PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 1 CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISM PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-PDD) Version 02 - in effect as of: 1 July 2004) CONTENTS A. General description of project activity B. Application of a baseline methodology C. Duration of the project activity / Crediting period D. Application of a monitoring methodology and plan E. Estimation of GHG emissions by sources F. Environmental impacts G. Stakeholders’ comments Annexes Annex 1: Contact information on participants in the project activity Annex 2: Information regarding public funding Annex 3: Baseline information Annex 4: Monitoring plan Annex 5: List of Abbreviations Annex 6: List of References This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 2 SECTION A. General description of project activity A.1 Title of the project activity: >> GHG emission reduction through the installation of energy efficient vacuum creating system in the vacuum distillation column of petroleum refinery Version No.: 01 Date: 03-03-2006 A.2. Description of the project activity: >> Purpose The main objective of the project activity is to optimize steam utilization in the vacuum distillation column of the Vacuum Distillation Unit (VDU) of the petroleum refinery of Essar Oil Limited through installation of an energy efficient vacuum creating system. This energy efficient vacuum creating system will result in lower energy consumption than the steam jet ejector system which is traditionally used for generating vacuum in the vacuum distillation column. The net energy savings in terms of reduced refinery fuel consumption achieved through this project activity will contribute to reduced GHG emissions from the refinery. Salient Features: The present system of creating vacuum in vacuum distillation column of petroleum refinery (as per the original design): The present system as adopted by EOL (the project proponent) for creating vacuum in vacuum distillation column is the use of steam-jet ejector system. The vacuum distillation column of EOL is originally designed with steam-jet ejector which maintains a vacuum of 12 mm of Hg in the column. Steam-jet ejector uses steam as a motive fluid and use steam flow through a convergent-divergent nozzle to create vacuum. Steam-jet ejector system entails high amount of motive steam as well as cooling water requirement for the inter stage condensers. Project activity for energy efficiency improvement: The project activity will involve re-engineering of the originally designed vacuum creating system by installation of a higher energy efficient vacuum creating system viz. Vacuum Hydrocirculating (VHC) system through retro-fitment. VHC system would replace the steam-jet ejector system in vacuum This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 3 distillation column. VHC technology uses one of the process streams (like diesel or vacuum gas oil) as the motive fluid which is re-circulated in a closed loop. In absence of the project activity, the project proponent would be continuing with the originally designed steam –jet ejector system as vacuum creating device in the vacuum distillation column of the refinery. This VHC unit will result in lower overall energy consumption (due to reduced steam and cooling water requirement) compared to the conventional steam-jet ejector system. Thus, the project activity will contribute to reduced GHG emissions due to lower energy consumption than the baseline scenario. The net impact of this project activity will be the reduction of 136274.8 tCO2 per annum which in absence of the project activity would have been emitted for meeting energy requirement for the conventional steam-jet ejector system. Project’s Contribution to Sustainable Development The project activity’s contribution to “Sustainable Development of India” is discussed under the three pillars of sustainable development: Social well-being: By creating a demand for some skilled jobs for the construction of the unit as well as operation and the maintenance of the installed equipments, the project activity has the potential to generate both direct as well as indirect employment. The skill set of the people will be enhanced with a pioneering technology transfer process. The project activity may also help to create a business opportunity for local stakeholders such as bankers / consultants, suppliers / manufacturers, contractors etc. Economic well-being: Through lower fossil fuel consumption for the process, the project activity will contribute to the conservation of non-renewable natural resources like petroleum oil. Moreover, the project activity will increase productivity of the process through reduced energy consumption. Environmental well-being: The project activity will ultimately result in the reduction of fuel oil consumption for energy generation. Thus emissions of CO2 and other pollutants like NOx associated with the combustion of fuel oil will be greatly reduced. Technological well-being: The proposed technology for the project activity is the first of its kind in India and the proprietary right of the technology lies only with the foreign technology licensor. A vital part of the project activity will be to impart proper technical and managerial training to the managerial and operational staffs of the refinery for proper functioning of the system. An intensive in-house knowledge base should be developed to build up scientific and technical expertise for running the new This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 4 vacuum creating system. Adoption of this novel technology will also help in capacity building of employees by better exposure to modern technological development in refining industry. Moreover, this technology can be replicated to other petroleum refineries in India leading to higher reduction of GHG emissions. A.3. Project Participants: >> Name of the Party Private and/or public entity(ies) involved Project participants (as applicable) ((host) indicates a host party) Government of India Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) (Host) A.4. Essar Oil Limited - EOL is a public limited company Kindly indicate if the Party involved wishes to be considered as project participant (Yes/No) No Technical description of the project activity: A.4.1. >> India Location of the project activity: A.4.1.1. Host Party(ies): >> India A.4.1.2. Region/State/Province etc.: >> Gujarat A.4.1.3. City/Town/Community etc: >> Vadinar, Jamnagar A.4.1.4. Detail of physical location, including information allowing the unique identification of this project activity (maximum one page): The project activity has been implemented in the greenfield refinery of EOL, located on the west coast of India at Vadinar, Gujarat .The refinery site is around 40 kms from Jamnagar city and is connected with other places through well-established network of railway, state highway and port. The site is connected This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 5 to the Kandla-Bhatinda petroleum product pipeline, providing the project proponent an easy access to the key markets of the north India and other potential markets of petroleum products the proposed central India pipeline will transport its products to the western and central parts of India cost-effectively. Vadiner port allows the low-cost coastal movement of products to the Eastern and Southern parts of India. Moreover, the nearby location of the port also provides substantial advantage to EOL in terms of import of crude oil. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 6 Khambalia Post Vadinar Map not to scale This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 7 A.4.2. Category(ies) of project activity: >> The project activity is steam optimization project in petroleum refinery where aggregate energy savings of the project exceeds the equivalent of 15 GWh per annum. The baseline and monitoring methodology has been adopted as per approved methodology AM0018. The project activity may principally be categorized in Category 3- Energy demand according to the scope of the project activities enlisted in the ‘list of sectoral scopes and approved baseline and monitoring methodologies’ on the UNFCCC website for accreditation of Designated Operational Entities1. A.4.3. Technology to be employed by the project activity: >> VHC unit consists of four major components – jet type vacuum creating device, centrifugal pump, separator and cooler. In this system one of the process liquid streams (e.g. diesel or vacuum gas oil) which meets the requirement of physical and chemical characteristics can be used as motive liquid. Motive liquid is delivered to the jet vacuum creating device (referred to as J-1 in the diagram describing project boundary) with the help of the pump (referred to as P-1 in the diagram describing project boundary) The suction gas from the process unit i.e. the vacuum distillation column goes to the jet vacuum creating device J-1 inlet where it is compressed up-to the design pressure due to high energy of the motive liquid stream and convergent-divergent design of the vacuum creating device. The continuous suction from the vacuum distillation column creates and maintains the desired vacuum at the column. The liquid gas mixture generated at J-1 goes to the separator device (referred to as S-1 in the diagram describing project boundary) where the separation of gaseous and liquid phase takes place. The gas compressed to the design pressure is discharged from the system for further utilization. The motive liquid thus recovered is cooled in the cooler device (referred to as C-1 in the diagram describing project boundary) and re-circulated into the system through P-1. At the inlet of P-1 arrangement is made for fresh motive liquid for the fill-up and motive liquid renovation. Excess motive liquid is discharged from the VHC unit and finds its utilization as product stream. (Refer to the diagram provided in the description of the project boundary in section B.4). The technology to be employed under the project activity for installation of this energy efficient vacuum creating device is developed by M/s TECHNOVACUUM of Russia. This project concept for energy efficiency as developed by M/s TECHNOVACUUM is a very innovative and crystallized after technical 1 http://cdm.unfccc.int/DOE/scopes.html This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 8 analysis of process profile for a long time. The technology is pioneering and first of its kind in India for which the technology partner is M/s TECHNOVACUUM of Russia. A.4.4. Brief explanation of how the anthropogenic emissions of anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHGs) by sources are to be reduced by the proposed CDM project activity, including why the emission reductions would not occur in the absence of the proposed project activity, taking into account national and/or sectoral policies and circumstances: >> Without this project, EOL would continue to generate additional steam (3.5 kg/cm2(g) Low Pressure steam) of approximately 56 MT /hr which would have been required for the steam-jet ejector system with which the vacuum distillation column is originally designed. This project activity would reduce steam consumption in the process and thus lower the firing of refinery fuel in the boilers for generating equivalent amount of steam. Reduction in the consumption of refinery fuel would lead to a reduction in GHG emissions from the baseline scenario. Perceived technical and financial risks to petroleum refining industry in adopting innovative as well as unproved energy saving technologies are very high in India because of complexity of the refining technology and inter-dependence of the individual processes. Any failure of the project activity may upset the overall refinery process leading to shutdown of some other downstream units thereby resulting in associated production loss. Moreover, fear that a new technology might be unreliable inhibits industry from adopting new energy saving technologies. Despite these inhibiting factors, it is commendable that EOL has taken up the initiative in adopting this innovative technology for the first time in India. With success of this project the replication potential of this technology would be widened since the same can be adopted by other petroleum refineries in India. A.4.4.1. Estimated amount of emission reductions over the chosen crediting period: >> This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 9 Years 2007-08 Annual estimation of Emission Reductions in tonnes of CO2 e 136274.8 2008-09 136274.8 2009-10 136274.8 2010-11 136274.8 2011-12 136274.8 2012-13 136274.8 2013-14 136274.8 2014-15 136274.8 2015-16 136274.8 2016-17 136274.8 Total estimated reductions (tonnes of CO2 e) 1362748 Total number of crediting years 10 Annual average over the crediting period of estimated reductions 136274.8 (tonnes of CO2 e) A.4.5. Public funding of the project activity: >> No public funding from parties included in Annex I is available to this project. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 10 SECTION B. Application of a baseline methodology B.1. Title and reference of the approved baseline methodology applied to the project activity: >> Title: Baseline methodology for steam optimization systems Reference: AM00018, website: http://:www.unfccc.int B.1.1. Justification of the choice of the methodology and why it is applicable to the project activity: >> As per the Kyoto Protocol (KP) baseline should be in accordance with the additionality criteria of article 12, paragraph 5(c), which states that the project activity must reduce emissions that are additional to any that, would occur in the absence of the certified project activity. Justification for why is the baseline methodology applicable to project activity. The project is about optimization of steam utilization in one of the petroleum refining processes. Under the project activity, the system in use would be replaced by the new system. Therefore, the emission would be compared with the historical emission. The applicability criteria laid down by the approved methodology AM0018, therefore are suitable for demonstration of additionality, selection of baseline and quantification of emission reductions from the project activity. As per the applicability criteria of AM0018:“This methodology is applicable to steam optimization projects in production processes with homogeneous and relatively constant outputs with continuous monitoring of steam output.” The project activity will involve installation of VHC system in the vacuum distillation column of the refinery of EOL. The project activity optimizes the steam utilization in the vacuum distillation column of the refinery. ‘Outputs’ (which is the mm Hg of vacuum generated by the vacuum creating system) will remain constant and homogeneous. Also, the steam output from the boiler will be continuously monitored. Moreover, as per AM0018, the steam must have some use inside the plant premise. In this case, the steam in the baseline scenario is determined to be used for vacuum generation through steam jet ejector system. Both the scenarios before and after the implementation of the project activity are as follows: This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 11 Scenario 1 Non-project option: In the business-as-usual scenario, EOL would continue to consume energy and emit CO2 for generating steam which would be used in the steam-jet ejector system with which the vacuum distillation column is originally designed. Scenario 2 CDM Project option: In the project activity scenario, new energy efficient ejector system would be in place, resulting in lower energy consumption in the system thereby leading to reduction in CO2 emissions. There is a direct comparison of emissions available with the project proponent based on the real time data. Before implementation of the project activity the facility would be emitting the additional CO2 due to combustion of refinery fuel in the boiler for generation of additional steam to be used in steam-jet ejector of the vacuum distillation column. Moreover, the project activity is the first of its kind in Indian petroleum refining industry; therefore any other project activity is not available for comparison. On the basis of this, it can be justified that most suitable baseline methodology for this application would be based on “Existing actual or historical emissions”. B.2. Description of how the methodology is applied in the context of the project activity: >> The methodology uses four-point approach. In this approach, actual data are collected for direct comparison of baseline and project specific steam consumption and thus estimating reduction in CO2 emissions. 1. Baseline Determination: Baseline for the project activity is the existing vacuum creating system viz. steam-jet ejector system the vacuum distillation column is originally designed with. In the after project scenario the VHC system would replace the steam-jet ejector system through retro-fit measure in the vacuum distillation column. 2. Baseline Fixation: Baseline for the project is fixed by calculating specific steam consumption (tph of steam/ mm Hg of vacuum created) in the vacuum creating system of the vacuum distillation column. The vacuum is created through continuous removal of hydrocarbon from the vacuum distillation column. The data required for this calculation would be taken from the data documented in the previous record sheets of VDU running on steam-jet ejector system. The value of “vacuum created” This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 12 used in this context is the average representative value of normal range2 of output3 (vacuum generated) measured in a day. The steam consumption values corresponding to the values of “vacuum created” selected above needs to be identified and the average representative value required to be calculated (refer section-D for details). 3. Estimation of Specific Steam Consumption After Project Implementation: In the project scenario, specific steam consumption (tph of steam/ mm Hg of vacuum created) in the vacuum creating system of the vacuum distillation column is calculated based on the ratio of average representative values of steam consumed (in tph) in the vacuum creating system the and the amount of vacuum created (in mm of Hg) in the vacuum distillation column. The method for estimating representative data of output and steam consumption is same as in case of baseline scenario (refer section D for details). 4. Estimation of Net Increase in Power Consumption after Project Implementation: In the project scenario there would be additional electricity load under operation due to motive liquid circulation pump etc. The net increase in emissions due to additional electrical load is taken into account while estimating emission reductions. In case the unavailability of facility of measurement/recording of actual electrical power consumed by motor, the rated power of motors is taken as fixed load, which is the maximum limit of their consumption. 5. Estimation of Emission Reduction: Total reduction in steam consumption in project scenario is calculated by multiplying the reduction in specific steam consumption by the vacuum created in the project scenario. The reduction in emission is calculated by estimating the fuel required for the generation of additional steam in the boiler and deducting from it the emissions due to additional electrical loads to be operated under the project activity. The efficiency of the boiler, net enthalpy of steam will be monitored to estimate the saving in refinery fuel at the boiler end. 2 Normal range is the range in which the plant output takes place most of the time. It is 95% confidence interval. This is based on the rated plant capacity and internally acceptable deviations ( 5% of rated plant capacity). 3 Output here is defined as the main outcome of process/system for which process/system is designed and where the steam generated by using fossil fuel is utilized. Therefore, in case of EOL, output of the process is the quantity of CO2 produced per hour (in kg or Tons) and accounted through the monitoring system. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 13 B.3. Description of how the anthropogenic emissions of GHG by sources are reduced below those that would have occurred in the absence of the registered CDM project activity: >> As per the decision 17/cp.7 Para 43, a CDM project activity is additional if anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases by sources are reduced below those that would have occurred in absence of the registered CDM project activity. The proposed project activity is energy efficiency improvement activity and results into net reduction in CO2 emissions of facility. Following steps of additionality test are followed with respect to the steam optimisation project of EOL for demonstration of additionality Step 0. Preliminary screening of projects started after 1 January 2000 and prior to 31 December 2005 The procurement for the project started after 1 January 2000. The project will be commissioned in July 2007. The CDM fund was seriously being considered before starting the planning of the project. There are sufficient evidences available in the form of documentation that shows that the CDM incentive played an important role in the decision-making. Following are the evidences available: 1. Approval from the top-management for investing in the project activity Step 1: Identification of alternatives to the project activity (steam optimisation project) consistent with current laws and regulations Define realistic and credible alternative scenarios to the CDM project activity that can be (part of) the baseline scenario through the following sub-steps: Sub-step 1a. Define alternatives to the project activity: The alternatives to the proposed project activity are following, which also has potential of substantial energy savings. Alternative 1 Non-project option: In the business-as-usual scenario, EOL would continue to consume steam for vacuum generation through the steam-jet ejector system. Alternative 2 CDM Project option: In the project activity scenario, new energy efficient ejector system i.e. VHC system will be in place, resulting in lower steam consumption in the system thereby leading to reduction in CO2 emissions. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 14 Sub-step 1b. Enforcement with applicable laws and regulations: For steam optimisation projects, there is no legal mandate applicable for the project proponent. But the project complies with all good and safe engineering practices. Step 2. Investment Analysis EOL does not follow this step to demonstrate additionality of the project activity, but follows step-3 for barrier analysis. Step 3. Barrier Analysis If this step is used, determine whether the proposed project activity faces barriers that: (a) Prevent a wide spread implementation of this activity and thus preventing the baseline scenarios from occurring; and (b) Do not prevent a wide spread implementation of at least one of the alternatives. Use the following sub-steps: Sub-step 3a. Identify barriers that would prevent a wide spread implementation of the proposed project activity: Following are the barriers that would prevent the proposed project activity from being implemented if the project was not registered as a CDM activity. Barrier due to prevailing practice: The project is not the prevailing practice in petroleum refining industry in India (and even other countries) with similar technologies. Therefore EOL lacks the familiarity with such project. The internal documents are available regarding risks associated with the project activity implementation and operation. The project is the “first of a kind” The project activity is the ‘first of its own kind’ in the Indian petroleum refining industry. The energy efficient technology is imported from M/s TECHNOVACUUM who is the leader in the development of vacuum hydrocirculating (VHC) system. This state-of-the-art technology is new to Indian refining industry and would be achieved and implemented for the very first time for a petroleum refinery in India. M/s TECHNOVACUUM has selective credentials primarily in Russian petroleum refineries. EOL has taken substantial efforts and also decided to bear all the technical as well as operational risks in implementing the project activity. Since the technology is new and an ejector system is of critical This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 15 importance in the vacuum distillation column of a refinery the failure of the ejector system may severely affect the operation of the column. Although the reliability of VHC system has not yet been established in Indian petroleum refining industry, EOL has decided to cross the associated barriers and go ahead with the CDM project activity. Success of this project activity would generate good replication potential across the petroleum refining industry, particularly where M/s TECHNOVACUUM is pursuing to supply the technology. Therefore it would ensure that greater amount of CO2 emission reduction will take place across the globe wherein this technology would be successfully applied. The high risk of the new technology therefore prevents widespread implementation of the project activity. Technological barriers Since the implementation of VHC system is entirely new in India, the risks associated with the unforeseen circumstances are not yet fully perceived. The technical people of EOL are not trained in handling the operational risks. Some of the potential technical and operational risks identified by the project proponent are as follows: 1. In all the petroleum refineries in India operation of steam jet ejector for creating vacuum in the vacuum distillation column is a common as well as a favourable practice due to the high reliability of conventional ejector system. This is because of the fact that during power failure in a refinery the supply of LP steam would continue since the turbine by-pass valve will open facilitating let down of HHP steam to LP level through Pressure Reducing and De-superheating Station (PRDS). This can keep the steam-jet ejector running for sometime to allow for smooth shutdown of the unit. However, in the vacuum hydrocirculating (VHC) system the motive liquid, which is nothing but one of the product streams of vacuum distillation column, would be circulated through electricity driven pumps. Therefore, power failure situation in the refinery would bring the VHC system into immediate halt due to tripping of the pump. This situation would tend to destabilize the process parameters of vacuum distillation column and result in deterioration of product quality due to inefficient separation of hydrocarbons. Therefore, from the reliability point of view VHC system is less favourable than the conventional steam-jet ejector system. Furthermore, vacuum distillation column serves as the feed preparation unit for the downstream secondary processing units like Fluidized Catalytic Cracking Unit (FCCU) which uses vacuum gas oil (VGO) as input feedstock. Failure of the VHC system would affect the distillate output from the vacuum distillation column thereby inhibiting the supply of VGO to FCCU. As a consequence the FCCU has to be brought under immediate shut-down which would result in its associated production loss. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 16 2. The motive liquid in the vacuum creating device of VHC system is one of the process streams that meets the requirement of the physical and chemical characteristics. The selection of motive liquid for VHC system is a critical parameter because the suction media mixes with the motive liquid and some components of the suction gas is also dissolved in the motive liquid. It is essential to define such motive liquid which can be saturated with the suction gas components without negative consequences for the overall process, e.g. in case of VHC unit the common motive liquid is the petroleum fraction (i.e. diesel or gas oil fraction) that goes into downstream units for reprocessing. However, no such difficulty exists in case of conventional steam-jet ejector system where steam is the motive liquid and acts as a very good solvent for the hydrocarbon fractions. 3. The feed of a vacuum distillation column is heated in a furnace before introducing it to the flash zone of vacuum distillation column. In the furnace usually dilution steam is used to prevent heater coil coking. When steam jet ejector system is in place as a vacuum creating device in the vacuum distillation column the use of steam as dilution medium in the heater coil is favourable. However, if dry vacuum creating system such as VHC is in place in the vacuum distillation column, usually steam is not preferred be used in the heater coil of the furnace. Therefore, installation of VHC system increases the chance of choking in the heater coil of the furnace which is placed in the upstream of the vacuum distillation column. 4. The conventional steam-jet ejector system uses steam as the motive liquid and steam is the cheapest utility in the refinery. Sacrificing this system with the new VHC system where one of the hydrocarbon product streams acts as motive liquid would add to the operational cost of the unit. Other Barriers: Lack of adequate experience about the operation of VHC system: The technology supplier for the project activity i.e. M/s TECHNOVACUUM is a Russian agency who has the credentials for implementing VHC system mostly in the Russian refineries only. Therefore, the international technology licensors of the major process units of EOL refinery are apprehensive about the reliability of operation of VHC system and the compatibility of VHC system with the major process units of the refinery. This is quite evident from a communication with IFP France which is the technology supplier for Diesel Hydro-desulphurization (DHDS) unit for EOL. The essence of the communication is given below: EOL management thought of installing VHC system in the DHDS unit and regarding that they had invited the opinion of IFP France. However, IFP France expressed their concern about the reliability of such a vacuum creating system with which they do not have any prior experience at all and they declared that they would not shoulder the risk of any adverse effect on the performance of DHDS if this new This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 17 vacuum creating system is installed in the DHDS unit. IFP France which is a world renowned technology supplier in petroleum and petrochemical industry showed their strong confidence on the higher reliability of conventional steam-jet ejector as vacuum creating system. The similar risk issues pertaining to the reliability of the VHC system would be relevant for installation of VHC system in VDU as well. In-spite of all these barriers EOL would implement the project activity considering the GHG emission reduction potential of the new vacuum creating system. Sub-step 3 b. Show that the identified barriers would not prevent a wide spread implementation of at least one of the alternatives (excepted the proposed project activity already considered in step 3a): The alternative of VHC system (i.e. conventional steam-jet ejector system) is relatively more common practices, more reliable and less risky, as it is proven across the world as well as in the Indian petroleum refining sector. The same was considered earlier, however not taken up as CDM project activity as this project alternative does not contribute to GHG emission reductions. The barriers as mentioned above do not prevent the wide spread implementation of the project alternative. Step 4. Common Practice Analysis Sub-step 4a. Analyse other activities similar to the proposed project: There is no activity similar to the proposed project activity in India, as evident from the letter of the technology supplier. Sub-step 4b. Discuss any similar options that are occurring: Not applicable Step 5. Impact of CDM Registration As stated earlier, during the conceptualization of the proposed CDM project activity the potential CDM revenue that would flow to the project activity had been seriously considered. Following impacts of CDM fund are identified from the point of view of mitigation of risks and barriers discussed above. CDM fund will provide additional coverage to the risks associated with the project activity and help in mitigating the other technical risk factors as mentioned above. CDM funds will provide the training support to EOL employees in understanding operational accuracies and troubleshooting measures during operational problems. The fund will stimulate R&D efforts in EOL to find methods of mitigating risks and enhance replication of such energy efficiency projects or process optimization schemes in petroleum refining industry, to promote GHG abatement. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 18 B.4. Description of how the definition of the project boundary related to the baseline methodology selected is applied to the project activity: >> Project Boundaries As per definition of project boundary as given in glossary of terms, “it will encompass all anthropogenic emissions by sources of Green House Gases (GHGs) under the control of project participants that are significant and reasonably attributable to the CDM project activity.” Based on the definition, the project boundary covers the new vacuum hydrocirculating system installed in the vacuum distillation column. The following components VHC system would be covered in project boundary. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 19 PROJECT BOUNDARY Suction gas J-1 Compressed gas to further utilization S-1 Motive liquid excess Make-up motive liquid C-1 P-1 VHC Project System Boundary Electricity supply source Steam generation source This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 20 Jet vacuum creating device J-1 The motive liquid circulating pump P-1 The separator S-1 which separates gaseous and liquid phases The cooler C-1 Boiler for steam generation The actual baseline CO2 emissions take place in the main steam generation boiler. Electricity supply source The source of electricity (i.e. turbo-generator) is the part of project boundary. B.5. Details of baseline information, including the date of completion of the baseline study and the name of person (s)/entity (ies) determining the baseline: >> Date of completing the final draft of this baseline section: 01/2005 Name of person/entity determining the baseline: EOL is the project participant. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 21 SECTION C. Duration of the project activity / Crediting period C.1 Duration of the project activity: C.1.1. Starting date of the project activity: >> May 2007. C.1.2. Expected operational lifetime of the project activity: >> Expected lifetime: 20 years C.2 Choice of the crediting period and related information: C.2.1. Renewable crediting period C.2.1.1. Starting date of the first crediting period: C.2.1.2. Length of the first crediting period: >> Not opted >> Not opted C.2.2. Fixed crediting period: C.2.2.1. Starting date: C.2.2.2. Length: >> 01/07/2007 >> 10 years This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 22 SECTION D. Application of a monitoring methodology and plan D.1. Name and reference of approved monitoring methodology applied to the project activity: >> Title: Monitoring methodology for steam optimization systems Reference: AM0018, UNFCCC website D.2. Justification of the choice of the methodology and why it is applicable to the project activity: >> The PDD is prepared in line with the approved methodology AM0018. As per approved monitoring methodology, the CO2 emission of proposed CDM project activities is monitored. The baseline is fixed on the basis of historical emissions. As indicated earlier, the CO2 emission baseline of non-project scenario is fixed in terms of steam consumption / mm Hg of vacuum created in the vacuum distillation column with steam-jet ejector as vacuum creating system and emission due to fuel combustion in boiler to generate equivalent amount of steam. The monitoring is done for the retrofits in the plant. The monitoring of project activity is in line with approved monitoring methodology. Approved monitoring methodology covers all the data variables used in the calculation of emission reduction. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 23 D.2. 1. Option 1: Monitoring of the emissions in the project scenario and the baseline scenario D.2.1.1. Data to be collected in order to monitor emissions from the project activity, and how this data will be archived: ID number Data Source of Data unit Measured (Please use variable Data (m), numbers to calculated (c) ease crossor estimated referencing (e) to D.3) Parameters related to specific steam consumption ration (SSCR) D.2.1.1 Output rate Vacuum mm Hg Measured created by every shift VHC system D.2.1.2 Steam rate D.2.1.3 Additional electricity consumption flow LP Steam flow tph to VHC system kWh Electricity consumption in the motive liquid circulation Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + years Measured every Every Shift shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured every shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Every Shift This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. Comment 2 Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of pressure gauge and will be recorded shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be recorded shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of energy meter and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) Data variable page 24 Source of Data Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? calibrated agency. pumps of VHC unit Parameters related to steam enthalpy D.2.1.4 Steam Temperature of Degree C temperature LP steam to VHC system Measured every Every Shift shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years D.2.1.5 Steam pressure Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years D.2.1.6 Feed water Boiler F.W. Deg C temperature temperature per shift Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years D.2.1.7 Feed flow Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 Pressure of LP Kg/cm2(g) steam to VHC system water Boiler F.W tph flow per shift Comment This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. by accredited Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of pressure gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) Data variable page 25 Source of Data Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Parameters related to determination of Boiler efficiency by Direct Method Measured D.2.1.8 Steam High High tph generation of pressure (HHP) boiler Steam generation in the boiler equivalent to LP steam utilization in the steam-jet ejector system Measured D.2.1.9 Fuel Fuel Flow for tph consumption refinery fuel used in the boiler equivalent to the LP steam used in steamjet ejector system Fuel related parameters Measured D.2.1.10 Net calorific Gross and kcal/kg Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Comment years accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be monitored shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Every shift Total Electronic/Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be monitored shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Electronic/ Crediting Measured With every Total This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. by laboratory PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) page 26 Data variable Source of Data value of fuel Net Calorific value of refinery fuel used in the boiler Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Other parameters D.2.1.11 Boiler efficiency Boiler efficiency % Estimated D.2.1.12 Retrofit Event - Measured D.2.1.13 Cooling water consumption Cooling water consumption in the steamjet ejector system m3/hr Measured Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Comment delivery of fuel. (Refer guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) Paper Period + 2 years analysis Total Monthly (Refer guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) As and Total when occurs. As and Total when occurs. Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Direct efficiency of boiler is to be estimated..(Refer to the methodology for guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Crediting Period + 2 years Follow Retrofit Monitoring Test as given in this methodology Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Electronic/ Paper This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 27 D.2.1.2. Description of formulae used to estimate project emissions (for each gas, source, formulae/algorithm, emissions units of CO2 equ.) >> 1. Emissions due to internal steam Consumption in VHC system The source of greenhouse gas emissions in the project activity is due to steam consumption in the VHC system resulting in CO2 emissions from refinery fuel fired in the service boiler for generating steam. Step-1: Estimate vacuum generated by the VHC system (Output of the system) Vacuum generated by the VHC system will be measured by the column-top pressure of the vacuum distillation column. Step-2: Estimate Representative Value of vacuum generated by VHC system Based upon capacity of the VHC system all values of vacuum generated (P1, P2, P3 etc.) under normal range of plant capacity to be measured and averaged out to find the representative value denoted as Prep Step-3: Estimate steam consumption for representative output values The steam consumption (consumption per shift) values corresponding to representative vacuum generation values are selected and the average of the same is calculated. Sr = (S1+S2+….Sn)/n S1…Sn = Values of steam consumption per hr (tph). S r = Representative steam consumption for the day (corresponding to representative production of the day) This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 28 No. operating hours per day = n Step-4: Calculate Specific Steam Consumption (tph/mm Hg vacuum) The steam consumption values corresponding to vacuum generated stated above, to be identified and average representative value (Sr) to be worked out. Ss = Sr / Prep Where, Ss = Specific Steam Consumption (tph/mm Hg vacuum generated) Sr = Representative Steam Consumption Rate (tph) Step – 5: Net Reduction in specific steam consumption (tph/ mm Hg of vacuum created) Sr1 = Ss1-Ss Where: Sr1 = Net Reduction in specific steam consumption (tph/mm Hg of vacuum created) Ss1 = Specific steam consumption in baseline scenario (tph/mm Hg vacuum created) Ss = Specific Steam Consumption in project scenario (tph/mm Hg vacuum created) Step – 6: Calculate reduction in hourly steam consumption due to project activity (tph) Snet = Sr1 x PVHC Where: Snet = Net reduction in steam due to project activity (tph) Sr1 = Net Reduction in specific steam consumption (tph/mm Hg vacuum created) PVHC= actual value of vacuum created by VHC system (mm Hg vacuum created) Step 7: Estimate the net daily reduction in energy due to reduction in steam consumption: Enet = Snet x Es This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board Enet = Net reduction in steam energy consumption per hour (kCal/hr) Snet = Net reduction in steam consumption per day (tph) Es = Net enthalpy of steam being supplied in boiler (kCal/tonnes). Es = Etot - Efw Es = Net enthalpy of steam being supplied in boiler (kCal/tonnes). (To be monitored) Etot = Total enthalpy of steam at the boiler outlet (kCal/tonnes) Efw = Heat content of feed water (kCal/tonnes) Step 8: Estimate daily reduction in input energy to the boiler Ein = Enet/ b Where, Ein = Net reduction in energy input in boiler Enet = Net reduction in steam energy consumption per hour (kCal/tonnes) b= Efficiency of boiler, to be monitored periodically by direct or indirect method (as specified in the methodology). Step-9: Calculate CO2 emissions reduction (tph) Ce1 = (Ein / NCV of fuel used)*(C% of fuel used)*44/12 Where Ce1 = CO2 emissions reduction per day due to fuel combustion in boiler to produce steam required for VHC system (tph) This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. page 29 PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 30 Ein = Net reduction in energy input in the boiler 2. Net effect on Emissions due to Electrical Energy Consumption The emission is resulted due to additional operation of motive liquid circulation pump. Net increase in emissions due to change of operation of motors, the formulae used are as follows. Step-1: Estimate net increase in electrical energy consumption (KWH) The net increase in electrical energy consumption in the VHC system compared to the steam-jet ejector system (considering the electrical loads in motive liquid circulation pump, cooling water circulation pump, cooling water fan etc.) is denoted by En En = En1 – En2 En1 = Electrical energy consumption of VHC system (kWh) En2 = Electrical energy consumption of steam-jet ejector (kWh) Step-2 : Calculate Increase in CO2 emission due combustion of refinery fuel for net increase in power consumption (tph) Ce2 = En x Ff / (1000 x g ) Where Ce2 = Increase in CO2 emission due to increase in power consumption (tph) En = Net effect on energy consumption (GJ/h) Ff = Emission factor of the refinery fuel used for power generation (tonnes / GJ) g = Minimum efficiency of electricity generating system based on historical data (assumed constant) This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 31 D.2.1.3. Relevant data necessary for determining the baseline of anthropogenic emissions by sources of GHGs within the project boundary and how such data will be collected and archived : ID number Data Source of Data unit Measured (Please use variable data (m), numbers to calculated (c) ease crossor estimated referencing (e) to D.3) Parameters related to specific steam consumption ration (SSCR) D.2.3.1 Output rate Vacuum mm Hg Measured created by every shift steam-jet ejector system D.2.3.2 Steam rate D.2.3.3 Electricity consumption flow LP Steam flow tph to steam-jet ejector kWh Electricity consumption in the pumps Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + years Measured every Every Shift shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured every shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Every Shift Parameters related to steam enthalpy This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. Comment 2 Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of pressure gauge and will be recorded shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be recorded shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of energy meter and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) D.2.3.4 page 32 Data variable Source of data Data unit Steam temperature Temperature of Degree C LP steam to steam-jet ejector system D.2.3.5 Steam pressure Pressure of LP Kg/cm2(g) steam to steamjet ejector system D.2.3.6 D.2.3.7 Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Comment Measured every Every Shift shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Feed water Boiler F.W. Deg C temperature temperature per shift Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Feed flow Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of pressure gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be monitored shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. water Boiler F.W tph flow per shift Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Recording frequency Parameters related to determination of Boiler efficiency by Direct Method This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) D.2.3.8 Data variable page 33 Source of data Steam High High generation of pressure (HHP) boiler Steam generation in the boiler equivalent to LP steam utilization in the steam-jet ejector system D.2.3.9 Fuel Fuel Flow for consumption refinery fuel used in the boiler equivalent to the LP steam used in steamjet ejector system Fuel related parameters D.2.3.10 Net calorific Gross and Net Calorific value of fuel value of SRFT used in the boiler Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Comment kg/shift Measured Every Shift Total Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Monitored by steam flow recording meter. For SRFT tph Estimated Total Monthly (Refer guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) Electronic/Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of orifice meter and will be monitored shiftwise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. kcal/kg Measured With every Total delivery of fuel. (Refer guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Measured analysis Other parameters This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. by laboratory PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to D.3) D.2.3.11 page 34 Data variable Source of data Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored Boiler efficiency Boiler efficiency % Estimated D.2.3.12 Retrofit Event - Measured D.2.3.13 Cooling water consumption Cooling water consumption in the steamjet ejector system M3/hr Measured Total Monthly (Refer guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) As and Total when occurs. As and Total when occurs. How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) For how long is archived data to be kept? Comment Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Direct efficiency of boiler is to be estimated.(Refer to the methodology for guidelines on boiler efficiency monitoring) Electronic/ Paper Crediting Period + 2 years Crediting Period + 2 years Follow Retrofit Monitoring Test as given in this methodology Measured in the plant premises to the best accuracy with the help of temperature gauge and will be monitored shift-wise through DCS. The instrument will be calibrated by accredited agency. Electronic/ Paper D.2.1.4. Description of formulae used to estimate baseline emissions (for each gas, source, formulae/algorithm, emissions units of CO2 equ.) >> The specific steam consumption (in tph) in the steam-jet ejector of vacuum creating system for per mm Hg of vacuum created is derived for base case scenario. This figure of specific steam consumption is used for all future project scenarios to compare the emissions of project scenario and likely emissions of baseline scenario. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 35 Emissions due to steam Consumption in the steam-jet ejector The source of greenhouse gas emissions in the project activity is due to steam consumption in the steam-jet ejector system resulting into CO2 emitted from refinery fuel fired boiler for generating steam. The historical one-month data on shift-wise output of vacuum created is analysed and representative output value (Prep) is calculated. While calculating daily average, the extreme values are segregated from the available values of output rate (shift output). This is because the specific steam consumption in a plant reduces with increased production rates. Based on our experience, the energy-production relationship is not significantly sensitive up to +/-5% of normal rated production. Therefore +/- 5% range is taken as ‘normal production range’ for this purpose. If production fluctuates (from shift to shift) beyond normal production range, these specific values are segregated to derive average production of the day. Similarly steam consumption value corresponding to such production is also segregated. 1. Emissions due to internal steam consumption in the steam-jet ejector system The source of greenhouse gas emissions in the project activity is due to steam consumption in the steam-jet ejector system resulting in CO2 emissions from refinery fuel fired in the boiler for generating steam. Step-1: Estimate vacuum generated by the steam-jet ejector system Vacuum generated by the steam-jet ejector system will be measured by the column-top pressure of the vacuum distillation column. Step-2: Estimate Representative Value of vacuum generated by steam-jet ejector system Based upon capacity of the steam-jet ejector system all values of vacuum created (P1, P2, P3 etc.) under normal range of plant capacity to be measured and averaged out to find out representative value denoted as Prep Step-3: Estimate steam consumption for steam-jet ejector system for representative output values This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 36 The steam consumption (consumption per shift) values corresponding to representative vacuum generation values are selected and the average of the same is calculated. Sr = (S1+S2+….Sn)/n S1…Sn = Values of steam consumption per hr (tph). S r = Representative steam consumption (corresponding to representative output) No. operating hours per day = n Step-4: Calculate Specific Steam Consumption for steam-jet ejector system (tph/mm Hg vacuum) The steam consumption values corresponding to vacuum generated stated above, to be identified and average representative value (Sr) to be worked out. Ss = Sr / Prep Where, Ss = Specific Steam Consumption (tph/mm Hg vacuum generated) Sr = Representative Steam Consumption Rate (tph) D. 2.2. Option 2: Direct monitoring of emission reductions from the project activity (values should be consistent with those in section E). This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 37 D.2.2.1. Data to be collected in order to monitor emissions from the project activity, and how this data will be archived: ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to table D.3) Data variable Source of data Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c), estimated (e), Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) Comment D.2.2.2. Description of formulae used to calculate project emissions (for each gas, source, formulae/algorithm, emissions units of CO2 equ.): >> Not applicable in this case. D.2.3. Treatment of leakage in the monitoring plan D.2.3.1. If applicable, please describe the data and information that will be collected in order to monitor leakage effects of the project activity ID number (Please use numbers to ease crossreferencing to table D.3) Data variable Source of data Data unit Measured (m), calculated (c) or estimated (e) Recording frequency Proportion of data to be monitored How will the data be archived? (electronic/ paper) This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. Comment PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 38 D.2.3.2. Description of formulae used to estimate leakage (for each gas, source, formulae/algorithm, emissions units of CO2 equ.) >> There are no potential significant sources of leakages. D.2.4. Description of formulae used to estimate emission reductions for the project activity (for each gas, source, formulae/algorithm, emissions units of CO2 equ.) >> Emission reduction = Baseline emissions – project activity emissions D.3. ID No. Quality control (QC) and quality assurance (QA) procedures are being undertaken for data monitored Explain QA/QC procedures planned for these data, or why such procedures are not necessary. D.2.1.1 Uncertainty level of data (High/Medium/Low) Low D.2.1.2 Low D.2.1.3 Low The QA procedure needs to be planned because the monitoring and selection of data corresponding to representative output is important for accurate emission reduction calculations. The QA procedure needs to be planned because the monitoring and selection of reliable data corresponding to emission factor due to electricity consumption is important for accurate emission reduction calculations. D.2.1.4 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of temperature of steam. D.2.1.5 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of pressure of steam. D.2.1.6 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of temperature of feed water. D.2.1.7 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of flow of feed water D.2.1.8 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of flow of steam D.2.1.9 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of flow of fuel. For calibration of refinery fuel flow meter procedure is defined. D.2.1.10 Low The calorific value of refinery fuel is tested in the in-house laboratory. The QA procedure needs to be planned because the monitoring and selection of representative data from total data is important for accurate emission reduction calculations. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 39 D.2.1.11 Low The estimation of boiler efficiency based on measured parameters is very critical parameter for estimation of emission reduction. Procedure is required. D.2.1.12 Low For retrofit monitoring retrofit test should be followed as given in section D.2.1.1. D.2.1.13 Low There is no procedure required for the measurement of cooling water flow rate. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 40 D.4 Please describe the operational and management structure that the project operator will implement in order to monitor emission reductions and any leakage effects, generated by the project activity >> General Manager (Process) Manager (Technical Cell) Shift in charge Operator D.5 Name of person/entity determining the monitoring methodology: >> EOL, their associated experts and consultants (indicate if the person/ entity is also a project participant) This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 41 SECTION E. Estimation of GHG emissions by sources E.1. Estimate of GHG emissions by sources: >> Calculation for Project Scenario (Emission Reduction due to Steam Optimisation) Steps Description Unit Value Step-1 Average value of representative data of vacuum generated mm Hg of vacuum 12 Average value of representative data of vacuum generated mm Hg of 12 vacuum Step-2 Representative value of HHP steam generated at the boiler end equivalent to the LP steam used in VHC system tph Step-3 Sp. Steam consumption used in VHC system tph/mm Hg 82.25 of vacuum Step-4 Net reduction in sp. Steam consumption (as compared tph/mm Hg 4.667 to baseline case) of vacuum Step-5 Calculate reduction in steam consumption due to project activity tph 56 Step-6 Calculate net reduction in energy consumption due to steam reduction(tph) kcal/hr 38286080 Step-7 Net reduction in cooling water requirement (as compared to baseline case) m3/hr 5858 987 PROJECT SCENARIO (INCREASED EMISSIONS DUE TO ADDITIONAL ELECTRICAL CONSUMPTION) DESCRIPTION UNIT VALUE Step-1 Step-2 Average value of daily energy consumption of motive MWh liquid circulation pump of the VHC system(for representative scenario of mm Hg of vacuum generated) Net increase in daily energy consumption MWh Calculate CO2 emission (based on the steam : fuel ratio tph and steam : power ratio of the captive power plant of the refinery) 1.7 1.3524 818.57 This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 42 E.2. Estimated leakage: >> There are no potential significant sources of leakages. E.3. The sum of E.1 and E.2 representing the project activity emissions: >> Operating Years GHG Emissions by sources Leakage Project emissions (tCO2/annum) (tCO2/annum) (tCO2/annum) 2007-08 740.1 0 740.1 2008-09 740.1 0 740.1 2009-10 740.1 0 740.1 2010-11 740.1 0 740.1 2011-12 740.1 0 740.1 2012-13 740.1 0 740.1 2013-14 740.1 0 740.1 2014-15 740.1 0 740.1 2015-16 740.1 0 740.1 2016-17 740.1 0 740.1 Total 7401 0 7401 E.4. >> Estimated anthropogenic emissions by sources of greenhouse gases of the baseline: BASE LINE CASE (Sample Calculation) STEPS DESCRIPTION UNIT Step-1 Average value of representative data of vacuum generated mm Hg of 12 vacuum created Average value of representative data of vacuum generated mm Hg of 12 vacuum created Representative value of HHP steam generated in the boiler end equivalent to the LP steam consumed in steam-jet ejector system tph Step-2 BASED ON VALUES OF JUNE 2003 1043 This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board Step-3 page 43 Sp. Steam consumption in steam-jet ejector system tph/ mm of 86.92 Hg vacuum generated E.5. Difference between E.4 and E.3 representing the emission reductions of the project activity: >> DESCRIPTION UNIT Net emission reduction (emission reduction due to steam tph optimisation – emission increase due to additional electricity consumption) Annual net emission reduction in CO2 Tons/year 17.21 136274.8 This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board E.6. >> page 44 Table providing values obtained when applying formulae above: Years Estimation of Estimation of Estimation of Estimation of Project Baseline leakage (tonnes of emission reductions Activity Emission CO2 e) (tonnes of CO2 e) Emission reductions reductions (tonnes (tonnes of of CO2 e) CO2 e) 2007-08 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2008-09 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2009-10 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2010-11 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2011-12 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2012-13 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2013-14 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2014-15 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2015-16 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 2016-17 740.1 137014.9 0 136274.8 Total 7401 1370149 0 1362748 This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 45 SECTION F. Environmental impacts F.1. Documentation on the analysis of the environmental impacts, including transboundary impacts: >> The only environmental impacts from this work are positive-reductions in refinery fuel use and associated pollution. There are no negative environmental impacts from the installation of this project activity. The technology is easily transportable and installation does not require any major construction equipment. This project does not require an environmental impact assessment (EIA) under Indian law. F.2. If environmental impacts are considered significant by the project participants or the host Party, please provide conclusions and all references to support documentation of an environmental impact assessment undertaken in accordance with the procedures as required by the host Party: >> NA This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 46 SECTION G. Stakeholders’ comments >> G.1. >> Brief description how comments by local stakeholders have been invited and compiled: Identification of stakeholders: EOL will be implementing steam optimization project in the vacuum distillation column of the refinery. Some of the key stakeholders identified for the project are as under: Elected body of representatives administering the local area (village Panchayt) Employees of EOL The technology supplier – M/s TECHNOVACUUM EOL is in the process of communicating to the relevant stakeholders to get their comments on the project activity. Further, as part of registration process, public comments will be invited by appointed DOE. G.2. Summary of the comments received: >> The comments received from M/s TECHNOVACUUM stating about the uniqueness of the project activity. There are no negative stakeholder comments received so far on this project. G.3. Report on how due account was taken of any comments received: >> There is no negative stakeholder comment received so far on the project activity. The relevant comments and important clauses mentioned in the project documents/clearances like Detailed Project Report (DPR), environmental clearances, local clearance etc. were considered while preparation of CDM project design document. As per UNFCCC requirement this Project Design Document (PDD) will be published at the validator’s web site for public comments. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 47 Annex 1 CONTACT INFORMATION ON PARTICIPANTS IN THE PROJECT ACTIVITY Organization: Essar Oil Limited Street/P.O.Box: P.O Box No -12 Building: - City: Vadinar State/Region: Gujarat Postfix/ZIP: 361 305 Country: India Telephone: 91-2833-241127 FAX: 91-2833-241414 E-Mail: bkm@essar.com URL: www.essar.com Represented by: Mr. B.K. Mukherjee Title: Head of Refinery Salutation: Mr. Last Name: Mukherjee Middle Name: Kumar First Name: Bimal Department: Mobile: - Direct FAX: - Direct tel: - Personal E-Mail: - This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 48 Annex 2 INFORMATION REGARDING PUBLIC FUNDING No public funding for this project. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 49 Annex 3 BASELINE INFORMATION Baseline for the project activity is the present system i.e. steam-jet ejector system adopted by the project proponent for vacuum creation in VDU. Sl. No. Parameter/data type 1 Vacuum created in the VDU by steam-jet ejector system 2 Average LP steam consumption in steam-jet ejector system 3 Average HHP steam consumption at the boiler end corresponding to LP steam consumption at steam-jet ejector system 4 Temperature of HHP steam at boiler outlet 5 Pressure of HHP steam at boiler outlet 6 Boiler feed water temperature 7 Boiler feed water pressure 8 Specific steam consumption for steam-jet ejector system 9 Power consumption in the steam-jet ejector system 10 Cooling water consumption in steam-jet ejector system 11 Steam:Fuel ratio 12 Steam:Power ratio 13 14 Boiler efficiency Calorific value of the fuel (SRFT)used in the boiler Carbon % of the fuel used in the boiler 15 Unit mm Hg Data Source 12 EOL source tph 63.1 EOL source tph 1043 EOL source Degree C 465 EOL source Bar absolute 63 EOL source Degree C 106 EOL source Bar absolute tph/ mm Hg of vacuum kWh 90 86.92 EOL source EOL source 347.6 EOL source tph 6888 EOL source Kg of steam/kg of fuel Tonnes of steam/MWh of power % kcal/kg 3.98 EOL source 12 EOL source 80% 10,000 EOL source EOL source % 90 EOL source This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 50 Annex 4 MONITORING PLAN Description of the Monitoring Plan The Monitoring and Verification (M&V) procedures define a project-specific standard (baseline of historical emissions) against which the project's performance (i.e. GHG reductions) and conformance with all relevant criteria will be monitored and verified. It includes developing suitable data collection methods and data interpretation techniques for monitoring and verification of GHG emissions with specific focus on specific energy consumption parameters. It also allows scope for review, scrutinize and benchmark all this information against reports pertaining to M & V protocols. The M&V protocol provides a range of data measurement, estimation and collection options/techniques in each case indicating preferred options consistent with good practices to allow project managers and operational staff, auditors, and verifiers to apply the most practical and cost-effective measurement approaches to the project. The aim is to enable this project have a clear, credible, and accurate set of monitoring, evaluation and verification procedures. The purpose of these procedures would be to direct and support continuous monitoring of project performance/key project indicators to determine project outcomes, greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reductions. The project employs latest state of art monitoring and control equipment that measure, record, and control various key parameters. Parameters monitored will be as follows. 1. The monitoring of vacuum created 2. The monitoring of quantity of steam used in the vacuum creating system in the baseline as well as in the project scenario 3. Monitoring of temperature and pressure of steam used in the vacuum creating system in the baseline as well as in the project scenario 4. Monitoring of boiler efficiency and steam enthalpy parameters and estimation of boiler efficiency by direct method. 5. Monitoring of retrofits in the plant for change in baseline and project emissions. The instrumentation system installed for the project is Distributed Control System (DCS) of reputed make, with shift-wise recording and feedback facility with desired level of accuracy. All instruments will be calibrated and marked at regular intervals so that the accuracy of measurement can be ensured all the time. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 51 GHG SOURCES Direct On-Site Emissions Direct on-site emissions after implementation of the CDM project arise from the following sources. Net emissions due to increased load of the motive liquid circulation pump of VHC system As discussed above, these emissions are monitored and taken into account while estimating net emission reductions of project. Direct Off-Site Emissions There is no off-site emission due to the project activity. Indirect On-Site Emissions There is no indirect on-site emission due to the project activity. Indirect Off-Site Emissions No indirect off-site emissions could occur due to CDM project. Project Parameters affecting Emission Reduction Monitoring Approach The general monitoring principles are based on: Frequency Reliability Registration and reporting As the emission reduction units from the project are determined by the reduction in steam quantity and subsequent reduction in consumption of refinery fuels in the boiler and net change in electrical energy consumption, it is important to discuss the monitoring principles in the context of monitoring these parameters. Frequency of monitoring The project developer has installed all metering facilities within the plant premises. The measurement is, monitored and controlled through DCS on continuous basis and recorded shift-wise (8-hours shift) in log sheets by operator, duly authenticated by head of plant This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 52 Reliability The amount of emission reduction units is proportional to the net energy reduction due to project. Thus the steam meter reading is of crucial value. All measurement devices will be of digital type meters with on-line DCS (Distributed Control System), having best accuracy and will be procured from reputed manufacturers. Since the reliability of the monitoring system is governed by the accuracy of the measurement system and the quality of the equipment for reproducibility, all instruments must be calibrated once a year for ensuring reliability of the system. All instruments carry tag plates, which indicate the date of calibration and the date of next calibration. Therefore it ensures the monitoring system is highly reliable. Registration and reporting Registration is done on the basis of shift-wise data logging in computer. Daily, weekly and monthly reports are prepared stating the steam consumption reduction and electrical consumption. The following reports will be generated for monitoring and controlling emissions. The daily report of hourly data of steam consumption in vacuum creating system, hourly generation of vacuum would be prepared. The steam consumption per unit of vacuum created in the vacuum distillation column is worked out. The net reduction in steam consumption is thus estimated by multiplying difference in specific steam consumption and amount of vacuum created in the project scenario. Furthermore, daily report on cooling water consumption for the vacuum creating system would also be prepared. Daily report has to be maintained for the electrical energy consumption in the motive liquid circulation pump of the VHC system. Verification The reduction in steam consumption leads to the CO2 emission reductions. The project control system comprises sophisticated monitoring system like on-line display meters and Distributed Control Systems (DCS) which measures, collects the information about various process parameters, monitors and controls on a continuous basis and records on two hourly basis. Fully functional management information is built, which is generated through DCS in pre-decided daily reports formats so that accessing and verification of actual data are possible at any point of time. A computerised MIS can be generated and distributed among decision makers of the project. The major activities to be verified are as under Verification of various measurement and monitoring methods Verification of instrument calibration methods Verification of data generated through on-line meters and DCS Verification of measurement accuracy This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 53 Monitoring of boiler efficiency Following guidelines are to be used to decide the periodicity for monitoring and estimation of boiler efficiency by direct method. 1. The fuel test certificate including calorific value and carbon percentage of the refinery fuel supplied in the boiler would be provided by the reputed laboratory 2. The generated steam enthalpy parameters (steam temperature, pressure and quantity) is continually monitored and entered in log-book at periodic intervals in every shift. 3. The fuel meters are available for refinery fuels which record the fuel flow to the boiler on continual basis 4. The efficiency is estimated on monthly basis by direct method. This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 54 Annex 5 List of Abbreviations CC CDM CER CO CO2 CP Cum DCS DOE DPR DM EB EIA EOL GHG GJ GOI GPCB GWh HP HHP HR or hr HV IPCC KP km KV KW KWh LP 1 Lakh MkWh MT MW NG Climate Change Clean Development Mechanism Certified Emission Reductions Carbon Monoxide Carbon di-oxide Credit Period Cubic Meter Distributed Control System Designated Operational Entity Detailed Project Report De-Mineralised Executive Board Environmental Impact Assessment Essar Oil Limited Green House Gas/es Gega Joules Government of India Gujarat Pollution Control Board Gega Watt hour High Pressure High High Pressure Hour High Voltage Intra-governmental Panel for Climate Change Kyoto Protocol kilo meter Kilo Volts Kilo Watt Kilo Watt hour Low Pressure 1,00,000 Million Kilo Watt hour Metric Ton Mega Watt Natural Gas This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board NOC p.a. PDD PFD PLF PIN SSCR TJ TPH UNFCCC VHC VDU page 55 No Objection Certificate Per annum Project Design Document Process Flow Diagram Plant Load Factor Project Idea Note Specific Steam Consumption Ratio Trillion Joules Tones Per Hour United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change Vacuum Hydrocirculating System Vacuum Distillation Unit This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font. PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM PDD) - Version 02 CDM – Executive Board page 56 ANNEX 6 LIST OF REFERENCES Sr.No Particulars of the references Kyoto Protocol / UNFCCC Related 1. Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change 2. Website of United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), http://unfccc.int 3. UNFCCC Decision 17/CP.7 : Modalities and procedures for a clean development mechanism as defined in article 12 of the Kyoto Protocol. 4. UNFCCC document, Clean Development Mechanism-Project Design Document (CDM-PDD) version 01(in effect as of: August 29, 2002) 5. UNFCCC document : Annex B to attachment 3 Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small scale CDM project activity categories ver 01, January 21, 2003. 6. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Document on emission factors. IPCC-1996-Rev. 7. British Standard BS-845-1987 for Indirect Boiler Efficiency Calculations 8. Steam tables to determine enthalpy of steam 9. Phychrometric charts to determine moisture in air based on wet bulb and dry bulb temperatures. 10. National Document to refer fuel emission factor, if any. Project Related 11. Project scheme documents and records from EOL records 12. Design data of M/s TECHNOVACUUM This template shall not be altered. It shall be completed without modifying/adding headings or logo, format or font.