PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 1 Final exam: Important Revision Topics Exoplanet: finding techniques Exolanet formation processes, debris disks Distances – luminosity – magnitudes - temperatures Radiation processes - multiwavelength Kepler’s laws Hertzsprung-Russell tracks Exolanets; brown dwarfs Stellar lifetimes Protostars & Young stars: classes.and evolution. Lectures Week 8: Star Formation 1. Intro: Star formation is on-going. What is the origin of our solar system? Descartes, Kant, Laplace: vortices, nebular hypothesis: importance of angular momentum. In general: Gravity is fast-acting. Galaxy is old. But young stars are still being born. Stars don't live forever, they must continue to be "born". Where? Born in obscurity….needed infrared/millimeter/radio wavelengths. 2. Molecular clouds: ingredients Young stars are located in or near molecular clouds (the stellar factories/nurseries). Stars mainly form in clusters in giant molecular clouds. Over 90% of atoms are tied up in molecules. 99.99% is molecular hydrogen: H2 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 2 Over 120 other molecules discovered, including water, carbon monoxide CO, formaldehyde H2CO, ammonia NH3, hydrogen cyanide HCN, formic acid HCOOH and methanol CH3CO Admixture of dust: 1% by mass– tiny grains (less than 1 micron in size) of silicates/graphite with ice coatingss, or soot (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs). Cosmic rays, magnetic field. The large amount of gas and dust in the cloud shields the molecules from UV radiation from stars in our galaxy. The molecules can then cool the gas down to 10-30K. Dense cold cores can form (eggs?) in which gravity rules). The H2 molecules cannot form by H-H collisions (excess energy needs an outlet). H2 forms on dust, atoms stick, migrate, bind, ejected. Other molecules form through collisions (ion-chemistry). 3. Molecular clouds: anatomy Opaque at UV and visible wavelengths. Bright and luminous at millimetre wavelengths: dust continuum. Bright rotational and vibrational molecular emission lines at radio and infrared wavelengths e.g. CO lines PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 3 Molecular clouds are cold: 8<= Tkin<=20 K Typical value ~10 K Low ionization: fe =ne/n ~10-6 - 10-7 => very neutral! High density: n(H2) >= 100 cm-3 Giant molecular clouds are very massive: M~ 104 to 106 solar masses Giant molecular clouds are large: size ~ 100 parsecs They are clumpy Supersonic gas motions are found in almost all clouds Line widths ~ 0.5 to 2 km s-1; sound speed ~ 0.2 km s-1 indicative of nonthermal motions such as rotation, turbulence, shocks, contraction or expansion, stellar bipolar outflows, etc. Measures: PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 4 Atmospheric cloud: A comparison of scales between typical molecular and atmospheric clouds. Molecular Cloud Size 1014 km Mass 1036 gm Particle density 103 cm-3 Temperature 20 K Mol/atomic weight 2.3 Speed of sound 0.3 km/s Turbulent speed 3 km/s Dynamical time Million years Atmospheric Cloud 1 km 11 10 gm 19 10 cm-3 260 K 29 0.3 km/s 0.003 km/s Five minutes Scales & Types: Estimated properties of individual molecular aggregates in the Galaxy: Phase GMCs Clumps/Globules Mass (Msun) 6x104 - 2x106 Size (parsecs) 20 - 100 Density (cm-3) 100 - 300 Temperature (K) 15 - 40 Magn. Field(G) 1 - 10 Line width (km/s) 6 - 15 Dynamic life (years) 3 x 106 102 0.2 - 4 103 - 104 7 - 15 3 - 30 0.5 - 4 106 Cores 1 - 10 0.1 - 0.4 104 - 105 10 10 - 50 0.2 - 0.4 6 x 105 Note: dynamical life defined as Size/(Line width), true lifetimes would be considerably longer if clouds were static. Example: Orion millimeter dust emission – clumps and cores PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith The Horsehead (optical – dark cloud) 5 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 6 Summary: clouds are turbulent, possibly fractal 4. Molecular clouds: their origin Agglomeration: collisions and merging/coalescence of smaller clouds – not sufficient number of small clouds. Spiral arm density-wave focusing. Gravitational instability followed by fragmentation Condensation: out of atomic clouds. Accumulation: gas swept up into supershells, focused in turbulent interstellar medium. Answer: combination of these. 5. Molecular cloud evolution PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 7 Observed: Giants, clumps, cores, eggs Gravitational Collapse: When a fragment of a molecular cloud reaches a critical mass – the Jeans mass (after Sir James Jeans (1877-1946) - it collapses to form a star. Gas PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 8 and dust are then pulled together by gravity until a star is formed. Balance forces: gravity and pressure: GM J2/R ~ MJcs2 Eliminate R in favour of the density, yields the Jeans Mass, which more precisely calculated is MJ T M J 1 10 K 3/ 2 6 G n 4 3 10 cm 1/ 2 T RJ 0.19 10 K 3/ 2 c s3 1 / 2 1 / 2 n 4 3 10 cm M sun 1 / 2 par sec s Fragmentation: The molecular cloud does not collapse into a single star. It fragments through the Jeans instability - into many clumps. As the density rises, the Jeans mass falls. This means the cloud continues to fragment into smaller clumps. What makes it reach/exceed the critical mass in the first instance? Mechanisms: sequential, spontaneous, turbulence, triggers PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 9 What are the conditions that favour the initiation of star formation? Decrease internal pressure: By decreasing the temperature or the density or both Increasing the mean mass per particle by transforming from an atomic gas to a molecular gas. Decrease the ionization fraction, fe = ne/n to < 10-7 => gas decouples from any magnetic field present so that magnetic pressure cannot support the cloud. Increase the external pressure: By partially focused shocks. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 10 By ionization of the gas around a molecular clump: radiativelydriven implosion. Collapse: Method 1 Accretion- coalescence: Build up of small clouds of gas and dust into clumps. Clumps "stick" together and grow. Very slow - due to low interstellar densities Collapse: Method 2 Gravity and Radiation Pressure Collapse: Method 3: sequential, triggered Compression by supernova blast waves Evidence that the Solar System/Sun was triggered by a supernova – (radioactive isotopes so short-lived that they no longer exist were trapped in chondrules within meteorites). PH507 Collapses Methods Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 11 Collapse: Method 1 Accretion- coalescence: Build up of small clouds of gas and dust into clumps. Clumps "stick" together and grow. Very slow - due to low interstellar densities Collapse: Method 2 Gravity and Radiation Pressure Collapse: Method 3: sequential, triggered Compression by supernova blast waves Evidence that the Solar System/Sun was triggered by a supernova – (radioactive isotopes so short-lived that they no longer exist were PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith trapped in chondrules within meteorites). 12 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 13 6. Why clouds can’t collapse The Difficult Path to Collapse Gravity makes parts of a the cloud collapse. Hindrances to collapse which favour expansion: 1. Internal heating Causes pressure build-up 2. Angular momentum Causes high rotation speeds (exemplified by a figure skater) 3. Magnetic support Internal Heating Cloud fragments collapse Potential energy => Kinetic Energy o Gas particles speed up and collide. The temperature increases. This causes a pressure build-up which slows (or PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 14 stops) the collapse. Angular Momentum Solution: Energy is radiated away. Angular momentum o A = mass x velocity. of rotation x radius o A=mvr Conservation of angular momentum. o Magnetic support A = constant for a closed system. As the cloud fragment shrinks due to gravity, it spins faster. Collapse occurs preferentially along path of least rotation. The cloud fragment collapses into a central core surrounded by a disk of material. Further collapse: magnetic braking – winding and twisting of magnetic field lines connected to external gas. There is a critical mass, for which gravity is held up by magnetic pressure. A cloud can be super-critical – free to collapse Otherwise, the field diffuses out slowly: ambipolar diffusion – since the magnetic field is only tied to the ions, and the ions slip through the molecules. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 15 7 The Final Collapse: approaching birth Final adjustments. The thermodynamics now take on supreme importance. Much of what occurs is still theory: Stage 1. The density shields the core from external radiation, allowing the temperature to drop. Dust grains provide efficient cooling. The hydrogen is molecular. Stage 2. An isothermal collapse all the way from densities of 104 cm-3 then proceeds. The gravitational energy released goes via compression into heating the molecules. The energy is rapidly passed on to the dust grains via collisions. The dust grains reradiate the energy in the millimeter range, which escapes the core. So long as the radiation can escape, the collapse remains unhindered. Stage 3. At densities of 1011 cm-3 and within a radius of 1014 cm the gas becomes opaque to the dust radiation even at 300 microns. The energy released is trapped and the temperature rises. As the temperature ascends, the opacity also ascends. The core suddenly switches from isothermal to adiabatic. Stage 4. The high thermal pressure resists gravity and this ends the first collapse, forming what is traditionally called the first core at a density of 1013 cm-3 - 1014 cm-3 and temperature of 100-200 K. Stage 5. A shock wave forms at the outer edge of the first core. The first core accretes from the envelope through this shock. The temperature continues to rise until the density reaches 1017 cm3 . Stage 6. The temperature reaches 2000 K. Hydrogen molecules dissociate at such a high temperature if held sufficiently long. The resulting atoms hold less energy than the molecules did (the dissociation is endothermic), tempering the pressure rise. The consequence is the second collapse. Stage 7. The molecules become exhausted and the cooling stops at the centre of the first core. Protostellar densities of order 1023 cm3 are reachedand with temperatures of 10,000 K, thermal pressure brakes the collapse. This brings a second and final protostellar core into existence. The mass of this core may only be one per cent of the final stellar mass. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 16 Stage 8. The first shock from Stage 5 disappears while a second inner shock now mediates the accretion onto the protostellar core. A star is born. Stage 9: Further Collapse with Angular Momentum into a Disk All astronomical objects spin, even if very slowly. The original collapsing cloud will have some small amount of spin. During a collapse, angular momentum is conserved. Angular momentum is J = a x W R2 o a = a constant whose value we aren't interested in o W = Angular velocity = 2 pi/P o P = Spin Period o R = Radius of the star cloud If angular momentum is conserved then Wfinal = W0 x (R0/Rfinal)2 Since R0/Rfinal is much larger than 1 Final angular velocity can be very high, even if the initial angular velocity is very low. Centrifugal acceleration (GMv2/R) is proportional to W2R) and gravity (GM/R2) approach equilibrium A very rapidly rotating cloud will get flattened into a disk. This disk can then fragment into protoplanets. Disk Forms PH507 Planet Formation Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 17 The disk around the central core will fragment further, producing rings of material. The particles in these rings can accrete together to form planetesimals and planets! PH507 Making the Stars Visible Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 18 Making the Stars Visible After a star is born it heats the gas and dust around it. Jets of gas are ejected: bipolar outflows are observed. Eventually the gas and dust are accreted or dispersed. The star is then "visible." Prior to this it could be seen only in the radio and the infrared. Spectral energy distributions define the classes of protostars and Young Stellar Objects…… PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 19 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 20 Processes in Young Star Evolution accretion, contraction, jets and outflow Proplyds – protoplanetary disks: Accretion through disc: bolometric luminosity of protostar is . GM M L R Where M*dot* is the mass accretion rate and GM/R is the energy released per unit mass onto the protostar of (accumulating) mass M and radius R. Star accumulates gas from envelope through the disc, releases some through jets back into cloud. The jets are thought to be the channels for the extraction of angular momentum. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 21 Jets: extend parsecs from source. They are seen through their impact with cloud: shock wave heating: Herbig-Haro Objects. They create large reservoirs of outpouring and swept-up gas: bipolar outflows or molecules outflows HH46/47: Optical: HST PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 22 Infrared: Spitzer Massive Stars & Clusters: Massive stars should not form: hydrogen burning begins while accreting: radiation pressure should resist the infall. Accretion must be high and through a disk: to suffocate the feedback. Massive stars create hot molecular cores, masers, compact/extended H II regions: PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 23 Most stars are in multiple bound systems. Frequency of occurrence: Single:binary:triple:quadruple is 58:33:7:1 Multiplicity theory covers: capture, fission, core/collapse/disk fragmentation Capture: extremely unlikely Fission: splitting leads only to close binaries Fragmentation is plausible. 90% of stars are born in clusters. Cluster: over 35 stars, at least 1 Msun/pc3 Embedded clusters: 1000 Msun with a density 10,000 Msun/pc3 Segregation: Massive stars tend to form in centre (form in situ, don’t migrate) Relaxation: Cloud evolves and cluster disperses in a few million years. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 24 Clusters dissolve: most stars are NOT in clusters, they become field stars. All suggests: Hierarchical fragmentation within a turbulent medium . Star formation efficiency, the amount of cloud gas transformed into stars, is only 3%-20%. The initial mass function (the IMF: initial mass function): most star are of low mass. Question: Power law? Salpeter IMF: N proportional to M-1.3 Scale-free hierarchy. Jeans mass? Is there a brown dwarf desert? Planets form in disks, stars in collapse. PH507 Astrophysics Turbulence v. Gravity Professor Michael Smith 25 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 26 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith The Sun: A Model Star 27 PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 28 Our Sun is the nearest star. The fascinating properties and phenomena of the solar surface layers are easily observed and have been studied intensely. Unfortunately, models for understanding solar phenomena have not kept pace with such detailed data. Because the Sun is a fairly typical star and because it is the only star that spans a large angular diameter as seen from the Earth, the discussion here serves as the physical basis to investigate the other stars. Sun Earth Mass (1024 kg) 1,989,100. GM (x 106 km3/s2) 132,712. Volume (1012 km3) 1,412,000. Volumetric mean radius (km) 696,000. Mean density (kg/m3) 1408. Surface gravity (eq.) (m/s2) 274. Escape velocity (km/s) 617.7 Ellipticity 0.00005 2 Moment of inertia (I/MR ) 0.059 Visual magnitude V -26.74 Absolute magnitude +4.83 24 Luminosity (10 J/s) 384.6 Mass conversion rate (106 kg/s) 4300. Mean energy production (10-3 J/kg) 0.1937 6 2 Surface emission (10 J/m s) 63.29 Spectral type G2 V Model values at center of Sun: Central pressure: Central temperature: Central density: (Sun/Earth) 5.9736 333,000. 0.3986 333,000. 1.083 1,304,000. 6371. 109.2 5515. 0.255 9.78 28.0 11.2 55.2 0.0034 0.015 0.3308 0.178 -3.86 2.477 x 1011 bar 1.571 x 107 K 1.622 x 105 kg/m3 The Structure of the Sun The average density of the Sun is only 1400 kg/m 3 - consistent with a composition of mostly gaseous hydrogen and helium. From its angular size of about 0.5° and its distance of almost 150 million kilometres, we determine that its diameter is 1,392,000 kilometres (109 Earth diameters and almost 10 times the size of the largest planet, Jupiter). All of the planets orbit the Sun because of its enormous gravity. It has about 333,000 times the Earth's mass and is over 1,000 times as massive as Jupiter. The Sun is made of 94% Hydrogen, 6% Helium, - the other elements make up just 0.13% (the three most abundant ‘metals’ Oxygen, Carbon, and Nitrogen make up 0.11%). PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 29 The Sun’s atmosphere has the following layers (from innermost to outermost): o The photosphere is about 300 km thick. Most of the Sun's visible light that we see originates from this region. o The chromosphere is about 2000 km thick. We only see this layer and the other outer layers during an eclipse. o The corona extends outwards for more than a solar radius. The Photosphere An image of the Sun's Photosphere shows: Limb Darkening. Limb darkening is evidence that the temperature of the Sun's photosphere decreases outwards. Sunspots The Sun's Spectrum is an Absorption Spectrum Since the photosphere is cooler and less dense than the interior region it allows the continuous blackbody spectrum to flow through it. Only at the wavelengths at which atoms in the photosphere can absorb light will photons be impeded in their outward travel. Sunspots: Sunspots are regions with high magnetic fields (1000 x higher magnetic field than average) Typical size of spots is similar to the size of the Earth. These regions are cooler (redder) than average, so they look darker than the surrounding hotter region. Sunspots are related to X-ray flares, mass ejections and the aurora seen on earth PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 30 . Close-up Picture of a group of Sunspots The darkest regions (umbra) have the largest magnetic fields and the coolest temperatures. The outer brighter region is the penumbra. Sunspots come in pairs: each member of the pair has opposite polarity. (I.e. one is a north magnetic pole, the other is south.) Each sunspot region lasts for a few days to a few weeks. The filaments in the penumbra are due to the magnetic lines of force. Movement of Sunspots Movements of spots reveal that the Sun rotates with a period close to one month. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 31 Equator rotates faster than the higher lattitudes. Differential Rotation You can find photos of the Sun in many different wavelengths (updated daily) at the website: http://umbra.nascom.nasa.gov/images/latest.html http://science.nasa.gov/ssl/pad/solar/surface.htm Granules Close-up Picture of the Photosphere Granules are the cell-like features seen on the Sun's photosphere that cover the entire solar surface, except for the sunspot regions.. The granules are the tops of convective cells which lie in the convective zone just below the photosphere. Each cell ranges in size from 100 km to 1000 km across and may last up to half an hour. The bright regions are zones where hot gas rises. They are the tops of deep gas columns where energy is transported by convection. Spectra of the centers of the granules shows these regions to be a few hundred Kelvin hotter than the surrounding darker lanes. The dark borders are the places where the cool gas sinks. The gas moves outwards or inwards at speeds up to 7 km/s. (Measured through Doppler shifts.). The Sun's Chromosphere A Solar Eclipse The photosphere is much brighter than the outer parts of the Sun's atmosphere (the chromosphere and the corona), so regular photos of the Sun do not show the outer atmosphere. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 32 During a solar eclipse the Moon blocks out the light from the photosphere and we can only see the light coming from the chromosphere and corona. The Chromosphere with a close-up of the spicules. The Chromosphere is not exactly a sphere: there are many spicules and prominences which jut outwards. Magnetic fields help support the spicules and the prominences. The red colour results from the emission of Balmer-alpha photons: electrons jumping from the n=3 level to the n=2 level. The emission lines can only occur if the gas in the chromosphere is very hot and the density is very low. The chromosphere is hotter (but less dense) than the photosphere. In the spicules, which are best observed in H , gas is rising at about 20 to 25 km/s. Although spicules occupy less than 1% of the Sun’s surface area and have lifetimes of 15 minutes or less, they probably play a significant role in the mass balance of the chromosphere, corona, and solar wind, and occur in regions of enhanced magnetic fields Solar spicules, short-lived narrow jets of gas that typically last mere minutes, can be seen sprouting up from the solar chromosphere in this H alpha image of the Sun. The spicules are the thin, dark, spikelike regions. They appear dark against the face of the Sun because they are cooler than the solar photosphere PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 33 Prominences Close-up picture of the chromosphere showing a prominence. The prominences are loops of gas which arch over sunspot regions. The quiescent prominences are very stable and can last weeks or months. Eruptive Prominences Some of the prominences will erupt, causing gas to be flung outwards. The gas travels outwards about 70,000 km in the course of a few hours. Prominences are more likely to erupt when the magnetic fields near the sunspots are changing. Variation of Temperature in the Sun's Atmosphere: Photosphere: Temperature decreases outwards. o At bottom: T = 6400 K PH507 Astrophysics o Professor Michael Smith 34 At top: T = 4000 K Chromosphere: Temperature increases outwards. o At top: T = 10,000 K Transition Zone: Temperature shoots up to near 1 million K Corona: Temperatures increase to about 2 million K The source of this heat is not well understood. Current theories suggest that magnetic waves might transport energy from the convective zone to the corona. The Transition Zone The next picture shows the transition zone as seen through a filter which only sees the light coming from an electronic transition of Sulfur VI at temperatures of about 200,000ºC. Instead of hydrogen, the light emitted by the transition region is dominated by such ions as C IV, O IV, and Si IV (carbon, oxygen, and silicon each with three electrons stripped off). These ions emit light in the ultraviolet region of the solar spectrum that is only accessible from space. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 35 These emission lines are Ultra-violet. which are only possible when the gas is very hot, near 100,000 K. The structures seen here are similar to those seen in the chromosphere. The Corona A visible light photograph of the Corona during a solar eclipse. Photograph of the solar corona during the July, 1991 eclipse, at the peak of the sunspot cycle. At these times, the corona is much less regular and much more extended than at sunspot minimum. Astronomers believe that coronal heating is caused by surface activity on the Sun. The changing shape and size of the corona are the direct result of variations in prominence and flare activity over the course of the solar cycle. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 36 The Corona emits X-rays. This image corresponds to an electronic transition of highly ionized iron. (Iron stripped of 11 of its electrons.) Iron can only lose 11 electrons and emit this X-ray light if the temperature is more than one million K. The dark regions are coronal holes which are lower density than average. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 37 The solar wind originates from the coronal holes. Coronal Loops Huge numbers of small, closely intertwined magnetic loops continuously emerge from the Sun's visible surface, clash with one another and dissolve within 40 hours. The loops seem to form a tight pattern that form a magnetic carpet. Their interaction generates electrical and magnetic short-circuits (magnetic reconnection) and releases enough energy to heat the corona to temperatures hundreds of times higher than those of the solar surface. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 38 Coronal loops come in a variety of shapes and sizes, but most are enormous, capable of spanning several Earth's. (Photo: NASA and the TRACE team) Solar Flares Solar flares are large outbursts similar to eruptive prominences, but larger and more energetic. Solar flares increase the amount of particles which escape into the solar wind. If the particles ejected from the flare hit the Earth, then we get intense auroral displays. A negative effect is that the solar wind particles can disrupt radio transmissions. Coronal Mass Ejection When an eruptive prominence or a solar flare occurs, a coronal mass ejection (CME) can also take place. A CME is a stream of plasma (charged particles) ejected from the corona. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 39 The Solar Wind UV images show the flow of gas from the Sun. The solar wind is a stream of charged particles (protons and electrons) which flow outwards from the coronal holes. PH507 Astrophysics Professor Michael Smith 40 The wind speed is high (800 km/s) over coronal holes and low (300 km/s) over streamers. These high and low speed streams interact with each other and alternately pass by the Earth as the Sun rotates. The solar wind particles flow throughout the solar system. The variations buffet the Earth's magnetic field and can produce storms in the Earth's magnetosphere THE END