improving development. BEHAVIOR A manner of acting or controlling oneself. CAMARADERIE Goodwill and rapport among co-workers. COALITION An organization or group of people involved in a common project. DESIGN Make or work out a plan for. TEAM Two or more people coming together to accomplish a specific task. RELATIONSHIPS In the team building context, strengths related to managing team relationships, such as interpersonal and facilitation skills. RESULTS In the team building context, strengths related to accomplishing a task, such as having a purpose/goal, boundaries, direction, and support. VISION Overall, encompassing goal of a team or organization. 16 | APPENDIX C GLOSSARY OF TERMS TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS | 17 TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS COURSE EVALUATION FORM Team Building Evaluation Please help us improve the workshop by responding candidly to the following statements: Scale Definition: 1 – Strongly Disagree 2 – Disagree 3 – Neither Agree nor Disagree 4 – Agree 5 – Strongly Agree 1. Course objectives were well communicated 1 2 3 4 5 2. The training was built to match the way I need to do my job 1 2 3 4 5 3. Adequate time was allotted for explanations/practice 1 2 3 4 5 4. The training materials were well written 1 2 3 4 5 5. Job aids are available to support what I learned 1 2 3 4 5 6. I know where to get assistance when I return to my job 1 2 3 4 5 7. Overall the class was satisfactory 1 2 3 4 5 What did you like most about the class? How can we improve the class? Do you have any additional questions regarding this topic? If you wish us to contact you, please provide the following information: Name 18 | COURSE EVALUATION FORM Email Telephone Number TEAM BUILDING FOR PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS COURSE EVALUATION FORM | 19