Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Youth Olympic Games proposal: Javelin Done by John Yap, Benedict Tan and Shawn Chua (Class 3I3) Introduction Javelin throwing made its debut in the 708 BC Olympic Games, and has been a regular feature at every Game since. Though our javelins have now become longer, are now made of metal instead of wood, and no longer feature riders on horseback aiming at targets (Cislunar Aerospace, 1997; Uyen, 2000; Lenord, 2002), the main change to javelin throwing lies not in the physical implements, but rather in a change in the approach taken in training. Increasingly, along with preparation and technique, understanding of physics, in particular aerodynamics and projectile motion, is needed for the perfect throw. The Physics of Javelin Throwing While a javelin thrower can condition his body into peak form, physics controls the situation on the competition day itself, with javelin size, weight, shape, wind conditions all determining the distance travelled by the javelin. This is seen clearly as javelin throwers themselves have reported a variation of as much as 10% in the normal distance thrown during training on the actual competition itself (Campos, Brizuela and Ramos, 2004). So what determines the javelin's flight in the air, and what angle should the javelin be released from? Once it is released, the javelin's flight is entirely determined by gravitational acceleration, air resistance and aerodynamics. By projectile motion, the motion of the javelin can be expressed as: V0= release velocity θ = release angle g= acceleration due to gravity and by differentiation, the optimum angle to achieve maximum distance appears to be 45o. (Young and Geller, 2007). However, this equation assumes firstly, the absence of wind, and secondly, that release velocity is independent of the release angle, and thirdly, the projectile is a particle, all of which are mostly not the case for athletes. Various physical models have be made that relate angle of release with release velocity and through fluid dynamics, and there is a general consensus that the optimum angle of release is from 35o to 37o. (Linthorne, 2006; Bartoneiz, 2000; Hatton, 2007) Such equations and models are complicated, but they stem from the aerodynamics of the javelin. When a javelin is thrown, it experiences a relative airflow opposite in the direction of motion. As the air flows around the javelin and separates on the upper surface, it increases drag but at the same time, increases lift, as with the lower pressure created by the separation of airflow, there is a net upward force. Because of this, The various aerodynamic forces in the javelin Retrieved from Lenord (2002) 1 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 headwinds of a mild velocity (blowing against the movement) of the javelin might actually aid in the distance travelled. (Lenord, 2002) Besides the angle of release, other optimal orientations of the javelin can also be explained through physics. The optimum angle of attack, defined as the angle between the javelin's longitudinal axis and the direction of the vector of the release velocity (α in the diagram) has also been hotly debated, but the widely accepted angle after much analysis is 0o: the angle that would reduce drag the most as there is a smaller exposed surface area. (Bartonietz et al., 1996; Bottcher and Kuhl, 1998; Bartonietz, 2005; Campos et al., 2000) The angle of yaw or slideslip is the angle of attack as seen from behind (β in the diagram). Though javelin throwers seem to achieve better results with smaller angles, larger angles also produce an upward directed Magnus lift force, as the spinning of the javelin about its long axis creates a "whirlpool" of air around it, which counteracts the effect of increased drag. (Bartonietz, 2005; Bartonietz et al., 1996) Various release parameters of the javelin Retrieved from Bartonietz (2005) Another important influence in the javelin's motion through air is the pitch rate (represented by q in the diagram), defined as the angular velocity of the javelin's tip at the instant of release. By rotating the javelin about its transverse axis in a clockwise or anticlockwise direction, athletes can compensate for an undesirable angle of attack (Bartlett, 1999; Bartonietz, 2005) When a javelin lands, physics also helps it land headfirst on the ground. The javelin's design underwent a major change when throwers began throwing distances that endangered the crowd, with Uwe Hohn throwing a distance of 104.80m in the 1984 Olympics. Javelins also tended to land flat on the ground, increasing the difficulty in obtaining an accurate measurement and producing safety concerns. As such, the javelin's design was changed and intentionally made unstable, with the centre of gravity being shifted 4 cm before the centre of pressure. This results in a forward torque, causing the javelin to pitch downward during its flight. Muscle groups required 2 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 As highlighted by Ogiolda (1993), the javelin thrower's movement can be characterised into 3 movement phases: the acceleration run, the five-stride rhythm and the final acceleration phase where the javelin is released. In each phase, the aim is to develop sufficient velocity to be transferred to the next phase, eventually resulting in a high release velocity and a further javelin throw. The javelin's initial linear velocity comes from the first phase, which most agree should be rhythmatic and relaxed. The approach speed should also not be too fast, such that the athlete does not lose control of the javelin at any time. The number of steps varies, with Gorski (2003) suggesting 4 to 6 steps for novice throwers and 8 to 12 steps for more experienced ones. Once the athlete has generated the initial momentum, the transition phase begins, where the thrower withdraws the javelin and performs crossover steps. Sing (1984) suggests that there are 3, 5 and 7-step transition rhythms and proposes the 5step rhythm as the most efficient one, though the 7-step rhythm is likely needed for the rotational thrower. In the final acceleration phase, a complicated series of movements ensue within an extremely short period of time, and examining the movement of the thrower (right-handed in this case) reveals the muscle groups required. Retrieved from Ogiolda (1993) After the thrower finishes the initial acceleration phase, his right leg is where the whole movement starts. As he moves his right leg, his hips accelerate. Then as his left leg touches the ground, his legs and hips stop moving and the sudden stop causes the energy to be immediately transferred to his upper body, as shown in positions 1 and 2. As the energy moves through the thrower’s body, his movements begin to accelerate, especially at his trunk, whereby the large amount of energy from the lower part of his body is transferred into the upper part of his body. As the energy moves up, the right side of his body turns almost 90 degrees to the left and is moving forward and turning upwards. The energy is transferred to the thrower’s shoulder as he turns upwards. His arm is held back and relaxed so as to stretch the muscles and store the energy before it is released into the javelin and the thrower now has an extreme bow or shoulder tension as shown in the 3rd position. The energy is 3 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 transferred in such a short amount of time through the body that it accelerates each time it moves, such that when the energy is released in the javelin in that short period of time, the acceleration and speed is very high. With the throwing arm being held back, a stretch-shortening cycle is initiated, and the stretched muscles of the arm and the shoulder start a reflex component of muscle action, accelerating the javelin into flight. (Ogioloda, 1993; Thom, 2006) This stage is critical, as 70% of the final release speed of about 30m/s is developed in these 50ms immediately before release. (Morris, Bartlett and Fowler, 1996) As can be seen by this description, momentum and energy for the final throw is generated by leg extension, hip rotation and trunk flexion. One of the key focuses of physical training should be therefore training of the quadriceps, hip flexors, gluteals and abdominals. (Young, 2001) In throwing the javelin, the deltoids, triceps, biceps, trapezius and rotator cuff muscles provide the energy for the final stage of throwing, and exercises should be put in place to train these key muscles. Lastly, for the initial run, the leg and trunk muscles must also be developed in order to ensure the thrower reaches a high enough velocity for sufficient momentum to be generated. Physical Training recommended Muscles involved in javelin throwing Adapted from: http://www.healthyflesh.com/wpcontent/uploads/2009/12/human-body-muscle-diagram.jpg Athletes should first find their one-rep max (1 Rm) by increasing the weight lifted until one is only able to lift it up once. Any weight exercises after that should first use 60% of the 1 Rm and 6 sets of 15 reps should be done on each training day, for each exercise, especially for the core exercises, training endurance. After about a month, athletes should progress to around 70% of their 1Rm and do 6 sets of 8 reps each day. Athletes may want to start off with the upper and lower body exercises before going on to the core exercises. Core Exercises Bench Press Clean Snatch Note: Athletes can also use the Smith Machine for Bench Presses. Bench Press http://blogbb.file s.wordpress.com/ 2009/08/benchpr ess.jpg Power clean http://www.glas gowschoolofspor tbellahoustonac ademy.co.uk/Im ages/SupportSer vicesImages/Po wer%20Clean%2 Power0Techniques.JPG snatch Adapted from : http://www.beyon 4 dthenextlevel.com /images/BTNLpow ersnatch.gif Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Upper body Exercises Bent arm pullover (Dumbbells, trains the triceps) Cable crossovers (Cable crossovers machine, trains chest muscles) tricep press (Dumbbells, trains the triceps) delt raises (Dumbbells, trains the deltoids) bicep curl (Dumbbells, trains the biceps) Shoulder Press (Shoulder press machine, trains anterior and lateral deltoids) Delt raises http://upload.wi kimedia.org/wiki pedia/commons/ thumb/d/d8/Du mbbellLateralRai se.JPG/300pxDumbbellLateral Raise.JPG Bent arm pullover Shoulder Press http://musclebuildingsupport. com/images/dumbbell%20pul lover%202.jpg http://www.precor.com/i mages/equipment/315/sl Medicine Ball Exercises ineShoulderPress_1.png Training deltoids, triceps, biceps, trapezius and rotator cuff muscles 3 x 8 Chest Pushes 3 x 8 Straight arm standing throws Note: For Straight arm standing throw, arms should be kept straight throughout, place one foot at least 50 cm behind the other. Medicine ball exercises (Mackenzie, 2010b) Sprint exercises (train speed for intial run) 8x50m 8x30m 8x100m Overall Fitness exercises 2.4 km run 5 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Recommended schedule Training times Monday Tuesday 8.00a.m.10.30a.m. Throwing 10.30a.m.12.30n.n. Wednesday Thursday Friday Throwing Throwing Throwing 8x50m Sprints 8x30m Sprints 8x50m Sprints 8x30m Sprints Straight arm standing throws Chest pushes Straight arm standing throws Chest Pushes Bench Press Power Clean Bench Press Power Clean Bent arm pullover Cable crossovers Tricep press Cable crossovers Power Clean Bench Press Power Snatch Power Snatch Power Snatch Power Snatch Delt raises Tricep press Bicep curl Shoulder press Bicep curl Shoulder press Leg curls REST Power Clean 1.30p.m.4.00p.m. Leg curls Bent arm pullover 4.00p.m.6.00p.m. Bench Press Delt raises Shoulder press Bicep curl Throwing Throwing Throwing Throwing 8x100m Sprints 2.4km run 8x100m Sprints 2.4km run 6 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Diet Recommended 65% of the athlete’s dietary calories should be made up of complex carbohydrates which come from vegetables, fruits (such as turnip, cabbages, apples and pears) and wholegrain foods like wholegrain bread and rice. (Springboard, 2004) As the main source of energy, carbohydrates provide 40 to 50% of the energy requirement in early ages of moderate exercise. These foods rich in complex carbohydrates are favoured as they add more fibre, vitamins and minerals to the diet than foods high in refined sugar. Many athletes of various sports often "load" glycogen a few days before the competition, and while this is helpful for endurance athletes, it may not be so for javelin throwers, whose performance is usually unaffected by glycogen depletion. (Pfeiffer and Magnus, 2008; Desai, 2000) Another 10 to 15% of the calories should be supplied by unsaturated fats, both polyunsaturated and monounsaturated. Fats are also an energy source, and about 50% in moderate exercise or as much as 75% during prolonged aerobic activity of total energy requirements are provided by fatty acid metabolism. (Anderson, Young and Prior, 2010) In fact, some studies recommend loading on fats before competition period, claiming that this benefits performance more than loading carbohydrates, but the nature of javelin throwing (requiring strength and speed instead of stamina) makes this unnecessary. (Groves, 2002) Most sources of unsaturated fats are plant sources, including most vegetable oils, nuts and seeds and fruits such as avocadoes and olives. (Volek, 2001) Like any health-conscious individual, however, the athlete should avoid foods with trans fat and eat foods with saturated fat in moderation. The remaining 10% of the athlete’s dietary calories should come from protein, also another energy source and necessary for synthesizing protein into skeletal muscle. There is a general consensus that athletes should have a protein intake much more than the recommended daily allowance, and should have a protein intake of 1.5 to 2.0g/kg/day, which should obtain their protein intake from a variety of sources, including lean meat, eggs, cheese, yoghurt, fish, milk, tofu, nuts and seeds. (Volek, 2001) However, too much protein is discouraged, as it not only deprives the athlete of a more efficient fuel such as carbohydrates or from fatty acid metabolism in exercise, excess amino acids formed from protein breakdown also need to be excreted, putting stress on the kidneys and livers. Dehydration may also occur the kidneys increase their urine output. (Anderson, Young and Prior, 2010; Pfeiffer and Magnus, 2008) Athletes should also frequently hydrate themselves. Insufficient water intake has been shown to consistently decrease strength by 2%, power by 3% and endurance by about 10%. Though the strength and power reductions are assumed to have little effect on the casual exerciser, the difference becomes more pronounced for competitive athletes, especially since the margin between winners and losers can be extremely small in competitions. (National Academy of Sports Medicine, 2009) Fluid requirements during strength and power activities such as javelin throwing need to be determined by an individual's sweat rate, or the body weight lost due to water loss after exercise. During training sessions, hydration breaks of at least 10-15minutes should be taken. While water is sufficient for sessions lasting than 1 hour, sports beverages are preferred for physical activities that last longer than 60 to 90 minutes. (Fink, Burgoon and Mikesky, 2008) 7 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Vitamins and minerals for an athlete can be obtained through a balanced diet, and there is no evidence that additional vitamins or minerals above the recommended daily allowance enhance athletic performance. For athletes with less than an ideal diet, multivitamin and mineral supplements, preferably taken after meals to aid absorption, supply all needed minerals and vitamins. As emphasised by Grosvenor and Smolin (2009), these micronutrients are essential in energy production, oxygen delivery, protection against oxidative damage and repair and maintenance of body structures. Estimated Budget Assuming 30 athletes are to be trained: Type of machine/equipment Dumb bells*30 pairs Power Racks (Bench Press etc.)*4 Long Bars (for Bench Press)*8 Smith Machines*4 Cable Crossovers*4 Medicine Balls 3.5kg (6lbs)*5 Medicine Balls 2.7 kg (4lbs)*5 Medicine Balls 1.8 kg (2lbs)*5 Spring Clips (Fasten Weights)*16 Leg Curl Machines*4 Javelin Shoes*30 pairs Price $100*30 = $3000 $500*4=$2000 $120*8=$960 $1000*4=$4000 $800*4=$3200 $24*5=$120 $18*5=$90 $14*5=$70 $14*16=$224 $400*4=$1600 $100*30=$3000 Total=$18264 (Prices retrieved from: http://www.nextag.com/javelin-shoes/products-html http://www.nutrifirst.net/view_products.asp?srchstr=cable http://www.nextag.com/olympic-bench-press/search-html) References Note: Due to the lack of space, all citations for pictures are included in the caption underneath the picture, and can be viewed by expanding the textbox manually. The authors apologise for any inconvenience caused as a result. AMWhelan (2008, March 22) Javelin Throw: Everything you need to know about how to throw a javelin (properly!) Retrieved June 19, 2010 from: http://www.squidoo.com/javelin Anderson, J., Young, L. and Prior, S. (2010, May 12) Nutrition for the Athlete. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://www.ext.colostate.edu/pubs/foodnut/09362.html Anderson, O. (2001, February 1) athletes diet. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://www.pponline.co.uk/encyc/0127.htm Bartlett, R. (1999). Sports biomechanics: reducing injury and improving performance. (pp.202-209). Routledge: New York. 8 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Bartonietz, K., Best, R.J. and Borgstrom, A. (1996). The throwing events at the World Championship in Athletics 1995, Gὂteborg - technique of the world's best athletes, part 2: Discus and javelin throw, New Studies in Athletics, 11(1), pp. 19-44. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.athleticscoaching.ca/UserFiles/File/Sport%20Science/Biomechanics/Throwing%20Events/Ja velin/Bartonietz%20WC%20Throwing%20Events%20Tech%20of%20the%20Worlds%20Best%20Javelin.p df Bartonietz, K. (2005). Javelin Throwing: an Approach to Performance Development. In V. Zatsiorsky (Ed.), Biomechanics in sport: performance enhancement and injury prevention (pp. 401-434). Retrieved 23 June 2010 from http://www.books.google.com Bartonietz, K. (2006, May 2). Javelin Throw: Technique Training, Injury Prevention. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.coachkrall.com/Articles/Jav/KNAU.pdf Becker, P. (1999) Healthy Diet for Athletes. Retrieved June 19, 2010 from: http://www.fitwise.com/healthy_diet.asp Borgstrom, A. (2000). The Development of the Javelin. New Studies in Athletics, 15, 3-4, 25-28. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.athleticscoaching.ca/UserFiles/File/Sport%20Science/Theory%20&%20Methodology/Throw ing%20Events/Javelin/Borgstrom%20The%20Development%20of%20the%20Javelin.pdf Bottcher, J. and Kuhl, L. (1998). The Technique of the Best Female Javelin Throwers in 1997,New Studies in Athletics, 13(1), pp. 47-61. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.athleticscoaching.ca/UserFiles/File/Sport%20Science/Biomechanics/Throwing%20Events/Ja velin/Bottcher%20Technique%20of%20best%20female%20JT%20in%2097.pdf Campos, J., Brizuela, G. and Ramon, V. (2004). Three-dimensional kinematic analysis of elite javelin throwers at the World Athletics Championship at Sevilla'99, New Studies in Athletics, 19(21), pp. 47-57 Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.uv.es/jcampos/Documentos/NEA_IAAF_MenJavelin.pdf Cislunar Aerospace (1997, July 1). Javelin Aerodynamics. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://wings.avkids.com/Book/Sports/instructor/javelin-01.html Desai B. B. (2000) Handbook of Nutrition and Diet. Marcel Dekker: New York. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.books.google.com Fink, H.H, Burgoon, L.A. and Mikesky, A.E. (2009). Practical Applications in Sports Nutrition. Jones and Bartlett Publishers: Sudbury. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://books.google.com Gorski, J. (2003). Javelin. In L.J. Silvester (Ed.), The complete book of throws (pp. 99-129). Champaign, Il: Human Kinetics. Retrieved from http://www.books.google.com Grosvenor, M.B. and Smolin, L.A. (2010). Visualizing Nutrition: Everyday Choices. John Wiley and Sons: New Jersey. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://books.google.com 9 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Groves, B. (2002, October 22). The Correct Nutrition for Athletes. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: www.second-opinions.co.uk/athletic_diet.html Hatton, L. and Parkes, B. (2005, May). Javelin Throwing- the Application of Science. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.leshatton.org/Documents/AW_JavelinArticle_1105.pdf Hatton, L. (2007, January 28). Optimising the javelin throw in the presence of prevailing winds. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.leshatton.org/Documents/jav2007a_paper.pdf Holtschlag H. (2009) List of Weight Room Machines. Retrieved June 19, 2010 from: http://www.livestrong.com/article/25882-list-weight-room-machines/ Lenord, D. (2002). Physics and the Olympics. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://ffden2.phys.uaf.edu/211_fall2002.web.dir/daniel_lenord/javelin.html Linthorne, N. (2006, June). A new angle on throwing. Physics World, 29-30. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.iop.org/News/file_5682.pdf Mackenzie, B. (2010a, May 22). Javelin. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.brianmac.co.uk/javelin/index.htm Mackenzie, B. (2010b, May 22). Javelin Training Program . Retrieved June 24, 2010 from: http://www.brianmac.co.uk/javelin/javplan.htm Mackenzie, B. (2010c, May 27). Planning the Training. Retrieved June 19, 2010 from: http://www.brianmac.co.uk/plan.htm Mackenzie, B. (2010d, May 27) Medicine Ball . Retrieved June 24, 2010 from: http://www.brianmac.co.uk/medball.htm Morriss, C., Bartlett, R. and Fowler, N. (1997). Biomechanical Analysis of the Men’s Javelin Throw at the 1995 World Championships in Athletics. New Studies in Athletics, 12(2-3), 31-41. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.athleticscoaching.ca/UserFiles/File/Sport%20Science/Biomechanics/Throwing%20Events/Ja velin/Morriss%20Biomechanical%20Analysis%20of%20mens%20JT.pdf National Academy of Sports Medicine (2009). NASM Essentials of Sports Training. (pp. 401-414). Lippincott Williams and Wilkins: Philadelphia. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://books.google.com Ogiolda, P. (1997). The Javelin Throw and the Role of Speed in Javelin events. New Studies in Athletics, 3, 7-13. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.coachkrall.com/Articles/Jav/Speed.pdf Pfeiffer, R.P. and Magnus, B.C. (2008). Concepts of Athletic Training (pp. 66-83). Jones and Bartlett Publishers: Sudbury. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://books.google.com 10 Problem Based Learning (PBL) 2010 Price R. G. (2007) The Ultimate Guide to Weight Training for Track & Field. Price World Enterprises: Cleveland. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.books.google.com. Reeves P. (n.d.) The Pat Reeves Power Page. Retrieved June 19, 2010 from: http://www.veganbodybuilding.org/patspowerpage.htm Sing, R. (1984). The dynamics of the javelin throw. Cherry Hill, NJ: Reynolds Publishers. Springboard (2004) The Athlete's Diet. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://www.springboard4health.com/notebook/diet_athlete.html Thom, C. (2006, July 4). Technical Considerations in Teaching the Javelin. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.completetrackandfield.com/teaching-the-javelin.html Uyen, N. (2000) Javelin. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://clackhi.nclack.k12.or.us/physics/projects/experiments/2000/Javelin%20folder/default.html Volek, J.S. (2001). General Nutritional Considerations for Strength Athletes. In Jackson, C.G.R (Ed.) Nutrition and the Strength Athlete. (pp. 31-52) CRC Press: Florida. Retrieved 27th June 2010 from: http://books.google.com Young, H.D. and Geller, R.M. College Physics (8th ed.) Pearson Addison Wesley: San Francisco Young, M. (2001). Developing event-specific strength for the javelin throw. Track Coach, 154, pp. 49214927. Retrieved 23 June 2010 from: http://www.elitetrack.com/article_files/javstrength.pdf 11