Hawksbill Turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus 1766) IUCN Status Category: Critically Endangered CITES Appendix: I INTRODUCTION The hawksbill turtle is a medium-sized cheloniid, usually less than 1m in length and weighs 4060kg. The shell is thin, flexible and highly coloured with elaborate patterns. As the English name suggests, Eretmochelys imbricata has a narrow pointed beak reminiscent of a bird of prey. Hawksbill turtles are mainly carnivorous and use their narrow beaks to extract invertebrate prey from crevices on the reef. Both sessile and mobile animals are consumed, and Eretmochelys imbricata would seem to be an opportunistic predator, although sponges normally constitute a major proportion of its diet. Nesting occurs widely throughout the range, but tends to be more dispersed than in other species. There are seldom more than a few hundred nests on a single beach and few major colonial nesting beaches. It has been suggested that this is simply a result of centuries of overexploitation. The hawksbill appears to nest every two to three years and lays 60 to 200 eggs at a time. Nesting is mainly seasonal and varies with the location of the nesting beach. Yearround nesting has been recorded in some localities. The hawksbill often nests close to coral reefs, and is often encountered by snorkellers and scuba-divers. In the past, the hawksbill was thought by many to have a more sedentary life history than the other species of marine turtle (Hendrickson 1980). However, more recent work involving satellite telemetry has revealed that the hawksbill does make long distance migrations. In 1994, Groshens and Vaughan found that all turtles tracked by satellite from Buck Island Reef National Monument in St Croix, US Virgin Islands moved away after nesting; it is likely they utilise completely different areas for feeding and breeding. The carapace of the hawksbill is unusual amongst the sea turtles as the scutes (the hard, bony plates that constitute the shell) are overlapping. These are often streaked and marbled with amber, yellow or brown, most evident when the shell material is worked and polished. This species is the sole source of commercial "tortoiseshell". DISTRIBUTION The hawksbill is pan-tropical and has only rarely been recorded outside the tropics. It can be found in the eastern Atlantic from as far north as the coast of France to the southern tip of Africa. There are feeding grounds in the Mediterranean. The range stretches from along the east coast of Africa, the Middle East and India to South Asia and as far north as China. It can be found in the coastal waters of Australia and Indonesia. In the Americas Eretmochelys imbricata can be found in the east Pacific, from the United States to Peru, and in the west Atlantic, from Nova Scotia to Brazil. Breeding range states: American Samoa, Anguilla, Antigua and Barbuda, Aruba, Australia, Bahamas, Bangladesh, Barbados, Belize, Brazil, British Indian Ocean Territory, Cambodia, Cameroon?, Cape Verde?, China?, Colombia, Comoros, Cook Islands, Costa Rica, Cote d'Ivoire, Cuba, Djibouti?, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Egypt, El Salvador?, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Federated States of Micronesia, Fiji, French Guyana, French Polynesia?, Gabon?, Ghana?, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Guam, Guatemala, Guinea?, GuineaBissau?, Guyana, Haiti, Honduras, India, Indonesia, Iran, Jamaica, Japan, Kenya, Kiribati?, Kuwait?, Madagascar, Malaysia, Maldives, Marshall Islands, Martinique, Mauritania?, Mayotte, Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 1 Mexico, Montserrat, Mozambique, Myanmar, Netherlands Antilles, New Caledonia?, Nicaragua, Nigeria?, Northern Marianas?, Oman, Palau, Panama, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Puerto Rico, Qatar, Reunion (Iles Glorieuses), Sao Tome and Principe?, Saudi Arabia, Senegal?, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Solomon Islands, Somalia, Sri Lanka, St Kitts and Nevis, St Lucia, St Vincent, Sudan, Suriname, Taiwan?, Tanzania, Thailand, Tokelau, Tonga?, Trinidad and Tobago, Turks and Caicos Islands, Tuvalu?, US Minor Pacific Islands?, United States. United Arab Emirates?, Vanuatu, Venezuela, Vietnam?, Virgin Islands (British), Virgin Islands (US), Western Sahara?, Western Samoa, Yemen [Atlantic (eastern central, north-east, north-west, south-east, south-west, western central), Indian Ocean (eastern, western), Mediterranean and Black Sea, Pacific (eastern central, north-west, south-east, south-west, western central)] POPULATION Worldwide numbers of sea turtle populations are very difficult to estimate. considering the wide range of these migratory animals. From the nesting beaches, estimates are possible of adult females. However, data are not recorded at all nesting sites. Even when data are recorded, numbers may be confused due to the uncertainty as to how many times an individual nests in a season. The adult female nesting population is largely unknown but 8000 + ? has recently been estimated (Euro Turtle 1999). There are only five populations worldwide with more than 1,000 females nesting annually. (Kemf, et al. 2000) Genetic studies of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) taken from Eretmochelys imbricata nesting on beaches in seven Caribbean countries (Belize, Mexico, Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands, Antigua, Barbados, and Brazil) have shown that at least six of these colonies are isolated breeding populations (Bass et al. 1996). The studies also show that foraging populations are drawn from many different nesting colonies (Bowen et al. 1996); it is still uncertain whether females always return to the same feeding ground. The significance of isolated breeding colonies in the Caribbean is that a depleted population will not be replenished by immigration from elsewhere. Expiration of a population will result in irreversible loss of genetic diversity. In northern Australia, there appear to be two separate breeding populations of the hawksbill, consisting of many nesting beaches. The closer colonies are related and colonies separated by 2,700km are genetically distinct. (Broderick et al 1994). Major breeding population: There is evidence that a nesting colony on Milman Island in Queensland, Australia is the largest hawksbill population in the world (Loop 1995). THREATS Because of overuse and other threats – including pollution, accidental drowning in fishing nets or hooking by longline fishing, and habitat loss -- six of the world’s seven marine turtle species are in danger of extinction. The hawksbill has been classified by the IUCN/SSC Marine Turtle Specialist Group as “Critically Endangered”. All seven species of marine turtles are listed on Appendix I of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), thus prohibiting international trade by more than 140 CITES member nations. As with other species, Eretmochelys imbricata is threatened by the loss of nesting and feeding habitats, excessive egg-collection, fishery-related mortality, pollution, and coastal development. Despite their protection under CITES, as well as under many national laws, there is still a disturbingly large amount of trade in Eretmochelys imbricata, and this probably constitutes the major threat to the species. Hawksbills have been hunted for centuries as a source of tortoiseshell ("carey" or “bekko”) for jewellery and ornaments. In recent decades eastern Asia, and Japan in particular, has provided Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 2 an eager market for tortoiseshell. Through international conventions and national legislation some countries have sought with some success to restrict trade. In 1975, the hawksbill was included on Appendix I of CITES. Many nations ended their shell imports and exports over the next decade as they became parties to CITES. Japan filed a reservation to CITES on the listing of the hawksbill on Appendix I and continued to import enormous quantities of shell. Between 1970 and 1992, Japan imported about 33 tonnes of hawksbill shell per year, a total equivalent to the deaths of 31,000 turtles annually (Marine Turtle Newsletter 1994). Between 1970 and 1986, approximately 250,000 hawksbill turtles were harvested in the Caribbean (Milliken and Tokunaga 1987). Japan withdrew its reservation to CITES in July 1992, and stopped the import of turtle products in 1993. However, illegal seizures of tortoiseshell at Japanese airports since 1994 include: 24 kg of tortoiseshell from the Dominican Republic in 1994 (TRAFFIC 1994); 3,000 kg of tortoiseshell from Indonesia in 1995 (TRAFFIC 1996); 115kg of tortoiseshell from Singapore in 1995 (TRAFFIC 1996); 66kg of tortoiseshell from Singapore in 1998 (TRAFFIC 1998). Hawksbills are among the small juvenile turtles collected and stuffed for sale as tourist curios. Although many countries have banned this trade, it still occurs. For example, stuffed hawksbill turtles were openly on sale at Hanoi’s international airport in 1998. Harvest for domestic trade still occurs in many countries, including Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Indonesia, Cambodia, the Solomon Islands, and Fiji. The hawksbill turtle is also subjected to many environmental threats. An unknown quantity of turtles (some estimates are as high as 200,000 to 300,000 annually) are killed as "bycatch" (i.e. incidentally), particularly in trawling nets. Decline was set in motion hundreds of years ago and accelerated in this century by decades of egg-collecting and the killing of females; then it was continued by trawler mortality. Longlines for tuna and swordfish are also responsible for killing leatherback and loggerhead turtles, which are attracted to the baited hooks. The turtles either become snared or tangled in the line and are then unable to reach the surface and drown (or in some cases lose a limb). Turtles that have swallowed hooks almost certainly die as well, although they may be released alive. This problem is particularly acute because these two species feed on planktonic organisms that are found in highest concentrations along oceanic fronts, areas that also support the highest densities of pelagic fish. Beachfront lighting is also a problem that affects all turtle species. For example, a study in Barbados found that of 55.6 per cent of nests, 100 per cent of the hatchling hawksbills crawled inland instead of to the sea, distracted by the artificial illumination (Horrocks et al. 1989). CONSERVATION AND RESEARCH ACTIVITIES Trade ban on hawksbill products: Demand for tortoiseshell remains high in Japan and other parts of East and Southeast Asia. In 2000, Cuba and Dominica have proposed to CITES member nations to reopen international trade in tortoiseshell, and WWF has rejected their proposal. (See the CITES Website at: http://www.cites.org and WWF's Website at: http://www.panda.org) Monitoring trade in turtles: TRAFFIC, the wildlife trade monitoring arm of WWF and IUCN, documents the extent of the illegal international trade and is working to bring violations of international treaties to the attention of government authorities. Such violations appear to be widespread: there is still a substantial underground trade in tortoiseshell, leather boots, whole turtles, meat, and eggs. For example, customs officials made a number of seizures of illegal turtle shells from Indonesia at European Union borders between 1990 and 1995. In September 1998, police officers in Japan arrested five people attempting to smuggle 66kg of tortoiseshell Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 3 into the country. In the United States, a number of arrests have been made recently at international airports in Florida, New York, and California, where people have been caught smuggling turtle eggs and meat in their luggage. The contraband finds its way to "ethnic" restaurants, where it is sold as a delicacy at high prices. As the trade in sea turtle eggs appears to be on the increase, TRAFFIC is stepping up its efforts to collect and disseminate information on its extent, so that more effective protection and management can be implemented. TRAFFIC is also working with governments to improve protection of species threatened by trade, even where that trade is largely internal and legal. TRAFFIC North America has just completed a review and legal analysis of the fisheries and primarily commercial trade in marine turtles in the Bahamas, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Haiti, Jamaica, Mexico, Puerto Rico, Turks and Caicos Islands, British Virgin Islands, and US Virgin Islands. Disposing of stockpiles: The government of the Seychelles has taken a different approach to marine turtle conservation. In 1988, it burnt its 2.5 tonne stockpile of tortoiseshell. Although the Seychelles once a huge source of tortoiseshell, recently the government has begun to take very strong action against this illegal activity. (Associated Press 1998) An artificial substitute to tortoiseshell has been developed, but goods manufactured from it have yet to acquire the same desirability as real shell. LEGAL STATUS The hawksbill turtle is listed on Appendix I of CITES; thus, member nations of the Convention are prohibited from international trade in this species and its parts. Turtles are ideally matched to the aims expressed by the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (known also as the Bonn Convention or CMS). The text of the CMS includes many of the concepts fundamental to regional conservation of migratory marine animals and their habitats. With the exception of the flatback (Natator depressus), all species of sea turtles are listed in both Appendix I and Appendix II of the Bonn Convention. The Inter-American Convention for the Protection and Conservation of Sea Turtles (IAC) is the only major international treaty dedicated exclusively to sea turtles and their habitats, formally setting standards for their conservation. The IAC recognizes that sea turtles migrate and that they are resources shared by the peoples of many nations. Hence, the IAC has been vigorously supported by many members of the international community of sea turtle biologists and conservationists, particularly specialists from Latin America. WHAT WWF IS DOING FOR MARINE TURTLES Mediterranean In 1998, WWF published recommendations for a new approach to conserving the Mediterranean’s turtles.These set out a number of urgent measures to reduce mortality of adult and sub-adult turtles, including: reduction of deliberate killing, especially in Egypt; reduction of bycatch in bottom trawls, especially in the eastern Mediterranean, longline fisheries and a variety of small coastal fisheries; and education aimed at reducing mortality of turtles accidentally caught by all kinds of fisheries. Efforts must continue to protect nesting beaches in Greece, Turkey, and Cyprus, to limit damage by urban and tourist developments, and to reduce predation by dogs and foxes. WWF is working to establish a fully representative network of protected areas. As part of its "Out of the Blue" programme for the conservation of the Mediterranean, WWF has started to place observers on Italian longline fishing fleets to monitor fish catches and document the extent Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 4 of sea turtle and shark bycatch and mortality. To date, the monitoring programme has been hampered by the unwillingness of many fishing captains to allow observers on board. Indo-Pacific In 1999, WWF together with a network of NGOs and governments participated in the 2nd Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) sea turtle meeting, 15-17 July in Sabah, Malaysia. Coordinating measures for marine turtle protection on a regional basis is a priority for marine turtle conservationists. The region's marine turtles and other species are threatened by coastal development, sand and coral reef mining, pollution, unsustainable egg-collection, and entanglement in fishing nets or accidental killing by longline fisheries. In Malaysia alone, the numbers of four species of marine turtles have fallen dramatically in recent decades with leatherbacks in critical danger. Despite government and WWF efforts over the past 30 years, sea turtles are in a state of decline not only in Malaysia but also throughout the region. The creation in 1996 of the Turtle Islands Heritage Protected Area, a group of nine islands shared by the Philippines and Sabah, Malaysia offers some hope for the future. Western Indian Ocean In November 1995, WWF co-sponsored an MTSG-IUCN regional meeting in the Western Indian Ocean to identify priority activities for marine turtle conservation. WWF is following up on the recommendations of the MTSG’s Marine Turtle Conservation Strategy and Action Plan for the Western Indian Ocean and is working to strengthen the network of turtle biologists in the region. Since 1996, WWF has sponsored regional scientists to attend international marine turtle meetings, and in 1997, co-sponsored a workshop on Turtle Excluder Device (TED) technology for resource managers and fishermen from Kenya, Tanzania, Eritrea, Madagascar, and Mozambique. WWF is involved in a number of marine protected areas on the east coast of Africa, including Mafia Island in Tanzania, the Kiunga Reserve in Kenya, and the Bazaruto Archipelago in Mozambique. A prime objective in all these areas is to ensure that marine resources are used sustainably by local communities and that critical habitats for coral fish, marine turtles, and dugongs are protected. Central American Region Annually, more than 80,000 turtles, mainly greens and hawksbills, are still captured off the coasts of Central America. WWF is working to encourage local communities and fishermen to protect turtles through the use of TEDs. Other initiatives include campaigns to keep trash, such as plastic bags and twine from banana plantations, out of rivers and oceans. WWF is also encouraging the establishment of wildlife refuges and sanctuaries and supporting patrols on turtle beaches. In addition, WWF is supporting measures to reduce the harmful effects of street lighting near beaches. A major effort to conserve marine turtles in the Central American region is being made through the Central American Environment Programme (Programa Ambiental Centroamericano -- PROARCA), which seeks to promote integrated coastal management and protected areas programmes. Western Atlantic - The Wider Caribbean Within the wider Caribbean, WWF has addressed threats to the region’s six endangered species of marine turtles. One of the first steps taken by WWF was the co-sponsoring of a meeting in November 1999 on Marine Turtle Conservation in the Wider Caribbean: a Dialogue for Regional Management. Recommendations arising from this meeting will be used to implement regional consensus on marine turtle conservation by identifying actions needed for their recovery, and examining ways governments could cooperate to undertake these actions. Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 5 Other WWF initiatives include measures to develop a network of protected areas within the MesoAmerican Caribbean Reef Ecoregion to protect critical habitat (mangroves, seagrass beds, and coral reefs) for hawksbill and green turtles. Guyana Shield Ecoregion WWF has been supporting marine turtle conservation in the Guyanas since the 1960s. This biologically rich area comprising Guyana, Suriname, French Guyana, and parts of Venezuela, Colombia, and Brazil has many important turtle nesting beaches along its coasts. Suriname is host to four species Anguilla WWF has supported the Anguilla National Trust in managing its sea turtle conservation programme, which included a survey of turtle nesting beaches. Anguilla imposed a five-year moratorium on harvesting of both adult turtles and eggs in 1995, but the number of nesting turtles is still declining. In the last few years, more young hawksbills and greens have been seen in Anguillan waters, but the conservation effort will have to continue for many more years before populations begin to recover. Venezuela WWF’s associate in Venezuela, FUDENA, has worked for two decades on sea turtle conservation on the Isla de Aves and the Laguna de Tacarigua National Park. The organisation's activities on Isla de Aves include yearly monitoring and tagging of females during their nesting period. FUDENA’s "Adopt a Sea Turtle" campaign helps to support this programme. In Laguna de Tacarigua, FUDENA collaborates with several partners to involve local communities in the protection of sea turtle nests. Eastern Atlantic Mauritania The Banc d’Arguin National Park, an important nesting and feeding ground for green and loggerhead turtles, has been supported by WWF since 1976. Observers estimate that several thousand turtles are killed each year as bycatch in the offshore shark fisheries. It is hoped that WWF’s work on fisheries management will help to turn this situation around and have a positive impact. Tag recoveries show that the Banc d’Arguin’s green turtles come from as far away as Florida, although others originate in the Archipelago dos Bijagos in Guinea-Bissau. References Associated Press. 1998. Destruction of Turtle Shell Stockpile. In Marine Turtle Newsletter 83: 22—23. Bass, A L, Good, D A, Bjorndal, K A, Richardson, J I, Hillis, Z M, Horrocks, J A, and B W Bowen. 1996. Testing models of female reproductive migratory behaviour and population structure in the Caribbean hawksbill turtle, Eretmochelys imbricata, with mtDNA sequences. Molecular Ecology. 5: 321-328. Bowen, B W, Bass, A L, Garcia-Rodriguez, A, Diez, C E, van Dam, R, Bolten, A B, Bjorndal, K A, Miyamoto, M M and R J Ferl. 1996. Origin of hawksbill turtles in a Caribbean feeding area as indicated by genetic markers. Applications. 6 (2): 566-572. Broderick, D, Moritz, C, Miller, J D, Guinea, M, Prince, R I T and C J Limpus. 1994. Genetic studies of the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata: evidence for multiple stocks in Australian waters. Pacific Conservation Biology. 1(2): 123-131. Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 6 Dominguez, T G and Villalba, A A, 1994. Trade of hawksbill carapaces in Santo-Domingo, Dominican Republic. In: Bjorndal, K A, Bolten, A B, Johnson, D A and P J Eliazar (compilers). Proceedings of the Fourteenth Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation. NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-SEFSC-351, 323pp: 34-35. Euro Turtle. 1999. Species distribution: hawksbill turtle--Eretmochelys imbricata. http://www.ex.ac.uk/NEDASSET/dhawks.htm Groshens, E B, Vaughan, M R. 1994. Post-nesting movements of hawksbill sea turtles from Buck Island Reef National Monument, St. Croix, US Virgin Islands. In Schroeder, B A and Witherington, B E (compilers). Proceedings of the Thirteenth Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation. NOAA Technical Memorandum. NMFS-SEFSC-341. US Dept. of Commerce, Miami, FL, USA. 278 pp. Hendrickson, J R. 1980. The ecological strategies of sea turtles. American Zoology. 20: 597-609 (original not seen, quoted from Eckert, K L Hawksbill Sea Turtle, Eretmochelys imbricata. In Plotkin, P T (ed). 1995. National Marine Fisheries Service and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Status Reviews for Sea Turtles Listed under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. National Marine Fisheries Service, Silver Spring, Maryland, USA. Kemf, E, Groombridge B, Abreu A, Wilson, A. 2000. Wanted Alive! Marine Turtles in the Wild, WWF International, Gland, Switzerland. hLoop, K. 1995. Hawksbill nesting on Milman Island, Great Barrier Reef, Australia JanuaryMarch 1991. Pp. 73-76. In Richardson, J I and Richardson, T H (compilers). Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual Workshop on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation. NOAA Technical Memorandum. NMFS-SEFSC-361. US Dept. of Commerce, Miami, FL., USA. 274pp. Marine Turtle Newsletter. 1994. Tortoiseshell trade: end of an era? Marine Turtle Newsletter 66: 16 -17. Meylan, A B. 1999a. International movements of immature and adult hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Conservation & Biology 3(2189194. Meylan, A B. 1999b. Status of the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Conservation & Biology 3(2):177-184. Meylan, A B. and Donnelly, M. 1999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically Endangered on the 1996 IUCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Conservation & Biology 3(2): 200-224. Milliken, T and Tokunaga, H. 1987. The Japanese Sea Turtle Trade 1970-1986 A Special Report. Prepared by TRAFFIC (Japan). Funded by Center for Environmental Education, Washington, D.C. 171 pp. TRAFFIC Bulletin. 1999. 17 (3): 120 TRAFFIC Bulletin. 1996. 16 (2): 75 TRAFFIC Bulletin. 1994. 14 (3): 116 Prepared by WCMC and WWF Int. March 2000 7