SEAMEO-RETRAC 11th Governing Board Meeting and Conference Institut Aminuddin Baki Malaysia 27-30 August 2008 “BASIC EDUCATION CURRICULUM REVISITED: A LOOK AT THE CURRENT CONTENT AND REFORM IN MALAYSIA" by DR. KHAIR MOHAMAD YUSOF Director, Institut Aminuddin Baki Preamble It is with great pleasure that I welcome the members of the SEAMEO RETRAC Governing Board to this meeting and conference. Indeed it is our honor to host this year’s gathering of some of the leaders in education in the region. As leaders of the education sector in Southeast Asia, we all understand that we are at the forefront of educational development in the region. Still, one of the issues that we are currently facing is to remove the disparities in educational access, inclusion, and achievement. Hence, in all of the countries in Southeast Asia, our governments always put a premium of education as a way towards social development and economic growth. In the case of Malaysia, we have likewise always perceived education as one of the foundations of development. This is a challenging call because Malaysia is a young nation in terms of the composition of the population. In 2007, slightly more than half of the Malaysian citizens are below 24 years old. Out of a total of 27 million citizens for the same year, about 33.2 percent are under 14 years of age while 17.6 are between the ages 15 to 24 (MOE, 2008). This poses a great challenge to the government to provide resources to develop the abundance of young human capital. To give you a clearer picture of the state of education and schooling in our country, let me first go through several facts and figures. At the primary level, participation rate is high at 94.24 percent as of 2007 data. While participation at the lower secondary level at 85.05 percent increased by 3.29 percent between 2003 and 2007, participation rate at the upper secondary level, however, increased by a smaller 0.81 percent or a participation rate of 72.47 percent. The figures mentioned do not include that from private institutions, which would otherwise increase the participation levels in the lower and upper secondary level. A key factor in the increase of participation rates, particularly in basic education is the implementation of the reviewed Education Act of 1996 that enabled the implementation of compulsory education at the primary school level that took effect in 2003. This policy sees to it that every child in the country 1 beginning at age 6, regardless of sex, social and economic background, and residential locality has the right to primary education. Hence, parents must ensure that their children who reach six years old should have access to education. "... an educational programme that includes curriculum and co-curricular activities which encompasses all the knowledge, skills norms, values, cultural elements and beliefs to help develop a pupil fully with respect to the physical, spiritual, mental and emotional aspects as well as to inculcate and develop desirable moral values and to transmit knowledge" EducationAct1996 [Education (National Curriculum) Regulation 1997] The National Education System at school level under the government education institution category consists of:(a) Pre-School Education Education programme for pupils of 4-6 years of age (b) Primary Education The course of study at the primary level planned for a duration of six years but may be completed in five to seven years; It consists of national schools or national-type schools Status of the Basic Education: Integrated Curriculum for Primary Schools The current basic education was first introduced in 1982 in the form of Kurikulum Bersepadu Sekolah Renda, KBSR (Integrated Curriculum for Primary Schools). KBSR was trial run in 302 primary school in 1982, and a year later was implemented in all primary schools. KBSR was fully implemented in 1988 at the same time Ujian Pencapaian Sekolah Rendah UPSR (Primary School Achievement Test) was introduced. The principles if ICPS is based on the National Education Philosophy. These are : i. ii. iii. iv. an integrated approach ii. individual holistic development iii. equal education for all, and iv. Life long education. The integrated approach is the main focus in the design of the ICPS. The elements of knowledge, skills and values are incorporated so as to bring about 2 the integrated development of the intellectual, spiritual,emotional and physical aspects of the individual. The concept of integration is manifested as follows: teaching, the four skills are speaking (oral skill), listening (aural skills), reading and writing. Two or more of these skills can be integrated in a lesson. Integration of skills across a number of subjects. Drawing, for example, is one of the activities that can be adopted on Mathematics. Assimilation of various content in subjects. Elements of science,for example, are assimilated in the teaching of language. Integration of values in subjects. Cleanliness and safety, for example, are given emphasis during practical session. Elements taught across the curriculum include language. The environment, science and technology, patriotism, thinking skills and study skills. Integration of the curriculum and co-curriculum, Here, co-curricular activities are reinforced in the formal classroom learning situation. acquired can be put into practice outside the formal classroom situation. Integration of past experiences and the newly acquired experience of pupils. The aim of primary school education is to ensure an overall, balanced and integrated development of an individual's potential which includes the intellectual, spiritual, emotional and physical aspects so as to produce balanced and harmonious with high moral standards. For operational purpose, the structure of the Integrated Curriculum for Primary School is divided into 2 phases of three years each. Phase I comprises Year 1, 2 and 3 while Phase II of Years 4, 5 and 6. The ICPS consists of three areas namely Communication, Man and His Environment, and SelfDevelopment. These three areas are subdivided into six components, namely: Humanities and Environment Attitudes Living Skills Co-curriculum 3 Recent Improvements and Interventions Having introduced the current implementation of the Integrated Curriculum for Primary Schools ICPS, I shall now expound on the characteristics of the recent improvements and interventions in Malaysian education in the past few years, particularly on curriculum revision. Started in 1999, the motivation for the revision was to realign the curriculum to existing and future needs, particularly in recognition of the need to adapt to rapid technological development within and outside the country. The revised curriculum was placed in the context of national development, learning theories and the National Philosophy of Education, and the Vision 2020 These are then translated into disciplines and special programs such as patriotism, drug education, and environmental education. 4 Changes in the curriculum are but part of the achievements of the Malaysian educational development experience. Along the years, especially in past two decades or so, the country tackled head on the challenges in educational access, equity, quality, and relevance. The success of the system in responding to these issues was closely linked to the systematic strategies as expressed in Malaysia’s Outline Perspective Plan, which was implemented starting in the 1960s. The OPP has always identified the education sector as one to the main mechanisms in national growth. This premium placed on education thus ensured that funds are sufficiently allocated to the education sector. Moreover, the government fully recognizes the immense impact of developing human resources in meeting the goals of Vision 2020. This is translated to continuous training and upgrading of skills. It is not hard to see the results of these efforts as noted, for instance, by the continuous increase of Malaysia’s literacy rate from 85 percent in 1990, to 93.7 percent in 1998, to 94 percent in 2002 and to 97 percent in 2006. In 2003, the average class size was 31 and 33 for primary and secondary education respectively. In the same year, the student-teacher ratio for primary schools was 17, and 16 among secondary schools. The number of primary schools increased to 7,623 in 2007 from 7,504 in 2003 and 7,130 five years before that. The number of secondary schools also increased from 1,566 in 1998 to 1,902 in 2003 and 2,058 in 2007. These outcomes are just part and parcel of the efforts of the Malaysian government in dealing with the issues and concerns in education, particularly in terms of access, equity, quality and relevance, and participation of the society in educational change. (1) To improve access to education, the Federal Constitution ensures that there will be no discrimination against any citizen in terms of access to and financial support for education. Universal primary education is almost achieved and efforts to provide twelve years of basic education is being intensified. As pointed out earlier, literacy rates and enrolment rates are growing. (2) In terms of educational equity, equal opportunity for education is provided to every child, including those from remote and rural areas. Parents can also choose to enroll their children into National Schools that provide instruction in Malay and the National-type schools of their choice. (3) Quality and relevance of education to individual needs and nation building have likewise been given top priority in the national development plan. The National Curriculum places emphasis on the holistic development and potentials of individuals. Technical, vocational, and skills training offered in secondary technical and vocational schools provide students with practical training and employability skills. Moreover, using technology to facilitate teaching and learning makes the process more interesting, motivating, stimulating, and meaningful. (4) Participation of the society is also given priority in educational development. In designing and implementing education programs, the Ministry of 5 education has close cooperation and collaboration with other government agencies, private enterprises, non-government organizations, community-based organizations, religious institutions, and industries in activities such as strengthening early childhood education, vocational and trainings skills programs, parent-teacher associations in fundraising, and the mass media. The government, to better improve the quality of education in Malaysia, also adopted a number of upgraded approaches, strategies, and reforms in education. This is of course closely hinged on the National Education Philosophy, that aims to develop the potential of individuals in a holistic and integrated manner for them to be intellectually, spiritually, emotionally, and physically balanced and harmonious, based on a firm belief in and devotion to God. (1) First, there had been strategic changes in the teaching and learning of mathematics and science in primary and secondary schools by enhancing the teaching of those subjects. In Malaysia, the delivery of mathematics and science subjects are traditionally in Malay, the National Language. In 2002, the English language was made as the medium of instruction for both of these subjects, which is expected to enable students to access information in the internet, read articles and research papers and other materials published in English. Policy outcomes have been positive, albeit a few problems were noted, which are immediately trying to address. (2) Second, the Ministry of Education is also working on making the utilization of ICT more common among Malaysian schools. This may come in ways such as ICT–enhanced teaching and learning, distance learning, video conferencing, and Internet links to facilitate the exchange of ideas and collaborative classroom discussion. Majority of primary and secondary schools in Malaysia already have computer laboratories and internet facilities. The Smart School Project or SSP is a flagship program in Malaysia’s Multimedia Super Corridor ICT Application. SSP utilizes the browser-based teaching and learning materials for Bahasa Malaysia, English Language, Science, and Mathematics. These materials accommodate different needs and abilities that allow learners to take greater responsibility in managing their own learning. The SSP also encourages the development of teaching and learning courseware in the classroom that would be incorporates in the Smart School Integrated System or SSIS. All coursewares are launched through the networked computer system provided to all Smart Schools. (3) Thirdly, the Ministry of Education, through the intervention initiatives KIA2M or Kelas Intervensi Awal Membaca dan Menulis (Early Intervention Classes for Reading and Writing) actively pursuing to redress the 100,000 primary school pupils who are still struggling to master basic skills in reading and writing. Introduced in 2006 for grade 1 pupils, the assessment is carried at the very beginning of the school session to screen and identify those needed special help and care in reading and writing. The progress is progressively monitored and measured six month later, with those achieving the set minimum standard in reading and writing will be transitioned back to the main stream. 6 (4) The fourth key initiative that I will share with you is on the changes in public examinations. The School-based Assessment of Oral Skills focuses on the Malay and English languages. It entails that students be assessed in or outside the classroom situation. It is offered to students in grade 1 to grade 6 in primary schools and in grade 7 to grade 9 in lower secondary schools. The Oral Test of Speaking and Listening Skills meanwhile is offered to student in grade 10 and grade 11 in upper secondary school. As mentioned earlier, Mathematics and Science were first conducted in Malay and English in 2003, hence, another assessment on bilingual proficiency was conducted starting in 2004. By 2008, all assessment instruments for grades 6, 9, and 11 public examinations for Mathematics, Science, Technical and Technology subjects would be in English for all national primary and secondary schools. Certification for Vocational Subject in Academic Schools or VSAS was also introduced. It comprises parts on competency-based assessment and modular certification. Challenges and opportunities Despite the aforementioned recent improvements and interventions in the education system in Malaysia, and the substantial achievements in education as a whole since our independence in 1957, we do recognize that there are still a number of challenges that we have to immediately address in due course to affect short-term and long-term solutions to these issues. (1) First, Malaysia has always been motivated to pursue integration through education in line with Vision 2020’s goal of uniting all races. Vision Schools were thus established to keep pupils learning together in the same vicinity irrespective of race or religion. It also creates greater opportunities for pupils of different ethnic groups to mix and interact through various school activities. (2) Expansion of preschool education is another challenge as indicated by only 36 percent of children aged 5-plus years who did not have access to preschool as of 2000. The Ministry of Education institutionalized the National Preschool Curriculum compulsory in all preschools beginning 2003. This effort, and some other related ones, increased participation rate on the preschool level from 64 percent in 2000 to 88.3 percent in 2003. (3) As mentioned earlier, the government is giving increased emphasis on science and technology education, which is a challenge that the MOE is facing. Currently, the low participation rate in the science stream is far from the targeted ratio of 60 percent in science and technology, compared to 40 percent in the arts. We have thus undertaken the upgrading of vocational and technical schools, building and upgrading science schools and science laboratory facilities. The MOE also introduced science subjects in grade 1 starting in 2003. We are also increasing the number of science teachers to complement this. (4) Another challenge that we are facing is sustaining students’ participation in the system, especially among the poor. The Poor Students’ Trust Fund for instance distributed 1.54 million Malaysian ringgit to 800 primary school 7 students nationwide in 2003. Each poor student receives a maximum of 2,000 Malaysian ringgit a year to pay for their school expenses. In 2003, the MOE also introduced a financial assistance program for children at risk of dropping out of school because of poverty. Further, the tuition voucher scheme for children in Years Four, Five, and Six at the primary level qualify children from needy families who show poor academic performance to enroll into extra-classes in critical subjects such as Mathematics, Science, English, and the Malay language. (5) In the area of education and gender equality, the main challenge for the Malaysian education system is the low participation of male youths at the secondary level. While in primary school the composition of males and females enrolled in public primary school is about the same, there is low participation among male youths at the secondary level, which places Malaysia in a unique situation among other developing countries. The decline in enrolment of male youths at the university level in almost all fields of study is another concern of the government. This is more obvious in the arts and pure sciences as compared to enrolments into the technical fields. In 2007, from 331,025 students enrolment in the public universities, there are 126.836 male students representing 38 percent of the total enrolment (MOE, 2007). (6) The Malaysian education sector is also trying to address social inclusion in education, particularly among children with special needs and children of indigenous peoples of the country. The Orang Asli, the indigenous population of Malaysia, has been the main focus of integration and assimilation by providing them with equal opportunities in education and introducing measures to ensure the teaching of their dialects. School uniforms, food rations, textbooks, and other forms of assistance are continually supplied as incentives for school attendance. We are also overcoming the negative attitude of the Orang Asli parents towards their children’s education through adult education to the Orang Asli communities to foster more literate and optimistic parents. The Ministry of Education is also working with other government agencies to provide learning and training facilities and services for children and youths with special needs. For instance, the Special Education Department of the Ministry of Education coordinates all special education programs of all special education schools to students with hearing and visual impairments. In the case of students with special needs, we have also developed Integrated Special Education Programs through special education classes in mainstream schools to enhance their social integration. (7) To better pioneering changes in education, the Education Development Master Plan (Pelan Induk Pembangunan Pendidikan, PIPP) 20062010 outlines the strategic moves to close the gap and raise the bar of Malaysian education. Being a diverse society, it cannot be ignored that unity, social cohesion and developing the human capital of the country made significant contribution to economic growth and social maturity that the country is enjoying right now. Certainly, however, there is still a lot work to be done. Constantly we need to monitor and enhance the present system based on its past and present strengths and weaknesses. Focal areas are still on improving equity, access, and democratization of education. In addition, we need to further improve education 8 quality and efficiency to better prepare our children for a changing global community. We are fully aware that it is a continuing process of transformation, one that has to be consciously and consistently prioritized. Revisiting the curriculum: transforming the pre-school and primary school curriculum and assessment. Beginning 2008, the Ministry of Education is conducting a trial run on 50 primary schools nationwide in implementing the modular and thematic curriculum and school based assessment. This is a rolled-out project with 500 schools coming on board in 2009, before the full implementation in 2010. Graphically, the changes are depicted as in Diagram 2 below: Curricular approach Linear, subject and topical based, constant time Modular and thematic, Time is variable Assessment Locally (school based) administered assessment at all grades + centrally administered grade 6 examination + centrally assessed psychometric test Centrally administered examinations at grade 6 Diagram 2: Now and new curriculum approach and assessment The rationale behind these projected and progressive transformations in curriculum and assessment for primary schools is to ensure the relevancy of the schooling with the current and future needs by enhancing students learning with the acquisition of new skills in thinking, communication, entrepreneurship, innovation and creativity. Additionally, the development of primary school pupils upon completion of their primary education must be in a holistic manner. This must begin with the right kinds of skills, knowledge and values without compromising on their integrity, moral fibre and personal qualities. To achieve these, there are six core thrusts of the curriculum content and forms : namely Communication, Students Well Being, Physical and Aesthetic, Humanities, Literacy in Science and Technology, and Spirituality, Values and Attitudes. The emphases of these core thrusts of the curriculum is depicted in Diagram 3 below. 9 Key Stage 2 Grade 3-6 Socio-emotional & Cognitive Development; Spiritual, Values & Attitudes; Enhanced & Applied 4R; Basic ICT Skills; Generic & Complex Skills; Knowledge Acquisition Key Stage 1 Grade 1-2 Socio-emotional & Cognitive Development; Spiritual, Values & Attitudes; 4R (Reading, Writing, Arithmetic, Reasoning); Basic ICT, Generic Skills Socio-emotional & Cognitive Development; Spiritual, Values & Attitudes; Preparation for schooling Pre School Age 4-6 Stages of Development Curriculum Emphases Diagram 3 – Curriculum emphases at stages of development Of course, that this is still new and the trial is being conducted in 50 schools this year and I do not want to preempt the implementation that there is still more to be achieved before the transformation that will most likely to take place in the 2010. However suffice for me to say that what we are doing now is to fulfill our hope to develop a quality basic education which will realize the full potential of the individual and fulfill the aspiration of the Malaysian nation. On that note, I am again welcoming everybody to the 11th SEAMEORETRAC Governing Board Meeting and Conference. There are a lot of things that we are looking forward to discuss, thus let me invite you to a fruitful assembly of some of the leaders of the education community in Southeast Asia. Thank you. Khair Bin Mohamad Yusof, PhD Institut Aminuddin Baki Ministry of Education Malaysia 15 July 2008. 10