BUSINESS CONTINUITY MANAGEMENT IN THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION GUIDELINES October 2015 COPYRIGHT © NSW Department of Education All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or copied in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying without the written permission of the publisher. Published by the NSW Department of Education Direct all enquiries to the Enterprise Risk Management Unit - contact details as follows: Level 2, 35 Bridge Street Sydney NSW 2000 GPO Box 33 Sydney NSW 2001 Internet and intranet references www.dec.nsw.gov.au https://detwww.det.nsw.edu.au/lists/directoratesaz/erm/index.htm https://www.det.nsw.edu.au/policies/general_man/erm/implementation_1_PD20040036.shtml?level= Version no. 2.2 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Contents 1.0 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 3 1.1 Business Continuity Management ........................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Context .................................................................................................................................................... 3 1.3 Benefits .................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.4 Business Continuity Plans for the Department ........................................................................................ 5 1.5 Business Continuity Management Objectives ......................................................................................... 5 1.6 Relationship ............................................................................................................................................. 6 2.0 The Business Continuity Management Process .......................................................................................... 7 2.1 Overview .................................................................................................................................................. 7 2.2 The Process illustrated ............................................................................................................................ 7 2.2.1 Step 1 – Create Awareness and Identify Critical Business Functions ............................................. 9 2.2.2 Step 2 - Conduct a Risk and Vulnerability Analysis ....................................................................... 10 2.2.3 Step 3 - Conduct a Business Impact Assessment ......................................................................... 12 2.2.4 Step 4 - Define Response Strategies ............................................................................................. 14 2.2.5 Step 5 - Identify Resource and Interdependency Requirements ................................................... 16 2.2.6 Step 6 - Develop Business Continuity Plans .................................................................................. 17 2.2.7 Step 7 - Develop a Communication Strategy ................................................................................. 18 2.2.8 Step 8 - Maintain and Test Plans ................................................................................................... 18 2.3 Activation and Deployment .................................................................................................................... 20 3.0 References ................................................................................................................................................ 21 4.0 Appendices ................................................................................................................................................ 22 Appendix 1 - Roles and Responsibilities of Departmental Stakeholders .................................................. 22 Appendix 2 - Business Interruption - Incident Management Process ....................................................... 24 Appendix 3 - Terminology of Business Continuity Management ............................................................... 25 Appendix 4 - Business Continuity Plan Help Card .................................................................................... 26 Appendix 5 - Resources – supporting worksheets .................................................................................... 27 Appendix 6 - BCM Process: Step 1 – Identify Critical Business Function Template ................................ 33 Appendix 7 - BCM Process: Step 2 – Risk and Vulnerability Analysis Template...................................... 34 Appendix 8 - BCM Process: Steps 3 & 5 BIA & Resources ..................................................................... 35 Appendix 9 - BCM Process: Step 4 - Response Strategies ...................................................................... 36 Appendix 10 - BCM Process: Step 7 - Stakeholder Communication Matrix ............................................... 37 Appendix 11 - Business Interruption - Incident Management Structure ...................................................... 38 Appendix 12 - Business Continuity Management as part of the Planning Process .................................... 39 2 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 1.0 Introduction The Department of Education (the Department) is committed to a structured and systematic approach to Business Continuity Management (BCM) in accordance with current policy, industry standards and best practice. These guidelines outline the Department’s approach to BCM and associated responsibilities of all staff (see Appendix 1). Before going any further, you should determine if you already have a Business Continuity Plan (BCP). If you do, the objective would be to update it as required to reflect your current structures and processes. The aim of these guidelines is to provide you with the steps to update or create a BCP for your area to address critical business functions. Any business unit that performs a critical business function (CBF) should develop and implement a BCP. BCPs are not anticipated to be developed at school level as it is expected that they should be adequately covered by emergency response plans and higher level BCPs. 1.1 Business Continuity Management What is Business Continuity Management and why is it important? The Business Continuity Institute1 defines BCM as a “holistic management process that identifies potential threats to an organisation and the impacts to business operations that those threats, if realised, might cause. It provides a framework for building organisational resilience with the capacity for an effective response that safeguards the interests of its key stakeholders, reputation, brand and value creating activity”. BCM is concerned with managing the effects of severe unexpected events as opposed to managing business-as-usual issues. Accordingly, managing the effects of severe unexpected events is the primary focus of these guidelines and the framework that underpins the management process is illustrated by Appendix 2. A table of terminology associated with BCM is shown in Appendix 3. 1.2 Context To help with understanding the context, the following definitions are used in this process: At any time throughout this document, whenever the term the Department is used, this extends to all entities within the Department of Education cluster A division is any one of the following areas within the Department under the leadership of a member of the Executive – Corporate Services; External Affairs and Regulation; Strategy and Evaluation; and School Operations and Performance A business function is a series of logically related activities or tasks performed together to obtain a defined set of results (see Table A for examples) A critical business function is any vital set of activities or tasks without which the Department cannot operate for very long. Ask the question “Can we continue to operate for a month without it and still achieve our business objectives?” A business unit is a branch of the corporate office, a division, a schools area, a directorate, or other business area. The following illustrates different types of business functions - 1 Critical. These functions cannot be performed by manual means or can be performed manually for only a very brief period of time. In applications classified as critical, a brief suspension of processing can be tolerated, but a considerable amount of "catching-up" will be needed to restore data to a current or usable form. Sensitive. These business processes can be performed, with difficulty but at tolerable cost, by manual means for an extended period of time. Sensitive applications also require "catching-up" once restored. Noncritical. These applications may be interrupted for an extended period of time, at little or no cost to the Department and require little or no "catching-up" when restored. Business Continuity Institute is a global industry body and is headquartered in the United Kingdom. 3 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Table A: Some Examples of Business Functions Area Some Examples of Business functions Detailed Functions Accounts Payable Accounts Receivable Income and Expenditure Financial Statements - Balance Sheet, Profit and Loss Asset Management Finance Delivery Developing the product (course material, syllabus, curriculum etc.) Delivering the services Marketing Marketing - determining student or community needs, new products, marketing strategy, product promotion Human Resources Management of the employment function – e.g. hiring, awards, pay rates and conditions, maintenance of employee records Wages/Salaries Administration Clerical and record keeping tasks – e.g. Typing, reception, filing and retrieval, mail Information Technology Maintenance of IT infrastructure and associated processes (e.g. Acquisition of new equipment, backup of data, maintenance of network, help desk) Maintenance of telecommunication infrastructure and associated processes (e.g. Telephones, mobiles, PABX hardware) Acquiring assets Disposing of assets Practical asset management (in association with finance) Buying goods/services required by the Department to deliver its services Procurement 1.3 Benefits These guidelines help staff to address government directives and other requirements. Moreover, they evidence good business practice as BCM acts to mitigate the negative consequences of severe unexpected events. Some of the benefits of implementing and maintaining an effective BCM capability are summarised in Table B. Table B: Summary of Business Continuity Management Benefits Tangible Benefits ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Intangible Benefits ▪ ▪ ▪ Compliance with regulatory requirements Compliance with contractual requirements and avoidance of liability and penalties Compliance with insurance policy conditions Reduced operational downtime Reduced costs of operating during a disruption Reduced losses as a result of a disruption and reduced costs of backlog management More cost effective recovery. ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ 4 Managed exposure to risks of business disruption Improved operational resilience to unforeseen events Preservation of reputation through ensuring continuity of supply Improved efficiency and effectiveness of processes Improved staff confidence Improved stakeholder confidence Improved process understanding. Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Thus, by treating the negative consequences of an event, business continuity management can create opportunities for benefit and gain. Hence, those business units that respond positively to a disruptive event can position themselves to recover quickly and improve their long term business performance. Finally, BCM helps to restore critical services as it facilitates the creation and maintenance of BCPs which contain the recovery procedures and strategies necessary to resume critical services. BCPs are activated when standard operational procedures and responses are rendered inoperative as a result of being inundated by a severe unexpected event. 1.4 Business Continuity Plans for the Department The Department adopts a three-level hierarchical approach to BCP documentation as outlined in Figure 1 below. This ensures that all components of a robust BCP are addressed across the full suite of plans whilst ensuring that plan activation is easily facilitated across the various levels of management within the Department. It allows the Department to focus on strategic judgements and the prioritisation of resources. BCP Department Wide Level 2 BCP Division 1 BCP Division 2 BCP Division 3 BCP Division n Level 3 BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP BCP Operational Strategic Level 1 BCP Area 1 BCP Area 1 BCP Area 2 BCP Area 2 BCP Area n BCP Area n Figure 1: BCP Hierarchical Approach 1.5 Business Continuity Management Objectives The objectives of BCM for the Department are to: ▪ protect academic and community outcomes by identifying and managing where possible any risk to major Departmental products and/or services ▪ provide managers with guidelines to enable them to develop a local BCP that identifies and manages potential and actual risks that threaten the Department’s major systems and services ▪ provide staff with a selection of procedures that shall be used to minimise or prevent exposure to business continuity risks ▪ ensure that regular tests of BCPs are undertaken and to ensure the effectiveness and efficiency of the plans ▪ ensure that regular reviews and updates of planned strategies are undertaken to account for changes in critical business systems and services. 5 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 1.6 Relationship There are a number of interrelated activities that work together to prevent and/or manage a severe unexpected event (or business disruption event2). These include: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ business continuity management (encompassing Information Technology (IT) disaster recovery) risk management emergency response management incident management. As previously discussed, BCM is an element within the wider context of risk management. Accordingly, risk management and BCM need to be considered as part of an integrated process. Risk management is the identification, analysis and evaluation of risks and is the important preliminary step to understanding the risks as well as scoping the need for BCPs. The interface between risk management and BCM is reflected in Figure 2 as follows. Figure 2: The relationship between risk, emergency response, incident, and business continuity management in managing a crisis situation Each response is described in detail in Section 2.2.4 and is summarised as follows: Emergency response: this is the tactical response to the event. It occurs immediately after the event, and the primary concern is the protection of life and safety. The transition from emergency response to continuity needs to be explicitly managed. To assist staff with the management process reference should be made to the Department’s Emergency Planning and Response Policy which is published on both the Internet and intranet. The above Policy outlines the Department’s commitment to the provision, development, documenting and communication of emergency systems. Continuity: this is the strategic and operational response to the business disruption. During this period the affected business unit relies on alternative processes and resources, and aims to establish at least the minimum level of capability and performance required. Recovery: this is the strategic and operational response to the business disruption. During this period the affected business unit returns to routine business processing, and aims to operate at the business-as-usual level of capability and performance. While a BCP is a means of minimising the impacts of a particular risk, it is not a preventative control for all risks. Thus, overall, risk management minimises potential losses, whereas BCM provides processes and resources in order to ensure the continual achievement of central BCM objectives. Hence, risk management addresses the question, "how do we control or manage our risk?", whereas business continuity management addresses the question, "what do we do to continue business operations?" 2 ANAO 2009 Guide. 6 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes A structured, systematic approach to risk management will enable business units to develop a thorough understanding of risk issues that could prevent the achievement of their goals or objectives. As part of this process, business units should define their essential functions and key dependencies. Moreover, they should clearly identify those risks which may potentially result in a severe unexpected event that would disrupt the delivery of their products and/or services. To assist with business continuity planning a quick reference “Business Continuity Plan Help Card” is provided at Appendix 4. 2.0 The Business Continuity Management Process 2.1 Overview The Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) has conducted an analysis of audits of financial statements of public sector agencies over several years, in particular business continuity implementation. Their analysis has identified the following generic characteristics associated with best practice in relation to BCM programs. A BCM framework is in place. Training and awareness of business continuity has been conducted. A risk assessment has been conducted. A business impact analysis has been conducted. Preparatory controls have been implemented. The entity has documented, and the executive has endorsed, its business continuity plans and framework. Business continuity testing and exercises have been conducted. The entity monitors business continuity. 2.2 The Process Illustrated These guidelines are written using a worksheet approach, and each completed worksheet using the information gathered from within your business unit will assist you in developing your business unit's BCP. These worksheets are contained in Appendix 5. Furthermore, these guidelines have adopted the relevant Australian Standards and best practice. Accordingly, the steps which are central to the Department are based on AS/NZS 5050:2010, AS/NZS ISO 31000:2009 and the ANAO 2009 Guide. The steps are listed below. Step 1 - Create Awareness and Identify Critical Business Functions Step 2 - Conduct a Risk and Vulnerability Analysis Step 3 - Conduct a Business Impact Assessment Step 4 - Define Response Strategies Step 5 - Identify Resource and Interdependency Requirements Step 6 - Develop Business Continuity Plans Step 7 - Develop a Communication Strategy Step 8 - Maintain and Test Plans The above process is illustrated by Figure 3 and is discussed in detail throughout this section. However, should an event occur and is deemed to adversely affect the operations of one or more business units, then tested plans (see Step 8) will be activated and resources deployed as reflected by the final step labelled: Activation and Deployment. 7 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Figure 3: Business Continuity Management Process 8 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.1 Step 1 – Create Awareness and Identify Critical Business Functions Create awareness about BCM and gain the commitment and support of management and staff for the implementation and maintenance of the BCP when establishing your business unit's BCM structure. In accordance with the BCM structure, senior managers should: ▪ create awareness of BCM within the business unit and gain support for the implementation and ongoing maintenance of BCM ▪ ensure that staff are designated with responsibilities for BCM ▪ ensure that a BCP is developed, implemented, regularly tested, received and updated as appropriate. Senior managers can facilitate this action with their staff by asking: ▪ “What is important to the success and sustainability of our business unit?” ▪ “What does our business unit depend upon to continue operating?” ▪ “What might prevent our business unit from achieving its key objectives?” To help create awareness and understanding within your business unit, consider the following: ▪ critical objectives, critical success factors and key performance indicators ▪ major current and emerging risk exposures ▪ critical business functions and processes ▪ critical plant, property, assets and other infrastructure ▪ critical people and information resources ▪ third party relationships such as with the community, suppliers, partners and regulators. Senior managers should also analyse past incidents and disruptions that indicate a propensity for future disruption, including: ▪ occurrences within your business unit ▪ occurrences within the Department as a whole ▪ prior involvement of key interdependencies, such as suppliers, strategic alliances and other stakeholders ▪ experiences of others within the education sector, communities, government, geographical location, etc. Senior managers and their staff should identify and agree upon the following: ▪ the goals and objectives of strategic and operational activities of BCM ▪ expected deliverables and outcomes ▪ time requirements, demands or constraints ▪ resourcing capabilities and limitations, i.e. geographical extent and boundaries and organisational structure, extent and boundaries. The following diagram (Figure 4) illustrates the process for identifying the critical business functions and the resources required. Figure 4: Critical business functions Action To assist in the implementation of Step 1, read and understand these guidelines (the whole of this document). To record information, use the checklist at Appendix 5A and complete the template at Appendix 6. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 9 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.2 Step 2 - Conduct a Risk and Vulnerability Analysis 2.2.2.1 Analysis components Analyse the products and/or services that your business unit provides, identify the risks that would disrupt the delivery of the products and/or services and determine whether the business unit is vulnerable to those risks (see Section 2.2.2.2). It is important to define and understand the environment in which your business unit operates. This allows your BCP to focus on the critical business functions and processes, including all internal and external providers, which ensure the business unit is able to provide ongoing services to the Department and to other stakeholders. It is also important for business units to refer to and adopt the Department’s Enterprise Risk Management policy and guidelines which is published on the Internet and intranet. In brief, this entails identifying, assessing, and treating risks and is discussed below. Identifying risks As part of this stage, an understanding must be gained of the risk management strategy and the focus of the business unit, as well as its relationship to the Department’s core activities. Reference to the Department’s annual report can be useful in focusing your identification of key business activities. Risk identification can be most effective when undertaken as a brainstorming activity involving staff from a variety of levels and activities within your business unit. The following points provide background material for your business unit: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ What does my business unit do? That is: what products and/or services does it deliver? What inputs including all internal and external providers does our business unit depend upon to deliver its products and/or services? What existing strategies are in place to ensure inputs are maintained? What risks could interrupt the inputs to our unit's business? What existing strategies are in place to ensure that our unit's services continue? What risks could interrupt the services provided by our unit? Assessing risk Assessment and analysis will provide a priority ranking of the business continuity risks that have been identified in the risk identification. This ranking is used as the basis to develop the business unit's BCP. There are two criteria for assessing the level of risk: firstly the consequence and secondly, the likelihood of each identified business continuity risk. Determine the consequence of the risk To evaluate the risk level, you will need to first assess the risk consequence by identifying the potential consequences of a risk event occurring. The 'Department-wide consequence criteria’ is used to estimate a potential impact which a risk might have on the achievement of the Department/division objectives in terms of negative consequence (threats) – see Table C. 10 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Table C: Department-Wide Negative Consequence Criteria (Threats) (The potential impact on the objectives and resources) Consequence Criteria The Department will not meet its objectives The Department/Business unit may not meet its objectives and will require considerable additional resources from other areas Impact can be absorbed with treatment but will require additional resources to be allocated Can be accommodated with existing resources Virtually no change in operations Impact Descriptor Impact Code Critical 5 Major 4 Moderate 3 Minor 2 Insignificant 1 Note: Use the Department’s Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) Guidelines or ERM Quick Reference Guide to assess the risk likelihood and rating in conjunction with the above consequence table. For the purposes of formulating your business unit's BCP all risks ranked Extreme or High are to be considered for the next stage - Step 3 – Conduct a Business Impact Assessment. 2.2.2.2 Developing risk scenarios Creating scenarios is a proven approach to planning for the future. When it is done in an engaging fashion, it harnesses participants' collective experience and knowledge as well as their powers of judgment and intuition. The above risk assessment can define a large amount of severe unexpected events. Trying to use this significant amount of information as the basis for the subsequent Business Impact Assessment (BIA) (Step 3 – Conduct a Business Impact Assessment) and for subsequent planning can be an overwhelming and unnecessary task. To improve information processing, it can be more effective to group risks into broader risk scenarios on which to base the BIA and subsequent development of plans. For example, consider the following potential sources of risk that one or more business units could face at any one time: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ fire flood power failure industrial dispute chemical spill delay in construction works bomb hoax severe storm damage failure of building access controls. The above risks can all have the same disruption effect and accordingly, can be grouped into a consolidated risk description or scenario as follows: ‘following a severe unexpected event, access to one or more buildings is denied for a period of x hours or y days’. Action Complete a separate analysis template (Appendix 5B) for each Critical Business Function. To record information, complete the template at Appendix 7. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 11 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.3 Step 3 - Conduct a Business Impact Assessment This step is an essential part of the business continuity planning process as it provides an analysis of how severe unexpected events could affect a business unit’s operations and what capabilities will be required to manage these risks. The BIA identifies mission-critical areas and business processes that are critical to the maintenance of the delivery of products and/or services. Furthermore, the BIA helps to raise senior management’s awareness of undesirable consequences and potential risks. Accordingly, business unit managers should determine the potential organisational effects of severe unexpected events to their operations and identify the resources required to continue to operate following these disruptions. BIA key steps Key steps that underpin the business impact assessment process are outlined below. 1. Developing communications for the BIA This will assist with establishing trust and a two-way dialogue in order to develop a more effective BIA. 2. Confirming critical business functions Given the completion of the risk and vulnerability assessment, this aspect confirms that previously identified business functions retain their critical status. 3. Identifying resource requirement In this step the current level of resourcing for each critical business function is identified to determine current capabilities and the potential for future spare capacity or shortfall. It should cover for example the type, number, location, etc. of the following resources: ▪ People: Managers, staff, contractors and consultants currently contributing to the critical business function. Include key roles and responsibilities for each individual and location, contact details, deputies for each position, etc. ▪ Facilities: Identify types of facilities in use currently (for example: 25 workstations in open office, 1 manager's office, 1 meeting room) ▪ Equipment: Identify general office equipment, telecommunications, and any specialised equipment in use (for example computers, filing cabinets, cameras, photocopiers etc.) ▪ IT systems: Identify IT systems and applications currently in use ▪ Information: Identify current information requirements (for example required paper records and electronic documents) ▪ Budget: Identify current budget, cash flow, expenditure and/or revenue requirements ▪ Transport: Identify transport requirements (for example fleet requirements, vehicle hire and vehicle parking requirements) ▪ Other service and assets: Identify any other key factors required to support the normal operations of the critical business function (for example couriers, inventory etc.). 3 3 Once the normal day-to-day resource requirements have been determined, business unit managers should be challenged to identify which resources are absolutely essential to achieve the level of operation that will meet the critical business objectives in the event of a disruption. The aim here is to identify the minimum resourcing that must be made available following a disruption. 12 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 4. Establish independencies A range of interdependencies will usually need to be identified and mapped, both internally and externally. The following types of interdependency need to be considered: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ between individual critical business functions within your business unit and across the Department as a whole with key suppliers (including critical infrastructure suppliers such as water, power and telecommunications utilities with key customers with strategic partners with regulators parties where no current interdependency exists, but could be created following a disruption. For each of these interdependencies, mapping should include details on but not limited to: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ the nature and level of the interdependency any critical failure points contractual conditions service level agreements/objectives. A common shortcoming of many attempts at mapping interdependencies is neglecting to ensure that people and resources are mapped against business needs for a minimal level of operation. 5. Determine the disruption impacts Determine the impact of the disruption on the critical business function and/or non-financial terms, over defined periods. The impact levels should be tested at predetermined intervals in accordance with the business unit’s ‘business cycle’ (e.g. school term or financial reporting period). 6. Identify outage times and recovery objectives Maximum Accepted Outage (MAO) times should be determined for each of the critical business functions (down to process level where applicable), key IT applications and other critical assets including human resources. The MAO time represents the maximum period of time that your business unit can tolerate the loss of capability of a critical business function, process, asset, or IT application. Note that this should be determined by the 'owners' of the critical business function. 7. Identify alternate workarounds and processes Alternate workarounds and processes may need to be developed where resources or capability are inaccessible or insufficient during the disruption such as the introduction of processing following the loss of IT functionality. 8. Confirm current preparedness Confirm the critical business functions’ current preparedness to manage a disruption. This may include, for example, re-evaluating the extent of redundancies within the business area (e.g. spare equipment), that could be redeployed to affected areas, the existence of alternative suppliers that could be contracted, or the potential to utilise a multi-skilled team. Action Complete the BIA checklist at Appendix 5C. To record information, complete the template at Appendix 8. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 13 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.4 Step 4 - Define Response Strategies The development of response strategies is concerned with determining how your business unit will react to an incident, and the manner in which the different elements of this overall response will interact. As previously mentioned in Section 1.6, the response should include the following broad strategies: the emergency response (initial response) the continuity response (interim operations) the recovery response (back to normal). In each case, it is advisable to consider a number of optional responses and then select the most cost effective option. 2.2.4.1 Response strategies described The Emergency Response ▪ The emergency response is the immediate response to the event. It is primarily concerned with the protection and preservation of life and property. This response could be as simple as the activation of a building evacuation plan, or as comprehensive as an emergency management strategy involving the immediate protection of property, people and information across multiple sites or communities. ▪ Typically the development of the emergency response will involve: ▪ Determining regulatory and industry standards' requirements (e.g. for fire evacuation) Confirming existing emergency response plans and capabilities Identifying gaps that require further development Identifying triggers for the activation of plans Identifying responsibilities for components of the response Documenting the strategy including the identity and location of component plans Identifying command, coordination and control requirements for the response. Note that your business unit should already have such emergency management procedures in place (e.g. fire evacuation procedures). Action Use the flow chart at Appendix 2 to assist in deciding when and how to activate, escalate and manage the Emergency response strategy. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. The Continuity Response ▪ The main purpose of the continuity response is to ensure the continued delivery of a minimum acceptable level of performance per the predefined MAOs. There are several important considerations in developing a response in order to determine the level of detail a BCP must contain and these are listed below. (i) Are plans required for: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ (ii) critical business functions? key processes? specific assets, facilities, locations, or other infrastructure? key people? and/or key supply relationships? determining the structure of continuity planning and are documents required? Another important consideration is to determine the structure of continuity planning and required documents ▪ will one plan or multiple plans be developed? or ▪ will plans be developed in a hierarchy with consolidated departmental level plans sitting above local functional plans? (iii) Confirming that the identified critical business functions (or assets, facilities, etc.) are still appropriate. This may lead to the consolidation of one or more business functions into a single critical business function for planning purposes 14 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes (iv) Identifying criteria for activating the continuity phase (i.e. triggers) (v) Identifying criteria of the deactivation, step down, or stand down of the phase. The Recovery Response ▪ The recovery response is aimed at restoring your business unit to a long-term operationally acceptable and sustainable capability. In developing this response it is necessary to consider what can be practically identified and planned for and what will be decided on following the actual incident. ▪ An important, though often neglected consideration, is the management of backlogs. As the business is returned to 'normal' capability there is likely to be a continuing backlog of work that will require attention. Appropriate strategies should be considered, e.g. additional temporary staff required and or staff to work over time. 2.2.4.2 Cost benefit analysis It is outside the scope of these guidelines to provide instructions as to how to perform a cost benefit analysis in relation to the development of business continuity strategies. However, the ANAO 2009 Guide states that “typically, the lower the maximum tolerable period of disruption, the more costly and complex the recovery treatment is likely to be. This is particularly true when the recovery of technology is involved. It is important to establish a realistic representation of the recovery requirements of the entity.” In undertaking any cost benefit analysis, consideration should be given to the nature of the product and/or service being offered, the Department’s current service delivery model and any identified internal economies of scale. Action Complete the Response Strategies template at Appendix 9. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. A description of the three responses is outlined above. 15 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.5 Step 5 - Identify Resource and Interdependency Requirements Identify, consolidate and map resource requirements from across the Department according to business priorities and according to the interdependencies with internal and external service providers. In circumstances where multiple plans have been developed (e.g. for a range of critical business functions) consolidation of all the resource information will be required to be performed by the business unit as designated by the Secretary. 2.2.5.1 Factors Factors that need to be considered include: ▪ Type, volume/quantity and location of resources required for each process during the severe unexpected event ▪ Dedicated resource requirements, such as processes or location that require the named resources to be dedicated to their use ▪ Access requirements, where processes or locations require access to the use of resources, but do not require dedicated resources ▪ Identification of synergies and conflicts between processes/locations in the unit or application of resources. While critical business resources were assessed during the risk assessment and BIA stages, it is necessary to determine the resources that will be needed to ensure the success of each strategy from Step 4 through to Step 8. Thus, it is critical that when determining the most suitable recovery strategy that the identification of the internal resources which are required to continue business operations following a disruption is carefully performed. Some examples of business resources are as follows: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ vital records (hard copy and electronic) contact lists of staff operating manuals procedures manuals location of off-site storage facilities minimum quantity of IT equipment required (this should already have been identified by your business unit) telecommunications support alternate office locations (if required) a list of staff with expertise required by the business unit authority for the payment of emergency expenses minimum quantity of office equipment required. If your business unit requires a specific product or service from a supplier, a commitment should be obtained from the supplier that its BCP is operational and that they can guarantee the ongoing supply of that product or service in the event that the supplier experiences a disruption. Action Review and revise your resource lists identified at Appendix 8. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 16 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.6 Step 6 - Develop Business Continuity Plans Use the information collected and developed during the BCM process to write BCPs that can be implemented following an incident. One of the most important issues in writing a plan for managing a disruption is to ensure that it is written so that it can be understood and applied by those expected to use it. A plan should be written in such a way that it could be understood by someone who has not previously seen the document. For certain functions it is possible that the plan may have to be activated and operated by individuals who are not fully familiar with the processes and procedures being employed. 2.2.6.1 What generic information to include in plans Although for the majority of plans there will be no predetermined standard, as a minimum the following generic information should be provided: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ current version criteria for activation of the plan (Who has the authority to activate the plan? Who is the backup in case this person is unavailable? Under what situations will the plan be activated?) specific actions and responsibilities resource requirements communication requirements contact lists. 2.2.6.2 What information to include in specific plans Emergency management plans The detailed content of emergency management plans may be specified by regulations, national standards (for example fire emergency evacuation plans), or by generally accepted practices (for example industry specific or local community emergency management plans). IT recovery plans IT recovery plans are included within separate IT Service or Application Recovery Plans as maintained by, and available from, the IT Directorate. Your business unit's BCP should not include the technical details of IT recovery but must determine workaround (perhaps manual) procedures which you will undertake should IT systems not be successfully recovered as expected. Business continuity plans The BCP's content must be developed to reflect your business unit's functions and provide the required capability to support the achievement of your pre-identified critical business processes within their MAO times. It is important to maintain effective governance and control during a major business interruption. BCPs must therefore define explicit control requirements which help ensure that the Department’s governance policies and procedures are maintained and applied during an interruption. Content should include but not be limited to the following: ▪ ▪ ▪ Financial delegations and control Insurance claims and management Appropriate communications with stakeholders (refer next section). Action The following points will assist you in developing your Business Continuity Plan(s). ▪ For a fully completed template, visit the policy section of the Internet or the intranet ▪ From the A-Z list, select Business Continuity Management Template with Sample Text ▪ Save the document to a file of your own choice or open it ready for use ▪ The document will be your actual BCP and will bring together the outcomes of each of the prior steps. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 17 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.2.7 Step 7 - Develop a Communication Strategy It is vital that communications are considered as one of the highest priorities throughout all BCM activities, both pre and post event. Your business unit's BCP documentation should include formal communication plans with all stakeholders and address the following communication issues: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Engagement Participation Comprehensiveness, clarity, adequacy and transfer of information Perceptions of the parties involved. 2.2.7.1 Identify stakeholders and their needs Communication with stakeholders should be a feature of all stages of the BCM program. However, following a disruption, there will often be a need to prioritise stakeholders as both audiences and information sources. A lack of consideration in this respect can adversely impact upon stakeholder relationships for a considerable time. Although considerable preplanning can be undertaken, there will always be a number of decisions on stakeholder communications that can only be made once the nature of the event and its impact become understood. As part of the communications plan, an initial stakeholder communications matrix should be developed and included as part of your BCP. Action Develop a Stakeholder Communication matrix and insert it within your BCP(s). Refer to Appendix 10 for guidance. When you have finalised and tested your BCP forward it to the ERM Unit for uploading to the Department’s intranet site. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 2.2.8 Step 8 - Maintain and Test Plans Plans can date very quickly (particularly contact lists). Even after a few weeks, if not updated, the effectiveness and relevance of plans begin to deteriorate. Furthermore, although plans may accurately reflect the status quo, they will remain as pieces of paper unless the relevant people within your business unit understand them and know how to use them. The three key tasks for effective plan management are as follows: Training and awareness Staff should understand the need for business continuity, what the plans are for and how to use them. Therefore the capability of staff to undertake these tasks must be maintained, for example through training and exercising. Thus, all staff identified as having a role in the development of a BCP should receive appropriate initial training and whenever a significant change is made to the BCP. The following items should be covered as part of BCP training: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Objectives and intent of BCP Definition of threats and risks covered by the BCP Structure of the Department’s overall BCP including relationships to Emergency Management Plans Roles and responsibilities of various groups involved in BCP Specific roles and responsibilities of the individual being trained. Testing The testing of all aspects of your business unit’s BCP (where practical) is critical to the plan’s success. The type of test you choose for your plan will depend upon the potential impact of your identified business continuity risks and the environment in which you work. Types of BCP tests include the following: 18 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes ▪ Structured Walkthrough - The most basic type of test that takes place in a group meeting setting where the main purpose is to ensure that critical personnel from all areas are familiar with the BCP. For example, staff members are provided with a handout and work through a pre-determined scenario. ▪ Desktop Drill - The participants choose a specific event scenario and apply the BCP to it. The main goals here are to practice team interaction, as well as decision-making and problem-solving skills. ▪ Functional Testing - A drill that involves the actual relocation of personnel to another site in an attempt to establish communications and coordination as defined in the BCP. The main focus here is to test the business continuity capabilities of groups in an actual recovery situation. ▪ Full-Scale - The most comprehensive type of test. With this test, all or most of the BCP is put into action. The main goals are to simulate an actual recovery situation as closely as possible. The exercises in this case usually are longer, and should evolve and develop just as they would in an actual crisis. A BCP test can be considered worthwhile only if the results are analysed and compared against your original objectives, and then acted upon. A self-assessment test can be completed by asking the following important questions: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Were the test objectives completed? What gaps did we find? What actions must we take to bridge those gaps? What approach should we take for our next test? At a minimum, all BCPs must be tested at least once every year or whenever a significant change is made to the BCP. All test plans and results must be documented and retained as an audit trail. Maintenance New technology, legal requirements, policy and procedures can all introduce new business continuity risks. When business processes change, it is important that the BCP is reviewed and updated to reflect those changes. Issues which may be considered during a review of your BCP include: ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Is the BCP based on a risk analysis assessment that has been conducted and documented? Has the potential impact of business continuity risks been assessed? Has the BCP been developed to minimise disruption of services, reduce financial loss, and ensure timely resumption of normal operations? Does the BCP include contact details for personnel, vendors, equipment and transportation? Do the BCP contact details include names, positions and phone numbers of persons responsible for the business continuity strategies? The Department's Audit Directorate may include a review of the management of business continuity planning as a project on their strategic audit plan. This could include random checks of business units' BCPs. The Audit Office of New South Wales may also review business continuity planning across the public sector. It is essential that you continue to test your BCP and ensure it remains relevant and up-to-date. 19 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 2.3 Activation and Deployment Activation A severe unexpected event as illustrated by Figure 5 could result in the activation of one, several, or many emergency response plans as well as multiple business continuity plans. Moreover, progressively over time, a series of recovery and restoration plans affecting one or multiple locations could also be activated. Figure 5: The activation of a BCP, key time lines and the resumption of critical business processes BCM does not have a discrete start and end: it is a continuous and iterative process. Accordingly, the crisis timeline depicted in Figure 5 encompassing the various components will vary according to the nature and extent of the unexpected severe event. Thus, the MAOs and RTOs will need to be monitored throughout the disruption as any adverse variances against stated objectives could impede the resumption of normal business operations. Based on best practice, business units are encouraged to manage business continuity on an ongoing basis and have their BCPs integrated with departmental management practices. Deployment The activation of the above plan(s) may have business units competing for resources, time and the attention of senior management. Based on the Australian Standard Handbook HB 292-206 an ‘Incident Control System’ (ICS) for coordinating and controlling the activation, deployment stand-down, and interrelationships between plans would assist the Department to effectively manage the above situations. An ICS provides an accepted approach for achieving control and coordination and is based upon the concepts of: ▪ ▪ ▪ limited effective span of control modular structure scalability. This task of developing a suitable ICS for the Department is currently being undertaken by the WHS Directorate. Once approved, the resource will be published on the Internet and the intranet. Although these guidelines provide assistance at a business unit level, further work is required to establish a Department-wide Incident Coordination Centre (ICC). The ICC would be responsible for coordinating BCPs across the Department in the event of a significant incident. An example of how this ICC may function is provided at Appendix 11. Action Complete the Activation and Deployment checklist at Appendix 5D. Retain and file all outputs for future reference. 20 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Document retention It is essential that adequate records are kept of all key decisions and communications as they relate to BCM. These may need to be produced for the Audit Office of NSW, other auditors, government departments, insurers, regulators, courts, release of information requests, or for departmental debriefs. Thus, it is important that business units have at least one staff member who is tasked to collect and maintain such documents. This would include indexing and secure storage. Business units would benefit from this process as these documents should also prove helpful for directing further improvements to strategies, documented plans and the development of new exercise scenarios and simulations. 3.0 References ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ The Department’s Enterprise Risk Management Policy The Department’s Enterprise Risk Management Guidelines The Department’s Emergency Planning and Response Policy and Guidelines. The Department’s Pandemic Management Strategy Guidelines. Disaster Recovery Institute International, "Professional Practices for Business Continuity Planners", 1997. ▪ ▪ Attorney General's Department Business Continuity Guide Australian National Audit Office Business Continuity Management. Building resilience in public sector entities. Better Practice Guide June 2009 Australian National Audit Office Business Continuity Management. Keeping the wheels in motion. Better Practice - A Guide to Effective Control 2000 ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Standards Australia Risk Management Standard AS/NZ ISO 31000:2009 Standards Australia Business Continuity Standard AS/NZS 5050:2010 Standards Australia Business Continuity Management Handbook HB 221:2004 Standards Australia A Practitioners Guide to Business Continuity Management HB 292-2006 Standards Australia Executive Guide to Business Continuity Management HB 293 -2006 Additional information concerning the development of business continuity plans is available by contacting the ERM Unit on telephone number (02) 9561 8840. 21 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 4.0 Appendices Appendix 1 - Roles and Responsibilities of Departmental Stakeholders The following schedule outlines the roles and responsibilities of key departmental stakeholders and should be read in conjunction with the current organisational chart. DESIGNATED RESPONSIBLE STAFF 1. 2. 3. 4. The Secretary is responsible for ensuring: Deputy Secretaries, Executive Directors, General Managers, the Chief Information Officer, State Office Directors, Schools Directors are responsible within their areas for ensuring: The Manager, Enterprise Risk Management is responsible for ensuring: Division heads and other members of the Executive are responsible for ensuring: RESPONSIBILITIES ▪ the Department complies with the requirements of the Department of Premier and Cabinet for NSW government agencies to develop and maintain a BCP ▪ the convening and chairing or delegation of responsibility for convening and chairing an Incident Co-ordination Centre (ICC) to manage the incident (the course of action taken will depend upon the severity of the business continuity interruption). ▪ The Department's BCM policy and guidelines are implemented, and that their local BCPs are regularly tested and monitored ▪ staff are designated with the responsibilities of coordinating the development and maintenance of a local Business Continuity Plan in accordance with the Department’s BCM policy and procedures ▪ based on the severity of the business continuity interruption, they participate as a member of an ICC that is convened to manage an incident ▪ an annual report on their areas' BCM performance is completed, approved and forwarded to the ERM Unit for collation and submission to the Executive and to the Audit & Risk Committee (ARC). ▪ through their performance agreements, they can demonstrate compliance with the Department's BCM policy and guidelines. ▪ the Department's BCM policy and guidelines are developed, promulgated and reviewed ▪ senior managers are aware of their BCM responsibilities ▪ advice is provided to all business areas concerning BCM policy, guidelines and reports ▪ the Department complies with the Department of Premier and Cabinet requirements and corporate policy, procedures and guidelines are monitored and evaluated ▪ annual reports from all business areas on the Department's overall BCM performance are collated and the results submitted to the Executive and to the Audit & Risk Committee (ARC). ▪ the development and maintenance of a database of all BCPs within their areas ▪ the development and maintenance of a hard copy of all current BCPs ▪ the coordination of regular reviews of all BCPs ▪ the ERM Unit is provided with copies of all BCPs to enable reporting to the Executive and the Audit and Risk Committee (ARC). 22 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5. 6. Business continuity owners are responsible for: All staff are responsible for: ▪ undertaking appropriate BCM training ▪ coordinating basic BCM training, and providing advice and information, for other staff in their area ▪ coordinating the development, testing and review of their business unit's BCP ▪ liaising with the ERM Unit as required for reporting purposes to the Executive and the ARC in relation to their BCP. ▪ following the Department's BCM policy and procedures ▪ participating as a member of their business unit's BCP team. 23 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 2 - Business Interruption - Incident Management Process Significant Business Interruption Incident Identified Continue to Review & Assess Evaluation Process Includes: 1. 2. 3. Emergency Procedures Ownership Establish Incident Management Teams 4. Roles & Responsibilities 5. Incident Coordination Centre 6. Impact Assessment 7. Incident Categorisation 8. Escalation 9. Notification 10. Continual Assessment Escalation Required? Yes Initiate Incident Management Process Incident resolved Process Includes: 2. 3. 4. Formal Review with all Stakeholders Remedial Strategies Feedback to Stakeholders Amendment to BCP Resolve Incident at Local Level Process Includes: Management of Incident 1. No Post Incident Review 24 1. Recovery Action (Repair) 2. Communication and PR 3. Media 4. Business Continuity Management 5. Forward Planning 6. Investigation 7. Legal / Regulatory 8. Finance 9. Human Resources 10. External Organisations 11. Emergency Services & Local Authority 12. Specialist Services 13. Continual Assessment Incident Closure Notification Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 3 - Terminology of Business Continuity Management Acronym Business Continuity Terminology Definition AS Australian Standards The relevant AS are Standards Australia AS/NZS 5050:2010 on business continuity management and AS/NZS ISO 31000:2009 on risk management. BCM Business Continuity Management BCM provides for the availability of processes and resources in order to ensure the continued achievement of critical objectives. BCP Business Continuity Plan BCR Business Continuity Risk A BCP is a collection of information and procedures developed, complied and maintained in readiness for use in the event of an emergency or a disaster. The BCP enables an organisation to manage a major disruption or disaster and resume critical business functions within the required pre-determined time. The relationship of business continuity plans to other plans within the Department is reflected by Appendix 12. A BCR is an event that could result in an unacceptable and sudden interruption to a major system or service. BIA Business Impact Assessment A BIA provides analysis of how key disruption risks could affect your business unit's operations and what capabilities are required to manage them. ICC Incident Coordination Centre Department-wide ICC will be responsible for coordinating the BCPs across the Department in the event of a significant incident. An example of how this ICC may function is provided at Appendix 11. MAO4 Maximum Acceptable Outage The MAO represents the maximum period of time that your business unit can tolerate the loss of capability of a critical business function, process, asset, or IT application. R+V Risk and Vulnerability Analysis The R&V involves analysing the services your business unit provides, identifying risks that would disrupt the delivery of services and determining whether your business unit is vulnerable to those risks. RM Risk Management RM aims to "manage" (usually reduce) either the likelihood or the impact of a threat. RTO Recovery Time Objective The RTO is the target time set for recovery of an activity, product, service, or critical business process after a business disruption event, or recovery of an IT system or application after a business disruption event. 4 May also be referred to in some publications as ‘Maximum tolerable period of disruption’ (MTPD), ‘Maximum tolerable down time’ (MTDT), ‘Maximum down time’ (MDT), ‘Maximum allowable outage’ (MAO) or ‘Maximum Tolerable Outage’ (MTO). 25 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 4 - Business Continuity Plan Help Card This Help Card is designed to assist you to create a Business Continuity Plan for your business unit and is to be read in conjunction with other Appendices as listed below. How to Develop Your Business Continuity Plan Step 1 Create Awareness & Identify Critical Business Functions - review Business Continuity Management Guidelines (the whole of this document) and complete Appendix 5A & 5B. Step 2 Risk & Vulnerability analysis – refer to Section 2.2.2 of these guidelines. Undertake analysis using the available template at Appendix 7. Note: A separate analysis template should be completed for each Critical Business Function. Step 3 Business Impact Assessment - using your completed Risk & Vulnerability Analysis template, refer to Section 2.2.3 of these guidelines. Complete the checklist contained in Appendix 5C and the BIA template at Appendix 8. Step 4 Define Response Strategies – refer to Section 2.2.4 of these guidelines. Complete the Response Strategy template at Appendix 9. Step 5 Identify Resource and Interdependency Requirements – refer to Section 2.2.5 of these guidelines. Review the BIA template at Appendix 8. Step 6 Business Continuity Plan - using your completed BIA template, refer to Section 2.2.6 of these guidelines. Complete the BCP template available in the policies section of the Department’s intranet or the Internet. Step 7 Develop a Communications Strategy – refer Section 2.2.7 of these guidelines. Complete the Stakeholder Communication Matrix template at Appendix 10. When you have finalised and tested your BCP forward it to the ERM Unit for uploading to the Department’s intranet site. Step 8 Maintaining and Testing Plans – refer to Section 2.2.8 of these guidelines. The activation and deployment of tested BCPs is outlined in Appendix 5D. Important note: It is imperative that business units are able to refer to a hard copy of their BCP in the event of a loss of functional IT systems. 26 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 5 - Resources – supporting worksheets 5A Checklist – Identify critical business functions For each question, copy and paste this tick in the appropriate box below. Identify critical business functions Completed Yes 1. Document and confirm the business unit’s objectives and performance criteria. 2. List all critical business functions which underpin achievement of objectives. 3. Rank the functions in order of importance to the entity’s objectives and exclude those functions not considered critical to achieving the objectives. 4. Review the functional organisation chart to identify general areas of operational responsibility. 5. Obtain any supporting documentation that is available which would provide a summary of critical business functions. 6. Interview managers responsible for critical business functions to confirm understanding. 7. Consider interdependencies that exist: ▪ between business units ▪ with external entities or organisations. 8. Determine the minimum requirements necessary to perform each critical business function (see Appendix 5B.4.1). Consider: ▪ critical processes ▪ resources people facilities (including building and equipment) technology (including IT systems/applications) telecommunications vital records ▪ interdependencies ▪ other. 9. Obtain senior management endorsement of the prioritised list of critical business functions. Adapted from ANAO 2009 Guide 27 No Other actions required Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5B Templates – Identify critical business functions 5B.1 Document Control Identify critical business functions document details Version number Authorisation date Authorised by Expiry date To be revised on 5B.2 Business unit details Business unit details Business unit name Contact name Title Location Phone number Mobile Email 5B.3 Business unit objectives and performance indicators Objectives (in priority order) Performance indicators 1. 2. 3. 4. 5B.4 Business unit critical business functions Critical business functions (in priority order) Section/Team Key contact 1. 2. 28 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5B.4.1 Requirements to perform each critical business function Critical Business Function 1: <insert function name> Process 1 <insert name> Process 2 <insert name> Process n <insert name> Resources ▪ People ▪ Facilities(including building and equipment) ▪ Technology(including IT systems/applications) ▪ Telecommunications ▪ Vital records (including paper and electronic). Interdependent functions (including internal and external) Maximum Acceptable Outage Other Critical Business Function 2: <insert function name> Process 1 <insert name> Resources ▪ People ▪ Facilities(including building and equipment) ▪ Technology(including IT systems/applications) ▪ Telecommunications ▪ Vital records (including paper and electronic). Interdependent functions (including internal and external) Maximum Acceptable Outage Other Adapted from ANAO 2009 Guide 29 Process 2 <insert name> Process n <insert name> Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5C Checklist – Undertaking a business impact analysis For each question, copy and paste this tick in the appropriate response box below. Identify critical business functions Completed Yes 1. Gather relevant existing information, such as ▪ disruption scenarios ▪ emergency response management plan ▪ incident management plan ▪ pandemic plan ▪ IT disaster recovery plan 2. Consult key personnel and business units. Consider: ▪ building and facilities ▪ internal audit ▪ customer contact points ▪ emergency response management ▪ external stakeholders and organisations (for example, service providers, interdependencies, and unions) ▪ finance (and insurance) ▪ information technology ▪ risk management ▪ work health and safety 3. Evaluate the impacts of a loss of each critical business function from the perspective of the business unit’s objectives. Consider the following risk focus areas as outlined in the Department’s ERM guidelines: ▪ Service /Program delivery ▪ Financial ▪ Management effort ▪ Health & safety ▪ Legal/Compliance ▪ Reputation/External relationships 4. Identify interim process procedures (alternative or manual processing) techniques to be adopted during the recovery phase. 5. Determine the maximum tolerable period of disruption for each critical business function. 6. Determine internal and external critical interdependencies. 7. Identify vital records. 8. Determine the recovery time objective for each critical business function and IT system/application. 9. Determine the recovery point objective electronic data. 10. Estimate the time to overcome the backlog of work accumulated during a business disruption event. 11. Obtain senior management endorsement of the business impact analysis. Adapted from ANAO 2009 Guide 30 No Other actions required Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5D Activating and deploying your Business Continuity Plan Introduction The following example and checklist reflects Activation and Deployment of the Business Continuity Management Plan. Declaring the outage and agreeing on the appropriate time to initiate operations under the business continuity plan can be difficult and requires advance planning. It is therefore important to give clear guidelines on the declaration of a business disruption (severe unexpected event). 5D.1 Example – Activation levels Level Description Critical ▪ Incident management team and/or the business continuity management team convene (in person or via teleconference or videoconference) to manage the situation. Major ▪ Response and/or recovery situation monitored by emergency response manager or delegate, with the incident management team and/or other nominated management team alerted and on standby. ▪ Hourly situation reports are provided to the incident management team and/or other nominated management team. ▪ Response and/or recovery situation monitored by administrative support staff, with the incident management team and/or other nominated management team alerted and on standby. ▪ Daily situation reports are provided to the incident management team and/or other nominated management team. Minor Source: ANAO 2009 Guide 31 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes 5D.2 Checklist – Considerations for estimating the duration of a business disruption event For each question, copy and paste this tick in the appropriate response box below. Identify critical business functions Completed Yes No 1. Has input from emergency services, contractors been gathered to use in the evaluation of likely repair time? 2. Are critical business functions affected? 3. If 2 is answered YES, have the impacts on the critical business functions been considered? 4. Are the people involved in the estimation process clearly identified? 5. Are notification procedures for those involved in the estimation process clearly identified? 6. Are timeframes for the assessment clearly identified? 7. Do external stakeholders need to be part of the assessment? 8. If Question 7 is answered YES, are all external stakeholders identified? 9. Are all relevant insurance companies appropriately informed of the incident before assessment takes place (refer to insurance policy protocols to see if insurance policy is void if certain disaster assessments are carried out without the insurance company present or without their knowledge? Adapted from ANAO 2009 Guide 32 Other actions required Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 6 - BCM Process: Step 1 – Identify Critical Business Function Template Critical business function Physical location Critical success factor Functional interdependencies Priority Practical grouping Title or simple description of the critical business function or process. Identify the location or locations where the activity is conducted. Identify what the function is trying to achieve, this may be based on minimum acceptable performance standards. Identify key upstream and downstream interdependencies. Determine Criticality. Identify common groupings of critical business functions, for example those that may be suitable for the conduct of a combined single BIA. Level 3, 35 Bridge St Sydney 24 hour access to services 4 hour response business hours 8 hour response after hours Specialist Personnel Support Personnel Technology Communications Data Accommodation Medium Preparation of the financial statements in accordance with statutory requirements and accounting standards. Provide financial information and advice to Senior Management. Worked Example Financial reports and issues for the Executive 33 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 7 - BCM Process: Step 2 – Risk and Vulnerability Analysis Template Critical business function Risk Existing controls Impact Likelihood Residual Rating Target Risk Rating Treatment option Recovery Plan required? Responsibility Carry forward from Appendix 6 Describe what can go wrong What mitigating controls exist? Refer table above Refer table above Refer table above Refer table above Accept or reduce? Yes or No? Responsible for developing plan Loss of functional IT systems Nightly data backups A4 B4 F5 4L High Medium Reduce Yes Director Finance Worked Example Cont. Financial reports and issues for the Executive 34 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 8 - BCM Process: Steps 3 & 5 BIA & Resources Step 3 - Business Impact Assessment Step 5 – Resource and Interdependence Approach identify critical business functions per business unit list critical business processes for each identified critical business function identify the key resources required to achieve each of these functions determine the impact it would have if the function became inoperable rank the results from the perspective of the business unit as a whole. As completed in Appendix 5B.4.1 Example: Extract from HR Systems Support and Development Unit Impact assessment 1-5 days 1 month 3-4 months 1. Production of pay calculation – School / Corporate Permanent and Temporary Employees Critical Critical Critical 2 hours 2. Production of pay calculation – TAFE Employees Critical Critical Critical 2 hours 3. Production of financial interface information – School / Corporate Permanent and Temporary Employees Major Critical Critical 1 day Critical business functions 35 MAO Key resources required to achieve function Functional premises iSeries hardware platforms Oracle Database Network Access Email Access Internet Access Telephony (phone/fax) PEPS payroll CEPS Payroll Leave Management System Personnel System SHR Web applications (ELAPS) Specialist HRSSD Staff ITD Support Staff Functional premises Lattice / UNIX hardware platforms Oracle Database Network Access Email Access Internet Access Telephony (phone/fax) Lattice Payroll application Criminal Records Check system THR Web applications Specialist HRSSD Staff ITD Support Staff Functional premises Network Access Telephony PEPS payroll SAP Finance Module Operational FTP link to SAP Specialist HRSSD Staff Specialist SSC Finance staff ITD Support Staff Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 9 - BCM Process: Step 4 - Response Strategies Organisational unit Finance Directorate Location Level 3, 35 Bridge St Sydney Contact name Justin Time Title Director, Finance Telephone 0123 4567 Email Justin.Time@det.nsw.edu.au Critical business function Cheque processing Critical infrastructure Financial systems and cheque printer Risk scenario Loss of access to building MAO 48 hours Response requirement Establish alternate cheque printing capability to cover 48 hour period before recovery. Response option 1 Use a bureau service - Favourable Response option 2 Purchase second cheque printer for recovery site - Not favourable Response option 3 Manually prepare cheques Recommended option Use a bureau service Response objectives Resume cheque printing to 80% capability within 48 hours. Detailed description of response Notify bureau Flat file transfer from the Department to bureau Bureau processes file Verification and validation by the Department’s Accounts Officer Authorisation to process Cheque collection and distribution Preparatory requirements Develop list and contact details for approved bureau Establish capability for file generation and transfer Develop verification and validation process Develop alternatives for cheque collection and distribution 36 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 10 - BCM Process: Step 7 - Stakeholder Communication Matrix Stakeholder Communication Needs Who How Staff ▪ ▪ ▪ Secretary Emergency number plus website Families Immediately: ▪ What has happened? ▪ Who are the staff members involved and are they safe? ▪ What does the family do now? Later: ▪ How did it happen and what was the cause? Local community Immediately: ▪ What has happened? ▪ Is it safe? ▪ Could it happen again in the near future? Later: ▪ What is the Department doing to ensure that it does not happen again in the future? Students / Customers ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ What has happened and why it has happened? What will happen in the immediate future? Where is assistance available? What is the impact on product/service delivery and quality? How long will delivery be affected for? How adversely will contractual conditions be affected? Will the Department be able to continue trading into the immediate and longer terms (longer term sustainability of supply)? What compensation will be made available? What other alternate sources of the product/service exist? Suppliers ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ Any changes to supply requirements? How long will inventory be required to be held for? Any capacity for changed pricing? What is the likely duration of supply impacts? What compensation is available under contractual conditions? Minister ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ What has happened and how? What is being done to fix it? What are the impacts on local communities/customers and how these are being managed? When will normal capability and capacity be restored? Media ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ What has happened and how? Who was responsible? Can it happen again? What similar events have happened previously? Regulators ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ What has happened and how? What is being done to fix it? What is being done to prevent it happening again? What is the compliant/capability/performance of other elated areas? 37 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 11 - Business Interruption - Incident Management Structure Ministers’ Offices Director Audit Dep Sec Strategy and Evaluation Secretary Communications Media Executive Support Program Management Office Strategic Delivery Enterprise Risk Management Corporate Planning & Reporting Incident Coordination Centre (ICC) ICC may include but not limited to: Finance Shared Services Human Resources Industrial Relations Employee Services Information Technology Media Communications Dep Sec School Operations and Performance Corporate Functions & Schools areas Resources Dep Sec External Affairs and Regulation Incident Management Teams Roles / Responsibilities / Functions Formed to respond to specific incidents Dep Sec Corporate Services Corporate Functions & Regional Corporate Services 38 Bus i ne s s Conti nui t y Ma na ge me nt Gui de l i nes Appendix 12 - Business Continuity Management as part of the Planning Process STATE PLAN SETS DIRECTION Direction Aspiration Inspiration Department’s 5 YEAR STRATEGIC PLAN 2012-2017 Priorities Outcomes Targets (updated annually) DEPARTMENT-WIDE PLANS DIVISION ENABLING PLANS Strategic Enabling Plans Division Plans (financial year basis) Total Assets Plan Aligned to 5 Year Strategic Plan 2012-2017 ICT Plan Strategic HR Plan S&E CS ExAR SOP Aboriginal Education Training Strategy Disability Action Plan School Plans Workforce Diversity Plan Relate to Division Plans which are focused on service delivery within budget Multicultural Plan Literacy & Numeracy Action Plan National Goals for Schooling Business Continuity Plans 39 Unit Work Plans Relate to Division Plans which are focused on service delivery within budget