WREXHAM COUNTY BOROUGH COUNCIL Interim Implementing Electronic Government Statement Version: Final April 8th, 2002 1 1 Contents Page Number FOREWORD 1 OVERVIEW 1. Introduction Purpose 1 1 2. Our goal for electronic service delivery Delivering electronic government 2 3 3. Summary Action Plan How outcomes will be judged 4 4 MILESTONES 4. Customer Access to Service Strategy 6 5. Development of partnership and joint working 6 6. Meeting electronic service delivery targets Meeting electronic service delivery targets - an early analysis High volume transactions 7 7 7 7. Integration with national frameworks & standards 8 8. Flexible working and asset management Work-life balance Asset Management 9 9 10 9. State of readiness Community access to the internet and technology ICT Support within the Council Current eGovernment activities 11 11 11 12 TRANSITION 10. Leading eGovernment Leadership and Management Perceptions of Senior Management 13 13 13 11. Financing eGovernment Outline cost/benefits Outline funding/resourcing strategy Outline plans for realising savings 14 14 15 15 12. Business options and tactics 16 13. Risk assessment 16 14. Skills needs analysis 16 1 Appendices A: Council vision and strategic aims 19 B: Corporate Planning Process 20 C: Milestones and targets for Wrexham 21 D: Electronic service delivery by function and service type 24 E: Telecommunications Best Value Survey of the Public & Members 28 F: Partnership arrangements 29 G: EGovernment Initiatives - current position as at December 2001 32 H: Structure for eGovernment Implementation in Wrexham CBC 34 I: Risk log 35 Glossary of terms and acronyms Useful website links 2 Foreword Wrexham County Borough Council is committed to the implementation of electronic government. We have a track record of providing high quality services by working in partnership and delivering information and services electronically. This IEG Statement builds upon this platform, and explores how information communications technologies can be used to further develop and enhance our services so that they are fit for the 21st Century. We will spend the next 12 months considering the range of options open to us in delivering electronic local government. At the same time we will be gathering evidence for our approach to electronic government through a cross-cutting review on customer access to services as part of the Wales Programme for Improvement. Our services will respond to changing expectations from the public and will combine the best of traditional service delivery with the more innovative approaches. This document outlines some of our early thinking on electronic government. We will use it to consult all the stakeholders involved in developing better Council and other public sector services locally, so that we can set our priorities for the delivery of eGovernment over the medium and long term. Electronic government will also be a consideration in the work with our key partners on the development of a Community Strategy over the next 2 years. This is a long-term programme for improvement. We can't launch into all these changes overnight as many of them involve a high degree of investment and, in the case of electronic voting, a change in legislation to allow them to happen. The take-up of online services is linked to how comfortable people feel with the technology and whether they can afford to access services electronically. We want to see local people and businesses get online and thrive in the electronically connected 21 st Century. To this end, we are widening access to the internet and providing learning opportunities through our schools and libraries. We hope that you will find this Statement easy to read. Some of the terms used are technical, but we've provided a glossary of terms at the back to help explain some of them. We look forward to hearing your views on this document and seeing the benefits that this e-agenda will bring to Wrexham County Borough. 1 2 Wrexham has a goal of becoming one of the leading e-Counties in Wales. In the future, local people will have better access to information and advice from their public services, be more engaged in local democracy and find services easy to reach when they need them. We do not underestimate the amount of effort required to attain this goal, but are dedicated to a vision that sets Wrexham firmly within the Information Age. This statement sets out how Wrexham County Borough Council will move towards electronic government. This does not mean that all services will be automated in the future. It means a better experience for anyone doing business with the Council, because the power of information communication technologies (ICTs) will be harnessed to allow the re-design of services around customers and citizens. This will mean closer working with partners to deliver services. Customer-focus also means widening the ways in which our services can be reached. For example, through the internet, or through an extended hours contact centre, or, for those that need more help with complex or sensitive issues, appointments with a member of staff who can advise them and help them to access services. Purpose This document sets out Wrexham County Borough Council's aspirations for electronic government for the next 5 years. The purpose of this document is to: set out a vision for modern service delivery for all stakeholders within Wrexham County Borough summarise the practical steps required to achieve this vision, including the milestones to achieve government targets demonstrate partnership working and demonstrate our commitment to national interoperability frameworks and standards. This Interim Implementing Electronic Government (IEG) Statement will be submitted to the National Assembly for Wales at the end of March 2002. It will be used as a basis for discussion and consultation with all those who are involved in the process of modernising and improving service delivery for the citizens of Wrexham County Borough. By March 2003, we will have reviewed the Statement and included full costings for proposed projects. The revised Statement will set the strategic direction for the Council in terms of eGovernment to 2006 and beyond. In the meantime we will continue to invest in pilot projects and feasibility reports to test our ideas for electronic service delivery. The 2003 IEG Statement will be reviewed regularly to respond to changes in customer expectations and developments in technological capabilities. About Wrexham Wrexham County Borough covers an area of 50,500 hectares in the north east corner of Wales, with a population of 125,7501, one-third of whom live within Wrexham town. Wrexham has an important role in North Wales as the premier administrative, commercial, shopping and industrial centre for the area. Characteristics of the Borough include: A growing population2; Prosperity with inward investment, jobs growth and low unemployment3; An active tourist sector4; Strong manufacturing base5 and positive business formation in construction, transport, communications and other business services. Strong higher academic institutions with North East Wales Institute and Yale College. Quality leisure and cultural facilities. 1 Mid Year Estimate 2000 (ONS). By 1.2% between 1991-6. 3 In 1995 the area had a GDP3 per full-time employee of £26,700, 4% above the Wales average. Since 1991, Wrexham has attracted 94 inward investment projects, creating around 6,200 jobs. Unemployment rate is consistently below the Welsh average. 4 Supports 1,000 jobs. 1.18 million visitors in 1998, generating £31.3 million. 5 Manufacturing of products such as rubber and plastic goods, food and drink, and chemical products. 2 1 SUMMARY Introduction OVERVIEW 1. 2. Our goal for electronic service delivery OVERVIEW SUMMARY The Council fully endorses the vision outlined for Wales by the National Assembly in Cymru Arlein - Online for a Better Wales, that views information communications technology (ICT) as a facilitator of a confident, creative and culturally rich society living within a sustainable environment. Electronic, or eGovernment, is one part of a wider modernising agenda that will transform the way in which the Council communicates and works with its communities (see Appendix A for the overarching Council vision). Within the framework of the Community Strategy, and with reference to the Wales Improvement Programme, the implementing electronic government agenda will deliver better services to people, by increasing the means of access to information and services and working with partners to jointly deliver services (see Figure 1). Figure 1: The future for a modernised public sector Our goal for electronic local government is for: "A Council that is citizen and customer centred and uses ICT (information communications technology) to improve its services and enhance its role as democratic leader, to make life better for people." 2 Delivering electronic government Electronic communication is the major route for providing information and communicating with all organisations and individuals dealing with the Council, through channels that suit their circumstances whether at work, at home or on the move. This increases the access to public information and services to 24 hours a day, 7 days a week over the internet, or extended hours provision through a contact centre. Support Elected Members in their use of information communications technologies to enhance and improve their democratic role. Access to the internet is made widely available so that no one is excluded from digital communication. There is joint-working between public sector and other services so that they respond to the needs of the customer rather than those of organisational and professional structures. Customer enquiries, or notification of changes, reach those parts of the public sector that need to know with one contact from the customer. Increased democratic involvement at individual and community level, supported by a higher flow of information and consultation through electronic media, enabling greater involvement in decision-making that affects the area. Best value services delivered that are efficient, effective and continually improving, enhanced by the use of information communications technologies (ICTs). A Council that values and invests in its staff in terms of skills, particularly ICT skills, and the use of ICT to deliver learning. The Council is a learning organisation - gaining knowledge from its experience and using this knowledge to inform future actions. An organisation that values information and knowledge and has decision-making based upon sound evidence. A vibrant local community and economy that makes best use of ICT to further its aims. 3 OVERVIEW Customers calling a single number to reach the service that they require within the Council. Calls are answered promptly to set standards and the person answering the phone can resolve a majority of the questions raised within one call. SUMMARY In the future, citizens will expect to reach the services that they want at times and in places that are convenient to them. This will require a long-term change programme, with stepchanges in service delivery along the way. Our success will be characterised by service transformation, and will include the following ideals: 3. Summary Action Plan SUMMARY Table 1 represents the milestones and target dates for implementing eGovernment for the next financial year to March 2003. These milestones mark some of the steps contributing to the delivery of eGovernment in the short term, while allowing time for the development of the longer term action plan by the end of March 2003. A list of potential milestones for the longer term is given in Appendix B. There are no target dates set against these milestones as yet. The purpose of this list is to encourage discussion of the goals for Wrexham in terms of eGovernment. As a consequence, this list of actions is highly indicative and selective at this stage. A thorough plan will be produced after consultation and as a result of some of the reviews proposed in this year's action plan. An important consideration for the timing of the milestones is the constraint upon resources to fund the activity over and above current service provision levels. While some sources of external funding have been made available, most are ring-fenced to particular initiatives. EGovernment is a broad push for change, so lack of financial resources may limit what can be achieved both in the short and longer term. How outcomes will be judged The Interim IEG Statement will become part of the service planning mechanism that operates within the Council. As a cross-cutting corporate initiative, eGovernment actions will be reflected within Service Management Plans (see Appendix C). These actions will have targets set for each year, based on the National Assembly for Wales Performance Indicator 1.5 (see Appendix D), and on local targets developed for Wrexham County Borough Council. These local targets will develop and evolve over the lifetime of the plan to reflect local needs. OVERVIEW Progress against eGovernment initiatives has been planned and tracked through the ICT Strategy 2000/2 and Information Systems Management Plans for 2001/2. For 2002/3, the interim IEG Statement will provide the corporate position on eGovernment actions. By March 2003, the document will be reviewed and fully costed for the future with targeted milestones. Performance will then be reviewed against these targets and those set by the National Assembly for Wales for electronic service delivery. Outcomes will be judged against planned actions, but will also be assessed from customer's feedback. Regular reviews of progress and customer's perceptions of changes in service delivery will inform the success of our electronic government plans. We will also benchmark our services against other service providers to set our progress in the wider context. 4 Milestones Initiate Customer Access to Services Review Set up Implementing Electronic Government (IEG) Co-ordination Group Extend consultation on IEG Statement Smartcards allocated for concessionary travel for pensioners and people with disabilities Awareness raising sessions on electronic government for staff and elected members Implement content management system for intranet Pilot work-life balance solutions Adoption of revised telephone call-handling policies and procedures Explore the business case for working with National Land Information Service Q2 July -Sept Q3 Oct - Dec Q4 Jan - Mar Feasibility study on Contact Centre options Agreed priorities for electronic service delivery Establish a portfolio of electronic service delivery projects Publish frequently asked questions (FAQs) on Council Services on the Council website Upgrade corporate network - higher bandwidth connections to remote offices Install NAfW Broadband Lifelong Learning Network (BLLN) Link Secondary schools to BLLN Establish funding arrangements for agreed IEG projects Implement financial systems - upgraded for e-commerce potential Implement electronic financial transactions - implementation of swipe cards payment at Cash Office, telephone and web payments Explore potential for getting Community Councils online Local Land and Property Gazetteer (LLPG) data cleaned to national BS7666 standard Implement content management system for web Establish 1st wave of electronic service delivery (ESD) projects Revised ICT Strategy Link all libraries to BLLN, providing free internet access Customer Access to Service Review - Final report and Action Plan Implement transactional processes on website e.g. job applications Arrange workshops to share best practice & encourage innovation Implementation of kiosk pilot Report on feasibility study for electronic Building Control application Replacement of back office mainframe systems Revised and fully costed Implementing Electronic Government (IEG) Statement Technical feasibility study for putting library catalogue online through website 2nd consultation on IEG Statement with stakeholders 2nd wave Electronic Service Delivery projects 5 OVERVIEW Timescale Q1 April-June SUMMARY Table 1: Milestones for 2002/3 4. Customer Access to Service Strategy Understanding how people prefer to access information and services and the constraints that some sections of the population experience in reaching the services that they need will be an important component for developing eGovernment. The Council has over 50 locations (excluding schools) from where services are provided, where the public can obtain information and advice via a personal visit, but by far the most popular form of contact with the Council is by telephone: Table 3: Preferred methods of contact - telephone MILESTONES Preferred method of contact Telephone Visit an office e-mail Letter Fax Other Citizen's Panel August 2001 77% 22% 7% 7% 2% 5% Note: Percentages do not add up to 100% because more than one method of contact could be chosen. We receive over 1 million incoming telephone calls every year at our central offices. During the past year the Council has conducted a best value review for telecommunications within the Council (see Appendix E). The Best Value Review found that while customers find the service over the telephone to be reasonably prompt, courteous and effective, there are a large number of published telephone numbers published, which can cause some confusion for our customers. Building upon this review, we will review the other methods that people use to access our services, to gain an understanding of why and how people make these choices now and in the future, with the aim of developing a Customer Access to Service Strategy. 5. Development of partnership and joint working The Council works within many partnerships involving private, voluntary and other public sectors with the joint aim of delivering better services for people (see Appendix F). Over the next 2 years, local partners will be drawn together under the banner of the Community Strategy with the general aim of promoting or improving the economic, social and environmental well-being of the area. The Community Strategy Steering Group will comprise representatives from: the Council, NHS Trust, North Wales Health Authority, local Health Group, North Wales Police, AVOW 6, NEWI7, Yale College and a representative from either the Chamber of Commerce or Confederation of British Industry (CBI). In terms of collaboration across North Wales, the Chief Executives of the six Councils of Anglesey, Gwynedd, Conwy, Denbighshire, Flintshire and Wrexham have set up a North Wales eGovernment Steering Group and are: “committed to working collaboratively to promote eGovernment within North Wales. This will initially take the form of being open in sharing best practice, policies and strategy documents with the expectation of identifying common themes which will lead to joint working. This has been prevalent amongst various service departments for some time who, through collaboration on particular projects with similar aims, have achieved savings and increased effectiveness. Partnerships with other organisations in the public sector will also be investigated." This degree of openness and collaboration between the North Wales authorities is a welcome precursor to closer working, and the possibility of joint eGovernment projects. 6 7 Association of Voluntary Organisations of Wrexham North East Wales Institute 6 6. Meeting electronic service delivery targets Meeting electronic service delivery targets - an early analysis A corporate eGovernment strategy was developed as part of the ICT Strategy 2000/2. An early action was to assess the state of readiness for electronic service delivery8 within the Council. This survey was completed in August 2001, in accordance with the guidance on the National Assembly for Wales performance indicator (NAW PI) 1.5, and against the standard list of functions delivered by local government, as drawn up by SOCITM 9. The summary figures for the whole of the Council are given in Table 2, with the detailed figures broken down by service area in Appendix D. Type of function Providing information Receive payments Making payments (benefits and creditors) Receiving feedback (complaints and consultation) Regulation (issue licenses) Making an application Making a booking Paying for goods and services Providing access to community, professional and business networks Procurement Average percentage of functions available by electronic service delivery. Key Performance Indicator results Benchmark Target for August 2001 March 2003 30% 40% 13% 15% 48% 60% 20% 30% Not measured 10% 6% 15% 15% 20% Not measured 20% Not measured 10% Not measured 10% While the results show that there is still a way to go before being fully electronic, there are encouraging signs. Almost half of the payments made by the authority are made electronically. Other services, such as the public making an application electronically, are slower to develop because of the need for appropriate developments in security and verification frameworks. These results will provide a useful benchmark from which the authority can assess its progress. This exercise will be repeated in 2002 and thereafter on an annual basis to monitor developments against targets set for each function. High volume transactions The electronic service delivery assessment was set against the 74 categories of services identified by SOCITM as being the main services delivered by local government. As part of the work for the Customer Access to Services Review an assessment will be made of the high volume transactions, against degree of complexity of the transaction, against ease of improvement through eGovernment intervention. This will identify "early winner" e-projects and longer term priorities for action. 8 Electronic service delivery is defined as interactions, delivered electronically, including the use of the internet (whether accessed through a PC digital TV, telephone or other device), or access by telephone through a call centre, front office or other means in which the operator has access to information electronically and can carry out a meaningful transaction on behalf of the caller. 9 Society of Information Technology Management 7 MILESTONES Table 2: Percentage of functions available by electronic service delivery 7. Integration with national frameworks & standards The Council maintains a watching brief on national developments on eGovernment to ensure that the Council can integrate or comply with the evolving standards. MILESTONES The Council is currently working upon the Local Land and Property Gazetteer so that it reaches BS7666 compliance, and is compatible with the National Land and Property Gazetteer (NLPG). This database is being cleaned, that is ensuring that the data is held in such a way that it is compatible with the national standard. Once it has reached the standard, it will be continuously updated so that it becomes the reference address database within the Council, ensuring a unique reference and standardised addressing for all properties in the Wrexham County Borough. NLIS (National Land Information Service) is intended to transform the way you buy and sell property, to improve turnaround times for property transactions. Initial services have been developed to speed up the property searches necessary as part of the conveyancing process, with the aim of reducing the length of time between offer acceptance and exchange of contracts. The Council is exploring the business case for involvement in this service. The LASER (Local Authorities' Secure Electoral Register) project aims to provide electoral registers that are joined up, maintained and managed locally, and can be accessed on a national level to authorised users. The project is still in its infancy, but steps have been taken within the authority to monitor developments and to assess the implications for involvement. In terms of interoperability, all technology-based projects within the Council will include an examination of eGIF (electronic government interoperability framework) compliance to ensure compatibility with agreed national standards. Links to UK Online are standard on the Council website, particularly with reference to life events information. The website also adheres to the Bobby standard10 to enable access to the website by people with visual or hearing disabilities. The site is currently being reviewed by RNIB for accessibility for people who have difficulties with their sight. The website carries an ICRA label allowing filtering for content11. We have been implementing the National Grid for Learning since 1998 and now have significant networks in most of our schools. We will continue to link our schools to the national Broadband Lifelong Learning Network. Construction Line is a government-sponsored database for contractors within the construction industry and allows the Council to speed up its tendering process by using pre-checked lists of contractors to create tender lists for projects. Wrexham County Borough Council subscribes to this service. The People's Network - the public library ICT programme will be completed by December 2002, which will extend internet access to the public. As part of the move to develop an individual pupil level information system within Wales, and following National Assembly for Wales guidance, all maintained schools in Wales were required to issue Unique Pupil Numbers (UPNs). This is blind number and only output when required to provide information to the Local Education Authority, National Assembly for Wales, ACCAC12 or to another school to which a pupil transfers. The aim is to have a unique reference number that will follow a child throughout their education. It will help transfer/movement of pupils between schools and local education authorities, and provide an accurate mechanism for tracking pupil performance. 10 Bobby WorldWide is a tool for Web page authors. It helps them identify changes to their pages so users with disabilities can more easily use their Web pages. Bobby WorldWide was created by CAST. Founded in 1984 as the Center for Applied Special Technology, CAST is a not-for-profit organization whose mission is to expand opportunities for people with disabilities through innovative uses of computer technology. 11 The Internet Content Rating Association is an international, independent organization that empowers the public, especially parents, to make informed decisions about electronic media by means of the open and objective labelling of content. ICRA's dual aims are to: protect children from potentially harmful material; and, to protect free speech on the internet. 12 Awdurdod Cymwysterau, Cwricwlwm ac Asesu Cymru 8 Wrexham County Borough Council is also involved in the pilot phase for the Pupil Level Annual School Census (PLASC) which will replace the statistical return completed by schools. The aim is for all schools to be using an electronic system (PLASC) by 2004. Electronic methods for collecting pupil data and PLASC data are being investigated. For the future, an overall Information Management System (IMS) will be developed encompassing UPNs and PLASC. The Council spends a significant proportion of its revenue and capital budgets on purchasing goods, services and works from external supplies. Best Value is dependent on the effective procurement of these and future requirements. The Council has an interim strategy for procurement that will be implemented through a Procurement Code of Practice. This requires that: "electronic and other means of reducing acquisition and transaction costs are used where appropriate to achieve Best Value and that the Council will seek continuous improvement in invoice processing and electronic settlement procedures."14 8. Flexible working and asset management Work-life balance The Council has a Work-life Balance Group looking at the issue of flexible working for the Council. Potential benefits for the organisation include: Employee attendance patterns matched to the public's preferred opening hours Reduced absenteeism Maximising of available labour Employees feeling valued Loyal, better motivated workforce in a less stressful environment Can increase productivity Cements a reputation as an "employer of choice" Retains valued employees Benefits for the employees include: Greater responsibility and sense of "ownership" Loyalty and commitment Less need to take sick leave for personal reasons Better relations between management and customer facing staff Improved self-esteem, health, concentration and confidence A reduction in bringing "home" problems to work - and vice versa Pilot work-life balance solutions are being considered to understand the impact of flexible working upon the Council, its staff and its customers. Supporting flexible forms of working may have implications for the ways in which staff work, including their access to information and records through the use of technology. The eGovernment agenda therefore, includes, consideration for changes in the workplace linked to work-life balance. The Work-Life Balance initiative has implications for asset management. With a flexible working policy in action, then the ongoing review of property will optimise the use of office space with the aim of minimising overheads. 13 Customer Unique Process Identifier, Electronic Service Delivery Toolkit, V3, Improvement & Development Agency 2001 14 Interim Procurement Strategy, WCBC, December 2001. 9 MILESTONES We will use work developed in CUPID in the ESD Toolkit from I&DeA13, as an aid to identifying the priority and high volume transactions and scripting responses for customers, to enable self-service through the website, or to support frontline staff in responding to enquiries. Asset Management An Asset Management Stakeholder Group has been set up within Wrexham County Borough Council to have an overview on asset management on a corporate basis, with the aim of "optimising the utilisation of assets in terms of service benefit and financial return". One of the challenges to service improvements, in terms of asset management is finding "alternative ways of delivering Services." This will rely strongly upon use of technology to facilitate remote working or reduce the need for storage space by holding information and documents electronically. The functions of the Asset Management Stakeholder Group are to: MILESTONES Prepare a council-wide asset management plan Establish terms of reference including corporate and service objectives for assets Build an understanding of strategic importance of property Identify key issues (problems, communication, change) Justify retention of surplus and under-utilised properties as a basic principle of asset management Challenge the need to hold non-operational assets Consider innovative new working practices Subject property services to Best Value Review and challenge New working practices will change the asset portfolio of the Council for the future. 10 9. State of readiness Community access to the internet and technology The possibilities for access to the internet and learning about how to use it are extensive in the Wrexham area, with the prime aim of getting people comfortable with being online (see Appendix G - for ICT learning initiatives). For example, those who do not have access to the internet from home, can have access to the internet in their local library. Public access to the internet is available at 5 libraries across the County Borough with ISDN15 connectivity and all libraries will be connected by the end of 2002. All library staff are trained to ECDL (European Computer Driving Licence) standard and can give users basic support. ICT learning facilities are available at schools and community venues, such as youth clubs and libraries, to promote use of ICT. All schools in the area have internet access and pupils are being taught how to use this form of communication. Basic ICT support is also being extended by the Business Connect IT Centre to the businesses in the area to encourage businesses into e-commerce. Kiosks are being piloted to provide information to the public. Bus and rail timetables will be provided through kiosks to people in Wrexham at the main bus and rail termini during 2002, and Brynteg Lifelong Learning Centre will host a kiosk in the reception area to inform visitors. Swipecards will be implemented to support concessionary travel for pensioners, and for lunches for secondary school children, through the TRANSACT cashless payment system, reducing the need for handling cash. ICT Support within the Council Wrexham Council puts great emphasis upon supporting its investment in information and communications technology (ICT). Issues facing the authority over the past few years have been those of software compatibility and rationalisation. This involves phasing out of old technology and provides opportunities for a shift to open systems, allowing greater interoperability. The authority supports ICT in 155 locations, including 85 schools. All procurement is carried out centrally for the Council Services and schools. The Information Systems Department is engaged as a contractor for schools' technical support and procurement. During the last 3 years, the IS Department has invested in infrastructure developments in all schools as part of the NGfL16. The Council is to improve on bandwidth with funding from the NAfW, which will be addressed by broadband links from the Council's network hub to outlying libraries and schools. The Council is also continuing to invest in its corporate network. Elected Members are increasingly using technology to support their work. Around twothirds have laptops and online access to the internet. The aim is to extend this facility to all Elected Members. All the networked office staff in the Council have email and access to the corporate intranet - Wrexnet - that was launched in 2001, giving them access to facilities such as the corporate telephone directory, Best Value documents and Committee agendas and minutes. In a customer satisfaction survey conducted as part of the SOCITM benchmarking survey in Wales in 2001, Wrexham County Borough Council (CBC) had the most improved levels of customer satisfaction across the ICT function. The same survey showed that Wrexham CBC is in the top quartile for performance in Wales and in the top half within the UK. Wrexham was cited as a source of good practice in seven out of the eleven key performance indicators. 15 16 Integrated Services Digital Network National Grid for Learning 11 MILESTONES Consultation with 300 members of the Citizen's Panel was undertaken in 2000 to provide representative baseline information on the use of computers, to assist the Authority's implementation of the eGovernment initiative. A key finding was that just under 50% of the panel have access to a personal computer, of whom two-thirds have internet access. A repeat survey is planned this year. Current eGovernment activities Different eGovernment initiatives are being implemented and evaluated. Some early success stories are given below, showing how we're getting online, widening access to the internet to promote digital inclusion, working with partners to deliver information and services to the public and to deliver and procure services more effectively. Further examples of electronic government projects are listed in Appendix G. Cyber Café in Cefn Mawr Welsh Capital Challenge Scheme funds have been invested in a new cyber café. Economic Development Services have been working with the Plas Madoc and Cefn Community to develop the project. The café is equipped with the internet, printing, photocopying and faxing services, while providing snacks meals and drinks. Customers can get online for £1 an hour. Cefn Mawr Library has also obtained a grant from a local trust fund to support local children and young people with an advice and guidance service in the use of ICT. The project is intended to enthuse children, particularly in the final two years of primary school, in the benefits of ICT in support of their studies. The grant will total £92,500 over 3 years. Wrexnet All office-based staff have access to the corporate intranet, with Council minutes and agendas, telephone directory, learning and development resources, published handbooks and guides, vacancy lists and other resources. Wrexham International Science and Technology Festival Since its inception in 1998, the annual Festival has grown in scale and popularity, to become the largest of its type in England and Wales. The Festival aims to share the excitement of science with people of all ages, stimulate debate about issues that concern us and demonstrate the impact of science and technology on all our lives. Its purpose is to promote public participation in science and technology, to support science education in schools, and to encourage innovation and enterprise in the business community. Fresh-air.info The Countryside Service has joined with the services of 6 neighbouring authorities to provide a seamless, web-based customer information service to country parks, walks and information from Denbighshire to Flintshire. A local company in Wrexham is developing the site, to be hosted by WCBC. Crime and disorder is being tackled in Wrexham with the introduction of CCTV. The partnership involves the Council, Police, Fire Service, Probation Service, Health Service and voluntary groups. During 2000/1, 1,023 incidents were monitored by CCTV resulting in 1,462 arrests. The success of CCTV in reducing incidents of crime and the fear of crime in the areas covered has been marked. The introduction of CCTV, together with the development of the Town Centre Police Team, led to a 52% reduction in crime within the first year of operation. Surveys of public opinion show significant support for the use of CCTV within the town centre with a high percentage of people indicating they want CCTV within their own community. Networking support maintenance was procured jointly by Denbighshire, Flintshire and Wrexham Councils from Siemens Network Services, to maximise best value. UP Brynteg Lifelong Learning Centre is a major construction project involving an extension to the present Library linking it with the adjacent Broughton Memorial Hall. At the heart of building will be a new ICT suite together with meeting rooms, offices and a creche facility. The ICT suite will be accessible to users for independent learning and for training courses. A touch screen computer will provide information about events and activities at the centre together with other information about the Council. Construction commenced at the end of January 2002 and it is planned that the Lifelong Learning centre will be open from September. The total cost of the scheme, to be funded from the Local Regeneration Fund, is £968,268. Elected Members online Our Elected Members are getting online. Around two-thirds have access to laptops so that they can send and receive email and access information through our intranet and website. Currently 34 out of 52 Elected Members have laptops. The Council provides training to encourage their use and to provide support for Elected Members. WIDENING 12 ACCESS Construction Line is a government sponsored database of contractors available for tendering. The Council reduces effort in tendering by using this database for the compilation of tender lists. JOINING UP MILESTONES DIGITAL Wrexham.gov.uk , Wrexham County Borough Council's website, won the Better Connected award for Wales in 2001. Jointly assessed by SPiN (Society of Public Information Networks) and SOCITM (Society of Information Technology Management), they looked specifically at local government websites and their state of development, the range and usefulness of the on-line information and facilities provided, and how accessible the sites are. The website is one of only a handful of council sites in the country to have gained the highest possible accessibility rating in the SOCITM survey. Residents can contact departments by email or access services at any time of the day or night. The site attracts around 600 visits a day. SOCITM/SPiN rated it a "Content+" site for 2002, and one of the best in Wales. INCLUSION GETTING ONLINE 10. Leading eGovernment Leadership and Management Wrexham is the first Council in Wales to have appointed a Corporate eGovernment Manager, dedicated to the delivery of electronic government. This post has a corporate remit and reports to an eGovernment Steering Group, Chaired by the Chief Executive and supported by Chief Officers with responsibilities for community strategy, corporate policy, best value, human resources, information systems, finance and libraries and leisure (see Appendix H for structure diagram). The composition of this group is critical as it reflects the links with policy and operational areas within the Council that will be responding to the change initiated by a move to eGovernment, under the leadership of the Chief Executive. Senior management champions for the implementation of eGovernment are represented at Directorate and Chief Officer level, these being the Director of Finance and Information Systems and the Chief Information Systems Officer. The Corporate eGovernment Manager and Web Development Manager work together as part of a corporate eGovernment team, pursuing the goals of eGovernment. eGovernment Projects will be supported and co-ordinated through the Implementing eGovernment Projects Co-ordination Group with representatives from Services across the Council. Projects will be set up to lead on the key priority projects determined through the audit of service delivery and consultation process. Each of these projects will have a lead officer and will report to the IEG Projects Co-ordination Group on their progress. Perceptions of Senior Management A survey was conducted in January 2002 amongst the senior management of the Council, to gain their view of the state of readiness of the organisation to face the challenge of electronic government. The self-assessment for "state of readiness" survey was based on work done by SOCITM and IDeA in "Local eGovernment now" (April 2001)17. SOCITM/IDeA identified 4 critical success factors: vision, management, information and infrastructure as key to implementing electronic government. Each of these factors is split into a series of key characteristics against which senior managers rated perception of the Council's state of readiness for this agenda. Average scores for the key characteristics show a generally positive and balanced view. The ratings are middle ranking, demonstrating an awareness of the change process that the Council is facing and a recognition that there is some distance to go before the goals are achieved. This is a solid base from which the Council can build its approach to implementing eGovernment, retaining balance across all the key characteristics. A regular review of management perceptions, including those closer to frontline staff, will help shape the change management programme to deliver a modernised Council. An area of particular concern was funding, highlighting the shared perception that the necessary expenditure to secure electronic government would be difficult to find within current resources. Ideas such as a Contact Centre require significant pump-priming investment. This funding competes with other priorities within local government within a limited budget. The potential for savings may only be realised in the medium term. 17 SOCITM (Society of Information Technology Managers) and I&DeA (Improvement and Development Agency), "Local eGovernment now - a baseline for measurement." A MAPIT Publication. 13 TRANSITION Such is the strategic interest in eGovernment that the Executive Board has appointed a Board Member with Special Interest for eGovernment. The IEG Statement outlines the work to be done on the eGovernment initiative by the Council and has been approved by the Executive Board. All local members will be fully involved in the consultation process about the IEG Statement. Executive Board and Corporate Issues Scrutiny Committee will provide the political leadership on the work being proposed. Figure 2: Perceptions of the state of readiness for eGovernment State of readiness survey 2002 INFRASTRUCTURE VISION LEARNING CLEAR GOALS 10 SHARED VALUES SKILLS COMMITMENT TO CHANGE SECURITY CONSULTATION 5 TECHNOLOGY COLLABORATION FUNDING 0 TRANSITION INFORMATION FAST DECISIONS STRATEGIC PLAN SERVICES OPEN TO EXPERIMENTATION CONTRACTS COMMUNICATION RISKS ICT GOVERNANCE PROJECTS MANAGEMENT 11. LEADERSHIP Financing eGovernment Outline cost/benefits Communication by email is generally cheaper than by letter, and all of these forms of communication are cheaper than personal contact. Evidence from industry has shown that costs of banking transactions across the counter are just over 100 times more costly than transactions over the internet18. However the impact of providing a service online is complex. For example, in terms of costs there is the following to consider: The cost of implementing the online solution, including training of staff, hardware and software purchase and development, and connection charges. The additional cost of maintaining traditional channels of access while introducing the new online channel. The additional, long term cost of supporting those that cannot access online channels. Reducing headline costs by working in partnership with other agencies and by joining up processes to reduce bureaucracy. In terms of benefits: Freeing of staff from administrative duties to provide more responsive and personal services to customers. Providing greater focus to those that need more help. Providing new services geared for customers' needs, by working in partnership. Increasing channels of access beyond the traditional to reach the "hard-to-reach". Reducing costs for servicing the majority of the customers. Opening access for customers to new services, e.g. archive records and historical artefacts held by remote institutions (e.g. the National Library of Wales, the National Gallery and Museum of Wales). The analysis of costs and benefits must be seen beyond the financial, and should include an impact analysis upon our citizens and customers. As yet the scope of the eGovernment work to be done has yet to be agreed and so the known costs are those commitments for a series of e-government projects over the next financial year (see Appendix G), as well as the staff costs for the eGovernment Team and the investment in the upgrading of Council ICT systems. 18 E.gov - electronic service delivery for the 21st Century, Performance and Innovation Unit, Cabinet Office, September 2001. 14 Outline funding/resourcing strategy Additional funds will be required to pump-prime eGovernment work prior to reaching the stage when we can realise savings. As these eGovernment projects are agreed, project management structures will be created with reporting mechanisms to the IEG Co-ordination Group and ultimately to the eGovernment Steering Group. Staff resources will be committed to these projects as part of the process of building the business case and implementation. Other national sources of funding are providing, for example, broadband infrastructure, connections to schools and libraries and kiosks (see Appendix G). The principal aim of the eGovernment Steering Group is to develop the synergies between these projects, where they can provide benefit for citizens and partners alike. Outline plans for realising savings The degree of investment required to deliver eGovernment in the short term is substantial and it may be that the savings to be made are minimal compared to the amount of investment needed. The business case for eGovernment may militate against realising savings in the short term, while the need for investment in delivering new forms of service is high. Any savings realised would need to be reinvested in the process to retain the momentum on service improvement. Each business case developed will be benchmarked against alternative service delivery models to ensure that best value is being delivered. While the Council welcomes recent announcements on funding for eGovernment initiatives, the longer term revenue implications of these projects need to be taken into account. In addition the degree of investment required to pump prime the eGovernment initiative militates against a rapid realisation of savings. The approach being developed within the Council is one that combines the best value approach to service improvement with a corporate push for joining up initiatives: a) take-up of online services including social inclusion implications We acknowledge that citizens in the County Borough have differential access to technology, with some not being able to access the new means of communication. National figures show that 66% of adults in the professional social class access the internet compared to 20% of unskilled and 26% of partially skilled19. Access to the internet by households shows that on average only 35% of households have access to the internet20. We are taking steps to extend facilities for internet access at our schools, learning centres and libraries, where staff are trained to help people. In terms of the Council's website, it has been developed to adhere to accessibility standards as recommended by government and other bodies such as the RNIB. We are keen also to keep pace with our customers' changing needs and expectations, and want to respond to these. We will monitor use of new and traditional channels to access services, to assess the impact of the eGovernment agenda upon the most vulnerable customers. b) decommissioning of traditional channels The idea of eGovernment is to match the optimal channel of access to the appropriate client group: giving self-service facilities to those clients that are able to access them, while others will need greater intervention and support. 19 20 Internet Access, National Statistics, 26th September 2000, HMSO. Internet Access, National Statistics, 26th September 2001, HMSO. 15 TRANSITION The National Assembly for Wales has awarded an initial sum of £406K to Wrexham County Borough Council, for the period 2002/4, to promote electronic government initiatives. A further sum of £110K per annum has been committed by the Council to fund an eGovernment Team to support the work programme. A Council "invest to save" fund has been set up to encourage innovation in service delivery and provide the pump-priming required for small projects that will release savings in the short term, on a loan basis. Beyond these sources of funding are the myriad of funded initiatives from the NAfW (see Appendix G). The eGovernment Steering Group will decide how to allocate the NAfW funding for e-government to maximise the impact upon eGovernment targets. The preferred method of contact varies with the nature of the customer and the type of issue they are trying to resolve. The Council's aim will be to encourage those that have the ability to get information or services through a "self-serve" option, while focussing skilled staff on the more sensitive cases. Digital inclusion is a key issue for the Council while implementing electronic government. It may be that traditional channels would be augmented in certain situations to ensure that communities do not find our services difficult to access. A review of customer access to services will take this issue into account. c) assets, accommodation and Human Resources implications TRANSITION With the increased use of electronic communication and storage of information, there could be less requirement for office space and the potential for different methods of providing staff resources. However, these savings will be slow to realise as they rely upon incremental changes in service delivery patterns and the development of technical and business support for the new forms of working. There may also be implications for growth in business if new services prove to be popular. The Council's resources will be allocated to best suit the requirements of our customers and citizens (see section 8, p10). 12. Business options and tactics Consulting and involving you The Council has adopted a robust and positive approach to consultation. Methods of consultation include surveys, discussion groups, website forms, exhibitions, special interest consultation forums. The Council has also established a Citizen's Panel of 500 local taxpayers. Other groups that are consulted are: "users and likely users of services", and "those with an apparent interest in an issue". Consultation occurs for specific service areas to support the best value review process, but also at Council-wide level to set a customer-sensitive direction for future policy and service delivery. This IEG Statement will be published on the website for consultation with the public and other stakeholders, to gather people's views on electronic delivery of services. We will be sensitive to our customers' needs, taking into account: life circumstances of individuals, special interests of groups, business and economic drivers, and the integration of public sector services where it can help local people. The next financial year will be a transitional year with consultation on the eGovernment agenda. This will help to inform work on the Community Strategy and Wales Programme for Improvement. 13. Risk assessment The risks associated with a change programme of this magnitude are many, however, they can be managed to reduce the impact upon the momentum of modernisation. The table in Appendix I summarises some of the key risks and the proposed actions to mitigate their impact. This is an initial high-level risk register that will be refined and detailed at project level and monitored throughout the change programme. The eGovernment Steering Group will take responsibility for risk management at the highest official level. 14. Skills needs analysis Wrexham is one of three authorities in Wales that has achieved an Investors in People award within all of its departments. The Council has put a strong emphasis on staff development, introducing team briefing and training and development plans for all staff. 16 A Management Development Programme is offered to managers, which looks at issues of cross-functional working to encourage joined-up government and action leadership to encourage a more fluid and flexible response to changes. It will also look in future at transformational leadership, addressing the skills that Senior Officers will need to respond to the new environment, looking at management styles, communications and 360 o feedback. Training opportunities have been extended to support staff in the new electronic environment, for example all Library staff have been trained to ECDL standard to support the public in accessing the internet within public libraries. A further 40 staff went through the ECDL (European Computer Driving Licence accreditation) in January 2002. Project management skills will be critical to the successful implementation of such a complex series of projects. The principles of Prince221 will be used to provide the necessary controlled environment. Business process analysis and re-engineering skills have been developed over the years through the Best Value approach, these skills will be required for staff to redesign services to meet customers' requirements and increase efficiency. 21 PRINCE, which stands for Projects in Controlled Environments, is a project management method covering the organisation, management and control of projects. PRINCE was first developed by the Central Computer and Telecommunications Agency (CCTA) now part of the Office of Government Commerce (OGC) in 1989 as a UK Government standard for IT project management. Since its introduction, PRINCE has become widely used in both the public and private sectors and is now the UK's de facto standard for project management. Although PRINCE was originally developed for the needs of IT projects, the method has also been used on many non-IT projects. The latest version of the method, PRINCE2, is designed to incorporate the requirements of existing users and to enhance the method towards a generic, best practice approach for the management of all types of projects. 17 TRANSITION Customer services training will become part of the Council's standard approach to its business. Parts of the Council have already achieved very high standards, with the Library and Information Service being awarded the Charter Mark in 2000, after having first obtained it in 1997. 18 Appendix A: Council vision and strategic aims Wrexham County Borough Council’s vision is of a County Borough that is: Aspiring to University City Status with Wrexham centre as its civic hub developing a vibrant commercial and shopping centre attracting visitors from North Wales and its borders; With revitalised distinct towns and villages and an attractive viable hinterland; With a modern, robust economy across all sectors, including health, education, commerce, tourism and manufacturing; With an improving quality of life for its residents, with an emphasis on: supporting access to a variety of educational and employment opportunities providing care for the more vulnerable in society providing a decent place to live conserving the environment balancing rural and urban needs promoting leisure and arts promoting the Welsh language to encourage a bilingual society developing safer communities. With institutions of growing stature, for example: the Council NEWI emerging as a University22 Yale College continuing to develop its status Wrexham Maelor Hospital developing further its healthcare expertise, research and teaching capacity. To deliver this vision, we have four strategic aims. These are to: Provide high quality, responsive, cost-effective services through a highly developed workforce. Work with communities to develop a sense of belonging and shared understanding of their needs, and to build community ownership of the Council and its services. Achieve the vision for the County Borough area by working in partnership with Town and Community Councils, voluntary organisations, industry, Trade Unions and other agencies. Seek to influence issues in Wales, Britain and Europe, which will have a bearing on the well being of the people of Wrexham County Borough Council. The vision and strategic aims provide the long-term view of where the Council wants to be and what it wants to achieve in the next 5 to 10 years. In addition to these, a series of corporate policy priorities have been identified for 2001-2, indicating broad priority areas for budget allocation, these are: Improving the Quality of Education Improving the Quality of Economy Improving the Quality of Care, Health and Well Being Improving the Quality of Life Improving the Quality of Services Within Improving the Quality of Services, the cross-cutting actions are: Modernising Local Government Best Value Consultation and partnership working Performance Management Electronic Government (eGovernment) The action of electronic government is: "The Council will develop and implement its agreed strategy for meeting the Government's targets for electronic service delivery. It will develop on-line interactive services using the Council's website, improve the integration of information systems within the organisation and tailor service delivery in a way that suits individual needs, to enable all its citizens to access local services electronically."23 22 23 North East Wales Institute Performance Plan, WCBC, 2001-2002 19 Appendix B: Corporate Planning Process 20 Appendix C: Milestones and targets for Wrexham Key priorities and actions Community Strategy and EGovernment partnerships Community Strategy, Consultation with community and other stakeholders on eGovernment Best Value/ Wales Establish new partnerships for eGovernment Improvement Investigate joint delivery plans/programmes Programme and Investigate information sharing protocols eGovernment Council-wide assessment of performance as part of Wales Improvement Programme Use BVRs to consult and challenge for the eGovernment agenda Democratic Renewal Using the internet to reach community groups and voluntary groups to promote community spirit All Elected members to be online Community Councils online Other voluntary groups online -AVOW Electronic consultation Electronic voting (LASER) Access to Services – Channels Access to services Strategic Review of Access to Services in the Council strategy Standards for call handling Channels Website Kiosks Smartcards/ swipecards One Stop Shop/ Contact Centre Mobile phone/ WAP/ Texting IDiTV Target Consultation exercises on e-government New partnerships based on e-government targets Joint delivery plan containing e-government targets Protocol ratified and actioned by partners EGovernment issue included as part of assessment Revised guidelines setting the challenge of e-government within BVR process Pilots All Elected Members with email access, and using it to conduct business Explore Community Councils' use of internet/email to conduct business Explore Voluntary Groups use of technology to communicate electronically Consultation exercises over the web Participating in national initiatives to encourage voter turnout Report on customer contact containing recommendations for improvement Guidance and training reissued Continually enhance as a transactional website Pilot for bus timetables Pilots in Schools and OAP transport Feasibility study Feasibility study linked to services for youth Investigate business case for delivery of web content over iDITV 21 Improving efficiency and effectiveness Organisational Management development Development Project management Risk management Innovation workshops Training programme in place to include eGovernment issues. Training plans in place looking at Investigate PRINCE2 as a standard to adopt in project management. Training plans in place Workshops to draw operational managers and technical solutions providers together to encourage creative thinking in service improvement - also involving partner organisations Skills assessment - IIP Elearning Awareness raising for Elected Members, strategic management, operational staff and partners Encouraging Elected Members to get online Flexible working/ teleworking Asset and property review Information and ICT Improve call handling Realising savings Office staff access to intranet Work-life balance pilot Review hand held devices pilot in Housing Hot-desking/ Home working - teleworking Property review Information management Geographic information management ICT platform for eGovernment Establish security and authentication Communications/ Marketing/ PR Resolution at first point of contact Increased knowledge at first call Look at options for developing FAQs Encourage move to self-reliance by customers Identifying savings as part of business case development for eGovernment Risk assessment Prioritising eGovernment projects Realising savings 22 Requirements of EGovernment be considered in Training plans, e.g ECDL training as standard, business process re-engineering skills, ICT, project management Pilot set up for self-directed training Awareness raising sessions and workshops on eGovernment, the capacities of ICT and potential for joint working IT training for Elected Members All Elected members to use email 100% office staff access to intranet Pilot for work-life balance solution Review of pilot Pilot teleworking Cross Council review of property requirements, linked to flexible working arrangements Review Information Strategy Standardise GIS platforms Corporate Strategy for Geographic information management Updated ICT Strategy Standards/ policy set within ICT strategy Communications strategy Encourage self-service and phone calls where appropriate Develop scripts for frontline staff Scripted FAQs prepared for use on the web or in a Contact centre Marketing of online facilities Business cases containing cost/benefit and potential savings As part of project management process Identification of early winners and those with savings potential Developed mechanism for realising savings from eGovernment projects Priorities for Electronic Service Delivery - volume, efficiency and statutory High volume services Assessment of priorities for investment in eGovernment for the high volume services in and electronic service the Council delivery Monitor National Assembly for Wales PI 1.5 e-payments e-Procurement Co-ordination with national projects Providing information Collecting revenue/ Receive payments Providing benefit and grants/ Making payments (benefits and creditors) Consultation/ Receiving feedback (complaints and consultation) Regulation (issue licenses) Applications for Services/ Making an application Booking venues, resources and courses/ Making a booking Paying for goods and services Providing access to community, professional and business networks Procurement Modernising Financial applications to support e-payments Audit of procurement practices Partnership arrangements Technological enhancements Implementation e-procurement (see above) Voting - LASER (see Democratic Renewal) Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages NLPG/NLIS UK Online National Grid for Learning (NGfL) eGIF compliance Successful implementation of this project Manage IEG process Set up IEG Co-ordination group with terms of reference Produce Revised IEG Produce Plan for Review of IEG Identify and set up task and finish groups for eGovernment projects Monitor take-up of online services Develop funding mechanism for IEG within WCBC Priority services to be identified eGovernment - % of interactions with the public, by type, which are capable of electronic service delivery and which are being delivered using internet protocols or other paperless methods: Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Set Council targets up to 2006 Financial systems capable of electronic transactions Review of procurement in the Council Explore partnership arrangements to secure better value for money in procurement Implement e-procurement pilots Council-wide roll-out of e-procurement Comply with national standard Comply with national standard Comply with national standard Land and Property Gazetteer to BS7666 standard System in place for updating addressing to BS7666 standards for all Council systems Link to UK Online through website and life episodes Provide internet access to all schools, colleges and libraries Application of eGIF standards to new systems IEG Co-ordination Group with terms of reference Published IEG Statement Plan produced as part of IEG Statement Task and Finish Groups set up with terms of reference and plan of action Survey of online access Agreed funding mechanism 23 Appendix D: Electronic service delivery by function and service type LIST OF SERVICES FUNCTIONS Enter percentage of service available via electronic service delivery or enter Not applicable (N/A) Department Providing information Public Making application Public Making booking Authority Receiving payment Receiving feedback Authority Making payment Adoption & Fostering Social Services 25% n/a n/a n/a n/a 25% Animal Health/ Issues Public Protection 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Archives/Historical/Museums Services Leis, Lib, Culture 40% 1% 0% 0% n/a 0% Arts & Entertainment Leis, Lib, Culture 60% 0% 0% 0% n/a 0% Building Control Planning 40% 0% n/a 0% n/a 70% Buildings Services/Energy conservation Property Services 20% 5% n/a n/a n/a 25% Business Rates Finance 10% 25% n/a 80% 100% 50% Car Parks Transport & Engineering 20% n/a n/a 0% n/a 0% Cemeteries & Crematoria Community Services 0% 0% n/a 0% n/a 0% Child Protection Social Services 1% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Cleansing Services Community Services 25% n/a 0% 0% n/a 25% Community Issues Policy & Corporate 50% 0% n/a n/a n/a 40% Conservation Leis, Lib, Culture 15% n/a n/a n/a n/a 5% Council Tax Finance 25% 25% n/a 80% 75% 50% Council Tax Benefits Finance 25% 0% n/a n/a 75% 50% Countryside Service Leis, Lib, Culture 50% n/a n/a n/a n/a 10% Crime & Disorder Policy & Corporate 25% n/a n/a n/a n/a 25% Disabilities Social Services 10% 0% n/a n/a n/a 5% Drainage & Sewerage Transport & Engineering 0% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Economic Development Economic Development 44% 10% n/a n/a n/a 5% Education Education 50% 30% n/a n/a n/a 1% Education - Adult/Lifelong Education 10% 0% n/a n/a 5% Education - Further/6th Form Education 10% 0% n/a n/a n/a 5% Education - General Education 30% 5% n/a n/a n/a 30% Education - Pre school Education 10% 1% n/a n/a n/a 10% 24 LIST OF SERVICES FUNCTIONS Enter percentage of service available via electronic service delivery or enter Not applicable (N/A) Department Providing information Public Making application Public Making booking Authority Receiving payment Receiving feedback Authority Making payment Education - Primary Education 40% 10% n/a n/a n/a 10% Education - Secondary Education 40% 10% n/a n/a n/a 10% Education - Special Needs Education 40% 10% n/a n/a 1% Electoral Registration Legal & Admin 50% 0% n/a n/a n/a 50% Emergency Planning Policy & Corporate 20% n/a n/a n/a n/a 50% Environmental Health Public Protection 25% 0% 0% n/a n/a 25% Europe (affairs, funding, issues) Economic Development 20% 10% n/a n/a n/a 1% Footways & Pavements Transport & Engineering 0% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Fraud Hotline Finance 50% n/a n/a n/a n/a 100% General Council Matters Legal & Admin 63% n/a n/a n/a n/a 30% Grants (general) Policy & Corporate 25% 5% n/a n/a 0% 10% Grounds Maintenance Community Services 25% n/a n/a 0% n/a 0% Health Public Protection 10% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Highways Maintenance Transport & Engineering 40% n/a n/a n/a 0% 50% Home Care Service Social Services 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Housing Housing 60% 0% 0% 60% n/a 60% Housing Benefits Housing 70% 0% n/a n/a n/a 70% Housing Repairs Housing 5% n/a 0% n/a n/a 5% Human Resources Personnel n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Industrial Services Economic Development 80% 10% 0% 0% 0% 10% Jobs Personnel 40% 0% 0% n/a n/a 50% Land Charges Legal & Admin 40% n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Landscape & Horticulture Community Services 25% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Legal & Administration Legal & Admin n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Leisure Services Leis, Lib, Culture 50% 2% 60% n/a n/a 0% Libraries Leis, Lib, Culture 60% 0% 10% 0% n/a 25% Licensing Public Protection 25% 0% n/a 0% n/a 0% Markets & Town Centres Economic Development 15% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% 25 LIST OF SERVICES FUNCTIONS Enter percentage of service available via electronic service delivery or enter Not applicable (N/A) Department Providing information Public Making application Public Making booking Authority Receiving payment Receiving feedback Authority Making payment Members Information Legal & Admin 80% n/a n/a n/a n/a 80% Mobility Social Services 10% 0% n/a n/a n/a 0% Parks, Playgrounds & Open Spaces Leisure, Library, Culture 30% n/a 0% n/a n/a 0% Pest Control Public Protection 30% n/a 80% 0% n/a 0% Planning Planning 60% 0% n/a 0% n/a 80% Press and Public Relations Policy & Corporate 60% n/a n/a n/a n/a 40% Public Right of Way Transport & Engineering 20% 0% n/a n/a n/a 25% Public Transport Transport & Engineering 50% 50% n/a n/a 80% 5% Recycling & LA 21 Public Protection 50% 0% n/a n/a 0% 30% Refuse & Waste Collection & Disposal Community Services 60% n/a 60% 0% n/a 25% Registrar of Births, Marriage and Deaths Legal & Admin 0% 0% 0% 0% n/a 0% Safety Public Protection 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Snow Clearance and Gritting Transport & Engineering 2% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Social Services Social Services 10% n/a n/a n/a n/a 5% Street Lighting Transport & Engineering 2% n/a n/a n/a n/a 0% Student Grants Strategic Services (education) 50% 5% n/a n/a 100% 40% Tourist Information Economic Development 32% n/a n/a n/a n/a 20% Trading Standards Public Protection 25% 0% n/a n/a n/a 0% Traffic Management Transport & Engineering 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 2% Welsh Policy & Corporate 60% n/a n/a n/a n/a 40% Youth Service Education 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 1% 72 38 14 17 9 71 30% 6% 15% 13% 48% 20% Maximum no. services available by ESD Total Average percentage of functions available by ESD (KPI results) 26 Appendix E: Telecommunications Best Value Survey of the Public and Members The extracts below are from the full results of a survey conducted with the public. The methodology involved operators phoning back people who had previously agreed to take part in the survey in order to complete a questionnaire. Departmental switchboards or reception facilities involved in the survey included the main corporate switchboard, Social Services, Education and Leisure and the Emergency Control Centre Out of Hours service. A cut-down version of the questionnaire was posted on the web site and included in the CONNECT magazine but the response was poor. Total achieved sample from the public: 190. A Citizen’s Panel survey was also undertaken and some initial results are shown below as a point of comparison. Preferred method to contact Council offices: By Telephone 68.3% Visit the office By e-mail By letter By Fax Other* 25.8% 2.3% 2.3% 1.4% 0.0% Comparative result Citizen’s Panel Telecoms 2001 80% Comparative result Citizen’s Panel Performance Plan 1999 76% Message:- Telephone is the preferred means of contact for accessing Council services How many times have you phoned the Council in the last 12 months <5 53.3% Last time you called, what happened, were you 6-10 19.8% >10 26.9% Comparative result Citizen’s Panel Telecoms 2001 81.6% 90% 11.2% 1.5% 4.9% 1.0% Answered promptly Answered eventually Answer machine Found line was busy Got no answer 27 Received a Bilingual greeting Able to conduct business in Language of choice Did you contact the service you required directly, i.e. not 292000? No 58.4% Yes No 97.8% 2.2% Yes 83.4% No 16.6% Yes 88.9% No 11.1% 1 2 or more 76.3% 23.7% Failed 0.0% Yes 41.0% No 59.0% If you contacted Council by main No. 292000 did you get through to correct service? How many attempts were made to transfer you? (i.e. of 11.1% above) Yes 41.6% Could the operator help with the enquiry without having to connect to other service? When contacting the Council by telephone, would you prefer Operator Service to direct you to service you require Dial direct to service you require from choice of published numbers Single contact number at which an officer can deal with all your enquiries Message: Lack of compliance with Welsh greeting standards – also confirmed by Mystery Shopper results Message: high percentage claim phone direct to service area rather than switchboard Message: Some issues on transfer effectiveness – Mystery shopper also confirmed issues on transfers within departments on calls direct to published service numbers Comparative result Citizen’s Panel Telecoms 2001 31.5% 40% 52.8% 40% 15.7% 20% 28 Message: Seeming preference for direct dial to service area, though the Citizen’s Panel which is statistically a more accurate survey, indicates an equal preference for switchboard and direct dial, and an increased percentage for single point of contact. Appendix F: Partnership arrangements Details of a range of "partnership" arrangements (private and voluntary sector) and joint working arrangements with other local authorities 1 Partnership Arrangements with Private Sector Partners/Partnership Independent sector care agencies Variety with individual developers Bus operators Local architectural practices Babtie Group Dee Valley Group/North Wales Gas 2 Purpose Residential/nursing care and home care Shared delivery of individual projects such as: retail developments, hotel, land reclamation schemes, bus station, leisure schemes and schools. Provision of services, quality of vehicles, timetable information, bust stops & shelters etc Provision of building control plan vetting services (this also involves other LAs) Provision of highways laboratory services Collection of water and gas charges via LA Cash Office and Housing Estate Offices Partnership Arrangements with Voluntary Sector (some joint with Health) Partners/Partnership ADVANCE Association of Voluntary Organisations Wrexham (AVOW) Caia Park Early Years Forum Caia Park Play Resource Centre CAIS CALL Carers Project Cartrefle Play Group Childrens Rights Service Dolen Disability Forum Early Years Forum Early Years & Childcare partnership Family Friends Homestart Longfields Marvel MYM National Childminding Association PPA Rainbow RELATE Stepping Stones Systems Advocacy Purpose Advocacy – Mental Illness Service Users Local Voluntary Council Early Years Support Service Play Resource Centre Counselling – Drugs/alcohol users Telephone Helpline – Mental Illness Users Support to carers Special Needs Playgroup Children’s Rights & Advocacy Mental Illness Daycare Service Physical Disability & Sensory Impairment consultation Early Years Services support Family Support – 5 to 11s Family Support – 0 to 5s Therapy – sexually abused children Reparation scheme – Young Offenders Welsh medium – pre-school playgroups Support for Childminders English pre-school playgroups Multi-purpose day centre – older people Counselling – relationship breakdown Counselling – Adults who suffered childhood sexual abuse Advocacy – people with learning disability 29 Partners/Partnership Purpose The Venture Crossroads Play Association Womens Aid Wrenewal Wrexham CAB Wrexham Homework Clubs Wrexham Association of Summer Playschemes Wrexham County Forum Young Carers Project Care and Repair Body Positive Children & Youth Partnership Sure Start Compass Partnership Schools Counselling project -Special Education and NSPCC Children & Young People in Need Respite Care – Disabled Adults Children in Need – Play Development Support for victims of domestic violence Recycling furniture – children in need & vulnerable people Advocacy – genera. School-based homework clubs Summer playschemes – children in need Consultation – Learning Disability Services Support for young carers Support re adaptations/grants for housing improvement Support for AIDS/HIV sufferers Assembly funded programme Assembly funded programme – development of 0-3s Youth Service, Social Services, Housing + Barnardos – support for young people Counselling service Basic Skills Programme/ Partnership Partnership with not-for-profit company Partnership with not-for-profit company Local sporting organisations & regional sports associations WCBC, Yale College of FE & Wrexham Association for the Arts Crime & Disorder Reduction Partnership (WCBC, North Wales Police, Health Authority, Police Authority, Probation) Area Flood Partnership (WCBC, Emergency Services, Environmental Agency, relevant Community Councils) North Wales Strategic Emergency Planning Group (Police, LAs, Military, Emergency Services) Groundwork Wrexham Community Regeneration – wide variety of voluntary sector involvement in community initiatives Multi-agency approach to improve literacy and numeracy Regional Tennis Centre Rhos Stiwt – Welsh Cultural Centre Sports development To create a theatre trust to undertake its management and operation - Town Centre Theatre To reduce local levels of crime & disorder To work together following floods to be better prepared for the future and provide effective means of communication between agencies and the community To co-ordinate pan-North Wales emergency planning LA provides officer support and advice, funding and representation on the Board EU Urban II, Communities First, Local Regeneration Fund, Area Community Strategies, EU Objective III, EG Leader Plus, EU Objective 5b Additional category - Private/Voluntary sector partnerships Partners/Partnership Community Legal Service Partnership Purpose LA -Voluntary Sector - Private Sector - Legal Services Commission – to co-ordinate development of local strategy for identifying need for funding of and provision of legal advice and assistance 30 3 Joint Working Arrangements with other Local Authorities and public sector Participants Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire/Conwy Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire/Conwy Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire/Conwy Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire/Conwy All North Wales Authorities All North Wales Authorities Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighshire/Conwy WCBC, Yale College and NEWI Wrexham/Flintshire/Denbighsire/Conwy Service North East Wales Registration and Inspection Service Receivership Design & Print – joint provision of design and print facilities by Las Borderlands – joint tourism promotion and marketing Inward investment – joint marketing Schools Library Service Outdoor Education Curriculum Advice and Support Services North Wales Economic Forum – development of regional economic development strategies /representation of economic interest of North Wales North Wales eGovernment Group - to co-operate on eGovernment initiatives Emergency Planning Opening resources and services to all residents, students and workers in the County Borough e.g. through joint membership and ICT facilitated access to the catalogues of all 3 libraries - GALW Schools Library Service 31 Appendix G: EGovernment Initiatives - current position as at December 2001 Initiative Title eGovernment Purpose of initiative Project Costs eGovernment Projects £406K over 2 Yrs Welsh Crime & Disorder Extranet Warehousing of relevant data from partner agencies to assist crime analysis and reduction £500,000 (Wales) Business Connect IT Centre To provide basic ICT support to business £85,000 % External Funding 100% External Funding Source Credit Approvals Status (e.g. bidding stage/funding allocated Details of Allocation Awaited Home Office North Wales Pilot Protocol in place by April 2002 Business Connect Funding Allocated: In Place 41% Business Connect £35,000 Business Connect 16% UK Online for Business £13,500 UK Online for Business Implementation timetable 2002/03 & 2003/04 Internal Funding National Grid for Learning Provide Internet connection, ICT training, equipment and software. £318,000 60% NAfW via GEST Funding Allocated On-going NOF ICT Training for Teachers and School Librarians Fund access to external training service (LSP) £483,683 100% NOF Funding Allocated Training to be completed by half-term Spring 2003 ICT for Learning a) Provide computer suites software, etc. for all secondary schools; £435,000 100% NOF via NAfW Funding Allocated Complete by March 2002 b) ICT for SEN pupils Funding Allocated £175,000 (10% top-sliced for implementation) Direct Funding by NAfW To be completed by March 2002 (See below for 3rd element) £19,000 ICT for Learning To improve facilities for schools and learners at community venues £157,500 100% NAfW Broadband Lifelong Learning Network a) Provide Broadband link to Local Authority; £8.5m (Wales) 100% NAfW b) Provide broadband links to schools; £10m over 3yrs (Wales) Not yet known Details Awaited c) To provide multi-media equipment to all schools; £437,500 100% Funding Allocated 32 March 2002 March 2002 Initiative Title Purpose of initiative d) To provide support and training. PLASC – UPNS To develop a common pupil dataset in Wales People’s Network To provide free public internet access from all libraries Project Costs £4m (Wales) Capital £198,287 % External Funding External Funding Source 100% Status (e.g. bidding stage/funding allocated Implementation timetable Details Awaited £1000 per school for admin 2001/ 2002. Additional funding 2002 due – approx £1,200 per school NAfW Funding Allocated – ring fenced for PLASC Dec 2001 – Secondary Jan 2002 – Primary Almost 100% New Opportunities Fund (NOF) – Community Access to Lifelong Learning Funding Allocated £259,653 To be completed by December 2002 (Revenue £64,818 pa) ICT Training of Library Staff To train Library staff in the use of ICT £25,475 100% New Opportunities Fund (NOF) – Community Access to Lifelong Learning Funding Allocated 3 year phased programme commenced 2001/2002 Children First Assessment Framework for Children Improve Childcare record keeping £120,000 90% NAfW Funding Allocated April 2002 Smartcards for Concessionary Travel Smartcards to help in the understanding & resource allocation of concessionary travel for pensioners and people with disabilities £800,000 (North Wales) 100% NAfW Bidding Stage April 2002 Passenger Information Network Information Kiosks Real time public transport information £4 m (North Wales) £40,000 100% NAfW Bidding Stage April 2002 100% NAfW Funding Allocated £15,000 April 2002 Provide bus and rail times at termini 33 Appendix H: Structure for eGovernment Implementation in Wrexham CBC eGovernment Steering Group (EGSG) Objectives: To define and galvanise WCBC’s eGovernment response To establish strategies for delivery To maintain corporate commitment To monitor IEG implementation Deliverables: IEG Statement Overall eGovernment strategy & priorities Identification of services for priority action Resources identification Membership: Chief Executive Director of Finance & Information Services Chief Information Systems Officer Chief Corporate Development Officer Chief Leisure, Libraries & Culture Officer Chief Personnel Officer Corporate eGovernment Manager IEG Projects Co-ordination Team Objectives: To develop project implementation plans based on priorities from EGSG To establish project teams To develop project specifications To co-ordinate activities across eGovernment projects Deliverables: Project Plans Progress on actions defined within IEG Statement Membership: Corporate eGovernment Manager Service representation Corporate policy representation IS representation Web Development Manager Web Development Group Objectives: To develop Web/Intranet information & service delivery To co-ordinate Web activities across e-govt projects Deliverables: Devolved content management Transactional web portal Intranet as key business tool Membership: Web Development Manager Service representation Individual Project Implementation Teams Task and Finish Project 1 Project 2 Project 3 34 Project 4 Appendix I: Risk log Type of risk Planned action to eliminate or lessen the risk Risk assessment Probability No Action Action M/H M Impact No Action H Action Resistance to change from the public Change can be uncomfortable for people, and they may find the new ways of working unappealing and difficult to understand. This could lead to them not taking up the new channels, consequently savings will not be realised. Continuing to consult with the public and stakeholders to understand their points of view - prior to and after implementation. Marketing campaign to promote the "new service". Resistance to change from staff Electronic service delivery may be treated as an add-on to the current way of working, rather than changing the underlying business processes to realise savings. As part of best value/improvement process, challenge current ways of working and re-engineer them to best suit the customer's requirements. Staff training to cope with changes in working practices. Training in business process redesign and working alongside consultants. M/H L H L Resistance to change from political and official leadership Commitment from all Elected Members and senior management is critical to the success of electronic government. Awareness raising sessions for Elected Members and senior managers Policy leadership through eGovernment Steering Group, Chaired by Chief Executive. M/L L H L Unequal access to technology or channels Social inclusion is critical to the public sector. Not all people are able to access technology easily. Opening up of channels of access that can be reached by those who might otherwise be excluded e.g. outreach workers using handheld information appliances. Making savings on self-serve services and refocusing investment towards those prone to exclusion. H M/L H M/L Failure of IT systems All information systems are mission critical, so that any break in performance will have a major impact upon the day to day running of the Council. ICT Services maintains the integrity, security reliability of the systems and networks for the Council. Customer communications are managed through a helpdesk and the IS Liaison Group - a group with cross-Council representation - for planning future work programmes. M L H L Significant problems with ICT integration This could result in delay in implementation of systems. Ensure professional ICT representation at outset of project H M H H Lack of co-ordination or programme management Successful delivery of the integrated projects under eGovernment depends upon good programme management. The inter-related nature of these projects makes it critical that they are phased appropriately. Staff training in project and programme management. Mentoring of inexperienced managers by Senior Management from within and outwith the Council. Buying in consultancy if required, for major projects. M/H M/L H L 35 L Type of risk Planned action to eliminate or lessen the risk Risk assessment Probability No Action Action M/H M/L Impact No Action H Action Lack of commitment to joined-up and partnership working A lack of partnership working leads to a disjointed and unfocussed service for the customer. Partners may have different priorities to ours. Already have many partnerships in place within the Council. The Community Strategy will draw together the partnerships on a corporate basis. Improvement programme and eGovernment will challenge traditional ways of working. Consultation/workshops with partners when developing IEG agenda. Lack of funding Investment in the eGovernment agenda will be heavy, especially for opening new channels such as a One Stop Shop or Contact centre. Seek challenge funding if available. Work in partnership to share resources and costs. Develop a self-service model to reduce costs and reinvest savings realised. H M H M Inability to realise savings from services or difficulties in redirecting resources There will need to be a realisation of savings to reinvest in further innovation as funds will be limited. Best Value Review process and business case approach to projects should identify savings to be made and set up systems for monitoring actual savings. H M H H Legal constraints Legal constraints on the sharing of information between Council Services and with other organisation limits the level of "joining-up" that can be achieved. Learning from best practice models. Seeking guidance on what's possible from DTLR, NAfW. M L H L Entry to the Euro Financial systems need to accommodate the Euro. Timescales are uncertain. Some of the Council’s information systems and printers capable of accommodating different currency. H M/L Security and fraud The security of Council systems in terms of attack, accidental release of personal information or fraudulent claims for payments from the Council. IT security policies for the systems. Data Protection and Freedom of Information awareness amongst staff. Fraud controls, separation of duties, appropriate controls and fraud detection. Information Strategy being developed. H M 36 H M/L L H M/H Glossary of terms and acronyms 24x7 Back office Best Value BPR Contact Centre CCTV Channel eGovernment EGIF Electronic service delivery (ESD) GDP GIS HR ICT IDeA IDTV IEG Inclusion Interoperability ISDN Performance Indicator (PI) – PI 1.5 PRINCE2 NAfW NGfL NLIS NLPG NOF One Stop Shop Social inclusion SOCITM UPRN WCBC Services available 24 hours a day 7 days a week The information systems that are held in the “back office “ and support the business functions of the organisation Government initiative to challenge, compare, compete and consult on services to improve them for the customer Business Process Re-engineering – a way to analyse how people are currently working so that it can be re-arranged into a more effective/efficient way of working A central unit with a main phone number(s) that handles calls from customers and can handle basic enquiries or transactions by telephone predominantly, and other forms of communications e.g. email, fax, letters. Closed Circuit Television Phrase used to describe methods of accessing the Council e.g. website, telephone Electronic government Electronic Government Interoperability Framework. Standards that make data sharing easier. Delivery through internet protocols and other ICT methods. Includes delivery by telephone if the transaction is electronically enabled i.e. the officer receiving the call can access electronic information and/or update records on-line there and then. Gross Domestic Product Geographic Information System – electronic mapping Human Resources Information Communications Technology Improvement and Development Agency Interactive Digital Television Implementing Electronic Government Inclusion - see social inclusion Term used to describe how information and technology standards have to be addressed to allow data-sharing Integrated Services Digital Network National Assembly for Wales Performance Indicator to assess progress on electronic government for local government. English equivalent is BV 157. Project In Controlled Environments – 2nd version National Assembly for Wales National Grid for Learning National Land Information Service – linked to NLPG National Land and Property Gazetteer – standard for giving each property a unique identification to BS7666 standard New Opportunities Fund Where you can deal with more than one type of service within one building with a “shop front” Policy whereby no one is excluded from society for any reason Society of Information Technology Managers Unique Property Reference Number Wrexham County Borough Council Useful website links Organisation Cabinet Office Cymru Arlein Directorate-General for the Information Society, Europe Govtalk Improvement and Development Agency National Assembly for Wales Office of e-Envoy Society of Information Technology Management Syniad UK Online Welsh Local Government Association Wrexham County Borough Council Link www.cabinet-office.gov.uk www.cymruarlein.wales.gov.uk http://europa.eu.int/comm/dgs/information_society/index_en.htm www.govtalk.gov.uk www.idea.gov.uk www.wales.gov.uk www.e-envoy.gov.uk www.socitm.gov.uk www.syniad.gov.uk www.ukonline.gov.uk www.wlga.gov.uk www.wrexham.gov.uk 37